resettlement action plan (rap) for the proposed …

106
RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED KINDARUMA- MWINGI-GARISSA (233.146 KM) TRANSMISSION LINE VOLUME II: VALUATION REPORT September 2013 Draft Report Prepared and Submitted By: Norken (I) Ltd. Engineering and Management Consultants Norfolk Towers, Block G P.O. Box 9882-00100 Nairobi, Kenya Tel. 254 20 2248762 Fax 254 20 2248900 Email: [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jan-2022

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP)

FOR THE PROPOSED KINDARUMA-MWINGI-GARISSA (233.146 KM)

TRANSMISSION LINE

VOLUME II: VALUATION REPORT

September 2013

Draft Report Prepared and Submitted By:

Norken (I) Ltd.

Engineering and Management Consultants

Norfolk Towers, Block G

P.O. Box 9882-00100

Nairobi, Kenya

Tel. 254 20 2248762

Fax 254 20 2248900

Email: [email protected]

Page 2: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 2 of 8 

 

Proponent: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED (KETRACO) Assignment: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN FOR THE PROPOSED KINDARUMA –MWINGI -

GARISSA 132KV TRANSMISSION LINE

Name and Address of Consultant: Norken (I) Limited, Block G, Norfolk Towers, Kijabe Street, P. O. Box 9882 - 00100, Nairobi, Kenya. Tel. 254 020 2248762 Signed: ____________________________ Date: _____________________ Casty Gatakaa Mbae (Registered Valuer)

For: Norken International Ltd Name and Address of Proponent: Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Limited 2nd Floor, Capitol Hill Square, Chyulu Road, Upper Hill PO Box 34942-00100, Nairobi, Kenya. Tel. 254 20 4956000 Signed: _______________________________ Date: ______________ For: Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Limited ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Disclaimer: This Resettlement Action Plan is strictly confidential to Kenya Electricity Transmission Company Limited (KETRACO) and any use of the materials thereof should strictly in accordance with the agreement between KETRACO and Norken International Limited (the Consultant).

Page 3: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 3 of 8 

 

Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................... 5 

1  VALUATION ................................................................................................................................. 6 

1.1  Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 6 

1.2  Analysis of the Valuation Methodology Adopted for this Project .......................................... 7 

1.2.1  Structures ........................................................................................................................ 7 

1.2.2  Trees and Crops .............................................................................................................. 7 

1.2.3  Land Values .................................................................................................................... 7 

1.3  Primary Data Collection.......................................................................................................... 7 

1.4  Basis for Valuation.................................................................................................................. 8 

1.5  Cost Summary ......................................................................................................................... 8 

 

List of Tables Table 1: Summary of Costs ..................................................................................................................... 8 

List of Appendices Appendix 1 Valuation of Structures Appendix 2 Valuation for Land Appendix 3 Valuation of the Trees Appendix 4 List of Values for the Trees Appendix 5 Values of trees and Crops from the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry

Page 4: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 4 of 8 

 

ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS AIDS Immune Deficiency Syndrome CRC Central Resettlement Committee EMA External Monitoring Assistance ESIA Environmental and Social Impact Assessment ETB Energy Transmission Board FGD Focus Group Discussions KETRACO Electricity Transmission Company of Kenya GCI Galvanized Corrugated Iron GLA Government Lands Act GOK Government of Kenya HIV Human Immune Virus IFC International Finance Cooperation IPPs Independent Power Producers KCAA Kenya Civil Aviation Authority KenGen Kenya Electricity Generation Company Km Kilometer kV Kilovolts LARC Local Area Resettlement Committees L.R. No Land Reference Number NEMA National Environment Management Authority OP Operational Policy PAPs Project Affected Persons PIC Public Information Centre PIU Project Implementation Unit RAP Resettlement Action Plan RSC Resettlement Steering Committee RoW Right of Way RLA Registered Land Act SME Small and Medium Sized Enterprises VAT Value Added Tax

Page 5: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 5 of 8 

 

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The valuation process of the Kindaruma-Mwingi-Garissa Transmission Line is premised on the National and International Regulations that trigger resettlement whenever land is needed for public interest. Nationally, the major regulations related to this project include the following: The Constitution of Kenya (2010), The Land Act (2012), and The Way Leave Act and Eviction and Resettlement Bill (2012). Internationally, valuation is based on the principles provided in the World Bank Policy (OP 4.12) on Involuntary Resettlement. The methods adopted for this valuation were both the comparables and Gross replacement cost methods aimed at estimating the replacement cost of the developments that would be affected by the project. Valuation of land was based on zonal values and comparables from a Mwingi-Tsaikuru road project that was undertaken this year (2012). A major challenge in the valuation process was that most of the land is unregistered and remains as trust land, though there are settlements. This made it difficult to establish the claims by the residents. Valuation of trees was based on the list of values from the Ministry of Agricultural and Forestry. Most of the land was still in its natural state, and thus most of the trees were indigenous. The project will acquire approximately 1,728 acres of which, 886 acres is registered and privately owned by individuals, groups or institutions, while 842acres is not registered and is held as trust land. The value is approximately Kshs. 297,382,000 (read Kenya shillings, two hundred and ninety seven million, three hundred and eighty two thousand only) for the land. About 28,260 trees will be affected valued at approximately Ksh.43, 724,250 (read Kenya Shillings forty three million, seven hundred and twenty four thousands, two hundred and fifty. About 490 structures will be affected by the project valued at approximately Ksh.66, 574,407 (Read Kenya Shillings, sixty six million, five hundred and seventy four Thousand, four hundred and seven only). Approximately 30% of the total will be added for resettlement, monitoring and evaluation, and other miscellaneous needs that may arise, which is approximately Kshs. 122,304,197 (Read, Kenya Shillings one hundred and twenty two Million three hundred and four thousands, one hundred and ninety seven only)). Therefore the total project cost is approximately Ksh. 529,984,854 (Read Kenya Shillings five hundred and twenty nine million, nine hundred and eighty four thousands, eight hundred and fifty four only).

Page 6: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 6 of 8 

 

1 VALUATION

1.1 Introduction

In property valuations there are 5 generally accepted methods or approaches to value. These are the Sales Comparison, the Income Capitalization, the Gross Replacement Cost Method (GRC), the Residual, and the Profits method: The first method comparative approach to value that considers the sales of similar of substitute properties and related market data and establishes a value estimate by processes involving comparison. Property prices needs to be analyzed and interpreted in order to obtain the true values utilized in the comparison analysis. This method is the preferred approach in an active market where a trend of prices can be established. The second method is a comparative approach that considers income and expense data relating to the property being valued and estimate value through a capitalization process. This method is applied when income generating capabilities is present and is considered by the market as forming the primary basis for value. The capital value arrived at is the value attributed to the right to an annual income stream. This approach, to name a few, entails a research and analysis of transaction prices of similar or comparably substituting properties, rental rates, expense ratios, yields, capitalization rates, tenant covenants, and risk. In essence this approach entails an income stream from which expenses are deducted, the net income is then capitalized (income is converted to capital) by dividing it with a capitalization factor. Although the value is determined by capitalization, the basis of information researched and analyzed by utilizing the comparison approach. This method, therefore, is a combination of income and expense data though valued by processes of comparison. The third method, known as the Gross replacement Cost method(GRC) evaluates the current cost of replacing an asset with its modern equivalent asset less deductions for physical deterioration and all the relevant forms of optimization such as the expected optimum land productivity. This is appropriate when little or no market evidence is available and the property does not transact readily in the market. The approach entails the measuring of the improvements (buildings, site works) to which the appropriate construction costs are applied, resulting in the new replacement (or reproduction) cost. A depreciation factor (being composed of three factors namely physical deterioration, functional obsolescence, and external or economical obsolescence) is applied to the replacement values per category or segment in order to arrive at the present day value for the improvements. The market value of the land as if unimproved is then to be determined and added to this depreciated amount with the total amount reflecting the market value for the property. The fourth method, known as the residual method, is the estimated amount that an entity can obtain from the disposal of an asset after deducting the estimated costs of disposal, if the asset were already of the age and in condition expected at the end of its useful life. This approach is applicable where a valuation is to be conducted for undeveloped land or where redevelopment of an obsolescent piece of land demands it. The first step is to estimate the value of the development as complete, whether it’s a township development or residential development or any other use or type of building. Then an allowance for development costs, professional fees, advertising and marketing costs, financing costs, developer’s profit and risk is deducted from the value as complete which results in the residual value.

Page 7: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 7 of 8 

 

The fifth method is the profit’s method and is sometimes referred to as the accounting method. The method entails an estimation of the gross annual income or turnover from which cost of sales and operating expenses are deducted. The net balance is then divided into a rent and profit split. The rental split is capitalized at an appropriate capitalization factor. In addition, the goodwill is to be ascertained at a market related multiplier with the market represented by the total of these two amounts. The second approach takes the estimated net profit only, divides it into a rental and profit split, and capitalizes the rental amount in order to determine the value of the business “lock, stock and barrel”.

1.2 Analysis of the Valuation Methodology Adopted for this Project

1.2.1 Structures

The method adopted is the Gross Replacement Value Method and comparable method that evaluates the current cost of replacing an asset. This is appropriate because there is little or no market evidence available. The approach entails the measuring of the improvements (buildings, site works) to which the appropriate construction costs are applied, resulting in the new replacement (or reproduction) cost. An addition of 15% is added to the value as statutory allowance to cater for disturbance.

1.2.2 Trees and Crops

Trees and crops are counted and valued based on the values given from the Ministry of agriculture (see attached annex from the Ministry). During the field work, the trees were recorded according to the size (Young, Medium, or Mature) interpretation of the values of the trees and crops values was sought from the agricultural officer. Comparables from the Ministry of land were also checked on compulsory acquisition cases, and a list was prepared as attached in Annex. This was a dry season and no crops were found in the farms.

1.2.3 Land Values

Land values were calculated based on zonal values and comparable values (Mwingi-Tseikuru Road 2012 Project) from the Ministry of Lands. A large portion of the land (approximately 910 acres) is not registered and falls under trust land. This area was valued based on the zonal values and government comparables. A major challenge was on establishing the individual land ownership where the land was not registered, while some of the land is settled and developed and adjudication is ongoing (such as Nguni), other land is undeveloped but there are individuals claiming for ownership (especially Ukasi to Garrissa). Establishing individual land interests on this area was not possible and the land was valued as a whole under trust land. The second challenge was establishing the whole land, while the team was able to establish the affected land using GPS, due to the alignment of the transmission line, some land did not have searches from the Ministry of lands and that made it difficult to get the size of the whole land. This can be established by carrying out the land searches.

1.3 Primary Data Collection

The data collected during field survey was as follows, i. Land size was established by the surveyor noting the size of the whole land and also

the land affected (The challenge was in cases where the land is not adjudicated. The land is held informally by individuals but registered under the local authority. Under such cases, the affected land and whole land per individual could not established)

Page 8: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

Norken International Limited Engineering and Management Consultants    September 2013 

 

Kindaruma‐Mwingi‐Garissa Transmission Line Resettlement Action Plan    Page 8 of 8 

 

ii. Affected structures were measured and the structures characteristic noted. They include, the materials used in the construction of walls, roof, floor and the status of the structure. For purposes of depreciation factor, the date that the structures were built were also noted.

iii. Trees were counted, noting the types of the trees, and the size iv. On crops, this was a dry season, and none were found in the farm. There was also the

assumption that since power line does not prohibit farming, any farming done before the project commences needed not be compensated.

1.4 Basis for Valuation

The valuation process is premised on the national and international regulations that trigger resettlement whenever land is needed for public interest. Nationally the major regulations include Constitution of Kenya (2010), Land Act (2012), and Way leave Act and Eviction and resettlement bill (2012). Internationally, valuation is based on the principles provided in the World Bank Policies (OP 4.12) on Involuntary Resettlement.

1.5 Cost Summary

The compensation cost caters for structures and 15% disturbance allowance, land and trees valuations. Valuations for crops were not done explained earlier because at the time of the census and socio-economic survey, the season was dry and there were no crops in the fields. The Consultant has also assumed that since this is a transmission line project, crops will not be affected and the PAPs can continue to grow and harvest their crops. The total compensation cost is approximately Kshs.530 Million as indicated in the Table below and the breakdown of the cost estimates is provided in Appendices 1-3.

Table 1: Summary of Costs

Item Quantity Cost (Kshs)

Structures Values 490 number 66,574,407

Land Values 1,728 acres 297,382,000

Tree Values 85,257 trees 43,724,250

Sub-Total 407,680,657

30% to cater for resettlement costs, transportation, monitoring and evaluation and miscellaneous

122,304,197

Total Compensation Cost 529,984,854

  

Page 9: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal Value

Start End

1 1134

David Ndeto

Kasyima Kyondoni Kivaa 722466135 68.5

368208E

,9910266 N

367907 E ,

9910354 N . 2.32 3.4 150,000 348,000

2 822

James

King'esi

Mwangangi Kyondoni Kivaa 715606751 172

369019 E ,

9910158 N.

368944 E ,

9910186 N . 0.6 0.3 150,000 90,000

3 1105

Josphat

Kyengo

Ndwiwa Kyondoni Kivaa 711844430 14.2

368827 E,

9910166N

368907E,

9910176N 0.6 4.2 150,000 90,000

4 1107

Joseph

Mutuku

Ndwiwa Kyondoni Kivaa 16.2

368907E,

9910176N

369037E,

9910149N 0.3 1.8 150,000 45,000

5 820

Anthony

Mbolu

Ndwiwa Kyondoni Kivaa

729652395/

0717842098

4 30

369302 E ,

9910015N

369019 E,

9910158 N . 2.35 7.8 150,000 352,500

6 613

Mulu Katiku

Mukulu Kyondoni Kivaa 711844430 19.5

369311 E ,

9910003 N

369533 E .

9909892 N . 1.83 9.4 150,000 274,500

7 895

Samuel

Mwanzia

Muindi Kyondoni Kivaa

0728360196

/

0727654846

/

0726845122 10.1 0.01 0.1 150,000 1,500

8 * 968

Bonface

Muia Kioko Kyondoni Kivaa

0729248657

/

0728595947 0.11 150,000 16,500

9 611

Bonface

Muia Kioko Kyondoni Kivaa

729284657/

0728595974 4.2

369533 E,

9909892 N

369623 E,

9909836 N. 0.8 19.2 150,000 120,000

10 600

Patrick

Tunda

Maingi Kyondoni Kivaa

0723425796

/

0717041819

369623 E,

9909836 N.

369903E,

9909703 N. 2.31 150,000 346,500

Co-ordinates

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 1

Page 10: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

11 50

Joseph

Nzioka

Kimilu Kyondoni Kivaa 707337887 4

370599 E,

990338 N

370278 E,

9909504 N. 2.09 52.7 150,000 313,500

12 125

Kavuli

Mutuku

Mwanga Kyondoni Kivaa 710544455 39.7

370278 E ,

9909504 N.

370027 E,

9909634 N. 2.09 5.3 150,000 313,500

13

Musyoka

Ndambuki Kyondoni Kivaa

370027E,

9909634N

369903E,

9909703 N. 1.05 150,000 157,500

14 733 Mutune Kyondoni Kivaa

370599 E,

9909338 N

370776 E,

9909246 N 1.62 150,000 243,000

15 59

Jeremiah

Nzioki Kyondoni Kivaa 726503854 1.8

370776 E,

9909246 N.

370914 E,

9909172 N. 1.16 65.9 150,000 174,000

16 76

Ruth Ndindi

Ngila Kyondoni Kivaa 7.9

370914 E,

9909172N

370960 E,

9909149 N. 0.38 4.8 150,000 57,000

17 897

Kilonzo

Musyoka Kyondoni Kivaa 717763817 5.2

370960 E,

9909149 N

371000 E,

9909125 N. 0.38 7.2 150,000 57,000

18 730

Teresiah

Kavata

Mulwa Kyondoni Kivaa 703166425 6

371000 E,

9909125 N.

371031 E,

9909111 N. 0.25 4.2 150,000 37,500

19 3 &4

Mumbua

Mwitwa Kyondoni kivaa

0729496133

/

0714436481 35.7

371031 E,

9909111 N

371391 E,

9908921 N. 3.02 8.4 150,000 453,000

20 901

Mumbua

Mwitwa Kyondoni kivaa

0729496133

/

0714436482 6.3

0371058E,

9909122N

0371413E,

9908942N 2.95 47.1 150,000 442,500

21 5 Muia Mbithi Kyondoni kivaa

0716466560

/

0739716065 31.8

371391 E,

9908921 N.

371660 E,

9908774 N. 2.27 7.1 150,000 340,500

22 53

Benedict

Mwendwa

Muthini Thaana Thaana Nzau 724376573 21

371768 E,

9908720 N.

372018 E,

9908605 N. 2.04 9.7 150,000 306,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 2

Page 11: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

23 845

William

Wambua

Mutui

inherited by

Thomas

King'oo

Mutui Thaana Thaana Nzau 712427401

372018 E,

9908605 N.

372215 E,

9908517 N 1.6 150,000 240,000

24 52

Bonface

Mbai Thaana Thaana Nzau 704962743 1.7

372030 E,

9908597 N.

372090 E,

9908574 N. 0.49 28.1 150,000 73,500

25 50

Benjamin

Maluki

Mwasya Thaana Thaana Nzau 704985915 3.4

372215 E,

9908517 N

372332 E,

9908463 N. 0.95 27.7 150,000 142,500

26 51

Patrick

Malusi

Muthangya Thaana Thaana Nzau 9.1

372332 E,

9908463 N

372515 E,

9908379 N 1.49 16.5 150,000 223,500

27 41

Michael

Kusola

Musee Thaana Thaana Nzau 718702248 12.2

372528 E ,

9908378 N

372574 E,

9908352 N. 0.39 3.2 150,000 58,500

28 29

Pius Ngiti

Kalaa Thaana Thaaana Nzau 707673814 49.8

372574

E,9908352 N

373007

E,9908159 N. 3.51 7.1 150,000 526,500

29 59

Bonface

Mulinge

Kiliku Thaana Thaaana Nzau

373007 E,

9908159 N.

373108 E,

9908107 N. 0.84 150,000 126,000

30 119 Kyasi Kyalivu Kasavini Thaaana Nzau 716109949

0374404E,

9907654N

0374429E,

9907644N 0.2 150,000 30,000

31 115

Paul Ituli

Ngeta Thaana Thaaana Nzau 721928399

373510 E,

9907925 N

373690 E,

9907844 N. 1.46 150,000 219,000

32 115

Kivawa

Kitema Thaana Thaaana Nzau 718014104 63.5

373390 E,

9907844 N

373810 E,

9907789 N. 0.98 1.5 150,000 147,000

33 171

Dominic

Kitema

Mulwa Thaana Thaaana Nzau 717780292

373810 E,

9907789 N

375474 E,

9907037 N 13.53 150,000 2,029,500

34

132, 133,

135, 137,

139

Makau

Kivata

Makau Kakongo Kairungu 713714198 223.6

375474 E,

9907037 N

376270 E,

9906640 N 6.63 3 150,000 994,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 3

Page 12: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

35 957

Mwinzi

Munuve Kairungu Kairungu 52.8

377025E,

9905825N

377462E,

9905353N 4.76 9 150,000 714,000

36 948

Juliana

Katunge

Mwatoo Kakongo Kairungu 700852983 13.4

377563 E,

9905282 N

377761 E.

9905127 N 1.86 13.9 150,000 279,000

37 905

Juliana

Munanu

Mwangangi Kakongo Kairungu 713686186 54.1

377761 E,

9905127 N

378119 E,

9904848 N 3.36 6.2 150,000 504,000

38 903 Andrew David Ngusya 52.6

378119 E,

9904848 N

378403 E,

9904509 N 3.29 6.3 150,000 493,500

39 925

Michael

Mutisya

Kyere Kakongo Kairungu

0720071615

/

0788323029

/

0701876184 19.8 5*60 m 0.07 0.4 150,000 10,500

40 925 Michael Mutisya Kyere

378403 E,

9904509 N

378494 E,

9904398 N. 1.07 150,000 160,500

41 901 Kyere Munuve KimwereKakongo Kairungu 23.1

378494 E,

9904398 N

378572 E,

9904301 N 0.92 4 150,000 138,000

42 480

Simon

Kathara

Kyere Kakongo Kairungu 721843438 93.4

378579 E,

9904289 N

378700 E,

9904141 N. 0.57 0.6 150,000 85,500

43 465 Ngata Singa Kakongo Kairungu 729397510 120.9

378700 E,

9904132 N

379031 E,

9903717 N. 3.93 3.3 150,000 589,500

44 759

Fredrick Muli

Kyania Kairungu Kairungu 711486823 44.2

379031 E,

9903717 N

379128 E,

9903596 N. 1.15 2.6 150,000 172,500

45 Simon Kathara Kyere 721843438

379128 E,

9903596 N.

379259 E,

9903430 N. 1.57 150,000 235,500

46 2416

Julius Musai

Mbiti Kairungu Kairungu 723780318

379280 E,

9903409 N.

379389

E,9903271 N. 1.3 150,000 195,000

47 Simon Kathara Kyere 721843438

379389 E,

9903271 N.

379495 E,

9903142 N. 1.25 150,000 187,500

48 2241

Kinami

Ngoto Kairungu Kairungu 725241471 89.6

379495 E,

9903142 N

379783 E,

9902965 N. 2.5 2.8 150,000 375,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 4

Page 13: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

49 2226

Mutunga

Kyania

Ikanzu Kairungu Kairungu

0723984568

/

0719609915 34

379783 E,

9902965 N.

379936

E,9902835 N. 1.48 4.4 150,000 222,000

50 1921

Damaris

Kasembi

Komu Kairungu Kairungu 710879787 21.3 0.12 0.6 150,000 18,000

51 1920

Peter

Maithya

Kimanzi Kairungu Kairungu 721589453 6.4

379942 E,

9902830 N

380004 E,

9902784 N. 0.57 9 150,000 85,500

52 1919

Paul

Munyambu

Kimanzi Kairungu Kairungu

0721167041

/

0725395590 9.4

380004E,

9902784 N

.380104 E

9902716 N 0.9 9.6 150,000 135,000

53 1918

Joseph

Musili Kioko Kairungu Kairungu 711460951 34.2

380104 E,

9902716 N

380272

E,9902601 N. 1.51 4.4 150,000 226,500

54 1917

Julius Ngui

Kioko Kairungu Kairungu 723217411 33.7

380389

E,9902520 N

380487 E,

9902464 N 0.83 2.5 150,000 124,500

55 1911

James

Kyamui

Ngandi Kairungu Kairungu 728287034 5.3

380487E,

9902464 N

380582 E,

9902390 N 0.89 16.7 150,000 133,500

56 1907

Kathuva

Kithikii Kairungu Kairungu 716458817

380582 E,

9902390 N

380668 E,

9902326 N 0.79 150,000 118,500

57 1908

Julius

Nyerere

Ngandi Kairungu Kairungu 729556727 10.5

380668 E,

9902326 N.

380839 E,

9902209 N 1.54 14.7 150,000 231,000

58 1902

Boniface

Kimanzi

Mwania Kairungu Kairungu 708720521 15.5

380839E,990

2209 N

381071,

E,9902052 N. 2.08 13.4 150,000 312,000

59 1853

Zacheaus

Kalundo Katu Kairungu Kairungu 700858884 10.8 10m*30m 0.07 0.7 150,000 10,500

60 1852

Joseph

Musili Katu Kairungu Kairungu 701630553 11.4

381079

E,9902042 N

381524

E,9901733 N. 2.66 23.2 150,000 399,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 5

Page 14: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

61 1849

Nathan

Kathuri

Mwendwa Kairungu Kairungu 723117026 33.4

381378 E,

9901844 N

381524

E,9901733 N. 1.36 4.1 150,000 204,000

62 1848

Mutemi

Joseph

Mwendwa Kairungu Kairungu 723685983 30.4

381524

E,9901733 N

381684 E,

9901626 N. 1.43 4.7 150,000 214,500

63 1860

Cyrus

Mwendwa

Mutemi Kairungu Kairungu 710446043 9.2

381684 E,

9901626 N

381942 E,

9901445 N 2.34 25.5 150,000 351,000

64 1869

Daniel

Mwendwa

lava Kairungu Kairungu 723685983 26.4

381942 E,

9901445 N

382296 E,

9901204 N. 3.25 12.3 150,000 487,500

65 1679

David Ng'ati

Meli Kairungu Kairungu 725227991 36.5

382305E,

9901196 N.

382597 E,

9900989 N. 2.65 7.3 150,000 397,500

66 1840 Gabriel Ngeta MununaKairungu Kairungu 13.5

382597E,990

09809 N

382627 E,

9900971 N 0.26 1.9 150,000 39,000

67 1780

Sammy

Musili

Ngunga Kairungu Kairungu 726657646 44.2

382627 E,

9900971 N.

382770 E,

9900874 N. 1.28 2.9 150,000 192,000

68 1780

Joel Maithya

Wambua Kairungu Kairungu

0713267642

/

0736689395 42.1

383021 E,

9900701 N

382770 E,

9900874 N. 2.26 5.4 150,000 339,000

69 1779

Tabitha

Wambua Kairungu Kairungu

0713267642

/073668939

5 75.8

383021 E,

9900701 N

383140 E,

9900617 N. 1.08 1.4 150,000 162,000

70 1692

Joshua

Mutemi

Muisyo Kairungu Kairungu 9.5

383141E,

9900615 N.

383262

E,9900532 N. 1.09 11.5 150,000 163,500

71 1691

Emmanuel

Musyoka

Muisyo Kairungu Kairungu 718728349 7

383262

E,9900532 N.

383406 E,

9900432 N. 1.3 18.6 150,000 195,000

72 1782

Muithya

Ivai(decease

d) Nzanzai

Mwinzai Kairungu Kairungu 715711487 28.5

383406 E,

9900432 N.

383672 E,

9900249 N. 2.39 8.4 150,000 358,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 6

Page 15: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

73 1783

Nyamu

Mutemi

Katungu Kairungu Kairungu 15.8

383672 E,

9900249 N

383836 E,

9900137 N 1.47 9.3 150,000 220,500

74 1684

Benjamin

Ngui Nzioka Kairungu Kairungu 717515637 15

383582 E,

9900122 N.

383895 E,

9900092 N. 0.4 2.6 150,000 60,000

75 1385 Joseph Mwendwa Mutemikairungu kairungu 30.1

383911 E,

9900081 N

384036E,

9899998 N. 1.11 3.7 150,000 166,500

76 1386

Francis Kithu

Mutemi Kairungu Kairungu 723507719 6.9

384038 E,

9899995 N.

384234 E,

9899860 N. 1.76 25.4 150,000 264,000

77 1392

Musyoka

Mulu Kairungu Kairungu 718324046 34.4

384234 E,

9899860 N

384352 E,

9899776 N. 1.07 3.1 150,000 160,500

78 1396 Mwinzi Kairungu Kairungu 9.6

384352 E,

9899776 N.

384408

E,9899737 N. 0.51 5.3 150,000 76,500

79 1398 Unoo Kavuu MukutaKiomo Kiomo 33

384408 E,

9899737 N.

384598 E,

9899601N. 1.73 5.3 350,000 605,500

80 1410 Mbathi Musyimi KonyeKiomo Kiomo 29.7

384598 E,

9899601 N

384678 E,

9899556 N. 0.68 2.3 350,000 238,000

81 1399 Katana Kieve Kiomo Kiomo

384678 E,

9899556 N.

384801 E,

9899467 N. 1.12 350,000 392,000

82 1399 Mwivi Kieve Kiomo Kiomo 712641038 46.3

384801 E,

9899467 N.

384953 E,

9899363 N. 1.36 2.9 350,000 476,000

83 1415

Kavata Kieve

Ndana Kiomo Kiomo 725741645 9

384953 E,

9899363 N

385081 E,

9899271 N. 1.17 12.9 350,000 409,500

84 1412

Musyoka

Konye Ndana Kiomo Kiomo

0700058851

/

0720048444

2/

0719478396 7.1

385081 E,

9899271 N.

385197 E,

9899192 N. 1.04 14.7 350,000 364,000

85 1418

Mbathi

Musyimi

Konye Kiomo Kiomo 708474297 11.3

385197 E,

9899192 N.

385375 E,

9899076 N. 1.57 13.9 350,000 549,500

86 1417

Mutwa

Kitheka

Musyimi Kiomo Kiomo 702011422

385386

E,9899063 N.

385569 E,

9898935 N. 1.65 350,000 577,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 7

Page 16: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

87

Mwingi/Kio

mo/1401

John Mutemi

Musee Kiomo Kiomo 721382198 38.3

385579 E,

9898932 N.

385858 E,

9898777 N. 2.36 6.2 350,000 826,000

88 1439 Phillip Mati KitisyaKiomo Kiomo 5.9

385858 E,

9898777 N.

385859 E,

9898755 N. 0.03 0.6 350,000 10,500

89 1495

James

Mulwa

Kyalya Kiomo Kiomo 721778624 7.1

385906 E,

9898757 N.

385991 E,

9898709 N. 0.72 10.2 400,000 288,000

90 1494

Mati Kyalya

(Sold to

Laban

Rindiri) Kiomo Kiomo 711593767 4.1

385991 E,

9898709 N

386073

E,9898658 N 0.71 17.3 400,000 284,000

91 2323

Laban

Muthengi

Rindiri Kiomo Kiomo

0722694486

/

0725008514 2.8

386147

E,9898622 N.

386073

E,9898658 N 0.61 21.4 400,000 244,000

92 1491

Laban

Muthengi

Rindiri Kiomo Kiomo

0722694486

/

0725008514 7.6

386147 E,

9898622 N.

386227 E,

9898583 N. 0.66 8.7 400,000 264,000

93 1536

John Kilonzi

Kikumbu Kiomo Kiomo

0722489705

/

0721778624 3.9

386227 E,

9898583 N.

386315 E,

9898526 N. 0.77 20 400,000 308,000

94 1534

Joel Mwaniki

Kikumbu Kiomo Kiomo 722489705 8.2

386315 E,

9898526 N

386478 E,

9898442 N. 0.55 6.7 400,000 220,000

95 1535

John Kilonzi

Kikumbi,

David

Kikumbi,Joel

Mwaniki

Kikumbi Kiomo Kiomo 722489705 0.5

386478 E,

9898442 N.

386498 E,

9898432 N. 0.17 30.5 400,000 68,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 8

Page 17: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

96 1490

Kitui Kivunzi

Munyambu Kiomo Kiomo

0711118247

/

0712458893 18.3

386505

E,9898430 N.

387118 E,

9898334 N. 4.61 25.2 400,000 1,844,000

97 1485 Michael Kaka MatitiKiomo Kiomo

387118 E,

9898334 N

387363 E,

9898134N. 2.38 400,000 952,000

98 646

Michael

Kilonzi

Musee Kiomo Kiomo 721201240 5.1

387373 E,

9898131 N.

387470 E,

9898049 N. 0.94 18.3 400,000 376,000

99 638 Michael Kilonzi MuseeKiomo Kiomo 14.2

387373 E,

9898131 N.

387470 E,

9898049 N. 0.94 6.6 400,000 376,000

100 647 Phillip Kitheka MuseeKiomo Kiomo 2.4

387638 E,

9897894 N.

387679 E,

9897866 N. 0.37 15.3 400,000 148,000

101 623 Kimanzi Musee (deceased)Kiomo Kiomo 7.1

387679 E,

9897866 N

387716 E,

9897838 N 0.34 4.9 400,000 136,000

102 626

David

Mwangangi

Musee Kiomo Kiomo 721382198 11.3

387716 E,

9897838 N.

387730 E ,

9897817 N. 0.18 1.6 400,000 72,000

103 627

Mbathe

Kilungu

Mutisya Kiomo Kiomo 701779356 9.9

387730 E ,

9897817 N.

387877 E,

9897712 N. 1.33 13.5 400,000 532,000

104 641

Thomas

Tinga

Mutisya Kiomo Kiomo 712789345 9

387877E,

9897712N

387971E,

9897661N 0.79 8.8 400,000 316,000

105 655

Annah

Nzambi Muli Kiomo Kiomo 723655986 4.2

387971E,

9897661N

388118E,

9897582N 1.24 29.6 500,000 620,000

106 684

Dominic

Mwinzi

Muthama Kiomo Kiomo 704872791 46.1

388118E,

9897582N

388465E,

9897401N 2.9 6.3 500,000 1,450,000

107 685

John

Musembi

Mutio Kiomo Kiomo 706586747 15.2

388465E,

9897401N

388635E,

9897313N 1.42 9.3 500,000 710,000

108 688

Francis

Musili

Musyimi Kiomo Kiomo 716247470 6.3

389209E,

9897010N

389413E,

9896907N 1.69 26.8 500,000 845,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 9

Page 18: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

109 2224

Titus

Ndambu

Musili Kiomo Kiomo

0712515113

/

0734030321 5.5

388725E,

9897265N

3888725E,

9897265N 0.81 14.7 500,000 405,000

110 593

John Kilonzo

Musili Kiomo Kiomo 716275430 3.2

388833E,

9897211N

38889E,

9897176N 0.55 17.1 500,000 275,000

111 595

Syothome

Mbiva

Kitense Kiomo Kiomo 4.1

388899E,

9897176N

388994E,

9897176N 0.62 15.1 500,000 310,000

112 554

John

Nzamba

Kithu Kiomo Kiomo

0718501948

/

0727986294 7.4

389114E,

9897059N

389209E,

9897010N 0.79 10.7 500,000 395,000

113 2504

John

Nzamba

Kithu Kiomo Kiomo

0718501948

/

0727986294 7.8

388998E,

9897121N

389114E,

9897059N 5.78 74.1 500,000 2,890,000

114 555

Telesia Mali

Mulyungi Kiomo Kiomo 0711692828' 10.1

389417E,

9896904N

389564E,

9896824N 2.07 20.5 500,000 1,035,000

115 549

Munuve

Mbuvu Kiomo Kiomo 712694052 1

389682E,

9896765N

389809E,

9896698N 1 96.4 500,000 500,000

116 569

Jackson

Kimoro

Kimanzi

(Deceased);

Sammy

Kimoro (Son) Kiomo Kiomo 726006403 8.4

389860E,

9896672N

390040E,

9896575N 1.52 18.1 500,000 760,000

117 2358

Kikunduu

Self Help

Group Kiomo Kiomo 714210785 2.7

389809E,

9896698N

389860E,

9896672N 0.42 15.7 500,000 210,000

118 558

Bernard

Mutunga

Katambu Kiomo Kiomo 0721293254'

389564E,

9896824N

389611E,

9896801N 0.39 500,000 195,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 10

Page 19: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

119 569

Jackson

Kimoro

Kimanzi

(Deceased);

Sammy

Kimoro (Son) Kiomo Kiomo 726006403 8.4

389860E,

9896672N

390040E,

9896575N 1.52 18.1 500,000 760,000

120 579

James

Mutunga

Musyimi Kiomo Kiomo 714210785 12.6

390045E,

9896575N

390101E,

9896544N 0.47 3.8 500,000 235,000

121 2432

Loise Gideon

Kamia Kiomo Kiomo 713980376 4.5

390555E,

9896305N

390665E,

9896247N 0.92 20.5 500,000 460,000

122 290

Dorothy

Kasyoka

Munywoki Kiomo Kiomo 0731046787'

392844 E,

9896865 N.

392868 E,

9896949 N. 0.64 600,000 384,000

123 288

Peter

Muinde

Nduvi Kiomo Kiomo 717168886

392835 E,

9896839 N.

392844 E,

9896866 N. 0.2 600,000 120,000

124

Mwende

Mutaaru

Nzuva Kiomo Kiomo 0708124438'

392768 E,

9896612 N.

392787 E,

9896676 N 0.49 600,000 294,000

125 286 Sarah Mumbe MusyokaKiomo Kiomo 727885857

392768 E,

9896612 N

392833 E,

9896828 N. 1.67 600,000 1,002,000

126 289 Mwende Mutaru NzuvaKiomo Kiomo 2.9

392833 E,

9896828 N.

392835 E,

9896839 0.26 8.8 600,000 156,000

127 283

Masila Nzuva

Kakunyi Kiomo Kiomo 725360969 7.2

392728 E,

9896475 N

392768 E,

9896612 N. 1.06 14.8 600,000 636,000

128 281

Alice Mungai

Kathoka Kiomo Kiomo 712507650 69.3

392601 E,

9896050 N.

392728 E,

9896475 N. 3.29 4.7 600,000 1,974,000

129 280

Patrick

Munyoki

Mwandao

(Deceased) Kiomo Kiomo 711801499 34.7

392513 E,

9895749 N.

392601 E,

9896050 N. 2.32 6.7 600,000 1,392,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 11

Page 20: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

130 178

Kimanzi

Mutumba

(Deceased) Kiomo Kiomo 0700707152'

392402 E,

9895377 N.

392513 E,

9895749 N. 2.88 600,000 1,728,000

131 403

Joseph

Mutemi

Munyoki Kiomo Kiomo

0702936135

/

0704401959

390608 E,

9896370 N.

390521 E,

9896379 N. 0.65 600,000 390,000

132 241

James Muli

Munyithya

(Deceased) Kiomo Kiomo 0717220638'

390776 E,

9896339 N.

390608 E,

9896370 N. 1.27 600,000 762,000

133 2430 John Munyoki Kitheka

390849 E,

9896331 N

390776 E,

9896339 N. 0.55 700,000 385,000

134 Muthui Mwasuvye

390940 E,

9896271 N.

390849 E,

9896331 N. 0.79 700,000 553,000

135 2430 John Munyoki Kitheka

391020 E,

9896219 N

390940 E,

9896271 N. 0.69 700,000 483,000

136 2181

John Musili

Muthui Kiomo Kiomo 715098508 8.8

391345 E,

9896019 N.

391020 E,

9896219 N 2.94 33.4 700,000 2,058,000

137 182

Thomas

Nduvi Mboo Kiomo Kiomo 720997807 20.3

391782 E,

9895735 N.

391675 E,

9895804 N. 0.94 4.6 700,000 658,000

138 4288

Joyce

Muthina

Muli Kyanika Mwingi 711579856 5.3

392881 E,

9896995 N.

392917 E,

9897115 N. 0.93 17.6 800,000 744,000

139 659 Musili Ndilu Mang'ooKyanika Kyanika 1.2

392917 E,

9897115 N

392938 E,

9897185 N 0.67 56.4 800,000 536,000

140 657 Anna Muingo NdiluKyanika Kyanika 1.7

392938 E,

9897185 N

392955 E,

9897259 N 0.56 33.3 800,000 448,000

141 593

Ferdinand

musyoka

Syengo

(Inherited by

Edwin

Musyoka

Syengo) Kyanika Mwingi 720605751 4.6

392955 E,

9897259 N.

392983 E,

9897339 N. 0.63 13.6 800,000 504,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 12

Page 21: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

142 594 Makau MumamaKyanika Mwingi 4.2

392983 E,

9897339 N

392989E,

9897361N. 0.17 4 800,000 136,000

143 4734 Jane Nguli ( deceased). Muli Nguli.Kyanika Mwingi 725407371 1.8

392989 E,

9897361 N

393010 E,

9897433 N 0.56 30.9 800,000 448,000

144 584 Benjamin Muthami MasilaKyanika Mwingi 3.6

393010 E,

9897433 N

393020 E,

9897461 N 0.22 6.2 800,000 176,000

145 4733

Peter Mbuvi

Vere

(Deceased) Kyanika Mwingi 712102504 8

393020 E,

9897461 N

393066 E,

9897611 N. 1.16 14.6 800,000 928,000

146 4729

Musyimi

Vere Makau Kyanika Mwingi 719286722 8.7

393066 E,

9897611 N

393098 E,

9897721 N. 0.85 9.7 800,000 680,000

147 4729 Lucas Mutua Muthami. Sold by Musyimi vereKyanika Mwingi

393098 E,

9897721 N.

393112 E,

9897757 N. 0.29 800,000 232,000

148 663 Patrick Mwinzi MatitiKyanika Mwingi 37

393112 E,

9897757 N

393141 E,

9897801 N 0.39 1.1 1,000,000 390,000

149 585

Benjamin

Wambua

Matiti Kyanika Mwingi

0728253040

/

0724608925 9.2

393141 E,

9897757 N

393223 E,

9897968 N. 1.38 15 1,000,000 1,380,000

150 1065

Mulwa

Mwalwa Kyanika Mwingi

0739168629

/

0700672048 0.9 40m*15m 0.15 16.4 1,000,000 150,000

151 588

Simon

Kimanthi

Malusi Kyanika Mwingi 725787651 1

393277 E,

9898040 N

393420 E,

9898172 N. 0.67 68.5 1,000,000 670,000

152 585 Benjamin Wambua MatitiKyanika Mwingi 7.9

393277 E,

9898040 N

393420 E,

9898172 N. 1.44 18.3 1,000,000 1,440,000

153 575

Anthony

Mutua

Mwinzi Kyanika Mwingi 702879492 14.6

393420 E,

9898172 N,

393484 E,

9898229 N. 0.63 4.4 1,000,000 630,000

154 574

John Thomas

Ngwei Kyanika Mwingi

0716742290

/

0728920911 1.4

393484 E,

9898229 N

393518 E,

9898261 N. 0.35 25.4 1,000,000 350,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 13

Page 22: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

155 571

Mulatya

Ulinge Kyanika Mwingi 713369289

393520E,

9898268N

393538E,

9898287N 0.2 1,000,000 200,000

156 572

Kiluti

Mutunga

Maengo Kyanika Mwingi 717322145 12.4

393538 E,

9898287 N.

393552 E,

9898294 N. 0.11 0.9 1,000,000 110,000

157 571

Mwangangi

Mulinge Kyanika Mwingi 710677173 8.4

393552 E,

9898294 N.

393564 E,

9898308 N. 0.14 1.6 1,000,000 140,000

158 571

Mwangangi

Mulinge

(Deceased)-

Sold to Jacob

Mulatya Kyanika Mwingi 713369289

393564 E,

9898308 N.

393631 E,

9898368 N. 0.67 1,000,000 670,000

159 4496

Francis

Mwaniki

Munuve Kyanika Mwingi

0725800358

/

0732074821 1.3

393631 E,

9898368 N.

393705 E,

9898439 N. 0.76 56.6 1,000,000 760,000

160 576

Charles Kyalo

Nduvi Kyanika Mwingi 720997807 3.4

393735 E,

9898439 N.

393760 E,

9898487 N. 0.38 11.3 1,000,000 380,000

161 691

Kilonzi

Mulatya Kyanika Mwingi 716104683 9.9 0.11 1.1 1,000,000 110,000

162 4396

Thomas

Ngondu

Mwinzi Kyanika Mwingi 710652012 4

393775 E,

9898506 N

393895 E,

9898618 N. 1.22 30.3 1,200,000 1,464,000

163 993

Dominic

Musyoka

Mwangangi Kyanika Mwingi 725725494 10.2 150m*15m 0.56 5.5 1,200,000 672,000

164 954

Johnson

Munyoki

Kano Kyanika Mwingi 716781853 4.8

393895 E,

9898618 N

393978 E,

9898692 N. 0.82 17 1,200,000 984,000

165 718

Samson

Kano

Ngumbi

(Deceased) Kyanika Mwingi

0723545219

/

0700420399 8.8

393978 E,

9898692 N.

394148 E,

9898853 N. 1.73 19.6 1,200,000 2,076,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 14

Page 23: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

166 700

Mutemi

Musee Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 3.3

394153 E,

9898857 N

394223 E,

9898922 N. 0.29 8.7 1,200,000 348,000

167 705

Jimmy

Makuthu

Kanno Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 7.5

394223 E,

9898922 N.

394258 E,

9898955 N. 0.36 4.8 1,200,000 432,000

168 4911 David Kitema Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 7.8

394258 E,

9898955 N.

394330 E,

9899022 N. 0.73 9.3 1,200,000 876,000

169 703

PatricK

Kimanzi

Maluki Kyanika Mwingi 716184526 9.4

394330 E,

9898022 N

394439 E,

9899124 N. 1.11 11.7 1,200,000 1,332,000

170 704

Jane

Mutinda

(Bought

from

Kamami

Syengo Kyanika Mwingi 722932202 7.9

394439 E,

9899124 N

394487 E,

9899169 N. 0.49 6.2 1,200,000 588,000

171 *1687

Elijah Nzomo

Katee Kyanika Mwingi 727826456 13.8

394487

E,9899169 N

394654 E,

9899323 N. 1.68 12.2 1,200,000 2,016,000

172 1004

Ibrahim

Malonza

Kula Kyanika Mwingi 723709523 14.1

394660 E,

9899331 N

394800 E,

9899461 N. 1.42 10 1,200,000 1,704,000

173 717

Jimmy

Mukutho

Kanno Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 7.5

394800 E,

9899461 N

394927 E,

9899580 N. 1.29 17.2 1,200,000 1,548,000

174 1009

Peter

Munyoki

Mutambuki

(Deceased) Kyanika Mwingi

0729113822,

0733958122 8.1

394927 E,

9899580 N

394997 E,

9899645 N. 0.71 8.7 1,300,000 923,000

175 1008

Mutua

Kathau

(Deceased)-

Bought from

Mbiti Kitima) Kyanika Mwingi 713820638 8.5

394997 E,

9899645 N.

395119 E,

9899760 N. 1.24 14.6 1,300,000 1,612,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 15

Page 24: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

176 4710

Onesmus

Kilonzo

Kapeleki(Bro

ught from

Kilonzi

Kavisi) Kyanika Mwingi 738379870 3.6

395119 E,

9899760 N.

395205 E,

9899840 N. 0.87 24.1 1,300,000 1,131,000

177 1073

Joseph

Kavindu

Mailu Kyanika Mwingi 4.8

395205 E,

9899840 N

395316 E,

9899943 N. 1.12 23.4 1,300,000 1,456,000

178 1476

Benedict

Kinuva Kyanika Mwingi 714596130 7.8

395316 E,

9899943 N.

395430 E,

9900049 N. 1.15 14.8 1,300,000 1,495,000

179 930

Stephen

Kilonzo

Munyithya Kyanika Mwingi 711570572 2.6

395527 E,

9900140 N

395567 E,

9900177 N. 0.48 18.7 1,300,000 624,000

180 930

Julius

Mwandikwa

Mutia Kyanika Mwingi 720844960 2.6

395437 E,

9900056 N

395527 E,

9900140 N. 0.91 35.7 1,300,000 1,183,000

181 928

John

Mulunga Ithumbi Mwingi 723036751 5.1

395863 E,

9900240 N

395915 E,

9900238 N. 0.39 7.5 2,000,000 780,000

182

*4721, 4403,

4698

Peter

Mwendwa

Kinyili Ithumbi Mwingi

0722755348

/

0734288277 12.3

395915 E,

9900238 N.

396190E,

9900228 N. 2.04 16.6 2,000,000 4,080,000

183 5359

Simon

Mulyungi

Kitema Ithumbi Kivou 716631357

396199 E,

9900228 N.

396275 E,

9900226 N. 0.56 2,000,000 1,120,000

184 652

Peter

Musyoka

Ngunga Kyanika Mwingi 713415699 9.5

396391 E,

9900221 N.

396412 E,

9900221 N. 0.16 1.6 2,000,000 320,000

185 1707

Mary

Kimanzi Ithumbi Mwingi 722119926 2.2

396199 E,

9900228 N.

396275 E,

9900226 N. 0.56 25.4 2,000,000 1,120,000

186 597

Ibrahim

Mwaka

Munyithya Kyanika Mwingi 710707754 29.2

396941E,

9900186N

396603E,

9900197N 2.51 8.6 2,000,000 5,020,000

187 597

Joseph

Mutui

Kivunzi Kyanika Mwingi 702495029 4.2

396505 E,

9900217 N

396590 E,

9900214 N. 0.63 15 2,000,000 1,260,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 16

Page 25: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

188 603

Maithya

Munyithya Kyanika Mwingi

0723205921

/

0734713144

/

0716280631 1.1 15m*6m 0.02 2 1,300,000 26,000

189 605/4678

Samuel

Kithome

Makau Ithumbi Mwingi

0720983407

/

0726270908

/

0733892147 3.5

396952 E,

9900201 N

397049 E,

9900198 N. 0.72 20.7 1,300,000 936,000

190 610

Kimwele

Maluki Ithumbi Ithumbi 789290299 2.9

397049 E,

9900194 N

397168 E.

9900194 N. 0.88 30.6 1,300,000 1,144,000

191 607 Fredrick Augustus Kiluku NyenzeIthumbi Ithumbi

0733382983

/

0725996603 3

397168 E,

9900194 N

397216 E,

9900192 N. 0.34 11.2 1,300,000 442,000

192 4679

Samuel

Kithome

Makau Ithumbi Mwingi

0720983407

/

0726270908

/

0733892147 6.7

396952 E,

9900201 N

397049 E,

9900198 N. 1.06 15.9 1,300,000 1,378,000

193 612

Kennedy

Kilonzi Matii

bought from

Mwanzia

Muthami

Ngombe Ithumbi Mwingi 707594553 13.3

397367 E,

9900186 N.

397489 E,

9900182 N 0.9 6.8 1,000,000 900,000

194 612

Mwanzia

Muthami

Ng'ombe

(inherited by

John

Mwanzia) Ithumbi Mwingi

0723307387

/

0739480057 4.9

397489 E,

9900182 N

397600 E,

9900178 N. 0.82 16.7 1,000,000 820,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 17

Page 26: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

195 612

Mwanzia

Muthami

Ng'ombe

(inherited by

Kilonzo

Mwanzia) Kyanika Mwingi

0723307387

/

0739480057 3.8

397489 E,

9900182 N

397600 E,

9900178 N. 0.67 17.5 1,000,000 670,000

196

Mulwa

Mwanzia(De

ceased)

Joyce Vilita

Mulwa Ithumbi Mwingi 710148767

397690 E,

9900175 N.

397814 E,

9900171 N. 0.92 1,000,000 920,000

197 820 Julius Ngui MuoniKivou Kivou 725713337 17.9

397814 E,

9900171 N.

398086 E,

9900161 N. 2.02 11.3 500,000 1,010,000

198 802

Kitheka

Baringo

inherited by

Mutuku

Kilonzo Kivou Kivou

723153093/

0736016360 14.8

398086 E,

9900161 N

398181 E,

9900158 N. 0.7 4.8 500,000 350,000

199 802

Kitheka

Baringo

Inherited

by;Charles

Kyalo

Kitheka Kivou Kivou 714390142 14.8

398181 E,

9900158 N

398290 E,

9900154 N. 0.81 5.5 500,000 405,000

200 478

Musyoka

Matiti

(Bought

from

Wambua

Kasolo) Kivou Kivou 728520230 5.4

398295 E,

9900153 N

398423 E,

9900149 N. 0.95 17.5 500,000 475,000

201 476

Kalunda

Kasolo Konga Kivou Kivou 700807652 4.6

398423 E,

9900149 N

398548 E,

9900145 N. 0.93 20.3 300,000 279,000

202 473

Musyoka

Kasolo Kunga Kivou Kivou 703645934 5.3

398611 E,

9900142 N

398752 E,

9900137 N. 0.39 7.3 300,000 117,000

203 475

Mutemi

Musee Kivou KIvou 720071610 8m*40m 0.1 300,000 30,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 18

Page 27: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

204 474

Ngui

Mbwaru Kivou Kivou 727437622 3.5

398611 E,

9900142 N.

398752 E,

9900137 N. 1.04 29.9 300,000 312,000

205 475

Mutemi

Musee Kivou Kivou 720071610

398752E,

9900137N

398852E,

9900133N 0.74 300,000 222,000

206 470

Abel Kiema

Mulanga Kivou Kivou 713267670 4.8

398852 E,

9900133 N.

398882 E,

9900132 N. 0.22 4.6 300,000 66,000

207 2874

Mutemi

Musee Kivou Kivou 720071610 21.2

398882 E,

9900132 N

398968 E,

9900130 N. 0.64 3 300,000 192,000

208 2876

Samson

Munyoki

Ndulu Kivou Kivou 725211476

398968 E,

9900130 N.

399080 E,

9900125 N. 0.83 300,000 249,000

209 2875

Charles

Ndulu

Ndekwa(Inhe

rited by

Kyalo Charles

) Kivou Kivou 729156304 8.6

399080 E,

9900125 N.

399259 E,

9900119 N. 1.33 15.4 300,000 399,000

210 2880

Ndavi

Kisusya Kivou Kivou 701630590

399259 E,

9900119 N

399305 E,

9900118 N. 0.34 300,000 102,000

211 2881 Ngui Kisosya Kivou Kivou 700281890

399305 E,

9900118 N

399454 E,

9900112 N. 1.11 300,000 333,000

212 2892

Michael

Kyalo

Muthuvi Kivou Kivou

0733201002

/

0718801868

399460 E,

9900118 N

399572 E,

9900108 N. 0.83 300,000 249,000

213 2891

Mwikya

Muthuvi Kivou Kivou 787830044

399572 E,

9900108 N

399658 E,

9900105 N. 0.64 300,000 192,000

214 2890 Stephen Peter Muthuvi Inherited from Muthuve MunuveKivou Kivou 700699888 4.6

399748 E,

9900144 N

399658 E,

9900105 N. 0.73 16 300,000 219,000

215 3048 Paul Mwendwa MuthuviKivou Kivou

399748 E,

9900144 N

399772 E,

9900154 N 0.19 300,000 57,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 19

Page 28: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

216 3561

John

Musyimi

Kamuti

Bought from

Julius

Muthusi

Mbulai Kivou Kivou 703596274 4.7

399772 E,

9900154 N

399888 E,

9900203 N. 0.93 19.9 300,000 279,000

217 4664 Kanzoka A.I.C Church 0.9

399888 E,

9900203 N.

399982 E,

9900226 N. 0.74 85 300,000 222,000

218 3558 John Musyimi Kamuti 2.5

399986 E,

9900225 N.

400083 E,

9900207 N. 0.73 28.7 300,000 219,000

219 5189 John Musyimi Kamuti 6.2

400083 E,

9900207 N

400140 E,

9900197 N. 0.43 6.9 300,000 129,000

220 3559 John Musyimi Kamuti

400140 E,

9900197 N

400331 E,

9900161 N. 1.44 300,000 432,000

221 3598

Pius Musili

Munyithya Kivou Kivou 726294747 9

400331 E,

9900161 N

400502 E,

9900130 N. 1.29 14.3 300,000 387,000

222 3559

Kitheka Mulu

Kisilu Kivou Kivou

400502 E,

9900130 N

400710 E,

9900092 N 1.57 300,000 471,000

223 3272

Musyoka

Mutia(Inheri

ted by

Kitonga

Musyoka) Kivou Kivou 721290527

400710 E,

9900092 N

401197 E,

9900044 N. 3.63 300,000 1,089,000

224 3680

Musyoka

Mutia

(Inherited by

Ngundi

Musyoka Kivou Kivou 707196140 32.8

401197 E,

9900044 N.

401296 E,

9900035 N. 0.74 2.2 300,000 222,000

225 2836 Isaiah Ngusu Kivou Kivou 722274446

401459 E,

9900026 N

401691 E,

9900020 N. 1.72 300,000 516,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 20

Page 29: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

226 2827

Mbuvi

Mbava

(Gabriel

Musembei

Mbuvi ) Kivou Kivou

0716741606

/072536960

1

/+25261638

3629

401340 E,

9900030 N

401450 E,

9900026 N. 1.14 300,000 342,000

227 *2883

Dominic

Mutavanya

Ngusu Kivou Kivou 15m*50m 0.19 300,000 57,000

228 2838 Isaiah Ngusu Kivou Kivou 722274446 7.5

401459 E,

9900026 N

401691 E,

9900020 N. 1.72 22.8 300,000 516,000

229 2846

Manzo

Mutia(Decea

sed) Kivou Kivou 710700127 50*13m 0.16 300,000 48,000

230 2736 Muthangya Mutemi inherited by Muvisi MuthangyaKivou Kivou 727662202 6.7

401691 E,

9900020 N

401857 E,

9900016 N. 1.22 18.3 300,000 366,000

231 2742 Peter Mutie Kivou Kivou 705543580 4.3

401857 E,

9900016 N

402003 E,

9900012 N. 1.08 25 300,000 324,000

232 2745 Jacob Kimanzi Mwinzi (Inheritor Jones Mwinzi Nzengu)Kivou Kivou 705062056 2.9

402003 E,

9900072 N.

402048 E,

9900012 N. 0.33 11.5 300,000 99,000

233 2735

Muvisi

Muthangya Kivou Kivou 727662202

402048 E,

9900012 N

402066 E,

9900011 N. 0.13 300,000 39,000

234 2725 Mati Mutia Mbali sold to Muvisi MuthangyaKivou Kivou 727662202

402066 E,

9900011 N.

402224 E,

9900007 N. 1.17 300,000 351,000

235 2723

Manzo

Mutia(Decea

sed) Kivou Kivou 710700127 50m*13m 0.16 300,000 48,000

236 Muthina NzenguKivou Kivou 50m*8m 0.1 300,000 30,000

237 2727

Samuel

Kikwatu

Nzengu Kivou Kivou 725947285 7.8

402292 E,

9900006 N.

4023396E,

9900003N 0.77 9.9 300,000 231,000

238 2773 Mati Mutia Kivou Kivou

402396 E,

9900003N

402423 E,

9900003 N 300,000 0

239 2726

Munyoki

Makau

Mutia Kivou Kivou 721241733 13.4

402435 E,

9900003 N

402571 E,

9899999 N. 1.01 7.5 300,000 303,000

240

2722, 2801,

2804

Mwendwa

Makau Kivou Kivou 711475134 0.7

402571 E,

9899999 N

402605 E,

9899998 N. 0.25 35.4 500,000 125,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 21

Page 30: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

241 2845 Mati Mutia Mbali sold to Muvisi MuthangyaKivou Kivou

0714646377

/

0737678458 7.1

402605 E,

9899998 N.

403140 E,

9899985 N. 3.97 56.2 500,000 1,985,000

242 2710 Concleter Mwikali ManziKivou Kivou 702936327 14.6

403147 E,

9899986 N

.403433

E,9899979 N. 2.13 14.6 500,000 1,065,000

243 2808 Martha Mbiti Kivou Kivou 735971495 9.2

403579E,

9900103N

403434E,

9899984N 1.39 15.1 500,000 695,000

244 2807

John

Johnson

Manzi Kivou Kivou 719819441 7.4

403620E,

9900136N

403579E,

9900103N 0.39 5.2 500,000 195,000

245 2912

John Muthui

Mwendwa Kisama Kivou 715794296 22.2

403742E,

9900236N

403620E,

9900136N 1.17 5.3 500,000 585,000

246 *2913

Fridah Loise

Kisoya Kisama Kivou

0721699257

/

0733592542 5.9

403756E,

9900246N

403742 E,

9900236N 0.13 2.1 500,000 65,000

247 2914

William

Kang'ola

Nzengu Kisama Kivou 710813294 6.6

403918E,

9900386N

403859E,

9900331N 0.6 9.1 500,000 300,000

248 2915

William

Kang'ola

Nzengu Kisama Kivou 710813294

403859E,

9900331N

403756E,

9900246N 20.15 500,000 10,075,000

249 2920

Benson

Mwangangi

Mwendwa Kisama Kivou 729905498 1.9

403997E,

9900386N

403918E,

9900386N 0.72 38.1 300,000 216,000

250 2921

Mwendwa

Ilwe Kisama Kivou 729723039 5.7

404041E,

9900483N

403997E,

9900442N 0.45 7.8 300,000 135,000

251 2933

Muthui

Munyambu Kisama Kivou 725475738 9.7

404201E,

9900612N

404048E,

9900488N 1.46 15.1 300,000 438,000

252 2930

Musyoki

Nzue

Mutweti Kisama Kivou 721241733 8.7

404287E,

9900682N

404201E,

9900612N 0.82 9.5 300,000 246,000

253 3201

Nguno

Kithae Kisama Kivou 734427435 1.8

404467E,

99008321N

404287E,

9900682N 1.73 96 300,000 519,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 22

Page 31: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

254 3105

Mwanzia

Kimanzi

Mwikuyu Kisama Kivou 718593454 2.6

404540E,

9900888N

404467E,

9900831N 0.69 26.7 300,000 207,000

255 3104

Daniel

Mutemi

Kimanzi Kisama Kivou

0725458819

/

0702784144 1.4

404570E,

9900914N

404540E,

9900888N 0.3 22.4 300,000 90,000

256 3102

David

Mulonzya

Kimanzi Kisama Kivou

0726542309

/

0701818661 4.1

404678E,

9901001N

404575E,

9900917N 0.98 24 300,000 294,000

257 3096

Solomon Keli

Mutunga

(sold to John

Mutua Kasi) Kisama Kivou

0727936740

/

0738464681 3.4

404726E,

9901040N

404678E,

9901001N 0.46 13.4 300,000 138,000

258 3009, 3008

Ngui

Kumanda Kisama Kivou 10.1

404812E,

9901111N

404725E,

9901040N 3.55 35.3 300,000 1,065,000

259 3097

Mwendwa

Mukungi

Makila(dece

ased) Katisya

Mwendwa Kisama Kivou 729973561 18.5

405073E,

9901325N

405013E,

9901277N 0.57 3.1 300,000 171,000

260 3097

Munyithya

Nzoka

(inherited by

Kilonzo

Mwangangi Kisama Kivou 702211336 18.5

405073E,

9901325N

405013E,

9901277N 0.57 3.1 300,000 171,000

261 *3317

John Kamau

Kisuva Kisama Kivou

0718336581

/

0724055825

405673E,

9901816N

405521E,

9901694N 0.51 300,000 153,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 23

Page 32: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

262 3215

Paul

Mwendwa

(bought from

Koki

Muneeni

Muthengi) Kisama Kivou 712874192 37.1

405759E,

9901888N

405679E,

9901823N 0.76 2.1 300,000 228,000

263 3216

Naomi

Mueni

Simba(buyer

) Robert

Mutia

Muthuka

Seller Kisama Kivou

0722550205

/

0736759332 24.7

405868E,

9901975N

405764E,

9901892N 0.99 4 300,000 297,000

264 3188

Musyoka

Mbovo

Ngonde Kisama Kivou 722117813 17.6

406249E,

9902289N

405967E,

9902057N 2.71 15.4 300,000 813,000

265 3424

Mutambu

Mbovo

Ngonde Kisama Kivou 716339156 19.5

406530E,

9902518N

406259E,

99002291N 2.62 13.5 300,000 786,000

266 3183

Francis

Kilonzi

Munyasya(D

eceased) Kisama Kivou 716339156 4.5

406649E,

9902618N

406530E,

9902518N 1.15 25.5 300,000 345,000

267 3182

Mwendwa

Ngare

Muthuku Kisama Kivou 2.5

406658E,

9902623N

406651E,

9902619N 0.06 2.5 300,000 18,000

268 1141

Mwasya

Kitheka Kathoka Endui 703299635 16.8

406660E,

9902624N

406800E,

9902757N 1.43 8.5 150,000 214,500

269 2813

Sammy

Mwendwa

Kasyima Kathoka Endui

0722273520

/

0722253872

406800E,

9902737N

406884E,

9902806N 0.81 150,000 121,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 24

Page 33: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

270 1220/1221

David

Musyoka

Kalai, Samuel

Muthui Kalai,

Joel Kilonzo

Kalai,

Hudson

Mwinzi Kalai Kathoka Endui 711862069 5.7

406884E,

9902806N

407008E,

9902910N 1.2 21.1 150,000 180,000

271 2282

Muthui

Mwinzi Kathoka Endui 711862069 1.8

407008E,

9902910N

407031E,

9902928N 0.22 11.9 150,000 33,000

272 2283

Johnstone

Wambua

Mwinzi Kathoka Endui 724759833 1

407031E,

9902928N

407061E,

9902955N 0.3 28.6 150,000 45,000

273 2281

Ndanu

Mwinzi Kathoka Endui 720801336 1.1

407061E,

9902955N

407089E,

9902976N 0.64 56.6 150,000 96,000

274 2279

Christopher

Mwoni

Musyoka Kathoka Endui 722996204 2.5

407089E,

9902976N

407132E,

9903012N 0.41 16.3 150,000 61,500

275 2277 Julius Kiambi Kathoka Endui 20

407132

E,9903012 N

407351

E,9903193 N. 2.1 10.5 150,000 315,000

276 2275

Kaunda

Kavuli Kathoka Endui

0722857519

/

0735557178 15.3

407351E,

9903193N

407449E,

9903270N 0.69 4.5 150,000 103,500

277 735

David

Mwanzia

Kyumbu Kathoka Endui 727720454 17.9 1 5.6 150,000 150,000

278 2274

Kavuli

Mutwango

Mengo Kathoka Endui

787412371/

0735557178 20.1

407449E,

9903270N

407512E,

9903323N 0.61 3 150,000 91,500

279 1530

Mulwa

Mwinzi

Kitonga Kathoka Endui

739815524/

0714916133 8.7

407512E,

9903323

407673E,

9903454N 1.54 17.6 150,000 231,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 25

Page 34: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

280 1529

Muthui

Mburu Kathoka Endui

0716287665

/

0788414094 5.7

407673E,

9903454N

407762E,

9903530N 0.87 15.2 150,000 130,500

281 688

Beatrice Muli

Mwanzia Kathoka Endui 739891159 3.8

407779E,

9903541N

407817E,

9903571N 0.36 9.4 150,000 54,000

282

776, 775,

773, 774,

787,786,

785, 784,

777, 788

John Kavulu

Musembi Kathoka Endui 738719013

407817E,

9903971N

407874E,

9903620N 0.56 150,000 84,000

283 1362

Eunice

Mbuvi

Musenya Kathoka Endui 702446711 3.2

407878E,

9903628

407923E,

9903662N 0.42 13.2 150,000 63,000

284 1366

Grace Kaki

Muatha Kathoka Endui 716172695 1.4

407923E,

9903663N

407987E,

9903708N 0.58 41.9 150,000 87,000

285 1367

Paul Ngei

Muatha Kathoka Endui 789669714

407987E,

9903709N

408015E,

9903735N 0.28 150,000 42,000

286 1368

Jacobate

Muthui

Muatha Kathoka Endui 716172695 0.6

408015E,

9903735N

408046E,

9903760N 0.29 49.4 150,000 43,500

287 1370

David

Mwendwa

Muatha Kathoka Endui

0712813800

/

0789669714 1.1

408046E,

9903760N

408088E,

9903793N 0.4 35.6 150,000 60,000

288 3218

Patrick

Muthui

Kiema Kathoka Endui 786760798 12.2

408088E,

9903793N

408206E,

9903891N 1.14 9.3 150,000 171,000

289 3219

Agnes Muli

Muthangya

Kiema Kathoka Endui 735504732 7.1

408206E,

9903891

408296E,

9903965N 0.86 12.1 150,000 129,000

290 3221

Dawson

Musila

Kiema Kathoka Endui 704279037

408296E,

9903965

408314E,

9903982N 0.18 150,000 27,000

291 3220 Ngoki Kiema Kathoka Endui 735504732 12.7

408314E,

9903983N

408332E,

9903995N 0.16 1.3 150,000 24,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 26

Page 35: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

292 Kathoka Endui

408332

E,9903995 N

408977

E,9904523 N. 150,000 0

293 2217

Musee

Mbitu/ Mbisi

Mbitu Kathoka Endui

731216933/

0737063205 4.8

408977E,

9904523N

409073E,

9904500N 0.91 18.9 150,000 136,500

294 2186

Lydia

Nthambi

Mutemi Kathoka Endui 710161171

408338E,

9903999

408499E,

9904131N 1.54 150,000 231,000

295 2594

Charles

Mumu

Mutinda Kathoka Endui 737112441 9.7

408499E,

9904131N

408752E,

9904341N 2.44 25.1 150,000 366,000

296 L.R Missing

Victor

Mwaniki

Mutinda Kathoka Endui 703612910

408752E,

9904341N

408801E,

9904377N 0.45 150,000 67,500

297 2180

Charles

Mumu

Mutinda Kathoka Endui 737112441 11.9

408801E,

99043771N

408977E,

9904523N 1.69 14.3 150,000 253,500

298 2178

Simon

Mutemi

Mutinda Kathoka Endui

721595908/

0710161171 7.4

409084E,

9904606N

409135E,

9904650N 0.5 6.8 150,000 75,000

299 L.R Missing

Andrew

Kilonzi Kathoka Endui 722841501

409135E,

9904650N

409259E,

9904751N 1.19 150,000 178,500

300 Kilonzi Simon Kathoka Endui

409073

E,9904599 N.

409265

E,9904759 N. 1.86 150,000 279,000

301 1487

David

Mwanzia

Maithya Kathoka Endui

0710568382

/

0789636716

409265E,

9904759N

409337E,

9904820N 0.13 150,000 19,500

302 2222

Grace Ndanu

Kitema Kathoka Endui 734746622 2.3

409346E,

9904824N

409427E,

9904892N 0.78 34.7 150,000 117,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 27

Page 36: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

303 2224

Mumbi Muli

Muindi&

Anna

Kasyoka

Munyithya Kathoka Endui

0710568382

/

0789636716 1.6

409427E,

9904892N

409439E,

9904905N 0.13 7.9 150,000 19,500

304 2225

Muema

Kyaka Kathoka Endui 710941148

409439E,

9904905N

409494E,

9904947N 0.51 150,000 76,500

305 3176

Titus Musila

Kitheka Kathoka Endui 786314587

409494E,

9904947N

409640E,

9905068N 1.31 150,000 196,500

306 2248

Mwende

Musyimi

Muindi Kathoka Endui

0789919941

/

0735701268 17.7

409648E,

9905070N

409886E,

9905266N 2.28 12.9 150,000 342,000

307 2250

Joseph

Mutua Nzavi Kathoka Endui 736770749

409886E,

9905266N

410004E,

9905366N 2 150,000 300,000

308 1468

Tom Mwinzi

Ngunu Kathoka Endui 736563272 4.5

410009E,

9905366N

410135E,

9905442N 1.09 24.1 150,000 163,500

309

1459/1460/1

461/142

Benedict

Bernard Kaka Kathoka Endui 729698391

410166E,

9905462N

410862E,

9905850N 5.91 150,000 886,500

310 1449

Siri Mulatya

Tomu Kathoka Endui 786211979 47

0410864E,

9905848N

0410988E,

9905118N 0.49 1.1 150,000 73,500

311 1454

Mbala Nguli

Moki Kathoka Endui 786838075 72.9

0410988E,

9905918N

0411154E,

9906009N 1.4 1.9 150,000 210,000

312 1448

Paul Kimanzi

Mutemi Kathoka Endui 735748536 7.7

0411161E,

9906013N

0411390E,

9906141N 0.85 11 150,000 127,500

313 L.R Missing

Bonface

Mwangangi

Munyasya Kathoka Endui

0715826091

/073821144

6/07138783

96

0411390E,

9906141N

0411550E,

996230N 1.36 150,000 204,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 28

Page 37: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

314 1673

Ngui Musili

King'ao

(Deceased) Kathoka Endui

735241576/

731008526(

Wife)

0411559E,

9906235N

0411650E,

9906286N 0.77 150,000 115,500

315 1653

Mwendwa

Musyimi Kathoka Endui 702489982

0411650E,

9906286N

0411959E,

9906458N 2.62 150,000 393,000

316 1677

Jones

Muthengi

Mukuri Kathoka Endui

0733463067

/

0712965989 8.6

411968E,

9906460N

412134E,

9906554N 1.41 16.4 150,000 211,500

317 1769/3184

Susan

Mwikali

Munyoki Katitika Endui 734974585

412154E,

9906554N

412432E,

9906722N 2.71 150,000 406,500

318

Not

registered

Mulyungi

Kivunzi Katitika Endui

0717634464

/

0734974585

(Neighbour)

412432E,

9906722N

412469E,

9906740N 0.3 150,000 45,000

319 1749

Stephen

Nguli

Mutune Katitika Endui 736109843 43.9

413004E,

9907038N

413139E,

9907112N 1.14 2.6 150,000 171,000

320 1761

Kiviu Mutua

Mulinge Katitika Endui

0710527975

/

0729481967

413139E,

9907112N

413362E,

9907236N 1.89 150,000 283,500

321 1914

Elijah

Kanyange Katitika Endui

0733724047

/737686833

(Wife)

413364E,

9907238N

413433E,

9907276N 0.58 150,000 87,000

322 2285

Sammy

Mwendwa

Kasyima Kathoka Endui

722273520/

0722253872 1.9 0.3 16.1 150,000 45,000

323 735

David

Mwanzia

Kyumbu Kathoka Endui 727720454 17.9 1 5.6 150,000 150,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 29

Page 38: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

324 1470

Tom Mwinzi

Ngunu Kathoka Endui

0739616201

/

0705848440 0.21 150,000 31,500

325 L.R Missing

Anthony

Mutia

Mwandikwa Kathoka Endui 720844960 2.1 150,000 315,000

326

Misplaced

L.R

Kyalo,

Mbua,Mwen

ga Mutambu Katitika Endui 720080812

0413623E,

9907382N

0413433E,

9907277N 1.45 150,000 217,500

327 1915 Kalekye Muli Katitika Endui

0725586324(

Daughter)/0

734775920(C

ousin) 6.6

0413724E,

9907455N

0413623E,

9907382N 5 75.9 150,000 750,000

328

Mwendwa

Mathuka Katitika Endui

0413724E,

9907455N

0413610E,

9907390N 0.97 150,000 145,500

329 L.R Missing

John Mutemi

Kisombo Katitika Endui 736109843

0413745E,

9907433N

0413625E,

9907367N 1.01 150,000 151,500

330

Misplaced

L.R

Matheka

Mbalo Katitika Endui 735923534

0413830E,

9907497

0413841E,

9907488N 0.11 150,000 16,500

331

Misplaced

L.R

Matheko

Mbalo Endui 0 150,000 0

332

Misplaced

L.R

Kyalo

Mutambu,

Mbua,Mwen

ga Mutambu Katitika Endui 720080812

0414514E,

9907877N

0413830E,

9907497N 1.61 150,000 241,500

333

Musyimi

Mbuvi Katitika Endui

414749

E,990807 N

414564

E,9907905 N. 150,000 0

334 lost l.r

Jackson

Musili Matiti Katitika Endui 736109843

0414564E,

9907905N

0414521E,

9907881N 0.36 150,000 54,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 30

Page 39: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

335 L.R Missing

Bernard

Mwaniki

Muthui Katitika Endui

0726553678

/

0786212002

0414858E,

9908068N

0414749E,

9908007N 0.93 150,000 139,500

336 2110

Simon

Maluki

Mutemi Katitika Endui 724387478

0414946E,

9908133N

0414867E,

9108073N 0.73 150,000 109,500

337

Simon

Mutemi Katitika Endui

414976 E,

9908133 N.

414867 E,

990873 N. 150,000 0

338 2109

Jonathan

Mutie

Mutemi Katitika Endui

0710158036

/078811808

6

0415172E,

9908243N

0414976E,

9908133N 0.51 150,000 76,500

339 2103

Nashon Thuo

Musee Katitika Endui 736433834

0415327E,

9908328N

0415172E,

9908243N 1.31 150,000 196,500

340 2010

Ndumbu

Mutisya

Musili Katitika Endui

0786528908

/

0719399016

0415753E,

9908566N

0415566E,

9908462N 3.71 150,000 556,500

341 2005

Musila

Mutisya Katitika Endui 787220647

0415995E,

9908700N

0415756E,

9908567N 2.03 150,000 304,500

342 2007

Ndusya

Mutisya Katitika Endui 786528908

0416066E,

9908740N

0415995E,

9908700N 1.24 150,000 186,000

343 L.R Missing

Mwathi

Ndinda Katitika Endui

0701576943

/

0703632486

0416246E,

9908839N

0416066E,

9908740N 1.52 150,000 228,000

344 2000

Nicodemus

Kasee Matiti Katitika Endui

0786528908

/

0718533670

0416409E,

9908930N

0416246E,

9908839N 4 150,000 600,000

345 1999

Benjamin

Kitheka

Muthoka Katitika Endui 710376888

0416465E,

9908961N

0416409E,

9908930N 2 150,000 300,000

346 2000

Nicodemus

Kasee Matiti Katitika Endui

0786528908

/

0718533670

0416522E,

9908992N

0416465E,

9908961N 2 150,000 300,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 31

Page 40: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

347 2003

John

Wambua

Munywoki Katitika Endui

0734313144

/

0786528908

/

0724096514

0416636E,

9909056N

0416522E,

9908992N 3 150,000 450,000

348 1952

James

Masauru

Muthui Katitika Endui 718275830

0416840E,

9909169N

0416636E,

9909056N 1.73 150,000 259,500

349 1956

Joseph

Munyoki

Mwangae Katitika Endui 729279316

0416942E,

9909227N

0416840E,

9909169N 0.87 150,000 130,500

350 1749

Stephen

Nguli

Mutune Katitika Endui 1.14 150,000 171,000

351 1964

Maluki

Syethoka

(Divided to

Mwenga

Maluki &

Kwilekya

Maluki) Katitika Endui 733437851

0417296E,

9909424N

0419642E,

9909227N 14.47 150,000 2,170,500

352

Not

registered

Emily

Kalumu

Mwinzi Mwasuma Nguni 716706695

0417389E,

9909474N,

0417300E,

9909425N 0.75 150,000 112,500

353

Not

registered

Munyoki

Mwangangi Mwasuma Nguni 739139663

0417529E,

9909553N

0417389E,

9909474N 1.19 150,000 178,500

354

Not

registered

Maluki

Syethoka

(Divided to

Mbila

Maluki,

David Maluki

& Mwikali

Maluki) Mwasuma Nguni

0735008043

/

0734679315

0417917E,

99099768N

0417529E,

9909553N 3.29 150,000 493,500

355

Not

registered

Dorcas

Kenyatta Mwasuma Nguni 724228443

0418165E,

9909906N

0417917E,

9909768N 2.1 150,000 315,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 32

Page 41: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

356

Not

registered

Munyoki

Mwendwa Mwasuma Nguni

0710141225

/

0733709379

0418180E,

9909914N

0418165E,

9909906N 0.13 150,000 19,500

357

Not

registered

Mutua

Munyasya Nguni Nguni 786300985

0418529E,

9910108N

0418180E,

9909914N 2.96 150,000 444,000

358

Not

registered

Syothome

Muthangya

Mbaute Mwasuma Nguni 727800049

0418727E,

9910216N

0418529E,

9910108N 1.67 150,000 250,500

359

Not

registered Unknown Mwasuma Nguni

0418891E,

9910309N

418723E,

9910216N 150,000 0

360

Not

registered

Jacob Musee

Muthangya Mwasuma Nguni 725611995

0419292E,

9910510N

0418897E,

9910312N 3.28 150,000 492,000

361

Not

registered

Ngali

Mutembei Mwasuma Nguni 712556867

0419374E,

9910544N

0419292E,

9910510N 0.45 150,000 67,500

362

Not

registered

Justus

Stanely

Wambua Mwasuma Nguni 727557717

0419571E,

9910625N

0419374E,

9910544N 1.58 150,000 237,000

363

Not

registered

Muthui

Mwanzia Mwasuma Nguni 727557717

0419685E,

9910672N

0419571E,

9910625N 0.91 150,000 136,500

364

Not

registered

Joel Kiseu

Mulwa Mwasuma Nguni 722448283

0419712E,

9910666N

0419687E,

9910657N 0.2 150,000 30,000

365

Not

registered

Kilonzi

Kitundu Mwasuma Nguni 708483716

0419853E,

9910741N

0419685E,

9910672N 1.35 150,000 202,500

366

Not

registered

Moses

Mulandi

Kang'ite Mwasuma Nguni 722662932

0420082E,

9910835N

0419853E,

9910741N 1.83 150,000 274,500

367

Not

registered Ngui Kiteme Mwasuma Nguni

0720705188

/

0728285344

040318E,

9910932N

0420082E,

9910835N 1.2 150,000 180,000

368

Not

registered

Dennis

Musomba

Ngui Mwasuma Nguni 731577098

0420529E,

9911019N

0420318E,

9910935N 1.69 150,000 253,500

369

Not

registered Ngei Mwoki Mwasuma Nguni 718356842

0421071E,

9911242N

0420529E,

9911019N 4.34 150,000 651,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 33

Page 42: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

370

Not

registered

Fredrick

Siasa

Munyithya Mwasuma Nguni 728797977

0421448E,

9911396N

0421193E,

9911291N 2.04 150,000 306,000

371

Not

registered

Japheth

Musili

Musunza Mwasuma Nguni

733773428,

723942534

0421654E,

9911480N

0421448E,

9911396N 2 150,000 300,000

372

Not

registered

John Kilonzi

Mangole Mwasuma Nguni

0729530271

/

0737774810

4 0.75 150,000 112,500

373

Not

registered

Monicah

Ngovu Mwasuma Nguni 7.06E+09

0422536/

9911842N

0422419E,

9911795N 0.93 150,000 139,500

374

Not

registered

John Mutua

Munyoki Mwasuma Nguni 710597329

0422639E,

991885N

0422536E,

9911842N 0.83 150,000 124,500

375

Not

registered

Jeremiah

Nganika

Mavuti Mwasuma Nguni 727807192

0422778E,

9911942N

0422639E,

9911885N 1.11 150,000 166,500

376

Not

registered

District

Officer's

Residence Kyavyuka Nguni

0714942123(

Chief Nguni,

Mula Simon)

0422959E,

9912016N

0422778E,

9911942N 1.59 150,000 238,500

377

Not

registered

Muthakye

Nduvoi Kyavyuka Nguni 728747729

0423442E,

9912215N

0423296E,

9912155N 1.17 150,000 175,500

378

Not

registered

Sammy

Kitheka Mwasuma Nguni 723255671

423589E,

9912276N

423605E,

9912280N 0.5 150,000 75,000

379

Not

registered Simon Mutie Mwasuma Nguni

0731127810

/

0713884950

423605E,

9912280N

423846E,

9912382N 1.95 150,000 292,500

380

Not

registered

Peter

Kithusya Mwasuma Nguni

423846E,

9912382N

423937E,

9912420N 0.73 150,000 109,500

381

Not

registered David Kioko Mwasuma Nguni 715895527

423954E,

9912426N

424205E,

9912526N 2 150,000 300,000

382

Not

registered

Joshua

Mbauti Kioko Mwasuma Nguni 704280736

424204E,

9912526N

424419E,

9912618N 1.24 150,000 186,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 34

Page 43: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

383

Not

registered

Sammy

Musyoka

Musili Mwasuma Nguni

0701293826

/

0723755561

424419E,

9912618N

424600E,

9912692N 1.45 150,000 217,500

384

Not

registered

Joseph

Musingila

Musili Mwasuma Nguni 719150969

424600E,

9912692N

424608E,

9912694N 0.99 150,000 148,500

385

Not

registered

Daniel Mengi

Kioko Mwasuma Nguni 700769158

424690E,

9912722N

424835E,

9912786N 1.24 150,000 186,000

386

Not

registered

Musingila

Musili Mwasuma Nguni 719150969

424858E,

9912798N

425161E,

9912962N 2.55 150,000 382,500

387

Not

registered

Theophilus

Mutuku

Mutinda Mwasuma Nguni 729018944 0.92 150,000 138,000

388

Not

registered

Richard

Mutie Musili Mwasuma Nguni

0721736119

/

0733647235 0.8 100,000 80,000

389

Not

registered

Samson

Kioko

Musumbi Kakunike Mbuvu 0.12 100,000 12,000

390

Not

registered

Robert Kioko

Mwenga Kakunike Mbuvu 712648758

425161E,

9912962N

425294E,

9913046N 1.17 100,000 117,000

391

Not

registered

Simon

Muuthu

Kizitu Kakunike Mbuvu '0715239775

425494E,

9913146N

425465E,

9913154 0.24 100,000 24,000

392

Not

registered

James

Nzomo

Muasya Kakunike Mbuvu

0728630359

/

0724116436

425465E,

9913154N

425674E,

9913284N 1.82 100,000 182,000

393

Not

registered

Philip

Mwangangi Kakunike Mbuvu

0726657342

/

0726835618

425674E,

9913284N

425800E,

9913364N 10 100,000 1,000,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 35

Page 44: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

394

Not

registered

James

Nzomo

Muasya Kakunike Mbuvu

0728630359

/

0724116436

425800E,

9913364N

0426105E,

9913555N 2.67 100,000 267,000

395

Not

registered

Martha

Telesia

Mwasya Kakunike Mbuvu

0727977519

/

0733618783

0426561E,

99135540N

0426306E,

9913681N 1.04 100,000 104,000

396

Not

registered

Mwende

Kinyambu

Mulu Kakunike Mbuvu

0712953959

(Neighbour)

0426306E,

9913681N

0426105E,

9913555N 1.76 100,000 176,000

397

Not

registered

Samson

Kusina

Musyoka Kakunike Mbuvu 712953959

0426628E,

9913883N

0426560E,

9913840N 0.6 100,000 60,000

398

Not

registered

John

Musyoki

Mwambui Kakunike Mbuvu 712953959

0426726E,

9913945N

0426628E,

9913883N 0.86 100,000 86,000

399

Not

registered

Sammy

Mwangangi

Musyoki;

sold to

Jefferson

Ngui Kiruru Kakunike Mbuvu

0721154496

/

0727774056

0426809E,

9913990N

0426752E,

9913961N 0.44 100,000 44,000

400

Not

registered

Mulwa

Munyasya

(deceased) Kakunike Mbuvu

0715745625

/

0704677223

0427022E,

9914023N

0426809E,

9913990N 1.6 100,000 160,000

401

Not

registered

James

Musaili

Mumo Kakunike Mbuvu

0727977505

/

0707651570

0427130E,

9914055N

0427091E,

9914049N 0.29 100,000 29,000

402

Not

registered

Wambua

Mbuli Kakunike Mbuvu

0726922693

/071734118

6

0427144E,

9914042

0427118E,

9914038N 0.19 100,000 19,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 36

Page 45: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

403

Not

registered

Sammy

Mwangangi

Musyoki Kakunike Mbuvu

0714577543

/

0712337916

0427134E,

9914037N

0727022E,

9914023N 0.84 100,000 84,000

404

Not

registered

Fredrick

Mulatya

Musee Kakunike Mbuvu

0725471335

/072835966

9

0427262E,

9914060N

0427144E,

9914042N 0.87 100,000 87,000

405

Not

registered

Annah

Kalundi

Mwovi Kakunike Mbuvu

0712311054

/

0715792537

0427610E,

9914114N

0427262E,

9914060N 2.61 100,000 261,000

406

Not

registered

John

Mwangangi

Mwinzi Kakunike Mbuvu

0710159422(

Wife)/07033

12072(Son)

0427723E,

9914132

0427610E,

9914114 0.85 100,000 85,000

407

Not

registered

Solomon

Musyoka

Musumbi Kakunike Mbuvu 726175082

427732E,

9914132N

427862E,

9914154N 0.99 100,000 99,000

408

Not

registered

Joseph

Musingila

Muthoka Kakunike Mbuvu 720315447

427862E,

9914154N

428040E,

9914182N 1.34 100,000 134,000

409

Not

registered

Peter

Munyasya

Musumbi Kakunike Mbuvu 707116104

428040E,

9914182N

428132E,

9914194N 1.24 100,000 124,000

410

Not

registered

Nzomo

Muthoka

Mwenga Kakunike Mbuvu 723555751

428132E,

9914194N

428313E,

9914222N 1.36 100,000 136,000

411

Not

registered John Nzomo Kakunike Mbuvu 724667196

428313E,

9914222N

428491E,

9914252N 1.34 100,000 134,000

412

Not

registered

Samson

Mutwii

Musya Kakunike Mbuvu

0713036526

/

0726544894

428491E,

9914252N

428786E,

9914296N 2.21 100,000 221,000

413

Not

registered

Isaac

Mulungu Kakunike Mbuvu 703514089

428786E,

9914296N

428907E,

9914316N 0.91 100,000 91,000

414

Not

registered

Joseph

Mbuku

Mukuni Kakunike Mbuvu 714376734

428907E,

9914316N

429019E,

9914334N 0.84 100,000 84,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 37

Page 46: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

415

Not

registered

Titus Ukulo

Munuve Kakunike Mbuvu 734679123

429019E,

9914334N

429154E,

9914352N 1.01 100,000 101,000

416

Not

registered

Sarah Matei

Maangi Kakunike Mbuvu 714376743

429154E,

9914352N

429355E,

9914384N 1.51 100,000 151,000

417

Not

registered

Mary

Syombua

Malombe Kakunike Mbuvu

0710672621

/

0703477692

429557E,

9914416N

429625E,

9914428N 0.51 100,000 51,000

418

Not

registered

Mutinda

Mukovi Kakunike Mbuvu 717138800

429625E,

9914428N

429699E,

9914436N 1 100,000 100,000

419

Not

registered

Musyoki

Musyoka Kakunike Mbuvu 726179372

429699E,

9914436N

429801E,

9914452N 2 100,000 200,000

420

Not

registered

Musyimi

Musyoka

Muyanga Kakunike Mbuvu 714233199

429355E,

9914384N

429557E,

9914416N 6.48 100,000 648,000

421

Not

registered

Philip

Mutemi

Kirungu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0710298147

/

0720492758

0430337E,

9914536N

0430195E,

994514N 1.06 100,000 106,000

422

Not

registered

Kimwele

Masila Mbuvu Mbuvu 717327438

0430195E,

9914514N

0429801E,

9914452N 2.95 100,000 295,000

423

Not

registered

John Muthui

Kimanzi Mbuvu mbuvu

0720355820

/

0724470478

0430441E,

99914552N

0430337E,

9914536N 5 100,000 500,000

424

Not

registered

Dorcas

Kayumya

Syanda Mbuvu Mbuvu

0711817886

/

0713415695

0430593E,

9914576N

0430441E,

9914552N 1.14 100,000 114,000

425

Not

registered

Peter Musee

Mbindyo Mbuvu Mbuvu 710199449

0431257E,

9914678N

0430598E,

9914567N 5 100,000 500,000

426

Not

registered

Philip

Mutemi

Kirungu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0720492758

/

0710298147

0431548E,

9914723N

0431257E,

9914678N 1.06 100,000 106,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 38

Page 47: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

427

Not

registered

Simon Musili

Mutisya Mbuvu Mbuvu

0720118221

/

0713801602

0431664E,

9914741N

0431654E,

9914740N 3 100,000 300,000

428

Not

registered

Bonface

Mutuku

Mulwa Mbuvu Mbuvu 0714660226'

0432145E,

9914793N 2.5 100,000 250,000

429

Not

registered

Mutunga

Mbindyo

Kimwele Mbuvu Mbuvu 708466854

0432701E,

9914822N

0432617E,

9914815N 0.62 100,000 62,000

430

Not

registered

Mativo

Kitungu

Kiluvu Mbuvu Mbuvu 728083631

0432789E,

9914843N

0432145E,

9914793N 4.79 100,000 479,000

431

Not

registered

Kithumula B

joint Group

Dam Mbuvu Mbuvu 703224967

0432855E,

9914863N

0432821E,

9914861N 0.25 100,000 25,000

432

Not

registered

Kaleve

Mutua Mbuvu Mbuvu

0715695815

/

0717915071

0432789E,

9914855N

0432789E,

9914843N 1.11 100,000 111,000

433

Not

registered

Dickson

Mutia Nzuku Mbuvu Mbuvu

0715695815

/071093816

6

0432985E,

9914859N

0432938E,

9914855N 0.35 100,000 35,000

434

Not

registered

Mbuthye

Musili

Mukungi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0700728358

/ 070814214

0433209E,

9914877

0432985E,

9914859 1.67 100,000 167,000

435

Not

registered

Joseph

Mutie Mbuvi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0713056690

/071445491

7

(Neighbour)

0433278E,

9914868

0433212E,

9914862N 1.23 100,000 123,000

436

Not

registered

Jane Ngina

Mulwa Mbuvu Mbuvu 0712299956' 0 100,000 0

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 39

Page 48: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

437

Not

registered

Ndike Mbuvi

sold to

Josphat

Mutata

Makau Mbuvu Mbuvu 723665532

0433573E,

9914906N

0433362E,

9914888N 1.57 100,000 157,000

438

Not

registered

Maluki

Mukuthu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0716524896

/

0705358889 0 100,000 0

439

Not

registered

Daniel

Muthui

Musingu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0720765697

/

0700171323

0434005E,

9914944N

0433932E,

9914935N 0.98 100,000 98,000

440

Not

registered

Syengo

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu 71329542

434076E,

9914944N

434203E,

9914956N 0.95 100,000 95,000

441

Not

registered

Mwende

Mwove Mbuvu Mbuvu 717343216

434203E,

9914956N

434511E,

9914980N 4 100,000 400,000

442

Not

registered

Mutei

Musyoka Mbuvu Mbuvu 723909948

434511E,

9914980N

434753E,

9915000N 3 100,000 300,000

443

Not

registered

Mulwa

Mutie Mbuvu Mbuvu 708863416

434753E,

9915000N

435274E,

9915042N 5 100,000 500,000

444

Not

registered

Muthui

Mutemi

(Mary

Kamene

Muthui-

Wife) Mbuvu Mbuvu 714935560

435274E,

9915042N

435417E,

9914941N 1.33 100,000 133,000

445

Not

registered

Daniel

Kimwele

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0710618996

/072772341

5

435417E,

9914941N

435717E,

9914699N 2.86 100,000 286,000

446

Not

registered

Nicodemus

Mutheki

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0713295482

/072725105

6

435717E,

9914699N

435967E,

9914521N 2.26 100,000 226,000

447

Not

registered

Velesi

Martha

Mung'ang'a Mbuvu Mbuvu 720094245

435973E,

9914515N

436450E,

9913998N 5.2 100,000 520,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 40

Page 49: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

448

Not

registered

Mwendwa

Mung'ang'a Mbuvu Mbuvu 729568640

436450E,

9913998N

436656E,

9913774N 2.26 100,000 226,000

449

Not

registered

Gilbert

Mutisya

Mung'ang'a Mbuvu Mbuvu 722709040

436656E,

9913774N

436761E,

9913668N 1.11 100,000 111,000

450

Not

registered Muthui Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu 720911333

436761E,

9913668N

436786E,

9913642N 1.74 100,000 174,000

451

Not

registered

Daniel

Mutua Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu

0725508117

/

0774098069

436945E,

9913632N

437117E,

9913338N 1.72 100,000 172,000

452

Not

registered

William Kalui

Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu 724269744

437117E,

9913338N

437290E,

9913172N 1.59 100,000 159,000

453

Not

registered Muthui Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu 720911333

437290E,

9913172

437461E,

9913010N 0.27 100,000 27,000

454

Not

registered

Francis

Kilonzo

Mutyanzei Mbuvu Mbuvu

0729679719

/

0729270337

437461E,

9913010N

437583E,

9912896N 1.24 100,000 124,000

455

Not

registered

Andrew

Kisenga

Mengi sold

to ; Titus

Kyaai

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0723691373

/

0726403631

437583E,

9912896N

437713E,

9912776N 1.31 100,000 131,000

456

Not

registered

Andrew

Kisenga

Mengi Mbuvu Mbuvu 725230894

0438450E,

9912083N

0438122E,

9912391N 3.33 100,000 333,000

457

Not

registered

Francis

Kilonzo

Mutyanzei Mbuvu Mbuvu

0729679719

/072927033

7

0438122E,

9912391N

0437976E,

9912529N 2.18 100,000 218,000

458

Not

registered

Joseph Nzili

Mengi Mwalali Imba 710391943

0437976E,

9912529N

0437860E,

9912636N 1.17 100,000 117,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 41

Page 50: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

459

Not

registered

Lena Mutanu

Kasina Mbuvu Mbuvu 725103762

0438581E,

9911960N

0438790E,

9911766N 4.06 100,000 406,000

460

Not

registered

Moses

Mbindi Mui Mbuvu Mbuvu

0714394351

/

0700078547

0438790E,

9911766N

0438743E,

9911808N 1.59 100,000 159,000

461

Not

registered

John Mutua

Mbindi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0727595408

/

0727047511

0438743E,

9911808N

0438561E,

9911979N 1.85 100,000 185,000

462

Not

registered

Timothy

Mwaniki

Mbindi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0714594540

/

0710690360

0439126E,

9911450N

0438971E,

99115956N 1.58 100,000 158,000

463

Not

registered Nzasu Mbuvi Mbuvu Mbuvu 725508117

4386756E,

9913642N

436945E,

9913485N 1.6 100,000 160,000

464

Not

registered

Joster Willy

Mbindi Mbuvu Mbuvu 723059382

0439271E,

9911315N

0439126E,

99114650N 1.55 100,000 155,000

465

Not

registered

Muthili

Muinde Mbuvu Mbuvu 700014797 0.5 100,000 50,000

466

Not

registered

Mutisya

Kanyuku Ukasi Ukasi

0712513771

/071940356

7 (Son)

0439373E,

9911218N

0439271E,

9911315N 1.04 100,000 104,000

467

Not

registered

John Musili

Mwendwa Mwalali Ukasi 711318220

439373E,

9911218N

439445E,

9911151N 0.5 100,000 50,000

468

Not

registered

John Makau

Ivulu Mwalali Ukasi

0726496483

/

0726598398

439452E,

9911143N

439805E,

9910814N 2.3 100,000 230,000

469

Not

registered

Joseph

Mutunga

Kalua Ukasi Ukasi

0727930753

/

0715872865

439805E,

9910814N

439884E,

9910740N 0.54 100,000 54,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 42

Page 51: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

470

Not

registered

John Makau

Ivulu Mwalali Ukasi

0726496483

/

0726598398

439884E,

9910740N

440218E,

9910425N 2.4 100,000 240,000

471

Not

registered

Thomas

Toma

Ndengu Mwalali Imba 723096493

440218E,

9910425N

440372E,

9910282N 1.06 100,000 106,000

472

Not

registered

Darius

Muthui

Mwasya Mwalali Imba

0724636404

/

0705757827

440372E,

9910282N

440742E,

9909936N 2.54 100,000 254,000

473

Not

registered

Muthui

Mwenga Ukasi Ukasi

0700018766

/

0704490863

440751E,

9909926N

440821E,

9909861N 0.5 100,000 50,000

474

Not

registered

Darius

Muthui

Mwasya Ukasi Ukasi

0724636404

/

0705757827

440821E,

9909861N

441027E,

9909668N 1.4 100,000 140,000

475

Not

registered

Saddy Saidi

Kilungu Ukasi Ukasi 721460237

441027E,

9909668N

441141E,

9909563N 1.15 100,000 115,000

476

Not

registered

Kilungu

Mbaluka

Mutinda Ukasi Ukasi 726035240

441141E,

9909563N

441419E,

9904300N 2.84 100,000 284,000

477

Not

registered Koli Nzenge Mwalali Imba

0710898132

/

0716262293

441419E,

9909300N

441487E,

9909237N 0.69 100,000 69,000

478

Not

registered

Julius Ngei

Mutinda Mwalali Imba

0725588362

/

0721133778

441487E,

9909237N

441954E,

9908801N 3.23 100,000 323,000

479

Not

registered

Kilungu

Mbaluka

Mutinda Ukasi Ukasi 726035239

441954E,

9908801N

442133E,

9908632N 1.82 100,000 182,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 43

Page 52: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

480

Not

registered

Peter Musee

Kilungu Ukasi Ukasi

0710222921

/

0716059753

442133E,

9908632N

442374E,

9908406N 2.45 100,000 245,000

481

Not

registered

Joseph

Mwendwa

Kilungu Ukasi Ukasi 721404157

442374E,

9908406N

442444E,

990833N 0.72 100,000 72,000

482

Not

registered

Daniel

Mulwa

Kimwele Mwalali Imba 711663633

442444E,

9908339N

442682E,

9908117N 2.41 100,000 241,000

483

Not

registered

Justus

Mwanzia

Kimwele Mwalali Imba

0727508213

/

0727680502

442682E,

9908117N

443034E,

9907787N 3.58 100,000 358,000

484

Not

registered

Christina

Nyamai

Mwalya Ukasi Ukasi

0703577875

/

0727680502

443039E,

9907783N

443410E,

9907435N 2.03 100,000 203,000

485

Not

registered

John Kitheka

Mwalya &

Denis Mutiso

Mwalya Ukasi Ukasi 703577875

443250E,

9907583N

443410E,

9907435N 0.55 100,000 55,000

486

Not

registered

Kalunda

Syengo

Mwanzia Mwalali Imba

0721702590

/

0732764990

443410E,

9907435N

443858E,

9907015N 3.11 100,000 311,000

487

Not

registered

Musembi

Kithongo(dec

eased)

Mwikali

Musembi Ukasi Ukasi

0708764889

/

0729540875

/

0713903585

443858E,

9907015N

444142E,

9906751N 1.95 100,000 195,000

488

Not

registered

Kunzu

Muukulu

Ngula Mwalali Imba 724922809

444142E,

9906751N

444354E,

9906551N 1.48 100,000 148,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 44

Page 53: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

489

Not

registered

Simon Meru

Mwokolo Mwalali Imba

0723164482

/

0701417337

444483E,

9906430N

444971E,

9905973N 3.38 100,000 338,000

490

Not

registered

Joseph

Mwema

Nyalu Mwalali Imba 739744557

444971E,

9905973N

445007E,

9905940N 0.24 100,000 24,000

491

Not

registered

James

Kimanzi

Matele Mwalali Imba

0710645598

/

0735320905

445007E,

9905940N

445317E,

9905785 1.15 100,000 115,000

492

Not

registered Kyuta Nzaasa Mwalali Imba

445317E,

9905785N

445523E,

9905786N 1.53 100,000 153,000

493

Not

registered

Malimali

Mbuluku Mwalali Imba

445523E,

9905786N

446392E,

9905789N 6.44 150,000 966,000

494

Not

registered

Jeremiah

Mutua

Mulatya Mwalali Imba

722335276/

0716034735

/

0718334253

446392E,

9905789N

446722E,

9905810N 2.4 100,000 240,000

495

Not

registered

Patrick

Muukulu

Nzuki Mwalali Imba

0710293047

/

0710807748

444354E,

9906551N

444483E,

9906430N 1.31 100,000 131,000

496

Not

registered

Stephen

Somba Tuli Mwalali Imba

0713166841

/

0723178553

/

0710822077

446720E,

9905788N

447467E,

9905790N 5.54 100,000 554,000

497

Not

registered

Priscila

Musilu

Maluki Imba Ukasi 724138668

447467E,

9905790N

448282E,

9905793N 6.04 100,000 604,000

498

Not

registered

Tutu

Mwandikwa

Mutunga Mwalali Imba

0702886447

/

0731447078

448282E,

9905793N

448507E,

9905793N 1.67 100,000 167,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 45

Page 54: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

499

Not

registered

James

Mwandikwa

Mutunga Mwalali Imba

0731447078

/

0702886447

448507E,

9905793N

448803E,

9905794N 2.19 100,000 219,000

500

Not

registered

Mwendwa

Mutemi Mwalali Imba

0724799843

/

0728223937

449393E,

9905781N

448808E,

9905782N 4.33 150,000 649,500

501

Not

registered

Mutemi

Musyoka

Kula Mwalali Imba

0711719970

/

0712739695

449493E,

9905782N

449397E,

9905782N 0.71 150,000 106,500

502

Not

registered

Musyoka

Mulingwa Mwalali Imba

0733543388

/ 072994309

449905E

9905782N

449493E,

9905782N 3.05 150,000 457,500

503

Not

registered

Mulonzya

Kioko Mwalali Imba 734180689

450062E,

9905781N

449928E,

9905781N 0.99 150,000 148,500

504

Not

registered

Bonface

Mutuku

Mulwa Mwalali Imba 710628030

450569E,

9905780N

450062E,

9905781N 3.76 150,000 564,000

505

Not

registered

Duncan

Mumo

Kimwele Mwalali Imba

0716034752

/

0722905216

450657E,

9905780N

450876E,

9905780N 1.62 150,000 243,000

506

Not

registered

Musau

Mutunga Mwalali Imba 707942778

450919E,

9905794N

450873E,

9905795N 0.34 150,000 51,000

507

Not

registered

Nzambii

Ndumu Mwalali Imba

0787422664

/

0739615172

452439E,

9906580N

450657E,

9905780N 15.04 150,000 2,256,000

508

Not

registered

Kimanzi

Masila

(Deceased)

Kasyoka

Kimanzi Mwalali Imba

0727091780

/

0707664719

452507E,

9906622N

452443E,

9906581N 0.56 150,000 84,000

509

Not

registered

John Mutua

Mbai Mwalali Imba 710292715

452563E,

9906656N

452507E,

9906622N 0.49 150,000 73,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 46

Page 55: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

510

Not

registered

Joseph

Munyoki

Muthangya Ukasi Ukasi

0729080002

/

0729862962

/

0711761849

452754E,

9906774N

452573E,

9906662N 1.58 150,000 237,000

511

Not

registered

Muthangya

Mulu

Deceased)

Mulu

Muthangya

(Son) Ukasi Ukasi 712539779

455695E,

9908587N

452574E,

9906662N 27.17 150,000 4,075,500

512

Not

registered

Mwende

Nzovo Ukasi Ukasi 711312891

454756E,

9908009N

454452E,

9907021N 5.75 100,000 575,000

513

Not

registered

Mutunga

Nguma Ukasi Ukasi 706618192

445282E,

9908333N

454756E,

9908009N 1.2 150,000 180,000

514

Not

registered Kiluu Ndia Mwalali Imba 701297084

455958E,

9908749N

455695E,

9908587N 2.29 150,000 343,500

515

Not

registered Iloi Kasivu Ukasi Ukasi 708206581

458043E,

9910032N

455958E,

9908749N 18.14 150,000 2,721,000

516

Not

registered

Mwangangi

Mutangili Sosoma Ukasi 0707226103'

455695E,

9908587N

0457691E,

9909823N 17.4 100,000 1,740,000

517

Not

registered

Joseph

Mutemi

Muithya Ukasi Ukasi

0710200070

/

0733595568

459944E,

9911207N

458250E,

9910163N 14.75 150,000 2,212,500

518

Not

registered Muli Kitema Ukasi Ukasi 728452795

460443E,

9911434N

459944E,

9911207N 4.12 150,000 618,000

519

Not

registered

Ndune

Mutangili Ukasi Ukasi

0707880814

/

0707226103

460767E,

9911508N

460443E,

9911434N 2.47 150,000 370,500

520

Not

registered

John

King'ang'a

Musyoka Kathungu Ukasi 712553885

0467587E,

9913074N

0466912E,

9912920N 5.13 100,000 513,000

521

Not

registered

Kilonzi

Musyoka Ukasi Ukasi 706880049

0469603E,

9913537N

0467587E,

9913074N 0.5 100,000 50,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 47

Page 56: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

522

Not

registered

Nuru Maalim

Hajir Bangale Bangale 12m*50m 0.15 100,000 15,000

523

Not

registered

Bille Abdi

Aden Bangale Bangale 12m*50m 0.15 100,000 15,000

524

Not

registered Mohammed ShidhieBangale Bangale

501849 E,

9919274 N

501908 E,

9919294 N 0.46 100,000 46,000

525

Not

registered Ali Adow Bangale Bangale

501908 E,

9919294 N

501995 E,

9919328 N 0.28 100,000 28,000

526

Not

registered Nunu Hussein Bangale Bangale

501995 E,

9919328 N

502010 E,

9919334 N 0.12 100,000 12,000

527

Not

registered Umar Santur Bangale Bangale

502010 E,

9919334 N

502038 E,

9919344 N 0.22 100,000 22,000

528

Not

registered Daud Bangale Bangale

502038 E,

9919344 N

502122 E,

9919377 N 0.67 100,000 67,000

529

Not

registered Ibrahim Abdi Bangale Bangale 100,000 0

530

Not

registered Abdi Soyan Bangale Bangale 100,000 0

531

Not

registered Abdullahi HusseinBangale Bangale 100,000 0

532

Not

registered Gabo Gobu (Deceased)Bangale Bangale

502122E,

9919344N

502226E,

9919418N 0.83 100,000 83,000

533

Not

registered

Habida

Koriti,

Madina,

Mumina

Dube Madogo Madogo 716445902 0 100,000 0

534

Not

registered

Hamara

Kuney Bule Mulanjo Saka 726461683

565163E,

9953198N

565231E,

9953296N 0.88 100,000 88,000

535

Not

registered Kanyere Afi Mulanjo Saka 726461683

565331e,

9953446N

565367E,

9953495N 0.45 100,000 45,000

536

Not

registered

Mohamed

Barisa Jilo Konaramatha Saka 726846631 0 100,000 0

537

TND/MADO/

SH/105 of

31/3/1999 Gubatu Farm Konaramatha Saka

0721480071

/

0725468689

565692E,

9953917N

565839E,

9954192N 2.31 100,000 231,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 48

Page 57: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

538

Not

registered

Olive Branch

Farm Konaramatha Saka

0722836129

/

0731554242

565839E,

9954192N

566155E,

9954572N 3.66 100,000 366,000

539

Not

registered

Dullow Farm

community

(Owned by

Bonaya

Godana

Dullow) Konaramatha Saka

0715535363

/

0729690078

566155E,

9954572N

566861E,

9955394N 8.03 100,000 803,000

540

Not

registered Nasri Farm Athili Raya 713373482

567461E,

9956092N

568738E,

9957577N 14.52 100,000 1,452,000

541

Not

registered

Wathajir

Farm Athili Raya 723444308

568738E,

9957577N

569300E,

9958230N 6.39 100,000 639,000

886.42 213,166,000

Trust land 842.16 Total 100,000 84,216,000

Grand Total 297,382,000

Total

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 49

Page 58: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal Value

Start End

1 1134

David Ndeto

Kasyima Kyondoni Kivaa 722466135 68.5

368208E

,9910266 N

367907 E ,

9910354 N . 2.32 3.4 150,000 348,000

2 822

James

King'esi

Mwangangi Kyondoni Kivaa 715606751 172

369019 E ,

9910158 N.

368944 E ,

9910186 N . 0.6 0.3 150,000 90,000

3 1105

Josphat

Kyengo

Ndwiwa Kyondoni Kivaa 711844430 14.2

368827 E,

9910166N

368907E,

9910176N 0.6 4.2 150,000 90,000

4 1107

Joseph

Mutuku

Ndwiwa Kyondoni Kivaa 16.2

368907E,

9910176N

369037E,

9910149N 0.3 1.8 150,000 45,000

5 820

Anthony

Mbolu

Ndwiwa Kyondoni Kivaa

729652395/

0717842098

4 30

369302 E ,

9910015N

369019 E,

9910158 N . 2.35 7.8 150,000 352,500

6 613

Mulu Katiku

Mukulu Kyondoni Kivaa 711844430 19.5

369311 E ,

9910003 N

369533 E .

9909892 N . 1.83 9.4 150,000 274,500

7 895

Samuel

Mwanzia

Muindi Kyondoni Kivaa

0728360196

/

0727654846

/

0726845122 10.1 0.01 0.1 150,000 1,500

8 * 968

Bonface

Muia Kioko Kyondoni Kivaa

0729248657

/

0728595947 0.11 150,000 16,500

9 611

Bonface

Muia Kioko Kyondoni Kivaa

729284657/

0728595974 4.2

369533 E,

9909892 N

369623 E,

9909836 N. 0.8 19.2 150,000 120,000

10 600

Patrick

Tunda

Maingi Kyondoni Kivaa

0723425796

/

0717041819

369623 E,

9909836 N.

369903E,

9909703 N. 2.31 150,000 346,500

Co-ordinates

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 1

Page 59: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

11 50

Joseph

Nzioka

Kimilu Kyondoni Kivaa 707337887 4

370599 E,

990338 N

370278 E,

9909504 N. 2.09 52.7 150,000 313,500

12 125

Kavuli

Mutuku

Mwanga Kyondoni Kivaa 710544455 39.7

370278 E ,

9909504 N.

370027 E,

9909634 N. 2.09 5.3 150,000 313,500

13

Musyoka

Ndambuki Kyondoni Kivaa

370027E,

9909634N

369903E,

9909703 N. 1.05 150,000 157,500

14 733 Mutune Kyondoni Kivaa

370599 E,

9909338 N

370776 E,

9909246 N 1.62 150,000 243,000

15 59

Jeremiah

Nzioki Kyondoni Kivaa 726503854 1.8

370776 E,

9909246 N.

370914 E,

9909172 N. 1.16 65.9 150,000 174,000

16 76

Ruth Ndindi

Ngila Kyondoni Kivaa 7.9

370914 E,

9909172N

370960 E,

9909149 N. 0.38 4.8 150,000 57,000

17 897

Kilonzo

Musyoka Kyondoni Kivaa 717763817 5.2

370960 E,

9909149 N

371000 E,

9909125 N. 0.38 7.2 150,000 57,000

18 730

Teresiah

Kavata

Mulwa Kyondoni Kivaa 703166425 6

371000 E,

9909125 N.

371031 E,

9909111 N. 0.25 4.2 150,000 37,500

19 3 &4

Mumbua

Mwitwa Kyondoni kivaa

0729496133

/

0714436481 35.7

371031 E,

9909111 N

371391 E,

9908921 N. 3.02 8.4 150,000 453,000

20 901

Mumbua

Mwitwa Kyondoni kivaa

0729496133

/

0714436482 6.3

0371058E,

9909122N

0371413E,

9908942N 2.95 47.1 150,000 442,500

21 5 Muia Mbithi Kyondoni kivaa

0716466560

/

0739716065 31.8

371391 E,

9908921 N.

371660 E,

9908774 N. 2.27 7.1 150,000 340,500

22 53

Benedict

Mwendwa

Muthini Thaana Thaana Nzau 724376573 21

371768 E,

9908720 N.

372018 E,

9908605 N. 2.04 9.7 150,000 306,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 2

Page 60: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

23 845

William

Wambua

Mutui

inherited by

Thomas

King'oo

Mutui Thaana Thaana Nzau 712427401

372018 E,

9908605 N.

372215 E,

9908517 N 1.6 150,000 240,000

24 52

Bonface

Mbai Thaana Thaana Nzau 704962743 1.7

372030 E,

9908597 N.

372090 E,

9908574 N. 0.49 28.1 150,000 73,500

25 50

Benjamin

Maluki

Mwasya Thaana Thaana Nzau 704985915 3.4

372215 E,

9908517 N

372332 E,

9908463 N. 0.95 27.7 150,000 142,500

26 51

Patrick

Malusi

Muthangya Thaana Thaana Nzau 9.1

372332 E,

9908463 N

372515 E,

9908379 N 1.49 16.5 150,000 223,500

27 41

Michael

Kusola

Musee Thaana Thaana Nzau 718702248 12.2

372528 E ,

9908378 N

372574 E,

9908352 N. 0.39 3.2 150,000 58,500

28 29

Pius Ngiti

Kalaa Thaana Thaaana Nzau 707673814 49.8

372574

E,9908352 N

373007

E,9908159 N. 3.51 7.1 150,000 526,500

29 59

Bonface

Mulinge

Kiliku Thaana Thaaana Nzau

373007 E,

9908159 N.

373108 E,

9908107 N. 0.84 150,000 126,000

30 119 Kyasi Kyalivu Kasavini Thaaana Nzau 716109949

0374404E,

9907654N

0374429E,

9907644N 0.2 150,000 30,000

31 115

Paul Ituli

Ngeta Thaana Thaaana Nzau 721928399

373510 E,

9907925 N

373690 E,

9907844 N. 1.46 150,000 219,000

32 115

Kivawa

Kitema Thaana Thaaana Nzau 718014104 63.5

373390 E,

9907844 N

373810 E,

9907789 N. 0.98 1.5 150,000 147,000

33 171

Dominic

Kitema

Mulwa Thaana Thaaana Nzau 717780292

373810 E,

9907789 N

375474 E,

9907037 N 13.53 150,000 2,029,500

34

132, 133,

135, 137,

139

Makau

Kivata

Makau Kakongo Kairungu 713714198 223.6

375474 E,

9907037 N

376270 E,

9906640 N 6.63 3 150,000 994,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 3

Page 61: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

35 957

Mwinzi

Munuve Kairungu Kairungu 52.8

377025E,

9905825N

377462E,

9905353N 4.76 9 150,000 714,000

36 948

Juliana

Katunge

Mwatoo Kakongo Kairungu 700852983 13.4

377563 E,

9905282 N

377761 E.

9905127 N 1.86 13.9 150,000 279,000

37 905

Juliana

Munanu

Mwangangi Kakongo Kairungu 713686186 54.1

377761 E,

9905127 N

378119 E,

9904848 N 3.36 6.2 150,000 504,000

38 903 Andrew David Ngusya 52.6

378119 E,

9904848 N

378403 E,

9904509 N 3.29 6.3 150,000 493,500

39 925

Michael

Mutisya

Kyere Kakongo Kairungu

0720071615

/

0788323029

/

0701876184 19.8 5*60 m 0.07 0.4 150,000 10,500

40 925 Michael Mutisya Kyere

378403 E,

9904509 N

378494 E,

9904398 N. 1.07 150,000 160,500

41 901 Kyere Munuve KimwereKakongo Kairungu 23.1

378494 E,

9904398 N

378572 E,

9904301 N 0.92 4 150,000 138,000

42 480

Simon

Kathara

Kyere Kakongo Kairungu 721843438 93.4

378579 E,

9904289 N

378700 E,

9904141 N. 0.57 0.6 150,000 85,500

43 465 Ngata Singa Kakongo Kairungu 729397510 120.9

378700 E,

9904132 N

379031 E,

9903717 N. 3.93 3.3 150,000 589,500

44 759

Fredrick Muli

Kyania Kairungu Kairungu 711486823 44.2

379031 E,

9903717 N

379128 E,

9903596 N. 1.15 2.6 150,000 172,500

45 Simon Kathara Kyere 721843438

379128 E,

9903596 N.

379259 E,

9903430 N. 1.57 150,000 235,500

46 2416

Julius Musai

Mbiti Kairungu Kairungu 723780318

379280 E,

9903409 N.

379389

E,9903271 N. 1.3 150,000 195,000

47 Simon Kathara Kyere 721843438

379389 E,

9903271 N.

379495 E,

9903142 N. 1.25 150,000 187,500

48 2241

Kinami

Ngoto Kairungu Kairungu 725241471 89.6

379495 E,

9903142 N

379783 E,

9902965 N. 2.5 2.8 150,000 375,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 4

Page 62: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

49 2226

Mutunga

Kyania

Ikanzu Kairungu Kairungu

0723984568

/

0719609915 34

379783 E,

9902965 N.

379936

E,9902835 N. 1.48 4.4 150,000 222,000

50 1921

Damaris

Kasembi

Komu Kairungu Kairungu 710879787 21.3 0.12 0.6 150,000 18,000

51 1920

Peter

Maithya

Kimanzi Kairungu Kairungu 721589453 6.4

379942 E,

9902830 N

380004 E,

9902784 N. 0.57 9 150,000 85,500

52 1919

Paul

Munyambu

Kimanzi Kairungu Kairungu

0721167041

/

0725395590 9.4

380004E,

9902784 N

.380104 E

9902716 N 0.9 9.6 150,000 135,000

53 1918

Joseph

Musili Kioko Kairungu Kairungu 711460951 34.2

380104 E,

9902716 N

380272

E,9902601 N. 1.51 4.4 150,000 226,500

54 1917

Julius Ngui

Kioko Kairungu Kairungu 723217411 33.7

380389

E,9902520 N

380487 E,

9902464 N 0.83 2.5 150,000 124,500

55 1911

James

Kyamui

Ngandi Kairungu Kairungu 728287034 5.3

380487E,

9902464 N

380582 E,

9902390 N 0.89 16.7 150,000 133,500

56 1907

Kathuva

Kithikii Kairungu Kairungu 716458817

380582 E,

9902390 N

380668 E,

9902326 N 0.79 150,000 118,500

57 1908

Julius

Nyerere

Ngandi Kairungu Kairungu 729556727 10.5

380668 E,

9902326 N.

380839 E,

9902209 N 1.54 14.7 150,000 231,000

58 1902

Boniface

Kimanzi

Mwania Kairungu Kairungu 708720521 15.5

380839E,990

2209 N

381071,

E,9902052 N. 2.08 13.4 150,000 312,000

59 1853

Zacheaus

Kalundo Katu Kairungu Kairungu 700858884 10.8 10m*30m 0.07 0.7 150,000 10,500

60 1852

Joseph

Musili Katu Kairungu Kairungu 701630553 11.4

381079

E,9902042 N

381524

E,9901733 N. 2.66 23.2 150,000 399,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 5

Page 63: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

61 1849

Nathan

Kathuri

Mwendwa Kairungu Kairungu 723117026 33.4

381378 E,

9901844 N

381524

E,9901733 N. 1.36 4.1 150,000 204,000

62 1848

Mutemi

Joseph

Mwendwa Kairungu Kairungu 723685983 30.4

381524

E,9901733 N

381684 E,

9901626 N. 1.43 4.7 150,000 214,500

63 1860

Cyrus

Mwendwa

Mutemi Kairungu Kairungu 710446043 9.2

381684 E,

9901626 N

381942 E,

9901445 N 2.34 25.5 150,000 351,000

64 1869

Daniel

Mwendwa

lava Kairungu Kairungu 723685983 26.4

381942 E,

9901445 N

382296 E,

9901204 N. 3.25 12.3 150,000 487,500

65 1679

David Ng'ati

Meli Kairungu Kairungu 725227991 36.5

382305E,

9901196 N.

382597 E,

9900989 N. 2.65 7.3 150,000 397,500

66 1840 Gabriel Ngeta MununaKairungu Kairungu 13.5

382597E,990

09809 N

382627 E,

9900971 N 0.26 1.9 150,000 39,000

67 1780

Sammy

Musili

Ngunga Kairungu Kairungu 726657646 44.2

382627 E,

9900971 N.

382770 E,

9900874 N. 1.28 2.9 150,000 192,000

68 1780

Joel Maithya

Wambua Kairungu Kairungu

0713267642

/

0736689395 42.1

383021 E,

9900701 N

382770 E,

9900874 N. 2.26 5.4 150,000 339,000

69 1779

Tabitha

Wambua Kairungu Kairungu

0713267642

/073668939

5 75.8

383021 E,

9900701 N

383140 E,

9900617 N. 1.08 1.4 150,000 162,000

70 1692

Joshua

Mutemi

Muisyo Kairungu Kairungu 9.5

383141E,

9900615 N.

383262

E,9900532 N. 1.09 11.5 150,000 163,500

71 1691

Emmanuel

Musyoka

Muisyo Kairungu Kairungu 718728349 7

383262

E,9900532 N.

383406 E,

9900432 N. 1.3 18.6 150,000 195,000

72 1782

Muithya

Ivai(decease

d) Nzanzai

Mwinzai Kairungu Kairungu 715711487 28.5

383406 E,

9900432 N.

383672 E,

9900249 N. 2.39 8.4 150,000 358,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 6

Page 64: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

73 1783

Nyamu

Mutemi

Katungu Kairungu Kairungu 15.8

383672 E,

9900249 N

383836 E,

9900137 N 1.47 9.3 150,000 220,500

74 1684

Benjamin

Ngui Nzioka Kairungu Kairungu 717515637 15

383582 E,

9900122 N.

383895 E,

9900092 N. 0.4 2.6 150,000 60,000

75 1385 Joseph Mwendwa Mutemikairungu kairungu 30.1

383911 E,

9900081 N

384036E,

9899998 N. 1.11 3.7 150,000 166,500

76 1386

Francis Kithu

Mutemi Kairungu Kairungu 723507719 6.9

384038 E,

9899995 N.

384234 E,

9899860 N. 1.76 25.4 150,000 264,000

77 1392

Musyoka

Mulu Kairungu Kairungu 718324046 34.4

384234 E,

9899860 N

384352 E,

9899776 N. 1.07 3.1 150,000 160,500

78 1396 Mwinzi Kairungu Kairungu 9.6

384352 E,

9899776 N.

384408

E,9899737 N. 0.51 5.3 150,000 76,500

79 1398 Unoo Kavuu MukutaKiomo Kiomo 33

384408 E,

9899737 N.

384598 E,

9899601N. 1.73 5.3 350,000 605,500

80 1410 Mbathi Musyimi KonyeKiomo Kiomo 29.7

384598 E,

9899601 N

384678 E,

9899556 N. 0.68 2.3 350,000 238,000

81 1399 Katana Kieve Kiomo Kiomo

384678 E,

9899556 N.

384801 E,

9899467 N. 1.12 350,000 392,000

82 1399 Mwivi Kieve Kiomo Kiomo 712641038 46.3

384801 E,

9899467 N.

384953 E,

9899363 N. 1.36 2.9 350,000 476,000

83 1415

Kavata Kieve

Ndana Kiomo Kiomo 725741645 9

384953 E,

9899363 N

385081 E,

9899271 N. 1.17 12.9 350,000 409,500

84 1412

Musyoka

Konye Ndana Kiomo Kiomo

0700058851

/

0720048444

2/

0719478396 7.1

385081 E,

9899271 N.

385197 E,

9899192 N. 1.04 14.7 350,000 364,000

85 1418

Mbathi

Musyimi

Konye Kiomo Kiomo 708474297 11.3

385197 E,

9899192 N.

385375 E,

9899076 N. 1.57 13.9 350,000 549,500

86 1417

Mutwa

Kitheka

Musyimi Kiomo Kiomo 702011422

385386

E,9899063 N.

385569 E,

9898935 N. 1.65 350,000 577,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 7

Page 65: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

87

Mwingi/Kio

mo/1401

John Mutemi

Musee Kiomo Kiomo 721382198 38.3

385579 E,

9898932 N.

385858 E,

9898777 N. 2.36 6.2 350,000 826,000

88 1439 Phillip Mati KitisyaKiomo Kiomo 5.9

385858 E,

9898777 N.

385859 E,

9898755 N. 0.03 0.6 350,000 10,500

89 1495

James

Mulwa

Kyalya Kiomo Kiomo 721778624 7.1

385906 E,

9898757 N.

385991 E,

9898709 N. 0.72 10.2 400,000 288,000

90 1494

Mati Kyalya

(Sold to

Laban

Rindiri) Kiomo Kiomo 711593767 4.1

385991 E,

9898709 N

386073

E,9898658 N 0.71 17.3 400,000 284,000

91 2323

Laban

Muthengi

Rindiri Kiomo Kiomo

0722694486

/

0725008514 2.8

386147

E,9898622 N.

386073

E,9898658 N 0.61 21.4 400,000 244,000

92 1491

Laban

Muthengi

Rindiri Kiomo Kiomo

0722694486

/

0725008514 7.6

386147 E,

9898622 N.

386227 E,

9898583 N. 0.66 8.7 400,000 264,000

93 1536

John Kilonzi

Kikumbu Kiomo Kiomo

0722489705

/

0721778624 3.9

386227 E,

9898583 N.

386315 E,

9898526 N. 0.77 20 400,000 308,000

94 1534

Joel Mwaniki

Kikumbu Kiomo Kiomo 722489705 8.2

386315 E,

9898526 N

386478 E,

9898442 N. 0.55 6.7 400,000 220,000

95 1535

John Kilonzi

Kikumbi,

David

Kikumbi,Joel

Mwaniki

Kikumbi Kiomo Kiomo 722489705 0.5

386478 E,

9898442 N.

386498 E,

9898432 N. 0.17 30.5 400,000 68,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 8

Page 66: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

96 1490

Kitui Kivunzi

Munyambu Kiomo Kiomo

0711118247

/

0712458893 18.3

386505

E,9898430 N.

387118 E,

9898334 N. 4.61 25.2 400,000 1,844,000

97 1485 Michael Kaka MatitiKiomo Kiomo

387118 E,

9898334 N

387363 E,

9898134N. 2.38 400,000 952,000

98 646

Michael

Kilonzi

Musee Kiomo Kiomo 721201240 5.1

387373 E,

9898131 N.

387470 E,

9898049 N. 0.94 18.3 400,000 376,000

99 638 Michael Kilonzi MuseeKiomo Kiomo 14.2

387373 E,

9898131 N.

387470 E,

9898049 N. 0.94 6.6 400,000 376,000

100 647 Phillip Kitheka MuseeKiomo Kiomo 2.4

387638 E,

9897894 N.

387679 E,

9897866 N. 0.37 15.3 400,000 148,000

101 623 Kimanzi Musee (deceased)Kiomo Kiomo 7.1

387679 E,

9897866 N

387716 E,

9897838 N 0.34 4.9 400,000 136,000

102 626

David

Mwangangi

Musee Kiomo Kiomo 721382198 11.3

387716 E,

9897838 N.

387730 E ,

9897817 N. 0.18 1.6 400,000 72,000

103 627

Mbathe

Kilungu

Mutisya Kiomo Kiomo 701779356 9.9

387730 E ,

9897817 N.

387877 E,

9897712 N. 1.33 13.5 400,000 532,000

104 641

Thomas

Tinga

Mutisya Kiomo Kiomo 712789345 9

387877E,

9897712N

387971E,

9897661N 0.79 8.8 400,000 316,000

105 655

Annah

Nzambi Muli Kiomo Kiomo 723655986 4.2

387971E,

9897661N

388118E,

9897582N 1.24 29.6 500,000 620,000

106 684

Dominic

Mwinzi

Muthama Kiomo Kiomo 704872791 46.1

388118E,

9897582N

388465E,

9897401N 2.9 6.3 500,000 1,450,000

107 685

John

Musembi

Mutio Kiomo Kiomo 706586747 15.2

388465E,

9897401N

388635E,

9897313N 1.42 9.3 500,000 710,000

108 688

Francis

Musili

Musyimi Kiomo Kiomo 716247470 6.3

389209E,

9897010N

389413E,

9896907N 1.69 26.8 500,000 845,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 9

Page 67: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

109 2224

Titus

Ndambu

Musili Kiomo Kiomo

0712515113

/

0734030321 5.5

388725E,

9897265N

3888725E,

9897265N 0.81 14.7 500,000 405,000

110 593

John Kilonzo

Musili Kiomo Kiomo 716275430 3.2

388833E,

9897211N

38889E,

9897176N 0.55 17.1 500,000 275,000

111 595

Syothome

Mbiva

Kitense Kiomo Kiomo 4.1

388899E,

9897176N

388994E,

9897176N 0.62 15.1 500,000 310,000

112 554

John

Nzamba

Kithu Kiomo Kiomo

0718501948

/

0727986294 7.4

389114E,

9897059N

389209E,

9897010N 0.79 10.7 500,000 395,000

113 2504

John

Nzamba

Kithu Kiomo Kiomo

0718501948

/

0727986294 7.8

388998E,

9897121N

389114E,

9897059N 5.78 74.1 500,000 2,890,000

114 555

Telesia Mali

Mulyungi Kiomo Kiomo 0711692828' 10.1

389417E,

9896904N

389564E,

9896824N 2.07 20.5 500,000 1,035,000

115 549

Munuve

Mbuvu Kiomo Kiomo 712694052 1

389682E,

9896765N

389809E,

9896698N 1 96.4 500,000 500,000

116 569

Jackson

Kimoro

Kimanzi

(Deceased);

Sammy

Kimoro (Son) Kiomo Kiomo 726006403 8.4

389860E,

9896672N

390040E,

9896575N 1.52 18.1 500,000 760,000

117 2358

Kikunduu

Self Help

Group Kiomo Kiomo 714210785 2.7

389809E,

9896698N

389860E,

9896672N 0.42 15.7 500,000 210,000

118 558

Bernard

Mutunga

Katambu Kiomo Kiomo 0721293254'

389564E,

9896824N

389611E,

9896801N 0.39 500,000 195,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 10

Page 68: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

119 569

Jackson

Kimoro

Kimanzi

(Deceased);

Sammy

Kimoro (Son) Kiomo Kiomo 726006403 8.4

389860E,

9896672N

390040E,

9896575N 1.52 18.1 500,000 760,000

120 579

James

Mutunga

Musyimi Kiomo Kiomo 714210785 12.6

390045E,

9896575N

390101E,

9896544N 0.47 3.8 500,000 235,000

121 2432

Loise Gideon

Kamia Kiomo Kiomo 713980376 4.5

390555E,

9896305N

390665E,

9896247N 0.92 20.5 500,000 460,000

122 290

Dorothy

Kasyoka

Munywoki Kiomo Kiomo 0731046787'

392844 E,

9896865 N.

392868 E,

9896949 N. 0.64 600,000 384,000

123 288

Peter

Muinde

Nduvi Kiomo Kiomo 717168886

392835 E,

9896839 N.

392844 E,

9896866 N. 0.2 600,000 120,000

124

Mwende

Mutaaru

Nzuva Kiomo Kiomo 0708124438'

392768 E,

9896612 N.

392787 E,

9896676 N 0.49 600,000 294,000

125 286 Sarah Mumbe MusyokaKiomo Kiomo 727885857

392768 E,

9896612 N

392833 E,

9896828 N. 1.67 600,000 1,002,000

126 289 Mwende Mutaru NzuvaKiomo Kiomo 2.9

392833 E,

9896828 N.

392835 E,

9896839 0.26 8.8 600,000 156,000

127 283

Masila Nzuva

Kakunyi Kiomo Kiomo 725360969 7.2

392728 E,

9896475 N

392768 E,

9896612 N. 1.06 14.8 600,000 636,000

128 281

Alice Mungai

Kathoka Kiomo Kiomo 712507650 69.3

392601 E,

9896050 N.

392728 E,

9896475 N. 3.29 4.7 600,000 1,974,000

129 280

Patrick

Munyoki

Mwandao

(Deceased) Kiomo Kiomo 711801499 34.7

392513 E,

9895749 N.

392601 E,

9896050 N. 2.32 6.7 600,000 1,392,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 11

Page 69: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

130 178

Kimanzi

Mutumba

(Deceased) Kiomo Kiomo 0700707152'

392402 E,

9895377 N.

392513 E,

9895749 N. 2.88 600,000 1,728,000

131 403

Joseph

Mutemi

Munyoki Kiomo Kiomo

0702936135

/

0704401959

390608 E,

9896370 N.

390521 E,

9896379 N. 0.65 600,000 390,000

132 241

James Muli

Munyithya

(Deceased) Kiomo Kiomo 0717220638'

390776 E,

9896339 N.

390608 E,

9896370 N. 1.27 600,000 762,000

133 2430 John Munyoki Kitheka

390849 E,

9896331 N

390776 E,

9896339 N. 0.55 700,000 385,000

134 Muthui Mwasuvye

390940 E,

9896271 N.

390849 E,

9896331 N. 0.79 700,000 553,000

135 2430 John Munyoki Kitheka

391020 E,

9896219 N

390940 E,

9896271 N. 0.69 700,000 483,000

136 2181

John Musili

Muthui Kiomo Kiomo 715098508 8.8

391345 E,

9896019 N.

391020 E,

9896219 N 2.94 33.4 700,000 2,058,000

137 182

Thomas

Nduvi Mboo Kiomo Kiomo 720997807 20.3

391782 E,

9895735 N.

391675 E,

9895804 N. 0.94 4.6 700,000 658,000

138 4288

Joyce

Muthina

Muli Kyanika Mwingi 711579856 5.3

392881 E,

9896995 N.

392917 E,

9897115 N. 0.93 17.6 800,000 744,000

139 659 Musili Ndilu Mang'ooKyanika Kyanika 1.2

392917 E,

9897115 N

392938 E,

9897185 N 0.67 56.4 800,000 536,000

140 657 Anna Muingo NdiluKyanika Kyanika 1.7

392938 E,

9897185 N

392955 E,

9897259 N 0.56 33.3 800,000 448,000

141 593

Ferdinand

musyoka

Syengo

(Inherited by

Edwin

Musyoka

Syengo) Kyanika Mwingi 720605751 4.6

392955 E,

9897259 N.

392983 E,

9897339 N. 0.63 13.6 800,000 504,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 12

Page 70: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

142 594 Makau MumamaKyanika Mwingi 4.2

392983 E,

9897339 N

392989E,

9897361N. 0.17 4 800,000 136,000

143 4734 Jane Nguli ( deceased). Muli Nguli.Kyanika Mwingi 725407371 1.8

392989 E,

9897361 N

393010 E,

9897433 N 0.56 30.9 800,000 448,000

144 584 Benjamin Muthami MasilaKyanika Mwingi 3.6

393010 E,

9897433 N

393020 E,

9897461 N 0.22 6.2 800,000 176,000

145 4733

Peter Mbuvi

Vere

(Deceased) Kyanika Mwingi 712102504 8

393020 E,

9897461 N

393066 E,

9897611 N. 1.16 14.6 800,000 928,000

146 4729

Musyimi

Vere Makau Kyanika Mwingi 719286722 8.7

393066 E,

9897611 N

393098 E,

9897721 N. 0.85 9.7 800,000 680,000

147 4729 Lucas Mutua Muthami. Sold by Musyimi vereKyanika Mwingi

393098 E,

9897721 N.

393112 E,

9897757 N. 0.29 800,000 232,000

148 663 Patrick Mwinzi MatitiKyanika Mwingi 37

393112 E,

9897757 N

393141 E,

9897801 N 0.39 1.1 1,000,000 390,000

149 585

Benjamin

Wambua

Matiti Kyanika Mwingi

0728253040

/

0724608925 9.2

393141 E,

9897757 N

393223 E,

9897968 N. 1.38 15 1,000,000 1,380,000

150 1065

Mulwa

Mwalwa Kyanika Mwingi

0739168629

/

0700672048 0.9 40m*15m 0.15 16.4 1,000,000 150,000

151 588

Simon

Kimanthi

Malusi Kyanika Mwingi 725787651 1

393277 E,

9898040 N

393420 E,

9898172 N. 0.67 68.5 1,000,000 670,000

152 585 Benjamin Wambua MatitiKyanika Mwingi 7.9

393277 E,

9898040 N

393420 E,

9898172 N. 1.44 18.3 1,000,000 1,440,000

153 575

Anthony

Mutua

Mwinzi Kyanika Mwingi 702879492 14.6

393420 E,

9898172 N,

393484 E,

9898229 N. 0.63 4.4 1,000,000 630,000

154 574

John Thomas

Ngwei Kyanika Mwingi

0716742290

/

0728920911 1.4

393484 E,

9898229 N

393518 E,

9898261 N. 0.35 25.4 1,000,000 350,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 13

Page 71: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

155 571

Mulatya

Ulinge Kyanika Mwingi 713369289

393520E,

9898268N

393538E,

9898287N 0.2 1,000,000 200,000

156 572

Kiluti

Mutunga

Maengo Kyanika Mwingi 717322145 12.4

393538 E,

9898287 N.

393552 E,

9898294 N. 0.11 0.9 1,000,000 110,000

157 571

Mwangangi

Mulinge Kyanika Mwingi 710677173 8.4

393552 E,

9898294 N.

393564 E,

9898308 N. 0.14 1.6 1,000,000 140,000

158 571

Mwangangi

Mulinge

(Deceased)-

Sold to Jacob

Mulatya Kyanika Mwingi 713369289

393564 E,

9898308 N.

393631 E,

9898368 N. 0.67 1,000,000 670,000

159 4496

Francis

Mwaniki

Munuve Kyanika Mwingi

0725800358

/

0732074821 1.3

393631 E,

9898368 N.

393705 E,

9898439 N. 0.76 56.6 1,000,000 760,000

160 576

Charles Kyalo

Nduvi Kyanika Mwingi 720997807 3.4

393735 E,

9898439 N.

393760 E,

9898487 N. 0.38 11.3 1,000,000 380,000

161 691

Kilonzi

Mulatya Kyanika Mwingi 716104683 9.9 0.11 1.1 1,000,000 110,000

162 4396

Thomas

Ngondu

Mwinzi Kyanika Mwingi 710652012 4

393775 E,

9898506 N

393895 E,

9898618 N. 1.22 30.3 1,200,000 1,464,000

163 993

Dominic

Musyoka

Mwangangi Kyanika Mwingi 725725494 10.2 150m*15m 0.56 5.5 1,200,000 672,000

164 954

Johnson

Munyoki

Kano Kyanika Mwingi 716781853 4.8

393895 E,

9898618 N

393978 E,

9898692 N. 0.82 17 1,200,000 984,000

165 718

Samson

Kano

Ngumbi

(Deceased) Kyanika Mwingi

0723545219

/

0700420399 8.8

393978 E,

9898692 N.

394148 E,

9898853 N. 1.73 19.6 1,200,000 2,076,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 14

Page 72: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

166 700

Mutemi

Musee Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 3.3

394153 E,

9898857 N

394223 E,

9898922 N. 0.29 8.7 1,200,000 348,000

167 705

Jimmy

Makuthu

Kanno Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 7.5

394223 E,

9898922 N.

394258 E,

9898955 N. 0.36 4.8 1,200,000 432,000

168 4911 David Kitema Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 7.8

394258 E,

9898955 N.

394330 E,

9899022 N. 0.73 9.3 1,200,000 876,000

169 703

PatricK

Kimanzi

Maluki Kyanika Mwingi 716184526 9.4

394330 E,

9898022 N

394439 E,

9899124 N. 1.11 11.7 1,200,000 1,332,000

170 704

Jane

Mutinda

(Bought

from

Kamami

Syengo Kyanika Mwingi 722932202 7.9

394439 E,

9899124 N

394487 E,

9899169 N. 0.49 6.2 1,200,000 588,000

171 *1687

Elijah Nzomo

Katee Kyanika Mwingi 727826456 13.8

394487

E,9899169 N

394654 E,

9899323 N. 1.68 12.2 1,200,000 2,016,000

172 1004

Ibrahim

Malonza

Kula Kyanika Mwingi 723709523 14.1

394660 E,

9899331 N

394800 E,

9899461 N. 1.42 10 1,200,000 1,704,000

173 717

Jimmy

Mukutho

Kanno Kyanika Mwingi 722917161 7.5

394800 E,

9899461 N

394927 E,

9899580 N. 1.29 17.2 1,200,000 1,548,000

174 1009

Peter

Munyoki

Mutambuki

(Deceased) Kyanika Mwingi

0729113822,

0733958122 8.1

394927 E,

9899580 N

394997 E,

9899645 N. 0.71 8.7 1,300,000 923,000

175 1008

Mutua

Kathau

(Deceased)-

Bought from

Mbiti Kitima) Kyanika Mwingi 713820638 8.5

394997 E,

9899645 N.

395119 E,

9899760 N. 1.24 14.6 1,300,000 1,612,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 15

Page 73: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

176 4710

Onesmus

Kilonzo

Kapeleki(Bro

ught from

Kilonzi

Kavisi) Kyanika Mwingi 738379870 3.6

395119 E,

9899760 N.

395205 E,

9899840 N. 0.87 24.1 1,300,000 1,131,000

177 1073

Joseph

Kavindu

Mailu Kyanika Mwingi 4.8

395205 E,

9899840 N

395316 E,

9899943 N. 1.12 23.4 1,300,000 1,456,000

178 1476

Benedict

Kinuva Kyanika Mwingi 714596130 7.8

395316 E,

9899943 N.

395430 E,

9900049 N. 1.15 14.8 1,300,000 1,495,000

179 930

Stephen

Kilonzo

Munyithya Kyanika Mwingi 711570572 2.6

395527 E,

9900140 N

395567 E,

9900177 N. 0.48 18.7 1,300,000 624,000

180 930

Julius

Mwandikwa

Mutia Kyanika Mwingi 720844960 2.6

395437 E,

9900056 N

395527 E,

9900140 N. 0.91 35.7 1,300,000 1,183,000

181 928

John

Mulunga Ithumbi Mwingi 723036751 5.1

395863 E,

9900240 N

395915 E,

9900238 N. 0.39 7.5 2,000,000 780,000

182

*4721, 4403,

4698

Peter

Mwendwa

Kinyili Ithumbi Mwingi

0722755348

/

0734288277 12.3

395915 E,

9900238 N.

396190E,

9900228 N. 2.04 16.6 2,000,000 4,080,000

183 5359

Simon

Mulyungi

Kitema Ithumbi Kivou 716631357

396199 E,

9900228 N.

396275 E,

9900226 N. 0.56 2,000,000 1,120,000

184 652

Peter

Musyoka

Ngunga Kyanika Mwingi 713415699 9.5

396391 E,

9900221 N.

396412 E,

9900221 N. 0.16 1.6 2,000,000 320,000

185 1707

Mary

Kimanzi Ithumbi Mwingi 722119926 2.2

396199 E,

9900228 N.

396275 E,

9900226 N. 0.56 25.4 2,000,000 1,120,000

186 597

Ibrahim

Mwaka

Munyithya Kyanika Mwingi 710707754 29.2

396941E,

9900186N

396603E,

9900197N 2.51 8.6 2,000,000 5,020,000

187 597

Joseph

Mutui

Kivunzi Kyanika Mwingi 702495029 4.2

396505 E,

9900217 N

396590 E,

9900214 N. 0.63 15 2,000,000 1,260,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 16

Page 74: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

188 603

Maithya

Munyithya Kyanika Mwingi

0723205921

/

0734713144

/

0716280631 1.1 15m*6m 0.02 2 1,300,000 26,000

189 605/4678

Samuel

Kithome

Makau Ithumbi Mwingi

0720983407

/

0726270908

/

0733892147 3.5

396952 E,

9900201 N

397049 E,

9900198 N. 0.72 20.7 1,300,000 936,000

190 610

Kimwele

Maluki Ithumbi Ithumbi 789290299 2.9

397049 E,

9900194 N

397168 E.

9900194 N. 0.88 30.6 1,300,000 1,144,000

191 607 Fredrick Augustus Kiluku NyenzeIthumbi Ithumbi

0733382983

/

0725996603 3

397168 E,

9900194 N

397216 E,

9900192 N. 0.34 11.2 1,300,000 442,000

192 4679

Samuel

Kithome

Makau Ithumbi Mwingi

0720983407

/

0726270908

/

0733892147 6.7

396952 E,

9900201 N

397049 E,

9900198 N. 1.06 15.9 1,300,000 1,378,000

193 612

Kennedy

Kilonzi Matii

bought from

Mwanzia

Muthami

Ngombe Ithumbi Mwingi 707594553 13.3

397367 E,

9900186 N.

397489 E,

9900182 N 0.9 6.8 1,000,000 900,000

194 612

Mwanzia

Muthami

Ng'ombe

(inherited by

John

Mwanzia) Ithumbi Mwingi

0723307387

/

0739480057 4.9

397489 E,

9900182 N

397600 E,

9900178 N. 0.82 16.7 1,000,000 820,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 17

Page 75: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

195 612

Mwanzia

Muthami

Ng'ombe

(inherited by

Kilonzo

Mwanzia) Kyanika Mwingi

0723307387

/

0739480057 3.8

397489 E,

9900182 N

397600 E,

9900178 N. 0.67 17.5 1,000,000 670,000

196

Mulwa

Mwanzia(De

ceased)

Joyce Vilita

Mulwa Ithumbi Mwingi 710148767

397690 E,

9900175 N.

397814 E,

9900171 N. 0.92 1,000,000 920,000

197 820 Julius Ngui MuoniKivou Kivou 725713337 17.9

397814 E,

9900171 N.

398086 E,

9900161 N. 2.02 11.3 500,000 1,010,000

198 802

Kitheka

Baringo

inherited by

Mutuku

Kilonzo Kivou Kivou

723153093/

0736016360 14.8

398086 E,

9900161 N

398181 E,

9900158 N. 0.7 4.8 500,000 350,000

199 802

Kitheka

Baringo

Inherited

by;Charles

Kyalo

Kitheka Kivou Kivou 714390142 14.8

398181 E,

9900158 N

398290 E,

9900154 N. 0.81 5.5 500,000 405,000

200 478

Musyoka

Matiti

(Bought

from

Wambua

Kasolo) Kivou Kivou 728520230 5.4

398295 E,

9900153 N

398423 E,

9900149 N. 0.95 17.5 500,000 475,000

201 476

Kalunda

Kasolo Konga Kivou Kivou 700807652 4.6

398423 E,

9900149 N

398548 E,

9900145 N. 0.93 20.3 300,000 279,000

202 473

Musyoka

Kasolo Kunga Kivou Kivou 703645934 5.3

398611 E,

9900142 N

398752 E,

9900137 N. 0.39 7.3 300,000 117,000

203 475

Mutemi

Musee Kivou KIvou 720071610 8m*40m 0.1 300,000 30,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 18

Page 76: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

204 474

Ngui

Mbwaru Kivou Kivou 727437622 3.5

398611 E,

9900142 N.

398752 E,

9900137 N. 1.04 29.9 300,000 312,000

205 475

Mutemi

Musee Kivou Kivou 720071610

398752E,

9900137N

398852E,

9900133N 0.74 300,000 222,000

206 470

Abel Kiema

Mulanga Kivou Kivou 713267670 4.8

398852 E,

9900133 N.

398882 E,

9900132 N. 0.22 4.6 300,000 66,000

207 2874

Mutemi

Musee Kivou Kivou 720071610 21.2

398882 E,

9900132 N

398968 E,

9900130 N. 0.64 3 300,000 192,000

208 2876

Samson

Munyoki

Ndulu Kivou Kivou 725211476

398968 E,

9900130 N.

399080 E,

9900125 N. 0.83 300,000 249,000

209 2875

Charles

Ndulu

Ndekwa(Inhe

rited by

Kyalo Charles

) Kivou Kivou 729156304 8.6

399080 E,

9900125 N.

399259 E,

9900119 N. 1.33 15.4 300,000 399,000

210 2880

Ndavi

Kisusya Kivou Kivou 701630590

399259 E,

9900119 N

399305 E,

9900118 N. 0.34 300,000 102,000

211 2881 Ngui Kisosya Kivou Kivou 700281890

399305 E,

9900118 N

399454 E,

9900112 N. 1.11 300,000 333,000

212 2892

Michael

Kyalo

Muthuvi Kivou Kivou

0733201002

/

0718801868

399460 E,

9900118 N

399572 E,

9900108 N. 0.83 300,000 249,000

213 2891

Mwikya

Muthuvi Kivou Kivou 787830044

399572 E,

9900108 N

399658 E,

9900105 N. 0.64 300,000 192,000

214 2890 Stephen Peter Muthuvi Inherited from Muthuve MunuveKivou Kivou 700699888 4.6

399748 E,

9900144 N

399658 E,

9900105 N. 0.73 16 300,000 219,000

215 3048 Paul Mwendwa MuthuviKivou Kivou

399748 E,

9900144 N

399772 E,

9900154 N 0.19 300,000 57,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 19

Page 77: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

216 3561

John

Musyimi

Kamuti

Bought from

Julius

Muthusi

Mbulai Kivou Kivou 703596274 4.7

399772 E,

9900154 N

399888 E,

9900203 N. 0.93 19.9 300,000 279,000

217 4664 Kanzoka A.I.C Church 0.9

399888 E,

9900203 N.

399982 E,

9900226 N. 0.74 85 300,000 222,000

218 3558 John Musyimi Kamuti 2.5

399986 E,

9900225 N.

400083 E,

9900207 N. 0.73 28.7 300,000 219,000

219 5189 John Musyimi Kamuti 6.2

400083 E,

9900207 N

400140 E,

9900197 N. 0.43 6.9 300,000 129,000

220 3559 John Musyimi Kamuti

400140 E,

9900197 N

400331 E,

9900161 N. 1.44 300,000 432,000

221 3598

Pius Musili

Munyithya Kivou Kivou 726294747 9

400331 E,

9900161 N

400502 E,

9900130 N. 1.29 14.3 300,000 387,000

222 3559

Kitheka Mulu

Kisilu Kivou Kivou

400502 E,

9900130 N

400710 E,

9900092 N 1.57 300,000 471,000

223 3272

Musyoka

Mutia(Inheri

ted by

Kitonga

Musyoka) Kivou Kivou 721290527

400710 E,

9900092 N

401197 E,

9900044 N. 3.63 300,000 1,089,000

224 3680

Musyoka

Mutia

(Inherited by

Ngundi

Musyoka Kivou Kivou 707196140 32.8

401197 E,

9900044 N.

401296 E,

9900035 N. 0.74 2.2 300,000 222,000

225 2836 Isaiah Ngusu Kivou Kivou 722274446

401459 E,

9900026 N

401691 E,

9900020 N. 1.72 300,000 516,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 20

Page 78: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

226 2827

Mbuvi

Mbava

(Gabriel

Musembei

Mbuvi ) Kivou Kivou

0716741606

/072536960

1

/+25261638

3629

401340 E,

9900030 N

401450 E,

9900026 N. 1.14 300,000 342,000

227 *2883

Dominic

Mutavanya

Ngusu Kivou Kivou 15m*50m 0.19 300,000 57,000

228 2838 Isaiah Ngusu Kivou Kivou 722274446 7.5

401459 E,

9900026 N

401691 E,

9900020 N. 1.72 22.8 300,000 516,000

229 2846

Manzo

Mutia(Decea

sed) Kivou Kivou 710700127 50*13m 0.16 300,000 48,000

230 2736 Muthangya Mutemi inherited by Muvisi MuthangyaKivou Kivou 727662202 6.7

401691 E,

9900020 N

401857 E,

9900016 N. 1.22 18.3 300,000 366,000

231 2742 Peter Mutie Kivou Kivou 705543580 4.3

401857 E,

9900016 N

402003 E,

9900012 N. 1.08 25 300,000 324,000

232 2745 Jacob Kimanzi Mwinzi (Inheritor Jones Mwinzi Nzengu)Kivou Kivou 705062056 2.9

402003 E,

9900072 N.

402048 E,

9900012 N. 0.33 11.5 300,000 99,000

233 2735

Muvisi

Muthangya Kivou Kivou 727662202

402048 E,

9900012 N

402066 E,

9900011 N. 0.13 300,000 39,000

234 2725 Mati Mutia Mbali sold to Muvisi MuthangyaKivou Kivou 727662202

402066 E,

9900011 N.

402224 E,

9900007 N. 1.17 300,000 351,000

235 2723

Manzo

Mutia(Decea

sed) Kivou Kivou 710700127 50m*13m 0.16 300,000 48,000

236 Muthina NzenguKivou Kivou 50m*8m 0.1 300,000 30,000

237 2727

Samuel

Kikwatu

Nzengu Kivou Kivou 725947285 7.8

402292 E,

9900006 N.

4023396E,

9900003N 0.77 9.9 300,000 231,000

238 2773 Mati Mutia Kivou Kivou

402396 E,

9900003N

402423 E,

9900003 N 300,000 0

239 2726

Munyoki

Makau

Mutia Kivou Kivou 721241733 13.4

402435 E,

9900003 N

402571 E,

9899999 N. 1.01 7.5 300,000 303,000

240

2722, 2801,

2804

Mwendwa

Makau Kivou Kivou 711475134 0.7

402571 E,

9899999 N

402605 E,

9899998 N. 0.25 35.4 500,000 125,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 21

Page 79: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

241 2845 Mati Mutia Mbali sold to Muvisi MuthangyaKivou Kivou

0714646377

/

0737678458 7.1

402605 E,

9899998 N.

403140 E,

9899985 N. 3.97 56.2 500,000 1,985,000

242 2710 Concleter Mwikali ManziKivou Kivou 702936327 14.6

403147 E,

9899986 N

.403433

E,9899979 N. 2.13 14.6 500,000 1,065,000

243 2808 Martha Mbiti Kivou Kivou 735971495 9.2

403579E,

9900103N

403434E,

9899984N 1.39 15.1 500,000 695,000

244 2807

John

Johnson

Manzi Kivou Kivou 719819441 7.4

403620E,

9900136N

403579E,

9900103N 0.39 5.2 500,000 195,000

245 2912

John Muthui

Mwendwa Kisama Kivou 715794296 22.2

403742E,

9900236N

403620E,

9900136N 1.17 5.3 500,000 585,000

246 *2913

Fridah Loise

Kisoya Kisama Kivou

0721699257

/

0733592542 5.9

403756E,

9900246N

403742 E,

9900236N 0.13 2.1 500,000 65,000

247 2914

William

Kang'ola

Nzengu Kisama Kivou 710813294 6.6

403918E,

9900386N

403859E,

9900331N 0.6 9.1 500,000 300,000

248 2915

William

Kang'ola

Nzengu Kisama Kivou 710813294

403859E,

9900331N

403756E,

9900246N 20.15 500,000 10,075,000

249 2920

Benson

Mwangangi

Mwendwa Kisama Kivou 729905498 1.9

403997E,

9900386N

403918E,

9900386N 0.72 38.1 300,000 216,000

250 2921

Mwendwa

Ilwe Kisama Kivou 729723039 5.7

404041E,

9900483N

403997E,

9900442N 0.45 7.8 300,000 135,000

251 2933

Muthui

Munyambu Kisama Kivou 725475738 9.7

404201E,

9900612N

404048E,

9900488N 1.46 15.1 300,000 438,000

252 2930

Musyoki

Nzue

Mutweti Kisama Kivou 721241733 8.7

404287E,

9900682N

404201E,

9900612N 0.82 9.5 300,000 246,000

253 3201

Nguno

Kithae Kisama Kivou 734427435 1.8

404467E,

99008321N

404287E,

9900682N 1.73 96 300,000 519,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 22

Page 80: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

254 3105

Mwanzia

Kimanzi

Mwikuyu Kisama Kivou 718593454 2.6

404540E,

9900888N

404467E,

9900831N 0.69 26.7 300,000 207,000

255 3104

Daniel

Mutemi

Kimanzi Kisama Kivou

0725458819

/

0702784144 1.4

404570E,

9900914N

404540E,

9900888N 0.3 22.4 300,000 90,000

256 3102

David

Mulonzya

Kimanzi Kisama Kivou

0726542309

/

0701818661 4.1

404678E,

9901001N

404575E,

9900917N 0.98 24 300,000 294,000

257 3096

Solomon Keli

Mutunga

(sold to John

Mutua Kasi) Kisama Kivou

0727936740

/

0738464681 3.4

404726E,

9901040N

404678E,

9901001N 0.46 13.4 300,000 138,000

258 3009, 3008

Ngui

Kumanda Kisama Kivou 10.1

404812E,

9901111N

404725E,

9901040N 3.55 35.3 300,000 1,065,000

259 3097

Mwendwa

Mukungi

Makila(dece

ased) Katisya

Mwendwa Kisama Kivou 729973561 18.5

405073E,

9901325N

405013E,

9901277N 0.57 3.1 300,000 171,000

260 3097

Munyithya

Nzoka

(inherited by

Kilonzo

Mwangangi Kisama Kivou 702211336 18.5

405073E,

9901325N

405013E,

9901277N 0.57 3.1 300,000 171,000

261 *3317

John Kamau

Kisuva Kisama Kivou

0718336581

/

0724055825

405673E,

9901816N

405521E,

9901694N 0.51 300,000 153,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 23

Page 81: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

262 3215

Paul

Mwendwa

(bought from

Koki

Muneeni

Muthengi) Kisama Kivou 712874192 37.1

405759E,

9901888N

405679E,

9901823N 0.76 2.1 300,000 228,000

263 3216

Naomi

Mueni

Simba(buyer

) Robert

Mutia

Muthuka

Seller Kisama Kivou

0722550205

/

0736759332 24.7

405868E,

9901975N

405764E,

9901892N 0.99 4 300,000 297,000

264 3188

Musyoka

Mbovo

Ngonde Kisama Kivou 722117813 17.6

406249E,

9902289N

405967E,

9902057N 2.71 15.4 300,000 813,000

265 3424

Mutambu

Mbovo

Ngonde Kisama Kivou 716339156 19.5

406530E,

9902518N

406259E,

99002291N 2.62 13.5 300,000 786,000

266 3183

Francis

Kilonzi

Munyasya(D

eceased) Kisama Kivou 716339156 4.5

406649E,

9902618N

406530E,

9902518N 1.15 25.5 300,000 345,000

267 3182

Mwendwa

Ngare

Muthuku Kisama Kivou 2.5

406658E,

9902623N

406651E,

9902619N 0.06 2.5 300,000 18,000

268 1141

Mwasya

Kitheka Kathoka Endui 703299635 16.8

406660E,

9902624N

406800E,

9902757N 1.43 8.5 150,000 214,500

269 2813

Sammy

Mwendwa

Kasyima Kathoka Endui

0722273520

/

0722253872

406800E,

9902737N

406884E,

9902806N 0.81 150,000 121,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 24

Page 82: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

270 1220/1221

David

Musyoka

Kalai, Samuel

Muthui Kalai,

Joel Kilonzo

Kalai,

Hudson

Mwinzi Kalai Kathoka Endui 711862069 5.7

406884E,

9902806N

407008E,

9902910N 1.2 21.1 150,000 180,000

271 2282

Muthui

Mwinzi Kathoka Endui 711862069 1.8

407008E,

9902910N

407031E,

9902928N 0.22 11.9 150,000 33,000

272 2283

Johnstone

Wambua

Mwinzi Kathoka Endui 724759833 1

407031E,

9902928N

407061E,

9902955N 0.3 28.6 150,000 45,000

273 2281

Ndanu

Mwinzi Kathoka Endui 720801336 1.1

407061E,

9902955N

407089E,

9902976N 0.64 56.6 150,000 96,000

274 2279

Christopher

Mwoni

Musyoka Kathoka Endui 722996204 2.5

407089E,

9902976N

407132E,

9903012N 0.41 16.3 150,000 61,500

275 2277 Julius Kiambi Kathoka Endui 20

407132

E,9903012 N

407351

E,9903193 N. 2.1 10.5 150,000 315,000

276 2275

Kaunda

Kavuli Kathoka Endui

0722857519

/

0735557178 15.3

407351E,

9903193N

407449E,

9903270N 0.69 4.5 150,000 103,500

277 735

David

Mwanzia

Kyumbu Kathoka Endui 727720454 17.9 1 5.6 150,000 150,000

278 2274

Kavuli

Mutwango

Mengo Kathoka Endui

787412371/

0735557178 20.1

407449E,

9903270N

407512E,

9903323N 0.61 3 150,000 91,500

279 1530

Mulwa

Mwinzi

Kitonga Kathoka Endui

739815524/

0714916133 8.7

407512E,

9903323

407673E,

9903454N 1.54 17.6 150,000 231,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 25

Page 83: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

280 1529

Muthui

Mburu Kathoka Endui

0716287665

/

0788414094 5.7

407673E,

9903454N

407762E,

9903530N 0.87 15.2 150,000 130,500

281 688

Beatrice Muli

Mwanzia Kathoka Endui 739891159 3.8

407779E,

9903541N

407817E,

9903571N 0.36 9.4 150,000 54,000

282

776, 775,

773, 774,

787,786,

785, 784,

777, 788

John Kavulu

Musembi Kathoka Endui 738719013

407817E,

9903971N

407874E,

9903620N 0.56 150,000 84,000

283 1362

Eunice

Mbuvi

Musenya Kathoka Endui 702446711 3.2

407878E,

9903628

407923E,

9903662N 0.42 13.2 150,000 63,000

284 1366

Grace Kaki

Muatha Kathoka Endui 716172695 1.4

407923E,

9903663N

407987E,

9903708N 0.58 41.9 150,000 87,000

285 1367

Paul Ngei

Muatha Kathoka Endui 789669714

407987E,

9903709N

408015E,

9903735N 0.28 150,000 42,000

286 1368

Jacobate

Muthui

Muatha Kathoka Endui 716172695 0.6

408015E,

9903735N

408046E,

9903760N 0.29 49.4 150,000 43,500

287 1370

David

Mwendwa

Muatha Kathoka Endui

0712813800

/

0789669714 1.1

408046E,

9903760N

408088E,

9903793N 0.4 35.6 150,000 60,000

288 3218

Patrick

Muthui

Kiema Kathoka Endui 786760798 12.2

408088E,

9903793N

408206E,

9903891N 1.14 9.3 150,000 171,000

289 3219

Agnes Muli

Muthangya

Kiema Kathoka Endui 735504732 7.1

408206E,

9903891

408296E,

9903965N 0.86 12.1 150,000 129,000

290 3221

Dawson

Musila

Kiema Kathoka Endui 704279037

408296E,

9903965

408314E,

9903982N 0.18 150,000 27,000

291 3220 Ngoki Kiema Kathoka Endui 735504732 12.7

408314E,

9903983N

408332E,

9903995N 0.16 1.3 150,000 24,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 26

Page 84: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

292 Kathoka Endui

408332

E,9903995 N

408977

E,9904523 N. 150,000 0

293 2217

Musee

Mbitu/ Mbisi

Mbitu Kathoka Endui

731216933/

0737063205 4.8

408977E,

9904523N

409073E,

9904500N 0.91 18.9 150,000 136,500

294 2186

Lydia

Nthambi

Mutemi Kathoka Endui 710161171

408338E,

9903999

408499E,

9904131N 1.54 150,000 231,000

295 2594

Charles

Mumu

Mutinda Kathoka Endui 737112441 9.7

408499E,

9904131N

408752E,

9904341N 2.44 25.1 150,000 366,000

296 L.R Missing

Victor

Mwaniki

Mutinda Kathoka Endui 703612910

408752E,

9904341N

408801E,

9904377N 0.45 150,000 67,500

297 2180

Charles

Mumu

Mutinda Kathoka Endui 737112441 11.9

408801E,

99043771N

408977E,

9904523N 1.69 14.3 150,000 253,500

298 2178

Simon

Mutemi

Mutinda Kathoka Endui

721595908/

0710161171 7.4

409084E,

9904606N

409135E,

9904650N 0.5 6.8 150,000 75,000

299 L.R Missing

Andrew

Kilonzi Kathoka Endui 722841501

409135E,

9904650N

409259E,

9904751N 1.19 150,000 178,500

300 Kilonzi Simon Kathoka Endui

409073

E,9904599 N.

409265

E,9904759 N. 1.86 150,000 279,000

301 1487

David

Mwanzia

Maithya Kathoka Endui

0710568382

/

0789636716

409265E,

9904759N

409337E,

9904820N 0.13 150,000 19,500

302 2222

Grace Ndanu

Kitema Kathoka Endui 734746622 2.3

409346E,

9904824N

409427E,

9904892N 0.78 34.7 150,000 117,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 27

Page 85: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

303 2224

Mumbi Muli

Muindi&

Anna

Kasyoka

Munyithya Kathoka Endui

0710568382

/

0789636716 1.6

409427E,

9904892N

409439E,

9904905N 0.13 7.9 150,000 19,500

304 2225

Muema

Kyaka Kathoka Endui 710941148

409439E,

9904905N

409494E,

9904947N 0.51 150,000 76,500

305 3176

Titus Musila

Kitheka Kathoka Endui 786314587

409494E,

9904947N

409640E,

9905068N 1.31 150,000 196,500

306 2248

Mwende

Musyimi

Muindi Kathoka Endui

0789919941

/

0735701268 17.7

409648E,

9905070N

409886E,

9905266N 2.28 12.9 150,000 342,000

307 2250

Joseph

Mutua Nzavi Kathoka Endui 736770749

409886E,

9905266N

410004E,

9905366N 2 150,000 300,000

308 1468

Tom Mwinzi

Ngunu Kathoka Endui 736563272 4.5

410009E,

9905366N

410135E,

9905442N 1.09 24.1 150,000 163,500

309

1459/1460/1

461/142

Benedict

Bernard Kaka Kathoka Endui 729698391

410166E,

9905462N

410862E,

9905850N 5.91 150,000 886,500

310 1449

Siri Mulatya

Tomu Kathoka Endui 786211979 47

0410864E,

9905848N

0410988E,

9905118N 0.49 1.1 150,000 73,500

311 1454

Mbala Nguli

Moki Kathoka Endui 786838075 72.9

0410988E,

9905918N

0411154E,

9906009N 1.4 1.9 150,000 210,000

312 1448

Paul Kimanzi

Mutemi Kathoka Endui 735748536 7.7

0411161E,

9906013N

0411390E,

9906141N 0.85 11 150,000 127,500

313 L.R Missing

Bonface

Mwangangi

Munyasya Kathoka Endui

0715826091

/073821144

6/07138783

96

0411390E,

9906141N

0411550E,

996230N 1.36 150,000 204,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 28

Page 86: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

314 1673

Ngui Musili

King'ao

(Deceased) Kathoka Endui

735241576/

731008526(

Wife)

0411559E,

9906235N

0411650E,

9906286N 0.77 150,000 115,500

315 1653

Mwendwa

Musyimi Kathoka Endui 702489982

0411650E,

9906286N

0411959E,

9906458N 2.62 150,000 393,000

316 1677

Jones

Muthengi

Mukuri Kathoka Endui

0733463067

/

0712965989 8.6

411968E,

9906460N

412134E,

9906554N 1.41 16.4 150,000 211,500

317 1769/3184

Susan

Mwikali

Munyoki Katitika Endui 734974585

412154E,

9906554N

412432E,

9906722N 2.71 150,000 406,500

318

Not

registered

Mulyungi

Kivunzi Katitika Endui

0717634464

/

0734974585

(Neighbour)

412432E,

9906722N

412469E,

9906740N 0.3 150,000 45,000

319 1749

Stephen

Nguli

Mutune Katitika Endui 736109843 43.9

413004E,

9907038N

413139E,

9907112N 1.14 2.6 150,000 171,000

320 1761

Kiviu Mutua

Mulinge Katitika Endui

0710527975

/

0729481967

413139E,

9907112N

413362E,

9907236N 1.89 150,000 283,500

321 1914

Elijah

Kanyange Katitika Endui

0733724047

/737686833

(Wife)

413364E,

9907238N

413433E,

9907276N 0.58 150,000 87,000

322 2285

Sammy

Mwendwa

Kasyima Kathoka Endui

722273520/

0722253872 1.9 0.3 16.1 150,000 45,000

323 735

David

Mwanzia

Kyumbu Kathoka Endui 727720454 17.9 1 5.6 150,000 150,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 29

Page 87: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

324 1470

Tom Mwinzi

Ngunu Kathoka Endui

0739616201

/

0705848440 0.21 150,000 31,500

325 L.R Missing

Anthony

Mutia

Mwandikwa Kathoka Endui 720844960 2.1 150,000 315,000

326

Misplaced

L.R

Kyalo,

Mbua,Mwen

ga Mutambu Katitika Endui 720080812

0413623E,

9907382N

0413433E,

9907277N 1.45 150,000 217,500

327 1915 Kalekye Muli Katitika Endui

0725586324(

Daughter)/0

734775920(C

ousin) 6.6

0413724E,

9907455N

0413623E,

9907382N 5 75.9 150,000 750,000

328

Mwendwa

Mathuka Katitika Endui

0413724E,

9907455N

0413610E,

9907390N 0.97 150,000 145,500

329 L.R Missing

John Mutemi

Kisombo Katitika Endui 736109843

0413745E,

9907433N

0413625E,

9907367N 1.01 150,000 151,500

330

Misplaced

L.R

Matheka

Mbalo Katitika Endui 735923534

0413830E,

9907497

0413841E,

9907488N 0.11 150,000 16,500

331

Misplaced

L.R

Matheko

Mbalo Endui 0 150,000 0

332

Misplaced

L.R

Kyalo

Mutambu,

Mbua,Mwen

ga Mutambu Katitika Endui 720080812

0414514E,

9907877N

0413830E,

9907497N 1.61 150,000 241,500

333

Musyimi

Mbuvi Katitika Endui

414749

E,990807 N

414564

E,9907905 N. 150,000 0

334 lost l.r

Jackson

Musili Matiti Katitika Endui 736109843

0414564E,

9907905N

0414521E,

9907881N 0.36 150,000 54,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 30

Page 88: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

335 L.R Missing

Bernard

Mwaniki

Muthui Katitika Endui

0726553678

/

0786212002

0414858E,

9908068N

0414749E,

9908007N 0.93 150,000 139,500

336 2110

Simon

Maluki

Mutemi Katitika Endui 724387478

0414946E,

9908133N

0414867E,

9108073N 0.73 150,000 109,500

337

Simon

Mutemi Katitika Endui

414976 E,

9908133 N.

414867 E,

990873 N. 150,000 0

338 2109

Jonathan

Mutie

Mutemi Katitika Endui

0710158036

/078811808

6

0415172E,

9908243N

0414976E,

9908133N 0.51 150,000 76,500

339 2103

Nashon Thuo

Musee Katitika Endui 736433834

0415327E,

9908328N

0415172E,

9908243N 1.31 150,000 196,500

340 2010

Ndumbu

Mutisya

Musili Katitika Endui

0786528908

/

0719399016

0415753E,

9908566N

0415566E,

9908462N 3.71 150,000 556,500

341 2005

Musila

Mutisya Katitika Endui 787220647

0415995E,

9908700N

0415756E,

9908567N 2.03 150,000 304,500

342 2007

Ndusya

Mutisya Katitika Endui 786528908

0416066E,

9908740N

0415995E,

9908700N 1.24 150,000 186,000

343 L.R Missing

Mwathi

Ndinda Katitika Endui

0701576943

/

0703632486

0416246E,

9908839N

0416066E,

9908740N 1.52 150,000 228,000

344 2000

Nicodemus

Kasee Matiti Katitika Endui

0786528908

/

0718533670

0416409E,

9908930N

0416246E,

9908839N 4 150,000 600,000

345 1999

Benjamin

Kitheka

Muthoka Katitika Endui 710376888

0416465E,

9908961N

0416409E,

9908930N 2 150,000 300,000

346 2000

Nicodemus

Kasee Matiti Katitika Endui

0786528908

/

0718533670

0416522E,

9908992N

0416465E,

9908961N 2 150,000 300,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 31

Page 89: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

347 2003

John

Wambua

Munywoki Katitika Endui

0734313144

/

0786528908

/

0724096514

0416636E,

9909056N

0416522E,

9908992N 3 150,000 450,000

348 1952

James

Masauru

Muthui Katitika Endui 718275830

0416840E,

9909169N

0416636E,

9909056N 1.73 150,000 259,500

349 1956

Joseph

Munyoki

Mwangae Katitika Endui 729279316

0416942E,

9909227N

0416840E,

9909169N 0.87 150,000 130,500

350 1749

Stephen

Nguli

Mutune Katitika Endui 1.14 150,000 171,000

351 1964

Maluki

Syethoka

(Divided to

Mwenga

Maluki &

Kwilekya

Maluki) Katitika Endui 733437851

0417296E,

9909424N

0419642E,

9909227N 14.47 150,000 2,170,500

352

Not

registered

Emily

Kalumu

Mwinzi Mwasuma Nguni 716706695

0417389E,

9909474N,

0417300E,

9909425N 0.75 150,000 112,500

353

Not

registered

Munyoki

Mwangangi Mwasuma Nguni 739139663

0417529E,

9909553N

0417389E,

9909474N 1.19 150,000 178,500

354

Not

registered

Maluki

Syethoka

(Divided to

Mbila

Maluki,

David Maluki

& Mwikali

Maluki) Mwasuma Nguni

0735008043

/

0734679315

0417917E,

99099768N

0417529E,

9909553N 3.29 150,000 493,500

355

Not

registered

Dorcas

Kenyatta Mwasuma Nguni 724228443

0418165E,

9909906N

0417917E,

9909768N 2.1 150,000 315,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 32

Page 90: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

356

Not

registered

Munyoki

Mwendwa Mwasuma Nguni

0710141225

/

0733709379

0418180E,

9909914N

0418165E,

9909906N 0.13 150,000 19,500

357

Not

registered

Mutua

Munyasya Nguni Nguni 786300985

0418529E,

9910108N

0418180E,

9909914N 2.96 150,000 444,000

358

Not

registered

Syothome

Muthangya

Mbaute Mwasuma Nguni 727800049

0418727E,

9910216N

0418529E,

9910108N 1.67 150,000 250,500

359

Not

registered Unknown Mwasuma Nguni

0418891E,

9910309N

418723E,

9910216N 150,000 0

360

Not

registered

Jacob Musee

Muthangya Mwasuma Nguni 725611995

0419292E,

9910510N

0418897E,

9910312N 3.28 150,000 492,000

361

Not

registered

Ngali

Mutembei Mwasuma Nguni 712556867

0419374E,

9910544N

0419292E,

9910510N 0.45 150,000 67,500

362

Not

registered

Justus

Stanely

Wambua Mwasuma Nguni 727557717

0419571E,

9910625N

0419374E,

9910544N 1.58 150,000 237,000

363

Not

registered

Muthui

Mwanzia Mwasuma Nguni 727557717

0419685E,

9910672N

0419571E,

9910625N 0.91 150,000 136,500

364

Not

registered

Joel Kiseu

Mulwa Mwasuma Nguni 722448283

0419712E,

9910666N

0419687E,

9910657N 0.2 150,000 30,000

365

Not

registered

Kilonzi

Kitundu Mwasuma Nguni 708483716

0419853E,

9910741N

0419685E,

9910672N 1.35 150,000 202,500

366

Not

registered

Moses

Mulandi

Kang'ite Mwasuma Nguni 722662932

0420082E,

9910835N

0419853E,

9910741N 1.83 150,000 274,500

367

Not

registered Ngui Kiteme Mwasuma Nguni

0720705188

/

0728285344

040318E,

9910932N

0420082E,

9910835N 1.2 150,000 180,000

368

Not

registered

Dennis

Musomba

Ngui Mwasuma Nguni 731577098

0420529E,

9911019N

0420318E,

9910935N 1.69 150,000 253,500

369

Not

registered Ngei Mwoki Mwasuma Nguni 718356842

0421071E,

9911242N

0420529E,

9911019N 4.34 150,000 651,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 33

Page 91: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

370

Not

registered

Fredrick

Siasa

Munyithya Mwasuma Nguni 728797977

0421448E,

9911396N

0421193E,

9911291N 2.04 150,000 306,000

371

Not

registered

Japheth

Musili

Musunza Mwasuma Nguni

733773428,

723942534

0421654E,

9911480N

0421448E,

9911396N 2 150,000 300,000

372

Not

registered

John Kilonzi

Mangole Mwasuma Nguni

0729530271

/

0737774810

4 0.75 150,000 112,500

373

Not

registered

Monicah

Ngovu Mwasuma Nguni 7.06E+09

0422536/

9911842N

0422419E,

9911795N 0.93 150,000 139,500

374

Not

registered

John Mutua

Munyoki Mwasuma Nguni 710597329

0422639E,

991885N

0422536E,

9911842N 0.83 150,000 124,500

375

Not

registered

Jeremiah

Nganika

Mavuti Mwasuma Nguni 727807192

0422778E,

9911942N

0422639E,

9911885N 1.11 150,000 166,500

376

Not

registered

District

Officer's

Residence Kyavyuka Nguni

0714942123(

Chief Nguni,

Mula Simon)

0422959E,

9912016N

0422778E,

9911942N 1.59 150,000 238,500

377

Not

registered

Muthakye

Nduvoi Kyavyuka Nguni 728747729

0423442E,

9912215N

0423296E,

9912155N 1.17 150,000 175,500

378

Not

registered

Sammy

Kitheka Mwasuma Nguni 723255671

423589E,

9912276N

423605E,

9912280N 0.5 150,000 75,000

379

Not

registered Simon Mutie Mwasuma Nguni

0731127810

/

0713884950

423605E,

9912280N

423846E,

9912382N 1.95 150,000 292,500

380

Not

registered

Peter

Kithusya Mwasuma Nguni

423846E,

9912382N

423937E,

9912420N 0.73 150,000 109,500

381

Not

registered David Kioko Mwasuma Nguni 715895527

423954E,

9912426N

424205E,

9912526N 2 150,000 300,000

382

Not

registered

Joshua

Mbauti Kioko Mwasuma Nguni 704280736

424204E,

9912526N

424419E,

9912618N 1.24 150,000 186,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 34

Page 92: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

383

Not

registered

Sammy

Musyoka

Musili Mwasuma Nguni

0701293826

/

0723755561

424419E,

9912618N

424600E,

9912692N 1.45 150,000 217,500

384

Not

registered

Joseph

Musingila

Musili Mwasuma Nguni 719150969

424600E,

9912692N

424608E,

9912694N 0.99 150,000 148,500

385

Not

registered

Daniel Mengi

Kioko Mwasuma Nguni 700769158

424690E,

9912722N

424835E,

9912786N 1.24 150,000 186,000

386

Not

registered

Musingila

Musili Mwasuma Nguni 719150969

424858E,

9912798N

425161E,

9912962N 2.55 150,000 382,500

387

Not

registered

Theophilus

Mutuku

Mutinda Mwasuma Nguni 729018944 0.92 150,000 138,000

388

Not

registered

Richard

Mutie Musili Mwasuma Nguni

0721736119

/

0733647235 0.8 100,000 80,000

389

Not

registered

Samson

Kioko

Musumbi Kakunike Mbuvu 0.12 100,000 12,000

390

Not

registered

Robert Kioko

Mwenga Kakunike Mbuvu 712648758

425161E,

9912962N

425294E,

9913046N 1.17 100,000 117,000

391

Not

registered

Simon

Muuthu

Kizitu Kakunike Mbuvu '0715239775

425494E,

9913146N

425465E,

9913154 0.24 100,000 24,000

392

Not

registered

James

Nzomo

Muasya Kakunike Mbuvu

0728630359

/

0724116436

425465E,

9913154N

425674E,

9913284N 1.82 100,000 182,000

393

Not

registered

Philip

Mwangangi Kakunike Mbuvu

0726657342

/

0726835618

425674E,

9913284N

425800E,

9913364N 10 100,000 1,000,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 35

Page 93: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

394

Not

registered

James

Nzomo

Muasya Kakunike Mbuvu

0728630359

/

0724116436

425800E,

9913364N

0426105E,

9913555N 2.67 100,000 267,000

395

Not

registered

Martha

Telesia

Mwasya Kakunike Mbuvu

0727977519

/

0733618783

0426561E,

99135540N

0426306E,

9913681N 1.04 100,000 104,000

396

Not

registered

Mwende

Kinyambu

Mulu Kakunike Mbuvu

0712953959

(Neighbour)

0426306E,

9913681N

0426105E,

9913555N 1.76 100,000 176,000

397

Not

registered

Samson

Kusina

Musyoka Kakunike Mbuvu 712953959

0426628E,

9913883N

0426560E,

9913840N 0.6 100,000 60,000

398

Not

registered

John

Musyoki

Mwambui Kakunike Mbuvu 712953959

0426726E,

9913945N

0426628E,

9913883N 0.86 100,000 86,000

399

Not

registered

Sammy

Mwangangi

Musyoki;

sold to

Jefferson

Ngui Kiruru Kakunike Mbuvu

0721154496

/

0727774056

0426809E,

9913990N

0426752E,

9913961N 0.44 100,000 44,000

400

Not

registered

Mulwa

Munyasya

(deceased) Kakunike Mbuvu

0715745625

/

0704677223

0427022E,

9914023N

0426809E,

9913990N 1.6 100,000 160,000

401

Not

registered

James

Musaili

Mumo Kakunike Mbuvu

0727977505

/

0707651570

0427130E,

9914055N

0427091E,

9914049N 0.29 100,000 29,000

402

Not

registered

Wambua

Mbuli Kakunike Mbuvu

0726922693

/071734118

6

0427144E,

9914042

0427118E,

9914038N 0.19 100,000 19,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 36

Page 94: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

403

Not

registered

Sammy

Mwangangi

Musyoki Kakunike Mbuvu

0714577543

/

0712337916

0427134E,

9914037N

0727022E,

9914023N 0.84 100,000 84,000

404

Not

registered

Fredrick

Mulatya

Musee Kakunike Mbuvu

0725471335

/072835966

9

0427262E,

9914060N

0427144E,

9914042N 0.87 100,000 87,000

405

Not

registered

Annah

Kalundi

Mwovi Kakunike Mbuvu

0712311054

/

0715792537

0427610E,

9914114N

0427262E,

9914060N 2.61 100,000 261,000

406

Not

registered

John

Mwangangi

Mwinzi Kakunike Mbuvu

0710159422(

Wife)/07033

12072(Son)

0427723E,

9914132

0427610E,

9914114 0.85 100,000 85,000

407

Not

registered

Solomon

Musyoka

Musumbi Kakunike Mbuvu 726175082

427732E,

9914132N

427862E,

9914154N 0.99 100,000 99,000

408

Not

registered

Joseph

Musingila

Muthoka Kakunike Mbuvu 720315447

427862E,

9914154N

428040E,

9914182N 1.34 100,000 134,000

409

Not

registered

Peter

Munyasya

Musumbi Kakunike Mbuvu 707116104

428040E,

9914182N

428132E,

9914194N 1.24 100,000 124,000

410

Not

registered

Nzomo

Muthoka

Mwenga Kakunike Mbuvu 723555751

428132E,

9914194N

428313E,

9914222N 1.36 100,000 136,000

411

Not

registered John Nzomo Kakunike Mbuvu 724667196

428313E,

9914222N

428491E,

9914252N 1.34 100,000 134,000

412

Not

registered

Samson

Mutwii

Musya Kakunike Mbuvu

0713036526

/

0726544894

428491E,

9914252N

428786E,

9914296N 2.21 100,000 221,000

413

Not

registered

Isaac

Mulungu Kakunike Mbuvu 703514089

428786E,

9914296N

428907E,

9914316N 0.91 100,000 91,000

414

Not

registered

Joseph

Mbuku

Mukuni Kakunike Mbuvu 714376734

428907E,

9914316N

429019E,

9914334N 0.84 100,000 84,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 37

Page 95: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

415

Not

registered

Titus Ukulo

Munuve Kakunike Mbuvu 734679123

429019E,

9914334N

429154E,

9914352N 1.01 100,000 101,000

416

Not

registered

Sarah Matei

Maangi Kakunike Mbuvu 714376743

429154E,

9914352N

429355E,

9914384N 1.51 100,000 151,000

417

Not

registered

Mary

Syombua

Malombe Kakunike Mbuvu

0710672621

/

0703477692

429557E,

9914416N

429625E,

9914428N 0.51 100,000 51,000

418

Not

registered

Mutinda

Mukovi Kakunike Mbuvu 717138800

429625E,

9914428N

429699E,

9914436N 1 100,000 100,000

419

Not

registered

Musyoki

Musyoka Kakunike Mbuvu 726179372

429699E,

9914436N

429801E,

9914452N 2 100,000 200,000

420

Not

registered

Musyimi

Musyoka

Muyanga Kakunike Mbuvu 714233199

429355E,

9914384N

429557E,

9914416N 6.48 100,000 648,000

421

Not

registered

Philip

Mutemi

Kirungu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0710298147

/

0720492758

0430337E,

9914536N

0430195E,

994514N 1.06 100,000 106,000

422

Not

registered

Kimwele

Masila Mbuvu Mbuvu 717327438

0430195E,

9914514N

0429801E,

9914452N 2.95 100,000 295,000

423

Not

registered

John Muthui

Kimanzi Mbuvu mbuvu

0720355820

/

0724470478

0430441E,

99914552N

0430337E,

9914536N 5 100,000 500,000

424

Not

registered

Dorcas

Kayumya

Syanda Mbuvu Mbuvu

0711817886

/

0713415695

0430593E,

9914576N

0430441E,

9914552N 1.14 100,000 114,000

425

Not

registered

Peter Musee

Mbindyo Mbuvu Mbuvu 710199449

0431257E,

9914678N

0430598E,

9914567N 5 100,000 500,000

426

Not

registered

Philip

Mutemi

Kirungu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0720492758

/

0710298147

0431548E,

9914723N

0431257E,

9914678N 1.06 100,000 106,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 38

Page 96: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

427

Not

registered

Simon Musili

Mutisya Mbuvu Mbuvu

0720118221

/

0713801602

0431664E,

9914741N

0431654E,

9914740N 3 100,000 300,000

428

Not

registered

Bonface

Mutuku

Mulwa Mbuvu Mbuvu 0714660226'

0432145E,

9914793N 2.5 100,000 250,000

429

Not

registered

Mutunga

Mbindyo

Kimwele Mbuvu Mbuvu 708466854

0432701E,

9914822N

0432617E,

9914815N 0.62 100,000 62,000

430

Not

registered

Mativo

Kitungu

Kiluvu Mbuvu Mbuvu 728083631

0432789E,

9914843N

0432145E,

9914793N 4.79 100,000 479,000

431

Not

registered

Kithumula B

joint Group

Dam Mbuvu Mbuvu 703224967

0432855E,

9914863N

0432821E,

9914861N 0.25 100,000 25,000

432

Not

registered

Kaleve

Mutua Mbuvu Mbuvu

0715695815

/

0717915071

0432789E,

9914855N

0432789E,

9914843N 1.11 100,000 111,000

433

Not

registered

Dickson

Mutia Nzuku Mbuvu Mbuvu

0715695815

/071093816

6

0432985E,

9914859N

0432938E,

9914855N 0.35 100,000 35,000

434

Not

registered

Mbuthye

Musili

Mukungi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0700728358

/ 070814214

0433209E,

9914877

0432985E,

9914859 1.67 100,000 167,000

435

Not

registered

Joseph

Mutie Mbuvi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0713056690

/071445491

7

(Neighbour)

0433278E,

9914868

0433212E,

9914862N 1.23 100,000 123,000

436

Not

registered

Jane Ngina

Mulwa Mbuvu Mbuvu 0712299956' 0 100,000 0

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 39

Page 97: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

437

Not

registered

Ndike Mbuvi

sold to

Josphat

Mutata

Makau Mbuvu Mbuvu 723665532

0433573E,

9914906N

0433362E,

9914888N 1.57 100,000 157,000

438

Not

registered

Maluki

Mukuthu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0716524896

/

0705358889 0 100,000 0

439

Not

registered

Daniel

Muthui

Musingu Mbuvu Mbuvu

0720765697

/

0700171323

0434005E,

9914944N

0433932E,

9914935N 0.98 100,000 98,000

440

Not

registered

Syengo

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu 71329542

434076E,

9914944N

434203E,

9914956N 0.95 100,000 95,000

441

Not

registered

Mwende

Mwove Mbuvu Mbuvu 717343216

434203E,

9914956N

434511E,

9914980N 4 100,000 400,000

442

Not

registered

Mutei

Musyoka Mbuvu Mbuvu 723909948

434511E,

9914980N

434753E,

9915000N 3 100,000 300,000

443

Not

registered

Mulwa

Mutie Mbuvu Mbuvu 708863416

434753E,

9915000N

435274E,

9915042N 5 100,000 500,000

444

Not

registered

Muthui

Mutemi

(Mary

Kamene

Muthui-

Wife) Mbuvu Mbuvu 714935560

435274E,

9915042N

435417E,

9914941N 1.33 100,000 133,000

445

Not

registered

Daniel

Kimwele

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0710618996

/072772341

5

435417E,

9914941N

435717E,

9914699N 2.86 100,000 286,000

446

Not

registered

Nicodemus

Mutheki

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0713295482

/072725105

6

435717E,

9914699N

435967E,

9914521N 2.26 100,000 226,000

447

Not

registered

Velesi

Martha

Mung'ang'a Mbuvu Mbuvu 720094245

435973E,

9914515N

436450E,

9913998N 5.2 100,000 520,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 40

Page 98: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

448

Not

registered

Mwendwa

Mung'ang'a Mbuvu Mbuvu 729568640

436450E,

9913998N

436656E,

9913774N 2.26 100,000 226,000

449

Not

registered

Gilbert

Mutisya

Mung'ang'a Mbuvu Mbuvu 722709040

436656E,

9913774N

436761E,

9913668N 1.11 100,000 111,000

450

Not

registered Muthui Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu 720911333

436761E,

9913668N

436786E,

9913642N 1.74 100,000 174,000

451

Not

registered

Daniel

Mutua Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu

0725508117

/

0774098069

436945E,

9913632N

437117E,

9913338N 1.72 100,000 172,000

452

Not

registered

William Kalui

Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu 724269744

437117E,

9913338N

437290E,

9913172N 1.59 100,000 159,000

453

Not

registered Muthui Nzue Mbuvu Mbuvu 720911333

437290E,

9913172

437461E,

9913010N 0.27 100,000 27,000

454

Not

registered

Francis

Kilonzo

Mutyanzei Mbuvu Mbuvu

0729679719

/

0729270337

437461E,

9913010N

437583E,

9912896N 1.24 100,000 124,000

455

Not

registered

Andrew

Kisenga

Mengi sold

to ; Titus

Kyaai

Mutemi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0723691373

/

0726403631

437583E,

9912896N

437713E,

9912776N 1.31 100,000 131,000

456

Not

registered

Andrew

Kisenga

Mengi Mbuvu Mbuvu 725230894

0438450E,

9912083N

0438122E,

9912391N 3.33 100,000 333,000

457

Not

registered

Francis

Kilonzo

Mutyanzei Mbuvu Mbuvu

0729679719

/072927033

7

0438122E,

9912391N

0437976E,

9912529N 2.18 100,000 218,000

458

Not

registered

Joseph Nzili

Mengi Mwalali Imba 710391943

0437976E,

9912529N

0437860E,

9912636N 1.17 100,000 117,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 41

Page 99: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

459

Not

registered

Lena Mutanu

Kasina Mbuvu Mbuvu 725103762

0438581E,

9911960N

0438790E,

9911766N 4.06 100,000 406,000

460

Not

registered

Moses

Mbindi Mui Mbuvu Mbuvu

0714394351

/

0700078547

0438790E,

9911766N

0438743E,

9911808N 1.59 100,000 159,000

461

Not

registered

John Mutua

Mbindi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0727595408

/

0727047511

0438743E,

9911808N

0438561E,

9911979N 1.85 100,000 185,000

462

Not

registered

Timothy

Mwaniki

Mbindi Mbuvu Mbuvu

0714594540

/

0710690360

0439126E,

9911450N

0438971E,

99115956N 1.58 100,000 158,000

463

Not

registered Nzasu Mbuvi Mbuvu Mbuvu 725508117

4386756E,

9913642N

436945E,

9913485N 1.6 100,000 160,000

464

Not

registered

Joster Willy

Mbindi Mbuvu Mbuvu 723059382

0439271E,

9911315N

0439126E,

99114650N 1.55 100,000 155,000

465

Not

registered

Muthili

Muinde Mbuvu Mbuvu 700014797 0.5 100,000 50,000

466

Not

registered

Mutisya

Kanyuku Ukasi Ukasi

0712513771

/071940356

7 (Son)

0439373E,

9911218N

0439271E,

9911315N 1.04 100,000 104,000

467

Not

registered

John Musili

Mwendwa Mwalali Ukasi 711318220

439373E,

9911218N

439445E,

9911151N 0.5 100,000 50,000

468

Not

registered

John Makau

Ivulu Mwalali Ukasi

0726496483

/

0726598398

439452E,

9911143N

439805E,

9910814N 2.3 100,000 230,000

469

Not

registered

Joseph

Mutunga

Kalua Ukasi Ukasi

0727930753

/

0715872865

439805E,

9910814N

439884E,

9910740N 0.54 100,000 54,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 42

Page 100: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

470

Not

registered

John Makau

Ivulu Mwalali Ukasi

0726496483

/

0726598398

439884E,

9910740N

440218E,

9910425N 2.4 100,000 240,000

471

Not

registered

Thomas

Toma

Ndengu Mwalali Imba 723096493

440218E,

9910425N

440372E,

9910282N 1.06 100,000 106,000

472

Not

registered

Darius

Muthui

Mwasya Mwalali Imba

0724636404

/

0705757827

440372E,

9910282N

440742E,

9909936N 2.54 100,000 254,000

473

Not

registered

Muthui

Mwenga Ukasi Ukasi

0700018766

/

0704490863

440751E,

9909926N

440821E,

9909861N 0.5 100,000 50,000

474

Not

registered

Darius

Muthui

Mwasya Ukasi Ukasi

0724636404

/

0705757827

440821E,

9909861N

441027E,

9909668N 1.4 100,000 140,000

475

Not

registered

Saddy Saidi

Kilungu Ukasi Ukasi 721460237

441027E,

9909668N

441141E,

9909563N 1.15 100,000 115,000

476

Not

registered

Kilungu

Mbaluka

Mutinda Ukasi Ukasi 726035240

441141E,

9909563N

441419E,

9904300N 2.84 100,000 284,000

477

Not

registered Koli Nzenge Mwalali Imba

0710898132

/

0716262293

441419E,

9909300N

441487E,

9909237N 0.69 100,000 69,000

478

Not

registered

Julius Ngei

Mutinda Mwalali Imba

0725588362

/

0721133778

441487E,

9909237N

441954E,

9908801N 3.23 100,000 323,000

479

Not

registered

Kilungu

Mbaluka

Mutinda Ukasi Ukasi 726035239

441954E,

9908801N

442133E,

9908632N 1.82 100,000 182,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 43

Page 101: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

480

Not

registered

Peter Musee

Kilungu Ukasi Ukasi

0710222921

/

0716059753

442133E,

9908632N

442374E,

9908406N 2.45 100,000 245,000

481

Not

registered

Joseph

Mwendwa

Kilungu Ukasi Ukasi 721404157

442374E,

9908406N

442444E,

990833N 0.72 100,000 72,000

482

Not

registered

Daniel

Mulwa

Kimwele Mwalali Imba 711663633

442444E,

9908339N

442682E,

9908117N 2.41 100,000 241,000

483

Not

registered

Justus

Mwanzia

Kimwele Mwalali Imba

0727508213

/

0727680502

442682E,

9908117N

443034E,

9907787N 3.58 100,000 358,000

484

Not

registered

Christina

Nyamai

Mwalya Ukasi Ukasi

0703577875

/

0727680502

443039E,

9907783N

443410E,

9907435N 2.03 100,000 203,000

485

Not

registered

John Kitheka

Mwalya &

Denis Mutiso

Mwalya Ukasi Ukasi 703577875

443250E,

9907583N

443410E,

9907435N 0.55 100,000 55,000

486

Not

registered

Kalunda

Syengo

Mwanzia Mwalali Imba

0721702590

/

0732764990

443410E,

9907435N

443858E,

9907015N 3.11 100,000 311,000

487

Not

registered

Musembi

Kithongo(dec

eased)

Mwikali

Musembi Ukasi Ukasi

0708764889

/

0729540875

/

0713903585

443858E,

9907015N

444142E,

9906751N 1.95 100,000 195,000

488

Not

registered

Kunzu

Muukulu

Ngula Mwalali Imba 724922809

444142E,

9906751N

444354E,

9906551N 1.48 100,000 148,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 44

Page 102: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

489

Not

registered

Simon Meru

Mwokolo Mwalali Imba

0723164482

/

0701417337

444483E,

9906430N

444971E,

9905973N 3.38 100,000 338,000

490

Not

registered

Joseph

Mwema

Nyalu Mwalali Imba 739744557

444971E,

9905973N

445007E,

9905940N 0.24 100,000 24,000

491

Not

registered

James

Kimanzi

Matele Mwalali Imba

0710645598

/

0735320905

445007E,

9905940N

445317E,

9905785 1.15 100,000 115,000

492

Not

registered Kyuta Nzaasa Mwalali Imba

445317E,

9905785N

445523E,

9905786N 1.53 100,000 153,000

493

Not

registered

Malimali

Mbuluku Mwalali Imba

445523E,

9905786N

446392E,

9905789N 6.44 150,000 966,000

494

Not

registered

Jeremiah

Mutua

Mulatya Mwalali Imba

722335276/

0716034735

/

0718334253

446392E,

9905789N

446722E,

9905810N 2.4 100,000 240,000

495

Not

registered

Patrick

Muukulu

Nzuki Mwalali Imba

0710293047

/

0710807748

444354E,

9906551N

444483E,

9906430N 1.31 100,000 131,000

496

Not

registered

Stephen

Somba Tuli Mwalali Imba

0713166841

/

0723178553

/

0710822077

446720E,

9905788N

447467E,

9905790N 5.54 100,000 554,000

497

Not

registered

Priscila

Musilu

Maluki Imba Ukasi 724138668

447467E,

9905790N

448282E,

9905793N 6.04 100,000 604,000

498

Not

registered

Tutu

Mwandikwa

Mutunga Mwalali Imba

0702886447

/

0731447078

448282E,

9905793N

448507E,

9905793N 1.67 100,000 167,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 45

Page 103: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

499

Not

registered

James

Mwandikwa

Mutunga Mwalali Imba

0731447078

/

0702886447

448507E,

9905793N

448803E,

9905794N 2.19 100,000 219,000

500

Not

registered

Mwendwa

Mutemi Mwalali Imba

0724799843

/

0728223937

449393E,

9905781N

448808E,

9905782N 4.33 150,000 649,500

501

Not

registered

Mutemi

Musyoka

Kula Mwalali Imba

0711719970

/

0712739695

449493E,

9905782N

449397E,

9905782N 0.71 150,000 106,500

502

Not

registered

Musyoka

Mulingwa Mwalali Imba

0733543388

/ 072994309

449905E

9905782N

449493E,

9905782N 3.05 150,000 457,500

503

Not

registered

Mulonzya

Kioko Mwalali Imba 734180689

450062E,

9905781N

449928E,

9905781N 0.99 150,000 148,500

504

Not

registered

Bonface

Mutuku

Mulwa Mwalali Imba 710628030

450569E,

9905780N

450062E,

9905781N 3.76 150,000 564,000

505

Not

registered

Duncan

Mumo

Kimwele Mwalali Imba

0716034752

/

0722905216

450657E,

9905780N

450876E,

9905780N 1.62 150,000 243,000

506

Not

registered

Musau

Mutunga Mwalali Imba 707942778

450919E,

9905794N

450873E,

9905795N 0.34 150,000 51,000

507

Not

registered

Nzambii

Ndumu Mwalali Imba

0787422664

/

0739615172

452439E,

9906580N

450657E,

9905780N 15.04 150,000 2,256,000

508

Not

registered

Kimanzi

Masila

(Deceased)

Kasyoka

Kimanzi Mwalali Imba

0727091780

/

0707664719

452507E,

9906622N

452443E,

9906581N 0.56 150,000 84,000

509

Not

registered

John Mutua

Mbai Mwalali Imba 710292715

452563E,

9906656N

452507E,

9906622N 0.49 150,000 73,500

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 46

Page 104: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

510

Not

registered

Joseph

Munyoki

Muthangya Ukasi Ukasi

0729080002

/

0729862962

/

0711761849

452754E,

9906774N

452573E,

9906662N 1.58 150,000 237,000

511

Not

registered

Muthangya

Mulu

Deceased)

Mulu

Muthangya

(Son) Ukasi Ukasi 712539779

455695E,

9908587N

452574E,

9906662N 27.17 150,000 4,075,500

512

Not

registered

Mwende

Nzovo Ukasi Ukasi 711312891

454756E,

9908009N

454452E,

9907021N 5.75 100,000 575,000

513

Not

registered

Mutunga

Nguma Ukasi Ukasi 706618192

445282E,

9908333N

454756E,

9908009N 1.2 150,000 180,000

514

Not

registered Kiluu Ndia Mwalali Imba 701297084

455958E,

9908749N

455695E,

9908587N 2.29 150,000 343,500

515

Not

registered Iloi Kasivu Ukasi Ukasi 708206581

458043E,

9910032N

455958E,

9908749N 18.14 150,000 2,721,000

516

Not

registered

Mwangangi

Mutangili Sosoma Ukasi 0707226103'

455695E,

9908587N

0457691E,

9909823N 17.4 100,000 1,740,000

517

Not

registered

Joseph

Mutemi

Muithya Ukasi Ukasi

0710200070

/

0733595568

459944E,

9911207N

458250E,

9910163N 14.75 150,000 2,212,500

518

Not

registered Muli Kitema Ukasi Ukasi 728452795

460443E,

9911434N

459944E,

9911207N 4.12 150,000 618,000

519

Not

registered

Ndune

Mutangili Ukasi Ukasi

0707880814

/

0707226103

460767E,

9911508N

460443E,

9911434N 2.47 150,000 370,500

520

Not

registered

John

King'ang'a

Musyoka Kathungu Ukasi 712553885

0467587E,

9913074N

0466912E,

9912920N 5.13 100,000 513,000

521

Not

registered

Kilonzi

Musyoka Ukasi Ukasi 706880049

0469603E,

9913537N

0467587E,

9913074N 0.5 100,000 50,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 47

Page 105: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

522

Not

registered

Nuru Maalim

Hajir Bangale Bangale 12m*50m 0.15 100,000 15,000

523

Not

registered

Bille Abdi

Aden Bangale Bangale 12m*50m 0.15 100,000 15,000

524

Not

registered Mohammed ShidhieBangale Bangale

501849 E,

9919274 N

501908 E,

9919294 N 0.46 100,000 46,000

525

Not

registered Ali Adow Bangale Bangale

501908 E,

9919294 N

501995 E,

9919328 N 0.28 100,000 28,000

526

Not

registered Nunu Hussein Bangale Bangale

501995 E,

9919328 N

502010 E,

9919334 N 0.12 100,000 12,000

527

Not

registered Umar Santur Bangale Bangale

502010 E,

9919334 N

502038 E,

9919344 N 0.22 100,000 22,000

528

Not

registered Daud Bangale Bangale

502038 E,

9919344 N

502122 E,

9919377 N 0.67 100,000 67,000

529

Not

registered Ibrahim Abdi Bangale Bangale 100,000 0

530

Not

registered Abdi Soyan Bangale Bangale 100,000 0

531

Not

registered Abdullahi HusseinBangale Bangale 100,000 0

532

Not

registered Gabo Gobu (Deceased)Bangale Bangale

502122E,

9919344N

502226E,

9919418N 0.83 100,000 83,000

533

Not

registered

Habida

Koriti,

Madina,

Mumina

Dube Madogo Madogo 716445902 0 100,000 0

534

Not

registered

Hamara

Kuney Bule Mulanjo Saka 726461683

565163E,

9953198N

565231E,

9953296N 0.88 100,000 88,000

535

Not

registered Kanyere Afi Mulanjo Saka 726461683

565331e,

9953446N

565367E,

9953495N 0.45 100,000 45,000

536

Not

registered

Mohamed

Barisa Jilo Konaramatha Saka 726846631 0 100,000 0

537

TND/MADO/

SH/105 of

31/3/1999 Gubatu Farm Konaramatha Saka

0721480071

/

0725468689

565692E,

9953917N

565839E,

9954192N 2.31 100,000 231,000

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 48

Page 106: RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN (RAP) FOR THE PROPOSED …

September 2013

NO. LR No

Property

Owner Sub location Location Contacts Size of whole land (acres) Land affected (acres)Percentage of land affectedValue per acreTotal ValueCo-ordinates

538

Not

registered

Olive Branch

Farm Konaramatha Saka

0722836129

/

0731554242

565839E,

9954192N

566155E,

9954572N 3.66 100,000 366,000

539

Not

registered

Dullow Farm

community

(Owned by

Bonaya

Godana

Dullow) Konaramatha Saka

0715535363

/

0729690078

566155E,

9954572N

566861E,

9955394N 8.03 100,000 803,000

540

Not

registered Nasri Farm Athili Raya 713373482

567461E,

9956092N

568738E,

9957577N 14.52 100,000 1,452,000

541

Not

registered

Wathajir

Farm Athili Raya 723444308

568738E,

9957577N

569300E,

9958230N 6.39 100,000 639,000

886.42 213,166,000

Trust land 842.16 Total 100,000 84,216,000

Grand Total 297,382,000

Total

Appendix 2: Final Land Valuation Kindaruma Mwingi Garissa TL 49