proceedings of 171st meeting of the erc-ncte held on

Proceedings of 171st Meeting of ERC-NCTE held on 3rd -4th June, 2014

Shri Chandrapida Neelap (RD/Convener, ERC, NCTE) Prof P C Mahapatra (Chairperson ERC, NCTE)

1

PROCEEDINGS OF 171st MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE

HELD ON 3rd

- 4th

JUNE, 2014

The 171st

Meeting of the Eastern Regional Committee (ERC), National Council for Teacher

Education (NCTE) was convened on 3rd

- 4th

June, 2014 at Conference Hall, ERC, NCTE,

15, Neelakantha Nagar, Nayapalli, Bhubaneswar. The Chairperson, Members and Convener as listed below

were present at the time of the 171th ERC Meeting.

Prof.(Dr.) P.C. Mahapatra - Chairperson

Prof. Brajanath Kundu - Member

Shri Ali Imam - Member

Dr. Shukla Mohanty - Member

Prof. Manik Bhattacharjee - State Representative of West Bengal Mr. T.B. Guragain - State Representative of Sikkim

Shri N.P. Narain - State Representative of Bihar

Dr. Vanlalhruaii - State Representative of Mizoram

Shri Satapati - State representative of Odisha

Shri Dr. S. Gyaneswar Singh - State Representative of Manipur Dr. L.N. Sharma - State Representative of Assam

Shri Chandrapida Neelap - Regional Director, ERC & Convener.

At the outset, the Regional Director welcomed all the members of Committee and apprised them about

the provisions of the NCTE Act, Rules, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time. With the

permission of Chairperson, Shri Chandrapida Neelap (Convener) presented the Agenda before the

Committee for its due consideration and appropriate decision.

Sl.

No. Item No. Content

ER-171.1

Confirmation of the Proceedings of 170th

ERC meeting,

28th

February & 1st March, 2014 at Bhubaneswar.

Confirmed

Discussing about the confirmation of the proceeding of the 170

th ERC meeting held on 28.02.2014 and

01.03.2014 the Regional Director apprised the cases of 04 institutions i.e Bishupriya College of Education

ERCAPP-1613, Chittaranjan Smriti PTTI ERCAPP-1838, Kandi PTTI ERCAPP-1690 and Bihar College of

Education ERCAPP-37/2012 where the committee decided to issued formal recognition order under clause

7(11) of the NCTE Regulation 2009 for the applied course from the session 2014-15, after submission of

DFRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh in the joint name of institution/society/trust and RD, ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneshwar. Though the orders were reported to be signed by 3rd

March, 2014 not dispatched due to some

official formalities. All the four institutions submitted the converted FDRs on 31.03.2014, 27.03.2014,

24.03.2014 and 07.03.2014 respectively.

In between the NCTE HQrs called for some files along with the above files due to some complaint made

related to some files.

Meanwhile, the Kandi PTTI filed a Writ Petition WP1394(W)/2014 in the Hon’ble High Court of Kolkata.

The Hon’ble High Court has inter alia directed the Respondents to decide the matter within 4 weeks from date

or by 15.06.2014 and communicate to the same to petitioner.

As stated by the Regional Director, he was also alleged by the complainant in the complaint send to the NCTE

Hqrs, he has forwarded the Writ Petition and court order to the Member Secretary, NCTE, Hqrs who is also a

respondent in this case to defend the case and/or for appropriate direction.

The NCTE Hqrs may be requested to take appropriate action on or before 15.06.2014 in the line of the order

of the Honble High Court of Kolkata.



2

ER-171.2(i) Court Case:

1. 171.2(i)1

Directorate of Distance Education, L.N. Mithila University, Darbhanga,

Bihar - 846008 (B.Ed.-Distance & Open Learning System) (University

Department) (L.N.Mithila University) (Code No.APE00389)

After considering the records available in the file, and relevant provisions of the NCTE Act 1993, Rules,

Regulations and guidelines issued by NCTE Hqrs. VTR and reply received on 02.01.2014 in response to

clarification issued after notice u/s 17, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under:

List of the faculty recruited on 16.12.13 as stated by the institution vide letter dated 2.1.2014 be submitted

duly approved by the Registrar of the University along with educational/professional certificates of the

recruited faculty members.

In view of the above, the committee decided as under:

A clarification letter be issued to the university to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter

before the Committee takes final decision.

ER-171.2(ii).

Court Case:

Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction

given by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand.

2. 171.2(ii).1

(F.No.ERC/NCTE/JH (Insp. u/s 13)/2014)

A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P.(PIL) No.327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv

Shankar Munda - Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon’ble High Court of

Jharkhand at Ranchi.

As per direction of the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand, the 95 institutions were inspected by the NCTE

Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993. The inspection reports of all 95 institutions were

examined at the NCTE Hqrs level and same was forwarded to ERC, NCTE for taking appropriate action in the

matter.

The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs and decided as under:

Copy of the VTRs may be obtained from NCTE Hqrs for assessing the deficiencies objectively.

3. 171.2(ii).2

Bharathi College of Education, Plot No. 587, Vill-Kandri, Po-Mandar,

Tesil/Taluka/Town /City–Mandar, Dist-Ranchi, Jharkhand-835214 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B.- Ranchi University) (Code No. ERCAPP502)

A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda – Vs -

Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High

Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the

NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-

22/2014/NCTE/Insp/A85677 dated 07.04.2014.

1. A copy of the fee structure duly approved/counter signed by the affiliating university/state govt is to be

submitted by the institution.

2. Faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university along with the list of the other

staff, minutes of the selection committee, individual affidavit, education/professional certificates of the

appointed faculty is to be submitted.

3. Salary to the faculty and staff is not paid through bank.

4. Proof of EPF deduction/statement of deposit of EPF not submitted.

The committee considered the representation of the institution and decided as under:

A clarification letter be issued to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter




3

4. 171.2(ii).3

Chanakya Teachers Training College, Plot No- 506, Vill- Sapaha, Po- Madhupur,

Tehsil/Taluka- Madhupur, City- Madhupur, Dist.- Deoghar, Jharkhand- 815353

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (A.B.- S.K.M. University)

(Code No.ERCAPP458)





64/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87042 dated 11.04.2014.

1. The institution be asked to submit the faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned

university along with the list of the other staff, minutes of the selection committee, individual

affidavit, and education/professional certificates of the appointed faculty.

2. The institution submitted the list of 03 practice teaching schools. The list of 07 more practice

teaching schools is to be submitted along with the consent letter issued from the principal of the

concerned schools.




5. 171.2(ii).4

B.B.M. B.Ed. College, Plot No. 788, 813, & 797, Vill/Po. – Sardaha,

Tehsil/Taluka – Chas, Town/City – Bokaro, Dist. -Bokaro, Jharkhand–827013

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (A.B.-Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No. ERCAPP510)





32/2014/NCTE/Insp/A85687 dated 09.04.2014.

In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide

letter dated 03.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.


Institution be asked to submit resolution of the Management Committee for increase of the salary of staff

along with notarized copy from May 2014 within 30 days from issue of the letter.

6. 171.2(ii).5

Manrakhan Mahto B.Ed. College, Plot No. 261, 262, 293, Vill- Kedal, Po-Neori

Vikas, Tehsil/Taluka- Kanke, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand- 825217 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B.- Ranchi University) (Code No. ERCAPP498)





116/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87051 dated 30.04.2014.


letter dated 19.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.

The committee considered the representation of the institution and observed as under:

1. Institution be asked to submit the faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned

university along with the list of the other staff, minutes of the selection committee, individual

affidavit, education/professional certificates.

2. Proof of development of IT and Psychology lab to be submitted.






4

7. 171.2(ii).6

Dev Sangha Institute of Professional Studies and Educational Research, Po-Dev

Sangha, Bompas Town, Deoghar, Jharkhand – 814114 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B.- S.K.M. University) (Code No.APE00219 &

ERCAPP1074)

A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda –

Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the

High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section

13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency

letter No.93-38/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86401 dated 30.03.2014.

In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification

vide letter dated 16.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.


(i) A copy of the fee structure duly approved/counter signed by the affiliating university/state govt

be submitted by the institution.

(ii) Proof of EPF deduction/statement of deposit of EPF be submitted. In view of the above, the committee decided as under:



8. 171.2(ii).7

A.S. College, Deoghar, PO/Dist.- Deoghar, Jharkhand-814112 (Course:B.Ed.)

(Management: Constituent College) (A.B.- S.K.M. University)

(Code No.APE00439)







vide letter dated 21.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.


(i) Principal/HOD has not been appointed.

(ii) Appointed teachers are on contractual basis which is against the norms.

(iii) The built up area is only 5200 sq.ft. which is less than required 1500 sq,mts.(16146 dq.ft.).

(iv) Multipurpose hall and Art & Craft Resource Center are not available.

(i) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is not submitted towards endowment fund and

reserve fund respectively into joint account in the name of institution and RD, ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar.


Show Cause notice be issued to the institution as to why the recognition to the institution be not withdrawn on

the above points. The Committee therefore, provides an opportunity under section 17(1) of the NCTE Act

1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee

takes final decision.



5

9. 171.2(ii).8

Aviram College of Education, Plot No. 752/712, 749/713, Vill- Tiko, Po- Kuru,

Tehsil/Taluka- Kuru, City/Dist.- Lohardaga, Jharkhand-835213 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management:Private) (A.B.- Ranchi University) (Code No. ERCAPP948)







vide letter dated 10.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the

representation of the institution and observed as under: (i) Librarian has not been appointed.

(ii) One principal and 03 lecturers on regular basis were selected through selection committee just 03

days prior to the special inspection. No appointment letters were issued to the selected candidates

and not submitted the joining report. It seems that the required faculty was not available in the

institution before conducting the special inspection.

(iii) The institution is required to appoint the required faculty as per NCTE norms submit a fresh

faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university alongwith the relevant

documents like copy of advertisement, minutes of the selection committee, educational and

professional certificates of the newly appointed principal and lecturers.




10. 171.2(ii).9

G.D. Bagaria Teacher’s Training College, At. Aerodrome Road, Boro, P.O. &

Dist. Giridih, Jharkhand – 815301 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private)

(Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00473)








representation of the institution and observed as under: (i) As per VT report the institution is not functioning on the plot in Municipal holding No. 400 of

Ward No. 1 (old) of Giridih situated at Barganda, Makatpur, Thana No. 95, Thoka No. 228, PS

Giridih where recognition was grante. The institution is now functioning in another premises

namely a plot of land measuring 1.15 acre plot No. 856,849, 850 under Khata No. 1A/P 1/20/71

gifted by one Sangeetha Bagaria to GD Bagaria Teacher Training College. Thus the institution

has shifted to the new premises without permission of ERC which is against the rules.

(ii) The institution has not appointed a qualified librarian and part time teachers for Art Education

and Physical Education.

(iii) The institution has not converted FDRs in respect of Endowment and Reserve fund into joint

accounts with Regional Director, ERC,NCTE.








6

11. 171.2(ii).10

Chatra College, Chatra, Dist.- Chatra, Jharkhand-825401 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management:Constituent College) (A.B.-Vinoba BhaveUniversity)

(Code No.APE00447)








representation of the institution and observed as under: (i) The institution functions as a wing of the degree college. Its own building out of the B.Ed. fund is

still under construction.

(ii) The institution has failed to engage teaching and non-teaching staff on regular basis.

(iii) The institution has also failed to provide the necessary instructional facilities.

(iv) In the absence of a regular HOD, the institution is not managed professionally.

(v) While endowment fund of Rs. 5.00 lakhs is maintained in joint accounts with the Regional Director,

ERC, Bhubaneswar as required, the reserve fund of Rs. 3.00 lakhs is not being maintained jointly

with the Regional Director, ERC, Bhubaneswar as required and further it has not been renewed after

its maturity on 29.06.2008.






12. 171.2(ii).11

Rahat College of Education, Plot No. 42, Vill/Po-Madhupur, Tehsil/Taluka-

Barbad, Town/City-Madhupur, Dist.-Deoghar, Jharkhand – 815353 (Course:

B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (A.B.- S.K.M. University) (Code No.ERCAPP99)








representation of the institution and observed as under: (i) Certified copy of the salary statement of all the faculty/staff is to be submitted.

(ii) The name of Md. Hassan Ansari has been shown in the faculty list whereas as per letter dated

6.03.2014 received from Md. Hassan Ansari he has resigned from the post of lecturer.

(iii) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the

concerned university.

(iv) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is to be submitted towards endowment fund

and reserve fund respectively into joint account in the name of institution and RD, ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar.






7

13. 171.2(ii).12

ARS B.Ed. College, Plot No. 62, 63, 64, 65, Street No. 1, Vill- Lakrakhanda,

Po- Bokaro, Town/City- Bokaro Steel City, Tehsil/Taluka- Chas, Dist- Bokaro,

Jharkhand- 827010 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management:Private) (A.B.-Vinoba

BhaveUniversity) (Code No.ERCAPP708)








representation of the institution and observed as under:

(i) Institution submitted the faculty list including the name of Mrs. Sharda whereas as per letter

received from Mrs. Shards she has resigned from the post of lecturer.

(ii) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the





14. 171.2(ii).13

Vishweshwaraiya B.Ed. College, C/o – Samajik Kalyan Sanstha, Deoli, Po -

Jangalpur, Ps - Gobindpur, Dist - Dhanbad, Jharkhand - 826001 (Course:B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B. - Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00779)





78/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87037 dated 30.03.2014.


letter dated 24.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the representation of

the institution and observed as under:

(i) Initially, as per land document plots bearing numbers were 732, 738, 739, 418/2149, 418/2148,

Mauza No. 179, Khata No. 31 & 32 measuring land area 5.19 acres has been submitted by the

institution.

Now, the institution submitted another land document having plot Nos. 1548, 1549, 1560, 1561,

1562 & 1569 measuring land area 133.75 dec.

(ii) The plot Numbers mentioned in the previous land document and new land document does not

tally to each other. As per VT report the institution has shifted the premises of the institution

without getting permission from the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.

(iii) The institution in its representation has mentioned that the previous principal has quit from the

institution and another principal Dr. Miss Quyam Zehar was appointed. The institution has not

submitted the copy of advertisement, minutes of the selection committee, individual affidavit,

educational & professional certificates of the newly appointed principal alongwith the fresh

faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university.



8






15. 171.2(ii).14

Grizzly College of Education, Plot no. 468, Vill/PO/City- Jhumri Telaiya, Tehsil

Taluka-Koderma, Dist-Koderma, Jharkhand- 825409 (Course:B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B.- Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00799)





83/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86665 dated 01.05.2014.




(i) The institution is required to appoint a Librarian and submit the details of appointment.

(ii) A copy of the Bank authorization letter is to be sent to the institution for conversion of the FDR

of Rs. 3.00 lakh into joint name of institution and RD,ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.




16. 171.2(ii).15

Samarpan Deep B.Ed. College, Plot No. 271(Part), 271(a), Vill-Ushamatu,

PO-Ratu, Tehsil/Taluka-Ratu, City- Ranchi, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand-835222

(Course:B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (A.B.-Ranchi University)






39/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86403 dated 30.03.2014.




(i) It appears that the required faculty was not available before the inspection. The institution is

required to submit the previous faculty list alongwith cause of removal/resignation of the

previous faculty members.

(ii) Recently, the institution has appointed one principal and 05 lecturer. The relevant documents

like copy of advertisement, minutes of the selection committee, educational and professional

certificates of the newly appointed principal 05 lecturer were not attached.

(iii) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the







9

ER-171.4 Appeal Case

17. 171.4.1

Jai Prakash University, Plot No. 148, Vill/Po- Chapra, Tehsil/Taluka- Chapra,

Town/City- Saran, Dist.- Saran, Bihar-841301 (B.Ed.-Distance Mode) (University

Department) (Jai Prakash University) (Code No. APP1137)

As per 158th ERC meeting held on 23-24 July 2013, refusal order u/c 14(3)(b) was issued to the institution

vide letter No. 20220 dated 19.08.2013.

The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE Hqrs against the ERC’s order dated 19.08.2014. The Appellate

Authority vide its order No. 89-636/2013-Appeal/3rd

Meeting-2014/A86193 dated 24.03.2014 has remanded

the case to ERC with a direction to allow 30 days time to the University for selection & appointment of

required faculty members by revalidating the LOI to that extent.

The committee accepted the direction of the Appeal committee and decided as under:

The case will be processed/taken up as per the new Regulation.

18. 171.4.2

Assalam Educational Centre, Plot No - 443, 444, 452, 452, Street No - 68,

Vill/PO - Srikund, Tehsil/Taluka - Rajmahal, Town/City - Barharwa,

Dist.- Sahibganj, Jharkhand – 816101 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Code No. ERCAPP1513)

As per 150th ERC meeting held on 8-9 February 2013, refusal order u/c 7(1-A)(ii) was issued to the institution

vide letter No. 16664 dated 02.03.2013.

The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE Hqrs against the ERC’s order dated 02.03.2014. The Appellate

Authority vide its order No. 89-258/2013-Appeal/4th Meeting-2014/A86472 dated 28.04.2014 has remanded

the case to ERC with a direction to conduct a re-check of the records and ensure that appellant institution is

not deprived of its legal right to be considered simply because of misplacing or mix up of the documents in

some other file as claimed by the appellant. Also to make a through search for the other copies of the

application which might have been mixed up as the documents returned with the refusal order pertain to some

other institution.

The committee noted the direction and found as under:

The committee re-checked the file and found that the ground for summarily rejection was correct. There was

no mix up with file kept in the office. The institution itself submitted some other document alongwith an

affidavit dated 29.04.2014. Only one set of application was received. The committee stands with the

rejection order. The institution may apply a fresh as per new regulation.

ER-171.12 Misc. Cases

19. 171.12.1

Jote Kanuramgarh Mahatma Primary Teachers Training Institute, Vill/PO- Jot

Kanuramgarh, Ps- Daspur, Dist- Paschim Medinipur, West Bengal-721212

(D.El.Ed.)(Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education)

(Code No.ERCAPE00706)

W.P. No. 16691 (w) of 2013 and CAN No. 6749 of 2013 filed by Imdadul Haque & Ors. Vs the State of West

Bengal & Ors in the Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta.

The Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta has disposed of the Writ Petition on 19.08.2013 with a direction inter alia

“In order to finally conclude the controversy, I am of opinion that the NCTE and the WBBPE should conduct

a joint enquiry as regards the facilities and the infrastructure of the institution………

As per the request of West Bengal Board of Primary Education, Dr. U.N. Singh has been nominated by ERC

as a member of the Joint Inquiry Committee. The committee conducted the Inquiry and submitted the report.

The report was placed before the committee for consideration. During the discussion Dr. Manik

Bhattacharya, State Representative of West Bengal as well as President West Bengal Board of Primary

Education shown a letter received from NCTE Hqrs wherein the NCTE decided to conduct an inspection

under section 13 of NCTE Act 1993 alongwith the representative of West Bengal Board of Primary

Education.

In view of the above, The committee decided as under:

Defer the case till the report received from NCTE Hqrs. Report of the Joint Inquiry committee be forwarded

to West Bengal Board of Primary Education.



10

VOLUME-II

Sl.


ER-171.2(ii).

Court Case:



20. 171.2(ii).16

J.D. National B.Ed. College, Plot No. 148, Vill- Janum, Angara, Po- Angara, City-

Ranchi, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand- 835103 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private)

(Ranchi University) (Code No. ERCAPP520)





53/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86667 dated 01.05.2014.




(i) The land and building is to be Registered in the name of institution as per norms. The institution

is required to submit a certified copy of land document registered in the name of the institution

within 30 days from issue of the letter.

(ii) The Psychology Resource center , Art and Craft Resource centre are shortage of equipment.

(iii) Salary statement of staff last 3 months and EPF deduction to be submitted.




21. 171.2(ii).17 St. Xavier’s College, P.B. No.9, Purulia Road, Ranchi, Jharkhand–834001

(Course: B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit) (Ranchi University) (Code No. APE00244)





44/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86395 dated 30.04.2014.




(ii) The institution is required to appoint one more lecturer and submit a fresh faculty list duly

approved by the Registrar of the concerned university adding the name of newly appointed

lecturer.

(iii) Psychology Resource Center is not available in the institution.

(iv) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is to be submitted towards endowment fund

and reserve fund respectively into joint account in the name of institution and RD, ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar.






11

22. 171.2(ii).18

Ursuline Women’s Teacher Training College, Lohardaga, At/Po- Lohardagar,

Dist.- Lohardaga, Jharkhand-835302 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University)

(File No. JH-S/E-4/96)





54/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86399 dated 30.04.2014.




1. The part-time lecturers for Physical education and Fine Art/Music is to be appointed.

2. Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is to be submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.




23. 171.2(ii).19

Giridih College, PO- Sirsia, Dist- Giridih, Jharkhand-815301

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Constituent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No. APE00433)





68/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87025 dated 02.04.2014.




(i) The institution is running in the campus of Girdih Degree college having land area 11938.65

sq.m. with a number of buildings constructed thereon with a total built up area of 4500 sq.m..

The B.Ed course is also conducted by the institution alongwith other regular courses of the

college. The land and building is not demarcated for B.Ed course.

(ii) Multipurpose hall is 1259 sq.ft. only which is less then the required 2000 sq.ft.

(iii) The size of Computer lab and Psychology lab is very small.

(iv) The institution has engaged only 04 lecturers on contractual basis. One position of

HOD/principal and 03 positions of lecturers are vacant.

(v) Part-time lecturers for Art and Craft and Physical Eduction have not been appointed.

(vi) The institution does not fulfill the prescribed norms by not appointing a qualified HOD on

regular basis, by keeping three positions of lecturers vacant and by not appointing part-time

lecturers for physical Education and Art and Craft.

(vii) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is not submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.








12

24. 171.2(ii).20

N.N. Ghosh Sanatan Teachers Training College, Plot No-165, Vill- Jamuary,

Po-Kokodro Tehsil/Taluka- Kanke, Town/City-Rehala, Dist-Palamu, Jharkhand-

834006 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Ranchi University)






98/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86655 dated 01.05.2014.




(i) Recently, all the faculty members have joined between 25.09.2013 to 01.10.2013 that is, a few

days before of the special inspection. It appears that the required qualified faculty was not

available before the inspection. The institution is required to submit the previous faculty list

alongwith cause of removal/resignation of the previous faculty members.

(ii) Institution is also required to submit the fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the

concerned university alongwith the list of the other staff, minutes of the selection committee,

individual affidavit, education/professional certificates of the appointed faculty.




ER-171.2(iii).

Court Cases: Cases have been disposed up by the Hon’ble High Court. In the mean time

Supreme Court Direction has been received. Cases placed on the meeting.

25. 171.2(iii).1

Moulana Abul Kalam Azad Teachers Training College, Plot No-

47,48,81,82,83,84, St.No-NH-34, Vill.-Bagbari, P.O-Itanagar, Tehsil/Taluka-

Itahar, Town/City-Raiganj, Dist.-Uttar Dinajpur, West Bengal-733128 (Course

D.El..Ed.)(Code No. ERCAPP1498)

The application of the institution had been summarily rejected as per NCTE Regulation 2009 and

subsequently amended on 26.11.2010 under clause 7(1-A). Appeal committee has also confirmed the order of

the ERC.

The petitioner institution preferred writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta W.P. No. 35181 of

2013. The Hon’ble High Court has disposed of the writ petition on 14.03.2014 with a direction inter alia “the

impugned orders passed by both the Regional Authority as well as Appellate authority are set aside and the

Eastern Regional Committee and the NCTE are directed to reconsider the case of the writ petitioners within

six weeks from the date of communication of this order”.


File a review petition clearly stating the rule position as well as the recent supreme court order SLP (c) 4247-

4248/09.

26. 171.2(iii).2

Bangarh Scholar Teachers Training Institute: Plot No-15, Street. No.-S10 SHW,

Vill/P.o- Bolla, Tehsil/Taluka-Bolla Town/City-Balurghat, Dist:- Dakshin

Dinajpur,West Bengal-733158 (Course D.El.Ed.) (Code No. ERCAPP1391)



the ERC.

The petitioner institution preferred writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta vide W.P.No.

3926(w) of 2014. The Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta has disposed of the case on 11.02.2014 with a

direction inter alia “I set aside the impugned order and direct the concerned authority, especially the

respondent No 2 to consider the case of the petitioner upon giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner



13

or his authorised representative and the authority would allow the petitioner to submit relevant

judgments,documents and circulars in support of his claim. The respondent authority is directed to pass a

reasoned order and to communicate the same to the writ petitioner. The entire exercise would be completed

within a period of eight weeks from the date of communication of this order”.


As per the court order, the committee authorize the Regional Director who is respondent No. 2 to call the

petitioner for hearing their case and thereafter a reasoned order communicate to the petitioner.

27. 171.2(iii).3

Sunderban B.Ed College, Plot No 326,327,99/4778, Street Number-117, Vill-

Halder Chak, Tehsil/taluka-Kashi Nagar, Town/City-Kakdwip,P.o-

madhabnagar,Dist-South 24 Praganas. (Course-B.Ed) (Code ERCAPP1017)

W.P. No. 32429 (w) of 2013 C.A.N. No. 811 of 2014 Sunderban B.E. College & Ors Vs State of West Bengal

& Ors.

The Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta has disposed of the case on 26.02.2014 with a direction inter alia “ I set

aside all orders passed against the college authorities including refusal recognition and direct the concerned

respondents to reconsider the case of recognition afresh in its next meeting upon giving an opportunity of

hearing to the petitioner or their authorized representative and to communicate the decision to the petitioner

without any delay.


The petitioner be directed to appear before the RD with all relevant documents including the land documents

for hearing his case. The Regional Director may pass a reasoned order.

28. 171.2(iii).4

Aniel Primary Teacher’s Training Institute, plot No 8954-55/61, Street No.

Gourhati, Vill/Po-Gourhati, Tehsil/Taluka-Arambagh, Town/City- Gourhati, Dist –

Hoogly-712613, West Bengal (Course D.El.Ed) (Code ERCAPP1245)

The application of the institution had been refused vide order No. 15285 dated 14.12.2012 for the applied

course D.El.Ed under section 14 (3)(b) of NCTE Act 1993. Appeal committee has also confirmed the order of

the ERC.

The petitioner institution preferred writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta in W.P. No. 1386

(w) of 2014. The Hon’ble High Court has disposed of the case on 11.02.2014 with a direction to the NCTE to

make a fresh inspection within four weeks from the date of communication of the order and file report in the

court.


Counter affidavit to be filed.

29. 171.2(iii).5

Abdur Rahim Panchanan Pal Educational Institution: Plot No-9053, 9059, St. No.-

Choa, Vill/ P.O-Chowa, Town/City-Chowa, Dist: Murshidabad, West Bengal-

742166 (Course-B.Ed.) (Code No. ERCAPP1554)



the ERC.


2013. The Hon’ble High Court disposed of the case vide order dated 29.04.2014 with a direction inter alia

“Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties. It is not in dispute that as yet no new Regulation was

published nor effected. There is no question of consideration of application as per new Regulation as

indicated in the letter dated 26th

March, 2014. The concerned respondents will comply with the order and

take a decision accordingly to the rules which were prevailing at the time of submission of application by the

petitioner.”


Writ appeal against the order dated 29.04.2014 of Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta to be filed.



14

30. 171.2(iii).6

Odalchua Primary Teacher Training Institute, Plot No 46 and 47, ST No. P.W.D

Road, Vill Jukhia, P.o Jukhia Bazar, Tehsil Taluka-BhupatiNagar

(Course D.El.Ed) (Code-ERCAPP1779).

The petitioner institution has filed writ petition No W.P. No 4681 (w) of 2014 challenging the order dated

06.04.2013 and 26.08.2013 passed by the ERC-NCTE and the Appellate authority respectively in the Hon’ble

high court at Calcutta.

The Hon’ble High court at Calcutta has disposed of the writ petition with a direction inter alia “In my view,

the order impugned dated 6th April, 2013 as well as dated 26

th August, 2013 are not sustainable in law.

Accordingly, both the orders are set aside and the respondent no 2 is directed to rehear the matter upon giving

an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners or their authorized representative. The respondent no 2 is directed

to decide the matter by eights weeks from the date of communication of this order by the letter of the learned

Advocate appearing for parties”.


As per the court order, the committee authorizes the Regional Director who is respondent No. 2 to call the


31. 171.2(iii).7

Sagarpara Educational College: Plot No-l.r. 10733, Street. No./ Vill/

P.O-Sagarpara, Tehsil/Taluka-Jalangi, town/City-Berhampore Dist: Murshidabad,

West Bengal-742306 (Course-B.Ed.) (Code No. ERCAPP1494)



the ERC.


2013. The Hon’ble High Court disposed of the case with a direction inter alia “The council specially the

respondent No. 4 is directed to rehear the matter upon giving an opportunity of hearing and the committee will

consider the application for recognition of the institution and pass a reasoned order by six weeks and to

communicate the same by two weeks thereafter”


As per the court order, the committee authorize the Regional Director who is respondent No. 2 to call the


32. 171.2(iii).8

Domkal B.Ed College, Plot No 185, St. No Gobindapur, Vill: Gobindapur,

P.O- Joginda, Tehsil/Taluka-Domkal, Town/City-Domkal, Dist: Murshidabad,

West Bengal-742303. (Course-B.Ed) (Code ERC APP1763)

The petitioner institution has filed writ petition No W.P. No 10268 (w) of 2014 challenging the order dated



The Hon’ble High court at Calcutta has disposed of the writ petition with a direction inter alia “Accordingly,

both the orders passed by the Regional Committee as well as the Appellate Authority are contrary to the Rules

applicable and, therefore, the impugned orders are set aside. The concerned authorities are directed to

consider the case of the writ petitioner afresh following their own rule as well as taking note of the fact that

hard copies were deposited on 5th

January, 2013

Entire exercise should be completed within six weeks from date of communication of this order. Authorities who have returned the applications and other documents are directed to take back all the applications and

other relevant documents for consideration”.


Writ appeal be filed.



15

33. 171.2(iii).9

Malda Institute of Education and Training, Plot No 351, St. No NH-34,

Vill: Sonajhuri, P.O- Jhar pukuria, Tehsil/Taluka-Panchgaw,Town/City-Malda,

Dist Malda, West Bengal-732128. (Course-D.El.Ed) (Code ERC APP1424)

The petitioner institution has filed writ petition No W.P. No 8634 (w) of 2014 challanging the order dated



The Hon’ble High court at Calcutta has disposed of the writ petition with a direction inter alia “The Eastern

Regional Committee and NCTE is directed to reconsider the the case of the writ petitioner within six weeks

from the date of the communication of this order. The writ petitioner is permitted to file the application, which

was returned by the concerned respondent”.

The Regional Director has informed to the committee that the institution has already been informed vide

letter dated 02.04.2014 about the order dated 10.09.2013 passed in SLP (civil) 4247-4248/2009 by the

Hon’ble Supreme Court of India along with the copy of the order to the counsel to apprise the Hon’ble High

Court.

The committee noted the action taken of the Regional Director.

34. 171.2(iii).10

Netajee Subash Chandra Bose Institute of Education”, Plot No.-1, Vill.-ulda,

Po-Dhelaitbamu, Tehsil/Taluka-Purulia Sadar West, Town/City-Dhelaitbamu,

Dist.-Purulia, West Bengal-723127 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private)

(Affiliating Body: Sidho Kanhi Birsa University) (Code No .- Not available)



the ERC.

The petitioner institution preferred writ petition W.P No 31784 (w) of 2013 before the Hon’ble High court at

Calcutta for quashing the order dated 23.02.2013 as well as 26.08.2013 passed by ERC-NCTE and The

Appellate Authority, NCTE Hqrs. respectively. The Hon’ble High court vide its interim order dated

11.02.2014 directs inter alia “The impugned order passed by the appellate authority as well as the NCTE

dated 23rd

February, 2013 is set aside and the appellate authority is directed to consider the the application

of the petitioner afresh as per Clause 7A(I) of Regional Rules.

The respondent authorities are directed to complete the entire exercise within a period of six weeks from

the date of communication of the order”.




Court.

The committee noted the action taken of the Regional Director.

35. 171.2(iii).11

VIET Sansthan: Plot No-1739, Street. No.-Sahapur, Vill- Sahapur Tiwari Urf

Totaha, P.O-Lalganj, Tehsil/Taluka-Hazipur Town/City-Vaisali, Dist:Vaisali,

Bihar-844121 (Course-B.Ed.) (Code No. ERCAPP1681)



the ERC.

That the petitioner institution preferred writ petition before the Hon’ble High court of Delhi at New Delhi

Vide W.P. (c) No 7955 of 2013 Challenging the order of ERC dated 02.03.2013 and the order of Appellate

Authority dated 25.10.2013.



16

That the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi at New Delhi has disposed of the Writ petition on 25.02.2014 with a

direction inter alia “the impugned order dated 2nd

March,2013 and 25th

October, 2013 are set aide and the

matter is remanded back to Erastern Regional Committee of National Counsel for Teacher Education .

The Regional Committee is directed to issue a fresh show cause notice to the petitioner within a period of

three weeks”.




Court. But the letter sent to the institution had been returned undelivered both of the time.

The committee noted the action taken of the Regional Director and decided as under:

The letter to the institution be uploaded in the website of ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.

VOLUME-III

Sl.


ER-171.2(ii).

Court Case:



36. 171.2(ii).21

Maharshi Paramhansh College of Education, Plot No. 2109, Vill- Huhua, Po-

Ramgarh Cantt, Tehsil/Taluka- Ramgarh, Dist- Hazaribagh, Jharkhand-829122

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.ERCAPP523)





103/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87017 dated 22.04.2014.




(i) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the





37. 171.2(ii).22

Lala Pritam B.Ed College, Plot No. 1303, 1301, 1292, 1298, Vill-Kishunpur, Po-

Chatra, Tehsil/Taluka-Chatra, Dist-Chatra, Jharkhand-825401 (Course:B.Ed.)

(Private) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code

No.ERCAPP607)





24/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86405 dated 30.03.2014.




(i) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the


(ii) Academic calendar is to be submitted.



17

(iii) Equipments in Science and Math Resource Centers are not available.




38. 171.2(ii).23

Rama Krishna Vivekananda College of Education, Vill/PO – Bagodar,

Dist – Giridih, Jharkhand – 825322 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private)






120/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87029 dated 24.04.2014.


letter dated 19.05.2014 & 20.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the

representation of the institution and decided as under:

Recognition of the institution be continued.

39. 171.2(ii).24 R.P.S. College, PO-Jharia, Dist.-Dhanbad, Jharkhand-828111 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Constituent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00428)





69/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86379 dated 30.04.2014.




(i) Psychology lab, Science lab, Art and Craft resource center is not available in the institution.The

infrastructure facilities in the institution are insufficient.

(ii) Books in the library is only 1315 which is less then the required 3000.

(iii) Three lecturers are available in the institution who are appointed on contractual basis which is

against the rules. The faculty must be appointed on regular basis. The required faculty is one

principal, six lecturers and two part-time lecturers for physical education and fine arts/music.

(iv) The institution has not submitted a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the


(v) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is not submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.








18

40. 171.2(ii).25

Gautam Buddha Teacher’s Training College, Hazaribag, Vill- Shankarpur,

P.o./Dist- Hazaribag, Jharkhand- 825301 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Vinoba Bhave

University) (Code No.APE00812)





101/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87027 dated 21.04.2014.




1. The committee considered the application submitted by the institution for shifting of premises and

examined all the required documents.


1. VT will be constituted for shifting of premises as per new Regulation for issuance of formal shifting

order.

2. Recognition of the institution be continued.

41. 171.2(ii).26 Santhal Pargana College, Dumka, Jharkhand-814101 (Course: B.Ed.) (Constituet

Unit) (S.K.M. University) (Code No.APE00435)





107/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87049 dated 22.04.2014.




(i) In the VT report dated 25.05.2005 of the inspection conducted prior to grant of recognition

indicated that the proposal of the institution was to conduct the B.Ed course for the present

identified classrooms, hall, office room etc. alongwith other courses of the institution. There was

proposal for construction of a separate 4-storey building exclusively for the B.Ed department

within the campus. Land was also earmarked for the B.Ed department. The principal of the

institution also gave an undertaking dated 06.12.2004 that infrastructural, instructional and other

facilities will be provided as per the NCTE norms.

(ii) During special inspection of the institution, it is reveals that B.Ed course is still being conducted

in a very old double storey building having only 06 rooms with inadequate facilities. The

furniture are not proper.

(iii) There is no science lab, psychology lab, language lab, Art and works experience room

exclusively for B.Ed course.

(iv) There is no Multipurpose hall in this institution.

(v) The size of the library is only 246.5 sq.ft. having 1285 books only which is less as per norms.

(vi) Principal and two part-time lecturers for Physical education and fine art/music is not available.

(vii) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is not submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.








19

42. 171.2(ii).27

S.B.M. Teacher’s Training College, AT-Masipiri, PO – Babhanbai, Dist –

Hazaribagh, Jharkhand – 825301 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (A.B.-

Vinoba BhaveUniversity) (Code No. APE00873)





60/2014/NCTE/Insp/A85685 dated 07.04.2014.




(i) During the hearing of the appeal, the institution submitted that its intention was to conduct the

B.Ed course temporarily in the leased premises having a built up area of 1500 sq.mts. on a plot of

land measuring 0.509 acres of 2396.94 sq.mt. and to shift to its permanent premises with an area

of 2569 sq.mts. to be constructed on a plot No. 311/3 under khata No. 37, Thana No 172, Thana

– Hazaribag measuring 3973.88 sq.m. Necessary documentary evidence namely land documents ,

approved building plan etc in this regard were also submitted by the institution during the appeal.

Keeping in view the above, the appeal was accordingly accepted on 11.06.2009 leading to finally

granting recognition the institution.

(ii) Now, during the special inspection it is revealed that the institution is still functioning in the

leased ground floor building of the temporary premises which do not fulfill the requirement as

per the NCTE norms. The area of the land is only 2396.94 sq.m which is less then the required

2500 sq.m. The area of the multipurpose hall is 99.864 sq.m. or 1075 sq.ft which is less then the

required 2000 sq.ft.

(iii) Further, the institution handed over photo-copies of another sale deed executed on 10.06.2011 to

VT measuring 1 acre of land on plot No. 1 under khasra No. 1014 & 1015 in Babhanbai,

Hazaribad stated to have been purchased by the institution for construction of a new building for

the institution alongwith a approved building plan.

(iv) The proposed new premises is different from the permanent premises of land measuring 3973.88

sq.m. on which a 2-storey building having 2569 sq,m. was proposed to be constructed as per the

submission made before the Appeal Committee alongwith documentary evidence on 15.09.2009,

on the basis of which the appeal was accepted leading to grant of recognition to the institution.

The institution obtained recognition by submitting false documents.

(v) The new sale deed dated 10.09.2011 now submitted cannot be accepted.

(vi) The institution engaged one principal and five lecturers. As per requirements 01 full time

lecturer has not appointed.

(vii) Original copy of faculty list is not submitted with due approval of the Registrar of the concerned

university alongwith minutes of the selection committee, copy of news paper cutting, consent

from the appointed faculty, individual affidavit, bio-data and all educational/professional

certificates.






43. 171.2(ii).28 Guru Nanak College, Dhanbad, Post Box No. 93, Dist.-Dhanbad, Jharkhand-

826001 (Course:B.Ed.) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00429)





91/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86659 dated 01.05.2014.


letter dated 26.05.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the representation of the institution and observed as under:



20

(i) The institution is functioning as a department of the General Degree college. The principal of the

Guru Nanak College, Dhanbad has also submitted an undertaking dated 08.10.2004 on non-

judicial stamp paper that the infrastructural, instructional and other facilities will be provided for

B.Ed course as norms.

(ii) Now, during the special inspection it is found that khalsa college and Khalsa school are ruunng in

the same campus which is against the rules. Two class rooms have a space only 437 sq.ft. each as

against the requirement of 500 . Size of multipurpose hall is only 1890 sq,ft, only which is less

then the required 2000 sq.ft. The size of library, science lab and computer lab are very small and

inadequate. Psychology lab is not available in the institution. The Art and Craft room is available

but it has not been equipped with relevant material.

(iii) Encyclopedia is not available in the library.

(iv) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is not submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.






44. 171.2(ii).29

Mahila College, Po- Chaibasa, Dist- West Singhbhum, Jharkhand - 833201

(Course: B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit) (Kolhan University)

(Code No.APE00353)





107/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87049 dated 01.05.2014.




(i) The B.Ed course is being conducted in one portion of the existing building of the general college

namely the Mahila college. The existing B.Ed block has nine room with a built up area of 3831

sq.ft. which is less then the required 1500 sq.mts

(ii) The Multipurpose hall, staff room, common room for girls and boys and Art & Work Experience

room are not available.

(iii) No land and building is specifically earmarked for the B.Ed course.

(iv) One of the condition stipulated in the recognition order dated 12.05.2005 was that the institution

shall shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition. The institution has

failed to fulfill this condition even after more than eight years of recognition.

(v) The new building for B.Ed programe is under construction.

(vi) Books in the library are only 748 which is less then the required 3000.

(vii) The institution does not have its own Science Resource Center, ICT or Educational Technology

Resource Center. Art and Craft Resource Center have not been setup.

(viii) The recruited lecturers are on contractual basis which is against the rules. Faculty must be

appointed on Regular basis.

(ix) Principal/HOD is not appointed. Mathematic lecturer is also not appointed.

(x) Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is not submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.








21

45. 171.2(ii).30

Elite Public B.Ed. College, Plot No. 585, Vill/Po.- Chianki, Tehsil/Taluka- Sadar,

Daltonganj, Dist- Palamu, Jhrkhand - 822101 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Nilamber

Pitamber University) (Code No.ERCAPP546)





58/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86446 dated 30.04.2014.




1. The institution is required to appoint one more lecturer and submit a fresh faculty list duly approved

by the Registrar of the concerned university adding the name of newly appointed lecturer.

2. The part-time lecturers for Physical education and Fine Art/Music have not been appointed.

3. Salary statement of staff last 3 months and EPF deduction to be submitted.




ER-171.2(iii).

Court Cases:

Cases have been disposed up by the Hon’ble High Court In the mean time

Supreme Court Direction has been received. Cases placed on the meeting.

46. 171.2(iii).12

Jogendra Rajkrishna college of Teacher Education, Plot No 335,356, At-

street/Road-Amberia P.W.D Road, Vill/Po-Amberia, Tehsil/Taluka-Hingaganj,

Town/City-Village, Dist-North 24 Praganas-743435, West Bengal. (Course-B.Ed)

(Code-ERCAPP1022)

The application of the institution had been refused for the applied course B.Ed under clause 14(3)(b) of NCTE

Act 1993. Appeal committee has also confirmed the order of the ERC.

The petitioner institution preferred writ petition before the Hon’ble High court at Calcutta in W.P. No. 33782

(w) of 2013 challenging the order dated 15.10.2013 passed by the Appellate Authority i.e NCTE Hqrs.

The Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta vide its order dated 27.01.2014 has disposed of the writ application with

a direction inter alia “Accordingly I set aside the order dated 15th

October,2013 and directed the respondent

authority to re hear out the appeal on merit upon giving the parties an opportunity of hearing and to pass a

reasoned order within eight weeks from the date of communication of this order and to communicate the

reasoned order by two weeks from the date of passing such order”.


As per the court order, the committee authorized the Regional Director to call the petitioner for hearing their

case and thereafter a reasoned order communicate to the petitioner.



22

ER-171.4 Appeal Case

47. 171.4.1

Department of Education Vinaya Bhavana Institute of Education Visva Bharati

Santiniketan WB, Plot No.-2064/2507, PO.-Santiniketan, Tehsil/Taluka-Surul,

Town/City-Bolpur, Dist.-Birbhum, West Bengal-731235 (M.Ed) (University

Department) (Code No.ERCAPP2054)

Application was refused

The appeal committee remanded case back to ERC vide letter No. 49-15/2013/NCTE/N&S dated 12.09.2013

with a direction to process the application considering the relaxation given by the NCTE vide its letter No.

F49-15/2013/NCTE/N&S dated 12.09.2013 and Para 1(3) of the Norms and Standards for programme leading

to M.Ed degree.


VT be constituted as per new Regulations.

ER-171.7 Shifting of Premises

48. 171.7.1

Mirza Galib Teachers Training College, A/7-Indrapuri Colony Ashiyana Road,

Raja Bazar, Patna, Bihar-800014

To be shifted:-

Mirza Galib Teachers Training College, Plot No. 933 & 935, Vill/Town-Patna,

PO-Sorampur, City/Dist.-Patna, Bihar-801504


Regulations and guidelines issued by NCTE Hqrs., and reply dated 27.01.2014 for shifting of premises, the

Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under:

VT for shifting of premises to be constituted as per new Regulations.

ER-171.12 Misc. Cases

49. 171.12.2

Sova Rani College Of Education, Vill-Gobindapur, Tehsil/Taluka-Birahimpur,

City-Malda, P.O-Birampur, Dist-Malda, West Bengal-732207 (D.El.Ed.)

(WBBPE) (Code No.ERCAPP1272)

The following complaints received against the institution:

1. Complaint dated 10.2.2014 received from Bijan Poddar, Vill- Nazal pur, Dist- Malda.

2. Complaint dated 18.02.2014 received from Ram Singh, Mahadebpur, Dist- Malda.

3. Complaint dated 28.02.2014 received from Sukhdeb Biswas, Vill- Mohan Bagan, Dist- Malda.

4. Complaint dated 10.03.2014 received from Amit Kumar Mishra, Belgharia, Kolkata.

In view of the above the above, the committee decided as under:

A copy of the complaints may be forwarded to the Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education, West

Bengal with a request to inquire the matter by conducting an inspection and to submit the report within 30

days to ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar.

50. 171.12.3

Chatta Primary Teacher’s Training Institute, Po-Chatta Kalikapur, Via-Batanagar,

Ps-Maheshtala, Dist-South 24 Parganas, West Bengal-700140 (D.El.Ed.)

(WBBPE) (Code No.ERCAPE00771)


1. Complaint dated 29.1.2014 received from S.K. Saiful Islam.

2. Complaint dated 05.02.02.2014 received from S.K. Meah Alam.

3. Complaint dated 03.05.2014 received from Md. Sabir Mahmood.







23

51. 171.12.4

Agnibina College of Education, Plot No. 811, 812, 813, St. No.-34, Vill.-

Dewansaray, P.O.-Laskarpur, Tehsil/Taluka-Lalgola, Town/City-Jangipur, Dist.-

Murshidabad, West Bengal-742151 (D.El.Ed.) (WBBPE) (Code

No.ERCAPP1654).

The SDL&LRO vide letter dated 26.02.2014 submitted that a physical inquiry was held along with

BL&LRO, Lalgola, it is seen that 67 dec of land in plot No. 811, 812 & 813 J.L. No. 15, Mouza-

Gouridaspur is recorded in favour of Secretary, Agnibina College of Education and the college authority has

built up college building theron. Now, the allegation of land where the petitioners claimed that an

unauthorized construction has been made, used for drainage of water of village house. At present there is no

construction or boundary wall in the alleged portion through it appears that an effort was made to start a

construction in that portion. The spokesman of the college authority informed us that they had the work but

did not proceed. However, the college authority are warned not encroach the drain in future.

1. Complaint letter dtd. 11.08.2013 received in this office on 16.08.2013 from Isha Md. Chowdhury,

Treasurer, Ehasan Mandal Memorial Trust & Agnibina College of Education regarding Land

Documents and Endowment Fund, Reserve Fund and Bank Account defective in favour of application

code No. ERCAPP1654. This approved construction of building plan of Agnibina College of

Education of 16000 sq. Ft. As a NCTE Norms. But existing building of 12000 sq. Ft. As a illegal

construction. Not NCTE Norms and guide line.

2. Complaint letter dtd. Nil received in this office on 05.07.2013 from Samaun Sk. Regarding

information regarding an illegal construction of (Agnibina College of Education, Plot No. 811, 812 and

813, J.L. No. 15-15, Mouza Garidaspur) (Code No. ERCAPP1654) Not contiguous in nature of land.

In view of following a copy of the application seeking grant of recognition for conducting of D.El.Ed.

course submitted by the Agnibina College of Education of autheised Chairperson Mr Jahangir Alam.

Plot No. 811, 812 and 813 total land area 0.67 acres and area not contiguous in nature of land. It is

shown that the building of the college is being built in three plots, plot no. 811, 812 and 813 total land

area 0.67 acre the other two plots 812 and 813 belongs to other person and area not contiguous in

nature of land.


A copy of the inquiry report received from SD&LRO be sent to complainants and institution for record and

future action. A copy be sent to the Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education for information and

necessary action.

52. 171.12.5

Dhyaneswar Subodh College, Plot No.-287, St/No.-Tamluk Rd., Vill.-Gogras

Court Taluk, P.O.-Raghunath Bari, Tehsil/Taluka-Gogras, Court Taluk,

Town/City-Tamluk, Dist.-Midnapore, West Bengal-721634 (D.El.Ed.) (Private)

(WBBPE) (Code No.ERCAPP1833)


1. Complaint dated 22.1.2014 received from Sh. Buddhadev Bhunia, Advocate, High Court Calcutta.

2. Complaint dated 04.04.2014 received from Shyamal Paul.







24

VOLUME-IV

Sl.


ER-171.2(ii).

Court Case:

Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction given

by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand.

53. 171.2(ii).31

Sanghamitra Teacher Training College, Vill- Manatu, PO.- Ormanjhi, Tehsil/

Taluka- Ormanjhi, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand – 835219 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi

University) (Code No.ERCAPP41)





23/2014/NCTE/Insp/A85325 dated 13.03.2014.




(i) The Foundation/Trust runs a school and the B.Ed College in the same campus and shares many

facilities with the school. Separate land and building are not demarcated for B.Ed course required

as per norms.

(ii) Library is housed in a small room having seating capacity of 15 persons and not suitable for a

B.Ed college.

(iii) The ICT Resource Centre has also been setup in a small room which is not fit for a computer lab.

(iv) The Psychology lab set up in a class room does not have the required number of tests.

(v) As per VTR , the facilities actually created for the school have been claimed to be the facilities of

the B.Ed college. Thus the institution is very deficient in terms of instructional facilities.

(vi) The institution is not having a qualified Principal. There is no qualified regular Librarian in the

institution.

(vii) The institution is having only 04 lecturers out of which 03 are on adhoc basis. As per norms

faculty must be appointed on Regular basis. The teaching faculty is not appointed as per

requirement of norms. Non of the faculty member is approved by the affiliating university as on

the date of inspection. Thus violated the norms regarding appointment of faculty.

(viii) Salary to the staff are not being paid as per norms.

(ix) Only 5 practice teaching schools are arranged.

(x) The institution has not maintained the FDRs of RS. 5.00 and Rs. 3.00 lakh into the joint

operation as stipulated in the recognition order.






54. 171.2(ii).32

Subash Teacher’s Training College, Vill- Koldiha, Po- Giridih, Dist.- Giridih,

Jharkhand- 815301 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.ERCAPP46)





35/2014/NCTE/Insp/A85683 dated 07.04.2014.


letter dated 25.04.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the representation of the institution and observed as under:

1. Most of the lecturers are appointed on adhoc basis. The institution is required to appoint one



25

principal and six lecturers on Regular basis as well as two part time lecturers one for Physical

Education and another for Fine Arts/Music.

2. Fresh faculty list duly signed by Registrar of the concerned university alongwith other related

documents i.e. minutes of the selection committee, individual affidavit, educational/professional

certificates etc.





55. 171.2(ii).33

Mother Ziramani Teachers Training College, Plot No.- 829 & 830, Vill- Gunja,

PO-Hendebili, Tehsil/Taluka- Ormanjhi, City/Dist.- Ranchi, Jharkhand- 835219

(B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University) (Code

No.ERCAPP685)





109/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87019 dated 30.04.2014.




1. The institution is required to appoint two lecturers and one librarian on Regular basis.

2. Fresh faculty list duly signed by Registrar of the concerned university alongwith other related

documents i.e. minutes of the selection committee, individual affidavit, educational/professional

certificates etc.





56. 171.2(ii).34

Tetri Chandravansi College of Education, Garhwa, Vill- Pindra, PO/PS/Dist.-

Garhwa, Jharkhand-822114 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University)

(Code No.APE00767)





29/2014/NCTE/Insp/A85327 dated 13.03.2014.


letter dated 12.04.2014 & 17.04.2014 to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the

representation of the institution and observed as under:

1. Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh is to be submitted towards endowment fund and


Bhubaneswar.






26

ER-171.5 VTR received U/S 14/15

57. 171.5.1

College of Teacher Education, Bhawanipatna, Plot No.- 172/2, 185/2, Vill-

Paramanandapur, PO – Bhawanipatna, Tehsil/Taluka – Bhawanipatna,

Town/City – Bhawanipatna, Dist – Kalahandi, Odisha, 766001 (D.El.Ed.-Add.

Intake) (Government) (Sambalpur University) (Code No.APP1850)


Regulations and guidelines issued by NCTE Hqrs. VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and

decided as under:

NCTE Hqrs. vide letter No.A78554 Dt. 3.12.2013 given relaxation to the DIET/DRC/STS of Odisha

as one time major with following direction.

“The procedure for processing the request of the Government of Odisha would be initiated; the

formal letter of approval would however, be issued subject to the following to conditions:

a. All staff as per the norms and standards of NCTEis in place by February 2014.

b. There is an adequate budgetary allocation in the budget of the State Government for the year

2014-15, for provision of requisite infrastructure as per the norms and standards of NCTE.

2. As per the decision of the ERC in its 166th

meeting held on 19-20 December, 2013, the

Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Department of School and Mass Education, Govt of Odisha vide

letter dated 01.01.2014 was requested to comply the requirement as stated in above paragraph.

And as per the decision of 163rd

ERC meeting VT has been constituted and inspection has

been conducted on 10.03.2014.

The VT report and other document has put up before the Committee & the Committee

decided as under:

The deficiency pointed out by the VT member be communicated to institution, Govt. of Odisha, NCTE Hqrs.

and MHRD Govt. of India to fulfill all the requirement as per NCTE Norms by December 2014

58. 171.5.2

District Institute of Education and Training, Dhenkanal, Plot No.- 3274, 3273,

3276, Street No.- NH-55, Vill – Dhenkanal, PO – Dhenkanal, Tehsil/Taluka –

Dhenkanal, Town/City – Dhenkanal, Town, Dist – Dhenkanal, Odisha - 759001

(D.El.Ed.-Add. Intake) (Government) (Board of Secondary Education) (Code

No. APP1846)



decided as under:

















27


decided as under:



59. 171.5.3

Govt. Secondary Training School, Dharmagarh, Plot No.- 808/1206, Street No.-

M. Road, Vill – Dharmagarh, PO- Dharmagarh, Tehsil/Taluka – Dharmagarh,

Town/City – Dharmagarh, Dist – Kalahandi, Odisha – 766015 (D.El.Ed.-Add.

Intake) (Government) (Board of Secondary Education) (Code

No. APP1894)



decided as under:
















decided as under:



ER-171.7 Shifting of Premises

60. 171.7.2

Oriental College of Education, Scholar Public School (Campus), Mohalla-

Faizullakhan, Khan Chowk, Darbhanga, Bihar-846004

To be shifted:-

Oriental College of Education, Plot No. 1679, 2100, 394, 2103, 1264, 356, Vill-

Shisho, Po-Shisho West, Tehsil/Taluka- Darbhanga, Town/City- Darbhanga,

Dist.-Darbhanga, Bihar-846005


Regulations and guidelines issued by NCTE Hqrs., and reply dated 11.01.2014 in response to shifting of

premises, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under:

1. Principal is not appointed as per norms.

2. VT for shifting of premises be constituted as per new Regulations.


Principal to be appointed as per norms and following due procedure.



28

VOLUME-V

Sl.


ER-171.2(ii).

Court Case:

Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction given

by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand.

61. 171.2(ii).35

R.T.C. B.Ed. College, Vill-P.H.E.D., Buti, Po- Bariyatu, Dist-Ranchi,

Jharkhand - 834009 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University)

(Code No.APE00780)





111/2014/NCTE/Insp/A87035 dated 23.04.2014.




(i) As per special inspection report, the institution is not having proper land documents.

(ii) Building plan approved by any Govt Engineer mentioning plot Nos, total area of land, total built

up area, measurement of rooms etc alongwith an unedited CD covering whole area of the land

and building is to be submitted.

(iii) The required equipments and consumable items are not available in the Science and Mathematics

laboratories.

(iv) Facilities for Art and Craft laboratories are not available.

(v) The institution organized fresh interview on 04.09.2013 that is, a few days before of the special

inspection and selected one principal and six lecturers.

(iii) It appears that the required faculty was not available before the special inspection. The

institution is required to submit the previous faculty list alongwith cause of removal/resignation

of the previous faculty members.

(vi) Institution is also required to submit the fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the

concerned university alongwith the list of the other staff, minutes of the selection committee,

individual affidavit, education/professional certificates of the appointed faculty.

(vii) The institution is required to submit a blue print of the building plan mentioning total built up

area and measurement of rooms and halls duly approved by any Govt Engineer alongwith an

unedited CD covering whole area of the building specially rooms and halls.

(viii) Building completion certificate issued from any Govt Engineer.




62. 171.2(ii).36

Swami Ram Krishan Paramhansh Teacher Training College, Vill/PO -

Karmatand, Dist – Bokaro, Jharkhand - 828307 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private)






31/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86671 dated 01.05.2014.





29


1. The institution in its reply dated 28.05.2014 is stated that the visiting team has not visited the

institution whereas the visiting team has submitted its report.


A copy of the representation of the institution be sent to the NCTE Hqrs for further direction.

ER-171.5 VTR received U/S 14/15

63. 171.5.4

District Institute of Education and Training (DIET), Bhawanipatna, Kalahandi,

Plot No.- 830, Street No.- Naktiguda, Vill - Naktiguda, PO - Bhawanipatna,

Tehsil/Taluka - Bhawanipatna, town/City - Bhawanipatna, Dist - Kalahandi,

Odisha - 766001 (D.El.Ed.-Add. Intake) (Government) (Board of Secondary

Education) (Code No.APP1880)



decided as under:
















decided as under:



64. 171.5.5

Government Secondary Training School, Plot No.- 2094, 2046, 2097, 2098,

Street No.- Bagudi, Vill – Bagudi, PO – Mahumuhan, Tehsil/Taluka – Soro,

Town/City – Soro, Dist – Balasore, Odisha - 756045 (D.El.Ed.-Add. Intake)

(Government) (Board of Secondary Education) (Code No. APP1896)



decided as under:





30














decided as under:



The meeting ended with vote of thanks.