the expressive self: gestalt psychology, art and personality
TRANSCRIPT
The Expressive Self: Gestalt Psychology, Art and
Personality
Aesthetics in the 18th century
• Aesthetics: study of perception, sensory experience as opposed to conceptual thought.
• About human perception of artistic form:Edmund Burke, Baumgarten, Kant, Shaftesbury
• Eventually also came to encompass notion of the beautiful
Gustav Fechner (1801-1887)1860: Elements of Psychophysics1876: Vorschule der Aesthetik
Weber/Fechner’s Law: intensity of a sensation increases as the log of the stimulus (S = k log R)
Conducted Studies on the Golden Ratio/Golden Section: Ratio of AC to CB is the same as AC to AB (1: 1.618)
Golden Rectangle AGFD
The ratio of the length to the width should be close to the Golden Ratio (approximately 1.618).
Ratio of AG/AD = DC/CF
Within this one large Golden Rectangle there are six other Golden Rectangles
Robert Vischer (1873)
“Über das optische Formgefühl”
(On the Optical Sense of Form)
Einfühlung (“feeling into”) became
popular in German psychological aesthetics beginning in the 1870s
History of “Empathy” as “Einfühlung”
German Psychological Aesthetics
From: Dekorative Kunst: Illustrierte Zeitschrift fuer Angewandte Kunst, Band 1, (Munich: H.Bruckman & Paris, J. Meier-Graefe, 1898) p. 76
Einfühlung as “empathy” “Not only do I see gravity and modesty and pride and courtesy and stateliness, but I feel or act them in the mind’s muscles. This is, I suppose, a simple case of empathy, if we may coin that term as a rendering of Einfühlung” (1909; 21).
Edward Bradford Titchener(1867-1927)
James Ward (1843-1925)Philosopher and Psychologist,
Professor of Philosophy and LogicUniversity of Cambridge
“With an image of a bunch of grapes the observer spoke of “a cool, juicy feeling all over:” with a parrot, of “a feeling of smoothness and softness all over me: not tactual [i.e. not cutaneous];” with a fish, of “cool, pleasant sensations all up my arms; slippery feeling in my throat; coolness in my eyes. The object spreads all over me and I over it; it is not referred to me but I belong to it.”
From: Titchener’s Laboratory, Cornell UniversityCheves Perky “An Experimental Study of Imagination” American Journal of Psychology, Vol. 21, No. 3 (Jul. 1910), 448
June Etta Downey (1875-1932)Studied at University Chicago
Professor of PhilosophyHead of Philosophy/Psych. Dept
At University of WyomingWrote Creative Imagination (1929)
Herbert Sydney Langfeld (1879-1959)Studied with Stumpf, University of BerlinProfessor, Harvard 1910 -1924Head of Psychology Laboratory, PrincetonThe Aesthetic Attitude (1920)
From Keat’s Hyperion:
“Upon the sodden groundHis old right hand lay nerveless, listless, dead,
Unsceptred; and his realmless eyes were closed;While his bowed head seem’d list’ning to the Earth,
His ancient mother, for some comfort yet.”
Subject D: “Perfectly clear-cut visual image of the old
man in the posture described. Tactual and kinaesthetic feeling of the sodden ground. Feeling of weight and relaxation
in right hand. Kinaesthetic feeling of bowed head and of closed yes. Auditory attention, with strain in ear”
Subject 2 ”Put self into the old man and slight tendency to get outside and
see old man.” (CI, 188).
Subject 3“As Observer I am north-east of visualized self and of old man.
Visual self about one hundred feet off, looking at old man who is twenty feet farther off.
No imitation of old man’s posture.”
Downey, 1912, p. 308
Wheeled clouds, which as they roll
Over the grass, and flowers, and waves, wake sounds,Sweet as a singing rain of silver dew.”
Percy Bysshe Shelley, poet
Subject M: “Movement in chest; spreading forward of hands in
space. Feet not on ground. Become the cloud; feel of the cloud. The cloud, if conscious, would feel thus.”
(Downey, CI, 189)
“There are hours when I go out from myself and live in a plant, when I feel myself as the grass, as bird, as tree-top, clouds—hours when I run, fly, swim, when I unfold myself in the sun, when I sleep under leaves, when I float with the larks or creep with the lizards, when I shine in the stars and fire-flies, when, in short, I live in every object which affords an extension of my existence.”
George Sand, as quoted in Downey, Creative Imagination, 1929
Entombment, by Raphael (Villa Borghese, Rome)
Pietà , Perugino(Academy, Florence)
The Dream of St. Ursula, Vittorio Carpaccio, 1495Gallerie dell'Accademia, Venice
Botticelli, Portrait of a Young Woman (Berlin)
Kurt Koffka
Max Wertheimer
Wolfgang Köhler
Kurt Lewin
GESTALT PSYCHOLOGISTS
Examples of the Phi PhenomenonMax Wertheimer, 1912
“Gestalt” = Form, Configuration
Figure-Ground Gestalt Images
Study of the Regular Division of the Plane with Horsemen , By Dutch artist M.C. Escher (1898-1972)
Rudolf Arnheim (1904-2007) Gestalt Psychologist of Art
Sarah Lawrence 1943-1968Harvard Dept. of Visual and Environ. Studies 1968-1974
Art and Visual Perception (1954)
Towards a Psychology of Art (1966)
Visual Thinking (1969)
But if I sit in front of a fireplace and watch the flames, I do not normally register certain shades of red, various degrees of brightness, geometrically defined shapes moving at such and such a speed. I see the graceful play of aggressive tongues, flexible striving, lively color. The face of a person is more readily perceived and remembered as being alert, tense, concentrated rather than being triangularly shaped, having slanted eyebrows, straight lips, and so on.
(Arnheim, Art and Visual Perception, 1954, 430)
Herman Rorschach1884-1922
Determinants“Experiencing Types”
Common response: bat, butterfly or moth
Common Response:.pink animal
Common response—blue crab, lobster, spider
Rorschach Testing, c.1930
The Psychological Corporation 1921
• J. McKeen Cattell, President• Approximately 20 psychologists as directors.• Guaranteed training and standards of its
members (compiled a “black list of charlatans and ignoramuses” to be avoided).
• Aims: construct standardized tests; vocational guidance; “people-sorting tests;” job analysis; efficiency engineering; research for business concerns; research on conduct and control.
Source: J. McKeen Cattell, “The Psychological Corporation” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science (Vol.110), Psychology in Business (Nov. 1923) 165-171
Thematic Apperception Test (TAT)
• Henry Murray and Christina Morgan devised it in 1935.
• Evoke unconscious fantasies
• Freudian bent to the interpretation
• Subjects offered their own interpretations of ambiguous social situations
• Subjects would project their own complexes onto images
From TAT
From TAT
Myers-Briggs Personality Testderived from Carl Jung’s 1921 Pychological Types
Check out the website:humanmetrics.comThis test ends up 16 different types