liquid. you know it works.wingbeats.floridamosquito.org/wingbeats/pdfs/vol10no3.pdf · 2014. 4....
TRANSCRIPT
of the Florida Mosquito Control Association C/
·- Volume 10, Number 3
Liquid. You know it works.
Granules. You know it works.
Pellets. You know it works.
Briquets. You know the drill.
zoEcoM Always read and follow label direcUons. Wellmark lntemationat, Bensenville, IL. Altosid and Zoi!con are trademarks of Wellmark International. @1999 Wellmark International.
PO Box 60005
Fort Myers, FL 33906
Editor-in-Chief Dennis Moore, Fort Myers, FL voice: 941-694-2174 fax: 941-694-6959 e-mail: [email protected]
Associate Editors Charlie Morris, Sarasota, FL Stan Cope, Norfolk, VA
15191 Homestead Rd
Lehigh, FL 33971
John Gamble, New Smyrna Beach, FL
Graphics Alan Curtis, Vero Beach, FL James Newman, Vern Beach, FL
Column Editors Cbemline - Doug Wassmer, Odessa, FL Chip-Chat- Tom Floore, Panama City, FL Crankcase Eddie - Ed Meehan, Mound, MN
Regional Editors Massachusetts - Timothy D. Deschamps, Norwood Michigan -Thomas R. Wilmot, Sanford New Jersey - William C. Reinert, Northfield Texas - Dan Sprenger, Corpus Christi Utah - Glenn Collett, SaJt Lake City
Editorial Review Board Richard Berry, Columbus, OH David Dame, Gainesville, FL Gerry Hutney, Tampa, FL L. Philip Lounibos, Vero Beach, FL Robert Lowrie, Covington, LA Joseph Ruff, Panama City, FL John J. Smith, Norwood, MA James Webb, Santa Ana, CA
Florida Mosquito Control Association FMCA President: Joseph Ruff, Panama City, FL e-mail: [email protected]
Shelly Redovan. FMCA Executive Director PO Box 60837 Fort Myers, FL 33906-0837 voice: 941-694-2174; fax: 941-433-5684 e-mail: [email protected]
Amer ican Mosquito Control Associa tion AMCA President: Bill Zawicki, Freehold. NJ e-mail: bzawicki @aol.com
Marlene Comeaux, AMCA Business Manager 2200 E. Prien Lake Rd. Lake Charles, LA 70601 voice: 318-474-2723; fax: 318-478-9434 e-mail: amcaintl @deltech.net
www.floridamosqiilio.org www.mosquito.org
of the Florida Mosquito Control Association , Volume 10, Number 3 Fall 1999
On the Books: As We Head into the 21st Century: A Brief Retro-spective ... .... ..... ... .... ........ ........... ..... ......................... ............. .... .. 4 by~~ ie ;t;;tl#
Feature: The Mosquito Habitats of New Jersey .................................. a byU'~p. ~
Leading Edge : Education , An Essential Mosquito Control Tool ........ ... ............. .......... .... ..................... .................... : .. ............... 12 by ~ P. ?1t«4a
Vector Bearings: Tick-Tock-Doe: Tick Management Legislation for New Jersey ................ ..... .. ....................... ...................................... 18 by~S-~ .
Natures Way: The Use of Fish in Mosquito Control Programs in the Northeast U.S .......... .... ........ .......... .... ........... .. ..... . ....... ..... 20 by ;;;~ 'J:::e~tt 4l«t ~ s~-~Oo/Je4
Under Surveillance: West Nile Virus in New York City - The Initial Response .. .... ......... ... .. .... ..... ........ ....... .. .. ........ .... ......... ....... . 29 by'D~1/.~
Letter to the Editor & Technical Adviser Announcement .......... 33
~ ~t4U: An official publication of the American Mosquito Control Association, published quarterly by the Florida Mosquito Control Association. 1bis magazine is intended to keep all interested parties informed on matters as they relate to mosquito control. All rights reserved. Reproduction, in whole or part, for educational purposes is permitted, without pennission, with proper citation. The FMCA and the AMCA have not tested any of the products advertised or referred to in this publication, nor have they verified any of the statements made in any of the advertisements or articles. The FMCA and the AMCA do not warrant, expressly or implied, the fitness of any product advertised or the suitability of any advice or statements contained herein. Opinions expressed in this publication are not necessarily the opinions or policies of the FMCA or the AMCA.
Subscriptions: ~ &at.. is sent free of charge to anyone within the continental United States. Subscriptions are available for the cost of first class postage to any foreign address at the following rates: Europe, UK and Australia US$20; Canada, US$6; South America US$10. Make checks and purchase orders payable to the Florida Mosquito Control Association and send to FMCA, PO Box 60837, Fort Myers, FL 33906-0837.
Correspondence: Address all correspondence regarding 'IUf«? ~t4U to the Editor-in-Chief, Dennis Moore, PO Box 60005, Fort Myers, FL, 33906. Readers are invited to submit articles related to mosquito and biting fly biology and control, or letters to the Editors, to the Editor-in-Chief. Tbere is no charge if your article or lener is printed. Photographers and artists are invited to submit color transparencies, high quality original artwork or artWoric in electronic format for possible use in the magazine or on the cover; $100 will be paid for each cover photo. Businesses are invited to place advertisements through the Editor-in-Chief.
About the Cover : Bergen County Mosquito Extennination Commission larviciding catch basins in the 1920' s. Photograph from the Rutgers University Archives provided by Henry Rupp.
-AS,\.JE. HEAD INTO THE-2tsi CENTURY: --·
Mosquitoes have always played a significant role in the history of mankind; one researcher has even claimed that mosquito-borne disease has been responsible for half the world's deaths. Others have questioned the role of mosquitoes in the downfall of classical Grecian civilization. Hippocrates, the "Father of Medicine", was aware of malaria and its symptoms.
Malaria and yellow fever have always been participants in military affairs wherever men, mosquitoes and stagnant water coincided on the battlefield. Their impacts began to take shape in the 14th century and grew more severe as explorers and military personnel traveled to tropical areas where disease was endemic and mosquitoes plentiful. Mosquitoes played a significant role in earning sub-Saharan Africa the title of "The White Man's Grave." In World War I, malaria plagued Allied Forces in the eastern Mediterranean, and in World War II American servicemen ip the Pacific theater suffered more casualties from malaria than from the efforts of the Imperial Japanese Army. Veterans of the Vietnam conflict can also bear witness to the effects of mosquitoborne disease.
The history of the United States itself has been shaped by mosquitoborne disease. In the Americas, the 1st recorded case of yellow fever, a disease that came to the New World with the slave trade, was 1648. There were 135 major yellow fever epidemics in American port cities between 1668 and 1893, and a major outbreak in Philadelphia in 1793 may well have doomed that
4 Fall 1999
. A BRiEF Ii£TROSPE~fiVE ·. .
city's future as the capitol of the United States. Specific incidents of historic importance include the devastation of an army sent by Bonaparte in 1802 to conquer Haiti. It is reported that 29,000 out of 33,000 died of yellow fever. That loss led to the sale of the Louisiana Territories to the United States in 1803. The loss of 22,000 lives in the French effort to build the Panama Canal was one of the important elements that led to the abandoning of the effort in 1889 and ultimately to the successful construction of the Canal by the United States, an effort made possible by mosquito control efforts.
Early hand-ditching crew
In New Jersey, the historical role of mosquitoes has not been quite as significant, nor as traumatic, although mosquito-borne disease has a well-established pedigree in the state. Historians are not sure whether it was mosquitoes or the British that made the Swedish settlement of Fort Elfsburg on the Delaware Bay untenable although one historian places the blame squarely on the mosquitoes. More certain is the role of New Jersey mosquitoes in American humor. The adventures of visitors to shore
resorts from the New York area were not only reflected in the paintings of Winslow Homer but also in the jokes that made the mosquito the state bird: 0. Henry has a story in which a character refers to "those snipe they call mosquitoes in New Jersey." Since New York was home base to many entertainers in the 19th century, New Jersey's reputation as the mosquito state spread throughout the land. However, there were serious folks looking at mosquitoes in New Jersey.
Significant progress had been made in the latter part of the 19th century in studying mosquitoes and disease: Laveran and Ross in malaria, Manson in filariasis, Finlay and Reed in yellow fever. Efforts to control the cause of so much misery and economic trouble were under way, so it is no wonder that at the closing of the 19th century, New Jersey was looking to study the impact of mosquitoes on the state. Thus, the New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station (NJAES) provided Dr. John B. Smith a small sum of money to investigate the problem. As the 20th century started, Dr. Smith sent out a survey to local health officers to determine the nature and scope of mosquito problems, principally as they related to malaria. His work in 1901 prompted the legislature to authorize the expenditure of $10,000 "to investigate and report upon the mosquitoes occurring within the state, their habits, life history, breeding place, relation to malarial, and other diseases, the injury caused by them to the agricultural, sanitary, and other interests of the state, their natural enemies, and the best meth-
ods of lessening, controlling or otherwise diminishing the numbers, injury or detrimental effect upon the agricultural, sanitary, and other interests of the state." Although funding for that year was never implemented, Dr. Smith in 1904 presented a monumental report to the senate: The Mosquitoes Occurring
Early hand-ditching crew
within the State, Their Habits, Life History, etc. -the first major study of its kind on mosquitoes.
While Dr. Smith was busy studying mosquitoes and providing suggestions for their control, the citizens of South Orange, New Jersey, were starting the century by initiating a local campaign against mosquitoes. This municipal program continued until the work was taken over by the Essex County Mosquito Extermination Commission under Chapter 104, Laws of 1912, the statutes governing county mosquito control efforts in New Jersey. lri 1902 mosquito control efforts were started in Elizabeth, and Newark followed suit in 1903. In 1905, the legislature provided $6,000 for state aid to municipalities for drainage work for mosquito control under the direction of the NJAES. Only Elizabeth, with a grant of $1,000 took advantage of these funds. The NJAES became involved with the funding of the installation of extensive drainage for mosquito control
beginning in 1906 with laws that established the obligations of the . NJAES regarding mosquito surveys. Water management was a doubleedged weapon in those days, for in addition to controlling mosquitoes, many reports speak of reclaiming land through drainage and making it a generator of tax revenues.
Although mosquito control agencies exist in 20 of New Jersey's 21 counties, county involvement with mosquito control has not been as uniform as that figure would seem to indicate. In fact, only 2 of 21 counties have been actively involved in mosquito control continuously since the passage of the 1912 laws. With relatively few changes, these laws written by John B. Smith, a lawyer as well as an entomologist, have served the mosquito control community well. Essentially, it is the duty of the mosquito extermination commission ''To perform all acts which in its opinion may be necessary for the elimination of mosquito breeding areas, or which will tend to exterminate mosquitoes within the county." Dr. Smith died before he could see the product of his labors, but this straightforward declaration of intent established him as the founding father of mosquito control in New Jersey; and, to the extent these laws served as a model for other states, he can justifiably be considered one of the framers of mosquito control in this country. So, mosquito control in New Jersey started at the municipal level but since the passage of the mosquito laws the counties have done the bulk of mosquito control work.
In the 1914 Proceedings of the New Jersey Mosquito Extermination Association (NJMEA) all counties were reported as having mosquito extermination commissions in 1912; however, a review of the reports shows that only Essex and Union counties had actually started control operations. Six more started up in 1913 and 3
more in 1914. Mosquito control was not an easy sell in those early years. One of the things that weighed against the commissions was that they were established as autonomous bodies-something elected politicians viewed with concern because of their independence of the political process-whose members were appointed by judges and whose plans and estimates were approved by the Director of the NJAES. Commissions and later control agencies came into and went out of existence, and it was not until 1977 that the current figure of 20 of 21 counties was achieved as a constant. Although it was listed as having a commission in the 1914 Proceedings, Hunterdon County has from the beginning remained without a mosquito control agency.
Commissions have been established, disestablished and re-established for various reasons, but the most significant changes occurred after 1977 when Union County abolished all autonomous boards and commissions, a reflection of the desire to centralize control of county government. The last year in which all 20 mosquito extermination commissions did control work was 1970. Currently, 8 of 20 agencies remain as commissions.
Larviciding in Passaic County, NJ
A 3rd participant in New Jersey's mosquito control picture was created in 1956: the New Jersey State Mosquito Control Commission (SMCC). The SMCC was created ''to carry on a continuous study of
Fall 1999 5
mosquito control and extermination in the State, to recommend to the Governor and the Legislature, from time to time, changes in legislation which in its judgment may be necessary or desirable to be enacted in order to enforce and carry out mosquito extermination and control work throughout the State, to recommend to the Legislature the amount of money which in its judgment it shall deem necessary and desirable to be appropriated each year by the State for mosquito control purposes and to allocate funds appropriated for State aid to counties in the performance of such work among the various counties through the New Jersey State Agricultural .Experiment Station, to act in an advisory capacity in all matters pertaining to mosquito extermination and control and to cooperate with the agencies of other States and the Federal Government in the elimination of mosquito breeding areas under their control." The SMCC was housed at the NJAES until 1978 when it was moved to Trenton under the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). Initially, the primary role of the SMCC was to serve as a funding agency for projects and equipment that were beyond a county's funding resources; however, the SMCC soon assumed other duties. It began the administration of the State Airspray Program in 1960. The SMCC supports research activities and mosquito and vector surveillance programs. The DEP established an Office of Mosquito Control Coordination to service and administer the SMCC and to aid in processing permits required for water management projects and represent the state in mosquito control issues and prob-lems. ·
Recognizing the need for sharing of information and cooperative endeavor, New Jersey's first mosquito control association was formed in 1903: the Conference Committee on Mosquito Extermination. Representatives from 14 mu-
6 Fall 1999
nicipalities in north Jersey met .on July 17, 1903, at the Newark Board of Health. In 1910 the name was changed to the North Jersey Mosquito Extermination League. With the passage of the mosquito laws and the establishing of county mosquito extermination commissions, it was natural that the New Jersey Mosquito Extermination Association was established to share information on mosquito control activities in New Jersey and throughout the United States ("Extermination" was changed to "Control" in 1975 when the association was reorganized and incorporated.). Founded in late 1913 and formally organized in 1914, the NJMCA has published Proceedings of these meetings uninterruptedly since 1914.
As more counties became involved in operational mosquito control, it was clear to Dr. Thomas J. Headlee, Dr. Smith's successor, that more frequent meetings were essential. The monthly meetings of the Associated Executives of Mosquito Control Work in New Jersey answered this need and provided the coordination of efforts previously provided by the NJAES. The Associated Executives have been meeting since 1921 to ponder the problems of mosquito control-not all of them related to mosquitoes-but still the nuts and bolts of doing mosquito control in a modern, more environmentally oriented world.
In 1935, when the need for an organization of broader scope was recognized, the Eastern States Association of Mosquito Control Workers was formed in New Jersey. This regional association was reorganized as the American Mosquito Control Association (AMCA) in 1944 to reflect the widespread mosquito control activities and the extensive research projects taking place throughout the nation. The AMCA now claims worldwide membership, and its publications reflect the activities of researchers and control workers.
Mosquito control has come a long way since the beginning of the century when insecticides were few, labor inexpensive and budgets small. New methods have been developed and old methods have been improved. Where extermination was once the goal and draining swamps and wetlands was seen a positive step that made land available for useful and taxable purposes, now mosquito workers understand that control has to be environmentally more sound as well as economically effective. Ironically, some claim that mosquito control has been so effective that nobody knows it exists any more; and, statistically, at least here in New Jersey, mosquito-borne disease- with the exception of an eastern equine encephalitis outbreak that took 22 lives in 1959 - has been insignificant in terms of lost lives; adverse economic effects have usually been more severe than the physical ones. Only when things get bad or people get sick or die, do people remember that there are workers and researchers responding to their concerns.
As we move into the 21 st century, mosquito workers from around the world still meet regularly to share information . The mosquito has proved a resilient foe and, while we have controlled many, they still manage, through their consummate ability to adapt themselves to different and hostile environments, to cause suffering , death and discomfort throughout the world. What will mosquito control workers and researchers be reporting at the end of the new millennium?
r . ~
<_ Henry Rupp is semi:retired and is an active member .of NJMCA currently serY:ing as the copy editor for the AMCA program and abstract -books. ·
h.rupp@worldne._tatt.net ~ ~
~-L"l1~ . ' . ;I
~Jl,1~f(1lit(1 1lJ~Jtt~ ·ts
~l~l.t/ _]~l,S~lj
Although New Jersey is only 150 mi. long and less than 75 mi. wide, the state provides larval habitat for 62 different mosquito species. Few states, regardless of size, support greater numbers of mosquitoes. Much of the bio-diversity, in terms of mosquito breeding habitats, can be attributed to events that took place during the last ice age. The great glacier that covered much of North America stopped on a line that roughly separated New Jersey into halves. The southern half is flat and sandy, the northern half is rocky and hilly. The drastic differences that New Jersey exhibits interrain are the result of glacial sculpture. As the ice flow melted down over southern New Jersey, the finest particulates were deposited on what is now known as the coastal plain of the state. The area is an expansive flat, sandy zone that is only 0-20 m above sea level. The coastal plain was never exposed to glacial gouging and is entirely devoid of natural lakes.
The New Jersey Pine Barrens are the most striking ecological component of the ' coastal plain, with extensive stands of Pitch Pine and Scrub Oak growing in grayish-white sand. Most of the streams that meander through the pine barrens are rich in tannins and support ex-tensive areas of sphagnum bog habitat. Dense stands of Atlantic White Cedar grow along many of the streams and reach greatest size in areas where freshwater estuaries drain onto coastal ... salt marsh habitat. The streams that flow through the pine barrens are highly acidic and have the color of brewed tea. Locals call this water "cedar water'', a media that is revered in the culture of tropical fish. Further north, the vegetation changes from oak-pine to mixed hardwood forest and the flat sandy landscape becomes rolling foothill terrain. Someyvhat larger particles settled from glacial melt in this transition zone leaving soils containing small to moderate sized rocks and stones. Many of the lakes in this region are man-made but a few have been cut by glacial action. Much of the foothill region has a shale base but in some areas the subsoil is composed of a yellow clay. The streams that flow through the foothills are relatively clear but turn muddy brown after heavy rains. The bog habitats associated with south-
8 Fall 1999
ern New Jersey become swamps this far north with a thick mud substrate from years of eutrophication.
As you progress further northward in the state, the terminal moraine of the glacier gouged numerous deep lakes and created small mountain ranges that extend up to 600 m above sea level. Soils rich in limestone leave deep sink holes in some areas and roadways must be blasted through immense stands of pure granite. Rocks become boulders in the northern region, the largest melt depositions along the glacier's retreating path. The swamps in the north have a characteristically soft bottom made of a dark black muck. The streams in the
''-. northern portion of the state are freestone streams . ""' that rush down from portions of the higher ter-. · rain. New Jersey's mosquito habitats are
increased substantially by the fact that nearly 75% of its perimeter is coastal in nature. On the east coast, a series
of barrier beaches separate the main-land from the Atlantic Ocean and provide salt marsh habitat in areas where salt water bays meet fresh water estuaries.
The states of Delaware and Pennsylvania function like barrier beaches in the southern portion of New Jersey's western perimeter and create vast expanses
of salt marsh wetlands along Delaware Bay. Much of these marshes have been
purposely dyked for the commercial production of salt hay and function as a nursery for a
variety of salt marsh mosquito species. The Delaware River forms the western boundary of the
state, a river that supports commercial boat traffic on its southern third and undergoes a slow transition
to shallow, rushing torrent as it progresses past the Delaware Water Gap northward. This variety of habitats over a very short distance allows for a variety of mosquito life cycle types. The rapid geologic transition from north to south provides habitat for univoltine Aedes that reach greatest abundance in Canada as well as Aedes, Culex and Psorophora that are distinctly southern in distribution. The vast expanses of salt marsh along the coast provide habitat for select estuarine species and, like all areas, urban centers provide breeding habitat for domestic mosquitoes.
Single Generation Aedes -New Jersey provides habitat for 16 single generation Aedes. They all possess desiccation resistant eggs
, ..
.,
Typical Snowpool
that allow them to spend most of the year in diapause. Univoltine Aedes hatch in early spring, emerge during April or May and lay eggs that enter diapause until the following season. Although several univoltine Aedes have a geographic distribution that includes the coastal plain, the vast majority are limited to the northern 1/3 of the state. Aedes communis, Ae. implicatus, Ae. intrudens, Ae. provocans and Ae. punctorare very rare and have only been collected from elevations above 450 m near High Point, NJ. The single generation Aedes found in New Jersey fall into 3 different habitat groups. Most of the univoltine Aedes breed in woodland pools which are actually ground depressions underlayed with clay in wooded areas that support perched water tables in early spring. The term "snowpool" has been coined as a habitat that is common at high elevations in the northern areas. The snowpool/woodland pool Aedes must pupate and emerge before trees develop leaves because the roots quickly drain the water from this unique larval habitat as soon as the forest begins to show signs of awakening. Larvae that have not pupated become concentrated into
tiny puddles and many get stranded as the habitat dries. Ae. stimulans is New Jersey's most important woodland pool pest, but Ae.
excrucians and Ae. grossbeckii cause nuisance in some areas. New Jersey also has single generation Aedes that breed in swamps and bogs. The larvae are rarely, if ever, found in woodland pools but are common in wetlands that support aquatic vegetation. These mosquitoes also hatch from eggs in early spring, emerge during the month of May and
lay eggs that enter diapause until the following spring. Ae. abserratus forms the prototype for this life cycle type but Ae. aurifer, Ae. cinereus and A e. fitchii are bog Aedes as well. All of the single generation bog Aedes reach greatest abun dance in the northern half of the state but most have isolated populations on the coastal plain. Culiseta morsitans and Cs. minnesotae are bog species that have winter hardy eggs and undergo this Aedine life cycle type. The third single generation Aedes life cycle type has a major generation in early spring and one or more smaller generations in the fall if the habitats flooded late in the season. The mosquitoes are not restricted to geographic boundaries and function as pests statewide. Most scientists feel that the fall hatching in univoltine species represents eggs that failed to hatch during the spring
flooding. Some feel that the mosquitoes may be bivoltine rather than univoltine. Ae. canadensis is the best example of a single generation mosquito that frequently reappears later the same season. A e. sticticus is a species with this type of life cycle that is fast becoming recognized as one of New Jersey's most important mosquito pests.
Multiple Generation Aedes and Psorophora- New Jersey provides habitat for 24 Aedes and Psorophora that undergo multiple generations during each breeding season. Like the univoltine Aedes, this group has desiccation resistant eggs, but the overwintering brood gives rise to a series of generations that hatch with each major flooding event from spring through fall. The multivoltine Aedes and Psorophora found in New Jersey also fall into 3 different habitat groups. There are multiple generation Aedes/ Psorophora that breed in fresh floodwater and rely on rains to hatch each generation during the active season. Most of the multivoltine
Fresh Floodwater
floodwater pests have a statewide distribution but a few are restricted to the coastal plain. Ae. vexans belongs to this group and is recognized statewide as New Jersey's most important mosquito pest. Ae. at/anticus is a southern pest that is found only on the coastal plain. Ae. trivittatus reaches greatest abun-
continued on page 11
U'~ a'eat4 Fall 1999 9
To protect children ...
You have to be Tough on Adults.
You can't compromise when it
comes to protecting the public
health from vector-home diseases.
That's why FYFANON<» ULV
is the malathion of choice for
They !mow that quality and
performance go hand-in-hand.
And FYFANON ULV gives you both:
consistent quality
and consistent -
the overwhelming majority of
mosquito control professionals.
performance. FVFANON® ULV ,
@ CHEMINOVA
So the next time
you are faced with
INSECTICIDE
a choice, turn to the malathion you
!mow and trust: high-purity, proven
performance, FYFANON ULV
FYFANON<» ULV- Tough on adults!
Cheminova, Inc., 1700 Route 23, Suite 210, Wayne, New Jersey 07470
Now available in 260-gallon minibulk containers
For further information contact your local distributor
or call l -800-548-6ll3.
'"'FYFANON ls a R-gbteml n'ademark or Chtmtnova.
continued from page 9
Salt Marsh Floodwater
dance in the northwestern portion of New Jersey and is an extremely important regional pest around northern lake communities. Ae. dupreei, Ps. varipes and Ps. discolor are extremely rare but follow this basic life cycle type. New Jersey has multiple generation Aedes that have enough salt tolerance to use coastal salt marshes as their primary breeding habitat. The eggs rely on lunar tides rather than rains and normally produce 2 broods per month from May to October. New moon and full moon tides produce predictable broods of salt marsh mosquitoes. Rains, however, can trigger egg hatch on the marsh and produce additional nuisance. Ae. so/licitans is New Jersey's most important salt marsh mosquito pest but Ae. cantator and Ae. taeniorhynchus belong to this habitat type as well. Ae. dorsalis is a western salt marsh pest that occurs in small numbers on some of New Jersey salt marshes. The third multiple generation Aedes life cycle type uses containers as a vehicle to receive their desiccation resistant eggs. The species in this category deposit their eggs just above the waterline in containers that will eventually receive rain water. Ae. triseriatus is New Jersey's most important pest species in this life cycle type but Ae. hendersoni and Ae. atropalpus are container breeders as well. Two recently introduced exotics, Ae. albopictus and Ae. japonicus utilize this multivoltine life
cycle type but are found in tires more often than treeholes.
Multiple Generation Anopheles, Culex, Culiseta and Uranotaenia- New Jersey provides habitat for 15 multivoltine species that emanate from bodies of permanent water. The members of this multivoltine group have eggs that collapse if they dry, thus, the female deposits them
directly on standing water. Most hibernate during winter as mated females; a few species overwinter as larvae and one (An. walken) has a winter hardy egg. The mosquitoes that belong to this group are found in 3 different habitat types in New Jersey. Most lay their eggs in freshwater swamps and undergo multiple generations in this habitat after the bog Aedes have emerged. An. quadrimaculatus is the most common representative of this group and usually shares habitat statewide with Culex territans, An. walkeri, An. punctipennis and Uranotaenia sapphirina. Cx. erraticus is restricted to the coastal plain; An. earlei occurs only at high elevations in northwestern New Jersey. Cx. salinarius, An. bradleyi and An. atropos have salt tolerance and reach greatest concentrations in brackish marshes along the coast. Cx. pipiens, Cx. restuans and Cs. inomata have pollution tolerance and tend to be urban rather than rural pests.
Unique Multiple Generation Container Breeders - A number of non-aedine mosquitoes lay their. eggs in containers and spend their entire larval period in bodies of trapped water. Tin cans, plastic cups and discarded tires represent larval habitats that are provided by mankind. Treeholes, and plant ax-
ils are examples of natural containers that can be utilized by mosquitoes. Most of the members of this group occur statewide but are relatively rare. They also share habitat with the container breeding Aedes which makes their detection that much harder. An. barberi is a treehole anopheline that infrequently occurs in tires. This tiny An. is extremely aggressive and can be predacious on early instar larvae of other container-breeding mosquitoes. Orthopodomyia signifera and Or. alba are very rare container breeders that favor treeholes with very putrid water. Toxorhynchites rutilus septentrionalis is a containerbreeding predator that relies on the larvae of other container-breeding mosquitoes as a constant source of food. Tx. r. septentrionalis has a statewide distribution and overwinters as a larva in treehole habitats. Wyeomyia smithii is a unique con-
Early Season Freshwater Swamp
tainer breeding mosquito that is found only in the leaves of the northern pitcher plant, a predacious plant that is common in many areas of the New Jersey pine barrens. This tiny mosquito is autogenous at New Jersey's latitude and obtains protein by feeding on the decaying carcasses of insects that have been trapped by the plant. The mosquito undergoes multiple generations during the summer season and overwinters as a larva in the water trapped by the plant. During the
continued on page 26
Fall 1999 11
Where does education fall in your list of prioritized mosquito/vector control programs? Often, it is listed at the end; however, some put it right at the top. I have heard that education is a waste of time and that "real" mosquito control is surveillance, source reduction, biological control, larviciding and adulticiding. A person or an agency may have a
1999 NJ Mosquito Poster Contest Judy Hansen presents winners
good idea, a wonderful product or provide great service to the public but won't be able to market it if the product is not known. Education in mosquito control is a form of marketing. Also, it serves the purpose of enlisting assistance in the actual control of mosquitoes.
Dr. John B. Smith, entomologist at Rutgers University at the turn of the century, knew that mosquitoes could be controlled; he offered solid biological data as a basis for proposed legislation mandating mosquito control programs in New Jersey. However, Dr. Smith had to convince the New Jersey legislature that
12 Fall 1999
controlling mosquitoes was possible and that establishing county mosquito extermination commissions under the guidance of the Director of the NJ Agricultural Experiment Station was a reasonable approach. He began this endeavor in 1900. He also had to work with health officers to demonstrate that this endeavor was worthy of sepa-
rate agencies outside the Department of Health. Once the legislation was in place, county boards of chosen
1 freeholders (the governing , body for each New Jersey 1
county) had to be educated 1 and persuaded to establish , a county mosquito control
program and accept the mandatory appropriation for mosquito control as originally stipulated in the law. To this day freeholders have to be educated about mosquitoes and the need for mos-
quito control in order to maintain effective county mosquito control programs.
The Proceedings of the New Jer
quito can be controlled. Before we can obtain the proper local support, information of a very convincing character will have to be spread among us."
Also at this meeting it was noted that in 1901 the South Orange Improvement Association (in Essex County) under the direction of Spencer Miller "initiated a campaign against the pests and secured Dr. l. 0. Howard, entomologist for the United States Department of Agriculture, to lecture in South Orange on the subject. Following this lecture the South Orange Improvement Association carried out a campaign throughout the season and each season following until the work was taken up on a broader basis. The local campaign against mosquitoes ... continued steadily each year until it was taken over by the Essex County Mosquito Extermination Commission and carried on under the provisions of Chapter 104, Laws of 1912 which called for every county to establish a mosquito Commission. Beginning in 1902, similar activity had started in
Bill Zawicki at 1997
sey Mosquito Control Association's first annual meeting in Atlantic City on February 20 and 21, 1914 contained several references emphasizing the importance of education in the field of mosquito control. Mr. C.H. Cranmer, Board of Health member in Ocean County, reported at this meeting, "'The difficulty in our county is that the people do not believe that the mos-
NJ Mosquito Expo at Trenton, NJ
Elizabeth , Union County." Dr. Jacob G. Lipman, Director of the NJ Agricultural Experiment Station, added "It is, therefore, a question of education. The taxpayers in Essex and Union Counties have been educated, but those in other counties of the State have not been educated to this extent or not at all, and educational work must be continued."
Also at the 1914 meeting, Mr.
"We expect to start with a small sum of money, which will be devoted to educational and demonstrational work with the idea of so convincing the people of the value of the work that The Board of Freeholders may the following year appropriate sufficient money
may result in educating the parents at home. In a thank you note following a presentation, fourth grader
Walter Evans, Director of the Essex County Board of Chosen Freeholders stated, "I think it is of the utmost importance that a vigorous campaign of education be commenced for the purpose of arousing public sentiment in favor of this work which has been so satisfactorily begun in Essex County, and that through the mail , the attention of the people should be continually called to the dangers of existing conditions and the great benefits that would be reaped from a persistent successful fight against this plague." Dr. Thomas Headlee, New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station, stated at this meeting " ... most of the troubles which we experience in the carrying out of this law has been the result of trying to carry on mosquito extermination work in counties
to carry on a more extensive campaign."
Know Mosquitoes Board Game
Repeated educational efforts had to be undertaken to get mosquito control accepted and established in New Jersey. This was a critical part of the early process and an essential component to "real" mosquito control programs. One of the early activities undertaken around 1920 involved the production of a teaching manual and a motion picture. The manual made a simple statement concerning the New Jersey mosquito problem and showed the means taken to solve it. This manual was intended for use
••
by students from the eighth through twelfth grades. Cooperation from the state commissioner of education came in the form of a recommendation to county and city superintendents of schools for inclusion as regular part of their course in biology. Some 119,000copies of the manual were produced.
Today, reaching out to schools is
Jim McNelly in the classroom encouraged by
where the people are not sufficiently informed in the nature and value of it to support it." Dr. Headlee, referring to Middlesex County reported,
teachers and welcomed by students. A change of pace and a break from the regular teacher can be the foundation for an attentive audience. Distributing literature to students
Rose Turney wrote "Thank you for that program on mosquitoes. It was very interesting. My dad read the paper you gave us. I learned a lot about mosquitoes."
Recently, the AMCA Public Relations and Education Committee, developed a game to be used for public education. Jim McNelly, Rutgers University, has followed up on this idea. With funding made available through the AMCA's partnership in the US Department of Environmental Protection Agency's Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program and support from the AMCA Board of Directors, 3,000 copies of a board game, titled "KNOW MOSQUITOES", are being produced. The game is geared toward elementary school children and has players start at a school and travel through various environs en route to their local mosquito control office by answering mosquito related questions. Consider using it in your district in the future.
Residents can be of significant help in surveillance and actual control efforts. While at times other insects are mistaken for mosquitoes, almost everyone knows an adult mosquito when they see it. Some districts have limited personnel for conducting landing rates to identify the problem species and/or to jus-
continued on page 24
Fall 1999 13
ENVIRONMENTALLY COMPATIBLE MOSQUITO CONTROL PRODUCTS
Distributed By
ZANUS CORPORATION™ The Altosid® Distributor in the West and dedicated to the mosquito control industry.
LARVICIDES ALTOSID® A.L.L. SR-20, BRIQUETS, PELLETS AND XR BRIQUETS NEW: ALTOSID® XRG GRANULE
BIOSID™ LARVICIDE WITH BIODAC & ALTOSID A.L.L.
TEKNAR®HP-D Bti WITH SUPPRESSED SPORES
ADULTICIDES ANVIL® 2:2 & 10:10 WITH SUMITHRIN
BIOMIST® 3:15,4:12,12:60 & 31:66 WITH PERMErnRIN
EQUIPMENT THE TERMINATOR™ PESTICIDE APPLICATOR
ARRO-GUN™ GRANULAR APPLICATORS
EDUCATIONAL TRAINING AND SUPPLIES SAFETY EQUIPMENT LIGHT TRAPS & MOSQUITO SURVEY TOOLS
ZANUS CORPORATION: 1259 EL CAMINO REAL, SUITE 134, MENLO PARK, CA 94025 800-347-7783, FAX: 650-368-3104, e-mail: [email protected]; web: WWW.ZANUS.COM
AMI A TilL AMIIU( i\N MUSQUITl l CO'-'TROL \SSOCI \Ttl>'-:
2200 East Prien Lake Rd. Lake Charles, LA 70601
Phone: 318-474-2723 Fax: 318-478-9434
Individuals enhancing the health and qualify of life through the suppression of mosquitoes, other
vectors and pesfs of public health importance.
PAYMENT _ Check payable to AMCA enclosed.
Visa Mastercard _American Express Discover
AMCA tax I.D. #22-171-5661
Account Number Exp. Date
Printed Name of Cardholder
Signature
CANCELLATIONS Notifi~ation of cancellation must be submitted to AMCA Central Office in writing. A $50.00 cancellation fee will apply to cancellation received by March I, 2000. No fees will be refunded for cancellation received after March I. 2000 for any reason.
RETURN THIS FORM WITH PAYMENT TO: AMCA 2200 East Prien Lake Rd. Lake Charles. LA 7060 I
FAX CREDIT CARD PAYMENTS TO: 318-478-9434
QUESTIONS? Please call the AMCA Central Office at 318-474-2723.
Note: Registrations will not be processed without full payment. Purchase orders will not be considered as full payment. Please do not send a registration form without payment. Enclose a check payable to AMCA in U. S. funds drawn on a U. S. bank, U. S. postal money order or U. S. traveler's checks: or prO\·ide credit card information above. Only on-site registrations will be accepted after January 31, 2000.
For Continuing Education Credits (CEC) documentation, include completed CEC form.
2000 ANNUAL MEETING REGISTRATION
American Mosquito Control Association 66th Annual Meeting- March 12-16, 2000
Bally's Park Place
Atlantic City, NJ
ONE FORM PER PERSON/ PLEASE DUPLICATE
NAME for badge
ORGANIZATION for badge
CITY, STATE, OR COUNTRY for badge
MAILING ADDRESS FOR CONFIRMATION:
STREET ADDRESS
CITY STATE ZIP COUNTRY
WORK PHONE FAX E-MAIL
Are you a member of AMCA? Yes No Non-members may join and qualify for the member meeting registration fee by selecting a member category below and returning payment with your completed registration form.
Is this your first AMCA Meeting? Yes No
REGISTRATION FEES (Please circle your selection)
Member Status
AMCAMember
Non-member (join now and register at the member rate)
On or before 1131100
$175.00
$210.00
Trustee $225.00
Student (banquet not included) $50.00
Personal Guest $90.00
Extra Banquet $40.00
Additional items: CEC Documentation
Memberships: (Confirmation will be mailed within 6-8 weeks. )
Regular - $70.00 (receive-r 4 issues of lou mal, 6 issues ofNewsletter, 4 issues of WingBeats)
Associate - $30.00 (recei••es 6 issues ofNewsletler, 4 issues of Wing Beats)
Student - $30.00 (receil•es 4 issues of Joumal. 6 issues of Newsletter, 4 issues of Wing Beats)
After 1131100 and on-site
$200.00
$235.00
$250.00
$75.00
$105.00
$40.00
$ 15.00
TOTAL$. ____ _
Heavy duty cold fogger has exclusive f ty f t 18-20 SAFETY FEATURES sa e ea ures 0 Engine oil level/oil pre~sure_swil~h. Engin_e
automatically shuts off 1f eng1ne 011 supply 1s low. High volume Model18-20 surpasses most other foggers for two important reasons. One, a new-generation overhead valve, V-twin cylinder engine (with throttle down feature) produces fewer emissions, consumes less fuel, and has longer service intervals than conventionai'L' head engines. Two, our Triple-V Belt Drive feature reduces blower RPM more than 25%. This design extends blower life and creates a quieter operating fogging machine. The 18-20 produces the correct particle size to meet insecticide label requirements at vehicle speeds up to 20 miles per hour.
Durable nylon nozzle surpasses metal nozzles
Nozzle rotates 360 degrees, horizontally and vertically
Silencer tube reduces noise level
18-20 SPECIFICATIONS
18-20 SPECIAL FEATURES D Triple-V Belt Drive offers simplicity, reliability, and
minimizes vibration because it is not a direct drive system.
0 Blower life is extended by new drive system. 0 RPM and noise are reduced by Triple-V belt drive. 0 Durable nylon nozzle exceeds corrosive character-
istics of stainless steel nozzles. 0 Electric metering pump with ceramic piston deliv-
ers accurate flow rates up to 20 ounces per minute
More accessible flow control box
18 hp overhead valve, V-twin cylinder gas engine with throttle down feature·
Model 18-20 ULV Aerosol Generator Engine 18 hp overhead valve, V-twin cylinder, electric start Formulation pump 12 Volt DC adjustable output, positive displacement, 0-20 oz./min. Particle size 80% of droplets-less than 20 micron diameter Formulation tank 15 gallon (56 liter), corrosion resistant Fuel tank 9 gallons (34 liters) with gauge Flush tank 1 1/2 quart (1.58 liter), corrosion resistant Blower Rotary, positive displacement, up to 356 CFM Length 37 inches (94 em) Width 46 inches (117 em) Height 39 inches (99 em) Weight 445 lbs. (202 kg)
Prevents engine damage. 0 Blower air pressure switch. Formulation pump
automatically shuts off. Prevents formulation flow to nozzle when pressure is not adequate.
0 Safety yellow powder coated frame provides greater visibility.
0 Silencer tube reduces noise level of blower and nozzle.
REMOTE CAB CONTROL FEATURES D Engine On/Off, with throttle down D Engine Choke D Insecticide pump On/Off 0 Insecticide/flush selector
OPTIONS D Spare parts kit, domestic or export D Speed compensating flow control D Stainless tanks in various sizes
• NEW DESIGN • NEWV-BELT
DRIVE • NEW THROTTLE
DOWN
~ Used ll'tEtWfx]ilrxm& \6' in the mlrilo LONDON FOG Manufacturers of insect, pest and odor control equipment. since 1968 505 Brimhall Avenue • P.O. Box 406 Long Lake [Minneapolis), MN 55356 Information 612-473-5366 Fax 612-473-5302 Order line 800-448-8525 Email londonfog@usinternet. com
We work at maintaining our service at the highest level possible because we truly believe our customers are the most important part of our business. It's really quite simple ... no customers ... no business!
The pesticides we distribute are supplied directly from the basic manufacturers who are committed to the highest standards of quality. The equipment that we offer is constantly being improved through research and development focusing on the application of the latest technology to meet the changing requirements of the marketplace.
We want to thank all who value our professiona!isrllf quality products and service. Our goal is to continue to be deserving of your respect!
-__ : 'llCK~TQCI(4-D_OE -~t-- -- ---- ___ - ~ --___ __ TlCK-~-M~N.AC£M£Nt -LEGIStATION·-·f ·OR .. ~i_="-_ -___ _
- - - :-_~:· -_ ;:_ :~:~~E\ti .----J~RSEY.-:~~:~ - ---- - _ :·;~-
In 1977 mosquito control in New Jersey suffered a huge setback triggered by a piece of legislation and a court decision. These two items had more of a deleterious effect on mosquito control than the profession was prepared to deal with.
The law that was passed removed authority from the Director of the New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station to determine the necessary se'rvices and the amount of required funding to be raised by taxation for each of the County Mosquito Extermination Commissions. This responsibility was placed in the hands of the County Boards of Chosen Freeholders, the elected officials charged with the responsibility of governing each of New Jersey's twenty-one counties.
The impact was felt immediately. Instead of budgets being determined on the basis of scientific rationale and need, mosquito commissions were now competing against other county departments and agencies
·for a slice of the county tax dollar. In most counties we didn't compete very well , basically because we were scientists, not businessmen.
During 1978, while speaking before the New Jersey Mosquito Control Association, Ronald Altman, M.D., then Director of the New Jersey Department of Health (NJDOH) Division Of Communicable Disease pointed out that nobody was addressing the issue of tick management, and that tick transmitted diseases were emerging as a serious public health threat.
When Carmen Stoppiello became a Commissioner of the MCMEC in 1987, he advocated a program for the Commission that
18 Fall 1999
· :·.·-:-·.·-by~~ "~;::_.~ ·.-
would be designed to build partnerships with the municipalities, other counties, the State and the private sector. He immediately recognized that there were numerous opportunities to provide services that were tangential to mosquito control. He knew we couldn't legally participate in any activities that were not directly related to mosquito control due to the regulations imposed by the laws of New Jersey.
In 1988, Dr. Donald J. Sutherland, Chairman of the Department of Entomology at Rutgers University and Past President of the American Mosquito Control Association, encouraged me to pursue the idea of expanding the role of mosquito control agencies to include tick management. In 1989 he sent me considerable information concerning the Federal Comprehensive Lyme Disease Act that was enacted during that year.
On April11 , 1989 the Monmouth County Loss Prevention Consultants notified the Monmouth County Administrator that Lyme Disease was becoming a serious workers compensation problem within our County.
I then contacted the MCMEC attorney to determine whether we could become involved in tick management. His response was that we couldn't undertake work of any nature unless it was related to mosquito Control.
Carmen was elected to the Monmouth County Board of Chosen Freeholders in November of 1989. During his first term he served as the Freeholder liaison to the Commission. He became an outspoken public advocate for mosquito con-
troland took an active role in the New Jersey Association of Counties, where he extolled the necessity of counties expanding their mosquito control programs.
From 1990 through 1991 the County addressed its tick management activities by continued involvement with the NJDOH through the Monmouth County Health Department, Monmouth County Shade Tree Commission and the Freehold Area Health Department. In other words, everybody but us!
In April1991, I contacted William Parkin, M.D. Assistant Commissioner of the NJDOH regarding the possibility of getting legislation enacted that would establish a statewide network of mosquito control agencies with expanded mandate to manage Lyme Disease vectors. Dr. Parkin was supportive and suggested that we attend to share our thoughts with the Governor's Lyme Disease Advisory Council.
Soon thereafter, Dr. Wayne J. Crans, of the Mosquito Research and Control Unit at Rutgers University, and I attended a meeting of that body. The members of the Council appeared to listen to us but, with the exception of Dr. Parkin, they asked no questions, and immediately after our presentation the Chairman told us to leave.
In 1991 Carmen spearheaded a program that resulted in the MCMEC staff becoming involved in an experimental tick-management program with the New Jersey Department of Health & Senior Services (NJDHSS), Rutgers Cooperative Extension, Freehold Area Health Department and the Monmouth County Shade Tree Commission.
The study involved ground based applications of acaricide.
By 1992, Monmouth County was becoming more involved in developing a partnership with Dr. Louis Vasvary, Rutgers Cooperative Extension and Dr. Schulze, NJDHSS. In May of 1992 our Commission attorney gave approval for the Commission pilot to participate in the experimental field trials for tick management through aerial applications of acaricide. These are the results of field trials that generated considerable controversy within the mosquito control community:
1. We learned that aerial applications of acaricide were probably not the most effective modality for killing what were then referred to as deer ticks.
2. We found out that there were factions within the mosquito control community who believed that we had no business becoming involved in tick management or any non-mosquito activities.
3. We learned that many of our colleagues feared that any change in the State Statutes relating to control would result in negatively impacting the existing laws and diminishing our capabilities.
It was following this episode that I became more determined that we would have legislation enacted that
would allow mosquito commissions to assume this additional responsibility. We would achieve this goal by building partnerships.
The initial draft legislation mimicked the State mosquito control statutes as these laws had withstood the test of time with considerable success.
This generated considerable concern among the mosquito control community. A committee of members of the NJMCA met with the commissioners of the MCMEC. The concerns of the association members were understandable. Each time the mosquito statutes were amended in the last twenty years, the results were negative.
The meeting was very worthwhile except for one committee member who commented that if we wanted to undertake tick-related work we should dissolve our commission.
I rewrote the legislation so that it would be under the Lyme Disease section of the statutes. If you haven't figured it out yet New Jersey has a law for almost everything. We included a section that would require that any funding for tick-related activities be separate from the mosquito control budget, and also excluded from the State "cap" law, which sets a limit on how much a
AM MIA
governing body can raise taxes in a year. This was to satisfy those members who feared that they would be told to undertake these activities without the necessary funding. Ultimately both of those items were included in the approved legislation.
During the next 1112 years we worked diligently with Dr. Terry Schulze and Ken Fordyce, the new Chairman of the Governor's Lyme Disease Advisory Council, in an attempt to get a sponsor for this legislation. We were disappointed by the lack of enthusiasm exhibited by legislators to sponsor what we thought to be a win/win situation.
In May of 1994 I had the opportunity to meet with the newly appointed State Commissioner of Health, Len Fishman. I discussed my proposal with him and he seemed genuinely interested and supportive. I immediately confirmed the discussion that we had at our meeting in writing and he responded by offering the participation of Dr. Schulze on behalf of the NJDHSS.
On January 9, 1995 the Commissioners of the MCMEC adopted a resolution urging enactment of legislation that would enable mosquito commissions to undertake tick management activities. On February 23, 1995 the Monmouth County Board
continued on page 22
THE PREFERRED INSURANCE PROGRAM
HOW MUNICIPALITIES AND TAXING DISTRICTS CONTAIN THE HIGH COST OF INSURANCE PROTECTION
GENERAL LIABILITY*** PUBLIC OFFICIALS LIABILITY*** AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY AVIATION LIABILITY*** AVIATION HULL ***AVIATION CHEMICAL LIABILITY
SOUTHWEST ASSURANCE CORPORATION OF FLORIDA (PROGRAM ADMINISTRATORS) 40I EAST JACKSON STREET, SUITE 1700 TAMPA, FL 33601-3364
PHONE: 800-527-4953 FAX: 813-222-4040
ENDORSED BY THE AMERICAN MOSQUITO CONTROL ASSOCIATION
Fall 1999 19
I Tile Use of fil1l ia llasl(lliiD ca.tra1 ~-tile llartllastU.S_
The concept of biological control of mosquitoes is not a new one. It is, however, one that has had a hard time getting off the ground in some districts for a variety of reasons. The development and use of certain parasites and pathogens may be in- _ timidating to some, unless offered commercially with "how to" instructions. Introducing predacious organisms such as fish is a concept not unfamiliar to most, but tends to be cost-prohibitive. These pitfalls can terminate a biological control effort before it begins.
Some mosquito control programs have been geared to the control of various stages of the mosquito life cycle and attempts have been made to establish self-sufficient bio-control programs. Throughout the country, some have succeeded. This paper presents two programs established in the northeast which have succeeded in developing a larval control program using fish.
Many may be familiar with the effectiveness of various marine fish species as the biological mosquito control agents that are associated with Open Marsh Water Management. The two programs described herein are oriented to controlling mosquitoes in fresh water mosquito habitat utilizing several different fish species. Most mosquito control professionals are familiar with the mosquitofish, Gambusia affinis. Our programs, however, have developed stocks of freshwater killifish, fat-head minnows, several spe-
20 Fall 1999
by ~~ 7::ea aH4 ~ s~-"71~
cies of sunfish and the methods used to distribute them. One of these programs is operated statewide in New Jersey; the other as part of a county mosquito control project in Massachusetts.
The use of freshwater fish in a mosquito control program has usually meant a dependence on a source of Gambusia affinis. They are commercially available, expen-
Gambusia affinis
sive and may also have temperate restrictions on their survival and efficiency. There also may be environmental restrictions or concerns about releasing this species into new habitat.
The use of other mosquito-eating species has been reported in the literature. While the use of residential sunfish in mosquito control has been successful, other species native to the habitat differ in their larval control efficiency. They also may have different environmental requirements for their survival.
How to address these different requirements posed a challenge to
mosquito control workers in the northeast. A readily available, healthy stock of fish in adequate numbers requires a major facility, effort and staff. Knowledge of the biology of each species, its habitat, range and role in the ecosystem is paramount. Finally, the support of the operational aspect of such a program requires the resources to do so. It became clear to state mos
quito control officials that addressing these problems required a practical solution.
In New Jersey, as in most states, there exists a division of government dedicated to managing the state's resources. The N.J. Office of Mosquito Control Coordination (the administrative headquarters of the N.J. State Mosquito Control Commission) is a component of the N.J. Division of Fish, Game and Wildlife. A Bureau, also within the Divi
sion, is dedicated to freshwater fisheries. This bureau conducts fisheries-related research, operates two fish hatcheries and annually stocks New Jersey streams, lakes and ponds with various species of game and forage fish. The Bureau has divided the state by drainage areas, with each supervised by staff biologists. It was only natural that all the agencies collaborate to develop the New Jersey Bio-Control (mosquitofish) Program for mosquito control.
Step one involved the development of a policy around which the program would run. Soon to follow was an estimation of cost, equip-
ment needs, operational protocol, environmental issues and the composition of a bulletin or booklet which
Transportation tanks
would address the "how to" aspects of using the program.
Implementation of the program began with an initial stock of Gambusia affinis. These fish were used as brood stock at the fish hatchery in Hackettstown, in order to develop an almost unlimited amount of individuals for mosquito control. Next, the State Mosquito Control Commission agreed to annually provide dedicated funds to the Division of Fish, Game and Wildlife to cover expenditures of the Bureau of Freshwater Fisheries. Then, four oxygen bottleequipped fish transportation tanks were purchased, the size of which allowed for their transfer from truck to truck, thus enabling community servicing from county-to-county mosquito control district.
The booklet about the stocking program describes how any of New Jersey's county mosquito control agencies may, by following established policy and protocol, obtain a truck-tank full of healthy mosquito fish, and stock mosquito-breeding habitat with them. There is no charge to the counties for these fish, as part of the State Mosquito Control Commissions state-aid to counties program. Since 1990, the program has offered over 150,000 fish per year.
Fish are distributed throughout the mosquito season. An indoor over-wintering facility at the hatch
ery allows for early spring stocking to take place by April. The hatchery's outdoor brood rearing ponds and raceways are used as needs expand in the summertime. Fisheries biologists are readily available to deal with disease issues, habitat limitations and applicability of other mosquito larvivorous fish species as they become more and more familiar with the needs of the
mosquito control community. On the other hand, the New Jersey mosquito control community is also learning more and more about mosquito-eating fish as their use increases.
The Research and Development Committee of the New Jersey Mosquito Control Association is composed of staff biologists from the various county mosquito control agencies around the state. They have spent several mosquito seasons studying the use of these fish in the field. As a result, some interesting information about the stocking rates of mosquito fish has been published (N.J.M.C.A. Proc. 83:95-102).
In Massachusetts the approach to starting a mosquito control program utilizing fish has been very different. Mosquito control programs (called "projects") in that state are organized under the jurisdiction of the State Reclamation Board. This Board is placed in the state's Department of Agriculture, which is an agency separate from the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife. There is, therefore, no system in place for the mass production or release of fish for the purpose of mosquito control. In order to expand to a control program in the individual mosquito control dis-
tricts, a bio-control program, which utilizes fish had to begin as a research project.
In 1993, the Cape Cod Mosquito Control Project began to examine the potential of using fish in its day to day control operation. Gambusia sp. are not native to Cape Cod and the laws of the Commonwealth do not permit their importation and/ or release. The mosquito control project then decided to examine the potential of using native fish for mosquito control.
The biological control agent selected for this work was the Banded Sunfish, Enneacanthus obesus. The decision to use this species was reached after much literary research, discussion with fisheries biologists, and field work, which involved several different fish species. Research observations revealed that this species is able to survive throughout the year in a freshwater swam·p. Further, the Banded Sun-
9 Mosquitofish Fact Sheet f<i:>
Mo<qu;IO ilKJI\ 'l'l'lrtl: .... o.w
~lnf'Qoktc,_& ~20_,.~
., ......... .,.,~~cy.a""' ~-·-"~dl.• .. toorc:.~~oL.-v•IOIS~ !NUIIIo()'<Wo.mct. ~I!IOiqDUoD .. ~.]1!>-Cibt.po"'''Il .. ~orill~ -
-.... ..... ...... _,. uo .....
fish were found to readily feed on mosquito larvae in this habitat.
Since reproduction of a quantity of fish would be necessary for mosquito control practices, the next goal for the Cape Cod program was to determine if these fish could be stimulated to spawn in captivity. With the resources of the state
continued on page 23
Fall 1999 21
continued from page 19
of Chosen Freeholders, by re.solution encouraged the Monmouth Legislative Delegation to take the lead in sponsoring this legislation.
Freeholder Stoppiello and MCMEC President Lionel H.R. Schusterman, who was previously a campaign manager for Senator John 0. Bennett, the newly elected Senate Majority Leader, made personal contact with the Senator. Let me interject that the mysteries of life are stranger and stranger. Sean Kean, a kid whom I coached against in little league was now the chief aide to the Senator and was very helpful in moving the bill through the legislative maze.
On March 31, 1995 Sean notified us that Senator Bennett would be honored to sponsor the bill. It certainly didn't hurt that he also happened to be the Senate Majority Leader. Bennett claimed that the public response he received following the announcement that he was sponsoring this legislation was
among the best he's ever gotten. We thought for sure that this Bill would get fast tracked. No way!
On April9, 1995 the Asbury Park Press, calling it a "virtual nobrainer'', endorsed the initiative in a major editorial. Certainly with the support of the media and the public the light at the end of the tunnel was near. Not exactly!
On May 8, 1995 Senator Bennett introduced S-1944. The bill was given a name, number and committee referral. This sounds like being sentenced for committing a crime. We never realized how long the sentence would be.
On June 27, 1995 Senator Bennett was contacted by the New Jersey Environmental Federation (NJEF) an environmental activist coalition that claims to have major concerns regarding this legislation.
On the following day I wrote to NJDHSS Commissioner Fishman requesting support for the bill.
Crunch time was approaching and we needed all of the help that we could gather. He responded on 8/ 24/95 with some degree of equivocation. " There were many factors that must be weighed and considered" and "support from the NJDHSS could not be anticipated at this time."
On November 19, 1995 the Atlantic City Press called the proposed legislation a good idea but urged that we go slowly with the application of pesticides. The Atlantic City Press only heard one side of the issue and based their editorial on less than all of the information. This was a minor setback.
During this time period Schulze and I held a series of meetings with Jane Nogaki, an environmental activist and NJEF pesticide coordinator, and Dolores Phillips, the full-time paid lobbyist of the NJEF, concerning the wording of the legislation. We were close to reaching an
continued on page 34
Clarke Mosquito Control Products, now offering
22
The all-electric sprayers that offer a quiet alternative.
-Call 1-800-323-5727 or630-894-2000 for complete product information.
(i. Clarke-Mosquito Control Products, Inc. 159 Garden Avenue • Roselle, IL 60172 email: [email protected] web: www.cmosquito.com
Fall 1999
continued from a e 21
Division of Fisheries and Wildlife unavailable, Cape Cod Mosquito Control Project staff turned to the Marine Biological Laboratory (MBL) at Woods Hole. It was there that it was proven that by introducing Human Cyclic Gonadothrophic Hormone (HCG), this species could be raised in a captive environment. The labora-tory staff remains an impor- NJ Fish & Game truck stocking hatchery fish tant source of technical information in the continuation of this research.
At this point, field sites have been selected, stocked and evaluated. Mosquito surveillance strategies and fish surveys have yielded information, which has demonstrated the fish's ability to breed, and to be stocked and survive in mosquito breeding habitat. Mosquito speciesspecific targeting was done to control Cu/iseta me/anura in the fresh-
water swamp habitat. Gut content studies performed on recaptured sunfish have revealed this mosquito to be the preferred food source of the fish in late fall/ early winter. Mosquito survey data confirmed the efficiency of the bio-control agent in these sites.
The Cape Cod effort stimulated the New Jersey group to consider the use of other species in mosquito breeding habitats less appropriate for Gambusia stocking. The state mosquito-fish program, working with the Bureau of Freshwater Fish-
eries staff, now offers four additional fish species. In areas where the habitat and targeted mosquito species allow for it, the program now stocks the Fathead Minnow, Pimphales promela; the Freshwater Killifish, Fundulus diaphanus; the Blue Gill Sunfish, Leopomis macrochirus; and the Pumkinseed Sunfish, Leopomis gibbosus.
The future of these programs calls for the evaluation of additional
species as bio-control agents. The efficiency of these fish as mosquito control agents, their distribution and environmental impacts are all significant factors toward success. No less important has been the cooperative professional environment that the involved agencies have created.
Robert Kent is the Principal Biologist with the NJ Department of Environmental Protection, Office of Mosquito Control Coordination, Trenton, NJ and Gabrielle Sakolsky-Hoopes is an Entomologist for the Cape Cod Mosquito Control Project, Yarmouth Port, MA.
emaii:[email protected].
Fall 1999 23
continued from page 13
Larval surveillance exercise during an Open House
tify adulticidal applications. Once educated, residents are often willing to aid in surveillance efforts by collecting mosquitoes that are in their yard. Light traps are provided and picked up by local mosquito control personnel.
On the other hand, most people don't know what mosquito larvae or pupae look like. Without knowing this and without the knowledge that standing water is necessary for breeding mosquitoes, they cannot be of assistance. I carried home a breeder with larvae from a tire for an evening municipal meeting and a neighborhood teenager recognized them as mosquito larvae. When asked how she knew, she stated , "I saw them at the county fair." When the residents do know these basic facts, they recognize the problem and are far more likely to do something about it, whether this involves eliminating standing water in their yard, signing a right-of-entry agreement to allow a district to conduct water management activi-ties on their property or to be cooperative in allowing (not objecting to) the application of insecticides when necessary. This kind of education can be accomplished through presentations at schools, county fairs, scout functions and civic meetings as well as through displays at meetings attended by governing officials and legislators, and, of course, responding to citizen complaints can be an excellent forum for one-on-one education. Educational activities can be carried out at any time of year but are particularly encouraged during "National Mosquito Control Awareness Week" which was established by the
24 Fall 1999
AMCA in 1997 in order for mosquito professionals to consolidate their efforts and speak with a louder voice. When given the knowledge, people are appreciative and often willing to help eliminate mosquito breeding on their property.
Educating the general public helps increase the understanding of a scientifically based, environmentally sensitive approach to mosquito control and the reasons for doing so. Education helps smooth the path by lessening possible opposition from residents in the area, anti-pesticide groups, local, county, state and federal officials and legislators. This facilitates the ability of mosquito control districts to get the job done. Educating governing officials gives them a better understanding of how funds are to be utilized when it comes to deciding what appro-priation you receive to run your program.
Educational efforts were necessary to establish soundly structured mosquito control programs.
Lab tour during a school presentation
Education should hold a high position in any mosquito control program in an ongoing effort to provide and maintain effective mosquito control.
Christine P. Musa is the Superintendent of the Warren County Mosquito Control Commission, Oxford, NJ
email: [email protected]
F r o m c I e a n w a t e r to highly organic wat.er, VectoBac and VectoLex give you the best way to control a broad spectrum of mosquito larvae.
VectoBac is your first choice for cost-effective control of mosquitoes. Not only is VectoBac the highest quality Bti
on the market, it's also the most effective. With VectoBac, you'll see results almost immediately after application.
VectoBac® Superior Mosquito Control For Each Ext r e ·me And Everything In Between.
a Abbon Laboratories, Inc. - Quality Health Care Worldwide North Chicago, IL 60064 - (800) 323-9597
Vectolex® F o r t o u g h e r s i t u a t i o n s and residual control of mosquitoes, turn to VectoLex. Its active ingredient, Bacillus sphaericus, has the unique property of being able to control mosquito larvae for up to 4 weeks, even in highly organic environments.
No matter what your needs are, turn to VectoBac and VectoLex for superior mosquito control. Both products are supported by Abbott, a company committed to mosquito control.
continued from a e 11
Pitcher Plant
dead of winter, the larvae freeze in a block of ice but revive quickly as soon as the larval habitat thaws.
Unique New Jersey Mosquito Life Cycles - New Jersey provides habitat for 2 univoltine and 1 bivoltine mosquito species that do not directly fit into any of the categories listed above. None of these species are limited in their distribution to the state of New Jersey but most are relatively common in specialized larval habitats in selected regions of the state. Ae. thibaultiis a univoltine Ae. that lives in subterranean crypts in permanent swamps. The species is relatively common in red maple swamps on the coastal plain but the larvae are rarely collected because they are only present during the months of February, March and early April. The mosquito was thought to have a decidedly southern distribution in New Jersey until it was discovered in the cavity of a red maple tree growing in a snowpool near High Point. Its ability to invade temporary larval habitats explains the existence of isolated adult collections of this species as far north as Canada where permanent swamp larval habitat does not exist. Cs. me/anura is another mosquito that utilizes sub-
26 Fall 1999
terranean larval habitats reaching greatest abundance in crypts found in Atlantic White Cedar swamps on the coastal plain of New Jersey. This mosquito overwinters as a larva and appears to have only 2 generations each year. Extracting Cs. me/anura larvae from crypt habitats in dense cedar swamps is time consuming and separating the larvae from debris makes larval collection tedious. As a result, specialized equipment is needed to sort for this relatively common subterranean cavity breeder. Sampling for Cs. me/anura revealed that two other species overwinter as larvae and share subterranean habitat during the winter months. An. crucians is a multivoltine freshwater swamp breeder that overwinters in the larval stage. The mosquito is cryptic as an adult with An. bradleyi, a brackish water anopheline that is
,Cedar Swamp
particularly abundant throughout most of the coastal plain. Separating the adults is difficult but the larvae are diagnostic. Most of the An. crucians larvae we have been able to obtain have been taken during the winter months. Coqui/lettidia perturbans is another very common freshwater swamp species that is very difficult to collect as a larva. Both the larval and pupal stages attach to the roots of aquatic plants and do not come to the surface to breathe. The mosquito has an ex-
ceptionally slow metabolism and undergoes only one extended generation each year. Cattail is the aquatic plant that is most often associated with Cq. perturbans but the species is actually more common on sedge (Carex) , rush (Juncus) and swamp loosestrife (Decodon). Winter sampling indicates that the larvae also attach to the roots of Atlantic White Cedar and share habitat with Cs. me/anura in some areas.
Conclusions
Mosquito control workers do not like to use the term "Mosquito State" to describe the state of New Jersey but the nickname certainly conveys the multitude of breeding habitats found in this small geographic area. A number of species can be collected as larvae throughout the winter and the appearance of species
that hatch from overwintering eggs begins in February. The months of April and May produce a succession of univoltine mosquito species that occur in a wide variety of larval habitats. Species that overwinter as mated females add their eggs as soon as the nights are warm enough and summer rains produce multivoltine species that repeatedly hatch from eggs. The habitats range from
snowpool to salt marsh and permanent swamp to container. At latest count, this combination provides habitat for 62 different species.
Wayne Crans is a Professor at the Department of Entomology, Rutgers University
email: wcrans@ rci.rutgers.edu
To protect children ...
You have to be Tough on Adults.
You can't compromise when it
comes to protecting the public
health from vector-borne diseases.
That's why FYFANON<~> ULV
is the malathion of choice for
They know that quality and
performance go hand-in-hand.
And FYFANON ULV gives you both:
consistent quality
and consistent
the overwhelming majority of
mosquito control professionals.
performance. FVFANON® ULV INSECTICIDE So the next time
you are faced with ----- --
@ CHEMINOVA
a choice, turn to the malathion you
know and trust: high-purity, proven
performance, FYFANON ULV
FYFANON<~>ULV- Tough on adults!
Cheminova, Inc., 1700 Route 23, Suite 210, Wayne, New Jersey 07470
Now available in 260-gallon minibulk containers
For further information contact your local distributor
or call l -800-548-6113.
•fYFANON 1s a rt:glslcrtd uadtmark or Chtmlnova.
New ·from Griffin L.L.C.,
Atrapa VCP is a premium
quality, ultra low volume
formulation, labeled at
96.5% malathion.
Atrapa VCP is conveniently packaged in 2.5 gallon jugs, 55 gallon drums
and returnable kegs, and 220-275 gallon returnable mini-bulk IBC systems.
Bulk deliveries via truck are also available. Atrapa VCP is fully serviced by
Griffin end-user support systems positioned strategically throughout the
United States.
To learn more, call Griffin L.L.C. at
1-800-237-1854, or Van Waters & Rogers,
exclusive Distributors of Atrapa VCP
at 1-800-888-4897.
Always read and follow label directions. ©1999 Griffin LLC. Atrapa is a trademark of Griffin L.LC. 4016-01 -4/99
• ' '6\IH all ,. •• ~
. ~
1i'
GriffiiL Griffin L.L.C. [?"""' Valdosta, GA 31601
At about 8:30PM Thursday, September 2, 1999, I received a phone call from my Health Commissioner, Dr. Clare Bradley. She informed me that New York City (NYC) was reporting some 15 cases of what was then thought to be St. Louis encephalitis (SLE), that two cases were fatal, and that the City was requesting Suffolk County's assistance. Thus be~an _my inv?lvement in a large story that rs strll evolvrng. Only later would we find that we were dealing with West Nile virus (WNV), and that the problem was region-wide in scope. The whole picture of this ongoing event involves far too many people and organizations for a short article to accurately portray. From what I directly observed, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) the New York City and State Health Departments and the Health Departments of Nassau and Su~olk C?ounties deserve high praise fortherr raprd and professional response to what proved to be an unprecedented situation.
. I will try provide Wing Beats readers a frrst hand account of the response' during the first few days after the West-Nile outbreak was discovered. Over the winter, there will be a complete analysis of this important event. I am also confident that appropriate steps will be taken to prevent a repeat of a situation that made New York's largest city and the entire eastern U.S. all too aware of mosquito control as a-public health issue.
My first reaction was to call my counterpart at_ Nas~u County Public Works, Gregory Terrillion. Nassau County is immedi~tely_east of the NYC borough of Queens;, :w~rle Suffolk County occupies
,, the remarnrng two thirds of Long Island. yvhne Suffolk County was probably called
· rn because we have the largest mosquito control program in New York State Nassau County is not far behind. 1 wa~ not ab~ut to let Greg and his 26 years of mosqurto control experience enjoy his Labor Day weekend with this situation
DIE
going on next door. We agreed that we should go into the City the next day and provide whatever help we could.
All the reported cases at that time seemed to be in the Whitestone area of northern Queens, a mostly middle class r~sidential area with closely spaced srngle and two-family homes and some small apartment buildings. I was asked to meet with NYC officials at a site near Pelham Bay Park, a small salt marsh on the East River, By the time 1 got there a dozen or so officials were talking on cell phones, NYC police were directing traffic, and half dozen NY State Conservation Police were on the scene. More representatives from various CitY and State agencies continued to arrive and the City's mobile headquarters fo~ the Mayor's Office of Emergency Management (OEM) Wa& rolled into1he area. The a~pearanc&~f a portable podium made rt clear that,Mayor Giuliani was on the way. ·
It was Uflder these circumstances that I met Jery H~uer, head of OEM, and the person who would run the New York City response. Mr. Hauer proved to_ be an amazingly quick study and a person who had-the authority and the will to quickly summon resources and cut red tape in a manner few of us associate with government. He deserves tremend_ous credit for organizing the City's_ massrvereseonse to the virus. Over the -next few weeks, Mr. Hauer would mobilize hundreds of people and coordinate the activities of all,the involved .City, State and Federal agencies that wouiCtwork in the City .. Spray contractors were hired, pesticide_ bought, neighborhoods · were leafleted in six languages and tens o! th_ousands of cans of repellent were drstrrbut~~- Eventually, an entire city of seven mrlhon people was treated at least twice. ·
Greg and I ~ere given maps of the reported cases. I overflew the area in a NYC Police helicopter. It was clear that
--
aerial adulticiding was the primary response that would be needed, along with ground ULV and follow-up larval control. Th~re were no obvious target areas for aerral larvicide, since the cases were from high and dry residential areas without swamps or other natural larval habitats. Both our programs use Scourge for ground ULV, but Greg and I agreed th~t malathi~n (Fyfanon) was the appropnate matenal to use for aerial adulticide despite some concern that use of an OP would be controvel'$iaL W~ based tflis assessment on the consistent success my ~rogram has had with aerial Fyfanon • agarn~t salt marsh mosquitoes, and. on the mrxed re$ults Lhave had with aerial pyrethroids. These r~sults were con~ sistent with those ·of our colleagues in ~ew Jersey, a very strong consideration rn my mind. This is not to say !hat other products would not have wo~ed, and indeed, Anvil (sumithrin) was'eventually used a great deal.. In addition, there was the practical matter that our heli- l copter contractor, John Sondgeroth of No~h Fork Helicopters, was the only aerral contractor available on such short , notice, and he was equipped and set up for Fyfanon. We made that recommendation to NYC, and CDC and the New York State and City Health Departments concurred.
When ~ayo_r Giuliani arrived, Greg a~d,_l were called to the OEM van, along wrth _Hauer and representatives of the ~ity He~lt~ D~partment and other agencres. GruJranr was briefed on the situation, including the number of cases, their · location, the need for repellents and other personal protection and our recomrrien- - ~ dations for the aerial and ground ~dulticiding. He made a brief presentation to the media that accurately communicated what he had been told complete with a demonstration of applying rnsect repellent. This was the official beginning of the City's response.
continued on page 31
Fall 1999 29
Announcing the new mosquito control standard
for the next 20 years. New Aqua-ReslinT:
No oil. No mosquitoes. No comparison. It took ten years of research and millions in development costs to perfect. Now it's here. New Aqua-Reslin'" is America's first and only mosquito control spray which is water-based, yet as effective as traditional oil-based sprays. And it eliminates all the storage, environmental and application problems assodated with oil-based earners.
Retards 'Evaporation Our patented FFASFM formulation (Film Forming Aqueous Spray Technology) dramatically reduces the major problem assodated with water-based sprays: evaporation. By using long chain alcohol molecules to form a surface film around each Aqua-Reslin droplet, evaporation is significantly reduced. Each droplet - ideally sized by a standard ULV sprayer - can then reach and contact the insect. just like an oil-based droplet, in fact.
Field Proven Aqua-Reslin's permethrin and piperonyl butoxide formulation has been tested in a wide variety of field conditions against all major mosquito species, using the full array of commercially available ULV spray equipment. The results have proved comparable to solvent-based mosquito control sprays, with fast knockdown and kill, no biting fTenzy, and high effectiveness against organophosphate resistant strains.
A World of Advantages By eliminating oil fTom your mosquito control program, you eliminate a bunch of headaches. Suddenly, you have no oil storage problems (or the potential liabilities). You get the cost effectiveness and convenience of using water without the usual performance penalty. There's no risk of cosmetic damage to vehicles and buildiv .. It's all good news.
Find Out More For more information on how AquaReslin can revolutionize your mosquito control program, please ask your usual AgrEvo representative for an information pack, or call 1-800-843-1702. And welcome to 21st century mosquito control.
·= ·- ~-t . l
-~
AgrEvo Environmental Health 95 Chestnut Ridge Road
Montvale, fiJ 07645
continued from page 29
Once the decision to spray had been made, there were numerous logistical problems that had to be solved on the Friday before Labor Day. North Fork's Bell So loy was flying in from almost 1 00 miles away in Suffolk County, while the refueling truck was driving in. My warehouse in Yaphank, some 50 miles away, held the only accessible supply of Fyfanon. Because Governor Pataki had pledged full State cooperation, arrangements were made for the State Environmental Conservation Police to provide a lights and siren escort for a Suffolk County truck to bring the material in. A nearby ball field was chosen as a landing zone, and the helicopter and its payload came together. Meanwhile, Greg contacted his staff and arranged for Nassau County ground ULV units to spray the following morning. As events unfolded, Greg and I split the work, with Nassau County handling ground ULV and larviciding while Suffolk helped with the aerial work.
NYC was very conscious of the fact that these were densely populated areas that were unfamiliar with and unpre-
pared for large-scale pesticide applications. Within hours, over 15,000 leaflets were prepared, describing the need for spraying, suggesting that residents avoid the spray, and outlining personal protection against mosquitoes. We agreed that residential areas should not be treated until leaflets were distributed, and several hundred city workers set out to accomplish this. As evening approached, spray maps were prepared, and the helicopter began treating vacant and other non-residential areas. As leaflets were distributed and areas "cleared", residential areas were treated. Approximately 2,000 acres were treated by helicopter that evening, and a similar acreage by ground, not bad for a start. A landing site was set up in a cleared area in the park, next to the OEM headquarters van.
The following day, Dr. Dennis White, entomologist from the New York State Department of Health, and Dr. Scott Campbell from Suffolk County Health Services arrived. They began a sampling program, and identified a sewage treatment plant and poorly maintained
swimming pools as possible sources of the Culexpipiensvector, while ruling out an abandoned airport as a major problem. Greg had his Nassau County staff bring in Vectolex CG and they switched from adult to larval control
Saturday evening brought ideal conditions for aerial adulticiding, with temperatures around 80°F and an 8 MPH breeze from the east. All of northern Queens had received leaflets, printed in six languages, including Spanish, Korean, Chinese and Arabic. Approximately 7,000 acres in Queens and the southern Bronx (locations for other cases) were treated that night, finishing the entire 140 gallons of Fyfanon that we had on hand in Suffolk County. The helicopter treated the area where the news media were gathered, producing a mild malathion odor but no other ill effects. Fortunately, the general impression was "gee, that wasn't so bad", and that set the tone for the initial press coverage. This treatment covered the entire focus area where all the cases to that point (over 30 and growing) had been found.
Superior Sampling Equipment For Superior Results
Chill Table This ingenious table doesn't require a sink. Professional features include: digital surface readout, easy adjustment to -4°C/25°F, annodized work surface marked with division lines and more.
ABC Trap Kit Our basic kit is engineered with the features you need to make your job easier: all weather design, portability, 5 programmable modes, photosensor, easily emptied, simple adjustment and adaptability for C02 emissions.
Call for our 16 page catalog 1-800-323-5727
Order On-line! email: [email protected] web: www.cmosquito.com l#ttitfl
East Greenwich, Rhode Island
Q.oistributed by
~.Clarke Mosquito Control Products, Inc.
Fall 1999 31
This led to increased ground and aerial adulticiding in the areas with the most dead birds. As I write this, it now appears horses were affected in eastern Suffolk, and birds with WNV have been found throughout the County. We now know this is a regional, perhaps even a national, problem.
Coming Events
Dodd Plenary Courses January 24-28, 2000 Gainesville Sheraton Gainesville, FL For more information contact Shelly Redovan Phone: (941) 694-217 4 or visit FMCA's website at www.floridamosquito.org
MMCA Annual Meeting February 3-4, 2000 Shanty Creek Resort Bellaire, Michigan For more information contact Mary McGarry, Program Chair Phone: (517) 894-4555
I At that point, much of what I could
do was finished. Greg and I continue to provide technical assistance, but by Wednesday, Dr. Roger Nasci and other CDC staff arrived, and Dr. White was still on scene to advise the City. Since the City was in such capable hands, it was time for me to concentrate on my own program. Naturally, the scare in the City had made Suffolk County residents very mosquito conscious. My office received over 800 calls from the public in 5 days, requesting spray and reporting any potential breeding site. Our spray program normally winds down after Labor Day. Instead, all larval control crews were on overtime, and all three of our ULV trucks were operating. Surveillance was stepped up, especially for Culex pipiens. Many Suffolk residents discovered for the first time that they had an ongoing mosquito control program, complete with surveillance, and that this was why there was no need at that time to spray the entire county.
The weather has now cooled to the point where adulticiding is no longer effective. It is now time to focus on requesting supplementary budgets to deal with a new virus threat that can appear anywhere in Suffolk's 911 square miles. Clearly, we will have to step up larvicidingand larval surveillance to include storm sewers and catch basins. Our surveillance program, currently oriented toward Eastern Equine Encephalitis, will need to be expanded. At all levels of government, there is a great deal of research and preparation that will need to be done if we are to understand and properly deal with this issue. Next year will hold many new challenges for mosquito control and public health officials. If the actions witnessed this year are any guide, I would say we will rise to the occasion.
Southeast Regional Public Health Pest & Vector Management Conf.
For the next three weeks, we were working under the assumption that the problem was SLE and it was probably limited to urban areas. On Friday, September 24, we received word from the NY State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) that we had dead crows in western Suffolk, and they had some form of encephalitis. Ground ULV trucks were diverted to the area. Over the weekend, it became clear to CDC and other health officials that WNV (then called 'West Nile-like virus) was present in our area, and the culprit, we now know, for the human and animal cases.
Dominick V. Ninivaggi is the"' Superintendent of the Suffolk County DPW i1>ivision:of Vector ·Control '~~ ·
[email protected] ~ . ~
February 22-24, 2000 Panama City Beach, FL For more information contact Dr. Jack Petersen @ Phone: (850) 872-4184 ext. 36 or visit http://pherec.org
AMCA Annual Meeting March 12-16, 2000 Bally's I Park Place Resort Atlantic City, NJ For more information contact the AMCA Central Office Phone: (318) 474-2723 Fax: (318) 478-9434 or visit AMCA's website at www.mosquito.org
BVA MOSQUITO CONTROL PRODUCTS
32
BVA2 Larvicide Oil
BVA Maximum Flushing Oil
BVA Fog Oil 100
EPA# 70589 Quick Kill Larvicide
Short-Term
BVA 13 EPA# 55206-2
The Clear Choice For ULVDiluents
Cleans Nozzles and Tanks Dissolves Insecticide Residues
and Sludge Deposits
N aphthenic Oil Used for Certain
Fogging Operations
BVA Paint Slayer
Added to Paint for use on walls, ceilings and floors to provide protection against mosquitoes
and other insects
BVA OILS 8t•0~23t.3376
Fall 1999
BVA Conceal Skin Gel
Protects skin from mosquitoes, midge and other attack insects
Repels, does not kill
FAX # 248~348~2684
BVA Banzai Fabric Spray
Use on clothes, hats, picnic tables, patios Repels, does not kill
-~ -!' ., __ ,. ,.·,fl
1 -:. {m·a ·- :·1- '• ... _J .. l_~ '~
. . hi. : } -~- -:-·
Dear Editor:
Wing Beats (Vol.1 0 No.3) reached my mailbox this morning. As always it made good breakfast reading. I was surprised, though, to note the omission of an important piece of information in the Viewpoint: The Impact of Mosquitoes on Wildlife: Challenging Some Assumptions by Truls Jensen and Robert J. Novak. While they mentioned "pathogens", avian malaria is by far the most important of these in the present context.
One of the most important impacts of mosquitoes on wildlife is that many of the culicines serve as vectors of various species of Plasmodium causing avian and other
·6-
1111 'L\l'F.'( V\ \I''(,.\ If H \,JR 'I -.~ , > f '•
non-human malarias such as reptilian ones.
Avian malarias, for example the most widespread and commonest one, Plasmodium relictum, can cause severe sickness and death.
There's an abundance of literature on this subject, but few actual books about it. The best of the American ones is by R. Hewitt (1940). BIRD MALARIA, The Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore. P.C.C.
Garnham's (1966) MALARIA PARASITES AND OTHER HAEMOSPORIDIA, Blackwell Scientific Publications, OxfordUK is still the best source for the malarias overall, and includes various lists of species of mosquitoes known to attack wildlife.
My own AVIAN MALARIA IN THE ASIAN TROPICAL SUBREGION {1997), Springer-Verlag Singapore Pte Ltd includes detailed data on 12 of the species of avian malaria para-
sites plus 5 queried species, from 55,289 birds of 1132 species sampled by the US Army's Migratory Animals Pathological Survey for which I handled the plasmodia. This was reviewed in a recent issue of JAMCA. Some of the bird species concerned are now extinct - this survey began in the early 1960s, and while heavy destruction of forests in the area surveyed (which stretched from eastern I ran to Japan) was probably largely responsible for this, avian malaria very possibly contributed to the final extinction of heavily depleted populations.
Mention of this subject would have increased the force of the Jensen/Novak argument
r Marshall Laird 193 Wharawhara Road -.~ RD2 -KATIKATI 3063 · :<. ~
~-NEW ZEALAND :;. .. ~ ~
· Seeks · Technical Adviser Technical Adviser - The American Mosquito Control Association seeks an individual knowl
edgeable in the field of mosquito control. and adept at interacting_ ·with specialists in_, related ·"disciplines to serve as Technical Adviser.' The position ha_s:·been created to provide oversight and · continuity within the Association for~approved projects, committe~ activities, public relations, media
releases, website program, interaction with state,tegional and local mosquito assoCiations, liaison :yvith legislative and regulatory consultants and bodies, and related activities. The _position will be
: 'under the direct superVision of the Ass9qiation President..-__ · ..: . ..
-The-incumbent may reside .. anyWhere in the U.S. as a permanent staff member, visit the' princlpai office at lea_st one week each quarter, attend all Board meetings)· and conduct the technicaJ affairs of
::.the Assqcialion by a combinatiqn·of written and electronic communications andcm'-site visits. The incumbent will routinely interact with Association personnel responsible for. publications, office management, fiscal matters and meetin·gs preparations~ but not be responsible for these activities .
.: -". Coinpensation package (salary, social security,· health ben~fits and pe~sion) for the successful ,,:. ·candidate, based on an annual part-time work schedule of 1040 hrs, will range from $31 ,000-$43,000
depending on qualifications. · ·· __ _ • :: • • ....: • ·-. ~ · : ~ . ~.<:,:
_. For additional information contact David Dame. at tel. (352) 378-7151 ~ 'fax (352) 37 4-6886; or email dao~-me@ nen~p:nerdc.ufl.edu. Submit application, with three letters of recommendation from
- -i'ridividuals working tn fieldS:. related to mosquito or vector control; and an informative c.V. to::· Business Manager, American -Mosquito Control Association, 2200 East Prien Lake Road, Lake Charles, LA 70601. · ~~-.:. ·--· · ·
.,
Fall 1999 33
continued from page 19 agreement that would allow the bill to move forward. At this point, I must say that the original bill had become so emasculated that I seriously considered throwing in the towel. In fact I did, but I missed the ring!
The 1995 session of the legislature ended January 20,1996 and with it the the life of the bill. The Bill is prefiled as S-560 for the new legislature on the same day. This meant another session of the Legislature, two more years of waiting? Frustrations were rising among the Commissioners at the MCMEC.
On February 5, 1996 MCMEC passed another resolution urging passage of the legislation. Senator Bennett assured us that once we resolved our differences with the NJEF he saw no reason why the bill wouldn't move on a fast track.
Finally, on May 18, 1996 Dr. Schulze and I agreed in principle with the NJEF to a watered down bill, which is better than none.
Stuff happens! On May 23, 1996 the Senate Health Committee unanimously approves the Bill.
July 25, 1996 Dr. Schulze and I testify before the New Jersey State Pesticide Control Council and they unanimously endorse passage. The full Senate also passes the bill unanimously later that day. Assembly passage of S-560 doesn't take place until February 20, 1997.
April 1, 1997 Senator Bennett advises me that Governor Christine Todd Whitman had signed S-560 into law. My first thought was that this was an April fool's joke. This legislation, while significant to us, was signed without comment or fanfare. The law is ch 52 PL 1997 New Jersey Statutes 26:2P-7.
NEW JERSEY STATUTES ANNOTATED
TITLE 26. HEALTH AND VITAL STATISTICS
CHAPTER 2P. LYME DISEASE
26:2P-7. Designation of agency to conduct tick management activities
The Board of Chosen Freeholders of a county may designate any county mosquito commission or other agency or any combination thereof to provide surveillance, education, training and recommendations on integrated pest management for the management of Lyme disease or other tick-borne disease vectors.
In the event of a public health necessity, the designated commission or agency may conduct other tick management activities in accordance with tick management protocols established by the Department of Health and Senior Services.
"" · . •Martin S. Chomsky, M~H, Monmouth County ·Mosquito Extermination Commission Eatontown, NJ, o1724 ' . . . . _
email: [email protected]
34 Fall 1999
Attn: FMI Pump Users
Don•t Get Stung!!
Take Advantage of this Special
FMI PUMP· · •: TUNE-UP OFFER!
For Only $29.95 FMI will • Inspect Your Pump • Replace All Seals • Test It to Meet
Original Specifications!
We wiH also send you... ~ • A spare lip seal kit • AND ... A $50 Credit toward
the purchase of a new pump or spare pump head!
For Details - Call Toll Free (888) FMI-PUMP
(888-364-7867)
We're Sales VW&R's professional, educated, experienced staff knows and understands the vector control industry. You can count on us to be there when you need us.
We're Service VW &R has over 70 locations across the United States and Mexico that offer convenient, local vector control products. Count on our professional and knowledgeable industry experts to assist you in fmding solutions to your problems.
We're Support • VW&R's web site is designed to provide you with the latest
industry information. Visit PestWeb for labels, slides, MSDS's, industry news, and weather reports.
• ChemCare<ll provides you with chemical waste management solutions.
• Our licensed instructors are teaching seminars in classrooms across the nation. You can count on us to help you stay current.
We're Serving the Vector Control Industry • Bti's: granules, liquid,
sand, wettable powder, briquettes, dunks
• Larvicide oils • UL V foggers • Sprayers • Atrapa • Natural Pyrethrin
We'reVW&R.
• Resmethrin • Dibrom • Hantavirus live traps • Diluent oils • Safety equipment • Light traps • Thermal foggers
Call Your Local VW &R Office At. ..
1-800-888-4VWR @ Van Waters &Rogers Inc.
We're More Than Just A Distributor
Can't quite fit all the pieces together?
Don't worry. You're not alone. It has never been
harder to keep up with new products, EPA require-and it's environmentally friendly. Stop larvae before they
have a chance to develop into adults with VectoLex. ments and environme!l_tal issues than it is today. There's a New Dawn in Adult Mosquito Control
We'll make sure evel') RtT'I'L04:3 7 0 8·-· "'"771P. with ANVIL«~. No aquatic setbacks, no pasture restric-
. 93ooao 3999 fits beautifully and he Rt.T'l'LEDtJfi:, CY , ~~~ l 1
52
471 co
rum to vectoLexq 4 8 9 o :rm·ra:e;r. N'l'HIA ROXANNE 3 7 VE.Ro FJ.Ei:Jt.C;a .,fR.EJr.K DR A.:P'I' 5
· -·-,tions help ANVIL set
=ast knockdown and
way ahead of the pack. residual control. V ~ 3.2963-1.271
6 weeks which meal f111f 1 til II Ill r ' 'II II' •'/•o II I II I ' economical control.~ 1 11
1 n; ,,1/11.,,/,/,,lll applied by conventional ground or air equipment. ffie - The p1eces~ active ingredient is a naturally occurring soil bacterium We're here to help.
the right products,
Is we can help you put
- fit. Any questions?
1-800-323-5727
(§;Clarke,· Mosquito Control Products, Inc. 159 Garden Avenue • Roselle, IL 60172 email: [email protected] web: www.cmosquito.com
U'iH9 i$'eat4 PO Bmt 60005 Fort Myers, FL 33906
ADDRESS SERVICE REQUESTED
lfullfllll,llllflll.lllfj I iII~ .. ~ i 1111,11,1111,,1,,1,,1 i 1111111 raxapne Rut1eag.e z d 1~!! -c , .. 9!1-
PO Bax1
180 Baton Rouge LA 70893-8043
Non-Profit Org. US Postage
PAID Ft. Myers, FL PERMIT #59