marie curie - iof application · 2014. 10. 21. · introduction the application aftermath about me...

IntroductionThe application

Aftermath

About meThe projectTimeline

Marie Curie - IOF Application

Mierk Schwabe

Max-Planck-Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Garching

Marie Curie Workshop

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Marie Curie - IOF Application 1 of 22

Aftermath

Outline

1 IntroductionAbout meThe projectTimeline

2 The applicationWritingEvaluationResult

3 Aftermath

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

About me

did diploma thesis, PhDat MPE, complexplasma groupsince 12/2009: postdocat MPE, doing “sciencemanagement” of PK-3Plus experiment on ISSgoing to UC Berkeleyend of year with IOFfellowship, return hostMPE

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

About me

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

About me

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

onsetofcoop‐era-vebehavior

fluidsonmeso‐

scopicscale

hydro‐dynamicalinstabili-es

transi-ontohydro‐dynamics

ICPALInves-ga-onof

Coopera-vePhenomenaontheAtomis-cLevel

ComplexPlasmas(MPE)

ComputerSimula-ons(UCBerkeley)

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Timeline

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Introduction to host

introduction to host via group leader MPE

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

WritingEvaluationResult

Outline

3 Aftermath

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Writing

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

General things

be clear, understandablefor non-specialists, usediagrams, picturesstress important points inboldwrite what they ask aboutuse refereesget other proposals: MC,grant proposals; use thehelp available, e.g. EUoffice

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

General things

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

General things

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

General things

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

General things

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Scientific and technological quality

clear research objectives, tasksintroduction to methods,experimental procedures,methodologywhy can it work? both methods andplaceswhy it is new and relevant?

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Training

what will you learn during thefellowship?why is this important for you/yourcareer?why can the hosts teach you whatyou need to learn at this stage inyour career?

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

don’t be humble, find good words todescribe what you know and can doand how you showed that this is truedon’t forget to mention prizes youwon, e.g., poster prizes atconferenceslists of publications, presentations atconferences (invited talks?)any outreach activities (day of opendoors, girls’ day), teaching?

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

!"#$%&% !"#$%'% !"#$%(%

)*%+"$,"-"!% ./0%

$"1$2345678%"91"$6:"7;#-%$"<4-;<%

"91"$6:"7;<%;2%;"<;%1$"365=27<%

#336=27#-%;$#67678>%;"#5?678@%527A"$"75"<@%B%

1$"365=27<%A2$%A4;4$"%"91"$6:"7;<%

;$#67678%67%52:C%

14;"$%<6:4-#=27<%

;$#7<A"$%2A%,72D-"38">%<41"$E6<627%2A%

<;43"7;<@%527A"$"75"<@%52--#F2$#=27<%

673"1"73"7;%<6:4-#=27<%

!"#$%&>%G6:4-#=27%2A%

"91"$6:"7;<%27%

?!3$23!7#:65%67<;#F6-6="<%%

#73%:"<2<52165%<!<;":<%

!"#$%'>%H7E"<=8#=27%2A%%

27<";%2A%5221"$#=E"%

F"?#E62$%#73%;$#7<6=27%%

;2%?!3$23!7#:65<%

!"#$%(>%*27I$:#=27%%

2A%1$"365=27<%2A%%

74:"$65#-%<6:4-#=27<%%

D6;?%"91"$6:"7;<%

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Evaluation Summary Report

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

S & T Quality

Strengths of the proposal:The scientific quality is very good with appropriateresearch methodology.The state-of-the-art is very well described and theresearch objectives are accurately outlined.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

S & T Quality

Strengths of the proposal:The scientific quality is very good with appropriateresearch methodology.The state-of-the-art is very well described and theresearch objectives are accurately outlined.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

S & T Quality

Strengths of the proposal:The research goal is interdisciplinary and has potential tobring advances to the state-of-the-art.The project is timely and relevant for the field of plasmaphysics.Both the outgoing and the return hosts have a very goodexpertise in the field of complex plasmas.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

S & T Quality

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

S & T Quality

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

S & T Quality

Weaknesses of the proposal:none listed

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Training

Strengths of the proposal:the research training objectives for the researcher havebeen well described.The additional scientific training and complementary skillsdevelopment are very good.The expertise of both hosts in training, mentoring/tutoringresearchers is demonstrated.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Training

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Training

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Training

Weaknesses of the proposal:Insufficiently well described training at the return host.The supervisor at the outgoing host has administrativeposition which limits the ability to provide tutoring.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Training

Weaknesses of the proposal:Insufficiently well described training at the return host.The supervisor at the outgoing host has administrativeposition which limits the ability to provide tutoring.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

Strengths of the proposal:The applicant has a very good research experience in thefield of complex plasmas.The applicant has very good research results includingpublication record, participation at internationalconferences ant outreach activities.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

Strengths of the proposal:The applicant has a very good research experience in thefield of complex plasmas.The applicant has very good research results includingpublication record, participation at internationalconferences ant outreach activities.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

Strengths of the proposal:The independent thinking and leadership qualities havebeen demonstrated.The applicant’s skills and experience are suitable for theproject proposed.The applicant has well forseen measures to reach theprofessional maturity.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Researcher

Weaknesses of the proposal:none listed

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

Strengths of the proposal:The infrastructure at the outgoing and the return host isvery good.Both host institutions have long experience in internationalcollaborations.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

Strengths of the proposal:The infrastructure at the outgoing and the return host isvery good.Both host institutions have long experience in internationalcollaborations.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

Strengths of the proposal:The work plan is very good.The implementation and management of the project aregood at both host institutions.The risks and intellectual properties are discussed.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Implementation

Weaknesses of the proposal:A practical arrangement for the implementation at theoutgoing host where the close collaboration is basedthrough meetings on a monthly basis is insufficient.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Impact

Strengths of the proposal:The applicant will have an opportunity to gaincompetences in plasma diagnostics which will have goodcontribution to career development.There is a very good potential for creating long termcollaboration.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Impact

Strengths of the proposal:The applicant will have an opportunity to gaincompetences in plasma diagnostics which will have goodcontribution to career development.There is a very good potential for creating long termcollaboration.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Impact

Strengths of the proposal:Benefit of the mobility to the ERA is high, the the EUresearcher will move to one of the best places in US.The mobility is genuine as the applicant will work in asignificantly different geographical and workingenvironment.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Impact

Strengths of the proposal:Benefit of the mobility to the ERA is high, the the EUresearcher will move to one of the best places in US.The mobility is genuine as the applicant will work in asignificantly different geographical and workingenvironment.

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Impact

Weaknesses of the proposal:none listed(saw in other proposal: not written that plan is to gettenured position after fellowship)

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Total Score

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Total Score

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Outline

3 Aftermath

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Afterwards

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Summary

show yourself and the hosts in thebest light!be detailed!write a good proposal!

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Summary

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Summary

Mierk Schwabe MPE

Aftermath

Summary

Good luck!Mierk Schwabe MPE

marie curie - iof application · 2014. 10. 21. · introduction the application aftermath about me...

Documents