kirsten c. jackson - hollywoodreporter.com novel – the hobbit: an unexpected journey, the hobbit:...
TRANSCRIPT
...
1 JENNR & BLOCK LLPAndrew J. Thomas (SBN 159533)
2 [email protected] M. Alemi (SBN 255836)
3 [email protected] C. Jackson (SBN 265952)
4 [email protected] WesfFifth Street, Suite 3600
5 Los Angeles, CA 90071Telephone: (213) 239-5100
6 Facsimile: (213) 239-5199
7 Attorneys for PlaintiffsWARER BROS. ENTERTAINMNT
8 INC., NEW LINE CINEMA LLC, NEWLINE PRODUCTIONS, INC., METRO-
9 GOLDWY-MA YER STUDIOS INC.,and Tlf SAUL ZAENTZ COMPANY
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
",t.:v (".. ()r
\
r-,~ ...l~_)
:i: :.1J-; ;,... ::~r ~: -- C_"'
~ ". ~.:~"' t- ~ n l
~~ -=~ 2 -.:. !".--. ~.."'~':~ -,--I "r'1 ' J.rO;:r"l..' '. ~ r:(.jr) --I
." nr~ .i
r r- .i~~;J~
ê~§ri~. ."-'
~¡-rïlo
~'1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
WARNR BROS. .. ~leiZ.: 09 54zi~((~JENTERTAINMENT INC., a Delaware 7COlJoration; NEW LINE CINEMA COMPLAINT FOR:LLC, a Delaware limited liabilitycomJ=any; NEW LINEPRODUCTIONS, INC., a Californiacorporation; METRO-GOLDWY-MAYER STUDIOS INC., a DelawarecOrPoration; and Tlf SAUL ZAENTZCOMP ANY, a Delaware corporation,
Plaintiffs,
111 TRADEMARKNFRINGEMENT (15 U.S.C. § 1114)
f21 FALSE DESIGNATION OFORIGIN (15 U.S.C. § 1125)
f3) TRADEMARK DILUTION (15D.S.C. § 1125)
f4) FALSE ADVERTISING (15D.S.C. § 1125)
f51 COMMONLAWUNFAIRCOMPETITION
f61 VIOLATION OF CAL. BUS. &PROF. CODE § 17200 -
f71 VIOLATION OF CAL. BUS. &PROF. CODE § 17500
fSl VIOLATION OF CAL. BUS. &PROF. CODE § 17247
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
v.
Tlf GLOBAL ASYLUM INC. (akaThe Asylum), a California corporation,
Defendant.
COMPLAINT
-2- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Plaintiffs Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. (“Warner Bros.”), New Line
Cinema LLC, New Line Productions, Inc. (together with New Line Cinema LLC,
“New Line”), Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios Inc. (“MGM”), and The Saul Zaentz
Company d/b/a Middle-Earth Enterprises (“SZC” ) bring this action against
defendant The Global Asylum Inc. (“The Asylum”) for injunctive relief and
damages and allege as follows:
NATURE OF THE ACTION
1. This action arises out of defendant The Asylum’s knowing and willful
infringement of Plaintiffs’ rights with respect to the beloved, world-famous novels
The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy by J.R.R. Tolkien, the Academy
Award-winning, blockbuster motion picture trilogy The Lord of the Rings, and a
series of three soon-to-be released motion pictures based on the Tolkien novel The
Hobbit (the “Hobbit Films”). In a deliberate effort to profit from consumer
confusion, The Asylum is advertising and promoting for sale a low-budget
knockoff DVD titled Age of the Hobbits (the “Infringing DVD”).
2. Plaintiffs own the exclusive rights to produce and distribute motion
pictures based on the classic literary works of Professor J.R.R. Tolkien entitled The
Lord of the Rings, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King (known as the
“Lord of the Rings trilogy”) and The Hobbit, fantasy stories that follow the
adventures of fictional creatures called “Hobbits.” The events in The Hobbit and
The Lord of the Rings trilogy take place during a time that the books refer to as the
“Third Age” of Middle-earth, and result in the passing of the Third Age into the
Fourth Age. Tolkien’s novel The Hobbit is one of the bestselling books of all time,
and people throughout the world associate the fanciful term and title “Hobbit” with
Tolkien’s works and with the imaginary world of Middle-earth that he created.
3. Plaintiff New Line created, distributed and owns copyright interests in
the enormously successful The Lord of the Rings film trilogy, which grossed
-3- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
$3 billion at box offices worldwide and won 17 Academy Awards. Plaintiffs are
creating and will soon distribute three additional films based on Tolkien’s The
Hobbit novel – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, The Hobbit: The Desolation
of Smaug, and The Hobbit: There and Back Again. All three films are being
directed, co-written, and produced by Academy Award-winning filmmaker Peter
Jackson, who also directed the Lord of the Rings motion picture trilogy. All of
these titles contain the fanciful term “Hobbit,” and Plaintiffs have used and
continue to use marks associated with that fanciful term, including “HOBBIT” and
“THE HOBBIT” to brand the films and related licensed merchandise. The films
have been the subject of extensive pre-release publicity and millions of consumers
are awaiting the December 14, 2012 release of the first film.
4. Plaintiff SZC owns the worldwide trademark and merchandising
rights in the names of characters, places, events, and things in Tolkien’s books The
Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Plaintiffs SZC, New Line, and Warner
Bros. have collaborated for many years in licensing others to use trademarks and
service marks derived from The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Plaintiff
SZC also owns exclusive rights to the famous registered trademarks “HOBBIT”
and “THE HOBBIT” for use on and in association with various entertainment
products and services, including DVDs, computer games, video games, board
games, figurines, posters, as well as other goods and services. Not only is the
HOBBIT mark central to the content, promotion and advertising of The Lord of the
Rings and The Hobbit films, Plaintiffs and their related companies also have used
the HOBBIT mark on a wide variety of goods and services in connection with their
highly successful worldwide merchandising programs.
5. The Asylum is in the business of producing low-budget knockoffs
(which it calls “mockbusters”) of major motion pictures, which The Asylum
markets to the public at or around the time the major studio film that it is knocking
off is playing in theaters. In this case, The Asylum has been and is promoting and
-4- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
advertising its low-budget film using the confusingly similar and misleading title
Age of the Hobbits, in an intentional and willful attempt (i) to trade on the
popularity and goodwill associated with the Tolkien novels, the extraordinarily
successful Lord of The Rings film trilogy, and the famous HOBBIT mark, (ii) to
free-ride on the worldwide advertising campaign in connection with the
forthcoming Hobbit Films, and (iii) to divert customers and potential customers
away from the Hobbit Films.
6. The Asylum’s advertising for its low-budget knockoff also has been
and is confusingly similar to advertising for and images from the Plaintiffs’
copyrighted films and trademarked products, including the font and style in which
the titles appear and the overall look and feel of the images depicted in the artwork
and packaging. According to its own website, The Asylum intends to release its
knockoff movie Age of the Hobbits on December 11, 2012 – only three days prior
to the December 14, 2012 theatrical release date for the first of the Hobbit Films,
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
7. This is a civil action against The Asylum for trademark infringement
in violation of Section 32 of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1114, false designation
of origin and false advertising in violation of Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act,
15 U.S.C. § 1125(a), trademark dilution under Section 43(c) of the Lanham Act,
15 U.S.C. § 1125(c), and violations of California statutory and common law.
8. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this matter pursuant to
15 U.S.C. § 1121 and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338 in that it involves an action
arising under the federal Lanham Act.
9. Defendant The Asylum is subject to personal jurisdiction in the State
of California because it is a California corporation that has its main office in
Burbank, California, and because it conducts substantial business operations in this
judicial district.
-5- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
10. Venue is proper in this judicial district pursuant to 28
U.S.C. §§ 1391(b) and (c) and 28 U.S.C. § 1400(a) because Plaintiffs’ claims arise
in this judicial district and defendant The Asylum may be found in this judicial
district and is subject to personal jurisdiction in this judicial district.
THE PARTIES
11. Plaintiff Warner Bros. is a Delaware corporation with its principal
place of business at 4000 Warner Boulevard, Burbank, California. Warner Bros. is
an internationally-known motion picture studio which produces and distributes
motion pictures in the United States and around the world. Examples of films
produced and distributed globally by Warner Bros. and its subsidiary companies
include the well-known and highly successful Dark Knight, Harry Potter, and
Sherlock Holmes film franchises. Together with New Line, Warner Bros. owns
exclusive rights to distribute the Hobbit Films in the United States and, together
with New Line and MGM, owns the exclusive rights to distribute the Hobbit Films
in various territories around the world.
12. Plaintiff New Line Cinema LLC is a Delaware limited liability
company, with its principal place of business at 116 North Robertson Blvd., Los
Angeles, California, and is a wholly owned subsidiary of Warner Bros. Plaintiff
New Line Productions, Inc. is a California corporation, with its principal place of
business at 116 North Robertson Blvd., Los Angeles, California, and is a wholly
owned subsidiary of New Line Cinema LLC. New Line Cinema LLC (together
with New Line Productions, Inc., “New Line”) is an internationally-known motion
picture studio which produces motion pictures in the United States and around the
world. New Line produced and distributed the highly successful Lord of the Rings
motion picture franchise, as well as numerous other well-known and highly
successful films. Together with Warner Bros., New Line owns the exclusive rights
to distribute the Hobbit Films in the United States and, together with Warner Bros.
and MGM, owns the exclusive rights to distribute the Hobbit Films in various
-6- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
territories around the world.
13. Plaintiff MGM is a Delaware corporation, with its principal place of
business at 245 N. Beverly Drive, Beverly Hills, California. MGM is an
internationally-known motion picture studio which produces and distributes
motion pictures in the United States and around the world. Examples of films
produced and distributed globally by MGM include the well-known and highly-
successful Rocky, Pink Panther, and James Bond film franchises. Together with
New Line and Warner Bros., MGM owns the exclusive rights to distribute the
Hobbit Films in various territories around the world.
14. Plaintiff SZC is a Delaware corporation, with its principal place of
business at 2600 Tenth Street, Berkeley, California. SZC owns the exclusive
worldwide motion picture and merchandising rights for the J.R.R. Tolkien books
The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings trilogy, as well as the exclusive trademark
rights in the names of characters, places, events and things in these books,
including the HOBBIT mark. SZC has registered the HOBBIT mark and related
marks with the United States Patent and Trademark Office and in many other
countries. It has licensed exclusive motion picture rights in the Lord of the Rings
trilogy to New Line and exclusive motion picture rights in The Hobbit novel to
New Line and MGM.
15. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and on that basis allege, that
defendant The Asylum is a California corporation having its principal place of
business at 72 East Palm Avenue, Burbank, California.
THE HOBBIT AND THE LORD OF THE RINGS NOVELS
16. The Hobbit is a fantasy novel by Professor J.R.R. Tolkien, first
published in the 1930s. It was an instant success and remains highly popular to
this day, with an estimated 100 million copies sold in more than 40 languages.
17. The Lord of the Rings trilogy is a three-volume fantasy novel also
written by J.R.R. Tolkien and published in the 1950s. The sequel to The Hobbit¸
-7- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
the Lord of the Rings trilogy comprises three individual volumes entitled The
Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers, and The Return of the King. Tolkien’s
classic The Lord of the Rings trilogy has become one of the best-selling novels
ever written, with over 150 million copies sold worldwide.
18. The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings trilogy are referred to in this
Complaint collectively as the “Tolkien Works.” The Tolkien Works are among the
most well-known, popular and beloved series of literary works of all time. Each of
the Tolkien Works became enormously popular soon after publication, each is
currently in print in the United States, and each has been in print continuously
since its initial publication date. More than 60 printings of The Hobbit and more
than 50 printings of the Lord of the Rings trilogy have been published. More than
45 million copies of the Tolkien Works have been sold in the United States alone.
19. The term “Hobbit” was created by Professor Tolkien to describe the
fanciful characters first featured in his novel The Hobbit and later in the Lord of the
Rings trilogy. The leading (and title) character of The Hobbit is a Hobbit named
Bilbo Baggins. The leading character of The Lord of the Rings trilogy is a Hobbit
named Frodo Baggins, the nephew of Bilbo Baggins.
20. Because of the enormous and enduring popularity enjoyed by the
Tolkien Works, the fanciful term “Hobbit” has become widely known among the
consuming public to indicate the distinctive fantasy characters created by Professor
Tolkien as portrayed in the Tolkien Works and in the Lord of the Rings and
Hobbit motion pictures. Substantial goodwill has developed in the term “Hobbit”
as referring to the characters in the Tolkien Works, the Lord of the Rings films, and
the Hobbit Films and, furthermore, to the goods and services offered by Plaintiffs
and their predecessors in connection with the those books and films. The marks
THE HOBBIT and HOBBIT, alone or in combination with other words
(collectively, the “HOBBIT Marks”) are inherently distinctive and are inextricably
connected to the Tolkien Works, to the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films, and to
-8- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
the goods and services offered by SZC and/or its licensees related to the Tolkien
Works as well as the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films.
21. For more than 30 years, SZC and its predecessors have held the right
to use and license others to use marks derived from the Tolkien Works including,
without limitation, the titles of each of the Tolkien Works and the names and visual
representations of the characters, places, objects, and events described in the
Tolkien Works, including without limitation the HOBBIT Marks. SZC also holds
exclusive, worldwide theatrical motion picture and live stage production rights in
and to the Tolkien Works, as well as the right to sell merchandise and provide
services in connection with such film and stage productions and to license others to
do so as well.
LICENSING OF THE HOBBIT MARKS
22. Beginning in at least the mid-1970s, SZC established, and has
continued to maintain, successful worldwide licensing programs to promote
merchandise and other goods and services based on the Tolkien Works, as well as
on the films and stage adaptations thereof produced or licensed by SZC. As part of
this program, SZC and its licensees have aggressively promoted the HOBBIT
Marks through numerous channels of trade. SZC has used, and licensed others to
use, the HOBBIT Marks in connection with a wide variety of commercial goods
and services.
23. In addition to its substantial common law rights, SZC is the lawful
owner of numerous registrations and applications for the HOBBIT Marks, in
connection with various goods and services. Among other things, these goods and
services include DVDs, video games, computer game software, and pre-recorded
CD-ROMs featuring fantasy games, board games, lithographic prints, fantasy films
and music.
24. Among other federal trademark registrations, SZC owns Registration
No. 2,949,370 for THE HOBBIT (issued on May 10, 2005), Registration
-9- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
No. 1,230,026 for HOBBIT (issued on March 8, 1983), Registration No. 2,897,941
for HOBBIT (issued on October 26, 2004), and Registration No. 2,976,573 for
HOBBIT (issued on July 26, 2005). These registrations all are valid, subsisting,
and incontestable. SZC also owns Registration No. 3,245,235 for THE HOBBIT
(issued on May 22, 2007), Registration No. 3,938,229 for THE HOBBIT (issued
on March 29, 2011), Registration No. 3,981,769 for THE HOBBIT (issued on June
21, 2011), and Registration No. 4,187,873 for THE HOBBIT: AN UNEXPECTED
JOURNEY (issued on August 7, 2012). These registrations all are valid and
subsisting. True and correct copies of these trademark registrations and related
records, as printed out from the website of the United State Patent and Trademark
Office, are attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated by reference.
25. In addition, SZC has applied to register the titles of each of the three
Hobbit Films on an intent-to-use basis in Class 9 for, among other things, pre-
recorded DVDs featuring fantasy films, fantasy games and/or cartoons, and in
Class 41 for entertainment services, in connection with providing online electronic
games and interactive videogames over the Internet. In February 2012, the
Trademark Office issued Notices of Allowance for THE HOBBIT: AN
UNEXPECTED JOURNEY (Serial Nos. 85350515 and 85350688) and Notices of
Allowance for THE HOBBIT: THERE AND BACK AGAIN (Serial Nos.
85348202 and 85348380). SZC has a pending application to register the third title
THE HOBBIT: THE DESOLATION OF SMAUG (Serial No. 85736834).
THE LORD OF THE RINGS FILMS
26. Pursuant to licenses from SZC, New Line and its affiliates (now
subsidiaries of Warner Bros.) developed, produced, and distributed the Lord of the
Rings motion picture trilogy.
27. The Lord of the Rings film trilogy received widespread praise for its
innovative computerized special effects. Considered to be one of the largest and
most ambitious motion picture projects ever undertaken, the Lord of the Rings film
-10- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
series took eight years to produce.
28. New Line has spent more than $150 million advertising the Lord of
the Rings films worldwide. Since at least 2001, New Line has continuously used a
distinctive title design in promoting and advertising The Lord of the Rings films
and merchandise. This distinctive title design is shown below and is comprised of
an “ALL CAPS” title with reflective gold characters and pronounced serifs:
29. The Lord of the Rings film trilogy consists of three live action,
fantasy adventure motion pictures based on The Lord of the Rings novels, all
directed by Peter Jackson – The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring,
released theatrically in December 2001; The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers,
released theatrically in December 2002; and The Lord of the Rings: The Return of
the King, released theatrically in December 2003. Like the books, the New Line
Lord of the Rings film trilogy features leading Hobbit characters, including Bilbo
Baggins (the title character from The Hobbit) and his nephew, Frodo Baggins.
30. The Lord of the Rings film trilogy has been one of the most acclaimed
and successful film series of all time. Each film in the Lord of the Rings series is
among the all-time top grossing motion pictures in the United States and abroad.
31. The first film of the trilogy, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of
the Ring, has had theatrical grosses of approximately $315 million in the United
States and over $871 million worldwide. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of
the Ring received four Golden Globe nominations, including for Best Picture
-11- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Drama and Best Director, and 13 Academy Award nominations, including
nominations for Best Picture and Best Supporting Actor, and received four
Academy Awards.
32. The second film of the trilogy, The Lord of the Rings: The Two
Towers, has had theatrical grosses of approximately $341 million in the United
States and over $926 million worldwide. The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers
received two Golden Globe nominations, including for Best Picture Drama and
Best Director, and six Academy Award nominations, including a nomination for
Best Picture, and received two Academy Awards.
33. The third and final film of the trilogy, The Lord of the Rings: The
Return of the King, has had theatrical grosses of approximately $377 million in the
United States and more than $1 billion worldwide. The Lord of the Rings: The
Return of the King received four Golden Globe nominations and four awards,
including for Best Picture (Drama), Best Director, Best Original Score and Best
Original Song. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King received 11
Academy Award nominations and 11 Academy Awards, including in the
categories of Best Picture, Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay.
THE HOBBIT FILMS
34. The Hobbit Films are a soon-to-be-released film trilogy consisting of
three fantasy adventure films based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s novel The Hobbit.
Directed by Peter Jackson, the Hobbit Films are the much-anticipated prequels to
the Lord of the Rings motion picture franchise. As in the Hobbit novel, the
protagonist of the Hobbit Films is another Hobbit by the name of Bilbo Baggins.
The first film in the trilogy – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey – is scheduled to
be released in theaters in the United States on December 14, 2012.
35. Pursuant to a license from SZC, Warner Bros. will license and
distribute the famous HOBBIT Marks on a wide variety of merchandise sold in the
United States that is related to the upcoming Hobbit motion picture trilogy,
-12- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
including DVDs, computer game software, video game software, lithographs,
board games, figurines, and other goods.
36. In anticipation of the Hobbit Films’ theatrical release, Warner Bros.
under license from SZC, has invested significant time, effort and money in
promoting and marketing the first of the Hobbit Films in the United States and
around the world using the registered HOBBIT Marks.
37. Warner Bros. has used the same distinctive title design from the Lord
of the Rings film franchise in the promotion and advertising for the new Hobbit
Films franchise. This distinctive title design is comprised of an “ALL CAPS” title
with slender, reflective gold characters and pronounced serifs, which links the new
Hobbit Films franchise with its highly-successful predecessor:
38. Among other promotional efforts, Warner Bros. has launched an
Internet website devoted to promoting the first of the Hobbit Films
(www.thehobbit.com). The website, which is accessible worldwide, includes a
synopsis of the film’s story, movie trailers, and a gallery of images from the film.
The HOBBIT Marks and the distinctive title design are featured prominently on
the website.
39. Warner Bros. also has promoted the Hobbit Films through various
social media, including a Facebook page devoted to the first film
(www.facebook.com/TheHobbitMovie), a Twitter page devoted to the Hobbit
Films (@TheHobbitMovie), and a “Hobbit Movies” smartphone application
(“app”) available for free through iTunes. The fanciful HOBBIT Marks and the
distinctive title design are featured prominently on the Facebook page, the
-13- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
smartphone app, and in images posted on the official HobbitMovie Twitter page.
40. Warner Bros. has released three theatrical trailers for the first of the
Hobbit Films – in December 2011, June 2012, and September 2012 – each of
which has been viewed by audiences in thousands of theaters across the United
States. These trailers also have been distributed through iTunes, YouTube,
Facebook, and the Hobbit movie website and have been viewed by millions of
consumers. In addition, Warner Bros. has produced and will continue to produce
numerous print and television advertisements to run through and after the theatrical
release, all of which will contain the distinctive HOBBIT Marks and distinctive
title design.
41. Numerous magazines, newspapers, and Internet websites have
reported on the development and production of the Hobbit Films using the
HOBBIT Marks to refer to the Hobbit motion pictures produced by New Line and
Warner Bros.
42. As a result of enduring popularity of the Tolkien Works, the
extraordinary critical and commercial success of the Lord of the Rings film
franchise, the longstanding and widespread use of the HOBBIT Marks in
commerce, Warner Bros.’ extensive marketing efforts with respect to the
upcoming Hobbit Films, and the resulting worldwide media coverage of those
films, the fanciful and distinctive HOBBIT Marks also have acquired substantial
secondary meaning with respect to the titles of the forthcoming Hobbit Films.
THE ASYLUM’S INFRINGING DVD
43. The Asylum is a film production company whose business model is
based on confusing and misleading consumers. On its Internet website
(www.theasylum.cc), The Asylum touts itself as a producer of so-called
“mockbusters” – knockoff films that it describes as “similar to big studio films,
only cheaper.” Despite the “mockbuster” label, these low-budget films do not
-14- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
mock, parody or otherwise comment upon the theatrical motion pictures they
imitate. Instead, the films are intended to piggy-back on the publicity of the major
studio films, through The Asylum’s intentional use of confusingly similar titles,
artwork, and release dates to mislead consumers into believing the films are
popular, big-budget releases. Examples of films produced and distributed by The
Asylum – all timed to coincide with major studio theatrical releases – include
Transmorphers [studio release: Transformers], Sunday School Musical [studio
release: High School Musical], The Da Vinci Treasure [studio release: The Da
Vinci Code], The Day The Earth Stopped [studio release: The Day The Earth Stood
Still], Snakes On A Train [studio release: Snakes On A Plane], and American
Battleship [studio release: Battleship].
44. The Asylum’s business strategy of creating knockoff imitations of
major motion pictures and releasing them on DVD and video-on-demand at the
same time as the studio theatrical release is intended to and does confuse
consumers as to the source or origin of The Asylum’s productions by causing
consumers to believe they are the same as or associated with contemporaneously
released blockbuster films from major motion picture studios. Reviews for The
Asylum movies are replete with complaints from irritated consumers who were
misled into purchasing their movies instead of big budget studio productions.
45. By way of example, on September 27, 2012, a consumer purchased
The Asylum’s Abraham Lincoln vs. Zombies on Amazon.com believing it was the
recent 20th Century Fox theatrical release Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter.
The consumer complained on Amazon’s Customer Review page: “You see
Abraham Lincoln Vampire Slayer on TV then see Abraham Lincoln vs. The
Zombies on Amazon Prime. Not thinking or reading clearly, I ordered the wrong
movie…. Definitely not worth the price charged to watch it.”
46. Similarly, on June 23, 2011, a consumer was confused into purchasing
The Asylum’s Battle of Los Angeles instead of Columbia Pictures’ theatrical
-15- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
motion picture Battle: Los Angeles. According to the consumer: “Do I actually
HAVE to give this movie a single star? I accidently added this movie to my DVD
rental queue instead of Battle: Los Angeles and took me 20 min into my flight and
10 min into the movie to realize the monumental mistake I made.”
47. As a further example, consumers of The Asylum’s Sherlock Holmes
complained that they had been duped into thinking they had purchased Warner
Bros’ blockbuster by the same name. On January 29, 2011, one consumer wrote:
“This in all likelihood is the worst movie I have ever seen. It looks like it was
made in a high school video project; the effects are cheesy and low-budget. This
has nothing to do with Sherlock Holmes and appears to have been created just to
exploit the success of Robert Downey’s movie. Dreadful.” On March 20, 2010,
another consumer complained: “To be honest, I thought I had picked up the
Downey version for SH…. Shame on Asylum for making a buck on fools like me
… I’ve definitely been punked!”
48. Indeed, The Asylum has proudly posted on its own website evidence
of the consumer confusion it has created, in the form of a December 2011 message
that it ridiculed as “hate mail”: “I don’t know a single person that runs to the video
store to buy an Asylum release. In fact, most people I know only rent your films
by mistake thinking they are the big-budget films you rip off. Is that your
marketing strategy or something?”
49. On information and belief, based on statements on The Asylum’s
website, The Asylum filmed the Infringing DVD Age of the Hobbits during July
and August 2012 near Kampot and Kep, Cambodia – long after Warner Bros. and
New Line had begun their extensive, worldwide efforts to promote the Hobbit
Films as described herein. The budget for the knockoff Age of the Hobbits film
reportedly was less than $2 million.
50. Beginning in or about August 2012, The Asylum began to advertise
on its website the new low-budget, straight-to-DVD Age of the Hobbits. The
-16- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Asylum also has advertised the Infringing DVD on Netflix.com, and made the
Infringing DVD available for pre-order on various retail websites, including
Amazon.com and Bestbuy.com. In describing the Infringing DVD, these
misleading advertisements evoke the world of The Hobbit and The Lord of the
Rings books and films with references to dragons, an “ancient age,” and “small,
peace-loving Hobbits.” The Asylum’s advertising campaign has caused and will
cause the HOBBIT Marks to lose their distinctiveness and tarnish their value.
51. As further evidence of The Asylum’s intent to mislead and confuse
consumers into believing there is a connection or association between the
Infringing DVD and the Hobbit Films and the Tolkien Works, Plaintiffs are
informed and believe that in or about July 2012 The Asylum caused the following
description to appear on the Netflix website to promote the upcoming release of the
Infringing DVD: “In an ancient age, an enslaved hero escapes his bonds and
begins a dangerous quest to claim an enchanted dagger that will free his people.
This ‘mockbuster’ is based on a reimagined version of J.R.R. Tolkien’s mythical
universe.”
52. Based on descriptions of the film on The Asylum’s website, its Age of
the Hobbits film does not mock, parody or comment in any way upon the Lord of
the Rings films, the Hobbit Films, the Tolkien Works on which those films are
based, or any of the characters therein. Instead, as shown below, The Asylum has
been and is using the famous HOBBIT Marks commercially in the title of its film
solely for the purpose of creating consumer confusion and capitalizing on the
multi-million dollar worldwide marketing campaign for Plaintiffs’ highly-
anticipated Hobbit Films:
-17- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD
53. The Asylum has marketed its Infringing DVD – Age of the Hobbits –
using a title and title design that is confusingly similar to the title and distinctive
title design used in connection with the first of Plaintiffs’ Hobbit Films. Not only
has The Asylum made prominent use of the famous, registered HOBBIT Marks in
the title of the Infringing DVD, it also has employed a slender, gold, stylized serif
font in all-capital letters that is confusingly similar to the distinctive title design
used to promote both the Lord of the Rings films and the Hobbit Films:
Plaintiffs’ Title Design The Asylum’s Title Design
54. In addition to its use of a confusingly similar and misleading title and
title design, The Asylum has promoted its Infringing DVD in a manner that is
confusingly similar in look and feel to advertisements for and images from the
-18- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Lord of the Rings film trilogy and the Hobbit Films, as well as licensed
merchandise using the famous HOBBIT Marks. The Asylum’s promotional
materials have copied Plaintiffs’ advertisements, motion picture images, and
licensed merchandise by employing dark, muted color palettes and a collage
presentation. For example:
a. The Asylum’s Infringing DVD copies and misappropriates
images of Ringwraiths (mythical characters dressed in long,
black hooded robes) depicted in the Lord of the Rings films and
on licensed merchandise:
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD Plaintiffs’ The Lord of the Rings Poster
Plaintiffs’ Licensed The Lord of the Rings Strategy Battle Game
-19- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
b. The Asylum’s Infringing DVD depicts images of dragon-like
creatures in flight, similar to images from the Lord of the Rings
films, as well as promotional posters and merchandise for the
upcoming Hobbit motion picture:
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD Plaintiffs’ The Lord of the Rings Poster
Plaintiffs’ Licensed The Lord of The Plaintiffs’ The Hobbit Poster
Rings Lithograph
-20- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
c. Like the Lord of the Rings’ promotional posters, the Infringing
DVD features medieval battle scenes in the background of its
cover art:
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD Plaintiffs’ The Lord of the Rings Poster
d. The dark, bowed figure holding a golden, illuminated object on
the Infringing DVD artwork appears to have been modeled after
a famous image of the Hobbit Frodo Baggins used to promote
the Lord of the Rings films:
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD Plaintiffs’ The Lord of the Rings Poster
-21- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
55. That the packaging for The Asylum’s Infringing DVD has been
confusingly similar in look and feel to advertisements for and images from the
Plaintiffs’ Lord of the Rings film trilogy and Hobbit Films is no coincidence.
Representatives from The Asylum have told media outlets “that in the new media
world [of the Internet], it’s not always clear what movie it is because you can’t see
the art clearly.” On information and belief, The Asylum intends to take advantage
of consumers who stream the Infringing DVD online or purchase it over the
Internet by advertising thumbnail images of its cover art that, especially due to
their small size on websites like Netflix.com, Bestbuy.com, and Amazon.com, look
very similar to images from the Lord of the Rings films.
56. The Asylum has stated on its website and elsewhere its intention to
release the Infringing DVD for sale within just a few days of the theatrical release
of Plaintiffs’ first Hobbit film in the United States. Specifically, The Asylum plans
to start selling the Infringing DVD in the United States on December 11, 2012 –
just three days prior to the American theatrical release of The Hobbit: An
Unexpected Journey.
57. This timing likewise is no coincidence. Rather, The Asylum and its
agents have chosen to launch their knockoff movie at a time that will maximize
their ability to exploit the extensive publicity and consumer interest surrounding
the theatrical release of Plaintiffs’ Hobbit film. As one of The Asylum’s founders
stated in a news article: “We go after the tent poles – the big studio titles – for the
most part. Those have the most audience awareness and interest, and it’s unlikely
that the release date will change.”
58. Following complaints by Plaintiffs, in or about October 2012 The
Asylum began promoting its Infringing DVD on its own website and on
Netflix.com using modified artwork (the “Alternate Artwork”):
-22- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
The Asylum’s Alternate Artwork
59. The Asylum’s Alternate Artwork still prominently features Plaintiffs’
famous HOBBIT mark in the title “Age of the Hobbits.” The Alternate Artwork
still depicts dragon-like creatures in flight, medieval battle scenes, and a dark,
hooded figure holding an illuminated object – images that evoke Tolkien’s
imaginary world of Middle-earth and suggest an association with the Lord of the
Rings and Hobbit motion pictures. In small, blurry font underneath the title, the
Alternative Artwork now contains a tagline: “They’re Not Tolkien’s Hobbits …
They’re Real.” This statement is unclear and ambiguous, and is wholly inadequate
as a disclaimer in that it fails to redress or reduce the confusion created by The
Asylum’s previous marketing efforts surrounding the Infringing DVD. The
Infringing DVD’s Alternate Artwork therefore is still misleading and likely to
cause consumer confusion.
-23- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
FIRST CLAIM FOR RELIEF
TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT – 15 U.S.C. § 1114
60. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 59.
61. SZC’s registered HOBBIT Marks are inherently distinctive and have
become well-known and famous. This is a result both of the marks’ inherent
distinctiveness and the extensive advertising and sales throughout the United States
of goods and services bearing the HOBBIT Marks.
62. As described above, The Asylum is using in commerce, without
SZC’s authorization or consent and in an explicitly misleading manner, SZC’s
registered HOBBIT Marks in connection with the advertisement, offering for sale,
and/or sale of The Asylum’s Infringing DVD. SZC is informed and believes, and
on that basis alleges, that The Asylum is doing so with the intent to unfairly
compete against SZC, to trade upon SZC’s reputation and goodwill by causing
confusion and mistake among customers and the public, and to deceive the public
into believing that defendant The Asylum’s Infringing DVD is associated with,
sponsored by, or approved by SZC, when it is not. The Asylum’s unauthorized use
of imitations of SZC’s registered HOBBIT Marks is likely to cause confusion,
mistake, or deception in violation of 15 U.S.C. § 1114.
63. Defendant The Asylum’s aforementioned acts have injured SZC and
damaged it in an amount to be determined at trial. By its actions, The Asylum has
irreparably injured SZC. Such irreparable injury will continue unless The Asylum
is preliminarily and permanently enjoined by the Court from further violation of
SZC’s rights, for which SZC has no adequate remedy at law.
SECOND CLAIM FOR RELIEF
FALSE DESIGNATION OF ORIGIN AND
UNFAIR COMPETITION – 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A)
64. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
-24- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 63.
65. The HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit Films’ titles, and the title design and
artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and related licensed
merchandise, are used in commerce, are non-functional, are distinctive, and have
acquired substantial secondary meaning in the marketplace.
66. As described above in detail, The Asylum is using in commerce,
without Plaintiffs’ authorization or consent and in an explicitly misleading manner,
imitations of the HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit Films’ titles, and the title design and
artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and related licensed
merchandise, in connection with the advertisement, offering for sale, and/or sale of
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD.
67. The Asylum’s actions described above and specifically, without
limitation, The Asylum’s unauthorized use of the HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit
Films’ titles, and the title design and artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings
and Hobbit films and related licensed merchandise, and confusingly similar
variations thereof, in commerce to advertise, market, and sell the Infringing DVD;
its express and/or implied representations that its Infringing DVD originated with
or was associated with or endorsed or approved by Plaintiffs; together with its
similar release date for the Infringing DVD, constitute false designation of origin
and unfair competition in violation of 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A).
68. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and on that basis allege, that The
Asylum had actual knowledge of Plaintiffs’ ownership and prior use of the
HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit Films’ titles, and the title design and artwork
associated with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and related licensed
merchandise, prior to commencing the conduct complained of herein.
69. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and on that basis allege, that The
Asylum is engaging in the conduct complained of herein with the intent to compete
unfairly against Plaintiffs, to trade upon Plaintiffs’ reputation and goodwill by
-25- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
causing confusion and mistake among customers and the public, and to deceive the
public into believing that The Asylum’s Infringing DVD is associated with,
sponsored by, or approved by Plaintiffs, when it is not.
70. As a result of the acts complained of herein, The Asylum has created a
likelihood of injury to Plaintiffs’ business reputation and to the reputation and
goodwill surrounding the HOBBIT Marks, the Lord of the Rings films and the
Hobbit Films, and a strong likelihood of consumer confusion as to the source of
origin or relationship of Plaintiffs’ and The Asylum’s goods, and has otherwise
competed unfairly with Plaintiffs.
71. The Asylum’s acts complained of herein were willful and deliberate
and have caused damage to Plaintiffs in an amount to be determined at trial, and
such damages will continue to increase unless The Asylum is enjoined from its
wrongful actions.
72. The Asylum’s willful and deliberate acts constituting false designation
of origin have caused, and will continue to cause, irreparable injury to Plaintiffs’
businesses, substantial loss of goodwill and reputation, and pecuniary damages to
Plaintiffs and consequently have caused, and will continue to cause, a substantial
impact on United States domestic and foreign commerce. Such irreparable injury
will continue unless and until The Asylum is preliminarily and permanently
enjoined from further violation of Plaintiffs’ rights, for which Plaintiffs have no
adequate remedy at law.
THIRD CLAIM FOR RELIEF
TRADEMARK DILUTION – 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)
73. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 72.
74. By virtue of the decades of use and the enormous popularity of the
Tolkien Works and the Lord of the Rings film trilogy, and the massive advertising
and promotion of the Hobbit Films, the HOBBIT Marks are famous among
-26- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
consumers and became famous long before any use of the HOBBIT Marks by The
Asylum.
75. The Asylum’s use of the famous HOBBIT Marks in advertising for
the Infringing DVD as well as on the Infringing DVD itself is and has been for The
Asylum’s own commercial gain.
76. The Asylum’s use of the famous HOBBIT Marks in advertising for
the Infringing DVD as well as on the Infringing DVD itself dilutes the distinctive
quality of and tarnishes the public image of the HOBBIT Marks and is likely to
cause actual dilution of the HOBBIT Marks, thereby impairing the HOBBIT
Marks’ capability of identifying and distinguishing Plaintiffs’, or their licensees’,
goods and services, including the Hobbit Films and related licensed merchandise.
77. The Asylum’s acts complained of herein were willful and deliberate
and have caused damage to Plaintiffs in an amount to be determined at trial, and
such damages will continue to increase unless The Asylum is enjoined from its
wrongful actions.
78. The Asylum’s willful and deliberate acts of trademark dilution have
caused, and will continue to cause, irreparable injury to Plaintiffs’ businesses,
substantial loss of goodwill and reputation, and pecuniary damages to Plaintiffs.
Such irreparable injury will continue unless and until The Asylum is preliminarily
and permanently enjoined from further violation of Plaintiffs’ rights, for which
Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law.
FOURTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF:
FALSE ADVERTISING – 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B)
79. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 78.
80. The Asylum’s actions described above and specifically, without
limitation, The Asylum’s unauthorized use of the HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit
Films’ titles, and the title design and artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings
-27- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
and Hobbit films and related licensed merchandise, and confusingly similar
variations thereof, in commerce to advertise, market, and sell the Infringing DVD;
its express and/or implied representations that its Infringing DVD originated with
or was associated with or endorsed or approved by Plaintiffs; together with its
similar release date for the Infringing DVD, constitute unfair competition and false
advertising in violation of 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B).
81. Consumers are likely to be misled and deceived into believing, based
on The Asylum’s representations and conduct in connection with the
advertisement, offering for sale, and/or sale of The Asylum’s Infringing DVD, that
The Asylum’s Infringing DVD is associated with, sponsored by or approved by
Plaintiffs, when it is not.
82. The Asylum knew or should have known that its representations and
conduct were false or likely to mislead.
83. The Asylum’s acts complained of herein were willful and deliberate
and have caused damage to Plaintiffs in an amount to be determined at trial, and
such damages will continue to increase unless The Asylum is enjoined from its
wrongful actions.
84. The Asylum’s willful and deliberate acts of false advertising have
caused, and will continue to cause, irreparable injury to Plaintiffs’ businesses,
substantial loss of goodwill and reputation, and pecuniary damages to Plaintiffs.
Such irreparable injury will continue unless and until The Asylum is preliminarily
and permanently enjoined from further violation of Plaintiffs’ rights, for which
Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law.
FIFTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF:
CALIFORNIA COMMON LAW UNFAIR COMPETITION
85. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 84.
86. By virtue of the acts complained of herein, The Asylum has
-28- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
intentionally caused a likelihood of confusion among the public and has unfairly
competed with Plaintiffs in violation of the common law of the State of California.
87. The purpose, tendency and effect of The Asylum’s use of the
HOBBIT Marks, as well as titles, title designs, trade dress, packaging and
advertising materials that are confusingly similar to the Hobbit Films’ titles and the
title design and artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and
related licensed merchandise, in the manner alleged above, is to enable The
Asylum to deceive the public by passing off The Asylum’s Infringing DVD as
being rendered, sponsored, or otherwise approved by or connected with Plaintiffs.
88. The Asylum’s use of the HOBBIT Marks, as well as titles, title
designs, trade dress, packaging and advertising materials that are confusingly
similar to the Hobbit Films’ titles and the title design and artwork associated with
the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and related licensed merchandise, in
advertising and offering to sell the Infringing DVD is likely to cause confusion,
mistake or deception as to the source or origin of The Asylum’s Infringing DVD
and said use constitutes infringement of Plaintiffs’ rights with respect to the
Tolkien Works and the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films.
89. The Asylum’s willful acts of unfair competition have caused damage
and irreparable injury to Plaintiffs in an amount to be determined at trial.
90. The Asylum’s willful acts of unfair competition constitute acts of
fraud, oppression and malice. Accordingly, Plaintiffs are entitled to exemplary
damages pursuant to California Civil Code § 3294(a).
SIXTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF:
CALIFORNIA STATUTORY UNFAIR COMPETITION
Cal. Business & Professions Code § 17200, et seq.
91. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 90.
92. By using identical or confusingly similar variations of the HOBBIT
-29- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Marks, as well as titles, title designs, trade dress, packaging and advertising
materials that are confusingly similar to the Hobbit Films’ titles and the title design
and artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and related
licensed merchandise, The Asylum has willfully and without authorization,
appropriated the exclusive property of Plaintiffs. As such, The Asylum has taken
advantage of and usurped the Plaintiffs’ investment and goodwill and has
capitalized on markets created by Plaintiffs for the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit
films.
93. As a result of The Asylum’s exploitation of the HOBBIT Marks, as
well as titles, title designs, trade dress, packaging and advertising materials that are
confusingly similar to the Hobbit Films’ titles and the title design and artwork
associated with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films and related licensed
merchandise, in a manner such that the Infringing DVD packaging is commercially
indistinguishable, The Asylum has been and will be able to pass off and sell its
Infringing DVD of inferior quality as a substitute for Plaintiffs’ Hobbit Films.
94. By virtue of the acts complained of herein, The Asylum has
intentionally caused a likelihood of confusion among the public and has unfairly
competed in violation of California Business & Professions Code § 17200, et. seq.
95. The Asylum’s aforementioned acts constitute unlawful, unfair,
malicious or fraudulent business practices, which have injured and damaged
Plaintiffs. Among other violations of law, The Asylum’s aforementioned acts
constitute false designation of origin and false advertising under 15 U.S.C.
§ 1125(a) and false advertising under California Business & Professions Code
§ 17500, et seq.
96. By its actions, The Asylum has irreparably injured Plaintiffs. Such
irreparable injury will continue unless and until The Asylum is preliminarily and
permanently enjoined from further violation of Plaintiffs’ rights, for which
Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law.
-30- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
SEVENTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF:
CALIFORNIA STATUTORY FALSE ADVERTISING
Cal. Business & Professions Code § 17500, et seq.
97. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 96.
98. The Asylum’s actions described above and specifically, without
limitation, its use of the HOBBIT Marks, as well as titles, title designs, trade dress,
packaging and advertising materials that are confusingly similar to the Hobbit
Films’ titles and the title design and artwork associated with the Lord of the Rings
and Hobbit films and related licensed merchandise, in commerce to advertise,
market, and sell the Infringing DVD; its express and/or implied representations
that the sale of its Infringing DVD originated with or was endorsed or approved by
Plaintiffs; together with its similar release date for the Infringing DVD, constitutes
unfair competition and false advertising in violation of California Business &
Professions Code § 17500, et. seq.
99. Consumers are likely to be misled and deceived into believing, based
on The Asylum’s express and/or implied representations and conduct in connection
with the advertisement, offering for sale, and/or sale of The Asylum’s Infringing
DVD, that The Asylum’s Infringing DVD is associated with, sponsored by or
approved by Plaintiffs, when in fact it is not.
100. The Asylum knew or should have known that its express and/or
implied representations and conduct were false or likely to mislead.
101. The Asylum’s acts of false advertising have caused, and will continue
to cause, irreparable injury, loss of reputation, and pecuniary damages. Such
irreparable injury will continue unless and until The Asylum is preliminarily and
permanently enjoined by this Court from further violation of Plaintiffs’ rights, for
which Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law.
-31- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
EIGHTH CLAIM FOR RELIEF:
CALIFORNIA STATUTORY TRADEMARK DILUTION
Cal. Business & Professions Code § 17247, et seq.
102. Plaintiffs repeat, reallege, and incorporate herein by reference every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 101.
103. By virtue of the decades of use and the enormous popularity of the
Tolkien Works and the Lord of the Rings film trilogy, and the massive advertising
and promotion of the Hobbit Films, the HOBBIT Marks are famous among
consumers.
104. The Asylum’s use of the famous HOBBIT Marks in advertising for
the Infringing DVD as well as on the Infringing DVD itself is and has been for The
Asylum’s own commercial gain.
105. The Asylum’s use of the famous HOBBIT Marks in advertising for
the Infringing DVD as well as on the Infringing DVD itself dilutes the distinctive
quality of and tarnishes the public image of the HOBBIT Marks and is likely to
cause actual dilution of the HOBBIT Marks, thereby impairing the HOBBIT
Marks’ capability of identifying and distinguishing Plaintiffs’, or their licensees’,
goods and services, including the Hobbit Films and related licensed merchandise.
106. The Asylum’s acts complained of herein were willful and deliberate
and have caused damage to Plaintiffs in an amount to be determined at trial, and
such damages will continue to increase unless The Asylum is enjoined from its
wrongful actions.
107. The Asylum’s willful and deliberate acts of trademark dilution have
caused, and will continue to cause, irreparable injury to Plaintiffs’ businesses,
substantial loss of goodwill and reputation, and pecuniary damages to Plaintiffs.
Such irreparable injury will continue unless and until The Asylum is preliminarily
and permanently enjoined from further violation of Plaintiffs’ rights, for which
Plaintiffs have no adequate remedy at law.
-32- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for judgment against The Asylum as follows:
A. For entry of a preliminary and permanent injunction, prohibiting The
Asylum and each of its agents, servants, owners, shareholders, partners,
employees, attorneys, assigns, and all others in privity or acting in concert with it
from committing further infringing acts including:
(1) Using any title, name, service mark, trademark, trade name or
domain name that includes or is confusingly similar to the HOBBIT Marks or
Plaintiffs’ Hobbit Films’ titles or distinctive title design in the advertising or sale of
motion pictures, DVDs, video-on-demand offerings or related goods or services;
(2) Using in any manner any title, service mark, trademark, trade
name, domain name, trade dress, designs, colors, arrangements, collocations, or
any combinations thereof that imitates, resembles, or suggests or is otherwise
confusingly similar to images from the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films,
advertisements, or merchandise;
(3) Otherwise infringing or diluting Plaintiffs’ trademarks, service
marks, and trade names, unfairly competing with Plaintiffs, or otherwise injuring
Plaintiffs’ business reputation in any manner;
(4) Using, registering, or reserving any domain name, Twitter
name, Facebook page name or other similar domain or social networking name or
page that includes the HOBBIT Marks or the Hobbit Films’ titles or distinctive title
design or is confusingly similar thereto.
B. For an order that The Asylum be directed to deliver up for destruction
all DVDs, DVD covers, posters, trailers, advertisements, brochures, labels, signs,
prints, packages, wrappers, publications, software, websites, social networking
pages and all other materials in The Asylum’s possession or under its control that
bear the Age of the Hobbits title, or that use the HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit Films’
titles or distinctive title design, or images from the Lord of the Rings or Hobbit
-33- COMPLAINT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
films, advertisements, or merchandise, or any other reproduction, counterfeit, copy
or colorable imitation and all plates, molds, dies, matrices, and other means of
making or duplicating the same, pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1118.
C. For an order directing that The Asylum engage in corrective
advertising to disclaim any association between Plaintiffs and The Asylum, to
remedy the actual and potential customer confusion in the marketplace due to The
Asylum’s unlawful acts, and to do so in a form, manner and frequency that is
acceptable to Plaintiffs and the Court.
D. That the Court award Plaintiffs compensatory damages and lost
profits in an amount according to proof, and award Plaintiffs exemplary or punitive
damages to the extent permitted by law.
E. That the Court award actual damages for trademark infringement
pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a).
F. For an order that The Asylum account to and pay over to Plaintiffs all
profits derived from its infringing use of the Age of the Hobbits title, or any other
use of the HOBBIT Marks, the Hobbit Films’ titles or distinctive title design, or
images from the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit films, advertisements, or
merchandise, or confusingly similar variations thereof.
G. For costs of suit, attorneys’ fees, prejudgment interest and such other
and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.
H. For an order from the Court that an asset freeze or constructive trust
be imposed over all monies and profits in The Asylum’s possession which
rightfully belong to Plaintiffs.
///
///
///
///
///
1
2
3
1. F or such other relief as the Court deems just and proper.
Dated: November 7,20124
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
JENNR & BLOCK LLP
Attorneys for PlaintiffsWARR BROS. ENTERTAINMNTINC., NEW LINE CINEMA LLC, NEWLINE PRODUCTIONS, INC., METRO-GOLDWY-MA YER STUDIOS INC.,~d THE SAUL ZAENTZ COMPANY
-34-COMPLAINT
1 JURY DEMAND2 Plaintiffs Warner Bros., New Line, MGM, and SZC respectfully request a
3 jury trial on all issues so triable.
4
5
Dated: November 7, 20126
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
JENNR & BLOCK LLP
Attorneys for PlaintiffsWARR BROS. ENTERTAINMNTINC., NEW LINE CINEMA LLC, NEWLINE PRODUCTIONS, INC., METRO-GOLDWY-MA YER STUDIOS INC.,and Tlf SAUL ZAENTZ COMPANY
-35-COMPLAINT
Exhibit A
Int. Cl.: 9
Prior U.S. Os.: 21, 23, 26, 36, and 38
United States Patent and Trademark OfficeReg. No. 2,949,370
Regered May 10, 20
TRAEMAPRICIAL REGISTER
TH HOBBIT
SAUL ZAENTZ COMPANY, THE (DELAWARECORPORATION). DBA TOLKIEN ENTERPRI-SES, .'
2600 TENT STREETBERKELEY, CA 94710
FOR: COMPUTER GAME SOFTARE Al''D IN-STRUCTION MANUALS SOLD AS A UN; VIDEOGAME SOFTARE AND INSTRUCTION MAN-UALS SOLD AS A UNIT; INERACTIVE MULTI-MEDIA COMPUTER GAME SOFTWARE;illERACTIE MULTIMEDIA VIDEO GAME SOFT-WARE; DOWNLOADABLE COMPUTER GAME
SOFTARE; DOWNLOADABLE VIDEO GAMESOFTARE; PRE-RECORDED CD-ROMS FEA TUR-ING FANTASY GAMES, FANTASY FILMS Ar-TIMUSIC, IN CLASS 9 (U,S. CLS. 21, 23.26.36 AND 38).
FIRST USE 11-22-2004; IN COMMERCE 11-22-2004.
OWNER OF U,S, REG. NO, 1,230,026,
SN 76-977.310, FILED 7-9-2002.
ALICE BENMMIAN. EXAING ATTORNEY
7 t,
Trademark Electronic Search" .tem (TESS) Page 1 of2
United States Patent and Trademark Office
Trademarks )0 Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 205:02:46 EDT 2012--_.._~--'Logout I Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser toreturn to TESS)
Typed Drawing
Word Mark
Goods andServices
Mark DrawingCodeSerial NumberFilng Date
Current BasisOriginal Filng 1 B
BasisPublished forOppositionRegistrationNumberRegistrationDateOwner
Attorney ofRecordPriorRegistrationsType of MarkRegisterAffidavit TextLive/DeadIndicator
~. - . ... i I . I Ii 11.-.1.' i ,Ii
THE HOBBIT
IC 009. US 021 023 026 036 038. G & S: ( Computer game softare and instruction manuals soldas a unit; video game softare and instruction manuals sold as a unit;) interactive multimediacomputer game softare; interactive multimedia video game softare; downloadable computergame softare; downloadable video game softare; pre-recorded CD-ROMs featuring fantasygames, fantasy fims and music. FIRST USE: 20041122. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20041122
(1) TYPED DRAWING
76977310July 9, 20021A
March 25, 2003
2949370
May 10, 2005
(REGISTRANT) Saul Zaentz Company, The DBA Tolkien Enterprises CORPORATIONDELAWARE 2600 Tenth Street Berkeley CALIFORNIA 94710
Michael A. Grow
1230026
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL
SECT 15. SECT 8 (6-YR).
LIVE
2
http://tess2. uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4004:iaxj7i.l 0.1 11/2/2012 l 7
Int. Cl.: 41
Prior U.S. as.: 100, 101, and 107
United States Patent and Trademark OfficeReg. No. 3,245,235
Regtered May 22, 207
SERVICE MARKPRICIPAL REGISTER
TH HOBBIT
SAUL ZAENTZ COMPANY, THE (DELAWARECORPORATION), DBA TOLKIEN ENTERPRI-SES,
2600 TENT STREETBERKELEY, CA 94710
FOR: PROVIING NEWS AND INFORMATIONIN THE FIELD OF ENTERTAI!'~ENT RELATIGTO COMPUTER GA1ES. Al\1) VIEO GA1ES VIGLOBAL AND LOCAL AREA NETWORKS, INCLASS 41 (U.s. CLS, 100, 101 AND 107),
FIRST USE 3-15-2006; IN COMMERCE 3-15-2006.
OWNER OF U.s, REG, NO, 1,230,026,
SN 76-429,750, FILED 7-9-2002.
SUE LAWRENCE, EXAINIG AITORNEY
Î
3
35
Trademark Electronic Search C' "em (TESS) Page 1 of2
United States Patent and Trademark Office
Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks )0 Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EDT 2012--------dLògout"I Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser to
Mark DrawingCodeSerial NumberFilng Date
Current BasisOriginal FilingBasisPublished forOppositionRegistrationNumberRegistration Date May 22, 2007
Owner (REGISTRANT) Saul Zaentz Company, The DBA Tolkien Enterprises CORPORATIONDELAWARE 2600 Tenth Street Berkeley CALIFORNIA 94710
return to TESS)
Typed Drawing
Word Mark
Goods andServices
Attorney ofRecordPriorRegistrationsType of MarkRegisterLivelDeadIndicator
-,-' °.,11 I 11 11.-,1.' I .11
THE HOBBITIC 041. US 100 101 107. G & S: providing news and information in the field of entertainmentrelating to computer games, and video games via global and local area networks, FIRST USE:20060315. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20060315
(1) TYPED DRAWING
76429750July 9, 20021A
1B
April 8, 2003
3245235
Michael A. Grow
1230026
SERVICE MARKPRINCIPAL
LIVE--------I.HOME I SITE INDEX I SEARCH I eBUSINESS I HELP I PRIVACY POLICY
4
htt://tess2. uspto.gov /bin/showfie1d?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj 7 i. 9.1 11/2/2012 J 1
r&\\\t~~reb~~~~n~~ ~~~na~~erírq
THE HOBBIT
Reg. No. 3,938,229 THE SAUL ZAENTZ COlvlPANY (DELAWARE CORPORATION), DBA TOLKIENENTERPRISES
Registered Mar. 29, 2011 2600TEsTRETBERKLEY, CA 94710
Int. Cl.: 9
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
fOR: COMPACT GAME DISCS; PRE-RECORDED CD-ROMS fEATUNG fANSYGAMS; VIDEO GAM SOYTWARE FEAlURG FAN'IASY GAMS, IN CLASS 9 (U.S.CLS. 21, 23, 26, 36 AN 38).
FIRST USE 0-0-199 i; IN COMMRCE 0-0- i 99 i.
THE MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CHACTERS wrllOUT CLAIM TO ANY PAR-TICULAR FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
OWNR Of U.s. REG, NO. 2,949,370.
SN 77-197,242, FILED 6-4-2007.
CHRSIE B. KING, EXAG ATTORNY
~J.J:t-~l)in:;.:1i'f (if Ilk: I JIi¡leil Sliiti;~ I'atenl anú l"rtdcii:ik (1f1icc
5
40
Trademark Electronic Search (" 'tern (TESS) Page 1 of2
I) United States Patent and Trademark Office
,. .... Home I Site Index I Se~rch I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks:; Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EDT 2012---------, LogÖur"i Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser toreturn to TESS)
~.. . '. . II . i Ii I 1:.1. ' i ,I.
THE HOBBITWord Mark
Goods andServices
StandardCharactersClaimedMark DrawingCodeSerial NumberFiling DateCurrent BasisOriginal FilingBasisPublished forOppositionRegistrationNumberRegistration Date
Owner
THE HOBBIT
IC 009. US 021 023 026 036 038. G & S: Compact game discs; pre-recorded CD-ROMsfeaturing fantasy games; video game softare featuring fantasy games, FIRST USE:19910000. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 19910000
(4) STANDARD CHARACTER MARK
77197242June 4,20071A
1B
May 20, 2008
3938229
March 29, 2011
(REGISTRANT) The Saul Zaentz Company DBA Tolkien Enterprises CORPORATIONDELAWARE 2600 Tenth Street Berkeley CALIFORNIA 94710
Attorney of Record Michael A. Grow
Prior Registrations 2949370Type of Mark TRADEMARKRegister PRINCIPAL
6
http://tess2. uspto. gOY /bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj 7 i.8.1 11/2/2012 q¡
Int. CI.: 28
Prior U.S. CI.: 22
United States Patent and Trademark OfficeReg. No. 1,230,026
Regstered Mar. 8, 1983
TRADEMARKPrncipal Regiter
HOBBIT
Elan Merchandising Inc. (Delaware corpration)
Tenth and Parker 518,
Berkeley, Calif. 95710, assignee ofIdeal Toy Corporation (Delaware corporation)Holls, N.Y,
For: APPARATUS SOLD AS A UNT FORPLAYING A PARLOR GAME, in CLASS 28 (U.S.CI. 22),
First use Apr. 18, 1977; in commerce Apr. 18,1977.
Ser. No, 124,395, fied Apr. 27, 1977
KATHLEEN J, GALLAGHER, ExaminingAttorney
7
I
i
'-).
Trademark Electronic Search C' 'tern (TESS) Page 1 of2
l! United States Patent and Trademark Office
~ Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks:; Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EDT 2012--------Logout
I Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser toreturn to TESS)
Typed Drawing
Word Mark
Goods andServicesMark DrawingCodeSerial NumberFilng Date
Current BasisOriginal FilngBasisPublished forOppositionRegistrationNumberRegistration Date
Owner
-. ~ . .'. i I . J Ii 11..,1.' i,li
HOBBIT
IC 028. US 022. G & S: Apparatus Sold as a Unit for Playing a Parlor Game, FIRST USE:19770418. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 19770418
(1) TYPED DRAWING
73124395April 27, 19771A
1A
December 7, 1982
1230026
March 8, 1983
(REGISTRANT) Elan Merchandising Inc. CORPORATION DELAWARE Tenth and Parker Sts,Berkeley CALIFORNIA 95710
(LAST LISTED OWNER) SAUL ZAENTZ COMPANY, THE CORPORATION BY ASSIGNMENTDELAWARE 2600 TENTH STREET BERKELEY CALIFORNIA 94710
AssignmentRecordedAttorney of Record Michael A. Grow
Type of Mark TRADEMARKRegister PRINCIPALAffdavit Text SECT 15, SECT 8 (6-YR). SECTION 8(10-YR) 20120411.
Renewal 2ND RENEWAL 20120411Live/DeadIndicator
ASSIGNMENT RECORDED
LIVE--------8
http://tess2. uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj7i. 7.1 11/2/2012 q 3
Int. CI.: 28
Prior U.S. CIs.: 22, 23, 38, and 50
United States Patent and Trademark OfficeReg. No. .2,897,941
Regtered Oct. 26, 20
TRAEMARPRICIAL REGISTER
HOBBIT
SAUL ZAEÑ1Z COMPANY, THE (DELAWARECORPORATION)
2600 TENTH STREETBERKELEY, CA 94710
. FOR: TOY ACTION FIGURES AN ACCESSOR-IES THEREFOR; TOY FIGURES; PUZZLES EXCEPTCROSSWORD PUZZLES; BOAR GAMES; COLLEC-TIBLE TOY FIGURES; MECRA.NICAL ACTIONTOYS; POSITIONABLE TOY FIGURES. IN CLASS28 (U,S, CLS, 22,23,38 AND 50).
FIRST USE 4-7-2003; IN COMMERCE 4-7-2003,
OWNER OF U.S. REG, NO, 1,230,026.
SN 76-976,831, FILED 7-25-200.
LAVERNE THOMPSON, EXAG ATTORNEY
9
e. 4
Trademark Electronic Search Ç' 'tern (TESS) Page 1 of2
,l United States Patent and Trademark Office
'S Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks:; Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EDT 2012--------,Lggotikl Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR (Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser toreturn to TESS)
Typed Drawing
Word Mark
Goods andServices
Mark DrawingCodeSerial NumberFiling DateCurrent BasisOriginal FilingBasisPublished forOppositionRegistrationNumberRegistrationDateOwner
Attorney ofRecordPriorRegistrationsType of MarkRegisterAffdavit Text
LivelDeadIndicator
.,.. ",.tl. I Ii 11.-.1.' I iii
HOBBIT
IC 028. US 022 023 038 050. G & S: (toy action figures and accessories therefor; toy figures;)puzzles except crossword puzzles; board games(; collectible toy figures; mechanical action toys;positionable toy figures). FIRST USE: 20030407. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20030407
(1) TYPED DRAWING
76976831July 25,20001A
1B
January 15, 2002
2897941
October 26, 2004
(REGISTRANT) Saul Zaentz Company, The CORPORATION DELAWARE 2600 Tenth StreetBerkeley CALIFORNIA 94710
Michael A. Grow
1230026
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPALSECT 15. SECT 8 (6-YR).
LIVE--------10
http://tess2. uspto.gov /binlshowfie1d?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj 7 i. 6.1 11/2/2012 4)
Int. CI.: 6, 16, and 25
Prior U.S. CI.: 2, 5, 12, 13, 14, 22, 23, 25, 29, 37, 38,39, and 50
United States Patent and Trademark OfficeReg. No. 2,976,573
Regtered July 26, 20
TRAEMAPRICIPAL REGISTER
HOBBIT
SAUL ZAEKTZ COMPAr-r, THE (DELAWARECORPORATIOK), DBA TOLKIEN ENTERPRI-SES,
2600 TENT STREET
BERKELEY, CA 94710
FOR: PRIED MATTER, NAMELY POSTERS,ART PRINTS, POSTCARDS, IN CLASS 16 (U.S, CLS,2,5,22,23,29,37,38 AND 50),
FOR: FIGURINES AND FIGURAL PRODUCTS,NAMELY. COLLECTBLE FIGURIES AND FIG-URIES .rCORPRA TED INO SETTINGS, MADEOF COMMON METALS AND THEIR ALLOYS, INCLASS 6 (U.S, CLS. 2.12,13,14,23,25 AND 50),
FIRST USE 3-2-2005; IN COMMERCE 3-2-2005,
FOR: CLOTHING, NAMELY, COSTUMES, INCLASS 25 (U,S, CLS, 22 AND 39),
FIRST USE 3-2-205; IN COMMERCE 3-2-2005,
SN 76-164,934, FILED 11-13-200,
FIRST USE 3-2-2005; IN COMMERCE 3-2-2005, MICHELE SWAI, EXAr-lNG ATTORNEY
11
4 ~
Trademark Electronic Search" ~tem (TESS) Page 1 of2
United States Patent and Trademark Office
Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks )0 Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EDT 2012----------: LÕgôJtI Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser toreturn to TESS)
Typed Drawing
Word Mark
Goods andServices
Mark DrawingCodeSerial NumberFiling DateCurrent BasisOriginal FilngBasisPublished forOppositionRegistrationNumberRegistrationDateOwner
Attorney ofRecordType of MarkRegisterAffdavit Text
Live/Dead
-,-' '..fl. I ii 11.-'1" I ,Ii
HOBBIT
IC 006. US 002 012 013 014 023 025 050. G & S: figurines and figural products, namely,collectible figurines and figurines incorporated into settings, made of common metals and theiralloys, FIRST USE: 20050302. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20050302
IC 016, US 002 005 022 023 029 037 038 050. G & S: printed matter, namely, postersr' art prints,postcards). FIRST USE: 20050302. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20050302
IC 025, US 022 039. G & S: clothing, namely, costumes, FIRST USE: 20050302, FIRST USE INCOMMERCE: 20050302
(1) TYPED DRAWING
76164934November 13, 20001A
1B
December 25, 2001
2976573
July 26, 2005
(REGISTRANT) Saul Zaentz Company, The DBA Tolkien Enterprises CORPORATIONDELAWARE 2600 Tenth Street Berkeley CALIFORNIA 94710
Michael A. Grow
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL
SECT 15. SECT 8 (6- YR).
LIVE
12
htt://tess2. uspto.gov /bin/showfield?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj 7 i.5.1 11/2/2012 41
~\\\t;~æb~~~~n~a~~~~~~erírq
THE HOBBIT: AN UNXPECTEDJOURY
Reg. No. 4,187,873
Registered Aug. 7,2012
Int. Cl.: 25
TRA.DEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
1)JJ:t-~Director nfliit. Iiniled Slale," Palent anti Tm.1tinark OITi¡;t:
THE SAUL ZAENTZ COMl'ANY (DELAWARE CORl'OR1\'ION)2600 TENTH STREETBERKELEY, CA 94710
FOR: CLOTIING, NAMELY, T-SHIRTS, SHIRTS, IN CLASS 25 (U.S. CLS. 22 AND 39).
FIRST USE 4-5-20 I 2; IN COM.\1ERCE 4-5-20 I 2.
n-EMARK CONSISTS OF ST.A.NDARD CHARACTERS Win-OUT CLAIM TO, ANY PAR-TICULAR FONT, STYLE, SIZE, OR COLOR.
OWNER OF U.S. REO. NOS. 2,976,573 AND 3,484,821.
SN 85-350,639, FILED 6-20-201 i.
VIVIAN MICZNIK FIRST, EXAMINING ATTORNY
13
. Lje¿
Trademark Electronic Search C' 'tern (TESS) Page 1 of2
IB United States Patent and Trademark Office
_ Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks;: Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EOT 2012--_.._~--Logout I Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser to-..' ",,II' I ii
return to TESS)I 1.-,1. ' i ,I'
THE H()BRTT: AN lJNEXPECTEDJeJURNEY
Word Mark
Goods and Services
Standard CharactersClaimedMark Drawing CodeSerial NumberFilng Date
Current BasisOriginal Filng BasisPublished forOppositionRegistration NumberRegistration Date
Owner
Attorney of RecordPrior RegistrationsType of MarkRegisterLive/Dead Indicator
THE HOBBIT: AN UNEXPECTED JOURNEYIC 025, US 022 039, G & S: clothing, namely, t-shirts, shirts. FIRST USE: 20120405,FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20120405
(4) STANDARD CHARACTER MARK85350639June 20, 2011
1A
1B
September 13, 2011
4187873August 7,2012
(REGISTRANT) The Saul Zaentz Company CORPORATION DELAWARE 2600 TenthStreet Berkeley CALIFORNIA 94710Michael A. Grow2976573;3484821TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL
LIVE--_.._~..-14
http://tess2. uspto .gov /bin/showfie1d?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj 7 iA.l 11/2/2012 Li ~
r&\\\t;~reb~:~~~~ m~~ma~~Crí€cr
Reg. No. 3,981,769
Registered June 21, 2011
Int. Cl.: 16
TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL REGISTER
f)J.Yt-~Dirccllir nr,iic I liiitcd Stal!." Pille-nl and l'r:Jclmlrk. Olliic
THE HOBBIT
THE SAUL ZAENTL. COMPANY (DELAWARE CORPORATION), DBA TOLKIENENTERPRISES,
2600 TENTH STRETBERKELEY, CA 94710
FOR: STRATEGY GUIDES FOR GAMES; POSTERS, IN CLASS 16 (U.S. CLS, 2, 5, 22, 23, 29,37,38 AND 50).
FIRST USE 0-0-2003; IN COMMERCE 0-0-2003.
THE MARK CONSISTS OF STANDARD CHARACTERS WITHOUT CLAIM TO ANY PAR-TICULAR FONT, STYi,E, SIZE, OR COLOR.
O\VNER OF V,S. REG. NO, 2,976,573,
SN 77-197,257, FILED 6-4-2007.
ROBERT STRUCK, EXAMINING ATTORNY
15
50,
Trademark Electronic Search "-."tern (TESS) Page 1 of2
l! United States Patent and Trademark Office
'l Home I Site Index I Search I FAQ I Glossary I Guides I Contacts I eBusiness I eBiz alerts I News I Help
Trademarks:; Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS)
TESS was last updated on Fri Nov 2 05:02:46 EDT 2012--------;dLogout I Please logout when you are done to release system resources allocated for you.
Record 1 out of 1
TSDR ( Use the "Back" button of the Internet Browser to-.-' "..fl. I Ii
return to TESS)11.-.1. 1111
THE HOBBITWord Mark
Goods and Services
Standard CharactersClaimedMark Drawing CodeSerial NumberFilng Date
Current BasisOriginal Filing BasisPublished forOppositionRegistration NumberRegistration Date
Owner
Attorney of RecordPrior RegistrationsType of MarkRegisterLivelDead Indicator
THE HOBBIT
IC 016. US 002 005 022 023 029 037 038 050. G & S: strategy guides for games; posters.FIRST USE: 20030000. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20030000
(4) STANDARD CHARACTER MARK77197257June 4,20071A
1B
July 29, 2008
3981769June 21, 2011
(REGISTRANT) The Saul Zaentz Company DBA Tolkien Enterprises CORPORATIONDELAWARE 2600 Tenth Street Berkeley CALIFORNIA 94710Michael A. Grow2976573TRADEMARK
PRINCIPAL
LIVE--------16
http://tess2.uspto.govlbinlshowfield?f=doc&state=4004: iaxj 7i.3.1 i 11212012 5' J