what if inspections do not work? ir. rob van dorp (msc) inspectorate of environment and transport...

What if inspections do not work?

Ir. Rob van Dorp (Msc)Inspectorate of environment and TransportThe Netherlands

Inspectie Leefomgeving en Transport

Relentsless compliance problems

• Sometimes when regulation and inspections simply do not work. A regulator has to go “back to the drawing board” to invent a new solution to a societal problem.


Definition of a societal problem:

• Actor• Action• Harm• Limitations


A process approach


A simple example


Process analysis of the social process:

• Harmfull action:


Taking the individual perspective:

Tools, information, support


Taking the societal perspective:

Tools, information, support


Putting it together


To solve the problem, you change the process


7 strategys

• Strategy 1: creating awareness to the actor of the harm his action creates to society

• Strategy 2: negatively compensate the profit (fulfilled needs) of the actor

• Strategy 3: Filling the unfulfilled needs of the actor in another way• Strategy 4: taking away the tools, information or support needed for

the action• Strategy 5: Compensating the harm to society• Strategy 6: Changing the context of the action• Strategy 7: Adding tools, information or support to stimulate desired

behavior.


Strategy 1: creating awareness to the actor of the harm his action creates to society


Strategy 2: negatively compensate the profit (fulfilled needs) of the actor


Strategy 3: Filling the unfulfilled needs of the actor in another way


Strategy 4: taking away the tools, information or support needed for the action


Strategy 5: Compensating the harm to society


Strategy 6: Changing the context of the action


Strategy 7: Adding tools, information or support to stimulate desired behavior


A chain of processes


Thank you for listening,

• Rob van Dorp• +32704563273• [email protected]

what if inspections do not work? ir. rob van dorp (msc) inspectorate of environment and transport...

Documents