revision petition before deputy commissioner court
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
1/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS
X-M W.X. HEJNGSJPPJ
JIKG 74 TKJSX
AJWETJTDND ND\JX
7WE HSMXX" JXEMA NJIJSW[FA[S
: WEK JXXDXWJNW
HMFFDXXDMNKS
W[FA[S X[C&GD\DXDMN
FDND&\DGEJNJXM[GEJ
W[FA[S
3 WEK \DHK HEJNHKBBMS
W[FA[S [ND\KSXDWT
C.E. SMJG"
W[FA[S
8 WEK SKIDXWSJS
W[FA[S [ND\KSXDWT
C.E. SMJG"
W[FA[S
FKFMSJNG[F ML JPPKJB [NGKS XKHWDMN :8
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
2/32
3. Wek jppkjb ds dn rkspkht tm tek prmpkrty ekrkdnjltkr hjbbkg jsshekgubk prmpkrty ds fmrklubby gkshrdckg dn tek shekgubk
ekrkungkr wjs jn jirdhubturjb prmpkrty js ljr cjha js lrmf
tdfk dffkfmrdjb. Wek bjng ds sdtujtkg dn Xurvky nufckr
83
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
3/32
-::5-:44;&4
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
4/32
tek hmnvkrsdmn mrgkr. Wek mrgkr rkfjdnkg unhejbbknikg lmr
fmrk tejn 80 ykjrs.
4. Nm supkrdmr hmurt ml vjbdg ourdsgdhtdmn ejs kvkr qujsekg tek
bjymut jpprmvjb mrgkr ml tek W[GJ js qumtkg jcmvk. Nm
Xupkrdmr hmurt ejs hjbbkg lmr rkhmrgs ml tek bjymut jpprmvjb
mrgkr. Wek mrgkr rkfjdnkg unhejbbknikg lmr fmrk tejn :;
ykjrs.
:0. Nm supkrdmr hmurt ml vjbdg ourdsgdhtdmn ejs kvkr
qujsekg tek Fundhdpjb Ajtej mpkndni mrgkr ml tek
Fundhdpjb hmffdssdmnkr ungkr tek fundhdpjbdtdks jht" js
qumtkg jcmvk. Nm Xupkrdmr hmurt ejs hjbbkg lmr rkhmrgs ml
tek Ajtej mrgkrs. Wek mrgkr rkfjdnkg unhejbbknikg lmr
fmrk tejn :0 ykjrs.
::. Nm hdvdb hmurt ml vjbdg ourdsgdhtdmn ejs kvkr qujsekg
tek sjbk gkkgs jng bmni stjngdni kntrdks dn rkvknuk rkhmrgs
kdtekr mn prdvjtk gdsputks mr mn imvkrnfknt gdsputks mr cy
jny jutemrdtdks. Nm Xupkrdmr hmurt ejs hjbbkg lmr rkhmrgs ml
tek jppkbbjnts tm dnqudrk jny jspkht. Wek stjtk ml jlljdrs
rkfjdnkg unhejbbknikg lmr fmrk tejn ;0 ykjrs.
:3. Wekrk ds nm pkngdni cmungjry gdsputks js kbdhdtkg
ungkr hejptkr UDD ml Wek Ajrnjtjaj Bjng Skvknuk jht.
Wekrk ds nm mrgkr- prmhkkgdnis ungkr skhtdmn :73%3$ ml tek
Ajrnjtjaj bjng Skvknuk jht cy Wjesdbgjr Wufaur jltkr jny
prdvjtk mr pucbdh jutemrdty wjntkg tm gdsputk cmungjrdks.
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
5/32
:8. Wekrk jrk nm jhqudsdtdmn prmhkkgdnis mvkr tek
shekgubk prmpkrty lrmf teds jppkbbjnt lmr kdtekr
dntkrfkgdjtk hmbbkik mr lmr Wufaur undvkrsdty mr lmr jny
jutemrdty. Gurdni tek pkrdmg ml suhe bmni ykjrs ml vjbdg
mwnkrsedp jng pmsskssdmn jng gkfjrhjtdmn ml cmungjrdks"
nm jhqudsdtdmn nmtdldhjtdmn ds skrvkg kdtekr mn tek ljfdby
fkfckrs ml jppkbbjnt mr mn teds jppkbbjnt kvkn dnspdtk ml
bmni stjngdni kntrdks ml ajtejgjr njfks dn SWHs jng
sucskqukntby dn fundhdpjb rkhmrgs.
:7. Wek Xurvky nufckr 83
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
6/32
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
7/32
gm sm. Dn Xusedb Aufjr Fketj v. Imvdng Sjf Cmerj :440
XHH %:$ :48 dt ds ekbg" J gkhrkk pjsskg cy j hmurt wdtemut
ourdsgdhtdmn mvkr tek sucokht fjttkr mr mn mtekr irmungs
wedhe imks tm tek rmmt ml dts kxkrhdsk mr ourdsgdhtdmn" bjhas
dnekrknt ourdsgdhtdmn. Dt ds j hmrjf nmn ougdhk. J gkhrkk
pjsskg cy suhe j hmurt ds j nubbdty jng ds nmnkst. Dts
dnvjbdgdty hjn ck skt up weknkvkr dt ds smuiet tm ck knlmrhkg
mr ds jhtkg upmn js j lmungjtdmn lmr j rdiet" kvkn jt tek stjik
ml kxkhutdmn mr dn hmbbjtkrjb prmhkkgdnis. Wek gklkht ml
ourdsgdhtdmn strdhas jt tek jutemrdty ml tek hmurt tm pjss j
gkhrkk wedhe hjnnmt ck hurkg cy hmnsknt mr wjdvkr ml tek
pjrty.
8. NM PSMPKS KNZ[DST?& Kvkn dnspdtk ml suhe vdmbjtdmns ml
njturjb oustdhk" tek :st rkspmngknt ejs nmt vkrdldkg jbb tek
jvjdbjcbk gmhufknts jvjdbjcbk wdte tek tjesdbgjr mlldhk
cklmrk pjssdni suhe mrgkrs. Nm prmpkr knqudry wdte
gmhufknts wkrk hmnguhtkg.
7. SK\KN[K BJYX DINMSKG?& Js j bjw dfpbkfkntdni jngkfpmwkrkg jutemrdty ungkr Wek Ajrnjtjaj bjng Skvknuk
jht" tek prdnhdpbks ml bjw kbdhdtkg ungkr tejt stjtutk ds
dinmrkg usurpdni tek jppkbbjtk ourdsgdhtdmn mvkr ediekr
jutemrdty. Wek jbdknjtdmn mrgkr ds pjsskg cy Xpkhdjb Gkputy
Hmffdssdmnkr ds dngdrkhtby qujsekg cy bmwkr jutemrdty tejt
ds :st rkspmngknt. Yedhe ds jcusk ml prmhkss jng pmwkrs ml
hmurt.
;. NM LJDS PBJT?& Fkrk hejnidni ml SWHs wdtemut pjssdni
jny rkjsmnjcbk mrgkr jng wdtemut pjssdni jny kvdhtdmn
prmhkkgdnis ds edieby gkpbmrjcbk hmnguht ml :st rkspmngknt.
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
8/32
Wek jrkj ds jbrkjgy gkvkbmpkg jng surrmungkg cy cudbgdnis.
Wekrk jrk rkjb kstjtk fjldj kbkfknts jng cbjhafjdbkrs
ckedng suhe dbbkijb mrgkrs" dl jnytedni wrmni ds tekrk
nmtedni prkvkntkg tekf lrmf dssudni nmtdhk skkadni
kxpbjnjtdmns lrmf teksk jppkbbjnts.
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
9/32
4. NM SKJXMNX DN WEK MSGKS?& Wek dfpdnikg mrgkrs ds nmt
spkjadni mrgkrs. Wek dfpdnikg mrgkrs ds nmt suppbdkg wdte
rkjsmns jng hbkjr ljhts. Wek rkvknuk jutemrdtdks gkhdsdmns
semubg ck cjskg mn un&gdsputkg ljhts. Yedhe ds nmt lmbbmwkg
dn mur hjsk. Dn H.N. Njikngrj Xdnie vs Wek Xpkhdjb Gkputy
Hmffdssdmnkr Jng Mrs. %DBS 3003 AJS 39;0$ Wek
Emncbk Edie hmurt ml Ajrnjtjaj Ekbg tejt ? Wek gkhdsdmn ml
tek Skvknuk Hmurts ejs tm ck nkhkssjrdby cjskg mn tek
ungdsputkg ljhts.
:0. IM\KSNFKNW XEJBB NMW PSM\MAK BDWDIJWDMNX?&
Wek imvkrnfknt jutemrdtdks sejbb nmt prmvmak bdtdijtdmns. Wek
rkspmngknts jrk gmdni tek sjfk wdte unoustdldjcbk
hmntkntdmns jng unoust fjndpubjtdmn ml gmhufknts. Dn hjsk ml
[rcjn Dfprmvkfknt Wrust" Cdajnkr \s. Fmejn Bjb cklmrk
Xuprkfk Hmurt ml Dngdj" GG 80&:0&3004 JDS 30:0 XHY pjik
:
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
10/32
tekdr dngubiknhk dn unwjrrjntkg bdtdijtdmn rkqudrks tm ck
hmrrkhtkg.
::. PSKX[FPWDMN ML KNWSDKX?& Cklmrk pjssdni tek
dfpdnikg mrgkrs" :st rkspmngknt ejs nmt vkrdldkg tek
prksufptdmn ml kntrdks dn mbg rkvknuk rkhmrgs. Wek tdtbk
gkkgs wkrk nmt suffmnkg. Kvkn tek gmhufknts jvjdbjcbk
wdte gkpjrtfknt ml rkvknuk dtskbl spkjas ml tek vjbdgpmsskssdmn jng mwnkrsedp ml : jhrk 0: iuntjs cut suhe
prksufptdmns wkrk mvkrbmmakg cy fkrk jbbkijtdmns un&
suppmrtkg gmhufknts jng strdht prmml tm rkcutk suhe
prksufptdmns. Dn Ajrkwwj Jng Mrs. vs Eussknsjc Aejnsjekc
Yjojntrd Jng Mrs JDS 3003 XH ;07" Xuprkfk Hmurt mcskrvkg
js lmbbmws prksufptdmn ml hmrrkhtnkss ml jn kntry dn
rkvknuk rkhmrg hjnnmt ck rkcuttkg cy j stjtkfknt dn tek
wrdttkn stjtkfknt. Fkrk stjtkfknt ml ljht dn tek wrdttkn
stjtkfknt ds nmt j rkcuttjb ml prksufptdmn ml hmrrkhtnkss ml
jn kntry dn tek rkvknuk rkhmrg. Wek rkspmngknt wjs rkhmrgkg
js j tknjnt dn tek rkvknuk rkhmrg dn tek ykjr :498 jng ungkr
bjw tek prksufptdmn ds tejt tek kntry ds hmrrkht. Dt wjs lmr tek
jppkbbjnt tm rkcut tek prksufptdmn cy bkjgdni kvdgknhk. Wek
jppkbbjnt ejs nmt bkg jny kvdgknhk tm semw tejt kntry dn tek
rkvknuk rkhmrg ds Dnhmrrkht.
:3. NM JPPKBBJWK O[SDXGDHWDMN?& Wek mrgkrs pjsskg
cy Gkputy Hmffdssdmnkr ds ungkr skhtdmn 4; ml ABS jht. Wek
:st rkspmngknt ds nmt tek jppkbbjtk jutemrdty mvkr suhe
mrgkrs. Ek gdsturcs suhe mrgkrs wdtemut ejvdni ourdsgdhtdmn
tm gm tek sjfk. Dn FJNNJBJB OJDN v. XWJWK ML JXXJF"
Wekdr Bmrgsedps ml tek Xuprkfk Hmurt ejvk ekbg dn
pjrjirjpe&:3 js lmbbmws?& #Wek wdsgmf ml dssudni kxkhutdvk
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
11/32
dnstruhtdmns dn fjttkrs wedhe jrk imvkrnkg cy prmvdsdmns ml
bjw ds gmuctlub1 kvkn dl dt ck hmnsdgkrkg nkhkssjry tm dssuk
dnstruhtdmns dn suhe j fjttkr" tek dnstruhtdmns hjnnmt ck sm
lrjfkg mr utdbdskg js tm mvkrrdgk tek prmvdsdmns ml bjw. Xuhe
j fktemg wdbb gkstrmy tek vkry cjsds ml tek Subk ml Bjw jng
strdak jt tek vkry rmmt ml mrgkrby jgfdndstrjtdmn ml bjw.#
:8. PMXXKXXDMN NMW WSJNXLKSSKG?& Mn wejt cjsdsimvkrnfknt ejngkg mvkr mr irjntkg bjng ckbmnidni tm
prdvjtk pkrsmns wdtemut jhqudsdtdmns mr wdtemut prmpkr
trjnslkr ml pmsskssdmn dn tdfk ds nmt spkhdldkg dn tek mrgkr mr
hmffundhjtkg tm teds jppkbbjnts.
:7. BJHA ML JPPSKHDJWDMN ML K\DGKNHK JNG
GMH[FKNWX?& Dn tek dfpdnikg mrgkrs tekrk ds hbkjr
fkntdmndni tejt dn Cemmfd gjtj cjsk dt ds hbkjrby semwdni dt
ds nmt imvkrnfknt bjng jng dt ds prdvjtk bjng. Wek :st
rkspmngknt gmks nmt cmtekrkg tm vkrdly emw prdvjtk pkrsmns
njfks wkrk jggkg tm tejt ml dntkrfkgdjtk hmbbkik jng
wektekr suhe bjng ds jbdknjtkg mr nmt. Gkspdtk anmwbkgik mlsjbk ml bjngs jng kntrdks tm suhe kllkht dn rkvknuk rkhmrgs :st
rkspmngknt ljdbkg tm jpprkhdjtk tek anmwbkgik ml
gmhufknts mvkr tek bjng cy rkvknuk jutemrdtdks. Dn tek
gkhdsdmn dn Xft Gdbcmm vs. Xft Gejnrjod JDS 3000 XH 8:7<
" tek Jpkx Hmurt ejs ekbg tejt weknkvkr j gmhufknt ds
rkidstkrkg" tek gjtk ml rkidstrjtdmn jhts js tek gjtk ml
gkkfkg anmwbkgik. Dn mtekr hjsks" wekn j ljht hmubg ck
gdshmvkrkg cy guk gdbdiknhk" tekn gkkfkg anmwbkgik hmubg
ck jttrdcutkg tm tek pbjdntdll ckhjusk j pjrty hjnnmt ck
jbbmwkg tm kxtkng pkrdmg ml bdfdtjtdmn cy fkrkby hbjdfdni
tejt ek ejg nm anmwbkgik.
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
12/32
:;. SKBDKL WM PMXXKXXDMN?& Dn tek dfpdnikg mrgkrs dt dsstjtkg tejt bjng wjs jhqudrkg cy j nmtdldhjtdmn gjtkg :47:.
Dt ds nmt hbkjrby gdshusskg wektekr suhe nmtdldhjtdmn ds
prkhkgkg wdte prmpkr tjadni ml pmsskssdmn mr pjyfknt ml
hmfpknsjtdmn. Dt ds nmt gdshusskg emw tek rkbkvjnt rkvknuk
kntrdks hmntdnukg dn tek njfk ml mwnkrs. Dt ds nmt gdshusskg
emw tek prksufptdmn ml bmni gurjtdmn kntrdks cmte ungkr
rkvknuk jht jng kvdgknhk jht ds rkcuttkg wdte jny kvdgknhk.
Oustdhk XrkkgejrSjm ml Ajrnjtjaj Edie Hmurt dn Pknnjdje
Jng Mrs. vs Wedppjffj JDS 3007 Ajnt 777 ejs ekbg tejt
Yekn tek gmhufknts ml tdtbk rkbdkg mn cy tek pbjdntdll gmks
nmt hmrrkspmng wdte tek sudt shekgubk prmpkrty jng dn tek
jcsknhk ml nkhkssjry pbkjgdni jng prmml" tek jppkbbjtk
Hmurt wjs wrmni dn gkhbjrdni tek tdtbk ml tek pbjdntdll. Fjy
ck tejt tek gklkngjnt ejs nmt prmvkg tdtbk ml eds vkngmr" cut"
nmnktekbkss tek gklkngjnt ds ekbg tm ck dn pmsskssdmn ml tek
sudt prmpkrty" wekn tek pbjdntdll ejs ljdbkg tm prmvk tdtbk" ek
wmubg nmt ck kntdtbkg tm rkbdkl ml pmsskssdmn drrkspkhtdvk ml
tek vjbdg tdtbk ml tek gklkngjnt. Dn tejt vdkw ml tek fjttkr1
tek jpprkhdjtdmn ml ljhts jng kvdgknhk jng tek dnlkrknhk
grjwn ds pkrvkrsk jng hmntrjry tm bjw jng kvdgknhk mn
rkhmrg.
:
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
13/32
tm jbb temsk Ajsjjid pkmpbk dn pmsskssdmn jng knomyfknt.
Weds typk ml fdsusk ml mlldhdjb pmwkrs ckedng tek cjha ml teds
jppkbbjnt ds edieby unhmnstdtutdmnjb. Wek prmpmsjb ml
Wjesdbgjr mr dntkrfkgdjtk hmbbkik mr Wufaur undvkrsdty
semubg ejvk ckkn rkokhtkg cy tek :st rkspmngknt cjskg mn
bjw js kbdhdtkg dn Ajfbkse Cjcu , Mrs vs Bjopjt Sjd
Xejrfj , Mrs 3005 %
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
14/32
pmbdhy stjtkfknts hjnnmt ck gdsrkijrgkg unljdrby mr jppbdkg
skbkhtdvkby. [nljdrnkss dn tek lmrf ml unrkjsmnjcbknkss ds jadn
tm vdmbjtdmn ml njturjb oustdhk. .. Bjstby" dt ds jbsm
nkhkssjry tm nmtdhk tek pmsdtdmn ml j trkspjsskr wem ds dn
pkjhklub" mpkn" hmntdnumus jng undntkrruptkg pmsskssdmn ml
jnmtekr)s prmpkrty" dn gkndjb ml tek tdtbk ml tek truk mwnkr" lmr
j bmni pkrdmg. Xkhtdmn 39 ml tek Bdfdtjtdmn Jht" :4
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
15/32
wdtemut tjadni mur rkjb mwnkrs jng pmsskssmrs vkrsdmn dntm
eds hmnsdgkrjtdmn Xtjtk ml Edfjhejb Prjgkse v Ijnkse
Ymmg Prmguhts" JDS :44< XH :74 js lmbbmws? #. . . . Jbb tejt
wk wdse tm kfpejsdsk ds tejt jnytedni jng kvkrytedni gmnk cy
tek prmfdskk mn tek ljdte ml tek rkprkskntjtdmn gmks nmt
nkhkssjrdby jfmunt tm jbtkrdni eds pmsdtdmn sm js tm prkhbugk
tek prmfdsmr lrmf rksdbdni lrmf eds rkprkskntjtdmn. Dl kqudty
gkfjngs tejt tek prmfdsmr ds jbbmwkg tm rksdbk jng tek
prmfdskk ds hmfpknsjtkg jpprmprdjtkby" tejt muiet tm ck
gmnk. Dl" emwkvkr" kqudty gkfjngs" dn tek bdiet ml tek tednis
gmnk cy tek prmfdskk mn tek ljdte ml tek rkprkskntjtdmn" tejt
tek prmfdsmr semubg ck prkhbugkg lrmf rksdbdni jng tejt ek
semubg ck ekbg ljst tm eds rkprkskntjtdmn" tejt semubg ck gmnk.
Wm rkpkjt" dt ds j fjttkr ml embgdni tek shjbks kvkn cktwkkn
tek pjrtdks tm gm oustdhk cktwkkn tekf. Weds ds tek kqudty
dfpbdhdt dn tek gmhtrdnk. ... Wm wdt" tek rubk ml prmfdssmry
kstmppkb ckdni jn kqudtjcbk gmhtrdnk" ejs tm ck fmubgkg tm
sudt tek pjrtdhubjr sdtujtdmn. Dt ds nmt j ejrg jng ljst rubk cut
jn kbjstdh mnk" tek mcokhtdvk ml wedhe ds tm gm oustdhk cktwkkn
tek pjrtdks jng tm kxtkng jn kqudtjcbk trkjtfknt tm tekf. Dl dt
ds fmrk oust lrmf tek pmdnt ml vdkw ml cmte prmfdsmr jng
prmfdskk tejt tek bjttkr ds hmfpknsjtkg jpprmprdjtkby jng
jbbmw tek prmfdsmr tm im cjha mn eds prmfdsk" tejt semubg ck
gmnk1 cut dl tek Hmurt ds ml tek mpdndmn tejt tek dntkrksts ml
oustdhk jng kqudty gkfjng tejt tek prmfdsmr semubg nmt ck
jbbmwkg tm rksdbk lrmf eds rkprkskntjtdmn dn tek ljhts jng
hdrhufstjnhks ml tejt hjsk" dt wdbb gm sm. Weds" dn mur rkspkhtlubmpdndmn" ds tek prmpkr wjy ml ungkrstjngdni tek wmrgs
#prmfdskk jbtkrdni eds pmsdtdmn#. Jbtkrdni eds pmsdtdmn semubg
fkjn suhe jbtkrjtdmn dn tek pmsdtdmn ml tek prmfdskk js dt
fjaks dt jppkjr tm tek Hmurt tejt embgdni tek prmfdsmr tm eds
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
16/32
rkprkskntjtdmn ds nkhkssjry tm gm oustdhk cktwkkn tek
pjrtdks....#
:4. BJNG JHZ[DXDWDMN PSDNHDPBKX?& Dn tek dfpdnikg
mrgkrs tekrk ds fkntdmndni ml Jhqudsdtdmn nmtdldhjtdmn gjtkg
:47:. Wejt nmtdldhjtdmn skkfs tm ejvk ckkn dssuk ungkr
skhtdmn < ml Wek bjng jhqudsdtdmn jht wdtemut jny skhtdmn 7
nmtdldhjtdmn. Wek sjdg nmtdldhjtdmn dtskbl ds dbbkijb jltkr tek
Xuprkfk hmurt Ougikfknt wjs pjsskg dn :454. Wek :st
rkspmngknt jhtdmn dn upembgdni :47: dnhmfpbktkg jhqudsdtdmn
prmhkkgdnis gurdni 300; ds jijdnst tek prdnhdpbks ml bjw jng dt
vdmbjtks suprkfk hmurt ougikfknt. Wek Xuprkfk Hmurt dn
hjsk ml dts ougifknt gjtkg Ojnujry ::" :454 dn Xtjtk ml [ttjr
Prjgkse \s. Sjgeky Xey jf Ndijf rkpmrtkg dn :454 %:$
XHH ;4:ekbg tejt jltkr tek hmffknhkfknt ml tek bjng
Jhqudsdtdmn " tek gkhbjrjtdmn ungkr Xkhtdmn < ml tek Bjng
Jhqudsdtdmn Jht" :547 hjnnmt ck fjgk sdfubtjnkmusby wdte tek
pucbdhjtdmn dn tek Ijzkttk Nmtdldhjtdmn ungkr Xkhtdmn 7%:$ kvkn
temuie tek jppbdhjtdmn ml Xkhtdmn ;&J ejs ckkn gdspknskg wdte
ungkr Xkhtdmn :9%7$ ml tek sjdg Jht. Dn j bjrik nufckr ml
prmhkkgdnis ml jhqudsdtdmn ml bjng lmr tek Gkvkbmpfknt
Jutemrdtdks lmr tek dfpbkfkntjtdmn ml vjrdmus emusdnishekfks" tek gkhbjrjtdmn ungkr Xkhtdmn < wkrk fjgk
sdfubtjnkmusby wdte pucbdhjtdmn dn tek Ijzkttk ml nmtdldhjtdmn
ungkr Xkhtdmn 7%:$. Wek sjdg prmhkkgdnis wkrk bdakby tm ck
ekbg vmdg dn vdkw ml tek jlmrksjdg ougifknt ml tek Xuprkfk
Hmurt.
30. SK\KN[K HM[SW HJNNMW GKHDGK WDWBK WM
PSMPKSWT?& XWJWK ML I[OJSJW \s. PJWKB SJIEJ\
NJWEJ , MSX. JDS :4
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
17/32
lurtekr dl sm jgvdskg. Yk jrk jbsm ml tek mpdndmn tejt tek
Hmffdssdmnkr semubg nmt ejvk imnk dntm tek qukstdmn ml
tdtbk. Dt skkfs tm us tejt wekn tek tdtbk ml jn mhhupjnt ds
gdsputkg cy jny pjrty cklmrk tek Hmbbkhtmr mr tek
Hmffdssdmnkr jng tek gdsputk ds skrdmus tek jpprmprdjtk
hmursk lmr tek Hmbbkhtmr mr tek Hmffdssdmnkr wmubg ck tm
rklkr tek pjrtdks tm j hmfpktknt hmurt jng nmt tm gkhdgk
tek qukstdmn ml tdtbk edfskbl jijdnst tek mhhupjnt.
3:. NM 4%:$ NMWDLDHJWDMN LMS EJ\DNI WJAKN
PMXXKXXDMN?& Yekrk tek bjngs jrk jhqudrkg dn kxkrhdsk ml
kfkriknt pmwkrs ml tek Xtjtk ungkr Xkhtdmn :9 ml tek Jht" j
nmtdldhjtdmn ungkr Xkhtdmn < ml tek Jht ds dssukg jng tek
nmtdldhjtdmn dtskbl rklkrs tm tek prmvdsdmns ml Xkhtdmn :9%:$ml tek Jht. Emwkvkr" nmtdhk ungkr Xkhtdmn 4%:$ ml tek Jht
ejs tm ck pucbdsekg tm hmfpbktk jng lubby dnvmak tek pmwkrs
vkstkg dn tek Xtjtk lmr tjadni pmsskssdmn ml tek bjng" dn
tkrfs ml Xkhtdmn :9%:$ ml tek Jht. Jltkr tek kxpdry ml :;
gjys lrmf suhe pucbdhjtdmn ungkr Xkhtdmn 4%:$" tek
pmsskssdmn ml tek bjng hjn ck vjbdgby tjakn cy tek
Imvkrnfknt" wekrkupmn tek bjng wmubg vkst jcsmbutkby dn
tek Imvkrnfknt" lrkk lrmf jbb knhufcrjnhks. Dn mtekr
wmrgs" lmr prmpkr hmfputjtdmn ml tek spkhdldkg pkrdmg ml :;
gjys" dssujnhk ml nmtdldhjtdmn ungkr Xkhtdmn 4%:$ ml tek Jht
wmubg ck nkhkssjry. Ydtemut suhe nmtdldhjtdmn tekrk ds nm
jssufptdmn mr prksufptdmn ml tjadni pmsskssdmn cy tek
imvkrnfknt. Weds ds tek bjw ungkr Bjng jhqudsdtdmn jht"
wedhe ds fjngjtmry sdnhk dt gkprdvks tek bjng jng prmpkrty.
Dn tek dnstjnt hjsk tekrk ds wedspkr dn tek dfpdnikg mrgkr
jcmut 4%:$ nmtdldhjtdmn" wdtemut rksmrtdni tm suhe
nmtdldhjtdmn tek puttdni up ml hbjdfs kdtekr lrmf jny
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
18/32
jutemrdty ds nubb jng vmdg. Dn j prmhkkgdni ungkr tek Jht lmr
jhqudsdtdmn ml bjng jbb dntkrksts jrk wdpkg mut. Jhtujb
pmsskssdmn ml tek bjng ckhmfks nkhkssjry. lmr dts usk lmr tek
pucbdh purpmsk lmr wedhe dt ejs ckkn jhqudrkg. Wekrklmrk"
tek tjadni ml pmsskssdmn ungkr tek Jht hjnnmt ck
#syfcmbdhjb# dn tek sknsk js iknkrjbby ungkrstmmg dn Hdvdb
Bjw. Xurkby dt hjnnmt ck j pmsskssdmn fkrkby mn pjpkr.
Yejt ds rkqudrkg ungkr tek Jht ds tek tjadni ml jhtujb
pmsskssdmn mn tek spmt. Dn tek kyk ml bjw tek tjadni ml
pmsskssdmn wdbb ejvk tek kllkht ml trjnslkrrdni pmsskssdmn
lrmf tek mwnkr mr tek mhhupjnt ml tek bjng tm tek
Imvkrnfknt. %JDS :49; XH :9
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
19/32
pkrsmns jppkjrdni lrmf tek Skhmrg ml Sdiets mr Skidstkr ml
Futjtdmns tm ck dntkrkstkg dn tek futjtdmn" jng tm jny mtekr
pkrsmn wemf ek ejs rkjsmn tm ckbdkvk tm ck dntkrkstkg
tekrkdn.
Xkhtdmn :34 %
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
20/32
prmvdgks lmr rkpmrtdni ml tek jhqudsdtdmn ml rdiets dn rkspkht
ml bjngs hmvkrkg cy tek prmvdsdmns ml tek Jht. Wekrklmrk"
weknkvkr jny pkrsmn jhqudrks tek rdiet tm jny bjngkg
prmpkrty lmr wedhe tek Jht jppbdks lrmf dts mrdidnjb mwnkr
cy bkjsk" fmrtijik" idlt" purhejsk kth." tek sjdg Xkhtdmn
prmvdgks lmr rkpmrtdni ml suhe jhqudsdtdmn ml rdiets jng lmr
rkhkdvdni dt cy tek jutemrdty spkhdldkg mn pjyfknt ml
prkshrdckg lkk. Xkhtdmn :34 prkshrdcks tek prmhkgurk lmr
rkidstrjtdmn ml futjtdmns rkpmrtkg ungkr Xkhtdmn :35. Xuc&
skhtdmn %:$ ml Xkhtdmn :34 ml tek Jht prmvdgks lmr fjadni jn
kntry dn tek rkidstkr ml futjtdmns ml kvkry rkpmrt fjgk tm
edf ungkr tek prmvdsdmns ml Xkhtdmn :35 ml tek Jht. Xuc&
skhtdmn %3$ ml Xkhtdmn :34 ml tek Jht prmvdgks lmr pucbdhjtdmn
ml j hmpy ml tek kntry sm fjgk js jbsm lmr idvdni wrdttkn
dntdfjtdmn tm jbb pkrsmns dntkrkstkg" js gdshbmskg dn tek
rkvknuk rkhmrgs. Dl tekrk wkrk tm ck jny mcokhtdmns"" Xuc&
skhtdmn %8$ rkqudrks tek prkshrdckg mlldhkr tm kntkr tek
pjrtdhubjrs ml tek mcokhtdmn dn tek rkidstkr ml gdsputkg hjsks.
Xuc&skhtdmn %7$ ml Xkhtdmn :34 ml tek Jht kfpmwkrs tek
prkshrdckg jutemrdty tm gkhdgk tek gdsputks lmbbmwdni tek
prmhkgurk js prkshrdckg ungkr Xuc skhtdmn %;$. Xucskhtdmn
%
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
21/32
tm suhe rdiet jng jbsm prmvdgks tejt tek kntrdks dn tek rkhmrg
ml rdiet sejbb ck jfkngkg dn jhhmrgjnhk wdte jny
gkhbjrjtdmn irjntkg cy tek Hdvdb Hmurt.
Oustdhk E.\.I. Sjfkse" dn Fjejgkvjppj Jng Mrs. vs
Xtjtk Ml Ajrnjtjaj DBS 3005 AJS :9;0 Dt ds edie tdfk tm
dntdfjtk tek Skvknuk Gkpjrtfknt jng tek hmnhkrnkg
Gkpjrtfknt tm fktdhubmusby lmbbmw tek prmhkgurk js
prmvdgkg ungkr Xkhtdmn :35 , :34 ml tek Ajrnjtjaj Bjng
Skvknuk Jht jng jbsm dt semubg ck fjgk fjngjtmry js j
fjttkr ml rkspmnsdcdbdty mn tek pjrt ml tek Imvkrnfknt tm
sjvk tek pucbdh lrmf tek prkhjrdmus sdtujtdmn jng jbsm tekrk
sejbb ck tdfkby jhtdmn cy tek rkvknuk jutemrdtdks wdtemut
tekrk ckdni jny gkbjy mn tekdr pjrt dn fjadni kntrdks dn tek
futjtdmn rkidstkr jng mtekr rkidstkrs dn tek rkvknuk mlldhk
jng dn tek Hmrpmrjtdmn-Fundhdpjbdty dn hdty bdfdts tm jvmdg
luturk hmfpbdhjtdmns. . Imvkrnfknt Pbkjgkr tm
hmffundhjtk teds mrgkr tm tek Imvkrnfknt jng tek
Imvkrnfknt dn turn sejbb gdrkht Xkhrktjry tm Skvknuk
Gkpjrtfknt tm hdrhubjtk teds mrgkr dn tek gkpjrtfknt tm
lmbbmw tek prmhkgurk js prmvdgkg ungkr Xkhtdmn :35 , :34
ml tek Bjng Skvknuk Jht lmr guk hmfpbdjnhk jng tjadni
lmbbmw up jhtdmn. Lmr suhe nmn&hmfpbdjnhk cy tek hmnhkrnkg
Skvknuk Jutemrdtdks" tek Gkpjrtfknt sejbb prkshrdck smfk
nmrfs tm dndtdjtk jhtdmn.
Cedfjppj Hejnnjppj Ajpjbd ... vs Cedfjppj XjtyjppjAjfjimugj DBS 3003 AJS 80;;" 3008 %3$ AjrBO :75
Cknhe Oustdhk N Ojdn" Oustdhk N Aufjr" Wek kntry dn tek SWH
ds fjgk gurdni tek pkngknhy ml tek bkijb prmhkkgdnis
dndtdjtkg cy Xedvjwwj lmr hjnhkbbjtdmn ml tek idlt gkkg jng
fmrk sm dt ds mn tek cjsds ml j hmbbusdvk vjrged" js suhe tek
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
22/32
sjdg kntry wmubg nmt idvk rdsk tm jny prksufptdmn. Wejt
jpjrt sek sucfdttkg tejt cklmrk jn kntry ds fjgk dn tek SWH
dn tek njfk ml tek gkhkjskg jppkbbjnt" tek prmhkgurk
prkshrdckg dn bjw ungkr Xkhtdmns :35 jng :34 ml tek Bjng
Skvknuk Jht ejs nmt ckkn lmbbmwkg" js suhe nm prksufptdmn
wmubg jrdsk ungkr Xkhtdmn :88 ml tek sjdg Jht Jny
pkrsmn wem gmks nmt bjwlubby kntkr mn tek bjng ml jnmtekr
jng hubtdvjtk tek sjfk hjnnmt hbjdf tek stjtus ml j gkkfkg
tknjnt ungkr Xkhtdmn 7 ml tek Jht. Wemuie" dn tek hjsk ml
Gjeyj Bjbj" suprj" tek Emn)cbk Xuprkfk Hmurt ekbg dt ds nmt
tek hmngdtdmn tejt tek jppbdhjnt fust hubtdvjtk bjng wdte tek
hmnsknt mr ungkr tek jutemrdty gkrdvkg gdrkhtby lrmf tek
mwnkr" tm dfpmrt suhe j hmngdtdmn ds tm rkwrdtk tek skhtdmn"
jng gkstrmy dts prjhtdhjb utdbdty" j pkrsmn wem gkrdvks eds
rdiet tm hubtdvjtk bjng lrmf tek mwnkrs wmubg nmrfjbby ck j
hmntrjhtujb tknjnt jng ek wdbb mcvdmusby nmt ck j #gkkfkg
tknjnt#. Pkrsmns suhe js bdhknskks lrmf tek mwnkr fjy
hkrtjdnby ck rkijrgkg js ljbbdni wdtedn tek hbjss ml pkrsmns
bjwlubby hubtdvjtdni tek bjng ckbmnidni tm mtekrs" cut dt
hjnnmt ck jssufkg tekrklrmf tejt teky jrk tek mnby pkrsmns
wem jrk hmvkrkg cy tek skhtdmn. J tknjnt bjwlubby dnguhtkg
cy j fmrtijikk sejbb mn rkgkfptdmn ml tek fmrtijik ck
gkkfkg tm ck j tknjnt ungkr tek fmrtijimr.#Bjwlubby
hubtdvjtdni# fust ejvk smfk lmungjtdmn dn j bkijb rdiet tm
hubtdvjtk tek prmpkrty. Bjwlub hubtdvjtdmn hjnnmt Ck
kstjcbdsekg wdtemut hmnhmfdtjnt kxdstknhk ml j bjwlub
rkbjtdmnsedp. Bjwlub hubtdvjtdmn fust ejvk mrdidn dn j bkijbrdiet tm hubtdvjtk tek prmpkrty. Dn tek jcsknhk ml jny suhe
rdiet tm hubtdvjtk" dt hjnnmt ck sjdg tejt fkrkby ckhjusk j
pkrsmn ds hubtdvjtdni tek bjng ek ds ekbg tm ck dn bjwlub
hubtdvjtdmn. J pkrsmn wem hubtdvjtks tek bjng jijdnst tek
wdseks ml tek mwnkr hjnnmt ck sjdg tm ck dn bjwlub
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
23/32
hubtdvjtdmn. Fkrkby ckhjusk nm jhtdmn ds tjakn jijdnst edf
jng ek ejs hmntdnukg tm hubtdvjtk lmr j hmnsdgkrjcbk pkrdmg
ml tdfk wmubg nmt fjak eds hubtdvjtdmn bjwlub. Wek kssknhk
ml bjwlub hubtdvjtdmn ds tejt mnk semubg kntkr pmsskssdmn ml
tek bjng ungkr smfk hmbmur ml rdiet jng hubtdvjtk tek bjng js
j fjttkr ml rdiet" mtekrwdsk dt hjnnmt ck sjdg tejt ek ds dn
bjwlub hubtdvjtdmn ml tek bjng dn qukstdmn. Wekrklmrk" dn tek
jcsknhk ml jny bkijb rdiet j pkrsmn wem ds hubtdvjtdni tek
bjng hjnnmt hbjdf j stjtus ml gkkfkg tknjnt ungkr Xkhtdmn 7
ml tek Jht.
Dn Ojyjffj v. Fjrdj Cjd Gkjg cy prmpmskg B.Ss. jng
Jnmtekr Q%3007$ 9 XHH 7;4V" teds Hmurt ejs ekbg tejt wekn
jn jssdinfknt mr trjnslkr ds fjgk dn hmntrjvkntdmn ml
stjtutmry prmvdsdmns" tek hmnskquknhk wekrkml wmubg ck
tejt tek sjfk ds dnvjbdg jng teus mppmskg tm pucbdh
pmbdhy.
38. Wek jppkbbjnt rkskrvks eds bdckrty tm rjdsk lurtekr
irmungs cy wjy ml jriufknts mn fkrdts.
YEKSKLMSK" dn tek jcmvk ljhts jng hdrhufstjnhks ml tek
hjsk" tek Pbjdntdll fmst rkspkhtlubby prjys tejt" teds Emncbk Hmurt fjy
ck pbkjskg tm PJXX DNWKSDF MSGKSX jijdnst tek Skspmngknts
ekrkdn lmr tek lmbbmwdni rkbdkl-s?
d. GDSKHWDMN WM :st" rkspmngknt tm prmguhk jbb rkbkvjnt
rkvknuk rkhmrgs jbmni wdte prksknt sur vky rkpmrt rkhmrgs ml tek ml
Xur vky nm?83
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
24/32
YEKSKLMSK"dn tek jcmvk ljhts jng hdrhufstjnhks ml tek hjsk" tek
Pbjdntdll fmst rkspkhtlubby prjys tejt" teds Emncbk Hmurt fjy ck
pbkjskg tm PJXX LDNJB MSGKSX JLWKS KNZ[DST jijdnst tek
Skspmngknts ekrkdn lmr tek lmbbmwdni rkbdkl-s?
Zujsedni ml F utjtdmn mrgkrs dnMrgkr Nm. 8848-0;&0
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
25/32
Ykst?
Nmrte?
Xmute?
JG\MHJWK LMS JPPKBBJNW
JPPKBBJNW
\ K S D L D H J W D M N.
D" W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS" tek jppkbbjnt" ekrkcy gkhbjrks"
tejt" wejt ds stjtkg dn tek jcmvk pjrjs jt : tm :5 ml tek jppkjb
fkfm jrk truk jng hmrrkht tm tek ckst ml fy anmwbkgik"
dnlmrfjtdmn jng ckbdkl.
PBJHK ? W[FA[S
GJWKG ? JPPKBBJNW
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
26/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
DJ :-30::
DN
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW-JPPBDHJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS : WEK JXXDXWJNWHMFFDXXDMNKS
, MWEKSX
DNWKSBMH[WMST JPPBDHJWDMN [NGKS XKHWDMN 3; S-Y
XKHWDMN ;; ML AJSNJWJAJ BJNG SK\KN[K JHW?&
Wek Jppbdhjnt-JPPKBBJNW dn tek jcmvk hjsk fmst rkspkhtlubby
sucfdts tejt" lmr tek rkjsmns swmrn tm dn tek jhhmfpjnydnijlldgjvdt" teds Emncbk Hmurt fjy ck pbkjskg tm irjnt jn kxpjrtk
jg&dntkrdf Mrgkr ml XWJT ML F.S. Nm. 78-300;&0< JNG FS Nm.
7:-30:0&:: DN CKBMY FKNWDMNKG XHEKG[BK PSMPKSWT"
pkngdni gdspmsjb ml tek jcmvk hjsk" dn tek dntkrkst ml oustdhk jng
kqudty.
Xhekgubk Prmpkrty
Jbb tek pdkhk jng pjrhkb ml lmrfkr Jirdhubturjb prmpkrty sdtujtkg
jt Wufaur Wjbua" Ajsjcj emcbd" Wufaur irjfj dn survky nufckr
83
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
27/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
DJ :-30::
DN
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW-JPPBDHJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS : WEK JXXDXWJNW
HMFFDXXDMNKS
, MWEKSX
J L L D G J \ D W
D" W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS X-M W.X. HEJNGSJPPJ" JIKG 74 TKJSX"AJWETJTDND ND\JX" 7WE HSMXX" JXEMA NJIJS" W[FA[S" gm ekrkcy
smbkfnby jlldrf jng stjtk mn mjte js lmbbmws ?
:. D sucfdt" tejt" D jf tek JPPKBBJNW dn tek jcmvk hjsk. D jf wkbb
hmnvkrsjnt wdte tek ljhts ml tek hjsk. Eknhk" D jf swkjrdni tm tek hmntknts ml
teds jlldgjvdt.
3. D sucfdt" tejt" D ejvk ldbkg tek jcmvk jppkjb jijdnst tek SKXPMNGKNWX
qukstdmndni dbbkijb kntrdks dn SWHs jng ljak Futjtdmns wdtemut dssudni jny
nmtdhk tm rkjb mhhupjnts jng ajtejgjrs jng wdtemut jny rkidstkrkg gkkg.
Lurtekr" D sucfdt tejt" tek jvkrfknts fjgk dn tek jppkjb fjy adngby ck rkjgjs pjrt jng pjrhkb ml teds jlldgjvdt dn mrgkr tm jvmdg rkpktdtdmn ml tek ljhts.
8. D sucfdt" tejt" D ejvk prmguhkg skvkrjb gmhufknts lmr tek shekgubk
prmpkrty wekrkdn tekrk ds nm vjbdg irmung tm kntkr tek njfk ml rkspmngknt
nufckr twm dnstdtutdmn teds semws tejt tek kntrdks fjgk dn SWH jrk
lrjugubkntby fjgk wdte jn dntkntdmn tm tjak jwjy teds vjbujcbk bjng ml
jppbdhjnts ljfdby.
7. Lurtekr D sucfdt" tejt" wk ejvk ckkn dn pkjhklub pmsskssdmn jng knomyfknt
ml tek Xhekgubk Prmpkrty wdtemut jny bkt mr edngrjnhk lrmf jny cmgy cy
kxkrhdsdni jbb rdiets ml mwnkrsedp cy pjydni tek tjxks ml tek jppkjb XhekgubkPrmpkrty.
;. D sucfdt" tejt" wekn tednis stmmg teus" tek Gklkngjnt 3 WM 8 wem ejs nm
jny fjnnkr ml rdiet" tdtbk jng dntkrkst mvkr tek Xhekgubk Prmpkrty ds pbjnndni
tm dntkrlkrk wdte pkjhklub pmsskssdmn jng knomyfknt ml tek Xhekgubk
Prmpkrty cy ejvdni ldhtdtdmus kntry dn SWH.
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
28/32
lrmf fk. D sucfdt" tejt" D ejvk nm mtekr jbtkrnjtdvk jng klldhjhdmus rkfkgy
mtekr tejn tm jpprmjhe teds Emncbk Hmurt lmr tek rkbdkl ml XWJT ML SWHX
KNWSDKX rkstrjdndni tek Gklkngjnt 3 tm 8 jng tekdr fkn lrmf dntkrlkrdni
wdte tek pkjhklub pmsskssdmn jng knomyfknt ml tek Xhekgubk Prmpkrty cjskg
upmn suhe ldhtdtdmus kntrdks. Eknhk teds dntkrbmhutmry jppbdhjtdmn..
9. D sucfdt tejt" dl tek SWH KNWSDKX DX NMW XWJTKG cy fkjns ml Wkfpmrjry
Dnounhtdmn lrmf dntkrlkrdni wdte fy pkjhklub pmsskssdmn jng knomyfknt ml
tek sudt Xhekgubk Prmpkrty dn jny fjnnkr wejtsmkvkr pkngdni gdspmsjb ml
teds sudt" D wdbb ck put tm vkry irkjt ejrgsedp" drrkpjrjcbk bmss jng dnoury"
wedhe hjnnmt ck kqujtkg dn tkrfs ml fmnky mr fmndks wmrte. Dl tek mrgkr ml
Wkfpmrjry Dnounhtdmn ds pjsskg dn fy ljvmur nm ejrf mr dnoury wdbb ck
hjuskg tm tek mtekr sdgk.
5. D sucfdt tejt" D ejvk fjgk mut j prdfj ljhdk hjsk. Wek cjbjnhk ml
hmnvkndknhk lubby bdks dn fy ljvmur. Dl tek dntkrdf mrgkr ml Wkfpmrjry
Dnounhtdmn ds irjntkg dn fy ljvmur nm ejrf wdbb ck hjuskg tm tek mtekr sdgk.
Eknhk" teds Dntkrbmhutmry Jppbdhjtdmn lmr dntkrdf mrgkr" rkstrjdndni tek
Gklkngjnt lrmf dntkrlkrdni wdte tek pkjhklub pmsskssdmn jng knomyfknt ml
tek sudt Xhekgubk Prmpkrty CT XWJT ML SWH KNWSDKX JNG F[WJWDMN.
YEKSKLMSK" dn tek jcmvk ljhts jng hdrhufstjnhks ml tek hjsk" D
rkspkhtlubby prjy" tejt" teds Emncbk Hmurt ck pbkjskg tm irjnt jn kxpjrtk
mrgkr ml Wkfpmrjry XWJT ml F.S. Nm. 78-300;&0< JNG FS Nm. 7:-30:0&::ml tek sudt Xhekgubk Prmpkrty pkngdni gdspmsjb ml tek sudt dn tek dntkrkst ml
tek oustdhk jng kqudty.
D tek gkpmnknt ekrkdn" gm ekrkcy gkhbjrk tejt" teds ds fy njfk" sdinjturk jng
hmntknts ml tek jlldgjvdt jrk truk jng hmrrkht tm tek ckst ml fy anmwbkgik"
dnlmrfjtdmn jng ckbdkl.
PBJHK ? W[FA[S
GJWKG? GKPMNKNW
Dgkntdldkg cy fk
Jgvmhjtk
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
29/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
DJ 3-30::DN
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW-JPPBDHJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS : WEK JXXDXWJNW
HMFFDXXDMNKS
, MWEKSX
DNWKSBMH[WMST JPPBDHJWDMN XKHWDMN ; ML BDFDWJWDMN
JHW?&
Wek Jppbdhjnt-JPPKBBJNW dn tek jcmvk hjsk fmst rkspkhtlubby
sucfdts tejt" lmr tek rkjsmns swmrn tm dn tek jhhmfpjnydni
jlldgjvdt" teds Emncbk Hmurt fjy ck pbkjskg tm hmngmnk tek gkbjy
dl jny dn ldbdni teds jppkjb" dn tek dntkrkst ml oustdhk jng kqudty.
PBJHK? W[FA[S
GJWKG? JG\MHJWK LMS JPPBDHJNW
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
30/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
DJ 3-30::DN
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW-JPPBDHJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS : WEK JXXDXWJNW
HMFFDXXDMNKS
, MWEKSX
J L L D G J \ D W
D" W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS X-M W.X. HEJNGSJPPJ" JIKG 74 TKJSX"
AJWETJTDND ND\JX" 7WE HSMXX" JXEMA NJIJS" W[FA[S" gm ekrkcysmbkfnby jlldrf jng stjtk mn mjte js lmbbmws ?
:. D sucfdt" tejt" D jf tek JPPKBBJNW dn tek jcmvk hjsk. D jf wkbb
hmnvkrsjnt wdte tek ljhts ml tek hjsk. Eknhk" D jf swkjrdni tm tek hmntknts ml
teds jlldgjvdt.
3. D sucfdt" tejt" D ejvk ldbkg tek jcmvk jppkjb jijdnst tek SKXPMNGKNWX
qukstdmndni dbbkijb kntrdks dn SWHs jng ljak Futjtdmns wdtemut dssudni jny
nmtdhk tm rkjb mhhupjnts jng ajtejgjrs jng wdtemut jny rkidstkrkg gkkg.
Lurtekr" D sucfdt tejt" tek jvkrfknts fjgk dn tek jppkjb fjy adngby ck rkjg
js pjrt jng pjrhkb ml teds jlldgjvdt dn mrgkr tm jvmdg rkpktdtdmn ml tek ljhts.
8. D sucfdt" tejt" D ejvk prmguhkg skvkrjb gmhufknts lmr tek shekgubk
prmpkrty wekrkdn tekrk ds nm vjbdg irmung tm kntkr tek njfk ml rkspmngknt
nufckr twm dnstdtutdmn teds semws tejt tek kntrdks fjgk dn SWH jrk
lrjugubkntby fjgk wdte jn dntkntdmn tm tjak jwjy teds vjbujcbk bjng ml
jppbdhjnts ljfdby.
7. Wek kntrdks dn SWHs wkrk fjgk ckedng tek cjha ml teds jppkbbjnts jng guk
tm hmnvkrsdmn ml bjng lrmf jirdhubturk tm nmn jirdhubturk wk ejvk nmt
vkrdldkg rkvknuk gmhufknts jbb jbmni teksk ykjrs" nmn vkrdldhjtdmn ml dt ds guk
tm cmnjldgk rkjsmns" dt ds tdfkby nmt lmung jng rkhkntby wekn tek
rkspmngknts fjgk unbjwlubb kntry dt hjfk tm teds jppkbbjnts anmwbkgik.
Lrmf tek gjtk ml anmwbkgik tek jppkjb ds ldbkg dn tdfk dl tekrk ds jny gkbjy
adngby hmngmnk tek gkbjy dn tek dntkrkst ml oustdhk.
YEKSKLMSK" dn tek jcmvk ljhts jng hdrhufstjnhks ml tek hjsk" D
rkspkhtlubby prjy" tejt" teds Emncbk Hmurt ck pbkjskg gkbjy dl jny dn ldbdni teds
jppkjb dn tek dntkrkst ml tek oustdhk jng kqudty.
D tek gkpmnknt ekrkdn" gm ekrkcy gkhbjrk tejt" teds ds fy njfk" sdinjturk jnghmntknts ml tek jlldgjvdt jrk truk jng hmrrkht tm tek ckst ml fy anmwbkgik"
dnlmrfjtdmn jng ckbdkl.
PBJHK ? W[FA[S
GJWKG? GKPMNKNW
Dgkntdldkg cy fk
Jgvmhjtk
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
31/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW-JPPBDHJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS : WEK JXXDXWJNW
HMFFDXXDMNKS
, MWEKSX
DNGKU
NM PJSWDH[BJSX PJIKX: FKFMSJNG[F ML JPPKJB [NGKS
XKHWDMN :8
-
8/3/2019 REVISION PETITION BEFORE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER COURT
32/32
DN WEK HM[SW ML WEK GKP[WT HMFFDXXDMNKSJW W[FA[S
S.J. -30::
JPPKBBJNW-JPPBDHJNW \X SKXPMNGKNW
W.H. XJWEDXE A[FJS : WEK JXXDXWJNW
HMFFDXXDMNKS
, MWEKSX
BDXW ML GMH[FKNWX
NM PJSWDH[BJSX PJIKX
GJWK?&
PBJHK? W[FA[S
JG\MHJWK LMS JPPKBBJNW