Silver Linings: Thriving Through Sanctions

Stan Carrizosa, President, College of the SequoiasJennifer Hamilton, Dean, Modesto Junior College

Phil Crawford, ASCCC North Representative John Stanskas, ASCCC Secretary

Julie Bruno, ASCCC Vice President

2015 ASCCC Accreditation Institute

Overview

• Who is in the Room?

• Why are sanctions so nerve-wracking and stress-inducing?

• Review of current sanctions

• Panel discussion/support group regarding how to go about addressing sanctions

The Law

Our students need financial aid

• To receive Federal financial aid, students must attend a college or university accredited by an agency recognized by the Federal Government.

We need to be Accredited!

“Each community college within a district shall be an accredited institution.”

Title 5 § 51016

How does this feel?

• For some, like this…

Or worse…

• At some schools the stress of sanctions can bring out the worst in faculty members and administrators.

What are options that grant reaffirmation of accreditation but require additional action by

the college• Reaffirm accreditation, and request a Follow-

Up Report • Reaffirm accreditation, and request a Follow-

Up Report with a visit • Defer a decision on reaffirmation of

accreditation

Reaffirm with follow-up report

• The institution substantially meets or exceeds the Eligibility Requirements, Accreditation Standards and Commission policies, but has recommendations on a small number of issues of some urgency. The institution is required to submit a Follow-Up Report.

Reaffirm with Follow-Up Report and Visit

• The institution substantially meets or exceeds the Eligibility Requirements, Accreditation Standards and Commission policies, but has recommendations on a small number of issues of some urgency which, if not addressed immediately, may threaten the ability of the institution to continue to meet the Eligibility Requirements, Accreditation Standards and Commission policies.

Defer a Decision on reaffirmation of accreditation

• A Commission decision on reaffirmation of accreditation is postponed pending receipt of specified additional information from the institution or to permit an institution to correct deficiencies and report to the Commission within six months or less.

What about other Commission Actions?

• Warning• Show Cause• Probation• Restoration• Termination

Warning• When the Commission finds that an institution has

pursued a course deviating from the Commission's Eligibility Requirements, Accreditation Standards, or Commission policies to an extent that gives concern to the Commission, it may issue a warning to the institution to correct its deficiencies, refrain from certain activities, or initiate certain activities.

Probation• When an institution deviates significantly from the

Commission’s Eligibility Requirements, Accreditation Standards, or Commission policies, but not to such an extent as to warrant a Show Cause order or the termination of accreditation, or fails to respond to conditions imposed upon it by the Commission, including a warning, the institution may be placed on probation.

Show Cause• When the Commission finds an institution to be in

substantial non-compliance with its Requirements, or when the institution has not responded to the conditions imposed by the Commission, then ACCJC will require the institution to Show Cause why its accreditation should not be withdrawn at the end of a stated period.

• In such cases, the burden of proof will rest on the institution to demonstrate why its accreditation should be continued. The institution must make preparations for closure according to the Commission’s “Policy on Closing an Institution.”

Where Are We Now

Source: http://www.accjc.org/actions-on-institutions

College Warning Probation Show Cause RestorationCerritos College X

CCSF X

Crafton Hills College X

Evergreen Valley X

Golden West X

Hartnell College X

Imperial Valley X

LA Valley College X

Mission College X

Palo Verde College X San Bernardino Valley X

Victor Valley College X

West Valley College X

Total: 8 4 0 1

Some good news?

Panel

• Briefly describe your experiences with successfully addressing accreditation sanctions.

• How are sanctions helpful or beneficial to a college?

• Do you have any specific recommendations for colleges currently experiencing sanctions?

Questions/Discussion