the on-demand economy survey
TRANSCRIPT
1
2
• Overview
• Key Findings1. Size and Scope2. Good Experience3. Optimism and Satisfaction4. Motivated Workers5. Concerns6. Tension Between Independence and Security
Table of Contents
3
OverviewPurpose and MethodologyBurson-Marsteller, The Aspen Institute and TIME surveyed 3,000 adult Americans to understand the size and composition of the On-Demand Economy in the United States and to provide insights into trends surrounding the On-Demand Economy and its participants (both workers and users). The research was conducted online by Penn Schoen Berland from November 16-25, 2015. The survey sample is representative of the U.S. population, with demographics matched to the U.S. Census. The margin of error for the total general population sample is ±1.79% and larger for sub-groups.
Audience DefinitionsGeneral Population, including: On-Demand Economy Participants: Have used or offered one of the services* in the past
Users: Have purchased or used one of the services in the past
Workers: Have offered one of the services in the past
Motivated Workers: Workers who earn a minimum of 40% of their monthly income through On-Demand Economy companies, could not find work at a traditional company or whose primary source of income is offering sharing economy services
Casual Workers: Workers who are not motivated workers
Non-Participants: Have not used or offered one of the services in the past
*TerminologyFor reporting purposes, On-Demand Economy services include ride sharing, accommodation sharing, task services, short term car rental, or food and goods delivery. Instances where questions were asked in the context of the synonymous Sharing Economy are denoted in the question text respondents read.
4
1. SIZE AND SCOPE: The On-Demand Economy is BIG, young and diverse 86 million Americans have used an On-Demand Economy service and 45 million have offered services
2. GOOD EXPERIENCE: On-Demand Economy users have had overwhelmingly positive experiences and value the opportunity, access and savings 75% of users have had all or mostly positive experiences
3. OPTIMISM AND SATISFACTION: On-Demand Economy workers are optimistic and generally satisfied with working in the On-Demand Economy64% of workers expect their financial situation to improve in the next 12 months
4. MOTIVATED WORKERS: While most workers casually offer services, there is a more dependent and motivated group One-third of workers earn over 40% of their income from offering services, claim that offering services is their primary source of income, or need to offer services because they can not find traditional employment
5. CONCERNS: While experiences have been positive for workers, they do express some concerns about the On-Demand Economy 72% believe workers should be given more benefits
6. TENSION BETWEEN INDEPENDENCE AND SECURITY: Workers attitudes reflect this tensionWorkers are split about whether they prefer the security and benefits of working for a traditional company (41%) or the independence/flexibility of the On-Demand Economy (43%)
Key Findings
5
SIZE AND SCOPE The On-Demand Economy is BIG, young and diverse
6
Sizing and defining the On-Demand Economy
22%
19%
17%
14%
11%
10%
9%
11%
6%
7%
Of -feredUsed
Ride sharing services where drivers use their own vehicles to transport passengers (e.g., Uber, Lyft, Sidecar)Accommodation sharing/ vacation rental services where people rent out their house, apartment or a room (e.g., Airbnb, VRBO, HomeAway)Platforms that connect people looking for services like a handyman, babysitter, care provider or mover (e.g., Handy.com, Care.com, TaskRabbit, Fiverr)Services through which people rent cars from companies or each other for short periods of time (e.g., Car2Go, Zipcar, Getaround)Food or goods delivery services where people deliver goods for people (e.g., InstaCart, Postmates, Caviar)
42% (86.5 million)* have used at least one On-Demand Economy
service
Number of Services Used:
0 58%1 21%2 11%3 5%4 2%5 3%
22% (45.3 million)* have offered at least
one On-Demand Economy service
Number of Services Offered:
0 78%1 11%2 5%3 3%4 1%5 2%
*The number was calculated using the estimated number of American adults with access to the Internet, which is required to participate in the On-Demand Economy
45.3 million (22%) of adult Americans say they have offered services, 86.5 million (42%) have used at least one service
SIZE AND SCOPE
Q: Have you ever purchased or used this type of service in the past? Have you ever offered this type of service in the past? Showing General Population
7
Workers
Participants are more likely to be male, younger, racial minorities and live on the East or West coastThese demographic characteristics are particularly prevalent among those who have offered services
Users
SIZE AND SCOPE
Q: Have you ever purchased or used this type of service in the past? Have you ever offered this type of service in the past?
Male Female
54%
46%
Millenials Generation X
Baby Boomers
Silent Generation
43%
28%22%
8%
White Racial Minority
54%
46%
60%
40% 40%60%
Male Female
61%
39%
Millenials Generation X
Baby Boomers
Silent Generation
51%
29%
15%5%
White Racial Minority
45%
55% 63%
37%
47%
53%
8
Few workers offer services daily and the vast majority have additional sources of income
Car Rental
Professional Services
Food or Goods Delivery
Accommodation Sharing
Ride Sharing
2%
4%
6%
6%
6%
14%
14%
12%
14%
16%
12%
15%
11%
10%
14%
12%
17%
11%
13%
15%
60%
50%
59%
57%
49%
Daily A couple of times a yearMonthlyWeekly Never
Q: How often do you offer the following services? Showing all workers
Professional Services Offerors
Car Rental Offerors
Ride Sharing Offerors
Food or Goods Delivery Offerors
Accommodation Sharing Offerors
2%
6%
3%
4%
5%
3%
2%
7%
5%
5%
17%
25%
18%
23%
27%
20%
25%
22%
20%
15%
58%
40%
49%
47%
46%
1%
2%
2%100% 40-59%60-79%80-99% 20-39%
Q: Approximately what percent of your monthly income comes from services you offer through sharing economy companies?
<20%
SIZE AND SCOPE
9
GOOD EXPERIENCE Users have had positive experiences and value the opportunity, access and savings
10
21%
76%
3%
Those who have used On-Demand Economy services have had an overwhelmingly positive experience
All or mostly positive experience
Mixed or mostly negative experience
GOOD EXPERIENCE
Q: How would you describe your experience with sharing economy companies? Showing Users
11
While adventurous and tech savvy, users are still concerned about privacy and trust
I like to try new things I am concerned about privacy I believe you can never be too careful in dealing with other
people
I consider myself tech savvy
87%
75% 75%69%
13%
25% 23%30%
GOOD EXPERIENCE
Q: Do you agree or disagree with the following statements? Showing Users
Agree Disagree
12
Users see a clear financial benefit, leading to greater access and opportunity to try On-Demand Economy services and products
81% 79% 80%
12% 13% 13%
GOOD EXPERIENCE
Q: Do you agree or disagree with the following statements? Showing Users
Agree Disagree
13
OPTIMISM AND SATISFACTIONWorkers are Optimistic and Generally Satisfied with Working in the On-Demand Economy
14
Workers are more optimistic about their financial past and future
Offerors
General Population
51
34
34
44
14
21
Offerors
General Population
64
47
28
41
6
11
OPTIMISM AND SATISFACTION
Now looking back over the past year, has your personal financial situation gotten much better, somewhat better, stayed about the same, gotten somewhat worse, or gotten much worse? Showing %
Looking ahead one year, do you expect your personal financial situation to get much better, somewhat better, stay about the same, get somewhat worse, or get much worse? Showing %
Total better Same Total worse
15
Workers express a great deal of trust in the On-Demand Economy and believe companies care about their workers
Sharing economy services are reliable
Sharing economy companies are trustworthy
Sharing economy companies care about their workers
68% 66% 61%
24% 26% 29%
Q: Do you agree or disagree with the following statements? Showing Workers
Agree Disagree
OPTIMISM AND SATISFACTION
16
MOTIVATED WORKERSWhile most workers casually offer services, there is a more dependent and motivated group
17
Comparing Motivated and Casual Workers
Who is a Motivated Worker?Someone who offers services and depends on the On-Demand Economy for at least 40% of his or her income, says the On-Demand Economy is his or her primary source of income and/or says he or she cannot find work at a more traditional company.
Motivated workers make up 7% of the General Population (14.4 million)* and account for 32% of all workers.
Who is a Casual Worker?Someone who offers services but does not rely on the On-Demand Economy for more than 40% of his or her income, does not say the On-Demand Economy is his or her primary source of income and does not say he or she cannot work at a more traditional company.
*The number was calculated using the estimated number of American adults with access to the Internet, which is required to participate in the On-Demand Economy
MOTIVATED WORKERS
18
derive under 20% of their personal income from the On-Demand Economy68% rely on the On-Demand Economy for
over 40% of their personal income 78%
Motivated Workers vs. Casual Workers
MOTIVATED WORKERS CASUAL WORKERS
74% are male
57%
67%
54%
48%
49%
are Millennials (18-34)
are racial minorities
are male
are racial minorities
are Millennials (18-34)
71% have offered more than one On-Demand Economy service 40% have offered more than one
On-Demand Economy service
66% 53%are married or living as married are married or living as married
62% 42%have children living at home
have children living at home
MOTIVATED WORKERS
19
Motivated Workers are significantly more likely to offer services on a regular basis
Series1
46% 45% 44% 40% 39%
7% 6%11% 7% 5%
Ride SharingAccommodation Sharing
Professional Services
Foods or Goods Delivery
Car Rental
MOTIVATED WORKERS
Q: How often do you offer the following services? Showing % At Least Weekly
Motivated Worker Casual Worker
20
36%
27%
23%
22%
22%
While non-financial motivators are similar between the two groups, the On-Demand Economy is more of a financial necessity for Motivated Workers
Offering these services adds to my income
I need to make more money thanI currently do
I like the independence the sharing economy affords me
I enjoy the flexibility of working
for a sharing economy company
I like the idea of being my own boss
33%
33%
32%
30%
28%
Offering these services is my primary source of income
I could not find work at a traditional company
I enjoy the flexibility of working for a sharing economy company
I like the independence the sharing economy affords me
I like being in charge of my own work schedule
MOTIVATED WORKERS
Motivated Worker Casual Worker
Q: Which of the following would you say best describe(s) your motivation for offering sharing economy services? Please select all that apply.
Showing Top Five Reasons
21
CONCERNS While experiences have been positive for workers, they do express some concerns about the On-Demand Economy
22
Workers, particularly those more dependent on the On-Demand Economy, believe that the On-Demand Economy is exploiting a lack of regulation
Series1
4758
72
52
26 29 2232
General Population All Workers Motivated Workers Casual Workers
CONCERNS
Q: Do you agree or disagree with the following statement: Sharing economy companies are exploiting a lack of regulation for immediate growth?
Showing %
Total Agree Total Disagree
23
Workers believe the On-Demand Economy should do more for its employees
Sharing economy workers should be given more benefits as part of their job
Sharing economy workers don't have the financial safety net other workers do
Sharing economy companies don't invest in training of their workers
72% 68%56%
18% 24%32%
CONCERNS
Q: Do you agree or disagree with the following statements? Showing % Workers
Agree Disagree
24
Majorities of workers believe that companies have an obligation to a social contract – to provide benefits, training and reimburse workers
Series1 59 9 32Employers have an obligation to their
workers to provide benefits
Employers do not have an obligation to their workers to provide benefits
Don’t know
Series1 62 10 28Employers have an
obligation to provide workplace
education and training
Employers do not have an obligation
to provide workplace
education and training
Series1 60 11 29Sharing economy companies should reimburse their
workers for some job-related expenses
Sharing economy companies should
not be forced to reimburse their workers for job-
related expenses
CONCERNS
Q: Which of the following is closest to your view? Showing % Among All Workers
25
TENSION BETWEEN INDEPENDENCE AND SECURITY Workers attitudes reflect this tension
26
41%
43%
16%
Workers are split whether they prefer job security/benefits of a traditional company or the independence/flexibility of the On-Demand Economy
“I prefer the independence the sharing economy affords me even
though I may not have the same job security or access to benefits”
“I prefer the security and benefits of working for a traditional company
even if it might mean less flexibility”
Don’t know
TENSION BETWEEN INDEPENDENCE AND SECURITY
Q: Which of the following is closest to your view? Showing Workers
27
Even though most workers believe the On-Demand Economy should do more for them, they are split on government regulation if it led to better benefits but fewer jobs
General Population
All Offerors
Motivated Offerors
Casual Offerors
37
40
47
36
28
12
4
15
34
49
49
49
The government should regulate the sharing economy to guarantee
independent contractors the same benefits afforded to full-time workers,
even if it means fewer jobs.
The sharing economy should not be regulated and companies should
compete to offer workers fair pay and benefits, even if it means less security.
Don’t know
TENSION BETWEEN INDEPENDENCE AND SECURITY
Q: Which of the following is closest to your view? Showing %
28
THANK YOUBurson-Marsteller.com/OnDemand