uncertainty of measurement nihal gunasekara sri lanka

94
Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka Bangladesh BEST Programme 1

Upload: dalit

Post on 11-Feb-2016

93 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Bangladesh BEST Programme. Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka. Bangladesh BEST Programme. What is a measurement ? Property of something How heavy of an object is How hot of an object is How long it is - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

1

Uncertainty of Measurement

Nihal GunasekaraSri Lanka

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Page 2: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

2

Bangladesh BEST Programme

What is a measurement ?

Property of something How heavy of an object is How hot of an object is How long it is A measurement gives a number of that property

Page 3: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

3

Bangladesh BEST Programme

What do you need for a measurement ?

InstrumentRulersStopwatchesWeighing scalesThermometers

Page 4: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

4

Bangladesh BEST Programme

How do you report a measurement ?

The length of table is 20 m The weight of the object is 3 kg The temperature of the sample is 50 °C The volume of liquid is 50 ml

Use SI units for all measurements

Page 5: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

5

Bangladesh BEST Programme

What is not a measurement ?

Comparing two pieces of strings to see which is longer Comparing two liquids to see which is hotter Comparing height of two persons to see who is taller

Page 6: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

6

Bangladesh BEST Programme

What is uncertainty of measurement ?

The uncertainty of measurement tells us something about its quality

Uncertainty of measurement is the doubt that exists about the result of any measurement

Can we expect accurate results from all measuring instruments ? A margin of doubt !!!!!

Page 7: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

7

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Definition of Uncertainty of Measurement

“ Non-negative parameter characterizing the dispersion quantity values being attributed to a

measurand, based on the information used”

JCGM 200: 2012 BIPM 3rd Edition

Page 8: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

8

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Measurement Uncertainty

U

X

U

A range containing the true value

Page 9: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

9

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Expressing Uncertainty of Measurement

Margin of doubt about any measurement !!!!

How big is the margin ? How bad is the doubt ?

Two numbers are needed to quantify an uncertainty

Width of the margin or interval Confidence level

Page 10: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

10

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Error Versus Uncertainty

Error : is the difference between the “measured value” and the” true value” of the thing being measured

Error = measured value - true value (reference value)

Uncertainty : is a qualification of the doubt about the measurement result

Page 11: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

11

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Error Versus Uncertainty

Error can be corrected !!!!! How ?

Apply correction form calibration certificates

But any error whose value we do not know is a source of uncertainty !!!!

Page 12: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

12

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Why is uncertainty of measurement important?

“ We wish to make good quality measurement and to understand the result”

ISO 17025 requirementsCalibrations & Testing laboratories shall have a procedure for calculation of MUWhere not possible for some test methods of testing labs, the contributing factors need to be identified and a reasonable estimation be madeWhen estimating MU all components that contribute to MU should be taken into account

Page 13: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

13

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Basic Statistics on Sets of Numbers “Measure thrice, cut once- operator error”

Risk can be reduced by checking the measurement several times !!!!

Take several measurements to obtain a value !!!!

Page 14: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

14

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Basic Statistical Calculations

To increase the amount of information of your measurement : take several readings !!!!

Two most important statistical calculations : Average or arithmetic mean - Standard deviation - s

Page 15: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

15

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Getting the Best Estimate

Repeated measurements give different answers

If there is variation in readings when they are repeated

Take many readings Get the average

Best estimate for the “true” value

Value of reading

Mean or average value

Page 16: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

16

Bangladesh BEST Programme

How Many Readings Should you Average ?

More measurements : better estimate of true value

What is a good number ? 10

20 would give slightly better estimate than 10

Page 17: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

17

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Standard Deviation – Spread of Readings

Repeated measurements : different readings

How widely spread the readings are ?

Usual way to quantify spread is “Standard Deviation”

The standard deviation of a set of numbers tells us “about how different the individual readings typically are from the average of the set”

Page 18: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

18

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Calculating an Estimated Standard DeviationExample :

Let the readings are 16, 19,18, 16, 17, 19,20,15,17, and 13 Average is 17Find the difference between each reading and the average ie. -1 +2 +1 -1 0 +2 +3 -2 0 -4And square each of thoseie 1 4 1 1 0 4 9 4 0 16Find the total and divide by n-1 (in this case n is 10)ie. 1+4+1+1+0+4+9+4+0+16 = 40 = 4.44 9 9 Standard deviation s = = 2.1

Page 19: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

19

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Mathematical Equation for Standard Deviation

1

2

n

rrs i

Page 20: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

20

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Where do Errors and Uncertainties come from ?

Measuring instrument - ageing effect, drift, poor readability etc

Item being measured - ice cube in a warm room

Measurement process - measurement itself may be difficult

Imported uncertainties – instrument uncertainty

Environment – temperature, air pressure, humidity vibration etc.

Page 21: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

21

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Distribution – Shape of ErrorsThe spread of set of values can take different forms

Mean or average reading

Value of reading

Probability of occupation

Normal or Gaussian distribution

Page 22: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

22

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uniform or Rectangular Distribution

When measurements are quite evenly spread between the highest and lowest values a rectangular or uniform distribution is produced

Range

Value of reading Value of reading

Probability of occurrence

Full width

Page 23: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

23

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Triangular Distribution

Probability of occurrence

Value of reading

Page 24: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

24

Bangladesh BEST Programme

What is not a Measurement Uncertainty ?

Mistakes made by a operator

Tolerances of a product

Specifications of instruments

Page 25: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

25

Bangladesh BEST Programme

How to Calculate Uncertainty of Measurement

Identify the sources of uncertainty in the measurement

Estimate the size of the uncertainty from each source

Combine individual uncertainties to give an overall figure

Page 26: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

26

Specify Measurand

Identify Uncertainty sources

Simplify by grouping the sources covered by available data

Quantify grouped and remaining components

Convert components to standard uncertainties

STEP 1

STEP 2

STEP 3

How to Calculate Uncertainty of Measurement

Page 27: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

27

Calculate the combined standard

Uncertainty

Review and if required re-evaluate large components

Calculate the Expanded Uncertainty

STEP 4

How to calculate Uncertainty of measurement

Page 28: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

28

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Estimation of Total Uncertainty

Type A evaluation – method of evaluating the uncertainty by the statistical analysis of a series of observations

Type B evaluation - uncertainty estimates by means other than the statistical analysis of a series of observations.

Page 29: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

29

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Type B Evaluation

Category may be derived from:

Previous measurement dataExperience with or general knowledge of the behaviour and properties of relevant materials and instrumentsManufacture’s specificationsData provided in calibration and other certificatesUncertainties assigned to reference data taken from handbooks

Page 30: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

30

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Standard Uncertainty for a Type A Evaluation

“When a set of several repeated readings has been taken the mean and estimated standard deviation, s, can be calculated for the set”

Fro these , the estimated standard uncertainty , u of the mean is calculated from :

U =

Page 31: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

31

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Standard Uncertainty for Type B Evaluation

“Where the information is more scarce (in some Type B estimates), you might be able to estimate the upper and lower limits of uncertainty. You may then have to assume the value is equally likely to fall anywhere in between ie. rectangular or uniform distribution “

The standard uncertainty for rectangular distribution is found from: U = “a “ is the semi range or half width between upper and lower limits

Page 32: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

32

Rectangular Distribution

f(x)

x

2a

a a

a21

Area enclosed by

rectangle = 1

2 aa

aa

Upper limitLower limit

Best estimate

Page 33: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

33

There are simple mathematical expressions to evaluate the standard deviation for this. Another such distribution we normally encounter is the triangular distribution

a a

2 aa

a a

a1

xf

x

Area enclosed by

Triangle=1

Page 34: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

34

Confidence Level

Gaussian probability distribution

-ks +ks68% Within 1s of mean k = 195% Within 2s of mean k = 299% Within 3s of mean k = 3

Page 35: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

35

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Combining Standard Uncertainties

Individual standard uncertainties calculated by Type A and Type B evaluations can be combined validly by “root sum of the squares”

The result is the “combined standard uncertainty” This is represented by uc

If the Type A and Type B uncertainties are a, b, c & d, then combined standard uncertainty is : uc =

Page 36: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

36

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Coverage FactorThe overall uncertainty is stated at the confidence level of 95% with the coverage factor k=2

Multiplying the combined standard uncertainty uc by the coverage factor gives the result which is called “ expanded uncertainty “ usually shown by the symbol “Uc “

Uc = kuc (y)

Page 37: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

37

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Reporting Uncertainty

State the result of the measurement as :

Y = y ± U and give the units of y and U

where the uncertainty U is given with no more than two significant digits and y is correspondingly rounded to the same number of digits

The nominal value of 100 g mass is 100.02147 gThe expanded uncertainty is 0.00079 gThe result of measurement is expressed as 100.02147 g ± 0.00079 g and the coverage factor k = 2

Page 38: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

38

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Statement of Uncertainty in Measurement Calibration Certificate :

“The reported expanded uncertainty in measurement is stated as the standard uncertainty in measurement multiplied by the coverage factor k = 2, which for a normal distribution corresponds to a coverage probability of approximately 95 %. The standard uncertainty of measurement has been determined in accordance with Guide to expression of uncertainty in measurement (GUM) JCGM 100:2008”

Page 39: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

39

Bangladesh BEST Programme

How to Reduce Uncertainty in Measurement Calibrate measuring instruments Use calibration corrections given in the certificate Make your measurements traceable to International

system of units (SI)

Confidence in measurement traceability from an accredited laboratory (UKAS, SWEADC, NABL etc.)

Choose the best measuring instruments for smallest uncertainty

Check measurements by repeating them Check all calculations when transferring data Use an uncertainty budget to identify the worst

uncertainties and address them

Page 40: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

40

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Some Good Measurement Practices

Follow the manufacture’s instruction for using and maintaining instrumentsUse experienced staff and provide training Validate softwareCheck raw data by a third partyKeep good records of your measurements and calculations

Page 41: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

41

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty BudgetsExample: Calculation of uncertainty of a balance calibrationCapacity of balance : 50 gResolution of balance : 0.1 mgMeasured max. Std. deviation : 0.0939 mgNumber of measurements :10Task : Calibration of scale value of 45 gMethod : A combination of three masses are required

Mass Value U95 (mg) k u (mg)

1 20.000088 g 0.019 2 0.0095 2 19.999995 g 0.019 2 0.0095 3 5.000030 g 0.0043 2 0.0045 Total 45.000113 g 0.0235

Page 42: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

42

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Observations:1st zero reading : 0.0000 g 1st reading of standard mass : 45.0003 g2nd reading of standard mass : 45.0003 g2nd zero reading : 0.0001 g

Calculations:Mean zero reading ( zi ): 0.00005 gMean reading on standard mass ( ri ) : 45.00030 g

Page 43: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

43

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

The basic measurement model is:Ci = Mi – (ri - zi )Where C is the calculated correction Mi is the calibrated value of standard mass ri is the mean of two repeated readings zi is the mean of two no-load (zero) readings

Correction : Ci = Mi – ( ri – zi ) = 45.000113 g – (45.00030 – 0.00005 ) g = -0.000137 g = - 0.1 mg (rounded to least count of balance)

Page 44: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

44

ss

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Source of uncer. (quant..)

Units Type of evalu.

Prob. Dis. Uncer. (U or s)

Divisor Stand. Uncer. uc

Cal. Uncer. umass

mg B Normal 0.0235 1 0.0235 0.00055

Resolution uresolution

mg B Rect. 0.1/2 0.02887 0.00083

Repeatability

urepeatability

mg A Normal 0.0939 0.02972 0.00088

Sum 0.00226

Comb. std uncer.

0.0475 mg

Cov. Fac. k 2

Expan.uncr 0.095 mg

Page 45: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

45

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Comparison of magnitudes of Standard Uncertainty Components

Std. m

ass

Scale re

s.

Bal. re

peat.

Expa.

Uncer.

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

mg

Page 46: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

46

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Calibration and Measurement Capability (CMC)HistoryIn order to enhance the harmonization in expression of uncertainty on calibration certificates and on scope of accreditation of calibration laboratories, ILAC approved a resolution at its third General Assembly meeting in 1999. ILAC and BIPM have signed a MOU to harmonize the terminology, namely the “Best Measurement Capability (BMC)” used on the scope of accreditation of calibration laboratories with the “Calibration and Measurement Capability (CMC)” of CIPM MRA

This document was effective November 2011

Page 47: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

47

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Calibration and Measurement Capability (CMC)

The scope of accreditation of an accredited laboratory shall include CMC expressed in terms of:

MeasurandCalibration/measurement/performance methodMeasurement rangeUncertainty of measurement

Page 48: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

48

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Calibration and Measurement Capability (CMC) In the formulation of CMC:“The smallest uncertainty of measurement that can be expected to be achieved by a laboratory during a calibration or measurement”

“The uncertainty covered by the CMC shall be expressed as the expanded uncertainty having a specific coverage probability of approximately 95%”

Page 49: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

49

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Calibration and Measurement Capability (CMC)

In the formulation of CMC :“ Take the notice of the performance of the “best existing device” which is available for a specific category of calibrations”

Consideration should also be given to “repeatability of measurement”

Page 50: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

50

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Calibration and Measurement Capability (CMC)Example:

SWEDAC

Measured Quantity

Method of Calibration

Range Readability Calibration and Measurement Capability( ±)

Calibration of weighing balance

MM/MA/01 0 to 200 g 0.01 mg 0.10 mg

Performance test of

laboratory oven

MM/TE/01 50 to 250 °C 1 °C 0.2 °C

One mark pipette

MM/VO/01 0 to 200 ml 0.001 ml

Page 51: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

51

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Examples

Example 1 : Determination of uncertainty of the mass 1000 g

Reference mass standard used : uncertainty given in the calibration certificate is 0.005 g at 95% confidence level

Resolution of the balance : 0.001 g

Page 52: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

52

Example of uncertainty calculationDetermine the weight of 1kg

Mean Value : 1000.1446 gStandard deviation : 0.0011 gEstimated Standard deviation of mean : 0.0011/√10=0.00035 g

Observation Value of test mass123456789

10

1000.1431000.1441000.1441000.1461000.1461000.1461000.1441000.1431000.1451000.145

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Page 53: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

53

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Source of uncer. (quant.)

Units Type of Eval.

Pro. Dist. Uncer. (U or s)

Divisor Stand. Uncer. uc

Cal. Uncer. umass

mg B Normal 5 2 2.5 6.25

Resolution uresolution

mg B Rect. 0.5x 0.4082 0.1666

Repeatability

urepeatability

mg A Normal 1.1 0.35 0.1225

Sum 6.539

Comb.std uncer.

2.55 mg

Cov. Fac. k 2

Exp. uncer. 5.1 mg

Page 54: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

54

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Presentation of Results

The result is reported as: The value of the test mass = 1000.145 gExpanded uncertainty = ± 0.005 g with k=2 at 95% confidence level orThe value of test mass is 1000.145 g ± 0.005 g with k=2 at 95% confidence level

Page 55: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

55

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Example 2:Calibration of an oven at 100 °C

Reference thermometer : Calibrated set of TC, uncertainty given in the calibration certificate is 0.5 °C at 95% confidence level

Digital thermometer with a resolution of 0.1 °CTest oven used with a resolution of 1 °C

The standard deviation of 10 readings obtained at 100 °C is 0.6 °C

Page 56: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

56

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Source of uncer. (quant.)

Units Type of Eval.

Pro. Dist. Uncer. (U or s)

Divisor Stand. Uncer. uc

Cal. Uncer. utc

°C B Normal 0.5 2 0.25 0.0625

Dig. Ther. uresolution

°C B Rect. 0.1/2 0.0289 0.00084

Dig. Ther.urepeatability

°C A Normal 0.6 0.190 0.0361

Dig. Ther.U cjc

°C B Rect. 0.2 0.1156 0.0134

Test Ovenuresolution

°C B Rect. 1/2 0.289Sum

Co. Std. u

0.08350.19630.44 °C

Cov. Fac. k 2

Exp. uncer. 0.9 °C

Page 57: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

57

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Dig. Th. U tc

Dig. Th. Ures

Dig.Th. Urep

Dig. Th. U cjc

Tes. Ov. Ures

Exp. Un.0

0.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9

1

Comparison of Magnitudes of Standard Uncertainty Components

°c

Page 58: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

58

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Sensitivity Coefficients

Sensitivity coefficient converts all uncertainty components to the same unit as the measurand

Ex. The standard uncertainty due temperature( u1 ):0.05 °C The standard uncertainty in the bridge (u2 ) : 0.001 Ω The standard uncertainty in diameter ( u3 ) : 0.01mm

Combined standard uncertainty Uc =

Page 59: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

59

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Sensitivity Coefficients

The general formula for the sensitivity coefficient is:

Where : ci is the sensitivity coefficient for component xi y the measurand is a function of xi

is the partial derivative of yi with respect to xi

“The partial derivative gives the slope of the curve that results when the function yi, the measurand, is plotted for the appropriate range of xi values”

Page 60: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

60

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty BudgetExample 3: Measurement of resistivity of a rod using the following equation

Where : R is the rod resistance in ohms l is the length of the rod in meters A is the cross sectional area of the rod in m d is the diameter of the rod in m

Page 61: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

61

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Input Data :Distance between knife degrees : 1.00003 m , unce. ± 0.01 mm, 95% CLMeasured diameter of the rod : 6.001 mmNo. of measurements of diameter : 10Estimated std. dev. Of diameter : 0.25 µmMicrometer uncertainty : ±3 µm at 95% CL

Measurement Data :Mean resistance : 604.44 µΩNo. of resistance measurements : 5Estimated std. dev. : 0.3 µΩBridge reading uncertainty : ±1 µΩRod temperature : 20 ± 0.05 °C

Page 62: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

62

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Components and their Evaluation

Rod diameter uncertainty ud

Type A evaluation:

The sensitivity coefficient c is obtained by differentiating the model equation for ρ with respect to d, thus

Page 63: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

63

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Components and their Evaluation

Micrometer uncertainty um

Micrometer uncertainty is 3 µm, um = U/k = 3.0/2 µm

Page 64: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

64

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Components and their Evaluation

Rod length uncertainty ul

Uncertainty value supplied is 0.01 mm

Standard uncertainty ul is calculated as : ul = U/k = 0.01/2 mm The sensitivity coefficient ci is calculates as :

Page 65: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

65

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Components and their Evaluation

Resistance uncertainty uR

Uncertainty of resistance includes several terms

a.Repeatability uncertainty urdg

Type A evaluation is

Sensitivity coefficient crdg is given by

Page 66: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

66

Bangladesh BEST Programme

b.Bridge reading uncertainty ub is given by :

( Assume rectangular distribution)

Sensitivity coefficient is as in the previous case :

Uncertainty Components and their Evaluation

Page 67: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

67

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Component and their EvaluationC. Resistance temperature uncertainty uT

The model equation has not included a term for temperature but the resistance varies with temperature as:

The model equation can be written as :

Differentiate this equation with respect to t then we get:

Page 68: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

68

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Components and their Calculations

As per data supplied the possible temperature variation is 0.05 °C

Uncertainty due to temperature variation is :

Sensitivity coefficient is given by : cT =

Page 69: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

69

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Source of uncer. (quant.)

Unit

Typ. of Ev.

Pro. Dist.

Uncer. (U or s)

Div. Stand. Uncer. uc

Sen. Coff.ci

x uc

=ui (y)

Rod dia. ud

m B Nor. 7.91e-8

1 7.1e-8 5.7xe-6 4.5e-13 2.03e-25

Mi. Ca. um m A Nor. 3.0e-6 2 1.5e-6 5.7xe-6 8.7e-12 7.61e-23

Length ul m A Nor. 1e-5 2 0.5e-5 -1.7e-8 8e-14 6.45e-27

Res. U rdg Ω B Nor. 1.34e-7 1 1.34e-7 2.83e-5 3.8e-12 1.44e-23

Bri. Ca. Ub Ω A Rec. 1e-6 5.77e-7 -2.83e-5 1.6e-11 2.67e-22

R. Tem. ut ° C B Rec. 5e-2 2.89e-2 6.7e-11 1.9e-12 3.71e-24

SumStd. Un.

3.62e-221.9e-11 Ωm

kExp. Un.

23.8e-11 Ωm

Page 70: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

70

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Rod. Dia.Ud

Mic. Cal. Um

Len. Ul Res. Urdg Brg. Ub R.tem. Ut Exp. Un U

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

pΩm

Comparisons of Magnitudes of Standard Uncertainty Components

Page 71: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

71

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Example 4: Temperature measurement using a TC

A digital thermometer with a Type K TC was used to measure the temperature inside a chamber at 500 °C

Specification of digital thermometer:Resolution :0 .1 °CMeasurement accuracy : ±0.6 °C

TC calibration certificate provides :Uncertainty is ± 2.0 °C at 95% confidence levelCorrection at 500 °C is 0.5 °C

Page 72: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

72

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Measure temp. (T) = Displayed temp. + Correction

Calculation of uncertainty components

Urept - standard uncertainty in the repeatability of the measured resultsUdig -standard uncertainty in the digital thermometer Utc - standard uncertainty in the thermocouple

Page 73: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

73

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty BudgetMeasurement record: Measurement Temperature °C 1 500.1 2 500.0 3 501.1 4 499.9 5 4 99.9 6 500.0 7 500.1 8 500.2 9 499.9 10 500.0

Mean value is 500.02 Standard deviation s is 0.103 °C Standard deviation of mean SDOM is 0.03 °C (Type A)

Page 74: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

74

ss

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Source of uncer. (quant..)

Units Type of evalu.

Prob. Dis. Uncer. (U or s)

Divisor Stand. Uncer. uc

Cal. Uncer. utc

°C B Normal 1 2 0.5 0.25

Cal. Uncer.udig

°C B Rect. 0.6 0.349 0.1223

Repeat.Urep.

°C A Normal 0.103 0.326 0.0011

Sum 0.3734

Comb. std uncer.

0.61 °C

Cov. Fac. k 2

Expan.uncr 1.2 °C

Page 75: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

75

Bangladesh BEST Programme

U (TC) U (dig. Ther.)

U (Rept.) Exp. Uncer.

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

°C

Page 76: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

76

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Example 5: Calibration of 250 ml volumetric flask

A balance with a resolution of 1 mg is used for the calibrationUncertainty of balance is ± 1 mgWeight of volumetric flask is 200.001gThree readings are obtained:

First measurement : 449.822 g Measured temperature : 20.2 °CSecond measurement : 450.055 g Measured temperature : 20.1 °CThird measurement : 449.892 g Measured temperature : 20.2 °C

Page 77: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

77

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

The volume at 20 °C is given by :

201*1*1*(20

tRRVb

a

awEL

Z values are given in Tables B6, B7 and B8 in ISO 4787 : 2010 for different types of glass at common air pressure Vs temperature

Page 78: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

78

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Measurement Weight of water (g) First 249.821

Second 250.054

Third 249.891

Mean value 249.922

Std. deviation 0.1195

SDOM (Type A ) 0.06899 g

Page 79: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

79

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Volume at 20 °C mlFirst measurement 250.55Second measurement 250.78 Third measurement 250.65

Average volume is 250.66 ml at 20 °C

Uncertainties :Std. uncertainty of weighing process U1 = 0.06899 g

Weighing uncertainty U2 = cer. Value/2 = 0.0005 g

Balance resolution U3 = half inet./1.7321 = 0.00029 g

Page 80: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

80

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Preparation of Uncertainty Budget

Sensitivity coefficient:

Page 81: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

81

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Source of uncer. (quant.)

Unit

Typ. of Ev.

Pro. Dist.

Uncer. (U or s)

Div. Stand. Uncer. uc

Sen. Coff.ci

x uc

=ui (y)

Repeatability U1

g B Nor. 0.1195 0.06899 1.003 0.0692 0.4789e-2

Calibr. U2 g A Nor. 0.001 2 0.0005 1.003 0.0005 0.2e-6

Resolu. U3 g A Rec. 0.0005 0.00028 1.003 0.00028 7.84e-4

SumStd. Un.

0.0048680.0697

kExp. Un.

20.14 ml

Page 82: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

82

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Uncertainty Budget

Rep.U1 Cal. U2 Res. U3 Exp. Un.0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

ml

Page 83: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

83

Estimation of Standard Uncertainty

Modeling of the measurement process

Y= f(X1,X2,X3,……Xn) Y- measurement result

X1,X2,X3,……Xn - input values

f - functional relationship

Bangladesh BEST Programme

The measurands are the particular quantities subject to a measurement

Only one mesurand or output quantity Y that depends upon number of input quantities Xi

Page 84: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

84

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Estimation of Standard Uncertainty

An estimation of the measurand Y, the output estimate denoted by y, is obtained from the previous equation using input estimates xi for the values of input quantities Xi as

y = f ( x1, x2, x3,………xn )

The uncertainty of measurement of input estimates are determined by :

Type A evaluation

Type B evaluation

Page 85: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

85

m

kkqq m 1

__ 1

Type A Evaluation

Mean

Standard Deviation 1)(m)( 2m

1k

__

kq qqs

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Page 86: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

86

Standard Deviation of the Mean (SDOM)

mqss q__

Standard Uncertainty

mssu q

A q__

Type A Evaluation

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Page 87: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

87

y = f(x1,x2,x3,……xn)

............)()()( 22

2

21

22

1

2

xUxfxU

xfyU c

)(...... 2

2

nn

xUxf

Combined Standard Uncertainty

Law of Propagation of Uncertainties

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Page 88: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

88

Expanded Uncertainty & Coverage Factor

U = k .uc (y)

U- Expanded Uncertainty

Uc (y)- Combined Standard Uncertainty

k- Coverage factor , obtained from the t-distribution corresponding to the level of confidence desired (95 %)

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Page 89: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

89

Reporting ResultsBangladesh BEST Programme

Results are reported in a “ Calibration Certificate” or “Test Report”Information to be included:Name and address of laboratory, and the locationUnique identification of test report or calibration certificateIdentification of each page Name and address of the customerDescription of item, including capacity or range, resolution, serial number, manufacture and model number, any identification number etc.Condition of received

Page 90: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

90

Reporting of ResultsBangladesh BEST Programme

Request received dateDate of performance of test or calibrationIdentification of method usedEnvironmental conditionsUncertainty of measurementTraceability of measurement including reference standards used eg. “Set of accuracy class E2 traceable to Primary standards maintained at Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution (BSTI) – certificate number……….” Name (s), function(s) and signature(s) or equivalent identification of person(s) authorizing the test or calibration certificateRecommendation of re-calibration should not be included

Page 91: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

91

Presentation of ResultsBangladesh BEST Programme

Example : Calibration of Volumetric GlasswareMETHOD OF CALIBRATIONThe volumetric flask was calibrated generally in accordance with the method manual Ref. No MM/VO/01 – Calibration of volumetric glassware by the gravimetric method,

TEST EQUIPMENT USEDDescription Model Manufacture Capacity Resolution

Precision Balance BP 221 S Sartorius 220g 0.1 mg

Liquid in Glass Thermometer - - -10 to 52C 0.1C

Digital Pressure Gauge Model 370 Setra 600 to 1100mbar 0.01 mbar

Liquid : Deionised Water

Page 92: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

92

Presentation of ResultsBangladesh BEST Programme

Calibration of Results

Nominal capacity(ml)

Volume at reference temperature of 20oC

(ml)

Expanded Uncertainty

U (ml)

100 99.87 0.08

The measurement results can be varied UThe reported expanded uncertainty in measurement is stated as the standard uncertainty in measurement multiplied by the coverage factor k = 2, which for a normal distribution corresponds to a coverage probability of approximately 95 %. The standard uncertainty of measurement has been determined in accordance with Guide to expression of uncertainty in measurement (GUM) JCGM 100:2008

Note: The user is obliged to have the flask re-calibrated at appropriate intervals Authorized by Test Performed by

Authorized Signatory Name Designation Designation page ( ) of ( )

Page 93: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

93

Presentation of Results

Bangladesh BEST Programme

Material Coefficient of Cubical Thermal Expansion

OC-1 *10-6

Fused Silica (Quarts) 1.6Borosilicate Glass 9.9Soda-Lime Glass 27

NOTE : Temperature effectWhen the temperature at which the glassware is used (t2) differs from the reference temperature (t1=200C), the corresponding volume change can be calculated via the following equation.

Where : is the volume change due to temperature change is the cubical thermal expansion coefficient of the material by which

the glassware is made is the temperature change

Page 94: Uncertainty of Measurement Nihal Gunasekara Sri Lanka

94

Bangladesh BEST Programme