perry v. schwarzenegger - hearing on summary judgment transcript (2009-10-14)

104
Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 20 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Upload: parenthetical-greg

Post on 17-Nov-2014

957 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Transcript of the Oct. 14 hearing on Prop 8 official proponents motion for summary judgment (denied, see minute order of same date)

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 20 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 2: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 21 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 3: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 22 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 4: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 23 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 5: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 24 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 6: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 25 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 7: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 26 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 8: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 27 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 9: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 28 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 10: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 29 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 11: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 30 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 12: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 31 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 13: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 32 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 14: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 33 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 15: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 34 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 16: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 35 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 17: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 36 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 18: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 37 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 19: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 38 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 20: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 39 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 21: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 40 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 22: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 41 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 23: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 42 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 24: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 43 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 25: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 44 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 26: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 45 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 27: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 46 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 28: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 47 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 29: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 48 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 30: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 49 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 31: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 50 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 32: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 51 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 33: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 52 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 34: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 53 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 35: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 54 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 36: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 55 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 37: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 56 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 38: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 57 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 39: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 58 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 40: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 59 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 41: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 60 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 42: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 61 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 43: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 62 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 44: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 63 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 45: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 64 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 46: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 65 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 47: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 66 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 48: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 67 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 49: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 68 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 50: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 69 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 51: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 70 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 52: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 71 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 53: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 72 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 54: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 73 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 55: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 74 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 56: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 75 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 57: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 76 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 58: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 77 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 59: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 78 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 60: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 79 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 61: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 80 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 62: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 81 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 63: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 82 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 64: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 83 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 65: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 84 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 66: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 85 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 67: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 86 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 68: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 87 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 69: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 88 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 70: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 89 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 71: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 90 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 72: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 91 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 73: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 92 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 74: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 93 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 75: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 94 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 76: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 95 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 77: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 96 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 78: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 97 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 79: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 98 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 80: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 99 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 81: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 100 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 82: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 101 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 83: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 102 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 84: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 103 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 85: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 104 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 86: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 105 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 87: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 106 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 88: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 107 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 89: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 108 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 90: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 109 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 91: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 110 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 92: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 111 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 93: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 112 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 94: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 113 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 95: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 114 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 96: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 115 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 97: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 116 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 98: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 117 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 99: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 118 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 100: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 119 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 101: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 120 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 102: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 121 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 103: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 122 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901

Page 104: Perry v. Schwarzenegger - Hearing on Summary Judgment Transcript (2009-10-14)

Case: 09-17241 11/23/2009 Page: 123 of 188 DktEntry: 7139901