sept 2001bruce davies1 experts, expertise & gp’s
TRANSCRIPT
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 1
Experts, Expertise & GP’s
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 2
Aims of Today
Understand what an expert is.
What an expert is not.
When you will use an expert.
When you will not use an expert.
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 3
Really………
That GP’s are experts too
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 4
Politics of Information
Where data comes from is important for interpretation.
Not black and white.
Agendas of providers and givers.
Eclectism.
Constant awareness.
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 5
First Task
Brainstorm sources.10 minutes.
Agree a list.10 minutes.
Issues of bias for the list.
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 6
Are Experts Subject to Politics?
You tell me!
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 7
Expert
Shorter Oxford English Dictionary.
1. Experienced, having experience.
2. Trained by practice, skilled.
3. Tried proven by experience.
4. An authority.
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 8
American Legal Definition
“an individual who is knowledgeable in a specialised field”
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 9
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 10
Medical Expertise
“Attempts at developing instructional methods based on a theory of expertise met with limited success”
“It became apparent that it was not a tenable goal to transform a novice into an expert by teaching the novice expert performance”
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 11
Answers
Or in other words experts giving novices answers does not develop the expertise of the novice.
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 12
Task 2
Small groups.
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 13
GP’s As Experts
Do we meet the definitions?
Areas?
Skills?
Development of…..
Sept 2001 Bruce Davies 14