z bhubareswar 751 out, india -...

'tEf€-Ta

nry\Z

l)-

STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD, ODISHAIDEPARTMENT OF FOREST A EN-V^IRONMENT, GOVERNMCr.rrbi OOTSXElparibesh Bhawan, r;r18, Nirakanthi li jt u;f_ i/ t '

-

Bhubareswar _ 751 out, INDIA

No.

To pv 'reqs, rosl

The Secretary,Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate ChanoeGovt. of India, Indira paryavaran Bhawan.Jorbagh Road, New Delhi

Sub: Proceeding of public hearing for M/s Saraf Agencies pvt. Ltd. for proposedexpansion of 15 MW caplive.power prant, sooo-TpA rerro raitanium, IooS ipeFerro Man-ganese, 1-2 ipD aiuminium FL*ao "no

2.4 TpA scandium oxideRecovery ptant at Kanamana,. Tikiri-eerrrampur ;;; ari;;;i""J;;il;;ili;n",ChhatrapurTahasil of Ganjam aistrict._ reg;iJngSir,

Inviting a reference to the above, this is to inform that pubric hearing of the abovementioned project proposed by M/s saraf Agencies pvt. Ltd. for proposeo "ip"n"ion

oi rsMW captive power plant, s000^ TpA Feri raitanium, iooo rpA Ferro Manganese, 12TPD Aluminium powder and 2.4 TpA scandium oiii" ,""ou"ry plant at Kanamana,Tikiri-Berhampur and sriramchandrapur vittage, ctrhairapur Tahasir, Dist- Ganjam wasconducted on 16.09.2017 at 11:00 AM at the vacant space infront of Kanamana G.p.office under chhatrapur Tahasir of can;am uistiici i,i a"cordance with the Ministry ofEnvironment & Forest, covt. of India, EtA Noiitication No. SO-r533(E) dt. 14.09.2006.As per the above notification, notices inviting comments, views, objection andsuggestions from the pubric, in respect of the above proj""t *"" pubrished in newspapersnamely "The New Indian Express" and "Dharitri on IS.OZ,ZOtl .Further 03 (three) nos. of representations were received during pubric hearing, which

- are encrosed herewith for kind reference and further action during the considerliion ofenvironmental clearance.

A copy of the proceedings of the public hearing along with the following documentsare enclosed for kind information and necessary action at your end.1. Video CD of public hearing2. Statement of issues r?i:q by. prblic hearing meeting and comments of applicantprepared in local language and in English.3. Copies of the newspaper advertisement.4. List of persons who participated in the public hearing.5' Views and suggestions from the pubric receiveJ by the Board during the pubrichearing.6. Soft copy of the proceedings In pDF format.7' 03 (three) nos. of compraints were received during pubric hearing. (Encrosed asAnnexure - A).

Yours faithfully,

l-\f ,r1.1,,

MEMBER SECRETARV '

Encl: As above

Ht l .q -og-2o/V

, Copy along with copy of the proceedings of public hearing forwarded to the Additionalchief secretary, Forest & Env. Department, Govt. of odisha foi information and necessary

i l 2 t l

Memo No

action.

Encl: As above t\r-1111 r.l,

MEMBER SECRETAR.YMemo No !d t . l2-oq-2-o/V

co@iem Regionat officer, MoEF&cc covt.of India, A-3, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar for information and necessary action.

MEMBER rfr.l-1:liwtemotto /2/a-? lot .

Copy along with copy of proceeding of public hearing forwarded the Vice president(991geJ9ia!), M/s Saraf Agencies hrt. Ltd., Forum Mart (4th Ftoor), 99, Kharvel Nagar,Unit-lll, Bhubaneswar - 75{00{ for information.

Encl: As above

"=r"r*r*,,?lUr-

9

Annexure - A

Name of the percon who submitted represontations during publlc hearingconducted on 16.08.2017 for M/s Saraf Agencies hrt. Ltd.

1. Sri Dhanurjay Reddy, Chairperson P.S., Chhatdpur, Ganjam and Others'

2. Sri N. Narayan Reddy, President, Ganasangram Samiti, Ganjam.

3. Dr. Sidhant Mohapatra, MP, Berhampur, Odisha.

gPROCEEDINGS OF THE PUI}LIC HtrARING IN RESPECT OI''

T N V I R O N M E N T A L I M P A C T A S S E S S M E N T o F M / S . S A R A F A G E N C I I i SPRIVATELIMITEDFoREXPANSIONoF15MwCAPTIVEPowERPLANI . 'SO(}O TPA FERRO TITANIUM, 3OOO TPA FERRO MANGANESE' I21'PD

ALUMINIUMPowDERAND2.4TPASCANDIUMox IDERECOVERYPLAN. I .AT KANAMANA,

'IIKIRI-BERHAMPUR & SRIRAMCHANDRAPUR'

CHATRAPUR, DISTRICT- GANJAM

VENUE: AT THE VACANT SPACE INFRONT OF KANAMANA GRAM

PANCHAYAT OFFICE, UNDER CHATRAPUR TAHASIL OF GANJAM

DISTRICT ON 16'08.2017' AT I I .OO AM.

At the outset, sri Mitrasen Ma.ihi, Regional officer, State Pollution control

Board, Berhampur welcomed all the persons assembled in the hearing. Fle

briefed about the EIA notification, 2006 and the objectives of the public

hearing. He stated that M/s Saraf Agencies Private Limited has proposed to

have environmental assessment for expansion of 15 MW Captive Power Plant.

5000 TPA Ferro Titanium, 3000 TPA Ferro Manganese, l2 TPD Aluminitrnr

powder and 2.4 TPA Scandium oxide recovery plant at Kanamana, Tikiri-

Berhampur & Sriramchandrapur, Chatrapur, District- Ganjam and has applied

to obtain Environmental Clearance from the Ministry of Environment, Forcst

and climate change, Govemment of India and carried out Environmental

Impact Assessment (EIA) StudY.

: publ iciry regarding public hearing was made in the fol lowing manners -

. Advertisen'tents nnde through Oriyo daily "'l'he Dharitri" dated

15.07.2017 ancl an English daily "The New Indian Express" dated 15.07.2017

regarding the ventte, clate and time of the public hearing along wilh the places

of availabitity of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report, Executive

sttmmaries (oriya & English) rmd sofl copy in the ffice of Collectorute

Ganjant,Chcttrapur, District Industries Centre (DIC), Ganjam, Chief Executive

Offcer, Zilla Pari.shacl, Ganjam, Heatt Office of the State Pollution Conrrol

Board, Bhubanesr)or, Regional o/fice of the state Pollution Comrol Boarcl.

Berhampur & Departtnent of Forest & Environment, Govt of Odisha and ulso

in the website of State Pollution Control Board. Bhubane.stwrr

(\,tt fi: j)!p4),qd rd. o t g .

l -

l l r

\ i .N\:---

. Executive summaries along with paper clippings regarding date, tirre

and venue of public hearing were made urytiluble to the Kanantana Crant

P anchaya t, Sr iromchandrapur G ra m Panchayat, Arj ipalli Gram P ancha.vo t,

Kalipalli Gram Panchayat and Chamakhandi Gram Panchayat of Ganjant

district.

c Furlher, announcements were also made through loud speaker

regarding Public Hearing for information of the public in the surrounding

villages.

He requested the audience to express their opinion orally or in writing

on the environmental aspects. Then he requested the Additional District

Magistrate (Revenue), Ganjam, Sri Bijaya Kumar Dash, O.A.S. (S) to kindly

preside and supervise the public hearing.

The Additional District Magistrate (Revenue) Ganjam, welcomed the

people for attending the hearing with a message to the audience that they

should give their comments based on the Environment & Pollution related

aspects. He briefed about the project and elaborated the objective of

conducting public hearing in respect of any project seeking environmental

clearance from the Govt. of India. Then he asked the representatives of M/s

Saraf Agencies Private Limited to give the detail description on the project.

On behalf of M/s Saraf Agencies Private Limited, Kanamana Chatrapur.

Ganjam, Sri Bipin Bihari Panda, from M/s Centre for Envotech &

Management Consultancy Pvt. Ltd.,, presented the salient features of the

project, the present status of the environmcntal conditions, possible impact on

the environment due to execution and operational activities and the remedial

measures to be undertaken by the project proponent to reduce the impact rvhile

execuring the project.

IJe concluded that a suitable Environmental Management Plan has been

formulated and would be continuously upgraded to mitigate thc impact on the

differe-nt components of the environment such as Watcr, Air, Noise & Soil.

The Additional District Magistrate (Revenue) Ganjam, invited the pLrblic

to ofl'er their views, objections. opinions, comments and suggestions regardin-e

the proposed project; specifically relating to environmental issues. About 600

persons were present in the public hearing meeting. but only 87 persons signccl

in the attendance sheet. 127 persons rcgistercd in the del ibelat ion sheel ancl

102 pcrsons part icipated in the oral dcl iberation. 02nos. of r,vr i t ten

representations were received in the hearing. The attendance shects o1'

audience and deliberatot's along with the writtcn representations are enclosed

as Annexure-I, Annexure-II and Annexure-II I respectively.

The statements recorded are as follows:

01. B. Venkata Ramana, Vi l lage-Kanamana.

He addressed the gathering and welcomed the expansion project. He showed

his happiness and said that the local people are getting direct and indirect

employment due to the industry and hoped that due to expansion of the pro.iect

the local people will get more benefit. Fufther he said that more industry

should come up in this area for their development. Lastly he re{uested the

gathering to support the expansion project.

02. Sri Nabin Behera, Vi l lage- K. Arj ipal l i .

He extended his full support to the expansion project and welcomed it.

03. Umalata Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

She welcomed the project and said that the project should come up so that land

loosers will get benefit.

04.Sri Digambar Pradhan, Vi l lage- Kanamana.

He showed his apprehension and said that the establishment of the pro.icct

would affect the agriculture and increase the temperature of the surrounding

and opposed the expansion project.

05.Smt. Jasoda Kar, Vi l lage- K. Arj ipal l i .

She fully supported the establishment of the expansion project.

06. Smt. R. Jyoti Reddy, Vi l lage- Banabulapall i

She showed her happiness and said that they are getting employment due to the

industry and she fully supported the establishment of the expansion project.

07. Sri Ramesh Chandra Pradhan, Vi l lage-Chandrapada.

He fully supported the eslablishment of the expansion project.

08. Smt. Anahali Behera, Ward Member-Kanamana.

She fully supported the establishrnent of the expansion project.

09. S. Santamma Reddy, Vi l lage- T. Bcrhampur.

She ful ly supported the cstabl ishn-rent o1'the expansion project.

t ,

/ [.0

.0. Smt. Namita Beherao Village- T' Berhampur'

She fully supported the establishment ofthe expansion prqect'

11. Smt. B. Jema Reddy, Village- T' Berhampur'

She fully supported the establishment of the expansion project'

12. Sri Rabindra Nath Behera, Village- T' Berhampur'

He fully supported the establishment of the expansion project'

13. Sri R. Kamaya Reddy, Village- T' Berhampur'


14. Sri Surai Kumar Behera' Village- K' Arjipalli'


15. Sri S. Balaji Reddy, Village- Saradhaballi

He fully supported the establishment ofthe expansion project'

16. Sri R. Dandapani Reddy, Village- T' Berhampur

He futly supported the establishment of the expansion project' Further, he

t,op.a tiut the local area would be developed and more employment would be

generated due to the Project'

17. Sri Bharata Behera, Village- Kanamana'


18. Sri Somanath Sahu, Vit lage- T' Berhampur'


19. Sri R. Polleya Reddy, Village- T' Berhampur'

He fully supported the establishment of the expansion project and showed his

satisfaciion on the employment opportunity provided by the industry'

20. Sri Jirdtristir Behera, Village- Kanamana'

Hesairlthathehasnoanyobjectionforestablishmentoftheexpansionproject.

2t. Sri a.nol Kumar Behera, Vil lage- Kanamana

He fully supported the establishment of the expansion pro'iect'

l - -

\+l

,-2. Sri Panchami Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

He welcomed the establishment of the expansion project and said that they

fully suPPort it.

23. Sri B. Bairagi, Village- T. Berhampur'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project'

24. Sri Bikram Behera, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

Hewelcomedandsuppor ted thees tab l i shmento f theexpans ionpro jec t .F le

further showed his disappointment for those who are not supporting the

proJect.

25. Sri B. Simadri, Village- T. Berhampur'

Hewelcomedandsuppor ted thees tab l i shmento f theexpans ionpro jec tand

said that educated people will never oppose such types ofproject'

26. Sri S. Chakrapani Reddy, Vi l lage- Sarapanclra, Kanamana'

He addressed the gatherings and the chair and welcomed the establishment of

the expansion project. He said that they are happy with the employment

opportunity given by the company. Further he added that they are fully

suppor t ing thepro jec t fo r the i r loca ldeve lopmentsbe ingcar r iedout th rough

Gramya Kalyan Samiti. He demanded that the pollution aspects shall be taken

care ofby the project proponent. Lastly he supported & welcomed the pro.ject

: once again.

27. Smt. Rasmita Behera, Samit i Sabhya, Kanamana G'P'

She addressed the gatherings and supported the pro.lect and opined that the

Environment and climate of surrounding should be properly maintained so

that there should not be any adverse effect.

28. Sri N. Krishna Reddy, Vi l lage-T. Berhampur"

He welcomed and supported the establishment ofthe expansion project'

29. Sri Rama Chandra Sahu, Kanamana.

I iewe lcomedandsuppor ledrhees tab l i shmento f theexpans ionpro . jec t .

30. Smt. Usharani Behera, Naib Sarapanch, Kanamana G'P'

Shc fully supportecl the establishrnent of the expansion pro.iect and expectccl

that unemplovnent wi l l not be there after e stabl ishrncnt o1'the pro.ject.

iI r.q

.il. Sri P. Bhagirathi Reddy' Village-T. Berhampur

Hewelcomedandsupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionproject.

32. Sri Di l l ip Pradhan' Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

H e w e l c o m e d t h e g a t h e r i n g s a n d f u l l y s u p p o r t e d t h e e s t a b l i s h m e n t o f t h e

expansion Project.

33. Sri S. Ganesh Reddy, Village-T. Berhampur'

He fully supported the establishment ofthe expansion project'

34. Sri Trinath Behera, Village- T. Berhampur'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion pioject and

demanded that the nature, environment must be taken care by the authority

35, Sri Suresh Kumar Behera, Village- Kanamana'


36. Sri Basanta Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

He supported the establishment of the expansion project'

37. Sri Tankadhara Behera, Village- K' Arjipalli'


38. Sri S. Narsumulu Reddy, Vi l lage- T. Berhampur'

t H" ruppo.t.d the establishment ofthe expansion project'

39. Sri Judhist ir Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana'


40. Sri P. Sanyasi Reddy, Vi l lage-T. Berhampur'

Hewelcomedanclsupportedtheestabl jshnrentoftheexpansionproject.

41. Sri Parsuram Pradhan, Vi l lage-Chandrapada'

He supporred the establishment of the expansion project'

42. Sri V. Gopal Rao, Vi l lage-Kanamana.

He greeted the gatherings and supported the establishn-rent of the expanstorr

Drolect.

!

v'j3. Sri R. Gopal Reddy' Village-T' Berhampur'


44. Sri Laxmi Narayan Maharana, Village-T'Berhampur'

Hewelcomedthegatheringsandsupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionproject.

45. Sri Raghunath Nayak, Vi l lage-Chandrapada'


46. Sri E. Dharma Reddy, Village-T'Berhampur'


47. Sri S. Kama Raju Reddy, Village-T'Berhampur'


48. Sri S. Pitambar Reddy, Village-Saradhaballi'


49. Sri Harekrushna Behera, Vi l lage-T' Berhampur'


50. Sri Jugal Kishore Nayak, Vi l lage-Chandrapada'

.Hewelcomedtheaud ienceandsuppor ted thees tab l i shmento f theexpans ion

proJect.

51. Sri Jagannath Sahu, Vi l lage-T' Berhampur'

He welcorned and supported the establishment of the expansion project and

demanded that the pio.i""t proponent should take care of the environmental

pollution of the surrounding.

52. Sri P. Babu Rao, Vi l lage-Mayapatna'

He sup.portcd the establishment of the expansion proiect'

53. Sri K. Uttam Prasad Swamyo Vil lage-Kanamana'

He we lcomecl and supported the establishment of the expansion project

54. Sri B. Kamaraju Reddy, Vi l lage- T' Berhampur'

He rvelcomecl and suppofied the establishment of the expanslon pro'lect'

I ' I ^

Y

-j5. Sri Laxmi Narayan Behera, Village- Kanamana'

HewelcomedandSupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionproject '

56. Sri S. Trinath Reddy, Vi l lage- T' Berhampur'

He welcomed and suppofted the establishment of the expansion project'

57. Sri K. Srinivas Swamy, Vi l lage- Kanamana'


58. Sri Santosh Sethi, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion projept'

59. Sri Pradeep Kumar Behera, Village- Kanamana'


60. Sri Bhubani Nayak, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

Hewelcomedandsupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionpfoject.

61. Sri Praful la Kumar Nayak, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'


62. Sri Sudarsana Behera, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'


63. Sri Balaram Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

Hewelcomedandsupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionpro|ect '

64. Sri Dayanidhi Sahu, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

Hewelcomedandsupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionproject '

65. Sri Dayanidhi Sahu, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project

66. Sri Rabindra Kumar Sahu, Vi l lage- Puruna Chatrapur'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project

67. Sri Krushna Chantlra Pratlhan, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

He rvelcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion pro-icct'

{ / \

' -8. Sri Chitta Ranjan Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

He welcomed and supported the establishment' of the expansion proiect He

further suggested to speed up the expansion 'uvork'

69. Sri Santosh Kumar Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'


70. Sri Ranjan Pradhan,, Vi l lage- Chandrapada'

Hewelcomedthegatheringsandsupportedtheestabl ishmentoftheexpansionproject and demanded for"employment to the local people and the peripheral

area.

71. Sri G. Aiya, President Gopalpur Port Dock Workers Union'

He supporled the project & emphasized on use.of Gopalpur Port by the Project

Proponent lbr imporl & exporl activities, Social & Economical development of

the locality, proper address of the environmental issues' development of

olantation ln iO fito-.ter radius of the project and employment oppoftunrty

io the local peoPle.

72. Sri Rajendra Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana'


73. Sri N. Duryodhana Reddy, Samit i Sabhya' Laxmipur G'P'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project and

: demanded for local ".ptoy-.nt

and plantation activity in the surrounding

area. Further he demanded fo. ttuntpottution of coal through Gopalpur Ports

Ltd. instead ofthe proposed Paradeep Port Ltd'

74, Sri Himanshu Kumar Pradhan, Vi l lage-Chandrapada'

He supported the expansion project and demanded for proper management ot

the environmental pollution so ihat thett shall not be any effect to the local

area. Further he demanded for the peripheral development'

75. Sri K..Al laya, Ex- Sarapanch, Vi l lage- Sana Ari ipal l i '

Hewelcomec l thegather ingsandsuppor ted thees tab l i shmento f theexpans iunproject. tle suggested that the company must manage the Environmental

iottution o, p.i the EIA & EMP. He u,as satisfied by the employment

opportunity being generated by the company'

\j:,

)6. Sri Govinda Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana.

He welcomed and supported the establishment-of the expansion project.

77. Sri Soumya Ranjan Nayak, Student Leader, Chatrapur'

In his deliberation he emphasized on more and more industrialization in the

area so that the local people could get employment opportunity and social

development could occured. Lastly he supported the establishment of the

expansion project.

78. Sri S. Narasingha Reddy, Vi l lage- Kanamana.

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project.

79. Sri Padma Charan Sahu, Ex-Sarapanch, Kal ipal l i ' G.P.

He supported the project with the conditions that the project proponent should

take adequate steps for control of Environmental Pollution & employment to

the local people.

80. Sri Lingaraj Nayak, President Hari jan Kalyan Samit i ' Chatrapur.

He welcomed and supported the establishment ofthe expansion project.

81. Sri Sunil Kumar Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana.

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project.

82. Sri G. Dallaya, Vi l lage- Bada Arj ipal l i .

I He addressed the gatherings and supported the establishment of the expansion

project & requested the gathering to welcome the project.

83. Sri P. Lambodar Reddy, Vi l lage- Kal ipal l i .

He welcomed the project and demanded that the project proponent should give

first preference in crrployment opportunity to the land looser and then to the

local people.

84. Sri Madhusudan Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana.

He supponed the establishment of the expansion project.

85. Sri Laxmi Narayan Panda, Vi l lage- Chatrapur.

I- le said that the industry should come up and should give employment to the

af lecte d l'arnilies and the peripheral people

\ r /

. .16. Sri S. Janardan Reddy' Vi l lage- Gedalpal l i '


87. Sri S. K. Sahu, Advocate, Vitlage- Chamakhandi'

Hesa id tha t theEnv i ronmenta lpo l lu t ionshou ldbeproper lycont ro l ledandtheprojectproponentshouldgiveimporlanceforHydroElectr icProjectinsteadot-

it ." tt "rrnul

power plant. Lastly he suppofted the project with a suggestron

that the expenditure made towaids cSR should be shown with proof and the

proposed water management should be cross checked as the same was not

feasible 25 Years back.

88. Sri N. Naryan Reddy, Ex- MLA, Chatrapur'

He addressed the gathering and emphasized on more and more employment'

He said that they are not opposing the project but works should be done by the

proponent as per the p..uiout agieement' He demanded that the SOz emissron

,tlouta U" reduced below the norm. Lastly, he supported the project'

89. Sri Sibaram Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chasa Kanamana'




91. Sri Manoranjan Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chasa Kanamana'

: He welcomed and supporled the establishment of the expansion project'

92. Sri Duryodhan Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

Hewelcomedandsuppor ted thees tab l i shmento f theexpans ionpro jec tand

demanded for employment to the local people and requested to the company

authority to provide Ambulance facility to the villagers of 05 (five) nos. of

sorrounding Gram PanchaYats.

93. Sri S. Baihuntha Reddy, Vi l lage- T' Berhampur'


(€,

]4. Sri Parasa Chandra Sekhar, Village- Chatrapur.

He spoke in his original language and said that the plant should come up but

the Company should control the environmental pollution like emission of CO:,

NOx & SO2,, it should use high grade coal to control the environmental

pollution and construct one water barrage at river Rusikulya and the Rusikulya

water should be used in the industry instead ofuse ofground water.

95. Sri Ashok Choudhury, Ex-MLA' Chatrapur.

He welcomed the project and demanded lbr control of environmental

pollution & provide employment to local people and CSR activity should be

properly done in the locality.

96. Sri Dhiren Kumar Sahu, Village- T. Berhampur.

He welcomed the project.

97. Sri A. Sibaram Reddy, Vi l tage- T. Berhampur.

He welcomed the pro.1ect.

98. Sri A. Krishna Reddy, Vi l lage- T. Berhampur.

He \velcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project.

99. Sri Chandrasen Behera, Vi l lage- Puruna Chatrapur.

He fully supported the establishment of the expansion project.

100. Sri T. Gopinath Reddy, Vi l lage- Puruna Chatrapur.

He supported the project.

l0l . Sri Krushna Chandra Nayak, Youth Leader, Chatrapur.

He,uvelcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion proJect.

102. Sri B. Chandramani Patra' Vi l lage- Kal ipal l i .

He welcomed the gatherings and supported the establishment of the expansion

project and demanded that the project must be established without failure.

l l

. , ').\ b /

.16. Sri S. Janardan Reddy, Vi l lage- Gedalpal l i '


87. Sri S. K. Sahu, Advocate, Vi l lage- Chamakhandi '

He said that the Environmental pollution should be properly controlled and the

project proponent should give importance for Hydro Electric Project instead o1'

in"-fn.in-,ut power Plant. Lastly he supported the project with a suggestion

that the expenditure made towards cSR should be shown with proof and the

proposed water management should be cross checked as the same was not

feasible 25 years back.

88. Sri N. Naryan Reddy, Ex- MLA' Chatrapur'

He addressed the gathering and emphasized on more and more employment'

He said that they are not opposing the project but works should be done by the

proponent as pei the pre.'ibus agreement. He demanded that the SOu emission

should be reduced below the norm. Lastly, he supported the project'

89. Sri Sibaram Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chasa Kanamana'




91. Sri Manoranjan Pradhan, Vi l lage- Chasa Kanamana'

,Hewelcomedandsuppor ted thees tab l i shmento f theexpans ionpro jec t .

92. Sri Duryodhan Behera, Vi l lage- Kanamana'

He welcomed and supported the establishment of the expansion project and

demanded lbr employment to the local people and requested to the company

authority to provide Ambulance facility to the villagers of 05 (five) nos. of

sonounding Gram PanchaYats.

93. Sri S. Baihuntha Reddy, Vi l lage- T. Berhampur'

He wglcomed and suppofted the establishment of the expansion project'

j

\ ; jL

)4. Sri Parasa Chandra Sekhar, Village- Chatrapur'

Hespoke inh isor ig ina l languageandsa id thaLthep lan tshou ldcomeup-butthe iompany shoul4 control the environmental pollution like emission of CO:'

NOx & SOz, it should use high grade coal to control the environmental

pollution and construct one water barrage at river Rusikulya and the Rusikulya

water should be used in the industry instead ofuse of ground water'

95. Sri Ashok Choudhury, Ex-MLA' Chatrapur'

He welcomed the project and demanded for control of environmental

pollution & provide employment to local people and cSR activity should be

properly done in the localitY'

96. Sri Dhiren Kumar Sahu, Vi l lage- T. Berhampur'

He welcomed the Project.

97. Sri A. Sibaram Reddy, Village- T. Berhampur'

He welcomed the Project.

98, Sri A, Krishna Reddy, Vi l lage- T. Berhampur'


99. Sri Chandrasen Behera, Vi l lage- Puruna Chatrapur'


100. Sri T. Gopinath Reddy, Vi l lage- Puruna Chatrapur'

He supported the Project.

l0l . Sri Krushna Chandra Nayak, Youth Leader, Chatrapur'


102. Sri B. Chandramani Patra, Vi l lage- Kal ipal l i '

He welcomed the gatherings and supported the establishment of the expansion

project and demancled that the project must be established without failure.

t l

CONCLUSION:

Sri Mitrasen Majhi, Regional Officer' State Pollution Control Board'

Berhampur&representativeofStatePollutionControlBoard'Odishaprepared

the summary of the public hearing proceedings accurately reflecting the views

and concerns, expressed by the oral deliberators' After the hearing from public

theRegionalof f icer ,sPCBstatedtheobject ions/suggest ionsmadebythe

public.br. Ch' V.G.K. Murty, Director (Project) addressed the apprehensions

raised by the public The content of the proceedings was explained to the

audience in Odiya and the minutes were prepared which was ratified by the

Additional District Magistrate (Revenue), Ganjam' Chatrapur with the views

and concems of the deliberators'

The statement of issues and concerns of public with the comments of the

representative of the project proponent' prepared in Oriya and English

Languug. are annexed as Annexure-IV and Annexure-V separately'

The public hearing was ended with vote of thanks by the chair'

' r r l t1j h i )

Regional Officer,

State Pollution Control Board, Odisha

BerhamPur

(Assisted as rePresentative of

State Pollution Control Board)

'{,1*Yi^"n,oAS(s))( S r i B

Addi District Magistrate(Revenue )

Ganjam, ChatraPur

(Presided and SuPervised

the public Hearing meeting)

l . l

'f'Annex urt-E

qqieruroo elot6ea aogtCo at6ntoq 6sso 6q,6

GO EilUtO6r6 qrQl AqAIOO

arcereq 6oa oq

ensd ciorei seceQq qte6o6'| fifieeq,

6'61916ll, S99[Or 6ls'ln g6'e qglQ6'C Oa€rq

q 66ec al6'f1, qae Oedacc qtot aogloc

aototaEor fleoq

qqs6t 6se6t socso

^ < i

ofite1o0o6J6'fi|e18 qao e6a6a fl 9I€l1 aqrsal

6o6n 60, 6a s'gr cao6J qgs6t 6seo sta"

ordqGoier snrdco qg6o eoq, oo6ao 6o6a I

grals orQorq 6oee 6qOfl Adt odtacn 60, aoq@ slo edlctR Eal gnlCI

o6otq 6qO 6fiee aqtUato 0a6e t 6s qa8

adn6n 60 groiCI otQotqQeoo gnttoq 6at0e t

Q.<q.aro.^. ^.<a

fl qa1 6\6lla6n 60, glQlg alsolq sa oolfld ao

Q.sq.an oro{efi e$o 6dr6o g616{66r ootOo t

as 60to6l6

qt gldl o6re66l 60, qoaer otdot{o agn6a sq6)

ona -o€ odeo r

n ^ , , 4 1

ltrt4q nt4 !, r et(qt frqeso otff)

algfre'a8aw, eqqe,olQq qqE6l Q0861 6QlG" so6ll

t--'--r14z )

S1-1 . r t / - / 1 t ,h >\5 ,4''

(or 6os qEcr6w,( o.g.6a. ({q))

a66o 6-,4 qtaeqa (0t6'q), 6l&lcl

STATEMEN'|S ON THB ISSUES RAISE'D IN THE PUBLIC HEARING

TSSUNS RAISED

BY THE PUBLIC

'K' MurtY' Director

(proj"co assured that the industry will take all pollution

control measures as proposed in the executive summary'

Follution Control

to the locals.

SmompanYui l l take

employment based on the skill on priority basis to

p"opf". He further added that prime importance lvill

steps for

the local

be given

Employment

the local PeoPle

@ Y w i l l t a k e u P t h e c S Ractivity in consultation with the local people as per the

procedure.

Srt M".tfittma6tahut th-om-pany *ill undertake massive

sreen belt in and around the plant site'

CSR activitY

RESENTED BY DR.

V.G.K, MURTY, DIRECTOR (PROJECT)' M/S__SARTI

AGENCIES PRIVATE LIMITED' KANAMANA' CHATRAPUR'

4r,lunaYo'T

( Sri

'{*i#4 ^,n,( o. A. s. ( s) )

Ad I District Magistrate (Rev),

jam, ChatraPur

t . t i

GANJAM

Regional Officer'

Stale Pollution Control Board,

BerhamPur

-n-n-rsri"

€ryNo.9273/ tN(} -PH-728

Dale 14.07.2017

Sd/- MEMBER SECRETARY

grpi.g,mr'if $15'ffi;;;dgufrffii5$$irt11filfr 'ffi:"'J"wt'siiii,tJ:rma:ljxnlfl #:'Jq86ff"ffi:l-liilx*lffi i[r'lim*#"r*'1"*h*"r*:uru"*m":nt;i;,111ii:rTffi 3i."#:ffi,did"nts,

"*it-t"ntal groups ano oml

sites likelv to beatlecled

For the above purpose, a person wifl onry mean. y the grant or Environmentar.crearance.

A. Anv Pecon who is likely to be an

R Anvoersonwhoown'nis"ont'o'-J*itt'"proi6ctwith respea towhich an applicali0n has

.dn suOmitted tor environmental clearancerated

or likely to be atfected by the projecf

c lg,:,tr"illl,!'iffi':3,i.il1';lgj,il.',,-,,'," ;" *****, wherein,heD. Anv local authority within arry pa-

oidi"cr is ptoposdo to be located'

Personsdsabovewhodesiretosuoilittheirviews',T:T:,1;llii'fiil'llil;tlSllllii,ili

Itisbroushttothenotic"",'11*:"::**H:i,",?li,V::i',ili,t$;1ltffii;-SttHitohaveEnvironmentalAssessmenlrcr----.6.roh^r,,minir 'mpowderanqZ.4TPAscan'

1 .

ofiice( Zilla Parishad' Ganiam

i#tffi; Boaro disha. Parivesh Bhawan' A'l1 183 . :

ffi m*ffi ;tgr.:trl*tnfrtnu*atlt j,li$:+ffi

5.6.

It'_- - j

aE hleO !i"Con [r/,zt'1 ]'l'lS'V'tf'f-t

( r'{

€65i

ffi\tF/oQ6A6l 66.'c', 98eO89

6eno rsoqr6x soga aa66 A9r6a o$re *,u,"ud..,"ud

"nrr,d6oAq qe6q 8466,q o96rn 6ss 6ar.|

aqqa osaa a€6{o aaqhr, AOGgqqo uqr q6ter"9qo greror6a qq16o es 6q6rKrq 6aq 69!9 6e9.i

orde eooo 6q €qor 6Aq Ec6ao|66'r6q9], otda qlooo oq snor 66G 6€r6aqff6D, 566e o9 5.1

€qo 6AG areadqe oeost uq 0160 9.d 6.e a91or 66e Eeqgr aq|aq are61rar q6q| eAar 6q6€ 6tjao

oear6F 066o61, aee ,.ie" anoq o6odo oeomq qa oa6e6rq ela.ra 6nee anom oqe6' gdoiue5r

q61i6 arr6g sa6r q?sd 6qo6l serdq ar6oeo aAo6 r 6rao so6e a6t6oo, aca uei anerq ooerin

s"6t,il 9280 / IND-II-PH- 728 ot^cl,

o66a6rq rtqa 6Aa a.Lqoar €rffi u40. e8qrqr(a), or. e6rcr9oo9 aecrq eoe qEE$ 6qe{

, s66fl Ea6oqaq €6ola]!e6! q6nd eaqa,qqor gorn aQod l ua6ae 6od, o6€|.]re6r6 o6eo gqc

oa{o6rq Erq| se qsr6o qae qoe 6eaelar oa6o aoa6l, gaa 6qr6i a6ao 6eeetal aiear,

6or6i qq6o G?a€{er o6orgrlacorq qee qoo 661q" s66adq qa6. oaolq qg|a, flotflo, q6?! c

arod a9 a|qla aqod r ueLdAO o€a ae.l6aeR aflnsp g€rora6,

<e; ooseono nqa qel qq6o 69aqer or 6aQrQ llor60 6d16l6 €'r€ |(6l) qea aa6o oQ6o6lrq grqsl old a|6lo oa6rg o66q$6a oG ao6a a(iq o|oe coorqaor 6dka

or066d6 |(6) oQco6 66q6a adg QesLq oai-

66i6rA c'16 oAse ePo I(o) qal6o qe6a gPrq ol'rqa 6eoo61

eo66xq oqor1Kfij 66qra6Q qs|Q

s06r q O6Lo a|e[6a u0 6a€R

(GcPft€ oa6o6r 6quo, goar soa|a.)\o / eer, c4aaq o€lq gaS-r, qo6oqa-

u@q6loro o66a6rq goo qarrao od$6.Fdrel otore3a aaq q9e61 6qad 66ir6, eaaro eg6brs*.r,'rtirspcu,;

R AdOElgO) 6C

. - It-4

L{

Hffiq\--e3

z bhubareswar 751 out, india -...

Documents