proceedings of 174rd meeting of the erc-ncte held on

Proceedings of 174th Meeting of ERC-NCTE held on 5th August, 2014

Shri Chandrapida Neelap (RD/Convener, ERC, NCTE) Prof P C Mahapatra (Chairperson ERC, NCTE)

1

PROCEEDINGS OF 174rd

MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE

HELD ON 5th

AUGUST, 2014

The 174th

Meeting of the Eastern Regional Committee (ERC), National Council for Teacher

Education (NCTE) was convened on 5th

August, 2014 at Conference Hall, ERC, NCTE,

15, Neelakantha Nagar, Nayapalli, Bhubaneswar. The Chairperson, Members and Convener as listed below

were present at the time of the 174th ERC Meeting.

Prof.(Dr.) P.C. Mahapatra - Chairperson

Prof. Brajanath Kundu - Member

Dr. Shukla Mahanty - Member

Prof. Manik Bhattacharjee - State representative Govt. of West Bengal

Mr. Sanjiva Suman - State representative of Bihar

Dr. Vanlalhruaii - State representative of Mizoram

Dr. Rukhono Iralu - State representative of Nagaland

Dr. Tilottama Senapati - State representative of Odisha

Shri Chandrapida Neelap - Regional Director, ERC & Convener.

At the outset, the Regional Director welcomed all the members of Committee and apprised them

about the provisions of the NCTE Act, Rules, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time. With the

permission of Chairperson, Shri Chandrapida Neelap (Convener) presented the Agenda before the

Committee for its due consideration and appropriate decision.

Sl.

No. Item No. Content

ER-174.1

Confirmation of the Proceedings of 173rd

ERC meeting, 26th

June, 2014 at

Bhubaneswar.

Confirmed

The committee unanimously decided that the institution may reply in response to

the decision of the committee uploaded on the ERC website without waiting

formal letters from the office of ERC. The replies so received will also be

considered by the committee.

ER-174.2(ii)

Court Case:

Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction

given by the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand.

1. 174.2(ii).1

J.D. National B.Ed. College, Plot No. 148, Vill-Janum, Angara, Po- Angara, City-

Ranchi, Dist-Ranchi, Jharkhand-835103 (Course:B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi

University) (Code No.ERCAPP520)

A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda – Vs -

Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the Hon’ble

High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13

of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, clarification letter was issued to the

institution on 16.06.2014.

In response to the clarification letter, the institution submitted its reply dt. 12.07.2014 to the ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply dated 12.07.2014

submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under:

i. As per NCTE norms, the academic staff of the institution( including part time staff) shall be paid

such salary in such scale of pay as may be prescribed by the UGC/University from time to time,

through account payee cheque or as per advice as per advice into the bank account of employee

specifically opened for the purpose. The supporting shall be paid as per the UGC/State

Government/Central Government pay scale structure.

ii. The institution is required to submit the 3 months Bank statement clearly stating that amount has

been deposited in the bank account of the staff.

i. The educational/professional certificates of the appointed Librarian is required alongwith

appointment letter.

In view of the above, the committee decided as under:

A clarification letter be issued to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter

before the Committee takes final decision.



2

2. 174.2(ii).2

Mother Ziramani Teachers Training College, Plot No.- 829 & 830, Vill- Gunja,

Po-Hendebili, Tehsil / Taluka-Ormanjhi, City/Dist.- Ranchi, Jharkhand- 835219

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Ranchi University)

(Code No.ERCAPP685)





institution 0n 18.06.2014.

In response to the clarification letter, the institution submitted its reply dt. 02.07.2014

to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply

dated 02.07.2014 submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under:




specifically opened for the purpose. The supporting staff shall be paid as per the UGC/State




iii. The educational/professional certificates of the appointed Librarian is to be submitted.




3. 174.2(ii).3

Elite Public B.Ed. College, Plot No. 585, Vill/Po.- Chianki, Tehsil/Taluka-Sadar,

Daltonganj, Dist-Palamu, Jhrkhand - 822101 (Course : B.Ed.) (Private) (Nilamber

Pitamber University) (Code No.ERCAPP546)





















3

4. 174.2(ii).4

Chanakya Teachers Training College, Plot No.- 506, Vill - Sapaha,

PO - Madhupur, Tehsil/Taluka - Madhupur, City - Madhupur, Dist - Deoghar,

Jharkhand - 815353 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (S. K. M. University)

(Code No.ERCAPP458)









(i) The lecturer in Mathematics is to be appointed following due procedure.

(ii) The institution is required to submit the fresh faculty list adding the name of the newly

appointed lecturer duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university.


Show Cause notice be issued to the institution as to why the recognition to the institution be not withdrawn on

the above points. The Committee therefore, provides an opportunity under section 17(1) of the NCTE Act

1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee

takes final decision.

5. 174.2(ii).5

Jasidih B.Ed. College, Plot No. 23 Part & 24 Part, Town – Jasidih, Po- Jasidih,

Dist- Deogarh, Jharkhand – 814142 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (S.K.M. University)

(Code No.ERCAPP58)

A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No.327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda - Vs -



of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a clarification letter

dated 26.06.2014.

In response to the clarification letter, the institution submitted its reply dated 18.07.2014 to the ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of NCTE Hqrs as well as representation submitted by the

institution, the matter was discussed in detail and decided as under:

Recognition of the institution be continued.

6. 174.2(ii).6

Dev Sangha Institute of Professional Studies and Educational Research, Po-Dev

Sangha, Bompas Town, Deoghar, Jharkhand – 814114 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B.-S.K.M. University) (Code No. APE00219 &

ERCAPP1074)





dated 18.06.2014.







4

7. 174.2(ii).7

B.B.M. B.Ed. College, Plot No. 788, 813, & 797, Vill/Po. – Sardaha,

Tehsil/Taluka – Chas, Town/City – Bokaro, Dist. – Bokaro, Jharkhand –827013

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.ERCAPP510)



















8. 174.2(ii).8

Bharathi College of Education, Plot No. 587, Vill-Kandri, Po-Mandar,

Tesil/Taluka/Town/City–Mandar, Dist-Ranchi, Jharkhand-835214 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No.ERCAPP502)





dated 17.06.2014.





9. 174.2(ii).9 Ranchi Women’s College, Circular Road, Ranchi, Jharkhand-834001 (B.Ed)

(Constituent College) (Ranchi University) (Code No.APE00287)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, Show cause notice u/s 17(1) was issued to

the institution on 03.07.2014.

In response to the show cause notice, the institution submitted its reply dt. 10.07.2014 to the ERC, NCTE,



1. The institution has failed to observe the NCTE prescribed norms related to instructional facilities

and engagement of academic and supporting staff as it does not have.

(i) Well demarcated campus.

(ii) Appropriately equipped Resource Rooms.

(iii) Regular HOD.

(iv) The required Teaching and supporting staff on regular basis.

(v) It is not maintaining Endowment and Reserve Funds jointly with the Regional Director,

ERC, Bhubaneswar, as required.



5


Last opportunity is given to the institution to submit the compliance within 30 days from the publication of

minutes in the ERC website, failing which, the recognition of the institution will be withdrawn as per NCTE

norms.

A copy of the above show cause notice to be issued to the institution be endorsed to the Principal Secretary,

Ministry of HRD Govt of Jharkhand and Registrar of the concerned university for information and necessary

action.

10. 174.2(ii).10

Maharshi Paramhansh College of Education, Plot No. 2109, Vill- Huhua,

Po- Ramgarh Cantt, Tehsil/Taluka- Ramgarh, Dist- Hazaribagh, Jharkhand-829122

(Course : B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.ERCAPP523)









i. The supporting documents for appointment like minutes of selection committee, individual

affidavit along with educational & professional certificate etc. of newly appointed lecturers are

not submitted. Also the institution has not submitted the cause of removal/resignation of the

previous lecturers.




11. 174.2(ii).11

Dhanbad Teachers’ Training College, Plot No- 480, Street No- G.T. Road, Vill-

Gopalganj, Po- Nirsha, Tehsil/Taluka- Nirsha, Town/City- Nirsha, Dist.-Dhanbad,

Jharkhand-828205 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.ERCAPP399)
















iii. As salary statement only 05 lecturers (1+4) is projected in place of seven full time and two part-

time lecturers.

iv. The faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university is to be submitted.






6

12. 174.2(ii).12

ARS B.Ed. College, Plot No. 62, 63, 64, 65, Street No. 1, Vill- Lakrakhanda,

Po- Bokaro, Town/City- Bokaro Steel City, Tehsil/Taluka- Chas, Dist- Bokaro,

Jharkhand-827010 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Vinoba BhaveUniversity)

(Code No.ERCAPP708)









i. The supporting documents for appointment like copy of advertisement in newspaper cutting,

letter from the concerned University regarding nominating its Representative for selection of

faculty member & minutes of the selection committee etc. also the percentage of marks of the

part-time lecturers are not indicated in the submitted faculty list.




13. 174.2(ii).13

Giridih College, PO – Sirsia, Dist – Giridih, Jharkhand - 815301 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Constitutent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.APE00433).









i. The institution has not submitted the building plan indicating size of different rooms as per the

requirement of NCTE norms duly approved the Govt/University Engineer,

ii. Multipurpose hall is 1259 sq.ft only which is less than the required 2000 sq.ft. as norms.

iii. The size of Psychology & Computer lab is 164.9 sq.ft which is less as per requirement.

iv. The institution has not appointed the Principal & three more lecturers as per requirement of

NCTE norms.

v. All teaching faculty must be appointed on regular basis.

vi. The part-time lecturers for Arts/Music and Physical Education have not been appointed.

vii. A fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university is to be submitted.




norms.



action.



7

14. 174.2(ii).14

Sahadev Chandravansi B.Ed. College, Vill. Nawadih Kala, Po- Bishrampur, Dist.-

Palamu, Jharkhand-822124 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Ranchi

University) (Code No.APE00910)






In response to the show cause notice, the institution submitted its reply dt. 16.06.2014 & 02.07.2014 to the

ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply


i. Dr. Brahmananda Sahu, existing principal has resigned recently. The institution is required to

appoint a new principal following due procedure and submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by

the Registrar of the concerned university adding the name of the newly appointed principal.

ii. As per recognition order, the affiliating body of the institution was Ranchi university, as per the

letter head and other submitted documents the affiliating body is shown Nilamber Pitamber

University. The permission for change of university is not granted by the ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar.

iii. The institution is required to submit a certificate of change of affiliating body issued from

Nilamber Pitamber University and NOC issued form Ranchi university.






15. 174.2(ii).15

Lala Pritam B.Ed College, Plot No.- 1303, 1301, 1292, 1298, Vill – Kishunpur,

PO- Chatra, Tehsil/Taluka - Chatra, Dist - Chatra, Jharkhand - 825401 (Course:

B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APP607)







Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply submitted by the

institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under:

i. As per submitted faculty list, the English lecturer and part-time lecturers for Art/Music and

Physical Education have not been appointed. The institution is required to appoint required

faculty following due procedure and submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of

the concerned university adding the name of the newly appointed faculty members alongwith

their educational and professional certificates.

ii. The documentary proof like bills/cash memos for purchasing of tests/equipments in the

laboratories of Science & Math is not submitted








8

16. 174.2(ii).16 R.S.P. College, Po-Jharia, Dist.-Dhanbad, Jharkhand-828111 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Constituet Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00428)









i. The institution has not submitted the building plan duly approved by any Govt/University

Engineer showing the area of each room & laboratories, Library and Multipurpose hall..

ii. Books in the Library are only 1315 which are less than the required 3000 books as norms.

iii. The institution has not appointed the teaching faculty on regular basis as per requirement of

NCTE norms.

iv. The institution is required to appoint the teaching faculty on regular basis and submit a fresh

faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university.

v. The institution is required to submit the original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh and Rs. 3.00 lakh towards

Endowment fund and Reserve fund in the joint name of institution and RD, ERC, NCTE

Bhubaneswar.





norms.



action.

17. 174.2(ii).17 Kartik Oraon College, Gumla, Jharkhand-835207 (Constituent College) (Ranchi

University) (Ranchi University) (Code No.APE00295)









i. The institution has not purchased the items/equipments for Resource centres till date.

ii. The institution has not appointed the teaching faculty on regular basis as well as part-time

lecturers for Arts, Health & Physical Education and a librarian till date.

iii. The institution is required to submit the fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the

concerned university.

iv. The institution has not submitted the renewed/converted FDRs of Rs. 5 lakh and Rs. 3 lakh in the

joint name of institution and RD,ERC,NCTE, Bhubaneswar.




norms.



action.



9

18. 174.2(ii).18 Santhal Pargana College, Dumka, Jharkhand (Course:B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit)

(S.K.M. University) (Code No.APE00435)









i. The documentary proof like bills/cash memos for purchasing of furniture’s not submitted.

ii. The available of books in the library are 2000 which is less than the required 3000 as per the

norms.

iii. The institution has not appointed principal and part-time lecturers as per requirement till date.

v. The institution has not submitted the renewed/converted FDRs of Rs. 5 lakh and Rs. 3 lakh in the





norms.



action.

19. 174.2(ii).19

Bethesda Women Teachers Training (B.Ed.) College, Ranchi, G.E.L. Church,

PO-Church Road, Dist.- Ranchi, Jharkhand-834001 (Course:B.Ed.) (Private)

(Ranchi University) (Code No.APE00186)









i. The institution has not appointed the lecturer in Mathematics.

ii. The institution is required to appoint the required faculty following due procedure and submit the

fresh faculty list adding the name of newly appointed faculty member and duly approved by the

Registrar of the concerned university.








10

20. 174.2(ii).20

Govt. Women’s Training College, Gautam Budha Marg, Bariyatu Road, Ranchi,

Jharkhand - 834009 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Govt.) (Ranchi University)

(Code No.APE00101)









i. The institution is functioning in the premises of the Government High School building which is

against the rules.

ii. There is no multipurpose hall,

iii. Laboratories are not available in the institution. The ICT resource Centre, Psychology resource

centre, Art & Craft Resource Center and Physical Education Resource Centre have not been set up.

iv. Books in the Library are only 853 which is less than the required 3000.

v. The teaching faculty is not qualified as per NCTE norms as the appointed faculty members are the

officers of State Education Service and most of them are M.A & B.Ed.

vi. Qualified librarian, Part-time lecturers for Physical Education and Art & Craft have not been

appointed.




norms.



action.

21. 174.2(ii).21

Sanghamitra Teacher Training College, Vill-Manatu, PO.- Ormanjhi, Tehsil/

Taluka-Ormanjhi, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand-835219 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi

University) (Code No.ERCAPP41)









(i) The Foundation/Trust runs a school and the B.Ed College in the same campus which is contravent

to the NCTE Norms and Regulations.

(ii) As per the VT report Library is housed in a small room having seating capacity of 15 persons and

not suitable for a B.Ed college. The ICT Resource Centre has also been setup in a small room

which is not fit for a computer lab. The Psychology lab set up in a class room does not have the

required number of tests.

(iii) The facilities actually created for the school have been claimed to be the facilities of the B.Ed

college. Thus the institution is very deficient in terms of infrastructures and instructional

facilities. (iv) The institution is not having a qualified Principal.



11

(v) The list of the faculty submitted by the institution after the show cause notice is neither approved

by the Register of the University nor having information regarding the qualifications of the their

eligibility as per norms.

(vi) There is no qualified regular Librarian in the institution.


The committee concluded that the institution is running the B.Ed course violating the NCTE Norms and

Regulation 2009. The committee, therefore, decided to withdraw the recognition of the institution for B.Ed

course under Section 17(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 from the academic session 2015-16.

22. 174.2(ii).22

Govt. Teachers Training College, Po & Dist-Hazaribagh, Jharkhand-

825301(Course: B.Ed.) (Government) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.APE00105)









1. As per Special VT report, the institution is still running in an old building of the Zila School,

Hazaribagh, which does not have adequate facilities as per the prescribed norms.

2. Laboratories like Science, Mathematics, Psychology, ICT, Health and Physical Education are not

available.

3. Qualified and required teaching faculty is not available in the institution as per NCTE norms.

4. Part-time lecturers for Fine Art/Music and Physical Education are not available.

5. Librarian is not appointed.

6. The institution is required to appoint the qualified and required faculty as NCTE norms on regular

basis and submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university.




norms.



action.

23. 174.2(ii).23 Baharagora College, Baharagora, East Singhbhum, Jharkhand-832101

(Course: B.Ed.) (Constitutent College) (Ranchi University) (Code No.APE00377)









i. The institution is not having infrastructure and instructional facilities as per the NCTE norms. The

institution was to shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition i.e. by

19.05.2008. But even after more than 8 years, it is continuing at the same place. However, the

constitution of new building has been completed.

ii. The institution does not fulfill the prescribed norms regarding engagement of teaching and supporting

staff and also in respect of service conditions of staff.

iii. The institution is required to appoint the qualified and required faculty as per NCTE norms on regular

basis and submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university.



12

iv. The institution does not maintain Endowment and Reserve funds in joint account with Regional

Director, ERC.




norms.



action.

24. 174.2(ii).24

Tetri Chandravansi College of Education, Garhwa, Vill - Pindra, PO/PS/Dist -

Garhwa, Jharkhand - 822114 (Course:B.Ed.) (Management-Private) (Ranchi






dated 16.06.2014.





25. 174.2(ii).25

S.B.M. Teacher’s Training College, Masipiri, PO - Babhanbai, Dist - Hazaribagh,

Jharkhand – 825301 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave










(i) During the hearing of the appeal, the institution submitted that its intention was to conduct the

B.Ed course temporarily in the leased premises having a built up area of 1500 sq.mts. on a plot of

land measuring 0.509 acres of 2396.94 sq.mt. and to shift to its permanent premises with an area

of 2569 sq.mts. to be constructed on a plot No. 311/3 under khata No. 37, Thana No 172, Thana

– Hazaribag measuring 3973.88 sq.m. Necessary documentary evidence namely land documents ,

approved building plan etc in this regard were also submitted by the institution during the appeal.

Keeping in view the above, the appeal was accordingly accepted on 11.06.2009 leading to finally

granting recognition the institution.

(ii) During the special inspection it is revealed that the institution is still functioning in the leased

ground floor building of the temporary premises which do not fulfill the requirement as per the

NCTE norms. The area of the land is only 2396.94 sq.m which is less then the required 2500

sq.m. The area of the multipurpose hall is 99.864 sq.m. or 1075 sq.ft which is less then the

required 2000 sq.ft.

(iii) Further, the institution handed over photo-copies of another sale deed executed on 10.06.2011 to

VT measuring 1 acre of land on plot No. 1 under khasra No. 1014 & 1015 in Babhanbai,

Hazaribad stated to have been purchased by the institution for construction of a new building for

the institution alongwith a approved building plan.

(iv) The proposed new premises is different from the permanent premises of land measuring 3973.88

sq.m. on which a 2-storey building having 2569 sq,m. was proposed to be constructed as per the

submission made before the Appeal Committee alongwith documentary evidence on 15.09.2009,



13

on the basis of which the appeal was accepted leading to grant of recognition to the institution.

The institution obtained recognition by submitting false documents.

(v) The new sale deed dated 10.09.2011 now submitted cannot be accepted.

(vi) The institution engaged one principal and five lecturers. English lecturer has not been appointed.





26. 174.2(ii).26

Vishweshwaraiya B.Ed. College, C/o – Samajik Kalyan Sanstha, Deoli, Po –

Jangalpur, Ps – Gobindpur, Dist – Dhanbad, Jharkhand – 826001 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (A.B.- Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00779)









i. At the time of submission of application the institution was having land at Plot No. 732, 738.

739, 418/2149, 418/2184, Khata No. 31 & 32 under Mauza No. 179 Mauza- Kapasara, P.S-

Gobindpur, Dhanbad measuring land area 5.19 acres in favour of Smt Tanuja Chowdhary,

Secretary, Sanajik Kalyan Sansthan and the instititon submitted a copy of the sale deed dated

30.09.2005. The institution had submitted a building plan for construction of a 3-storey

building on the said plots of land but the total land area, total built up area, plot nos khata nos

were not indicated. However, an affidavit on Rs. 100/- stamp paper dated 01.05.2007

subsequently submitted by the institution indicated that the society was in possession of land

measuring 21010.8 sq.m. and built up area of 2245 sq.m. for the Vishwashwaraiya B.Ed college

at the aforesaid plots. Accordingly, the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar granted recognition to the

Vishwashwaraiya B.Ed college vide order dated 21.08.2008.

ii. As special inspection conducted on 28.09.2013, the institution is functioning from a building

with a built-up area 2529.73 sq.m. in 3 floors constructed on plot Nos. 1548(P), 1561(P),

1562(P), 1569(P) under Mausa No. 198, Khata No. 29 situated in Mausa- Deoli,

P.S.Govindpur, Dhanbad. The said property has been sold by the society namely samajik

Kalyan Santhan in favour of the Vishweshwaraiya B.Ed college vide sale deed executed on

16.12.2009 i.e after granting recognition by the ERC, NCTE, BBSR.

iii. The institution is not functioning in the land and building where the recognition was granted to

the Vishweshwaraiya B.Ed college on 21.08.2008. The institution shifted the premises to a

new place without obtaining approval of the ERC, Bhubaneswar and, thus, violated Regulation

No. 8(11) of the NCTE Regulation 2009.





27. 174.2(ii).27 R.T.C. B.Ed. College, Vill-P.H.E.D., Buti, Po-Bariyatu, Dist-Ranchi, Jharkhand –

834009 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No. APE00780)








14




1. The institution has not submitted the site plan issued from Land Revenue Department showing the

plots adjacent to each other.

2. Faculty list in original signed by the Registrar of the concerned university is to be submitted.




28. 174.2(ii).28

Tathagat Teachers Training College, Plot No.- 498, 500, Vill – Jorapipal, Po –

Kalyanapur, Dhanbad, Jharkhand - 826004 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private)

(A.B.- Binoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00508).









i. Faculty list in original signed by the Registrar of the concerned university is to be submitted.

ii. The institution has not submitted the renewed/converted FDRs of Rs. 5 lakh and Rs. 3 lakh in the


iii. As per NCTE norms, the academic staff of the institution( including part time staff) shall be paid





iv. The institution is required to submit the 3 months Bank statement clearly stating that amount has





29. 174.2(ii).29

Mahila College, PO – Chaibasa, Dist – West Singhbhum, Jharkhand - 833201

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Constituent College) (A.B.- Kolhan University)

(Code No.APE0035 3).











15

1. The B.Ed course is being conducted in one portion of the existing building of the general college

namely the Mahila college. The existing B.Ed block has nine rooms with a built up area of 3831

sq.ft. which is less then the required 1500 sq.mts

2. The Multipurpose hall, staff room, common room for girls and boys and Art & Work Experience

room are not available.

3. No land and building is specifically earmarked for the B.Ed course.

4. One of the condition stipulated in the recognition order dated 12.05.2005 was that the institution

shall shift to its own premises within three years from the date of recognition. The institution has

failed to fulfill this condition even after more than eight years of recognition.

5. The new building for B.Ed programme is under construction.

6. Books in the library are only 748 which is less then the required 3000.

7. The institution does not have its own Science Resource Center, ICT or Educational Technology

Resource Center. Art and Craft Resource Center have not been setup.

8. The recruited lecturers are on contractual basis which is against the rules. Faculty must be appointed

on Regular basis.

9. Principal/HOD is not appointed. Mathematic lecturer is also not appointed.




norms.



action.

30. 174.2(ii).30

S.S.L.N.T. Mahila Mahavidyalaya, Buby Circular Road, Hirapur, Dhanbad,

Jharkhand - 826001 (Course: B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.APE00443).









1. The land and building is not demarcated for the B.Ed. programme.

2. Multipurpose hall is not available in the institution.

3. There are no Psychology lab, Language learning lab. Art & work experience room, play-ground, staff

room, Principal room and common room, play ground and staff room for B.Ed course.

4. Books in the Library are only 1006 which is less than the required 3000 books. Seating arrangement

in the library is not available.

5. Computers in the ET room are not available.

6. The HOD is not appointed for B.Ed. programme.

7. The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list appointing the faculty on regular basis and

duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university alongwith their educational/professional

certificates.




norms.

A copy of the above show cause notice to be issued to the institution be endorsed to the Principal Secretary, Ministry of HRD Govt of Jharkhand and Registrar of the concerned university for information and necessary

action.



16

31. 174.2(ii).31

Grizzly College of Education, Plot No.- 468, Vill/PO/City – Jhumri Telaiya,

Tehsil/Taluka – Koderma, Dist – Koderma, Jharkhand - 825409 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No. APE00799).









i. The educational/professional certificate of the newly appointed Librarian is to be submitted.




32. 174.2(ii).32 Ranchi College, Ranchi, Morabadi, Ranchi, Jharkhand - 834008 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No. APE00293)









i. There is no separate land or building exclusively for the B.Ed course. The B.Ed programme is

located in a constituent College of Ranchi University.

ii. There is no Multipurpose hall in the Department of Education .

iii. There is not separate facilities available in the Psychology Lab, Science Lab, Education Lab. And

Library.

iv. The university has adopted a policy of contractual appointments of teachers which is violation of

the Norms of recognition and also of the condition of recognition.

v. Moreover, non-engagement of a regular and qualified HOD and non-engagement of supporting

staff is another violation.

vi. All faculty must be appointed on regular basis as per NCTR norms.

vii. In addition, the institution has failed to create the required infrastructural and instructional

facilities.




norms.



action.



17

33. 174.2(ii).33

Chatra College, Chatra, Dist.- Chatra, Jharkhand-825401 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Constituent College) (A.B.-Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.APE00447)






In response to the show cause notice, the institution submitted its reply dt.18.07.2014 to the ERC, NCTE,



1. The institution functions as a wing of the degree college. Its own building out of the B.Ed. fund is

still under construction.

2. The institution has failed to engage teaching and non-teaching staff on regular basis.

3. The institution has also failed to provide the necessary instructional facilities.

4. In the absence of a regular HOD, the institution is not managed professionally.

5. The institution has not submitted the renewed/converted FDRs of Rs. 5 lakh and Rs. 3 lakh in the





norms.



action.

34. 174.2(ii).34

Jawaharlal Nehru College, Chakradharpur, West Singhbhum, Jharkhand-833102

(Course: B.Ed.) (Consitutent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University)

(Code No.APE00312)









1. The institution is deficient in respect of both infrastructural and instructional facilities.

2. The institution has violated the prescribed norms relating to the appointment of teaching and non-

teaching staff.

3. All the staff members are appointed on a contractual basis for a limited period of less than one year.

4. They are not entitled to the service benefits admissible to regular employees of the University.

5. The HOD is also appointed on contact basis in the pay scale of a lecturer.




norms.



action.



18

35. 174.2(ii).35

Al-Habeeb Teacher’s Training College, Sector-VI, Bokaro Steel City,

Dist-Bokaro, Jharkhand-827006 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private)

(Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No. APE00796)









i. The institution has not submitted the consolidated faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of

the concerned University.

ii. As per NCTE norms, the academic staff of the institution( including part time staff) shall be paid





iii. The institution is required to submit the 3 months Bank statement clearly stating that amount has







36. 174.2(ii).36

Aviram College of Education, Plot No. 752/712, 749/713, Vill- Tiko, Po- Kuru,

Tehsil/Taluka- Kuru, City/Dist.- Lohardaga, Jharkhand- 835213 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No.ERCAPP948)





dated 18.06.2014.





37. 174.2(ii).37

N.N. Ghosh Sanatan Teachers Training College, Plot No.- 165, Vill – Jamuary,

PO- Kokodro, Tehsil/Taluka – Kanke, Town/City – Rehala, Dist – Palamu,

Jharkhand – 834006 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Ranchi University)

(Code No.ERCAPP1221).




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, clarification was issued to the institution on

16.06.2014.





19



the concerned university.




ER-174.4 Appeal Case

38. 174.4.1

Kaviguru Nobel Centenary Training College, (Run by : The Rural Improvement

Trust) Vill/PO - Kalitala, PS - Beldanga, Dist - Murshidabad - 742 133, West

Bengal (B.Ed.) (University of Kalyani) (Code No.ERCAPP58/2012)

In response to the ERC’s refusal order No. ERC/7-167.11.6/ERCAPP58/B.Ed./2013/23340 dated 20.01.2014,

the institution preferred and appeal on 23.07.2014 to NCTE Hqrs.

The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No. 89-94/2014Appeal/8th Meeting-2014-A90665 dated 08.07.2014

remanded the case back to the ERC, NCTE with a direction to conduct the inspection of the appellant

institution on payment of fee.

The committee accepted the direction of the Appeal committee and decided as under:

The case will be processed/taken up as per the new Regulation and VT will be constituted for inspection of

the institution as per the new Regulation.

ER-172.12(i) Misc. Cases- (I)

39. 174.12(i).1

Debnarayan Shiksha Sansthan (B.Ed.) College, Street No. - P.O. Road, Vill –

Natagachhi, PO - Beniabow, PS / Block - Sonarpur, Dist - South 24 Parganas,

West Bengal - 743613 (Course - B.Ed.) (Code No.ERCAPP719)

The Secretary, Deb Narayan Shiksha Sabsthan (B.Ed College) vide letter dated 07.06.2014 has submitted

particulars of the newly appointed principal in the college.

The committee noted the new appointment of the principal.

40. 174.12(i).2

Haladhar Mahato Teachers Training Institute (B.Ed.), Plot no. 3387, Vill - Dighi,

Town/ City - Manabazar, Dist - Purulia, West Bengal - 723 131 (B.Ed.) (Private)

(University of Burdwan) (Code No.ERCAPP736)

The Secretary Deoli Babu Jagjiban Ram Vidyapith Samilti and Secretary newly formed college Committee

vide letter dated 04.06.2014 has requested for consideration of newly formed college committee for HMTTI

for 2014-15.

The committee consider the representation of the institution and decided as under:

As there is different list of Managing body submitted by the President and Secretary of the institution, the

District Magistrate of the concerned District be requested to inquire the matter and submit the report within 30

days.

VOLUME-II

ER-174.2(ii)

Court Case:



41. 174.2(ii).38

Dr. S. Radhakrishnan College of Education, Plot No. 169, Vill/Po-Chiksia,

Tehsil/Taluka -Chas, City- Chas, Dist-Bokaro, Jharkhand-827013 (B.Ed.) (Private)

(Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.ERCAPP747)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, Show cause notice u/s 17(1) was issued to the institution on 27.06.2014.



20





the concerned University.













42. 174.2(ii).39

Shahid Sheikh Bhikari College of Education, Plot No. 1508,

Street No. Shutiyambe, Vill- Shutiyambe, Po-Pithoria, Tehsil/Taluka - Kanke,

Dist-Ranchi, Jharkhand-834014 (Course:B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University)

(Code No. ERCAPP73)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, clarification letter dated 26.06.2014 was

issued to the institution.

In response to the clarification letter, the institution submitted its reply dt.21.07.2014 to the ERC, NCTE,













43. 174.2(ii).40

Manrakhan Mahto B.Ed. College, Plot No. 261, 262, 293, Vill - Kedal, Po-Neori

Vikas, Tehsil/Taluka- Kanke, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand-825217 (B.Ed.) (Private)

(Ranchi University) (Code No.ERCAPP498)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, Clarification letter was issued to the





i. The institution has not submitted the consolidated faculty list adding the newly appointed

principal and lecturers duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned University. The



21

educational/professional certificate of the newly appointed faculty members are required.

ii. As per submitted faculty list, the part-time lecturers of Arts/Music and Physical Education have

not been appointed.






44. 174.2(ii).41

Patel B.Ed. College, Plot No.49, Vill- Katamkuku, Po- Lodhma, Tehsil/Taluka-

Karra, Town/City- Khunti, Dist.-Ranchi, Jharkhand- 834004 (Course:B.Ed.)

(Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No.ERCAPP705)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, clarification letter dated 03.07.2014 was

issued to the institution.














45. 174.2(ii).42

S B Pandey Sanatan Teachers Training College, Plot No. 440/1, Vill/Po- Rehala,

Tehsil/Taluka - Bishrampur, Town/City- Rehala, Dist.-Palamu, Jharkhand- 822124

(B.Ed.) (Private) (Nilamber Pitamber University) (Code No.ERCAPP1197)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the


In response to the show cause notice, the institution submitted its reply dated 05.07.2014 & 15.07.2014 to the

ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of NCTE Hqrs as well as representation

submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and decided as under:


46. 174.2(ii).43

Swami Sahajanand Saraswati B.Ed. College, Plot No. - 972 to 978, 1011-12, 1020

to 1054, Vill. - Bokaro Steel City, Po. - Sector 9, Tehsil/Taluka - Chas, Town/City

- Bokaro Steel City, Dist. - Bokaro, Jharkhand - 827009 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private)

(Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.ERCAPP1185)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the




22





47. 174.2(ii).44

Rahat College of Education, Plot No. 42, Vill/Po-Madhupur, Tehsil/ Taluka-

Barbad, Town/City-Madhupur, Dist.-Deoghar, Jharkhand - 815353 (B.Ed.)

(Private) (S.K.M.University) (Code No. ERCAPP99)









i. As per faculty list the lecturer in English is not appointed.

ii. The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list adding the name of newly appointed

lecturer duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned University.

iii. As per NCTE norms, the academic staff of the institution( including part time staff) shall be paid





iv. The institution is required to submit the 3 months Bank statement clearly stating that amount has



1. Show Cause notice be issued to the institution as to why the recognition to the institution be not

withdrawn on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides an opportunity under section

17(1) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the

letter before the Committee takes final decision.

2. A copy of the complaint received from Md. Sazad Ansari against the institution be forwarded to the

District Magistrate of the concerned District with a request to go through the facts and submit the

report to ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar as early as possible so that necessary action could be taken

against the institution.

48. 174.2(ii).45 Guru Nanak College, Dhanbad, Post Box No. 93, Dist.-Dhanbad, Jharkhand-

826001 (Course:B.Ed.) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00429)









(i) The institution is functioning as a department of the General Degree College.

(ii) The principal of the Guru Nanak College, Dhanbad has also submitted an undertaking dated

08.10.2004 on non-judicial stamp paper that the infrastructural, instructional and other facilities will be provided for B.Ed course as per norms.

(iii) As per special Inspection Report, the institution does not have adequate infrastructural facilities as



23

required as per the prescribed norms. Out of three classrooms available for B.Ed. course, two

classrooms have a space of 437 Sq. ft. which is less than the required 500 Sq. ft. as per NCTE norms.

Thus, only one classroom is only as per NCTE norms as against the requirement of a minimum two

classrooms with an area of minimum 500 Sq. ft. each.

(iv) The multipurpose hall available is having an area of 1890 Sq. ft. as against the requirement of a

minimum of 2000 Sq. ft. as per NCTE norms.

(v) The library is 420 Sq. ft., science lab 150 sq. ft. and computer lab 228 Sq. ft. are very small and

inadequate as per norms. Psychology lab is not available in the institution.

(vi) Thus, infrastructural facilities available with the institution are inadequate for running B.Ed. course.

(vii) During the special inspection it is found that khalsa college and Khalsa school are running in the same

campus which is against the rules.





49. 174.2(ii).46 Godda College, PO/Dist.-Godda, Jharkhand-814134 (Course:B.Ed.) (Constituent

College)(Ranchi University)(Code No.APE00437)









1. The institution has not submitted any proposal for shifting of the B.Ed department in the new

constructing building alongwith other relating documents.

2. As per special inspection of the institution, it is revealed that B.Ed course is still being conducted in a

portion of the buildingof Godda College. The available built up area for the B.Ed college is only

3500 sq.ft. as against the requirement of minimum pf 16146 sq.t. or 1500 sq,m.

3. The teaching faculty appointed on contractual basis. As per NCTE norms the teaching faculty must

be appointed on regular basis.

4. The post of HOD and two lecturers are vacant.

5. The size of Psychology lab, ET lab is inadequate.

6. The Multipurpose hall of the college is under construction.




norms.



action.

50. 174.2(ii).47

G. D. Bagaria Teacher’s Training College, At. Aerodrome Road, Boro, P.O. &

Dist. Giridih, Jharkhand – 815301 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba

Bhave University) (Code No.APE00473)

A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda - Vs -










24

i. At the time of submission of application the institution submitted a lease deed for a period of

10 years executed on 04.01.2005 between M/S Ratan Mica Exports Pvt Ltd and the Bagaria

Jan Kalyan Trust in respect of land measuring 3 Bighas and 6 chataks comprised in

Municipal Holing No. 400 of ward No. 1 (old) and ward No. 2 (new ) of Giridih

Municipality, situated at Barganda, Makatpur, Girdih, Thana No. 95, Thoka No. 228, PS-

Giridih, Dist-Girdih.

ii. As per application form, the postal address of the trust is “Ruby Lodge, Barganda, Distt-

Girdih, Jharkhand-815301.

iii. As per Certificate signed by Ajay Bagaria it is clearly indicated that the land measuring 3

Bighas and 6 chataks comprised in Municipal Holing No. 400 of ward No. 1 (old) and ward

No. 2 (new ) Tauzi No. 15/11, Thoka No. 326, Plot No. 326, Thana No. 95 situated in

Mohalla- Makatpur, Dist- Girdih in favour of M/S Ratan Mica Export Pvt Ltd has given on

lease for the period of 10 years to Bagaria Jan Kalyan Trust for opening of Teacher Training

at Girdih.

iv. Alongwith this certificate the institution submitted a Sale Deed measuring 3 Bighas and 6

chataks comprised in Municipal Holing No. 400 of ward No. 1 (old) and ward No. 2 (new )

Tauzi No. 15/11, Thoka No. 326, Plot No. 326, Thana No. 95 situated in Mohalla- Makatpur,

Dist- Girdih which is in favour of M/S Ratan Mica Export Pvt Ltd i.e. the same land was

taken on lease basis for a period of 10 years executed on 04.01.2005 between M/S Ratan

Mica Exports Pvt Ltd and the Bagaria Jan Kalyan Trust but during lease agreement the

Tauzi No. 15/11, Thoka No. 326, Plot No. 326 had not been mentioned in the submitted

Lease Deed.

v. No other land document had been submitted by institution at the time of submission of

application and till the date of first inspection which was conducted on 14.12.2005.

vi. The inspection letter 30.09.2005 was issued to the institution at the address : G.D. Bagaria

Teachr Training college, At-Aerodoms Road (Near Residance of Sarfaraz Ahmaed)

P.O./Dist Girdih-815301, Jharkhand. However, the previous address as per land document

& Certificate comprised in Municipal Holing No. No. 400 of ward No. 1 (oled) and ward No.

2 (new) of Giridih Municipality, situated at Barganda, Makatpur, Girdih, Thana No. 95,

Thoka No. 228, PS-Giridih, Dist-Girdih was not mentioned in the inspection.

vii. Avedently, the inspection was conducted at G.D. Bagaria Teacher Training College. At-

Aerodome Road, PO/Dist Giridih whereas the address as per land document submitted

initially is different.

viii. During 1st inspection conducted on 14.12.2005 a copy of two Lease Deed between Sangita

Bagaria & G.D Bagaria Teacher Training College, Girdih situated in Mauza Boro, P.S.

Girdih under Thana No. 91, Tauzi No. 15/11, Khata No. 37, Plot No. 708 having land land

area 11 ¾ decimal and another Lease Deed between Sangita Bagaria & G.D Bagaria

Teacher Training College, Girdih situated in Mauza Boro, P.S. Girdih (M) under Thana No.

91, Khata No. 1/120, Plot No. 856 measuring land land area 5 ¼ acre submitted to the VT

experts during the 1st inspection.

ix. As per Special Inspection conducted u/s 13 on 28.09.2013 by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution

is functioning in another premises gifted by one Sangeetha Bagaria to G.D. Bagaria Teachers

Training College, Girdih namely a plot of land measuring 1.15 acres (Plot No. 856, 849, 850

under Khata No. 01A/P1/20/71) situated in Mouza- Boro commonly known as

AERODRAMME Road (Boro). This gift deed was executed on 07th January 2010 whereas

the institution is recognized from 04.10.2006.

x. The institution shifted to a new premises without obtaining prior approval of the ERC,

NCTE, Bhubaneswar in violation of Regulation 8 (11) of the NCTE Regulations, 2009.



Regulation 2009. The committee, therefore, decided to withdraw the recognition of the institution for B.Ed course under Section 17(1) of the NCTE Act, 1993 from the academic session 2015-16.



25

51. 174.2(ii).48

Jagannath Jain College, At/PO- Jhumri Telaiya, Dist – Koderma, Jharkhand –

825409 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Constitutent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave

University) (Code No.APE00425).









1. The institution has not submitted any proposal for shifting of the B.Ed Dept in the new building

constructed by the Dept.

2. Before granting the recognition to the institution, the principal of the college has given an undertaing

to the effect that he would move the authorities to demarcate 5 acre of land from the available land of

college for B.Ed section exclusively.

3. During Special inspection of the college conducted on 23.10.2013 reveled that the B.Ed course is

conducted in a portion of the building of the General College namely the Jagannath Jain college.

Only two classrooms, one language lab and one office room aggregating to a total area of around

2334 dq.ft. are exclusively available for conducting the B.Ed course as against the requirement of a

minimum of 1500 sq. mts. as per the prescribed NCTE norms. All other facilities are shared with the

General college. Thus, the available infrastructure facilities are inadequate for conducting B.Ed

course as per the prescribed NCTE norms. The construction of the

4. Original FDRs of Rs. 5.00 lakh & Rs. 3.00 lakh in the joint name of the institution and RD, ERC,

Bhubaneswar not submitted.

5. The institution has not appointed the vacant post of teaching faculty. The existing faculty are also on

contractual basis till date.

6. No regular HOD appointed by the institution till date.

7. The institution has not submitted the fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the

concerned university.




norms.



action.

52. 174.2(ii).49 Karim City College, Jamshedpur, Jharkhand- 831001 (Course: B.Ed.)

(Management: Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No. APE00356)






1. At the time of submission of application dated 28.01.2004 submitted to the ERC, NCTE for recognition

of B.Ed course, the institution had indicatd that it was having 5.18 acre of land with a 4-storey building

having a built up area of 46,707 sq.ft. The proposal was to run the proposed B.Ed course in the existing

building of the Karim city college till consturuction of new building at Mango, Jamshedpur was

completed. A resolution dated 27.12.2004 in this regard passed by the college Governing Boday was

submitted to the ERC. An affidavit dated 27.12.2004 attested by notary stating that infrastructural,

instructional and other facilities will be provided as per the NCTE norms, was also submitted to the ERC,

NCTE, Bhubaneswar.



26

2. During special inspection of the institution conducted on 26.09.2013 reveals that the institution is now

functioning at Kapali Link Road, Zakir Nagar (W) P.P. Azad Nagar, Jamshedpur and not at Karim City

College, Sakchi, Jamshedpur where the recognition for conducting B.Ed. course was granted on

25.07.2005.

3. The Principal, Karim City College has handed over an undertaking dated 26.09.2013 inter-alia, stating

that from the session 2013-14 onwards, the B.Ed course has been shifted to the new building and that

they will inform the ERC, Bhubanesw at the earliest.

4. The institution had not submitted any application before conducting the special inspection i.e. upto

26.09.2013.

5. Now, the institution submitted it application for shifting of premises on 28.05.2014 alongwith a DD of

Rs. 40,000/- i.e after the special inspection. The process of all pending file is banned from 3rd

March,

2014 as per the direction of the Honble Supreme Court of India.

6. As per the sub-regulation (ii) of Regulation 8 of the NCTE, Regulations 2009, in case of change of

premises, prior approval of the Regional Committee concerned after due inspection of the instititon at the

new site is required.

7. The institution has shifted to a new place without obtaining prior permission of ERC, NCTE,

Bhubaneswar in violation of Regulation 8(II) of NCTE Regulation 2009.





53. 174.2(ii).50

A. S. College, Deoghar, PO/Dist – Deoghar, Jharkhand - 814112

(Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Constituent College) (A.B.- S.K.M. University)

(Code No. APE00439).









1. The institution has not appointed regular HOD/Principal till date.

2. The institution has not appointed teaching faculty and other supporting staff on regular basis till date

as per norms of NCTE.

3. The institution has only built up area 5200 sq.ft. which is less than the required 1500 sq.m.

4. Multipurpose hall and Art & Craft Resource Center are not available.




norms.



action.



27

54. 174.2(ii).51

Loyola College of Education, Riverview Area, Telco works, Jamshedpur, East

Singhbum, Jharkhand - 831004 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University)

(Code No. JH-S/E-2/96 & APE00204)








submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under: ]

i. The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list adding the name of newly appointed

lecturer duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned University.











norms.



action.

ER-174.4.7 Appeal Case

55. 174.4.2

Bipin Bihari Primary Teachers Training Institute, Plot No.1301, 1302, 1303, 1304,

1393, 1394, Vill/PO - Dighalgram Tehsil/Taluka- Haringhata, Dist- Nadia, West

Bengal - 741257 (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education)

(Code No.ERCAPP1322)

The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No. 89-133/2013-Appeal/8th

Meeting-2014-A90846 dated 08.07.2014

confirmed the rejection order of the ERC.

The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee.

ER-172.12(i) Misc. Cases-(I)

56. 174.12(i).3

Reimalie Academy College, Vill - Bhatipara Revenue, Bijni, Tehsil/ Taluka/

Town/City - Bijni, PO-Bijni, Dist - Bongaigaon, Assam - 783390 (Course-B.Ed.)


The Chairman of the institution vide latter dated 2nd

June 2014 requested to allow the change of affiliating

body from Gauhati University to Bodoland University and submitted the NOC issued from both of the

university.

In view of the above, committee decided as under:

The change of affiliating body from Gauhati University to Bodoland University is allowed.

57. 174.12(i).4

Aryabatta College of Education, Kiriteswari, PS-Nabagram, Dist-Murshidabad,

West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Kalyani)

(Code No.ERCAPP26/2012)

The Secretary, Kiriteswari Educational and Charitable Trust vide its letter dated Nil received in this office on

18.03.2014 has requested for withdrawal of the application viz. Aryabatta College of Education, Kiriteswari,

PS – Nabagram, Dist – Murshidabad, West Bengal bearing code no. ERCAPP26/2012 submitted for grant of

recognition of B.Ed. course.


The request of the institution is accepted and processing fee will be retained.



28

ER-172.12(ii) Misc. Cases - (II)

58. 174.12(ii).1

Kabi Sukanta PTTI, Vill.-Godagari, P.O.-Sagarparai, P.S-Jalangi,

Dist.-Murshidabad, West Bengal-742306 (Course: D.El.Ed.) (W.B.B.P.E)


A copy of the complaint dated 25.06.14 received from Sh Kaushik Dey Advocate, Hon’ble High Court of

Calcauuta against the institution was forwarded to the secretary, WBBPE, West Bengal on 26.06.2014 with a

request to inquire the matter and submit the report with 30 days. Reply from the West Bengal Board of

Primary Eduication has not been received so far,

Meanwhile, another complaint letter dated 25.06.2014 has been received from Kaushik Dey (Advocate),

Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta on behalf of Md. Miltan Sarkar.


A reminder may be sent to the Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education along with a copy of the

both complaints with a request to inquire the matter and submit the report within 15 days.

59. 174.12(ii).2

Nathulal Das B.Ed College, Vill-Manikpur, Po-Dafahat, Dist-Murshidabad,

West Bengal-742224 (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Kalyani)


In response to ERC letter dated 18.02.2014 regarding complaint received against the institution from

University of Kalyani the institution has submitted it reply vide its letter dated 17.03.2014 and 16.04.2014

stating that the complain given by the Kalyani University against our institution is due to misunderstanding

and misconducting.

In the meantime another letter from the inspector of colleges, university of Kalyani has been received wherein

the inspector of colleges, university of Kalyani has requested to kindly advise the University about the course

of action to be followed in relation to proposed Nathulal Das B.Ed College.


A copy of the faculty list approved by the Registrar of the university of Kalyani be forwarded to the Inspector

of colleges of Kalyani University for verification.

A copy of the resignation letter of Shri Samir Kumar, Principal of Nathulal Das B.Ed College may also be

sent for information

VOLUME-III

ER-174.2(i) Court Case

60. 174.2(i).

W.P. No 33931 (w) of 2013 filed by Md. Emamuddin Sarkar -Vs- The State of

West Bengal & Ors. In the High Court at Calcutta.

The committee considered the W.P.No. 33931 (w) of 2013 and decided as under:

As the appointment of the teacher is not coming under the jurisdiction of the

NCTE/ERC NCTE, an appeal to be filled against the order.

ER-174.2(ii)

Court Case:



61. 174.2(ii).52

The Graduate School College for Women, Jamshedpur, Sakchi, Jamshedpur,

Jharkhand - 831001 (Course:B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit) (Kolhan University) (Code

No.APE00355).











29

i. The B.Ed department is located in a part of the college building with a covered area of 443 sq.m.

which is less then the required 1500 sq,m. as per NCTE norms.

ii. The institution has failed to create the required instructional facilities. For instance, Science

Resource Center does not have the required apparatuses and the required consumables and

chemicals are not available. Psychology Resource Centre has not been created. No separate ICT

Resource Centre has been set up. Arc and Craft Resource Centre has not been created. No

separate provision has been made for Health and Physical Education.

iii. The departmental library has a stock of 800 books which is less then the required 3000 as per

NCTE norms.

iv. In short, the institution is very deficient in respect of instructional facilities prescribed by the

NCTE.

v. The University has recruited eight lecturers on contractual basis for 11 months for the year 2013-

14 and posted them in this college on 03.09.2013. The services of the staff are terminated after 11

months and fresh appointments are made in the beginning of a session. However, the institution

has not appointed teaching faculty on regular basis till date.




norms.



action.

62. 174.2(ii).53

B. N. Saha DAV Teacher’s Training College, At - Sirsia, Near Giridih Block,

Giridih - Madhupur Road, Dist - Giridih, Jharkhand - 815301 (Course:B.Ed.)

(Private) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00581).









i. The process to increase the Multipurpose hall is in under construction.















30

63. 174.2(ii).54

Subash Teacher’s Training College, Vill- Koldiha, Po- Giridih, Dist.- Giridih,

Jharkhand- 815301 (Course: B.Ed.) (Management: Private) (Vinoba Bhave

University) (Code No. ERCAPP46)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, a clarification was issued to the institution

on 18.06.2014.





64. 174.2(ii).55

Parjanya B.Ed. College, Plot No. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, Street Number- Hirak Road, Vill.-

Paharpur, P.O.- Baliapur, Tehsil/Taluka- Baliapur, City/Dist. Dhanbad, Jharkhand

– 828201 (B.Ed.) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No. ERCAPP1124)



















65. 174.2(ii).56

Ursuline Women’s Teacher Training College, Lohardaga, At/Po- Lohardagar,

Dist.- Lohardaga, Jharkhand-835302 (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi

University) (File No. JH-S/E-4/96)









i. The institution has not appointed the part-time lecturers for Physical Education & Fine

Arts/Music.



31






66. 174.2(ii).57

GLA College, Plot No. 16931, Street No. Panki Road, Vill-Baralota, Po - GLA

College Post Office, Tehsil/Taluka-Daltonganj, City- Daltonganj,

Dist- Palamu, Jharkhand – 822102 (B.Ed.)(Constituent Unit) (Nilamber Pitamber

University) (Code No. ERCAPP264)









(i) The B.Ed Department does not have a separate campus.

(ii) The college does not have its own Multipurpose hall and adequate number of rooms for various

laboratories and play ground required for the B.Ed course.

(iii) Library has a stock of 1788 books only which is less than the required 3000 books.

(iv) The Art and Craft Centre has not has not been set up.

(v) The staff is selected by the university on contractual basis for a period of 11 months and their

services are automatically terminated on the expiry of the contract period. The staff must be

appointed on regular basis as NCTE rules.

(vi) The resources of GLA college, though available for B.Ed Department, also are not appropriate for

conducting B.Ed. programme.

(vii) The institution does not maintain Endowment and Reserve Funds, in Joint Account with ERC,

Bhubaneswar.




norms.



action.

67. 174.2(ii).58

Samarpan Deep B.Ed. College, Plot No. 271(Part), 271(a), Vill- Ushamatu,

Po- Ratu, Tehsil/Taluka-Ratu, City- Ranchi, Dist- Ranchi, Jharkhand – 835222

(B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No. ERCAPP129)




of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, a clarification was issued to the institution

on 18.06.2014.

In response to the show cause notice, the institution submitted its reply dated 12.07.2014 to the ERC, NCTE,






32

ER-172.12(ii) Misc. Cases - (II)

68. 174.12(ii).3

Bakreswar College of Educaiton, Vill - Hetampur, PO - Hetampur Rajbati,

Tehsil/Town/City - Dubrajpur, Dist - Birbhum - 731 124, West Bengal (B.Ed.)

(Private) (University of Burdwan) (Code No.ERCAPP1471)

Eastern Regional Committee in its 169th meeting held on 13

th - 14

th February 2014 After considering the

records available in the file, and relevant provisions of the NCTE Act 1993, Rules, Regulations and

guidelines issued by NCTE Hqrs. VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under:

Another institution named Barkeswar Teacher Training Institution (ERCAPP177/2012) had been

given recognition in the same land.

While comparing the CD of both the institutions, it seems that the building is one and the same for

both the institutions.

In view of the above, the committee decided as under that – A letter to be written to the D.L. & L.R.O. of the

concerned District to verify whether both the institution are having separate land and building or running in

the same land and building. Accordingly, a letter to the DL & LRO issued on 20.02.2014

In response to the ERC letter dated 20.02.2014 issued as per the decision taken in 169th meeting the ADM,

Birbhum vide its letter dated 20.03.2014 received in this office on 07.04.2014 has informed that the matter has

been enquired into by the concerned BL & LRO , Dubrajpur, Birbhum and a copy of the report which is self

explanatory is sent herewith.

(i.) As per the report of the BL & LRO it is stated that Bakreswar College of Education is situated at

plot no.347 of mouza Anderbuni on 0.70 acre area which is recorded at Khatian no. 234 and

Bakreswar Teachers Training institution is situated on the same plot but in separate building

bounded by boundary wall on an area of 1.00 acre of plot no. 347, mouza Anderbuni JL no.141

which is recorded in khatian no. 208. Both the institutes are running on the same plot no.347 but

on separate buildings, both buildings are bounded by separate boundary wall, each having

separate entrance and between the two building there is a gap of 15 feet space.


As per Supreme Court order the application will be process as per the new regulation which is yet to be

notified.

Any other matter with permission of the Chair.

proceedings of 174rd meeting of the erc-ncte held on

Documents