scale bars for photogrammetry: user guideculturalheritageimaging.org/what_we_offer/gear/scale... ·...

18
Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guide July 2019: Document Version 3.0 To enable the measurement of an object or a site in 3D, you place scale bars on, around, or next to the imaging subject. When you process your series of images to create a 3D model, the processing software — CHI uses Agisoft Metashape Pro — finds the exact center of the targets on the scale bars in the set of photos. You then enter the precalibrated distance between the targets on the scale bar to set the scale of the project. Once the scale is set, you can get a highly accurate measurement of any feature of the imaging subject. Table of Contents About the Scale Bars ........................................................................................................................................... 2 Target Types ........................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Scale Bars Specifications.................................................................................................................................................... 3 How to Use the Scale Bars ................................................................................................................................. 4 Placing the Scale Bars ......................................................................................................................................................... 4 How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project ............................................................................................................ 6 Processing Data with Scale Bars ..................................................................................................................... 7 Set the Scale Bar Accuracy ................................................................................................................................................ 8 Detecting Markers ................................................................................................................................................................ 8 Examining and Editing Markers .................................................................................................................................. 11 Creating Scale Bar Objects ............................................................................................................................................. 13 Reference Information .................................................................................................................................... 16 Photogrammetry Resources ......................................................................................................................................... 16 How Scale Bars Are Calibrated .................................................................................................................................... 16 Thermal Expansion of the Scale Bars ........................................................................................................................ 17 Acknowledgments ............................................................................................................................................................. 18 Cultural Heritage Imaging Limited Warranty ....................................................................................................... 18

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetry:UserGuideJuly2019:DocumentVersion3.0

Toenablethemeasurementofanobjectorasitein3D,youplacescalebarson,around,ornexttotheimagingsubject.Whenyouprocessyourseriesofimagestocreatea3Dmodel,theprocessingsoftware—CHIusesAgisoftMetashapePro—findstheexactcenterofthetargetsonthescalebarsinthesetofphotos.Youthenentertheprecalibrateddistancebetweenthetargetsonthescalebartosetthescaleoftheproject.Oncethescaleisset,youcangetahighlyaccuratemeasurementofanyfeatureoftheimagingsubject.

Tableof Contents AbouttheScaleBars...........................................................................................................................................2TargetTypes...........................................................................................................................................................................2ScaleBarsSpecifications....................................................................................................................................................3

HowtoUsetheScaleBars.................................................................................................................................4PlacingtheScaleBars.........................................................................................................................................................4HowManyScaleBarstoUseinYourProject............................................................................................................6

ProcessingDatawithScaleBars.....................................................................................................................7SettheScaleBarAccuracy................................................................................................................................................8DetectingMarkers................................................................................................................................................................8ExaminingandEditingMarkers..................................................................................................................................11CreatingScaleBarObjects.............................................................................................................................................13

ReferenceInformation....................................................................................................................................16PhotogrammetryResources.........................................................................................................................................16HowScaleBarsAreCalibrated....................................................................................................................................16ThermalExpansionoftheScaleBars........................................................................................................................17Acknowledgments.............................................................................................................................................................18CulturalHeritageImagingLimitedWarranty.......................................................................................................18

Page 2: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 2

About the Scale Bars YoursetofprofessionallycalibratedscalebarsfromCulturalHeritageImagingisuniquelysuitedtotoday'spracticeofclose-rangephotogrammetry.

The10scalebarsinthesetareflat,lightweight,linearbars.Thesearecalibratedscalebarswithprintedtargetsseparatedbyaknowndistance.Therearetwoeachof5sizes,with6usingcodedand4usingnon-codedtargets.

Thescalebarsare:

• DesignedbyseniorphotogrammetryexpertsattheUSBureauofLandManagementforhighlyaccuratemeasurementandscientificimaginginphotogrammetryprojects.

• IndividuallycalibratedbyCHIstafftoaprecisionof1/10mmorbetteraccuracy.

• Printedon4mmALUPANEL®,atough,durablecompositematerialconsistingof2aluminumsheetsbondedoneithersidetoasolidpolyethylenecore.

• Notsubjecttodelaminationorwarping,optimizedforlong-termoutdooruse,water-andenvironment-resistant.

• Madewithagrayscalebackgroundwithhigh-frequencydetailstoenablethegenerationofameasurable3Dmodeloftheentirescalebar.

Werecommendthatyouprotectthescalebarsbystoringthemintheheavyplasticbagstheycomein.Ifneeded,cleanthemwithadampcloth.

Target Types

Therearetwobasictypesofscalebartarget,codedandnon-coded.

• Codedscalebarstargets

Threesizesofthescalebarshave12-bitcodedtargets.Thecodedtargetsareautomaticallydetectablebyseveralphotogrammetrysoftwarepackages,includingAgisoftMetashapePro,andautomaticallynamed(representedbynumbers).Thenumbersofthecodedtargetsaredifferentonallthebarsinaset,andCHIoffers5differentsets,eachwithuniquecodedtargets.Thisisusefulifmorethanonesetofscalebarsisneededinaproject.Thecodedtargetdesignensuresthattheprocessing

Page 3: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 3

softwarecanrecognizeeachtargetasuniqueandnotconfusethemwithothertargetswithinthesame3Dproject.

• Non-codedtargetscomeintwostyles:

• Non-codedcirclesareonthelongmeterbars.Theseareusefuliftheimagingresolutionofthecodedtargetsonthescalebarisinsufficientforautomateddetection(MetashapeProrequiresaminimumof10pixelsfromthecentertotheedgeofthetargettodetectacodedtarget).Thiscanoccurwhenyouusethescalebarswithlarge-scalesubjectslikesitesandlandscapes,wherethecameramaybedistantfromthesubject.Bysettingthetargetdetectionmodeto“Circlenon-coded”,thesoftwarecanlocatethetwolargeblackcirclesonthemeterscalebar.Thecirculardesignwithawhitedotinthecenterenablesthesoftwaretolocatethecenterofthetargetautomatically.

• Non-coded,cross-typetargets(alternatingquadrantsofblackandwhitewithinacircularboundary)areonthesmallscalebars(18cmand5cm).Thecrossdesignallowssomesoftwarepackages(includingAgisoftMetashapePro)todetectthemautomaticallyastargets,placingamarkeratthecenterofthecirclewheretheblackandwhitesectionsintersect.

Scale Bars Specifications

ThescalebarsarecalibratedbyCHIstafftoaprecisionof1/10mmorbetter,withtheactualcalibratedmeasurementbetweeneachtargetwrittenonthescalebar.

Meter Scale Bars (2)

Include3codedand2non-codedcirculartargets.Centersofeachtargetareapproximately25cmapart,withatotaldistancefromtargetsoneachendof1meter.Thebar’soveralldimensionsare108cmlongx6cmwide.

Half-meter Scale Bars (2)

Include3codedtargets.Centersofeachtargetareapproximately25cmapart,withatotaldistancefromtargetsateachendof1/2meter(or50cm).Thebar’soveralldimensionsare60cmlongx6cmwide.

Page 4: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 4

Quarter-meter Scale Bars (2)

Include2codedtargets.Centersofeachtargetareapproximately25cmapart.Thebar’soveralldimensionsare35cmlongx6cmwide.

18cm Scale Bars (2)

Include2non-coded,circularcross-typetargets.Centersofeachtargetareapproximately18cmapart.Thebar’soveralldimensionsare23cmlongx6cmwide.

5cm Scale Bars (2)

Include2non-codedcircularcross-typetargets.Centersofeachtargetareapproximately5cmapart.Thebar’soveralldimensionsare10cmlongx6cmwide.

How to Use the Scale Bars Tosupporthighlyaccuratemeasurementof3Ddataofanobjectorasite,itisessentialforphotogrammetrypractitionerstolearnthecorrectplacementanduseofcalibratedscalebars.

Placing the Scale Bars

Asyoupreparetoimageasubject,youstartbyplacingthescalebarson,around,ornexttothesubjectorsite.Youshouldconsiderthescalebarstobepartofthe“areaofinterest”foryourphotogrammetryproject,andmakesurethatyouroverlappingimagesetextendsbeyondthepositionofthescalebars.

Placethebarssuchthatthetargetscanbeclearlyseeninmultipleoverlappingimages.Whenoverlappingphotosaretakenofthesceneorobject,thetargetsonthebarsbecome

Page 5: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 5

markers.Themarkersserveasreferencepointsforscaledefinition,andalsohelptheprocessingtooltoaligntheimagesaccurately.Thescalebarsdonotneedtoappearineveryphoto.Theyshouldbewellcoveredbyoverlappingphotoswithgoodgeometrysotheircalibratedvaluescanbeusedtoprovideaccuratescaleforthewholephotogrammetryproject.

ImportantNote:Donotmovethescalebarsduringphotogrammetricimagecaptureofyourproject.Ifascalebarisaccidentallybumpedormoved,removeitfromthescene.Donotattempttoplaceitbackinthescene,asitwillnotbeinexactlythesameplace.Tobeusedaccurately,thescalebarsmustbeinaconstantlocationrelativetoyoursubject.

Thefollowingfiguresshowsomewaysofplacingscalebars.

Figure 1: On the left, four coded marker scale bars in place around a smaller subject. On the right, four non-coded cross-style scale bars are placed around the subject. In the Metashape Pro software, there is a limit of a 30-pixel radius (60-pixel diameter) to detect the coded markers. Placing the non-coded cross style markers eliminates this problem when using high-resolution cameras and smaller subjects.

Whenplacingscalebarsontheground,outsidetheprimarysubjectarea,youmusttakeadditionaloverlappingphotosthatincludethescalebarsinordertousethemforaccuratemeasurementinyourproject.Theseadditionalimagesshouldincludephotosthataredirectlyoverthescalebars.Ifyouonlytakephotosofaverticalsubjectwhenthescalebarsarehorizontalontheground,thenthescalebartargetswillbeobliqueinyourimages,andtheymaynotbedetected,ortheymaybedetectedwithhigherrors.Makesuretotakeoverlapping,“bridging”photos,tiltingyourcameranomorethan15degreesatatimesothatallthephotoscanaligntogether.

Inlargerprojects,placethescalebarsasfarawayfromeachotheraspossiblesothatyoucancontrolthescaleacrosstheentireproject.Forsomesubjects,itmaybeconvenienttoplacethescalebarsoverthesubject,butyoumaynotwanttohavescalebarsinyourfinalmodel.Inthiscaseyoucantakeimageswiththescalebarsoverthesubjectalongwiththesurroundingarea.Then,removethescalebarsandtakephotosofthatareaagain.Alignallphotostogether.Whenprocessingyourproject,youcanincludethescalebarimagesandthen“disable”(inMetashapesoftware)thescalebarimagesbeforebuildingyourdensecloud,mesh,orotherproducts.Thescale

Page 6: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 6

barswillhavedonetheirjobofscalingthesubjectorscenebutwillnotappearinyourfinalmodel.

Figure 2: Scale bars in place around a small kiosk-style building. Some are placed on the ground around the subject, and some are on the subject. On the right, two scale bars placed on the outside of a large painting. Two additional scale bars (not shown) are placed on the far side of the painting.

How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project

Whilephotogrammetrysoftwarecanaddscaletoyourprojectwithasinglescalebar,itisadvisabletoplaceaminimumofthreescalebarsinyourproject.Werecommendfour.Twobarsprovideabasiccheck,andthreeormoreaddconfidenceandstatisticalreassurance.

Usingfourbarsisideal,especiallyforlargerprojectsandoutdoorenvironments,becauseitisalltooeasyforascalebartobemovedbythewind,kicked,orotherwisedisplacedduringcapture.Ifthishappens,theprojectwillstillhavethestatisticalintegrityprovidedbythreescalebars.

Page 7: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 7

Figure 3: Four scale bars in place near an area of rock art and inscriptions to be imaged. These scale bars are placed near, but not covering, the inscriptions that appear above them on the rock.

Processing Data with Scale Bars Thereareanumberofsoftwarepackagesavailableforprocessingyour3Dproject.Thescalebarsinyoursetcanbeusedwithanyofseveralsoftwarepackages,thoughnotallpackageswillautomaticallydetectallofthetargetsinthesescalebars.CulturalHeritageImaging(CHI)usesAgisoftMetashapePro,andtheseinstructionsarebasedonthe1.5versionofthatsoftware.ThescalebarprocessingworkflowinAgisoftMetashapeProVersion1.5includesthesebasicsteps:

• Setthescalebaraccuracy.

• Detectthetargetsonthescalebarsintheimagesettogeneratemarkersineachphotothatincludesscalebars.

• Createscalebarobjectsbetweentherelatedmarkers.

• Addthecalibratedscalebardistancedatabetweentherelatedmarkerstothescalebarobjects.

Page 8: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 8

Eachofthesestepsisdescribedfurtherbelow.MoreinformationonplacingmarkersandcreatingscalebarscanbefoundintheAgisoftMetashapeUserManual,ProfessionalEdition,Version1.5,Chapter4,“Referencing.”

Set the Scale Bar Accuracy

ThescalebarsfromCulturalHeritageImagingarecalibratedto1/10mmaccuracyorbetter.Thescalebarsincludescribeddatato1/100mm.Theextrainformationistoeliminateroundingerrorswhenusinglongerscalebars,suchasthehalf-meterbars.YoushouldsettheScalebaraccuracy(m)to0.0001(thedefaultvalueis0.001).

Figure 4: Set scale bar accuracy.

Detecting Markers

Afteraligningphotosandoptimizingyourproject,usetheDetectMarkersdialogtodetectthetargetsonthescalebars,andusethemtoautomaticallygeneratemarkers.MakesuretheReferenceSettingspaneisvisibleandchooseTools>Markers>DetectMarkers(Figure5).

Page 9: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 9

Figure 5: Detect markers for scale bars.

TIP:Wesuggestthatyoustartwithatoleranceof50,andmakeithigherifnotalltargetsaredetected.

Figure5alsoshowsthedifferentkindsofmarkersonthescalebars.

ThescalebarsfromCHIincludethreekindsofmarkertargetssupportedbyMetashape,asshowninFigure5.CHIusesmarkertargetsthatarecircular12-bitcoded,circlenon-codedornon-codedcross.

Anadvantageofcodedtargetsisthattheyarealwaysnamedconsistently.Codedtargetsarenamed“targetxx,”wherexxisthenumberofthecodedtarget,printedonthescalebar.Non-codedtargetsarenamedsequentiallyintheorderthesoftwareidentifiesthem,andlabeled“pointxx,”butthenumberingisnotreproducibleindifferentprojects.

TIP:Ifyouareusingbothcircularcodedandcircularnon-codedtargets,youshoulddetectthecodedmarkers(thecircular12-bitmarkerinthisexample)beforeyoudetectanynon-codedcircularmarkers.Thisisbecausethecenterofthe12-bitcodedmarkerisacircle,anditwillbedetectedasanon-codedcircleifthereisnotalreadyamarkerpresentfromdetectingthecodedmarkers.Thenwhencodedmarkersaredetected,youmayhaveduplicationofmarkersinthecentercircleofthecodedmarkers.

Page 10: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 10

Figure 6: Detected coded and non-coded cross targets. Corners in the centimeter scale are also detected.

TIP:Ifyouarephotographingclosetoasmallersubjectwithahigh-resolutioncamera,andthesoftwaredoesnotdetectthecodedmarkers,itmaybethattherearetoomanypixelsacrossthemarkerinyourimages.ThelimitinMetashapeProv.1.5isa30-pixelradiusfromthecenterofthetargettotheedgeofthetarget(60-pixeldiameter).Inthiscaseyoucandetectnon-codedcircles,andchecktheboxfor“Inverted”,todetecttheinnercircleofthecodedmarkerasanon-codedcircle.

Themarkersoncodedandnon-codedcirculartargetsareplacedwithhighprecisionbecausethecenterofthecirclecanbedetectedalgorithmically.

Thecentersofnon-coded,cross-typetargetswithcalibrateddistances,aswellasthecornersofthesmallscalesmadeupofblackandwhitesquares,areplacedwithhighprecisionbecausethecenterpointofthecrosscanbedetectedalgorithmicallybythesoftware.Althoughyouwillrarelyusethescalesmadeupofblackandwhitesquaresforsettingscaleinyourproject,youmayretainanydetectedscalemarkersiftheyhavelowerror.Theymarkadditionalknownpointsthatcanaidthesoftwareinthephotoalignmentandcameracalibration.

Toseethemarkersthataregeneratedineachimage,clicktheEditMarkersiconinthetoptoolbar(theblueflag).Eachmarkerislabeledasatargetorpoint,withanindexnumber.

Formoreinformationonmarkers,seetheAgisoftMetashapeProuser’smanual,Chapter4,“Referencing.”

Page 11: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 11

Examining and Editing Markers

Afteryoudetectthemarkers,youcanseeinformationabouteachmarkerintheMarkersareaoftheReferencepane,asshowninFigure7.

Figure 7: The Markers area of the Reference pane after markers have been detected.

• TheError(pix)valueistheestimatederrorinunitsofpixelsforthatmarker’splacement.Youshouldcheckthesevaluestoevaluatethequalityoftheautomaticmarkerdetection.

• TheProjectionsvalueisthenumberofphotosinwhichthemarkerwasdetected.Werecommendaminimumofthreeprojectionsforanymarkerthatisusedtosetscalefortheproject.

Check the Error for Each Marker

Youcansortbyerrortofindthemostextrememarkererrorsinyourproject.Youcanreviewthemarkersonaphoto,removethem,orchangetheirpositions.

Ifyouintendtouseamarkertosetscale,werecommendthatyouremoveprojectionsonphotoswiththemosterror,orremoveprojectionsuntilthemarkererrorisbelow0.4pixels.(See“CreatingScaleBarObjects”belowforinstructions)

InMetashapePro,itispossibletoseeinformationaboutalltheimagesthathaveaprojectionforanygivenmarker,andtoseetheerrorinpixelsforeachprojectiononeachphoto.Toviewthisinformation,right-clickonamarkerintheworkspaceorintheReferencepane,andchooseShowInfo…fromthemenu.

Page 12: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 12

Figure 8: “Show Info…” box for a marker.

Youcansortthe“Value”columnforpixelerrorsintheShowInfo…dialogbox.Youcanremovethemarkerfromphotosthathavehighpixelerror.Youcandouble-clickonanimagenameintheShowInfo…dialogboxandthatimagewillappearinthemainwindow.Werecommendthatyouhaveaminimumof3projectionsforanymarkeryouplantousetocreatescale.(Seebelowonhowtoaddandremovemarkers.)

TIP:Aftersortingthepixelerrorsforeachphotowithaprojectionforamarker,youcanremovethemarkerfromanyphotothathasahighpixelerror.Removingthemarkeraffectsthenumberofprojectionsforthatmarker,sobesuretocheckthatyouhaveenough.

Youcanalsofindalltheimagesthathaveprojectionsforaspecificmarkerbyright-clickingonthatmarkerandchoosingFilterPhotosbyMarkers.Thencheckthemarkerplacementfortheimagesthathaveagreenorblueflag(indicatingthemarkerisbeingused).Todothis,double-clickontheimageinthePhotospane,andthenzoominonthetargetinthemainwindowarea.

Whenyouhavemadeanychangetoamarkerinaphoto,clicktheUpdateiconintheReferencepanetoolbartoupdatethepixelerrorestimate.

Check the number of projections for each marker

Markersshouldappearinthreeormoreimagesifyouhaveagoodimagesetwithproperoverlappingimages.Ifyouseefewerthanthreeprojectionsforamarker,youcanplacethe

Page 13: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 13

markerbyhandonadditionalphotos.Alternatively,youcanchoosenottousethatmarkerforcreatingscalebarobjects.Asdescribedabove,therearetwowaystofindthephotosthathaveprojectionsforagivenmarker.YoucanuseFilterPhotosbyMarkersortheShowInfo…dialogbox.Youcanthenremovemarkersthathavehigherror,orrepositionthem.Ifyoudonothaveenoughmarkers,youcanplacethembyhand.

Metashapesometimesdetectsadditionalphotosthathaveamarkerandshowsthemwithagrayflag,becausethereisnotenoughcertaintyabouttheposition.Thesepotentialmarkersarenotusedintheprojectunlessyouplacethemarkerexplicitlyintheadditionalphotoorphotos,asshowninFigure9.Ifyoudon'thaveenoughprojections,onewaytoaddmoreisbyexplicitlyplacinganypotentialmarkersinaphoto.

Thegreenflagbyphoto13inFigure9indicatesthatthemarkerfortarget72isbeingusedinthisphoto.Agrayflagindicatesthatapotentialmarkerwasdetected,butitisnotbeingused.

Toconvertapotentialmarkertoausedmarker,double-clicktoselectthephotowiththegrayflag.Inthemainwindowarea,hoveroverthebaseoftheflagforthesuggestedmarkeruntilitturnsred.Youcanthenright-clicktobringupamenu(notethatthemenuiscontext-sensitiveandchangesdependingonwhetheryouarehoveringoveramarkerornot).Toplacethemarker,choosePlaceMarkerfromtheright-clickmenu.

Figure 9: Placing markers by hand.

Page 14: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 14

Creating Scale Bar Objects

Theprocessingsoftwareusesascalebarobjecttorepresentthephysicalscalebarthatwasusedtocreatethemarkers.Youmustcreatethesescalebarobjectsfrommarkerpairs,afterallmarkershavebeencreated.

Tocreatescalebarobjects,selecttwomarkersintheReferencepane;thenright-clickandchooseCreateScaleBar.

Eachscalebarobjectyoucreateshouldcorrespondtoaphysicalcalibratedscalebarthatyouusedwhencapturingyourimageset.

Figure 10: Creating a scale bar from target 71 to target 72.

Adding Scale Bar Distances

ClicktheViewSourceiconintheReferencepanetoolbartoviewthescalebarobjectsyouhavecreated.EachscalebarobjectisassociatedwithaDistancevaluethatyoucansettotheexactdistanceinmetersbetweenthetwomarkersonyourphysicalscalebar.Thisistheinformationthatprovidesthescaleforthewhole3Dproject.

TheDistancevalueforascalebarobjectisinitiallyblank.Inordertosetthescalefortheproject,youmustenteradistancevalueforoneormorescalebarobjects.Thedistancebetweenmarkersinthescalebarobjectshouldmatchtheknowndistancebetweentargetsonthephysicalscalebar.Toenteraknowndistancevalue:

• Selectascalebarobject.

• Double-clickintheDistance(m)column.

• Entertheknowndistancebetweentargetsforthecorrespondingcalibratedscalebar.

TIP:Whileaprojectcanbescaledusingtheknowndistancefromasinglescalebar,morescalebarsarestronglyrecommended.Twobarsprovideabasiccheck,andthreeormoreaddconfidenceandstatisticalreassurance.

Page 15: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 15

TIP:Whenyoumakeanychangestomarkersorscalebarobjects,suchasmanuallyplacingormovingmarkersorenteringscalebardistances,clicktheUpdateicontoseetheeffectofthosechangesontheerrorsandestimateddistances.

Figure 11: Updating information about markers and scale bars.

Check estimated scale bar distance values

Inawell-shotprojectwithcrispphotosandproperimageoverlap,thedifferencebetweentheestimateddistancevalueforeachscalebarobjectandtheknowntargetdistanceinthecorrespondingcalibratedscalebarshouldbelessthantheprecisionofthescalebar.InthecaseofthescalebarsfromCHI,thisis1/10mm(0.0001meter).Eachtimeyouupdatethesourcedata,thetoolrefinesthescaleoftheentiremodel.Itthenusesthecurrentscaleandprojectgeometrytoestimatedistancesforalldefinedscalebarobjects.

Toshowtheestimateddistancevaluesthatarebasedonthecurrentscale,clicktheViewEstimatediconinthetoolbar.

Page 16: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 16

Figure 12: Show estimated distance between markers in scale bar objects.

InFigure12,thedistancevaluesyouenteredarereplacedbytheestimatedvaluesbasedonthecurrentprojectscale.Thetoolestimatesvaluesforallscalebarobjects,basedonthecurrentscaleithasdevelopedforthemodel.

• Thecheckmarksshowthoseobjectsforwhichyouhaveentereddistancedata.Fortheseobjects,theestimateddistancevalueisadjustedtoconformwiththecurrentscaleinthemodel.

• Theuncheckedobjectshaveonlyestimateddata,becausenodatahasbeenexplicitlyenteredforthem.

Youcanevaluatetheaccuracyofthecurrentscalebyseeinghowcloselytheestimateddistancevaluesforscalebarobjectsmatchtheknowndistancesbetweentargetsinthephysicalscalebarsthatyouusedtogeneratetheimageset.

TIP:Enterknownmarkerdistancesforallexceptoneofthescalebarobjectsthatcorrespondtoyourphysicalscalebars.Thisenablesyoutocomparethewhollyestimatedvaluewiththeadjustedvalues.

Reference Information

Photogrammetry Resources

• Photogrammetry Information ThereisaphotogrammetrypageontheCHIwebsitewithlinkstoavarietyofmaterials,includinganinstructionalvideoseriesentitledPractical,ScientificUseofPhotogrammetry.CHIhostsfreeuserforumsforpeopleworkinginthefieldofcomputationalphotography,includingaforumforphotogrammetry.

Page 17: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 17

• Photogrammetry Training and Consulting CulturalHeritageImagingoffersa4-dayclassinphotogrammetry.Thishands-ontrainingsessionisheld2or3timesayearinourstudioinSanFrancisco,orwecanmakearrangementstoconductthetrainingatyoursite.

CulturalHeritageImagingalsooffersconsultinginphotogrammetrytomeetawiderangeofneeds.Wecanhandlescientificimagingforyou,helpyouplanprojects,makeequipmentrecommendations,andmore.

How Scale Bars Are Calibrated

TheCulturalHeritageImaging(CHI)calibrationprocessusesphotogrammetry.Wehave"goldenmaster"scalebarsthatwerecalibratedmultipletimesusingdifferentcamerasandlenses,alongwithothergoldenmasterscalibratedbyseniorphotogrammetristsfromtheUSBureauofLandManagement.Weuseatleast4goldenmasterscalebarsinthephotogrammetryimagesetwhenwecalibratenewscalebars.

Inadditiontohowweimagethescalebars,wealsofollowanerrorreductionworkflowintheMetashapeProprocessingsoftware.Wereduceerrorinthephotogrammetryprojecttoarootmeansquareerrorofbetween0.13to0.15pixels.Weuseauto-detectioninAgisoftMetashapeProforplacingthemarkersonthescalebartargets.TheMetashapeauto-detectionalgorithmplacesthemarkerattheleastmeansquarescentroidofthedetectedtarget.Wemanagetheprocess,and,ifneeded,removeerrorfromthemarkers,asdescribedabove,toachieveanestimatederroronthemarkerplacementbelow0.15pixels.Weaddscalevaluestotheprojectfromourgoldenmasterscalebars.InourcalibrationprojectstheMetashapeestimatederror(foralltheestimatedgoldenmastersdistances)isbetween.000005and.00008ofameter(5to80microns).

Webelievethatourcalibratedmeasurementsareaccuratetoaprecisionof1/10mmorbetter.Ourtestingshowsrepeatabilitycloserto5hundredthsofamillimeter.Wescribethedataontothescalebarto1/100ofamillimetersoastopreventroundingerrorswhenaddingscalevaluesacrossthelargerscalebarsthathave3or5targets.

Thermal Expansion of the Scale Bars

Thescalebarsareprintedon4mmALUPANEL®.Themanufacturer’spublishedlinearthermalexpansionis2.4mm/mata100°Ctemperaturedifference.

Thistranslatestoalineardimensionalchangeof0.024mm/meterperdegreeCelsius(C)or0.013mm/meterperdegreeFahrenheit(F).Thelongercodedscalebarsarecalibratedevery25cm,sothelinearexpansionforthecalibrateddataforatemperaturechangeof1°C=0.006mmand1°F=0.0033mm. Thecalibratedscalebarsaremarkedwiththetemperatureatwhichtheywerecalibrated(generallybetween62°–68°F,16.7°–20°C).Ifyouwanttocompensateforlinearexpansion(forexample,ifyouareusingthescalebarsoutdoorsinawiderangeoftemperatures),youcanaddorsubtractthefollowingamountsforthetemperaturechangefromthenotedcalibrationtemperature.

Page 18: Scale Bars for Photogrammetry: User Guideculturalheritageimaging.org/What_We_Offer/Gear/Scale... · 2019-09-03 · How Many Scale Bars to Use in Your Project While photogrammetry

ScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide,v3©CulturalHeritageImaging2015-2019-AllRightsReserved 18

Temperature change in Celsius

Add or subtract the following amount for a 25cm calibrated distance

Temperature change in Fahrenheit

Add or subtract the following amount for a 25cm calibrated distance

+/- 5°C 0.00003 +/- 5°F 0.000017

+/- 10°C 0.00006 +/- 10°F 0.000033

+/- 15°C 0.00009 +/- 15°F 0.00005

+/- 20°C 0.00012 +/- 20°F 0.000067

+/- 25°C 0.00015 +/- 25°F 0.000083

+/- 30°F 0.0001

YoucandownloadabrochurefromtheALUPANEL®manufacturerwithadditionaltechnicalinformation:https://www.multipaneluk.co.uk/products/sign-display/alupanel/#panel-overview

Acknowledgments

ManythankstoTommyNobleandNeffraMatthewsoftheUSBureauofLandManagement,NationalOperationsCenterforthedesignanddevelopmentofthescalebars.Theirmanyyearsofphotogrammetryexperienceandseveraliterationsofscalebarshaveresultedinaveryefficientandhighlyaccurateproduct.ThanksalsototechnicalwriterJudyBogartforthedevelopmentandlayoutofthisdocument.

Cultural Heritage Imaging Limited Warranty

CulturalHeritageImagingIncorporated(“CHI”)warrantsthecalibrationdataonourCalibratedScaleBarsProducttobeaccuratewithin1/10ofonemillimeter.Weprovidetheabovewarrantyfor90daysaftertheshipmentoftheproduct.Weprovideaone-timereplacementofanyscalebarthatdoesnothavethislevelofcalibratedaccuracy.TheCustomershouldemailscale-bars@c-h-i.orgwithanyquestionsorconcernsaboutthecalibrationontheirscalebars.CHIwill,atitssolediscretion,determineifthereisacalibrationerror,andwillreplacethescalebarorbarsatCHI’sexpenseifitisdeterminedthereisacalibrationerror.NotethatthescalebarsareprintedonALUPANEL®whichhaslinearthermalexpansionpropertiesdescribedintheScaleBarsforPhotogrammetryUserGuide(theGuide)whichcanaffectthecalibrationdata.HowtocompensateforthermalchangesisalsodescribedintheGuide.

ExclusionsandLimitations

Exceptforthelimitedwarrantysetforthabove,CHIexpresslydisclaimsanyandallotherwarrantiesexpressorimplied,includinganywarrantyofquality,merchantability,orfitnessforaparticularpurpose,andyouspecificallyagreethatCHIshallnotbeliableforanyspecial,incidental,indirect,punitive,orconsequentialdamagesforbreachofanywarrantyofanytypeonanyCHIproduct.