Association of Schools of Political Studies

of the Council of Europe

Oxford, 22-26 January, 2018

in collaboration with The European Studies CentreSt Antony’s College, Oxford

with support from The Council of EuropeForeign and Commonwealth Office, UKNorwegian Institute of International Affairs

SAPERE AUDE

Freedom of Speech, M

edia,

and Society

2 / 3

We don’t receive wisdom; we must discover it for ourselves after a journey that no one can take for us or spare us. MArCEl ProuSt

2 / 3

“ ”

4 / 5

Monday 22 JanuaryInvestcorp lecture theatre, St Antony’s College, 62 Woodstock road, oxford

Everyday life defines consciousness. What does it have to do with us? We can’t do anything about it? But we can – everything.AlExAndEr SolzhEnItSyn

9.00–9.30 opening ceremony Lena Nemirovskaya Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education Baroness Shirley Williams Politician, Professor Emerita of Electoral Politics, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University Kalypso Nicolaïdis Director of the Centre for International Studies, Faculty Fellow, St Antony’s College, University of Oxford

11.00–11.30

Coffee break

09.30–11.00 Session:

the new World disorder

Dominique Moïsi

11.30–12.30 Session: liberal democracy – What does it Mean? Chris Patten

12.30–14.15 lunch

14.15–15.45 Session: Exodus, reckoning, Sacrifice: three Meanings of Brexit Kalypso Nicolaïdis

15.45–16.15 Coffee break

16.15–17.45 Session: 25 years of Economic transition Torbjörn Becker

17.45–18.15 Coffee break

18.15–19.00 Book presentation: “The Experience of Freedom: Lena Nemirovskaya, Yura Senokosov and the Moscow School” by the author, Andrey Kolesnikov

20.00–21.00 dinner at hawkwell house hotel

“ ”

6 / 7

tuesday 23 Januaryhawkwell house hotel, Church Way, Iffley Village, oxford

The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting. MIlAn KundErA

9.00–10.30 Session: history’s Ever-Changing Kaleidoscope: Forgetting, remembering, Commemorating … but in which order? Diana Pinto

10.30–11.00 Coffee break

11.00–13.00 Session: the Future of the Past Nikolay Epplée Dmitry Gorin

13.00–14.00 lunch

14.00–15.30 Session: Journalism and Power: the Journalist as historian Leonid Nikitinsky

15.30-16.00 Coffee break

16.00–17.30 Session: Censorship versus Self-Censorship Tatiana Lysova

17.30–18.00 Coffee break

18.00–20.00 Session: how Journalism tells and Misses the truth John Lloyd Arkady Ostrovsky

20.00–21.00 dinner

“ ”

Journalism at its best

8 / 9

17.00-18.30 Session: Making Europe More Citizens-oriented Natalie Nougayrede 18.30–19.30 dinner

19.30-21.30 round table: Propaganda and rhetoric Leon Conrad Alexander Shmelev

Wednesday 24 Januaryhawkwell house hotel, Church Way, Iffley Village, oxford

To limit our concern to our own nation alone is out of date. It’s time to ask the questions, ‘Where do we go?’ and ‘What do we do for our future?’ thE 14th dAlAI lAMA

10.00–12.00 Session: on universalism Lord Robert Skidelsky Edward Skidelsky 12.00–12.30 Coffee break 12.30-14.00 Session: Journalism and Foreign Policy Kadri Liik 14.00–15.00 lunch 15.00-16.30 Session: Myths and realities of Secessionists: a Constitutional Approach Miguel Beltrán de Felipe 16.30–17.00 Coffee break

“”

thursday 25 Januaryhawkwell house hotel, Church Way, Iffley Village, oxford

If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear. GEorGE orWEll

10.00–11.00 Project: Intersection Anton Barbashin Olga Irisova Project: 7x7 Maxim Polyakov 11.00–11.30 Coffee break 11.30-12.30 Project: team 29 Tatiana Tolsteneva 12.30–13.30 lunch 13.30-15.00 Session: transnational navigation: Modern Citizenship, Journalism and new Media Challenges Elisabeth Eide 15.00–15.30 Coffee break 15.30–17.00 Session: Public Media Journalism in America: the Ideal, the reality, and the Challenges Shula Neuman

17.00–17.30 Coffee break

17.30–19.00 Session: Fake news: the Erosion of Civil Society and dialogue Dan Mihalopoulos 19.00–20.00 dinner

20.00–22.00 round table: What is true Journalism? Leon Conrad Alexander Shmelev

10 / 11

“ ”

12 / 13

Friday 26 Januaryhawkwell house hotel, Church Way, Iffley Village, oxford

25 yEArS oF CIVIC EduCAtIon: WE ArE All dIFFErEnt, But WE ArE All CItIzEnS.

10.00–11.30 Brexit: the Choices We Make Sir Rodric Braithwaite 11.30–12.00 Coffee break 12.00–13.30 Session: the new World Affluence: Can the 21st Century be Managed? Sir Roderic Lyne 13.30–14.30 lunch 14.30–16.00 Session: What Went Wrong with liberalism? And What Can We do about It? Timothy Garton Ash 16.00-16.30 Coffee break

16.30–18.00 Session: liberal democracy versus Populist nationalism: Can the Centre hold? Quentin Peel

18.00–18.30 Closing remarks: John Lloyd 18.30–19.30 dinner

Experts

Anton Barbashin Founder, Managing Editor, Intersection(Poland)

torbjörn Becker Director, Stockholm Institute of Transition (Sweden) Economics

Miguel Beltrán de Felipe Professor of Administrative Law, (Spain) University of Castilla-La Mancha

Sir rodric Braithwaite Diplomat, Author, Ambassador to the (United Kingdom) Russian Federation (1988–1992)

leon Conrad Co-Founder, The Academy of Oratory; (United Kingdom) Founder, The LifeLore Institute

Elisabeth Eide Professor of Journalism Studies, (Norway) Oslo Metropolitan University

nikolay Epplée Independent Researcher, Heinrich Böll (Russia) Foundation Scholarship Holder

timothy Garton Ash Historian, Author, Professor of (United Kingdom) European Studies, University of Oxford

dmitry Gorin Professor, Plekhanov Russian University (Russia) of Economics

olga Irisova Founder, Senior Editor, Intersection (Russia)

Andrey Kolesnikov Senior Associate and Chair, Russian (Russia) Domestic Politics and Political Institutions Program, Carnegie Moscow Center

Kadri liik Senior Policy Fellow, European Council (Estonia) on Foreign Relations

John lloyd Contributing Editor, The Financial Times(United Kingdom)

14 / 15

Sir roderic lyne Diplomat, Ambassador to the Russian (United Kingdom) Federation (2000–2004)

dan Mihalopoulos Investigative Journalist, Political (USA) Reporter, Chicago Sun-Times

dominique Moïsi Political Scientist; Author; Co-Founder (France) and Senior Advisor Institut Français des Relations Internationales (IFRI); Pierre Keller Visiting Professor, Harvard University

lena nemirovskaya, obe Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education (Russia)

Shula neuman Executive Editor, St. Louis Public Radio (USA)

Kalypso nicolaïdis Professor of International Relations; (United Kingdom) Director, Centre for International Studies; Faculty Fellow, St Antony’s College, University of Oxford; Advisor to Greek Foreign Minister George Papandreou on European affairs (1996–2004)

leonid nikitinsky Journalist, Observer, Novaya Gazeta (Russia)

natalie nougayrède Editorial Board Member and (United Kingdom) Columnist, The Guardian

Arkady ostrovsky Russia and Eastern Europe Editor, (Russia) The Economist

lord Christopher Patten Politician; Governor of Hong Kong (United Kingdom) (1992–1997); Chairman, BBC Trust (2011–2014); Chancellor, University of Oxford (since 2003)

Quentin Peel Mercator Senior Fellow, Europe (United Kingdom) Programme, Chatham House

diana Pinto Historian; Author(France)

Maxim Polyakov Deputy Editor-in-Chief, 7x7 online (Russia) magazine

yury Senokosov Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education (Russia)

Alexander Shmelev Political Analyst (Russia)

Edward Skidelsky Senior Lecturer, University of Exeter; (United Kingdom) Author

lord robert Skidelsky Member of the House of Lords, (United Kingdom) UK Parliament

tatiana tolsteneva Project Coordinator, Team 29; Head, (Russia) Infometr project

Baroness Shirley Williams Politician; Adviser to Prime Minister (United Kingdom) Gordon Brown (2007–2010); Professor Emerita of Electoral Politics, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University

Andrey zakharov Editor, Neprikosnovennyi Zapas: Debates (Russia) on Politics and Culture magazine

honourEd GuEStS

Piero Borghini President, Lombardy Regional (Italy) Government (1990–1992); Mayor of Milan (1992–1993); Politician, Journalist

Susan Coughtrie Senior Programme Officer, Europe and (United Kingdom) Central Asia, ARTICLE 19

16 / 17

Andrey Gorianov General Producer, BBC Russian Service (Russia)

Ashley harris Strategic Advisor, Eastern Europe and(United Kingdom) Central Asia Directorate, FCO

Sanford henry Partner, Global Resources Partnership (United Kingdom)

her honour Marcia levy Solicitor, Circuit Judge (2004–2016) (United Kingdom)

daria litvinova Journalist, Reuters Fellow in Oxford (Russia)

Alex Mickelsen Desk Officer, Russia Team, Eastern (United Kingdom) Europe and Central Asia Directorate, FCO

Elisabeth Millar Lawyer (United Kingdom)

Igor Mintusov Chairman of the Board of Directors, (Russia) Niccolo M

Jeannette Purnell Translator Borghini (Italy)

russ Signorino Economics Instructor, University of (USA) Missouri, St. Louis

Elizabeth teague Independent Analyst of Russian politics (United Kingdom)

robert thompson Journalist, Reuters (United Kingdom)

Masha traub Writer (Russia)

Participants

ArMEnIA

Armen zakaryan Professor of Journalism, National School of Administration

BElAruS

lola Buryeva TV Correspondent, News Department, Belsat

KyrGyzStAn

timur toktonaliev Editor, Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR)

PolAnd

Agnieszka Kanevska PR Specialist, Coordinator, Siberian Bialystok - Resurrection project

ruSSIA

Kristina Abramicheva Curator, X-MAX gallery of (Republic of Bashkortostan) contemporary art

Arsen Akavov Volunteer, Hope charitable foundation (Republic of Dagestan)

dilyara Akhmetova Head of the Information and (Republic of Tatarstan) Analytical Department, Spiritual Directorate of the Muslims of Russia

18 / 19

Abdul Aliyev Executive Director, Friends of Mercy (Republic of Dagestan) philanthropic association

ruslan Azisov Correspondent, Yuldash (Sputnik) (Republic of Mordovia) republican newspaperPolina Bakhtina Coordinator, Heinrich Böll Foundation (St Petersburg)

Alexey Barayev Businessman; Member of the Public (Yaroslavl oblast) Council, Department of Tourism, Yaroslavl oblast

danila Bediaev Deputy Editor-in-Chief, Echo of (Yaroslavl oblast) Moscow radio station, Yaroslavl

Ivan Belyaev Social Networks Editor, Radio Liberty (Vologda oblast) Russian Service

liya degtyareva Press Secretary, Data Processing Centre, (Volgograd oblast) The Housing, Communal Services, Fuel and Energy Complex, Volgograd

Alena demina Journalist, Specialist in SMM, The Right (Altai krai) to a Miracle charitable foundation for preterm children

Vladimir dergachev Deputy Director of the Policy and (Moscow) Society Department, RBC media holding

Anna dulevskaya Head, Advertising and Information (Oryol oblast) Department, Free Space theatre

Mikhail Efimkin Editor in Chief, Smolgrad.ru web-portal (Smolensk oblast)

dzhabrail Evloev Consultant on IT-issues, Fund for (Republic of Ingushetia) Support of Low-Income and Unemployed

Sofia Ezhova Editor-in-Chief, 7x7 on-line magazine (Ryazan oblast)

Maxim Goryunov Journalist, Blogger (Novgorod oblast)

regina hisamova Correspondent, Idel.Realii web-portal (Republic of Tatarstan)

tatyana Karchenkova Freelance Journalist (Omsk oblast)

Philip Kochetkov Correspondent, Vzglyad-Info (Saratov oblast) information agency

Irina Kovshova Senior Product Development Manager, (Moscow) Russia Today international news agency

Maxim lisitsky Journalist, Russian Fabula cultural and (Moscow oblast) educational project

ulyana lomakina TV Producer, ZabTV channel (Zabaykalsky krai)

nikolay lykov Editor-in-Chief, Vzglyad-Info information (Saratov oblast) agency

Petr Manyakhin Special Correspondent, Batenka.ru (Novosibirsk oblast) web-portal

Victoria Mikisha Freelance Correspondent, Takie Dela (Khabarovsk krai) on-line magazine

Julia Mineeva Head of News Service, Novaya Gazeta (Moscow) newspaper

Sergey Mitrofanov Head of Internet Promotion (Moscow) Department, Megapolis company

natalia namozova PR Manager, Usadba Vorontsovo park (Moskovskaya oblast)

natalia nazemnova Journalist; Regional Correspondent, TASS (Penza oblast)

oksana nikulina Press-Attaché to the Head of the (Republic of Mari El) Republic of Mari El

Varvara nosyreva Journalist, Amurskaya Pravda newspaper (Amur oblast)

20 / 21

Valeriya odarenko Editor-in-Chief, Naukograd-Vesti (Novosibirsk oblast) newspaper and Naukograd-Press web-portal

natalya Paramonova Freelance Journalist, colta.ru; Takie Dela; (Moscow) geo.ru; Ecology and Law on-line magazines

Stepan Parfyonov Executive Director, Echo of Moscow (Penza oblast) radio station, Penza

Valery Perevozchikov Correspondent, Kavkaz.Realii web-portal (Krasnodar krai)

dmitry Pikalov Associate Professor, Department of (Stavropol krai) Advertising and Public Relations, North-Caucasus Federal University

Elena Pimenova Specialist in Promoting and Developing (Voronezh oblast) the Volunteer Movement, Tanais centre for historical, patriotic and international education for children and youth

Valeriya Safonova PR Specialist, Chizhov Gallery Association (Voronezh oblast)

daria Savelieva Editor-in-Chief, Remarka on-line (Bryansk oblast) magazine

Anna Savina Senior Laboratory Assistant, Institute of (Republic of Tatarstan) International Relations, History and Oriental Studies, Kazan (Privolzhsky) Federal University

Anastasia Sedukhina Editor-in-Chief for economic projects, (Moscow) Le Courrier de Russie French-language newspaper

Alexander Semerozubov General Manager, Pulse of the Volga Region (Samara oblast) newspaper

lyudmila Shabuyeva Editor-in-Chief, Echo of Moscow radio (Yaroslavl oblast) station, Yaroslavl

Anastasia Shamarina Editor, Krasnoyarsk media information (Krasnoyarsk krai) agency

dmitry Shchipanov Correspondent, Real Time on-line (Moscow) newspaper; Adviser to the Moscow City Duma Deputy on Media Communications

nadezhda Sinyakova Editor-in-Chief, Amur Lenta web-portal (Amur oblast)

Ivan Slobodenyuk Editor-in-Chief, Kommersant Southern (Chelyabinsk oblast) Ural newspaper

Elena Sokovnina Editor-in-Chief, The Source of Beauty (Kirov oblast) and Health magazine

natalia Solovyeva Correspondent, Media Ryazan Russian (Ryazan oblast) information agency

yuri Stepanov Editor-in-Chief, Kuban 24 web-portal (Krasnodar krai)

denis Strelkov Correspondent, 7x7 on-line magazine (Kirov oblast)

Isropil Sultygov Editor, Madspark web-portal (The Republic of Ingushetia)

Alexander tikhonov Deputy Editor-in-Chief, Vid Sboku – (Yaroslavl oblast) Yaroslavl on-line newspaper

Alexey topleninov Chairman of the Board, Centre for Social (Yaroslavl oblast) and Legal Protection of the Population

nikita Vasilyev Deputy Director, Na Svyazi mediagroup (Chuvash Republic)

Elena Vasilyeva Special Correspondent, Amurskaya Pravda (Amur oblast) publishing house

Anton Veselov Deputy Director of Public Relations, (Novosibirsk oblast) Russian National Public Library for Science and Technology

22 / 23

Vera Vlasova Journalist, Head of Special Projects, (Kirov oblast) Echo of Moscow radio station, Kirov

Pavel yuzhakov Editor-in-Chief, YugraMedia Group (Khanty-Mansiisk autonomous company okrug – Yugra)

Mariana zhinova Republic Chief Editor of Art (Karachay-Cherkessia) Broadcasting, Arkhyz 24 TV channel

uKrAInE

Ilya Afanasyev Associate Professor, Deputy Head of the Department of Advertising and Public Relations, The Institute of Journalism of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv

Alexandra Karpenko Head of Events, Same But Different marketing and communications agency

Polina lavrova Director, LAURUS publishing house

Maria litvin Press Secretary, Firtash Foundation

notes

Enlightenment is man’s emergence from his self-imposed nonage. Nonage is the inability to use one’s own understanding without another’s guidance. This nonage is self-imposed if its cause lies not in lack of understanding but in indecision and lack of courage to use one’s own mind without another’s guidance. Sapere aude! “Have the courage to use your own understanding”, is therefore the motto of the enlightenment. IMMAnuEl KAnt “Answering the Question: What Is Enlightenment?”

“

”