manitoba hydro keeyask generation & transmission projects...

December 20, 2013 Manitoba Wildlands 1

Review Process:

2) Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency reviews Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects jointly3) Clean Environment Commission reviews Keeyask Generation Project and holds hearings

Legend:Canadian Environmental Assessment Act ‐Canadian Environmental Assessment Act from 1992 applies to Keeyask Generation ProjectDescription ‐ events, documents, motions, activities of Clean Environment Commission and Canadian Environmental Assessment AgencyURLs ‐ If links are broken, email [email protected] for a copy of the documentAcronyms list ‐ Master list available at the end of document

Links:Manitoba Public registry ‐ http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency ‐ http://www.ceaa‐acee.gc.ca/Clean Environment Commission ‐ http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/Keeyask Limited Hydro Partnership ‐ http://keeyask.comBipole III Clean Environment Commission Hearings Events Chart ‐ http://manitobawildlands.org/pdfs/MWL‐CEC‐BP3ChronologyEvents‐19Mar13‐11thVersionUpdate‐FNL.pdf

Color Coding: CEAA = Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency New Additions to Chronology ChartCEC = Clean Environment CommissionMBHY = Manitoba Hydro and Proponent of KeeyaskCEC ParticipantsMB Gov =All branches of Manitoba Government Other federal government bodies

Manitoba Hydro Keeyask Generation & Transmission Projects Chronology Chart

Date Modified & Version: December 20, 2013 ‐ V37

1) Manitoba Conservation and Water Stewardship‐Environment Approvals Branch ‐ reviews Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects separately and oversees; Environment Act Proposals, Scoping Documents, Environmental Impact Statements, Technical Reports, filings and review comments

Clean Environment Commission and Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency


Date Description URL Source NotesJan 9, 2014 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB will be

extended to this week‐ as of Nov 8, 2013

CEC Week 8 (Thursday)

Jan 8, 2014 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB will be extended to this week‐ as of Nov 8, 2014

CEC Week 8 (Wedensday)


CEC Week 8 (Tuesday)


CEC Week 8 (Monday)

Dec 16, 2013 CAC submits edited documents CEC Particpants

Dec 16, 2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Jan 6 ‐ 9, 2014

Dec 16, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts ‐ Keeyask Winnipeg Hearing Dec 12,2013.pdf

CEC Dec 12,2013 Transcript




Dec 13, 2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Jan 6 ‐ 9, 2014

Dec 13, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released

CEC Dec 12,2013 Exhibit List

Dec 12, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF President Panel Presentation

Proponent


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 12, 2013 Cross Examination of KK Expert

Witnesses Presentations on Traditional Land Use

CEC Particpants

CFLGC, MMF, MWL

Dec 12, 2013 KK Expert Witnesses Presentations on Traditional Land Use

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3

CEC Particpants

Terry Dick, D'Arcy Linklater (Presentations KK‐004 to KK‐025)

Dec 12, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Adaptive Management

CEC Particpants

CFLGC, MMF, MWL

Dec 12, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Adaptive Management

Proponent

Dec 12, 2013 CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Adaptive Management

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Diduck, Fitzpatrick Keeyask Final_Nov 25, 2013.pdf

CEC Particpants

Drs. A.Diduck and P. Fitzpatrick (Presentations CAC‐032)

Dec 12, 2013 KK submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants



Dec 12, 2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB extended‐ as of Nov 1, 2013


Dec 11,2013 Cross Examination of Fox Lake First Nation Youth Panel Presentation

CEC Particpants

CAC

Dec 11,2013 Cross Examination of PFN Panel Presentation

CEC Particpants

CAC, CFLGC, MWL

Dec 11,2013 Peguis First Nation (PFN) Panel Presentation


CEC Particpants

(Presentations PFN‐005 to PFN‐009)


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 11,2013 MMF submits undertakings to CEC CEC

Particpants

Dec 11,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website



Dec 11,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released


Dec 11,2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB extended‐ as of Nov 1, 2014

CEC Week 7 (Wedensday)

Dec 10,2013 Cross Examination of Fox Lake First Nation Youth Panel Presentation

CEC Particpants

MWL

Dec 10,2013 Cross Examination of CFLGC Expert Witnesses Presentation

Proponent

Dec 10,2013 CFLGC Expert Witnesses Presentation http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3

CEC Particpants

Dr. P Kulchyski, Dr. S Maclachlan, A. Pawlowska( Presentation CFLGC‐

008 to ‐0012)Dec 10,2013 Fox Lake First Nation Youth Panel

Presentationhttp://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3

CEC Particpants

( Presentation CFLGC‐001 to ‐007)

Dec 10,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released


Dec 10,2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB extended‐ as of Nov 1, 2015


Dec 9, 2013 Fox Lake First Nation Youth Panel Presentation


CEC Particpants

( Presentation CFLGC‐001 to ‐007)


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 9, 2013 MMF submits undertakings to CEC CEC

Particpants

Dec 9, 2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB extended‐ as of Nov 1, 2016

CEC Week 7 (Monday)

Dec 6, 2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Dec 9, 2013 ‐ Jan 9, 2014






Dec 5, 2013 Cross Examination of KHLP Moving Forward as Partners on Environmental Matters

CEC Particpants

PIM, MWL, CAC

Dec 5, 2013 KHLP Moving Forward as Partners on Environmental Matters

Proponent ( Presentation KHLP‐069)

Dec 5, 2013 Cross Examination of PIM Expert Witness Cumulative effects assesmment and mitigaton measures proposed Presentation

CEC Particpants

CAC, CFLGC, MWL

Dec 5, 2013 Cross Examination of PIM Expert Witness Cumulative effects assesmment and mitigaton measures proposed Presentation

Proponent


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 5, 2013 PIM Expert Witness Cumulative effects

assesmment and mitigaton measures proposed Presentation

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/PIM‐008 Issues of Concern Presentation Luttermann.pdf

CEC Particpants

A. Lutterman (Presentation PIM‐008)

Dec 5, 2013 KK submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants

Dec 5, 2013 CAC submits edited documents CEC Particpants






Dec 5, 2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB extended‐ as of Sept 18, 2013


Dec 4, 2013 Cross Examination of PIM Panel The Nature, Health, Economy, Territory and Rights Presentation

Proponent

Dec 4, 2013 PIM Panel The Nature, Heatlh, Economy, Territory and Rights Presentation


CEC Particpants

(Presentation PIM‐002 to PIM‐004)

Dec 4, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Expert Witness Traditional Land Use and Knowlwege (TLUK) Presentation

CEC Particpants

CAC, CFLGC

Dec 4, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Expert Witness Traditional Land Use and Knowlwege (TLUK) Presentation

Proponent


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 4, 2013 MMF Expert Witness Traditional Land

Use and Knowlwege (TLUK) Presentation

CEC Particpants

P.M. Larcombe (Presentation MMF‐008)



Dec 3,2013 Transcript


Dec 3,2013 Exhibit List

Dec 4, 2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg MB extended ‐ as of sept 18, 2013

CEC Week 6 (Wednesday)

Dec 3, 2013 MMF Expert Witness Traditional Land Use and Knowlwege (TLUK) Presentation

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MMF‐008 TLUKS Presentation P. Larcombe.pdf

CEC Particpants

P.M. Larcombe (Presentation MMF‐008)

Dec 3, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Expert Witness Socio‐Economic Information Gaps Presentation

CEC Particpants

MWL

Dec 3, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Expert Witness Socio‐Economic Information Gaps Presentation

Proponent

Dec 3, 2013 MMF Expert Witness Socio‐Economic Information Gaps Presentation

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MMF‐007 Socioecon Info Gaps Presentation M. Birnie.pdf

CEC Particpants

M. Birnie (Presentation MMF‐007)

Dec 3, 2013 Cross Examination of Expert Witness Ungulate Information Gaps Presentation

CEC Particpants

CAC

Dec 3, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Expert Witness Ungulate Information Gaps Presentation

Proponent


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 3, 2013 MMF Expert Witness Ungulate

Information Gaps Presentation http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MMF‐005 Ungulate Information Gaps Presentation A. Stewart.pdf

CEC Participants

A. Stewart (Presentation MMF‐005)

Dec 3, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Panel Harvesters Presention

Proponent

Dec 3, 2013 MMF Panel Harvesters Presentation CEC Participants








Dec 2, 2013 Cross Examination of MMF Panel Community Presention

Proponent

Dec 2, 2013 (Manitoba Metis Federation) MMF Panel Community Presentation

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MMF‐003 Concerns and Issues of the Manitoba Metis Community Presentation.pdf

CEC Participants

(Presentation MMF‐003)

Dec 2, 2013 Cross Examination of MWL Expert Witness Presentation on Ecosystem Monitoring

CEC Participants

CFLGCDec 2, 2013 Cross Examination of MWL Expert

Witness Presentation on Ecosystem Monitoring

Proponent


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 2, 2013 MWL Expert Witnesses Presentation

on Ecosystem Monitoringhttp://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MWL‐011 Ecosystem Monitoring Presentation A. McHugh.pdf

CEC Participants

(Presentation MWL‐011)

Dec 2, 2013 Cross Examination of MWL Expert Witness Presentation on Sustainable Development and Sustainability

CEC Participants

CFLGCDec 2, 2013 Cross Examination of MWL Expert

Witness Presentation on Sustainable Development and Sustainability

Proponent

Dec 2, 2013 MWL Expert Witnesses Presentation on Sustainable Development and Sustainability

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MWL‐009 Sustainability and Sustainable Devt Presentation A. Clarke.pdf

CEC Particpants

Dr. A. Clarke (Presentation MWL‐009)


CEC Nov 26,2013 Exhibit List

Dec 2, 2013 CFLGC submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants


CEC Week 6 (Monday)

Nov 29, 2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Dec 2, 2013 ‐ Jan 9, 2014

Nov 29, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released



Date Description URL Source NotesNov 28, 2013 Cross Examination of MWL Expert

Witness Presentation on Wildlife VECs, Habitat Quality

Proponent

Nov 28, 2013 MWL Expert Witnesses Presentation on Wildlife VECs, Habitat Quality

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MWL‐007 Habitat Quality Models, SAR and Wildlife VECs Soprovich.doc1.pdf

CEC Participants

D. Soprovich (Presentation MWL‐007)

Nov 28, 2013 Cross Examination of MWL Expert Witness Presentation on Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

Proponent

Nov 28, 2013 MWL Expert Witnesses Presentation on Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/MWL‐004 Life Cycle Assessment Protocol Coldstream28Nov2013.pdf

CEC Participants

J. Salazar and M.Botwick (Presentation MWL‐004)

Nov 28, 2013 MMF submits Late Filing Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Participants



Nov 28, 2013 CEC Hearings in Winnipeg predicted to end


CEC

Week 5 (Thursday)Nov 28, 2013

9:30am‐4:30pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 5 ( Thursday)Nov 27, 2013 Cross Examination of KHLP Moving

Forward as Partners on Environmental Matters

CEC Participants

CFLGC


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 27, 2013 KHLP Moving Forward as Partners on

Environmental MattersProponent ( Presentation KHLP‐069)

Nov 27, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witnesses Socio‐Economics

CEC Participants

MWL, CFLGC, PIM, CACNov 27, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witnesses Socio‐EconomicsProponent

Nov 27, 2013 Cross Examination of PFN Expert Witness on Shoreline modelling and Inundation

CEC Particpants

CAC, CFLGC, PIM

Nov 27, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witnesses on Shoreline modelling and Inundation

Proponent

Nov 27, 2013 Peguis Expert Witness Presentation on Shoreline modelling and Inundation

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/PFN‐004 Identifying Shoreline Changes Flanders_Peguis presentation.pdf

CEC Particpants

D.Flanders (Presentation PFN‐003)

Nov 27, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts ‐ Keeyask Winnipeg Hearing Nov 26,2013.pdf

CEC Nov 26,2013 Transcript



Nov 27, 20139:30am‐4:30pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 5 ( Wednesday)


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 26, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witnesses Socio‐EconomicsCEC Participants

CFLGC, MWLNov 26, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witnesses Socio‐EconomicsProponent

Nov 26, 2013 CAC Expert Witnesses Presentation on Socio‐Economics

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/CAC‐029 CED Assessment of the Keeyask Model Buckland and O'Gorman.pdf

CEC Participants

Dr.J.Buckland and Dr M. O'Gorman (Presentations CAC‐029)

Nov 26, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witnesses on Health Impact Asssesment, HHRA

CEC Participants

CFLGC, MWLNov 26, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witnesses on Health Impact Asssesment, HHRA

Proponent

Nov 26, 2013 CAC Expert Witnesses Presentation on Health Impact Asssesment, HHRA


CEC Participants

MD. L. Murray, Dr. Breese and Dr.Brown

(Presentations CAC‐023 and CAC‐026)

Nov 26, 2013 MMF submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Participants







Date Description URL Source NotesNov 26, 2013



CEC

Week 5 ( Tuesday)Nov 25, 2013 Moving Forward as Partners on

Environmental Mattershttp://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐069 Moving Forward as Partners.pdf

Proponent ( Presentation KHLP‐069)

Nov 25, 2013 Cross Examination of Terrestrial Environment Panel ( Continued from Nov 4, 2013)

CEC Particpants

CAC (Presentation KHLP‐042)

Nov 25, 2013 MWL submits Expert Witness Presentation, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants



CEC

Week 5 ( Monday)Nov 20,2013 Peguis submits Expert Witness

Presentations, Reports, SubmissionsCEC Particpants

Nov 19,2013 CAC submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants

Nov 18,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website



Nov 18, 2013 Keeyask Hearings Adjourned for the Week of Nov 18 , 2013

CEC Mandatory CEC Hearings Break Nov 18 to Nov 21, 2013


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 15,2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Nov 25, 2013 ‐ Jan 9, 2014



Nov 14, 2013 Public Presentation by Janet McIvor, I. Disbrowe, M. Wavey, M. Mazurat, R. Spence, G. Kichekeesik, N. McIvor, J. Kitchekeesik

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/WPG‐007 Presentation from Janet McIvor and her family.pdf

Nov. 14 2013 Transcript

Nov 14, 2013 Public Presentation by Will Braun, InterChurch Council on Hydropower

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/WPG‐006 Presentation from Will Braun, Nov14.pdf

CEC Particpants

(Presentation WPG‐006)

Nov 14, 2013 Public Presentation by Cheryl Kennedy Courcelles

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/WPG‐005 Presentation from Cheryl Kennedy Courcelles, Nov14.pdf

CEC Particpants


Nov 14, 2013 Public Presentation by Allan Ciekiewicz http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/WPG‐004 Presentation from Allan Ciekiewicz Presentation, Nov14.pdf

CEC Particpants


Nov 14, 2013 Public Presentation by Solange Garson Nov 14 2013 Transcript

Nov 14, 2013 Public Presentation by Selena Saunders

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/WPG‐003 Presentation from Selina Saunders, Hydro effects my livelihood.pdf

CEC Participants




7:00pm‐9:00pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 4 (Thursday)Nov 14, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witness Presentation on Sustainability Assessment

CEC Particpants

CFLGC, PIM, MWL

Nov 14, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Sustainability Assessment

Proponent

Nov 14, 2013 CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Sustainability Assessment

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/CAC‐020 Sustainability Assessment Gibson.pdf

CEC Particpants

Dr.Robert Gibson (Presentation CAC‐020)


http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts%20‐%20Keeyask%20Winnipeg%20Hearing%20Nov%2013,2013.pdf




Nov 14, 20131:30pm‐4:30pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 4 ( Thursday)Nov 14, 2013

CEC submits revised Hearing ScheduleCEC

Nov 25, 2013 ‐ Jan 9, 2014Nov 13, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witness on CaribouCEC Particpants

MWL, PFN, FLCGC


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 13, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witness on Caribou Proponent

Nov 13, 2013 CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Caribou ‐ Dr. J. Schaefer

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/CAC‐017 Caribou and the Keeyask project, Presentation.pdf

CEC Particpants

James Schaefer (Presentation CAC‐017)

Nov 13, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witness on Lake Sturgeon

CEC Particpants

MWL, Peguis, CFLGC

Nov 13, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witness on Lake Sturgeon

Proponent

Nov 13, 2013 CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Lake Sturgeon ‐ Dr. S. Peake

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/CAC‐013 Lake Sturgeon Mitigation at Keeyask‐Concerns and Advice, (Presentation) S. Peake.pdf

CEC Particpants

Dr. Stephan Peake (Presentation CAC‐013)

Nov 13, 2013 CAC Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CAC










CEC

Week 4 ( Wednesday)Nov 12, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert

Witness Presentation on Cumulative Effects Assessment

CEC Particpants

CFLGC, PIM, MWL, Peguis

Nov 12, 2013 Cross Examination of CAC Expert Witness Presentation on Cumulative Effects Assessment

Proponent

Nov 12, 2013 CAC Expert Witnesses' Presentation on Cumulative Effects Assessment ‐Dr. Gunn & Dr. Noble

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/CAC‐009 Noble and Gunn CEA Presentation.pdf

CEC Particpants

Dr. Bram Noble and Dr. Jill Gunn (Presentation CAC‐009)



CEC

Week 4 ( Tuesday)Nov 8, 2013 CEC releases their descision on all

motions discussed at the CEC Motions Hearing Oct 17, 2013

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/ ‐ 1

CEC Decisions for CFLGC, PIM, Peguis Motions

Nov 8 ,2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Nov 12‐14, 2013 and Nov 25‐Dec 12, 2013







Date Description URL Source NotesNov 7, 2013 Cross Examination of Keeyas

Evaluation of the Keeyask Generation Project ‐Cree Nation Presentations (Continued)

CEC Particpants

CAC,PIM,FLCG,Peguis, CFLGC

Nov 7, 2013 Public Presentation by members of Shamattawa First Nation

CEC Particpants


Nov 7, 2013 CAC submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants




Nov 7 ,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released


Nov 7, 2013



CEC

Week 3 ( Thursday)Nov 6, 2013 Cross Examination of Keeyas

Evaluation of the Keeyask Generation Project ‐Cree Nation Presentations

CEC Particpants

CAC

Nov 6 ,2013 Keeyask Evaluation of the Keeyask Generation Project ‐Cree Nation Presentations

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐050 Environmental Evaluation of the Keeyask Generation Project Nov 6, 2013‐CNP.pdf

Proponent (Presentation KHLP‐050)


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 6, 2013 Cross Examination of Socio‐Economic

Environment, Resource Use and Heritage Resources Panel (Continued)

CEC Particpants

CFLGC, MMF, MWL


http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts%20‐%20Keeyask%20Winnipeg%20Hearing%20Nov%205,2013.pdf






CEC

Week 3 (Wednesday)Nov 5, 2013 Cross Examination of Socio‐Economic

Environment, Resource Use and Heritage Resources Panel

CEC Particpants

Peguis, CAC, PIM, CFLGC

Nov 5, 2013 CAC submits Expert Witness Presentations, Reports, Submissions

CEC Particpants










CEC

Week 3 ( Tuesday)Nov 4, 2013 Public Presentation by Baldur Nelson http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/

hearings/39/Wpg‐001 Presentation from Baldur Nelson Nov. 4, 20132.pdf

CEC Particpants


Nov 4, 2013

7:00pm‐9:00pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 3 (Monday)Nov 4,2013 Socio‐Economic Environment,

Resource Use and Heritage Resources Panel

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐044 Socio‐economic, Resource Use and Heritage Resources.pdf


Nov 4, 2013 Cross Examination of Terrestrial Environment Panel ( Continued from Oct 31, 2013)

CEC Particpants

** This Panel was paused and will resume at a later date‐ CAC still has

Cross Examination

Nov 4, 20131:30pm‐4:30pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 3 (Monday)Nov 1, 2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC CEC extends Hearings into an extra

week Nov 4‐ Dec 11,2013


CEC Oct 31,2013 Transcript

Oct 31, 2013 Cross Examination of Terrestrial Environment Panel

CEC Particpants

CFLGC,Peguis, MWL, PIM, MWL, CAC


Date Description URL Source NotesOct 31, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript

released on CEC websitehttp://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts ‐ Keeyask Winnipeg Hearing Oct 30,2013.pdf


Oct 31, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released

CEC Oct 30,2013 Exhibit List

Oct 31, 20139:30am‐4:30pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB


CEC

Week 2 (Thursday)Oct 30,2013 Terrestrial Environment Panel http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/

hearings/39/KHLP‐042 Aquatic & Terrestrial Environment ‐ Part 2.pdf


Oct 30,2013 Cross Examination of Aquatic Environment Panel (Continued)

CEC Particpants

PIM, CFLGC

Oct 30,2013 MBHY created a digital map book of all maps used in Project Description Panel and Physical Panel presentations

http://keeyask.com/wp/keeyask‐generation‐project‐cec‐hearings‐project‐description‐physical‐environment‐map‐book‐october‐2013


Oct 30, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts ‐ Keeyask Winnipeg Hearing Oct 29,2013.pdf





Date Description URL Source NotesOct 30, 2013



CEC

Week 2 (Wednesday)Oct 29,2013 Cross Examination of Aquatic

Environment PanelCEC Particpants

MWL, Peguis, CAC

Oct 29,2013 Aquatic Environment Panel Proponent (Presentation KHLP‐041)

Oct 29,2013 PIM submits a Expert Witness Resume CEC Particpants

Oct 29,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KeeyaskOct2813.pdf




CEC

Week 2 (Tuesday)Oct 28, 2013 Cross Examination of Physical

Environment PanelCEC Particpants

MWL, Peguis, MMF, CAC, CFLGC and then PIM (KK did not attend)

Oct 28, 2013 Physical Environment Panel Proponent (Presentation KHLP‐040)







CEC

Week 2 (Monday)Oct 25, 2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC Oct 28 ‐ Dec 5, 2013

Oct 25, 2013 CFLGC submits a Expert Witness Resume

CEC Particpants

Oct 25, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Transcript released on CEC website



Oct 24, 2013 Cross Examination of Regulatory Environmental Assessment‐Approach Methods and Processes Panel

CEC Particpants


Oct 24, 2013 Keeyask Generation Project Regulatory Environmental Assessment‐Approach Methods and Processes (Continued)

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐039 Approach, Methods and Processes Vicky Cole Oct 23, 20131.pdf



http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/keeyaskoct23.pdf


Oct 24,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list released






CEC

Week 1 (Thursday)Oct 23, 2013 Keeyask Generation Project Regulatory

Environmental Assessment‐Approach Methods and Processes Panel

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐039 Approach, Methods and Processes Vicky Cole Oct 23, 20131.pdf


Oct 23, 2013 Cross Examination of Project Description Panel

CEC Particpants


Oct 23, 2013 Project Description Panel http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐037 Keeyask Project Description, Marc St. Laurent Oct 23, 20131.pdf


Oct 23, 2013 Introduction to the Collaborative Two Track Approach Panel

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐036 Two Track Assessment Approach Oct 23, 20131.pdf

Proponent *This Panel was not Cross Examined Vicky Cole, Shawna Pachal, Joe Keeper

(Presentation KHLP‐036)

Oct 23,2013 MBHY releases Heritage Field Studies 2012

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KHLP‐048 Updates on Keeyask Heritage Field Studies 2012‐13.pdf


Oct 23,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Undertakings list released

CEC Oct 22,2013 Undertakings List





Date Description URL Source NotesOct 23,2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibits list

releasedCEC Oct 22,2013 Exhibit List



CEC

Week 1 ( Wednesday)Oct 22,2013 Cross Examination of KHLP Partnership

Presentation by CEC Participants PanelCEC Particpants

MWL, Peguis, MMF, CAC, CFLGC,PIM

Oct 22,2013 KHLP Partnership Presentation Panel Continued

Proponent Shawna Pachal(MBHY), Ted Bland(YFFN), George Neepin(FLCN), Victor Spence with Roy Flett and Roy

Ouskun(TCN)Oct 22,2013 CEC submits revised Hearing Schedule CEC October 23 ‐ 24




Oct 22, 2013 CEC Keeyask Hearing Exhibit list released

CEC Oct 21, 2013 Exhibit List

Oct 22, 2013





Date Description URL Source NotesOct 21,2013 KHLP Partnership Presentation Panel Proponent Shawna Pachal(MBHY), Ted

Bland(YFFN), George Neepin(FLCN), Victor Spence with Roy Flett and Roy

Ouskun(TCN)Oct 21,2013 Opening Statements from KHLP

Partnership PanelProponent Ken Adams, FLCN, YFFN, WLFN,TCN

Oct 21,2013 Opening Statements By all Participants CEC Particpants


Oct 21, 2013 MCWS Opening Statements MCWS Director of Administraion Ms.Tracey Braun

Oct 21,2013 MBHY Opening Statements Proponent MBHY Lawyer Mr. Doug Bedford

Oct 21, 2013 CEC Opening Statements CEC CEC Chair Mr. Terry Sargeant

Oct 21, 2013

9:30am‐4:30pm at Ft. Garry Spa and Conference Centre, 222 Broadway, Winnipeg, MB Week 1 ( Monday)


Date Description URL Source NotesOct 21, 2013 CEC Hearings Begin in Winnipeg MB http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/i

ndex.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 2CEC CEC hearings predicted to conitnue

for 5 weeks (Monday to Thursday), ending Nov 28, 2013.

Oct 18, 2013 Second version of the Hearing Schedule released

CEC Not available yet Agenda dates: Nov 4‐Dec 5

Oct 18, 2013 Motions transcript now available on CEC website

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts ‐ Motions Hearing Oct 17, 2013.pdf

CEC

Oct 18, 2013 KHLP releases a summary of every panel that will be presenting as the Proponent

Proponent not yet available

Oct 18, 2013 CEC releases their descision on all motions discussed at the CEC Motions Hearing Oct 17, 2013

CEC Their explanation will be released to the participants at a later date

Oct 18, 2013 The Proponent submits an additional Resume

MBHY Original Deadline; Oct 7 ,2013


Date Description URL Source NotesOct 17, 2013 CEC Motions Hearing http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/

hearings/39/KEEYASK MOTIONS HEARINGS final.pdf

CEC Winnipeg Convention Centre, Millennium Room; 9:00am (NOT 10:00am)

Oct 17, 2013 Proponent Releases list of Panel members for Hearings

MBHY not available yet

Oct 16, 2013 First version of the Hearing Schedule released

CEC Not available yet Agenda dates: Nov 4‐Dec 5

Oct 15, 2013 First version of the Hearing Schedule released

CEC Not available yet Agenda dates: Oct 21 ‐31

Oct 15,2013 The Proponent submits an additional Resume

MBHY Original Deadline; Oct 7 ,2013

Oct 11, 2013 Public Registry 5550.00 Keeyask Generation Project Updated May 2013 postings

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5550keeyask/

MB‐Gov Last Updated May 24, 2013


Date Description URL Source NotesOct 11, 2013 CEC Releases Kaweechiwasihki

Presentation exhibits http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3

CEC 3 submissions in total

Oct 11, 2013 CEC Releases Cross Lake written submissions


CEC 30 submissions in total

Oct 11, 2013 CAC submits an additional Resume CEC Particpants

Original Deadline; Oct 7, 2013

Oct 11, 2013 All Transcripts from the Northern Community Hearings are available


CEC Gillam, Bird , York Factory, Thompson, Split Lake, Cross Lake

Oct 11, 2013 CAC (Consumers Association of Canada) withdraws Motion to the CEC

CEC Particpants

Oct 10, 2013 Manitoba Wildlands Submit Support Letters for three Motions

CEC Particpants

Motions Submitted by: PFN, PIM, CAC (CAC withdrawn Motion Oct 11, 2013)


Date Description URL Source NotesOct 10, 2013 Kaweechiwasihk Submits Witness list,

Outlines,CVsCEC Particpants

Filed late due to some technical difficulties

Oct 10, 2013 The Propnent KHLP ( Keeyask Hydropower Limited Partnership) Submits Response to Peguis First Nation and Pimicikamak Notices of Motion

MBHY

Oct 10, 2013 MBHY Repsonse to CEC Participant Motions

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Report ‐ Keeyask Pre‐Hrg Mtg ‐ Sep 2013.pdf

MBHY Noon (12:00pm) deadline

Oct 9, 2013 The Propnent KHLP ( Keeyask Hydropower Limited Partnership) Submits Response to CFLGC Notice of Motion

MBHY

Oct 7,2013 Pimicikamak Submits Witness list, Outlines,CVs

CEC Particpants

Noon (12:00pm) deadline

Oct 7, 2013 Concerned Fox Lake Grassroots Citizens Submits Witness lists, Outlines, CVs

CEC Particpants



Date Description URL Source NotesOct 7, 2013 Manitoba Metis Federation Submits

Witness list, Outlines and CVsCEC Particpants


Oct 7, 2013 Consumers Association of Canada Submits Wintess list, Outlines and CVs

CEC Particpants

Noon (12:00pm) deadline; Additional CV sent out Oct 10, 2013

Oct 7, 2013 The Propnent KHLP ( Keeyask Hydropower Limited Partnership) Submits Witness list, Outlines and CVs

MBHY Noon (12:00pm) deadline

Oct 7, 2013 Peguis First Nation Submits Witness list, Outlines and CVs

CEC Particpants


Oct 7, 2013 Manitoba Wildlands Submits Witness list, Outlines and CVs

CEC Participants


Oct 7, 2013 Prefiling deadline for witnesses in Keeyask Hearing

CEC Noon (12:00pm) Deadline

Oct 4, 2013 Keeyask Generation Project Public Hearing Schedule posted for Day 1

CEC Day 1 October 21, 2013‐ not yet available


Date Description URL Source NotesOct 4, 2013 Keeyask Motions Hearing Agenda

postedhttp://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/KEEYASK MOTIONS HEARINGS final.pdf

CEC October 17,2013 ; Millenium Room 9:00am NOT 10:00am

Oct 2, 2013 Consumers Association of Canada (CAC) Submits Notice of Motion

CEC Particpants

not yet available

Oct 2, 2013 Concerned Fox Lake Grassroots Citizens (CFLGC) Submits Notice of Motion

CEC Particpants

not yet available

Oct 2, 2013 Filing of other Motions to the CEC, and any written responses to motions that are already filed


CEC Noon (12:00pm) Deadline

Oct 1, 2013 CEC Hearing Thomspon area community meeting


CEC Thompson Juniper Centre( 108 Nelson Rd.) 9:00am‐5:00pm

Sept 30, 2013 Concerned Fox Lake Grassroots Citizens (CFLGC) Submits Support letter for PIM and PFN Motions

CEC Particpants

not yet available

Sept 30, 2013 CEC Hearing Thomspon area community meeting


CEC Thompson Juniper Centre ( 108 Nelson Rd.) 7:00pm‐9:00pm

Sept 30, 2013 CEC Hearing Transcript‐York Factory http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3

CEC Public Hearing in York Factory on September 26, 2013

Sept 30, 2013 CEC Hearing Transcript‐Bird Reserve http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3

CEC Public Hearing in Bird Reserve on September 25, 2013


Date Description URL Source NotesSept 30, 2013 CEC Hearing Transcript‐Gillam http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/i

ndex.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 3CEC Public Hearing in Gillam on

September 24, 2013

Sept 27, 2013 Solange Garson, Councillor TCN Submits First Exhibit

CEC Participants

not yet available

Sept 24, 2013 CEC Hearing Gillam area community meeting

CEC Gillam Rec Centre ( 235 Mattonabee Ave) 7:00pm‐ 9:00pm

Sept 24, 2013 CEC Hearing Gillam area community meeting


CEC Gillam Rec Centre ( 235 Mattonabee Ave) 3:00pm ‐ 5:00pm

Sept 16, 2013 CEC September 10 Pre hearing Conference Report


CEC

Sept 16, 2013 CEC‐Pre hearing Transcript http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/Transcripts%20‐%20Keeyask%20Pre‐hearing%20Sep101.pdf

CEC

Sept 10, 2013 CEC Participant Peguis First Nation submits motion

CEC Participants


Sept 10, 2013 CEC Participant Pimicikamak submits motion

CEC Participants



Date Description URL Source NotesSept 10, 2013 CEC Pre‐Hearing Press Conference CEC

ParticipantsConference Rm 16, Winnipeg Convention Centre 3:00pm

Sept 10, 2013 CEC Pre‐Hearing meeting at Convention Centre

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/AGENDA Pre‐hearing September 10, 2013.pdf

CEC Millennium room, Winnipeg Convention Centre 10:00am

Sept 4, 2013 CEC submits a single Round 2 IR ‐ Late CEC Participants

Rd 2 CEC‐IR‐102c based on response to Rd 1 CEC‐IR‐0021

Sept 4, 2013 Pubic Registry still has not been updated


MB‐Gov Public Registry for Keeyask Generation last updated May 24, 2013

September 4, 2013 MBHY sends paper copies to Participants 2 additions to the Preliminary Monitoring Plans

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/preliminary‐environmental‐protection‐program

MBHY Posted on website August 14, 2013. Preliminary Aquatic Effects Monitoring Plan and Preliminary Fish Habitat Compensation Plan

Sept 4, 2013 MBHY sends paper copies to Participants an addition to Supplemental Filing #1 ‐ Errata Part 2

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/eis/supplemental‐filing‐1

MBHY The First Errata list (from supplemental filing # 1) was submitted April 26, 2013.This document is dated August, 2013

Sept 4, 2013 MBHY sends paper copies to Participants the Responses to Requests for Additional Info from TAC and Public Reviews Round #3

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/response‐to‐requests‐for‐information/round‐3

MBHY Posted on website August 23, 2013


Date Description URL Source NotesAug 23, 2013 Keeyask Generation Project Public

Hearing Schedule posted http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 2

CEC Postings for Hearing Schedule not Pre‐Hearing Schedule

August 16, 2013 MBHY submits responses to Round 2 IRs

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐new/cec‐round‐2

MBHY MBHY includes responses to MWL Round 2 IRs sent August 15, 2013

Aug 16, 2013 Clean Environment Commission (CEC) deadline for Manitoba Hydro (MBHY) to respond to round 2 Information Request (IR) from CEC and participants

CEC MBHY provided 16 days by CEC to respond to round 2 IRs from CEC and participants

Aug 15, 2013 MWL (Manitoba Wildlands) Submits 14 IRs

CEC and Particpants

MWL submits a total of 14 Round 2 IRs based on to the 26 lost ( and not acknowledged between May and July 15, 2013 Round 1 IRs MBHY)

Aug 14, 2013 Deadline responses for outstanding Manitoba Wildlands IRs (2nd Round)

CEC and Participants

26 outstanding IRs were responded to by MBHY after deadline. Final batch of the response to outstanding IRs were received by CEC and Participants July 31, 2013

Aug 1, 2013 CAC submits additional IRs to MBHY after deadline (2nd round )

CAC additional IR was excluded from original 2nd round batch of Irs submitted July 31, 2013


Date Description URL Source NotesJuly 31, 2013 Kaweechiwasihki submits Final Batch

of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)KK Ist and Final batch contained 4 Irs

July 31, 2013 Pimicikamak First Nation (PCN) submits Final batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)

PFN Final batch contained 2 IRs , for a total of 6 IRs

July 31, 2013 CEC submits Final batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)

CEC Final batch contained 2 IRs , for a total of 19 IRs

July 31, 2013 MBHY filed final 6 outstanding IR reponses regarding Manitoba Wildlands round 1 IRs

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐new/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐rd‐1http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐

MBHY All Participants have received hard copies of the 26 outstanding MWL IRs from round 1

July 31, 2013 Concerned Fox Lake Grassroots Citizens (CFLGC) submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY( 2nd round)

CFLGC 1st and final batch contained a total of 8 Irs

July 31, 2013 Pimicikamak First Nation (PCN) submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)

PCN 1st Batch contained 4 IRs, for a total of 6 IRs submitted


Date Description URL Source NotesJuly 31, 2013 Manitoba Wildlands submits final

batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)MWL Final batch contained 5 IRs, for a total

of 18 IRs submitted

July 31, 2013 Manitoba Metis Federation (MMF) submits Final batch of IRS to MBHY (round 2)

MMF Final and only batch of IRs contained a Report with IR responses included

July 31, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits Final batch of IRs to MBHY (round 2)

PFN Final batch contianed 12 IRs, for a total of 33 IRs submitted

July 31, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 2nd batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)

PFN 2nd batch contained 10 IRs for a total of 33 IRs submitted

July 31, 2013 Manitoba Wildlands submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)

MWL 1st batch contained 13 IRs, for a total of 18 IRs submitted


Date Description URL Source NotesJuly 31, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 1st batch

of IRs to MBHY (2nd round)PFN 1st batch contained 11 IRs, for a total

of 33 IRs submitted

July 31, 2013 Consumers Association of Canada (CAC) submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round )

CAC 1st batch contained 8 IRs , for a total of 62 IRs submitted and 1 letter to the CEC

July 31, 2013 CEC submits 2nd batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round )

CEC 2nd batch contained 7 Irs, for a total of 19 IRs submitted

July 31, 2013 CEC deadline for round 2 IRs from CEC and participants to MBHY

CEC Round 2 IRs submitted to MBHY can only ask additional questions relating to IRs submitted during round 1

July 30, 2013 CEC submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY (2nd round )

CEC 1st Batch contained 10 IRs, for a total of 19 IRs submitted


Date Description URL Source NotesJuly 29, 2013 MBHY provides number system for the

2nd Round of IRsMBHY Numbering system for 2nd Round of

IRs in the CEC Hearing Directive or Process Guidelines was not found

July 26, 2013 MBHY filed 8 outstanding IR reponses regarding Manitoba Wildlands IRs (second batch 3:00pm)

http://keeyask.com/wp/wp‐content/uploads/2013/07/CEC‐Round‐1‐Web‐Version‐July‐26‐1130‐am.pdf

MBHY Second Batch of outstanding IRs have been added to the Keeyask website. There are still 6 outstanding Irs. Submission of round 2 IRs is two weeks after the date of each rd 1 IR response.

July 26, 2013 MBHY submits Supplemental filings#3 http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/eis/supplemental‐filing‐3‐new

MHBY Correction to previous statement about no notification from KHLP about Supplemental Filing#3: There was an email sent on July 20th. Hard copies received by Participants Aug 1, 2013

July 26, 2013 MBHY sent hard copy of updated Supplemental Filings # 2 to participants

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/eis/supplemental‐filing‐2‐new‐2

MBHY

July 24, 2013 MBHY filed 13 outstanding IR reponses regarding Manitoba Wildlands Irs (first batch 3:15pm)

http://keeyask.com/wp/wp‐content/uploads/2013/07/CEC‐Round‐1‐Web‐Version‐July‐24‐2‐pm.pdf

MBHY Second Batch of outstanding IRs have been added to the Keeyask website. There are still 13 outstanding Irs. Submission of round 2 IRs is two weeks after the date of each rd 1 IR response.


Date Description URL Source NotesJuly 15, 2013 CEC deadline for MBHY responses to

round 1 IRs CEC MBHY provided 45 days to respond to

round 1 IRs from CEC and participants

July 15, 2013 Cumulative Effects Assessment Summary (CEC RD 1‐ IR‐0020)

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐new/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐rd‐1

MBHY Found in the Reposnse to Information Requests‐CEC Round 1

July 15, 2013 MBHY fails to answer MWL IRs 61‐68 (CEC RD 1‐ IR‐0020)

CEC Participants

CEC Secretary adjusts timetable as all participants need all IR reponses MWL will be completed

July 15, 2013 MBHY submits Responses to round #1 Information Requests , filed by CEC and participants

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐new/responses‐to‐information‐requests‐cec‐rd‐1

MBHY Not yet on the Public Registry

July 13, 2013 MBHY submits updates of EIS Supplemental Filings round #2

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/eis/supplemental‐filing‐2‐new‐2

MBHY Updates to Project Description Information and Caribou Sections

July 13,2013 MBHY submits two outstanding responses to Requests for Additional Info from TAC and Public Reviews Round #2

http://keeyask.com/wp/wp‐content/uploads/2013/05/Responses‐to‐Request‐for‐Additional‐Information‐from‐TAC‐Public‐Reviewers‐Round‐2‐secured.pdf

MBHY CEAA‐0014, EC‐0026, EC‐0027, EC‐0031 are now complete. Not in public registry yet (including previous additions on July 2,2013)


Date Description URL Source NotesJuly 2, 2013 MBHY submits two outstanding

responses to Requests for Additional Info from TAC and Public Reviews Round #2

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/response‐to‐requests‐for‐information/response‐to‐requests‐for‐additional‐information‐round‐2

MBHY not on public Registry yet (July 2,2013)

June 28, 2013 MBHY Keeyask Generation Project posts Preliminary Monitoring Plans on Keeyask website


MBHY These Preliminary Monitoring Plans are not yet on the Public Registry

June 18 , 2013 CEC emails participants about providing binders and CDs with the Responses to Round #1 of IRs

CEC Response delivery Date has not yet released

June 4, 2013 York Factory Cree Nation (YFCN) submits 1st batch of IRS to MBHY

YFCN 1st batch contained 13 IRs.

June 3, 2013 CEC submits 8th batch of IRs to MBHY CEC 8th batch contained 12 IRs for a total of 90 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 Pimicikamak First Nation (PCN) submits 3rd bactch of IRs to MBHY

PCN 3rd batch contained 2 IRs, for a total of 8 IRs submitted.

May 31, 2013 PCN submits 2nd batch of IRs to Manitoba Hydro (MBHY)

PCN 2nd batch contained 3 IRs, for a total of 6 IRs submitted


Date Description URL Source NotesMay 31, 2013 PCN submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY PCN 1st batch contained 3 IRs.

May 31, 2013 Manitoba Metis Federation (MMF) submits 2nd batch of IRS to MBHY

MMF IR about the resource economy. 2nd batch contained 1 IR, for a total of 39 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 Consumers Association of Canada (CAC) submits 4th batch of IRs to MBHY

CAC 4th batch contained 15 IRs, for a total of 110 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 CAC submits 3rd batch of IRs to MBHY CAC 3rd batch contained 19 IRs, for a total of 94 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 7th batch of IRs to MBHY

Peguis 7th batch contained 4 IRs, for a total of 47 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 Manitoba Wildlands (MWL) submits 5th batch of IRs to MBHY

MWL 5th batch contained 3 IRs, for a total of 86 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 MWL submits 4th batch of IRs to MBHY

MWL 4th batch contained 22 IRs, for a total of 83 IRs submitted


Date Description URL Source NotesMay 31, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 6th batch

of IRs to MBHYPeguis 6th batch contained 4 IRs, for a total

of 43 IRs submitted



May 31, 2013 MWL submits 3rd batch of IRs to MBHY

MWL 3rd batch contained 13 IRs, for a total of 60 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 MWL submits 2nd batch of IRs to MBHY

MWL 2nd batch contained 24 IRs, for a total of 47 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 CAC submits 3rd batch of IRs to MBHY CAC 3rd batch contained 8 IRs, for a total of 74 IRs submitted




Date Description URL Source NotesMay 31, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 3rd batch

of IRs to MBHYPeguis 3rd batch contained 8 IRs, for a total

of 23 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 CAC submits 2nd batch of IRs to MBHY CAC IRs addressing adaptive environment management. 2nd batch contained 5 IRs, for a total of 65 IRs submitted

May 31, 2013 CEC deadline for round 1 Information Requests (IRs) to MBHY

CEC IRs are submitted by CEC and participants to MBHY requesting additional information on issues identified within the EIS and Supporting Volume materials

May 30, 2013 MMF submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY

MMF 1st batch contained 38 IRs.

May 30, 2013 MWL submits 1st batch of IRS to MBHY

MWL 1st batch contained 23 IRs.


Date Description URL Source NotesMay 30, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 2nd batch

of IRs to MBHYPeguis 2nd batch contained 9 IRs, for a total

of 15 IRs submitted

May 30, 2013 Peguis First Nation submits 1st batch of IRS to MBHY

Peguis Total of 6 IRs submitted

May 30, 2013 CEC submits 7th batch of IRs to MBHY CEC 7th batch contained 9 IRs, for a total of 77 IRs submitted

May 29, 2013 CAC submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY CAC Total of 60 IRs submitted

May 26, 2013 CEC submits 6th batch of IRs to MBHY CEC 6th batch contained 12 IRs, for a total of 66 IRs submitted

May 23, 2013 MBHY Keeyask Generation Project round 3 ‐Public Engagement Program Winnipeg open house

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/public‐involvement/current‐public‐involvement‐events

MBHY MBHY conducting round 3 of the Keeyask Generation Project Public Engagement Program


Date Description URL Source NotesMay 23, 2013 CEC submits 5th batch of IRs to MBHY CEC IRs addressing mercury monitoring,

predictions, analysis, geographic limits, etc. 5th batch contained 7 IRS for a total of 54 IRs submitted

May 20, 2013 CFLGC submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY, containing 17 individual IRs.

CFLGC Total of 17 IRs submitted by participants

May 16, 2013 MBHY Keeyask Generation Project round 3 ‐Public Engagement Program Thompson open house

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/public‐involvement/current‐public‐involvement‐events

MBHY MBHY conducting round 3 of the Keeyask Generation Project Public Engagement Program

May 15, 2013 CEC circulates 3rd draft of CEC participant contact list

CEC Updated to include new participant, Pimicikamak Okimowin

May 9, 2013 CEC circulates 2nd draft of CEC participant contact list

CEC Updated to include new participant Kaweechiwasihk Inninuwuk

May 9, 2013 CEC submits 4rd batch of IRs to MBHY, containing 5 individual IRs.

CEC IRs focus on bioaccumulation of mercury in wildlife. 4th batch contains 5 IRs for a total of 47 IRs submitted

May 8, 2013 CEC submits 3rd batch of IRs to MBHY, including 8 individual IRs.

CEC 3rd batch contained 8 IRs, for a total of 42 IRs submitted


Date Description URL Source NotesMay 7, 2013 CEC submits single IR to MBHY CEC IR about cummulative effects to First

Nation communities. Total of 35 IRs submitted by CEC

May 3, 2013 MCWS posts MBHY response to round#1 of Keeyask Transmission Project Supplemtnatal Information Request by TAC and Public review

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5614keeyask_transmission/ktp‐tac‐public‐rd‐1ir‐responses.pdf

MCWS The request by TAC and Public review was forwarded by MB‐EAB, on January 18th 2013, to MBHY (MBHY response was released April 26, 2013)

May 1, 2013 CEC submits single IR to MBHY CEC IR about health risk assessment. Total of 34 IRs submitted by CEC

Apr‐May, 2013 MBHY conducts round 3 of Public Engagement Program

http://keeyask.com/wp/wp‐content/uploads/2012/01/Keeyask‐Newsletter‐R3_WEB.pdf

MBHY MBHY meets with public to review Keeyask Generation Project Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) (Posted on KHLP website).

http://keeyask.com/wp/wp‐content/uploads/2012/11/Responses‐to‐Request‐for‐Additional‐Information‐from‐TAC‐Public‐Reviewers‐Round‐2.pdf

Posted on KHLP Website April 29, 2013

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5550keeyask/responses‐tac‐round‐2/responses_tac_round_2.pdf

Posted on Manitoba Public Registry May 24, 2013

Apr 26, 2013 MBHY submits responses to round #2 requests for additional information from TAC and pulic reviewers

MBHY


Date Description URL Source Noteshttp://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/eis

Updates to Keeyask Generation EIS materials submitted by MBHY (Posted on KHLP website April, 2013).


Posted on Manitoba Public Registry on May 24, 2013


Preliminary EnvPP is incomplete, sections required (Posted on KHLP website April 26, 2013).


Posted on Manitoba Public Registry on May 24, 2013

Apr 23, 2013 CEC submits 2nd batch of IRs to MBHY CEC 2nd batch containing 14 IRs, for a total of 33 IRs submitted

Apr 22, 2013 CEC submits 1st batch of IRs to MBHY, containing 19 individual IRs.

CEC 1st batch of IRs dealt with a variety of issues. Total of 19 IRs submitted by CEC

Apr 26, 2013 MBHY submits Keeyask Generation Project EIS supplemental filing #1 to Manitoba Conservation & Water Stewardship (MCWS)

MBHY

Apr 26, 2013 MBHY submits Preliminary Keeyask Environmental Protection Program

(EnvPP) for review by public

MBHY


Date Description URL Source NotesApr 18, 2013 CEC circulates CEC pre‐hearing

meeting reportCEC Pre‐hearing meeting held on April 11,

2013 at the Winnipeg convention Centre

Apr 12, 2013 CEC circulates transcripts from CEC pre‐hearing meeting

CEC Pre‐hearing meeting held on April 11, 2013 at the Winnipeg Convention Centre

Apr 12, 2013 1st draft of CEC participant contact list circulated

CEC

Apr 11, 2013 Clean Environment Commission (CEC) Keeyask Generation Project pre‐hearing meeting

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/resource/hearings/39/AGENDA Pre‐hearing April 11 2013 .pdf

CEC Introduction of CEC hearing participants, CEC panel and CEC process for Keeyask Generation Project

Apr, 2013 http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/preliminary‐environmental‐protection‐program

EnvPP contains 15 sections, some of which are incomplete. Posted on KHLP/MBHY website April 2013


Posted on Manitoba Public Registry May 24, 2013

MBHYMBHY posts Preliminary Environmental Protection Progam (EnvPP) on KHLP/MBHY website.


Date Description URL Source NotesFeb 15, 2013 CEC Participant Assistance Application

Package (PAP) duehttp://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39 ‐ 2

CEC Application for participant funding to participate in CEC hearings for Keeyask Generation Project

Feb 13,2013 Environmental Protection Operations Division‐Environment Canada, submits addendum to round #1 supplemental information requests to MBHY

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5550keeyask/part_9.pdf

Environment Canada

Addendum to Fedreal comments, submitted February 19, 2013

Feb 2013 MB‐Gov EAB posts Keeyask Transmission Environment Act Proposal (EAP) Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) and public review comments online

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5614keeyask_transmission/index.html

MB‐Gov EAB Request Responses to TAC Public comments round#1 from MBHY

Jan 18, 2013 Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) and Public Review request for Supplemental Information in Keeyask Transmision Project round #1 to MBHY


MB‐EAB This request was forwarded by the MB‐EAB to MBHY This request is currently not found on MB public registries website

Jan 7, 2013 MB‐Gov EAB deadline for public comments on Keeyask Transmission Project Environment Act Proposal (EAP)


MB‐Gov EAB Comments submitted to MB‐Gov EAB

Dec 21, 2012 Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA) deadline for public comments on Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects ‐ Environmental Effects Summary

CEAA Comments submitted to CEAA


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 28, 2012 MB‐Gov EAB advertises public

comment period for Keeyask Transmission Project EAP

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5614keeyask_transmission/ad_5614.pdf

MB‐Gov EAB Advertised public notice in Thompson Citizen and WFP

Nov 21, 2012 CEAA invites public comments on MBHY Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects ‐ Environmental Effects Summary

http://www.ceaa‐acee.gc.ca/050/document‐eng.cfm?document=83603

CEAA Environmental Effects Summary based on Keeyask Generation EIS. Comments submitted to CEAA

Nov 21, 2012 MBHY submits Keeyask Transmission Project Environmental Assessment Report (ESR) and Technical Reports to MCWS and CEAA


MBHY Keeyask Transmission ESR and Technical Reports available through Public Registry and CEAA website

Nov 19, 2012 MBHY submits responses to round #1 requests for additional information from the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) and public reviews


MBHY Keeyask Generation EIS TAC and public comments forwarded by MB‐Gov EAB

Nov 16,2012 CEC hearings for MBHY Keeyask Generation Project announced by Manitoba Conservation and Water Stewardship (MCWS)

http://news.gov.mb.ca/news/index.html?item=15562

MCWS MCWS announces CEC hearing. Confirms province has initiated a Crown‐Aboriginal consultatation process

Nov 14, 2012 Minister of MCWS requests Clean Environment Commission (CEC) hearings for Keeyask Generation Project, includes terms of reference

http://www.cecmanitoba.ca/hearings/index.cfm?hearingid=39

MCWS MCWS Minister Gord Mackintosh sends letter to CEC Chair, directing CEC hold public hearings for proposed Keeyask Generation Project. Terms of reference for the CEC hearings enclosed


Date Description URL Source NotesSept 20, 2012 MB‐Gov EAB TAC and Public comment

deadline on Keeyask Generation Project EIS

MB‐Gov EAB Comments due to MB‐Gov EAB

July 14, 2012 MB‐Gov EAB ad notice of Keeyask Generation Project EIS review in Winnipeg Free Press (and other publications July 14‐21)

http://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/eal/registries/5550keeyask/5550_eis_ad.pdf

MB‐Gov EAB Notice posted in WFP and various other publications

July 6, 2012 MBHY submits Keeyask Generation Project EIS and Supporting Volumes to MB‐Gov EAB and CEAA

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/eis

MBHY MB‐Gov EAB to review and approve EIS submissions (Posted on KHLP website, July 2, 2012)

Apr 3, 2012 CEAA Funding Review Committee's Report on Aboriginal Funding Envelope


CEAA Participant Funding Program (PFP)

Mar 28, 2012 CEAA deadline for public comments on the Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects draft EIS guidelines


CEAA Written comments submitted to CEAA


Date Description URL Source NotesFeb ‐ May 2012 no exact date

MBHY conducts round 2 of Public Engagement Program

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/public‐involvement/public‐involvement‐documents

MBHY MBHY revisited Aboriginal and Non‐Aboriginal communities in northern Manitoba and other potentially affected areas. MBHY also met with interested organizations contacted from round 1Feb 29, 2012 CEAA public notice of comment period

to review draft EIS guidelines document


CEAA CEAA annouces public comment period to review draft EIS guidelines document

Feb 29, 2012 CEAA Draft EIS Guidelines for MBHY Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects

http://www.ceaa‐acee.gc.ca/050/documents‐eng.cfm?evaluation=64144

CEAA Document prepared by CEAA

Feb 29, 2012 CEAA Participant Funding Program Report


CEAA CEAA released the Participant Funding Program‐Regular Funding Envelope‐Funding Review Committees Report Entitled "Allocation of Federal Funds for the Environmental Assessment of the Keeyask Generation Project"

Feb 29, 2012 CEAA announces recipients of Federal funding for participation in the Keeyask Generation and Transmission projects Environmental Assessment


CEAA


Date Description URL Source NotesFeb,2012 MCWS posts Keeyask Generation

Project Environment Act Proposal (EAP) and Final Scoping Document (SD) TAC and public comments online


MCWS TAC and public comments posted on Manitoba public registry for final SD

Jan 31, 2012 Public comment deadline on the conduct of the CEAA Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects and conduct of Comprehensive study


CEAA CEAA review of the Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects, determined that project is subject to Comprehensive Study List Regulations and an Environmental Assessment

Jan 31, 2012 CEAA federal funding application deadline for Keeyask Generation Project


CEAA Application submitted to CEAA

Jan 31, 2012 CEAA and MCWS Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects EAP and Final SD public comments deadline‐ dates are listed in the public advertisement for Notice of Environment Act Proposal


CEAA MCWS

Comments submitted to both CEAA and MCWS. CEAA requesting comments on Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects. MCWS requesting comments only on Keeyask Generation Project

Jan 1, 2012 CEAA and MCWS notice of EAP and Final SD in Winnipeg Free Press (WFP) and other publications ‐ Indicated in the advertisement for Notice of Environment Act Proposal


CEAA MCWS

Joint CEAA and MCWS deadline for EAP and SD comments. All reviews under the Environment Act must be advertsied


Date Description URL Source NotesDec 15, 2011 CEAA federal funding announced for

Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects Environmental Assessment


CEAA

Dec 15, 2011 CEAA invites public comments on the Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects and conduct of the CEAA Comprehensive Study


CEAA CEAA background document about Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects to assisted public review

Dec 15, 2011 CEAA releases Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects Background Information Document

http://www.ceaa‐acee.gc.ca/050/documents/53536/53536E.pdf

CEAA Background document to assist public review of projects

Dec 13, 2011 CEAA public notice ‐ Commencement of Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects Environmental Assessment. Mention of Keeyask Infrastructure


CEAA CEAA announced that an Environmental Assessment for Keeyask Generation and Transmission projects was required, pursuant to the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act

Dec 9, 2011 MBHY files Keeyask Generation Project Draft SD to CEAA and MCWS for public review


MBHY Draft SD seek to lay out the requirements for Environmental Impact Statement

Dec 9, 2011 MBHY submits Environment Act Proposal Form (EAP) to MCWS for public review


MBHY All applications for a Manitoba Environment Act license begin with an Environment Act Proposal Form (EAP), submitted to MCWS


Date Description URL Source NotesNov 29, 2011 CEAA announces commencement of

Comprehensive Study of Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects


CEAA CEAA begins comprehensive study of the Keeyask Generation Project, pursuant to Canadian Environmental Assessment Act

Aug 31, 2011 CEAA receives Keeyask Generation and Transmission Projects description from MBHY


CEAA CEAA receives Keeyask Generation project description from MBHY, to determine if Comprehensive Study and Environmental Assessment should be conducted

May 9, 2011 MBHY submits Draft Description of Keeyask Generation Project to Major Projects Management Office (MPMO) of Natural Resources Canada

Not available online MPMO Document assists MPMO in fulfilling federal mandate of providing federal coordination, management and accountability for major resource projects

May 2008 MBHY initiates round 1 of Keeyask Generation Project Public Involvement Program

http://keeyask.com/wp/the‐project/environmental‐assessment‐process/public‐involvement/public‐involvement‐documents

MBHY MBHY required to engage with the public to seek feedback on the Keeyask Generation Project


Date Description URL Source NotesAcronyms: CAC = Consumers Association of

Canada (Manitoba) CEAA = Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency CEC = Clean Environment Comission CFLGC = Concerned Fox Lake Grassroots Citizens EAP= Environmental Act Proposal EIS = Env. Impact Statement EnvPP = Environmental Protection Program ESR = Environmental Study Report FLCN = Fox Lake Cree Nation IRs = Information Requests/Responses KHLP = Keeyask Hydropower Limited Partnership KK = Kqweechiwasihk Inninuwuk (York Factory Cree Nation) MCWS = Manitoba Conservation and Waterstewardship

MB‐Gov = Manitoba Government MB‐Gov EAB = Environmental Approvals Branch MBHY = Manitoba Hydro MMF = Manitoba Metis Federation MWL = Manitoba Wildlands NFAAT = Needs For And Alternatives To Peguis = Peguis First Nation PILC = Public Interest Law Centre SD = Scoping Document TAC =Technical Advisory Committee TCN = Tataskeyak Cree Nation WLCN = War Lake Cree Nation WEA = Whelan Enns Associates Inc. WFP = Winnipeg Free Press YFCN = York Factory Cree Nation