mohammed amin, 31 (jordan) | raouf mankaryous, 32
TRANSCRIPT
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan)
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan)
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Breach of Privacy !Date: March 5, 2005 3:32 AM ESTJust wondering how come my name is listed in the site.. when I am alive and featured in teh recent article on computerworld.com. Could u please explainregards, Rajiv DabhadkarALIVE and Rocking in India
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle,
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Breach of Privacy !Date: March 5, 2005 4:26:31 AM ESTI would like to check the credibility of the database of names that you have in your site. And your method of authenticating the same before puttign information online. I have found reference to my name in the database. And would like to communicate my dislike towards the same. I am the founder of an organization of software technology workers in America and though in India presently to work build the organization basics, I’d very much like to arrive in the US. However, am also in communication with individuals in Washington DC , and hence finding my name amongst those dissappeared IN America is most humiliating. As a reference, I have been featured in the LATEST issue of Computer World (print as well as online) http://www.computerworld.com and will further the stake to my credibility via documenting emails to those concerned within North America. Looking forward to having my name removed from the database and an early response Hurt deeplyRajiv Dabhadkar
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) |
From: Visible CollectiveSubject: Re: Breach of Privacy !Date: March 5, 2005 9:17:46 AM ESTHi RajivThe list of names came from Migration Policy Institute’s list of men detained since 9/11 Most likely it is another Rajiv. Have you ever been to the US? If not, it is obviously someone else as it lists there place of domicile in the US as well.-Naeem on behalf of Visible Collective
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE,
From: Visible CollectiveSubject: Re: Breach of Privacy !Date: March 5, 2005 10:25:05 AM ESTMr. RajivIt is obviously someone else with the same name as this person is listed as being 32 years old, and living in New Jersey prior to detention. If you have never been to US, it is obviously not you. By the way, your name is not so uncommon so entirely feasible that there is someone else with same name. The source for all names in the database is a report by MPI:America’s Challenge: Domestic Security, Civil Liberties, and National Unity After September 11Migration Policy Institute, 1400 16th Street NW, Suite 300, Washington DC 20036
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM,
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Re: I am ALIVEDate: March 5, 2005 11:38:48 AM ESTNo..I havent been detained ever. I arrived back here with my own free will. Could i receive the contact person at the Migration Policy Institute. I’d like to recify this at source. Your effort will allow me to set a right course in life.regardsRajiv
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH,
From: Visible CollectiveSubject: Re: Breach of Privacy !
Date: March 5, 2005 11:45:19 AM ESTHi RajivThe phone # was listed in the other e-mail I sent. If they take you off, let me know and we will take it off our website as well. But just to be clear, we are not for any closed borders. We are a group of artists and activists who have been doing public art interventions around post 9/11 detention and profiling. The list is part of a lightbox and wall print we created for a meditation on the enormity of the security panic led civil liberties breakdown. If anything, we are trying to start conversations that would make these sorts of profiling unacceptable. Our project would never be “used” to keep anyone out, the opposite in fact (if anything).
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine)
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Re: Breach of Privacy !Date: March 5, 2005 12:03:51 PM ESTSir;Would you mind doing a search under my name on google.com“Rajiv Dabhadkar”The 9/11 incident has not only affected me .. not this immigration related thing againI wanted a resolve, I began http://www.nostops.orgI Need to find the email address of the final point of contact... Could u please help..Rajiv
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine) | THAR ABDELJABER, 30 (Palestine) | DIB ANEEF SHIHADEH, 75, Illinois (Jordan) | FAROUK ALI-HAIMOUD, 22, Detroit, Michigan (Algeria) | OMAR SHISHANI, 47, Dearborn, Michigan (Chechnya) NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | BASAM NAHSHAL, Tri-state Area (Yemen) | NAIM SHAHAB, 27, Lindenhurst, New York (Afghanistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDI,
From: Visible CollectiveSubject: Re: Breach of Privacy !Date: March 5, 2005 6:03:48 PM ESTHello Rajiv, We did some research and now understand how your name is on the list. USA TODAY ran a story “Tech Workers Feel The Heat” (10/17/01) where your case was mentioned: Rajiv Dabhadkar was three blocks from his New Jersey home on Oct. 2 when police motioned his car to the
side of the road. Dabhadkar, a computer programmer from India here on an H-1B visa, was handcuffed and
held in jail for several hours. When released, he was fined $250 for an unpaid parking ticket. Though authorities
gave him no reason for the seemingly harsh treatment, Dabhadkar speculates he was hassled because of his
ethnicity. “I’m completely shaken.”....Before his arrest, Dabhadkar worked for 2 years on short-term projects for
several firms, including Merrill Lynch and AT&T. He says office relations became more strained as economic
woes mounted. Co-workers started leaving him “out of the loop” on decisions. “They treated me as though I
was non-existent because I wasn’t American,” he says....The heightened security and anxiety have taken an
emotional toll on workers like Dabhadkar, who has lived in the USA for 10 years, has a family and is looking for
work. “What should I do?” he asks. “I’m at my wits’ end.” There is also a photo of you, so it seems it was with your permission. When MPI was compiling list of people who were detained after 9/11, your name made it on the list based on this. But just to be clear, our project opposes these arbitrary detentions. So the purpose of including you in the project is a positive, not a negative.
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine) | THAR ABDELJABER, 30 (Palestine) | DIB ANEEF SHIHADEH, 75, Illinois (Jordan) | FAROUK ALI-HAIMOUD, 22, Detroit, Michigan (Algeria) | OMAR SHISHANI, 47, Dearborn, Michigan (Chechnya) NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | BASAM NAHSHAL, Tri-state Area (Yemen) | NAIM SHAHAB, 27, Lindenhurst, New York (Afghanistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDI, 44, Alexandria, Virginia (Somalia) | ARKAN ALANDON, 29, Dearborn, Michigan (Iraq) | SYED ALI, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ZINEDDINE TIROUDA, 37, San Diego, California (Algeria) | HANY IBRAHIM, 26, Brooklyn, New York (Egypt) NABIL MOKHTAR FERCHICHI, 21, Florida (Tunisia) | SYED AMJAD ALI JAFFRI | IRFAN
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Apologies from me !Date: March 20, 2005 5:16:41 AM ESTRespected Sir;I apologise for having written a few emails to you in bad taste. You were absolutely right in your approach of the web site, and with the events folloing in my personal life here.. a reference made on gogle.com was actually a refernce made by me in my own personal life.. and it was traumatic... just that my mind chose to relive the bad memories ..! And I got uncomfortable at wrote those emails to you.Please accept my apologies .. I was being too self-centric in my feelings..!Deep regards and with sincerityRajiv Dabhadkar
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine) | THAR ABDELJABER, 30 (Palestine) | DIB ANEEF SHIHADEH, 75, Illinois (Jordan) | FAROUK ALI-HAIMOUD, 22, Detroit, Michigan (Algeria) | OMAR SHISHANI, 47, Dearborn, Michigan (Chechnya) NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | BASAM NAHSHAL, Tri-state Area (Yemen) | NAIM SHAHAB, 27, Lindenhurst, New York (Afghanistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDI, 44, Alexandria, Virginia (Somalia) | ARKAN ALANDON, 29, Dearborn, Michigan (Iraq) | SYED ALI, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ZINEDDINE TIROUDA, 37, San Diego, California (Algeria) | HANY IBRAHIM, 26, Brooklyn, New York (Egypt) NABIL MOKHTAR FERCHICHI, 21, Florida (Tunisia) | SYED AMJAD ALI JAFFRI | IRFAN AHMED, 39, Torrington, Connecticut (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, St. Louis, Missouri (Saudi Arabia) | AMYNAH LAKHANI, Louisiana (Pakistan) | ABDOUL SALAM ACHOU, 37, New Jersey (Syria) | NAME UNAVAILABLE | DENIZ BOZKURT, 32, Tri-state Area (Turkey) | MUSTAFA ABU JDAI, 28, Tyler, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, California (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 46, Wisconsin (Iran) | MOHAMED DESOUKY, 28, Milford, Massachusetts (Egypt)
From: Visible CollectiveSubject: Re: Apologies from me !Date: March 20, 2005 10:15 AM ESTHi RajivThat is ok, no need for apology.But I am thinking maybe we should discuss the whole experience in wider context in public. You being tech-savvy were able to find the website, the other people who were caught in this unfair crackdown don’t even know about any other recourses or representations of their names in media they may or may not want. Perhaps we can have an e-mail conversation, which could become an essay in the future.
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Request for responseDate: November 17, 2005 12:57:20 AM ESTSir;We have had communicated earlier....I wish to clear my name of those detained in America..Who should i contact .i am in India presently... and with a choice..
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine) | THAR ABDELJABER, 30 (Palestine) | DIB ANEEF SHIHADEH, 75, Illinois (Jordan) | FAROUK ALI-HAIMOUD, 22, Detroit, Michigan (Algeria) | OMAR SHISHANI, 47, Dearborn, Michigan (Chechnya) NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | BASAM NAHSHAL, Tri-state Area (Yemen) | NAIM SHAHAB, 27, Lindenhurst, New York (Afghanistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDI, 44, Alexandria, Virginia (Somalia) | ARKAN ALANDON, 29, Dearborn, Michigan (Iraq) | SYED ALI, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ZINEDDINE TIROUDA, 37, San Diego, California (Algeria) | HANY IBRAHIM, 26, Brooklyn, New York (Egypt) NABIL MOKHTAR FERCHICHI, 21, Florida (Tunisia) | SYED AMJAD ALI JAFFRI | IRFAN AHMED, 39, Torrington, Connecticut (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, St. Louis, Missouri (Saudi Arabia) | AMYNAH LAKHANI, Louisiana (Pakistan) | ABDOUL SALAM ACHOU, 37, New Jersey (Syria) | NAME UNAVAILABLE | DENIZ BOZKURT, 32, Tri-state Area (Turkey) | MUSTAFA ABU JDAI, 28, Tyler, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, California (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 46, Wisconsin (Iran) | MOHAMED DESOUKY, 28, Milford, Massachusetts (Egypt) SHARIF KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | RAZA AHMAD, New Jersey (Pakistan) | MOHAMMED YOUSSEF, Evansville, Indiana | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s (Saudi Arabia) | ODED ELLNER, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | AHMAD ALI | NASSER ABUALI | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | MAZEN
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine) | THAR ABDELJABER, 30 (Palestine) | DIB ANEEF SHIHADEH, 75, Illinois (Jordan) | FAROUK ALI-HAIMOUD, 22, Detroit, Michigan (Algeria) | OMAR SHISHANI, 47, Dearborn, Michigan (Chechnya) NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | BASAM NAHSHAL, Tri-state Area (Yemen) | NAIM SHAHAB, 27, Lindenhurst, New York (Afghanistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDI, 44, Alexandria, Virginia (Somalia) | ARKAN ALANDON, 29, Dearborn, Michigan (Iraq) | SYED ALI, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ZINEDDINE TIROUDA, 37, San Diego, California (Algeria) | HANY IBRAHIM, 26, Brooklyn, New York (Egypt) NABIL MOKHTAR FERCHICHI, 21, Florida (Tunisia) | SYED AMJAD ALI JAFFRI | IRFAN AHMED, 39, Torrington, Connecticut (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, St. Louis, Missouri (Saudi Arabia) | AMYNAH LAKHANI, Louisiana (Pakistan) | ABDOUL SALAM ACHOU, 37, New Jersey (Syria) | NAME UNAVAILABLE | DENIZ BOZKURT, 32, Tri-state Area (Turkey) | MUSTAFA ABU JDAI, 28, Tyler, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, California (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 46, Wisconsin (Iran) | MOHAMED DESOUKY, 28, Milford, Massachusetts (Egypt) SHARIF KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | RAZA AHMAD, New Jersey (Pakistan) | MOHAMMED YOUSSEF, Evansville, Indiana | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s (Saudi Arabia) | ODED ELLNER, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | AHMAD ALI | NASSER ABUALI | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | MAZEN AL-NAJJAR, 45, Tampa, Florida (Palestine) | MORTADY ELMASRY, 44, Florida | ZAFER AL-ATASI, 32, Nashville, Tennessee (Syria) | JAMIL ALI JAGHMAN, 26, Virginia Beach, Virginia (Yemen) MALEK MOHAMED SEIF, 36 (Djibouti) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 41 (Egypt) | BOB RAJCOOMAR, 55, Lake Worth, Florida (India) | SAMIR AL-MAZAAL, 29 (Iraq) | SAIMA SAIMA, 32 (Pakistan) | NAME
From: Rajiv DabhadkarSubject: Re: Request for responseDate: November 18, 2005 12:18:18 AM ESTI’d very much like to meet up with you. I am in Bombay.What are u involved with wrt the project??
MOHAMMED AMIN, 31 (Jordan) | RAOUF MANKARYOUS, 32, Massachusetts (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23 (Tunisia) | REZA ZAZAI, 25 (Afghanistan) | MUHAMMAD QAYYUM, 58, New York (Pakistan) | FATI AWAD | HANI FATHI | SYED ASIF, 50, Metuchen, New Jersey (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, New Castle, Pennsylvania (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Brooklyn, New York (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, New Jersey (Jordan) | MOHAMMED RAFIQ BUTT, 55, Queens, New York (Pakistan) ALAA KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | MUHAMMAD MADDY, 45, Queens, New York (Egypt) | YASSER FATHI, 30 (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Paterson, New Jersey (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Seattle, Washington (Iraq) | AHMED SALIM DESAI, 40s, Florida (India) | SIDI MOHAMED OULD BAH, 32, Louisville, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | UNSIR HAFEEZ, 24 (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDIRAHMAN KARIYE, 41, Oregon (Somalia) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Egypt) | MEDHAT SHEHTA | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | GURDEEP SINGH WANDER, 48, Washington, New Jersey (India) | TARIQ HUSSAIN, 27, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | MEKKI HAMED MEKKI, 30, Greensboro, North Carolina (Sudan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Tri-state Area (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) HATEF AL-ATABI, 26 (Iraq) | S.M. DURRANI, San Bernadino, California (Pakistan) | HAIDER AL-TAMIMI, 28 (Iraq) | ADHAM AMIN HASSOUN, 40, Sunrise, Florida (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Indiana (Egypt) | MUKKARAM ALI, 25, Oklahoma (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, Tri-state Area (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 50, New York City, New York (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 21, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | OSAMA SEWILAM, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | KHALID BAHAMMANI | MOHAMMAD IMRAN BUTT, 37, Florida (Pakistan) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ABDELMUHSEN MAHMID HAMMAD, 32, New York (Jordan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 29 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | CHOUDRY JAMIL KHAN | MOHAMED NIDHAL KHARBECH, 19, Florida (Tunisia) | SIVAN KURZBERG, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | SOHAIL BASARIA, Baton Rouge, Louisiana (Pakistan) | OSSAMA ABDELALL, 35, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Egypt) | KHALED DARWICH, 21, Tennessee (Egypt) | SAJJAD NASSER, 27 (Pakistan) | SAKHER HAMMAD, 24, Tri-state Area (Jordan) AFNAN KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 22, Tri-state Area (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Turkey) | JAVED HASNAIN, 19, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 25 (Iraq) | NAJMUL HASAN, 33, Winsted, Connecticut (Pakistan) | FAISAL AL-SALMI, 34, Tempe, Arizona (Saudi Arabia) | NABIL SARAMA, 52, St. Petersburg, Florida (Palestine) | THAR ABDELJABER, 30 (Palestine) | DIB ANEEF SHIHADEH, 75, Illinois (Jordan) | FAROUK ALI-HAIMOUD, 22, Detroit, Michigan (Algeria) | OMAR SHISHANI, 47, Dearborn, Michigan (Chechnya) NAME UNAVAILABLE, Kentucky (Mauritania) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 23, Brooklyn, New York (Pakistan) | BASAM NAHSHAL, Tri-state Area (Yemen) | NAIM SHAHAB, 27, Lindenhurst, New York (Afghanistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Bronx, New York (Pakistan) | MOHAMED ABDI, 44, Alexandria, Virginia (Somalia) | ARKAN ALANDON, 29, Dearborn, Michigan (Iraq) | SYED ALI, New York (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (Iraq) | ZINEDDINE TIROUDA, 37, San Diego, California (Algeria) | HANY IBRAHIM, 26, Brooklyn, New York (Egypt) NABIL MOKHTAR FERCHICHI, 21, Florida (Tunisia) | SYED AMJAD ALI JAFFRI | IRFAN AHMED, 39, Torrington, Connecticut (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 35, St. Louis, Missouri (Saudi Arabia) | AMYNAH LAKHANI, Louisiana (Pakistan) | ABDOUL SALAM ACHOU, 37, New Jersey (Syria) | NAME UNAVAILABLE | DENIZ BOZKURT, 32, Tri-state Area (Turkey) | MUSTAFA ABU JDAI, 28, Tyler, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, California (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 46, Wisconsin (Iran) | MOHAMED DESOUKY, 28, Milford, Massachusetts (Egypt) SHARIF KESBEH, Houston, Texas (Palestine) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | RAZA AHMAD, New Jersey (Pakistan) | MOHAMMED YOUSSEF, Evansville, Indiana | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s (Saudi Arabia) | ODED ELLNER, 20s, Weehawken, New Jersey (Israel) | AHMAD ALI | NASSER ABUALI | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Missouri (Israel) | MAZEN AL-NAJJAR, 45, Tampa, Florida (Palestine) | MORTADY ELMASRY, 44, Florida | ZAFER AL-ATASI, 32, Nashville, Tennessee (Syria) | JAMIL ALI JAGHMAN, 26, Virginia Beach, Virginia (Yemen) MALEK MOHAMED SEIF, 36 (Djibouti) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 41 (Egypt) | BOB RAJCOOMAR, 55, Lake Worth, Florida (India) | SAMIR AL-MAZAAL, 29 (Iraq) | SAIMA SAIMA, 32 (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 30s (Pakistan) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) | GAMAL ALI | AHMED ATTIA HASSAN, 26, Indiana (Egypt) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 40, Akron, Ohio (Syria) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s (Egypt) | MALEK ZEIDAN, 42, Paterson, New Jersey (Syria) | RAJIV DABHADKAR, 32, New Jersey (India) | NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, Findlay, Ohio (Israel) NAME UNAVAILABLE, 20s, New Jersey (Guyana) | NAME UNAVAILABLE | ASHAR IQBAL BUTT, 21, Pennsylvania (Pakistan) | SABAH AL-HACHAMI, 47, Detroit, Michigan (Iraq) | SALEH HAMZE, 31, Tri-state Area (Lebanon) | YAZEED AL-SALMI, 23, San Diego, California (Saudi Arabia) |
����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| �������������
, 31
(Jo
rdan
) |�����������������
, 32
, M
assa
chus
etts
(E
gypt
) | ����������������
, 23
(Tu
nisi
a) |
����������,
25
(Afg
hani
stan
) | ���������������
, 58
, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) |
���������
| ����������
| ���������
, 50
, M
etuc
hen,
New
Jer
sey
(Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, 35
, N
ew C
astle
, P
enns
ylva
nia
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 30
s, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (S
udan
) | ����������������
, 30
s, N
ew J
erse
y (J
orda
n) |
�������������������
, 55
, Q
ueen
s, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n)
�����������
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ��������������
, 45
, Q
ueen
s, N
ew Y
ork
(Egy
pt)
| ������������,
30
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 30
s, P
ater
son,
New
Jer
sey
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 30
s, S
eatt
le,
Was
hing
ton
(Iraq
) | �����������������,
40s
, Fl
orid
a (In
dia)
| ���������������������
, 32
, Lo
uisv
ille,
Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
) | ����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ������������
, 24
(P
akis
tan)
| �������������������������
, 41
, O
rego
n (S
omal
ia)
����������������
, 30s
, Bro
nx, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
) | ����������������
, 30s
(Egy
pt) |
�������������
| ����������������
, 20s
, Fin
dlay
, Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ����������������
, 30s
, Bro
nx, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) | ��������������������
, 48,
Was
hing
ton,
New
Jer
sey
(Indi
a) | �������������
, 27,
Pen
nsyl
vani
a (P
akis
tan)
| �����������������,
30,
Gre
ensb
oro,
Nor
th C
arol
ina
(Sud
an) |
����������������
, 20s
, Mis
sour
i (Is
rael
) | ����������������
, 20s
, Tri-
stat
e A
rea
(Pal
estin
e) | ����������������
, Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
)
��������������,
26
(Iraq
) | ������������,
San
Ber
nadi
no,
Cal
iforn
ia (
Pak
ista
n) |
����������������,
28
(Iraq
) | ������������������
, 40
, S
unris
e, F
lorid
a (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 20
s, I
ndia
na (
Egy
pt)
| ������������,
25,
Okl
ahom
a (In
dia)
| ����������������
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, 50
, N
ew Y
ork
City
, N
ew Y
ork
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 21
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| �������������
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
| �������������������
, 37
, Fl
orid
a (P
akis
tan)
����������������
, 30s
, Pitt
sbur
gh, P
enns
ylva
nia
(Iraq
) | �������������������������
, 32,
New
Yor
k (J
orda
n) | ����������������
, 29
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, 20s
, Mis
sour
i (Is
rael
) | ������������������
| �����������������������
, 19,
Flo
rida
(Tun
isia
) | ��������������
, 20s
, Wee
haw
ken,
New
Jer
sey
(Isra
el) |
��������������
, Bat
on R
ouge
, Lou
isia
na (P
akis
tan)
| ���������������
, 35,
Min
neap
olis
, Min
neso
ta (E
gypt
) | ��������������
, 21,
Ten
ness
ee (E
gypt
) | �������������
, 27
(Pak
ista
n) | �������������
, 24,
Tri-
stat
e A
rea
(Jor
dan)
������������
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 22
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Egy
pt) |
����������������
, 30
s (T
urke
y) | �������������
, 19
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 25
(Ira
q) |������������
, 33
, W
inst
ed,
Con
nect
icut
(Pak
ista
n) | ���������������,
34,
Tem
pe,
Ariz
ona
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) | ������������
, 52
, S
t. P
eter
sbur
g, F
lorid
a (P
ales
tine)
| ���������������
, 30
(Pal
estin
e) | ������������������
, 75
, Ill
inoi
s (J
orda
n) | ������������������
, 22
, D
etro
it, M
ichi
gan
(Alg
eria
) | �������������,
47,
Dea
rbor
n, M
ichi
gan
(Che
chny
a)
����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ����������������
, 23
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| �������������
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Yem
en)
| �����������
, 27
, Li
nden
hurs
t, N
ew Y
ork
(Afg
hani
stan
) | ����������������
, 30
s, B
ronx
, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) |
������������,
44,
Ale
xand
ria,
Virg
inia
(S
omal
ia)
| �������������
, 29
, D
earb
orn,
Mic
higa
n (Ir
aq)
| ��������,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 30
s, P
ittsb
urgh
, P
enns
ylva
nia
(Iraq
) | �����������������
, 37
, S
an D
iego
, C
alifo
rnia
(A
lger
ia)
| ������������
, 26
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (E
gypt
)
�����������������������,
21,
Flo
rida
(Tun
isia
) | ���������������������
| �����������
, 39
, To
rrin
gton
, C
onne
ctic
ut (
Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, 35
, S
t. Lo
uis,
Mis
sour
i (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| ��������������,
Lou
isia
na (
Pak
ista
n) |
������������������
, 37
, N
ew J
erse
y (S
yria
) | ����������������
|����������������
|������������������������������
, 32
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Tur
key)
| ����������������,
28,
Tyl
er,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, C
alifo
rnia
(P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 46
, W
isco
nsin
(Ira
n) |
���������������
, 28
, M
ilfor
d, M
assa
chus
etts
(E
gypt
)
�������������
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
| ����������
, N
ew J
erse
y (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, E
vans
ville
, In
dian
a | ����������������
, 20
s (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| �����������
, 20
s, W
eeha
wke
n, N
ew J
erse
y (Is
rael
) | ���������
| �������������
|����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
| ���������������
, 45
, Ta
mpa
, Fl
orid
a (P
ales
tine)
| ���������������
, 44
, Fl
orid
a | ��������������,
32,
Nas
hville
, Te
nnes
see
(Syr
ia)
| �����������������
, 26
, V
irgin
ia B
each
, V
irgin
ia (
Yem
en)
������������������
, 36
(D
jibou
ti) | ����������������
, 41
(E
gypt
) | �������������
, 55
, La
ke W
orth
, Fl
orid
a (In
dia)
| ���������������
, 29
(Ira
q) | �����������
, 32
(P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
����������������
���������
, 30
s (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ���������
| ������������������
, 26
, In
dian
a (E
gypt
) | ����������������
, 40
, A
kron
, O
hio
(Syr
ia)
| ����������������
, 20
s (E
gypt
) | ������������
, 42
, P
ater
son,
New
Jer
sey
(Syr
ia)
| ���������������
, 32
, N
ew J
erse
y (In
dia)
| ����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
)
����������������
, 20s
, New
Jer
sey
(Guy
ana)
| ����������������
| ����������������
| ��������������������������������
, 21,
Pen
nsyl
vani
a (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������,
47,
Det
roit,
Mic
higa
n (Ir
aq) |
�����������
, 31,
Tri-
stat
e A
rea
(Leb
anon
) |���������������,
23,
San
Die
go, C
alifo
rnia
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) | �������������������
, 28
(Egy
pt) |
���������������
, 28,
For
t Lau
derd
ale,
Flo
rida
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, 30s
(Egy
pt) |
������������,
45,
Tri-
stat
e A
rea
(Yem
en) |
�������������������
, 52,
New
Jer
sey
(Pal
estin
e) | ����������������
, 29,
Min
neap
olis
, Min
neso
ta (P
akis
tan)
���������������������������
, 28
(Tu
nisi
a) |
����������������
, 30
s, N
ew J
erse
y (S
yria
) | ��������������������
, 25
(A
fgha
nist
an)
| ����������
, 32
(S
yria
) | �����������������������
, 25
, Lo
uisv
ille,
Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
) | ���������
, 23
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Isra
el)
| �����������
, 42
, Tr
ento
n, N
ew J
erse
y (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Sou
th A
frica
) | ����������������
, B
altim
ore,
Mar
ylan
d (J
orda
n) |
��������������������
| ����������������
����������������
�,
Tri-s
tate
Are
a (E
gypt
) | ����������������������
, 47
(In
dia)
����������������
|
����������������
|
����������������
�������������������
, 46
, In
dian
a (E
gypt
) | ����������������
|
����������������
|
����������������
����������������
, 23
, C
olor
ado
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) |
�������������
, 30
, D
etro
it, M
ichi
gan
(Iraq
) | ���������
���������
��������
���������������
��������
, 30
(E
gypt
) | ����������������
, 49
(P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
| ����������������
, 30
s, T
exas
(Ira
q) |
����������������
, 30
s, E
lizab
eth,
New
Jer
sey
(Jor
dan)
| ����������������
, 30
s (Y
emen
) | ������������
, 31
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Leb
anon
) | ��������������
, 30
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (E
gypt
)
������������������,
55,
Que
ens,
New
Yor
k (P
ales
tine)
| ��������������������������,
36,
Auc
klan
d, N
ew Z
eala
nd (
Iraq)
| �������������
, 26
, Fo
rt W
orth
, Te
xas
(Pal
estin
e) |
����������������
����������������
��������
|�����������������
, P
alm
Bay
, Fl
orid
a (S
yria
) | ����������������
, 58
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Sud
an)
| ������������������������,
21
(Leb
anon
) | �������������,
41,
Flo
rida
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) |
����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
| ������������������������,
34,
Los
Ang
eles
, Fl
orid
a (Iv
ory
Coa
st)
| ��������������
|
����������������
, 24,
Okl
ahom
a (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| ����������������
, 37
(Leb
anon
) | �������������
, 41,
Jer
sey
City
, New
Jer
sey
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
| �����������
, 18,
Cal
iforn
ia (P
akis
tan)
| �����������������,
27,
Boo
ne C
ount
y, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia) |
���������������
, 21
(Yem
en) |
�������������
, Hou
ston
, Tex
as (P
ales
tine)
| ������������
, 19,
Cal
iforn
ia (P
akis
tan)
| �������������
, 24,
Indi
ana
(Egy
pt) |
��������������,
20s
, Bro
omfi e
ld, C
olor
ado
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
) | �������������
, 32
(Pak
ista
n)
����������������
, 40
s (P
akis
tan)
| �������������
, 50
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (E
gypt
) | ��������������,
20s
, Fo
rt C
ampb
ell,
Ken
tuck
y (Y
emen
) | ������������
������������
����������
, 43
, O
rland
o, F
lorid
a (E
gypt
) | ���������������
, Q
uinc
y, M
assa
chus
etts
(E
gypt
) | ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| �������������,
Nor
th C
arol
ina
(Eg y
pt)
| ���������������
, P
ater
son,
New
Jer
sey
(Jor
dan)
| ����������������,
36
(Mor
occo
) | �������������
, M
anha
ttan
, N
ew Y
ork
(Egy
pt)
| �����������
, 21
(Jo
rdan
) | �������������
, O
klah
oma
(Pak
ista
n)
��������������
, S
arni
a, O
ntar
io (
Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, 30
s (Y
emen
) | �������������������
, 35
, S
an B
erna
dino
, C
alifo
rnia
(E
gypt
) | ����������������
����������������
�������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ����������������
, 40
(Le
bano
n) |
��������������,
31
(Iraq
) | �������������������������
, 21
, Fl
orid
a (T
unis
ia)
| ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ���������������������
, O
klah
oma
(Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, 20
s, I
n dia
na (
Egy
pt)
| �������������
, 35
(In
dia)
| ������������������
, 23
(Ira
q)
���������������
, W
est
Bab
ylon
g, N
ew Y
ork
(Tur
key)
| ������������
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ������������
, 39
, G
utte
nber
g, N
ew J
erse
y (P
akis
tan)
| �����������
, 26
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Isra
el)
| �������� �����������
| ������������
, 33
, D
etro
it, M
ichi
gan
(Mor
occo
) | ����������
, R
ock
Hill,
Sou
th C
arol
ina
(Pak
ista
n) |
������������������������,
29,
Ind
iana
(E
gypt
) | ������������������,
32,
Tor
ringt
on,
Con
nect
icut
(In
dia)
| ����������������
, 46
, Lo
ng I
slan
d, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
������������������,
23
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) | ����������������
, 30,
Atla
nta,
Geo
rgia
(Sud
an) |
��������������
, 26,
Indi
ana
(Egy
pt) |
�����������,
29,
Que
ens,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 30s
, Bro
nx, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) | ���������������
, Hou
ston
, Tex
as (P
ales
tine)
| ��������������
, 45,
Bro
okly
n, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, 31
(Ban
glad
esh)
| ������������
, 20s
, Wee
haw
ken,
New
Jer
sey
(Isra
el) |
����������������
, Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
) | ����������������
����������������
�, 3
0s (P
akis
tan)
| �������������������������
, 18
(Egy
pt)
�����������������
, 29
(Ira
q) |
����������������
, 42
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Pal
estin
e) |
����������������
, 37
(P
hilip
p ine
s) |
������������
, 24
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| �����������������
, C
olor
ado
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) |
���������������
, 33
, B
osto
n, M
assa
chus
etts
(S
omal
ia)
| �����������
, 22
, M
anha
ttan
, N
ew Y
ork
(Mor
occo
) | ������������������,
26,
Bro
omfi e
ld,
Col
orad
o (P
akis
tan)
| �����������������,
34
(Iraq
) | ������������,
20s
, W
eeh a
wke
n, N
ew J
erse
y (Is
rael
) | ��������������
, 36
, Je
rsey
City
, N
ew J
erse
y (E
gypt
)
����������������
, 30
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
, 20
s (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| ���������������,
41,
Ric
hard
son,
Tex
as (
Pal
estin
e) |
�������������
, 36
, O
rland
Par
k, I
llinoi
s (J
orda
n) |
�������������������,
23,
Flo
rida
(Jor
dan)
| ����������������
, 40
s (Ir
an)
| ����������������
, 42
, N
ew J
erse
y (E
gypt
) | �������������
, 66
, La
belle
, Fl
orid
a (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 46
, To
rrin
gton
, C
onne
ctic
ut (
Pak
ista
n) |
���������������
| �����������
| ����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
| ��������������������
|
����������������
, 40
, M
ontr
eal,
Que
bec
(Pal
estin
e) |
����������������
, 30
s (M
aurit
ania
) | ����������������
, 29
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Pal
estin
e) |
�������������������,
40s
, F l
orid
a (In
dia)
| ����������������
, 42
(E
gypt
) | ����������������
, 30
s, M
isso
uri
(Ban
glad
esh)
| ����������������
, 34
(Ye
men
) | ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ����������������
, 32
| ������������,
29
(Iraq
) | ������������
, 37
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Tur
key)
| ����������������
����������������
����
, Io
wa
(Sud
an)
| ����������������
, 29
, Le
esbe
rg,
Virg
inia
(In
dia)
����������������
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Yem
en)
| ���������������
, 27
, W
ilmin
gton
, D
elaw
are
(Pak
ista
n) |
����������������
| ����������������
, 20
s (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| ������������������
, 26
(S
omal
ia)
| ����������������
, 57
(E
gypt
) | ����������������
����������������
���������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ������ ������������������������
, 30
, M
onta
na (
Jord
an)
| ����������������
, 50
(A
lger
ia)
| ����������������
, 27
(In
dia)
| ����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ����������������,
32,
Kan
sas
City
, K
ansa
s (S
audi
Ara
bia)
����������������
, C
alifo
rnia
(P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 24
(P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 32
(A
lger
ia)
| ����������������
, 20
s, V
irgin
ia (
Sau
di A
rabi
a) |
����������������
, 28
, S
an D
iego
, C
alifo
rnia
(Ye
men
) | ����������������
, 40
(Tr
inid
ad)
| ����������������
, 37
(B
angl
ades
h) |
������������
| �������������,
37
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) |
����������������
, 20
s, S
eatt
le,
Was
hing
ton
(Iraq
) | ����������������
, 62
(Ira
n) |
����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ����������������
, 30
s (P
akis
tan)
����������������
, 50s
, Tri-
stat
e A
rea
(Pal
estin
e) | ����������������
| �������������,
24,
Wilm
ingt
on, D
elaw
are
(Tur
key)
| ����������������
| �����������������
, 29
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
����������������
�������
, 30s
, Ariz
ona
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) | ����������������
, Cal
ifor n
ia (P
akis
tan)
| ����������
, Pla
insb
oro,
New
Jer
sey
(Indi
a) | ����������������
, 30s
, Litt
le F
alls
, New
Jer
sey
(Egy
pt) |
��������������
, 26,
Pho
enix
, Ariz
ona
(Leb
anon
) | ���������������������������
, 20,
Ken
tuck
y (M
aurit
ania
) | ����������������������������,
Can
ton,
Ohi
o (T
unis
ia)
����������������
, 20s
, Mis
sour
i (Is
rael
) | ����������
|�������������
, 24,
Row
land
Hei
ght,
Cal
iforn
ia (Y
emen
) | ������������,
Lyn
woo
d, W
ashi
ngto
n (S
yria
) | ����������������
, Cal
iforn
ia (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 36,
Pho
enix
, Ariz
ona
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) | �������� �������
, 30,
Dea
rbor
n, M
ichi
gan
(Mor
occo
) | ����������������
, 39
(Pak
ista
n) | ������ ���������
, 21,
Cal
iforn
ia (J
orda
n) | ��������������
, 33,
Mas
sach
uset
ts (L
eban
on) |
����������������������������
, 34,
Tex
as (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| ����������������
, 32,
Que
ens,
New
Yor
k (In
done
sia)
����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
| �����������
, 33
, C
umbe
rland
, R
hode
Isl
and
(Pal
estin
e) |
������������
, 30
, M
isso
uri
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 20
s (J
orda
n) |
����������������
, 20
s, I
ndia
na (
Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 32
(S
udan
) | �������������
| �������������,
50,
Lyn
woo
d, W
ashi
ngto
n (S
yria
) | ����������������
, 20
s, A
sbur
y P
ark,
New
Jer
sey
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 31
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Pal
estin
e) |
����������������
, 30
s, T
ri-st
ate
Are
a (E
gypt
)
����������������
, 30
s (Y
emen
) | ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| �����������
, C
hica
go,
Illin
ois
(Pal
estin
e) |
������������,
25,
Flo
rida
(Pak
ista
n) |
�������������
, 40
, N
ew Y
ork
City
, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) |
���������������������
, 37
, Je
rsey
City
, N
ew J
erse
y (P
akis
tan)
| ������������
, H
ous t
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| �����������������
, N
orw
ood,
Mas
sach
uset
ts (
Leba
non)
| �������������
, H
o ust
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 30
s, K
ansa
s C
ity,
Mis
sour
i (U
zbek
ista
n) |
����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
)
��������������
, 46
, U
nion
, N
ew J
erse
y (E
gypt
) | ������������������������
, 26
, Te
nnes
see
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, 20
s (S
audi
Ara
bia)
| ������������������
, 39
, P
hila
delp
hia,
Pen
nsyl
vani
a (A
fgha
nist
an)
| �������������������
, 29
, La
belle
, Fl
orid
a (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | �������������,
26,
War
rens
burg
, M
isso
uri
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) |
��������������������
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ��������������
, 29
, C
onne
ctic
ut (
Jord
an)
| ����������������
, 20
s, M
isso
uri
(Isra
el)
����������������
, 30s
, Ham
ilton
, New
Jer
sey
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, 40s
, Litt
le F
alls
, New
Jer
sey
(Egy
pt) |
�������������
, 20s
, Wee
haw
ken,
New
Jer
sey
(Isra
el) |
����������������
, 34,
New
Yor
k (J
orda
n) | ����������������
, 30s
, Bro
nx, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) | ����������������
, 20s
, Fin
dlay
, Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ��������������,
23,
Det
roit,
Mic
hig a
n (M
oroc
co) |
����������������������
, Okl
ahom
a (P
akis
tan)
| �����������������,
34,
Alb
any,
New
Yor
k (P
ales
tine)
| ������������
, 38
| �����������������
, 34,
San
Fra
ncis
co, C
alifo
rnia
(Pak
ista
n)
������������
, 19
, N
ew J
erse
y (E
gypt
) | �����������������
, 32
, D
etro
it, M
ichi
gan
(Iraq
) | ����������������
, 25
, S
eatt
le,
Was
hing
ton
(Iraq
) | ������������
| ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ����������������
, 20
s, F
indl
ay,
Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | ����������������
, 20
s, A
rkan
sas
(Egy
pt)
| ����������������
, W
ilmin
gton
, D
elaw
are
(Egy
pt)
| ���������������
, 24
(Ira
q) |
�����������
| ������������������
, 25
, In
dian
a (E
gypt
) | ������������,
20,
Lyn
woo
d, W
ashi
ngto
n (S
yria
) | ��������������
, 18
(In
dia)
����������������
, Tr
i-sta
te A
rea
(Yem
en)
| ������������
, 25
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ����������
| ��������������
, 30
s, T
acom
a, W
ashi
ngto
n (T
unis
ia)
| �����������
, 51
, G
reen
sbor
o, N
orth
Car
olin
a (P
akis
tan)
| ������������
, 24
, Fl
orid
a (Is
rael
) | ��������������
, 28
, C
olor
ado
(Sau
di A
rabi
a) | ����������������
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k (P
akis
tan)
| ,
Bro
okly
n, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) |
, B
rook
lyn,
New
Yor
k��������������
| ����������������
, 21
, Fl
orid
a (E
gypt
) | ������������
, 31
(In
done
sia)
| �����������
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (P
ales
tine)
| ����������������
, 30
s, L
ong
Isla
nd,
New
Yor
k (T
urke
y)
����������������
, 24
(In
dia)
| ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ����������������
, 35
, M
anha
ttan
, N
ew Y
ork
(Pak
ista
n) |
������������������
, 32
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (S
omal
ia)
| ����������������
, K
entu
cky
(Mau
ritan
ia)
| ���������������
, 30
, M
anha
ttan
, N
ew Y
ork
(Egy
pt)
| ������������������
, 31
, H
oust
on,
Texa
s (S
omal
ia)
| �������������������
, 38
, Tr
inity
, N
orth
Car
olin
a (P
akis
tan)
| ���������������
, P
ater
son,
New
Jer
sey
(Jor
dan)
| ���������������
, 35
, Ill
inoi
s (S
yria
) | �����������
, 23
, N
ewar
k, N
ew J
erse
y (P
akis
tan)
������������
, 41,
Ann
Arb
or, M
ichi
gan
(Leb
anon
) | ��������������
, 41,
Say
lors
burg
, Pen
nsyl
vani
a (In
dia)
| ���������������
|����������������
, 20s
, Asb
ury
Par
k, N
ew J
erse
y (E
gypt
) | ����������������
, 20s
, Fin
dlay
, Ohi
o (Is
rael
) | �����������,
34,
Tri-
stat
e A
rea
(Egy
pt) |
������������
, 32,
Den
ver,
Col
orad
o (P
akis
tan)
| ����������������
, 41
(Iran
) | �����������������
, 29,
Que
ens,
New
Yor
k (E
gypt
)
Take Me Off Your DatabaseMuseum installation+email feedback loopVisible Collective/Naeem Mohaiemen
Visible Collective is a project by Naeem Mohaiemen and collaborating artists, activists and lawyers. Since 2004, the project has traced hyphenated identities and ideas of loyalty in times of security panic. The majority of detained migrants in post-9/11 hysteria are from the invisible underclass - shadow citizens who drive our taxis, deliver our food, clean our tables, and sell fruit, coffee, and newspapers. The only time we “see” them is when we glance at the license in the taxi partition, or the ID card around their neck. When detained, they cease to exist in the consciousness. This impulse to create an insider-outsider dynamic with “loyalty” overtones has a long pedigree: WWI incarceration of German-Americans; 1919 detention of immigrants in the Anarchist bomb scare; WWII internment of Japanese-Americans; execution of the Rosenbergs; the HUAC “red scare”; harassment of Deacons For Defense; COINTEL-PRO infiltration of Black Panthers; and the rise of the Minutemen militia. [disappearedinamerica.org]
A segment of the visuals on the preceding pages come from Nahnu Wahaad, But Really Are We One?, which was installed at the Queens Museum of Art. It was initially a lightbox with names of detainees (from a Migration Policy Institute database). The surface was covered with rice, which the audience had to clear to reveal the names.
Jesal Kapadia talks to Naeem Mohaiemen about the project, context and subtext.
Jesal: ‘...they cease to exist in the consciousness’ is a haunting thought. I remember my experience of moving my fingers through the trough of rice and first and foremost being moved by that experience. What made you want to work with rice as your material - was it a tactile choice, or more?
Naeem: Well, we conducted interviews with a few former detainees, and a prevailing con-cern was the absence of stabilizing forces in post-detention family hierarchy. In conversa-tion, this was linked back to the act of “putting food on the table.” Additionally, I wanted to reference the Bengali slogan: Bhat De Haramjada / Noile Manchithro Kheye Nebo (Give Me Rice You Son Of A Bitch / Or I’ll Eat Your Whole Map). The intriguing back chatter is that the use of a putatively “asian staple” left us vulnerable to charges of ethnic absolutism by art critics. Consider this in the context of Tirdad Zolkhadr’s concept of “ethnic marketing” and the limits of art world internationalism. Interventions by a non-white artist can be mis-read through a prism of ethnicity.
Jesal: As you read the names, you see that some letters are in bright red (gray in the RM version). It doesn’t appear to be a random choice to me - is there a link between these letters and the title Nahnu Wahaad?
Naeem: It is a bit strange to verbalize the subtext - it risks becoming too clear. But anyway, the red shade under some of the names spell out, at a distance, the arabic phrase nahnu wahaad (we are one). We were being very tongue in cheek about this forced, temporary unity around a common experience of marginalization. Anyone familiar with the condition of South Asian migrants in the Middle East knows that the notion of a united ummah, sans racism or classism, is an illusion. In the museum space, once we installed the piece, we realized that in order to see the arabic outline you needed to get on a ladder, or hang off the roof to get the right perspective. Obviously no one was going to do that, so most people just thought it was a “design” fetish - law of unintended consequences.
Jesal: What do you think is the impact of political art in the public sphere? Where do political
interventions in art appear, and how do you think they are received?
Naeem: There is almost an impulse to go against, or “correct”, the impact of Okwui En-wezor’s Documenta 11 (referred to as “the CNN Documenta” by the Village Voice). The New York Sun, which is a super right-wing rag, really hated the 2006 Whitney Biennial because they felt it was too political. I can imagine that crusty critic having a coronary when he walked up the ramp and saw the massive installation with peace signs. We also saw the Drawing Center get ejected from Ground Zero because of the controversy over Amy Burlingame’s drawing of a hooded Abu Ghraib figure. But more insidious than outright censorship are mar-ket forces, which can eventually strangle political art through neglect and marginalization.
Jesal: Do you think art critics overlook addressing the subject’s point of view directly, and instead privilege the insider art-world audience? Can you talk about the person in the e-mails that are another thread in this piece? I’m assuming the voice in the title Take Me Off Your Database is his?
Naeem: The interesting critique of our work was not from the art press, but from this pro-tagonist. About a week after the show opened, we received an email from Rajiv Dabhadkar in India, who had discovered his name on our installation. The disconnect stemmed from his concern that we had created a list of people who should be kept out of the country. In these e-mail correspondences, we understood that for an audience outside the white cube walls, the work was already too ambiguous. He was initially quite upset, and insisted he should not be on the list (even though he had earlier given an interview to USA Today about being detained). I think his frustration was also because our work was not identifiably journalism or advocacy. So the visceral reaction was: who the hell are you, and why is my name on your project? Later, after he understood the project, he was fine with it. But that was later.
Jesal: For me, Take Me Off Your Database has really changed my reading of Nahnu Wahaad. It is clear here that the subjects in the art could not only be the audience for the same work, but their presence also shapes the work in a way that challenges the status of art. Rajiv Dab-hadkar’s ‘right to say no’ echoes Gayatri Spivak’s emphasis on the ‘right to not be helped’, which she contextualized as a resistance to US and other foreign food aid ‘gifts’ to the third world, a response to the self-satisfying liberal benevolence towards the Global South. In “Can the Subaltern Speak?” Spivak highlights that artists and intellectuals are also some-times complicit in this violence of speaking for the ‘other’, but instead of simply disavowing our responsibility completely, she reminds us to always be vigilant of this ever present pos-sibility, and never take the power relations in any exchange for granted.
Naeem: There are also questions of “accuracy.” Because we have lawyers in the collective, we had an obsessive focus on getting the facts “right” and then building interventions on top. But is absolute truth emanating from Migration Policy Institute? Dabhadkar was essen-tially saying: Yes, I was detained. Yes I talked to the newspapers about it. But I’m no victim! He talks in e-mail exchanges about an organization he founded in India to advocate for high-tech workers coming to the US. I suppose he felt he had already left this issue in his past. Also significant is Rajiv’s profession as a technology worker, which made him more likely to find the online version of the project. How many people google their own names regularly (except artists)?
The easy, arrogant assumption is that every detainee wants representation in culture spaces. What of those who would prefer anonymity, to simply get on with their lives? Any work in this space is like the butterfly wing effect, conversations that lead to unpredictable future conver-sations. But not necessarily direct advocacy that will bring any of these detainees back into the country. So, should they be pressed into unwilling service as exhibits in a conversation about/against government policy?