% 1ji?=ijie?=g 8jgn=ca5aimeic 0a?d=iemh ’jinljgm … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw...

23
!&’$"%# % 1JI"?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA"5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM +=NEIC EI .#3 . ! ’D=IIAGM <ZJYQRLJU 5K[\ZJL\ =RPQURPQ\[ ! BX[\ @+E LQJWWNU[ N‘QRKR\ [\ZXWP ^XU\JPN PJ\RWP JWM JZN WX\ [RVYUN UNJT LQJWWNU[ ! IXU\JPN [NW[RWP RW^XU^N[ VX^NVNW\ XO @ $ RW\X \QN NUNL\ZRL gNUM XO JW RWJL\R^N gU\NZ ! B8 [RV]UJ\RXW XO YNZVNJ\RXW ZN^NJU[ RW[RPQ\ RW\X \QN gU\NZ PJ\RWP VNLQJWR[V ! BJWa YQa[RXUXPRLJU [\RV]UR VXM]UJ\N \QR[ ^XU\JPN&PJ\RWP KNQJ^RXZ 5]\QXZ[ BJZL][ GLQN_N% 9Q[JW CNVJ\RJW&5ZMN[\JWR% =JW G]W% ’’’% G\NYQNW ?’ H]LTNZ% BJZT][ FJYNMR][% HQXVJ[ 6J]TZX_R\b 7XZZN[YXWMNWLN \’KJ]TZX_R\b4YQa[RXUXPRN’]WR&TRNU’MN >W 6ZRNO @+E LQJWWNU[% _QRLQ MX WX\ YX[[N[[ J LJWXWRLJU ^XU\JPN&[NW[RWP MXVJRW% LJW KN ^XU\JPN PJ\NM Ka JW RXW LQNLT ^JU^N VNLQJWR[V’ GLQN_N N\ JU’% +)*/% 7NUU !#"% 2,0d2-2 ;NKZ]JZa +.% +)*/ !+)*/ HQN 5]\QXZ[ Q\\Y3((M‘’MXR’XZP(*)’*)*/(S’LNUU’+)*/’)+’))+

Upload: trinhdien

Post on 02-Dec-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

!&'$"%#

% 1JI"?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA"5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH'JINLJGM +=NEIC EI .#3 .! 'D=IIAGM

<ZJYQRLJU 5K[\ZJL\

=RPQURPQ\[

! BX[\ @+E LQJWWNU[ N`QRKR\ [\ZXWP ^XU\JPN PJ\RWP JWM JZN WX\

[RVYUN UNJT LQJWWNU[

! IXU\JPN [NW[RWP RW^XU^N[ VX^NVNW\ XO @$ RW\X \QN NUNL\ZRL

gNUM XO JW RWJL\R^N gU\NZ

! B8 [RV]UJ\RXW XO YNZVNJ\RXW ZN^NJU[ RW[RPQ\ RW\X \QN gU\NZ

PJ\RWP VNLQJWR[V

! BJWa YQa[RXUXPRLJU [\RV]UR VXM]UJ\N \QR[ ^XU\JPN&PJ\RWP

KNQJ^RXZ

5]\QXZ[

BJZL][ GLQN_N%

9Q[JW CNVJ\RJW&5ZMN[\JWR% =JW G]W% '''%

G\NYQNW ?' H]LTNZ% BJZT][ FJYNMR][%

HQXVJ[ 6J]TZX_R\b

7XZZN[YXWMNWLN

\'KJ]TZX_R\b4YQa[RXUXPRN']WR&TRNU'MN

>W 6ZRNO

@+E LQJWWNU[% _QRLQ MX WX\ YX[[N[[ J

LJWXWRLJU ^XU\JPN&[NW[RWP MXVJRW% LJW

KN ^XU\JPN PJ\NM Ka JW RXW LQNLT ^JU^N

VNLQJWR[V'

GLQN_N N\ JU'% +)*/% 7NUU !#"% 2,0d2-2

;NKZ]JZa +.% +)*/ !+)*/ HQN 5]\QXZ[

Q\\Y3((M`'MXR'XZP(*)'*)*/(S'LNUU'+)*/')+'))+

Page 2: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

%LNE?GA

, 6IH#>=HIHD>=F <IFM=B@#9@HLDHB 5@>C=HDLG-IHMKIFL 1=MDHB DH 4'7 4! -C=HH@FLDL\N_] INSPaP','2 <S]LY EPXL^TLY(7\OP]^LYT','2 ?LY I_Y'-'. DL\TLYYP D_]TY]dVT', IZh YVP 9Z\OPT\Z', >TZ`LYYL 8_NNT'/

8P\^ C) OP >\ZZ^'- I^P[SPY A) J_NVP\'/'0 DL\V_] HL[POT_]','1 LYO JSZXL] 8L_V\ZaT^d,'%.Finodopo` ja Mctndjgjbt) @cmdnod\i*>g]m`^con Ridq`mndot) /1..5 Hd`g) D`mh\it/@jhkpo\odji\g ?djhjg`^pg\m Ati\hd^n Dmjpk) J\s Mg\i^f Finodopo` ajm ?djkctnd^\g @c`hdnomt) 04-44 Djy oodib`i) D`mh\it0I`d]idu*Finodopo apy m Jjg`fpg\m` Mc\mh\fjgjbd`) .0./2 ?`mgdi) D`mh\it1@g\m`i_ji I\]jm\ojmt) A`k\moh`io ja Mctnd^n) Ridq`mndot ja Lsajm_) Lsajm_ LU. 0MR) RH2LUFLK Fidod\odq`) Ridq`mndot ja Lsajm_) Lsajm_ LU. 0MR) RH3K\idji Q`^cijgjbd`n Dh]E) 5-303 Jpid^c) D`mh\it4@j*"mno \pocjm

'@jmm`nkji_`i^`7 o+]\pfmjrdou=kctndjgjbd`+pid*fd`g+_`

cook7,,_s+_jd+jmb,.-+.-.3,e+^`gg+/-.3+-/+--/

Qcdn dn \i jk`i \^^`nn \mod^g` pi_`m oc` @@ ?V gd^`in` %cook7,,^m`\odq`^jhhjin+jmb,gd^`in`n,]t,1+-,&+

5700%4<

JaZ([Z\P OZXLTY #B-G$ B& NSLYYPW] L\P XLUZ\ \PR_(

WL^Z\] ZQ PbNT^LMTWT^c ^SL^ PYOZa NPWW] aT^S LY

Z_^aL\OWc \PN^TQcTYR MLNVR\Z_YO eeWPLVff NZYO_N(

^LYNP) @Y ]ZXP B-G NSLYYPW]' ]^\ZYR `ZW^LRP(OP[PY(

OPY^ LN^T`L^TZY SL] MPPY ZM]P\`PO' M_^ ^SP XPNSL(

YT]X \PXLTY] _Y\P]ZW`PO MPNL_]P ^SPc WLNV L

NLYZYTNLW `ZW^LRP(]PY]TYR OZXLTY) ?P\P' aP ]SZa

`ZW^LRP(OP[PYOPY^ RL^TYR T] NZXXZY ^Z XZ]^ B-G

NSLYYPW] LYO ^SL^ ^ST] `ZW^LRP ]PY]T^T`T^c Z\TRTYL^P]

Q\ZX ^SP XZ`PXPY^ ZQ ^S\PP ^Z QZ_\ TZY] TY^Z ^SP

STRS PWPN^\TN !PWO ZQ LY TYLN^T`P ]PWPN^T`T^c !W^P\) F`P\(

LWW' ^ST] TZY("_b RL^TYR XPNSLYT]X RPYP\L^P] L ZYP(

aLc eeNSPNV `LW`Pff aT^STY ^SP !W^P\ MPNL_]P Z_^aL\O

XZ`PXPY^ ZQ B& TYO_NP] !W^P\ Z[PYTYR' aSP\PL] TY(

aL\O XZ`PXPY^ [\ZXZ^P] TYLN^T`L^TZY) =_\^SP\XZ\P'

XLYc [Sc]TZWZRTNLW ]^TX_WT ]aT^NS ZQQ ^ST] "_b RL^TYR

XZOP ^Z NZY`P\^ B-G NSLYYPW] TY^Z L WPLV NZYO_N(

^LYNP) JSP]P !YOTYR] [\Z`TOP TY]TRS^ TY^Z ^SP Q_YN(

^TZYLW [WL]^TNT^c ZQ L B&(]PWPN^T`P !W^P\ LYO LW]Z \P!YP

Z_\ _YOP\]^LYOTYR ZQ B-G NSLYYPW] LYO ^SP XPNSL(

YT]X] Mc aSTNS TZY NSLYYPW] NLY ]PY]P `ZW^LRP)

-1642(7'6-21

Fi oc` \idh\g fdib_jh ocm`` h\di a\hdgd`n ja H( ^c\ii`gn _`"i`

H(*_`k`i_`io ^`ggpg\m `s^do\]dgdot) i\h`gt) oc` qjgo\b`*b\o`_

%Hq&) dir\m_gt m`^odatdib %Hdm&) \i_ oc` ]\^fbmjpi_ jm g`\f orj*

kjm` _jh\di %H/M& H( ^c\ii`gn+ Hq ^c\ii`gn ^jiomd]po` oj

h`h]m\i` m`kjg\mdu\odji8 oc`t \m` b\o`_ jk`i ]t h`h]m\i` _`*

kjg\mdu\odji) rcd^c dn n`in`_ ]t \ kjndodq`gt ^c\mb`_ vvP1*c`gdsww

rdocdi \ ^\ijid^\g qjgo\b`*n`indib _jh\di %SPA&+ Hdm ^c\ii`gn

no\]dgdu` oc` m`nodib h`h]m\i` kjo`iod\g %OJM& \i_ `scd]do \

nomjib qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io ]`c\qdjm ]`^\pn` oc`t \m` ]gj^f`_

]t kjgt\hdi`n gdf` nk`mhdi` pkji _`kjg\mdu\odji+ ?t ^jiom\no)

H/M ^c\ii`gn c\q` om\_dodji\ggt ]``i qd`r`_ \n qjgo\b`*di_`*

k`i_`io vv]\^fbmjpi_ww H( ^c\ii`gn rc`m` oc`dm nomjib jpor\m_

m`^od"^\odji dn ocjpbco oj \mdn` amjh oc` \nthh`omd^ H( bm\_d`io

\^mjnn oc` h`h]m\i` \n km`_d^o`_ ]t oc` Djg_h\i*Ej_bfdi*

H\ou %DEH& `lp\odji %Djg_no`di `o \g+) /--.8 I`n\b` \i_ I\u_pi*

nfd) /---&+ Qcdn jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji c\n dhkjmo\io dhkgd^\odjin

ajm oc` mjg` ja H/M ^c\ii`gn di oc` ^`iom\g \i_ k`mdkc`m\g i`mqjpn

ntno`h ]`^\pn` do ijo jigt no\]dgdu`n oc` OJM ]po \gnj ^jiomd]*

po`n oj m`kjg\mdu\odji \i_ `q`i `i\]g`n \^odji kjo`iod\g b`i`m\*

odji di oc` \]n`i^` ja ^g\nnd^\g Hq ^c\ii`gn %J\^H`iud` `o \g+)

/-.2&+ Pp^c kmjk`mod`n \m` bm`\ogt `ic\i^`_ di njh` H/M ^c\i*

i`gn %di k\mod^pg\m QOBH*. \i_ Q>PH*0& ]`^\pn` ja \__dodji\g

odh`* \i_ qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io \^odq\odji %?j^f`ic\p`m `o \g+)

/--.8 ?md^fg`t `o \g+) /--4&+ Ejr`q`m) H/M ^c\ii`gn g\^f \

SPA) \i_ oc` h`^c\idnhn oc\o pi_`mgd` ocdn qjgo\b`*b\odib

]`c\qdjm m`h\di pi^g`\m+

Qc`m` \m` .2 h`h]`mn ja oc` cph\i H/M a\hdgt oc\o ^\i ]`

_dqd_`_ dioj nds np]a\hdgd`n ]\n`_ ji oc`dm nomp^opm\g \i_ api^*

odji\g kmjk`mod`n %Djg_no`di `o \g+) /--28 I`n\b` \i_ I\u_pinfd)

/---&) i\h`gt) oc` QTFH) QOBH) Q>PH) QEFH) Q>IH) \i_ QOBPH

np]a\hdgd`n %Bit`_d \i_ @udme\{ f) /-.-&+ O`^`io ^mtno\g nomp^opm`n

_`hjinom\o` oc\o) pigdf` joc`m ^g\nnd^\g o`om\h`md^ H( ^c\ii`gn)

H/M ^c\ii`gn \nn`h]g` \n _dh`mn rdoc \ kn`p_jo`om\h`md^ kjm`

%?mjc\ri `o \g+) /-./) /-.08 Ajib `o \g+) /-.28 Jdgg`m \i_ Ijib)

/-./&+ Bso`indq` nop_d`n jq`m oc` g\no orj _`^\_`n c\q` m`*

q`\g`_ oc\o oc`n` ^c\ii`gn m`km`n`io h\ejm m`bpg\ojmn ja ^`ggpg\m

`s^do\]dgdot \i_ \m` diqjgq`_ di \ rd_` m\ib` ja kctndjgjbd^\g

api^odjin) di^gp_dib q\nj_dg\odji) i`pmjkmjo`^odji) \i`noc`nd\)

ng``k) ^c`hj* \i_ ipomd`io n`indib) \g_jno`mji` \i_ dinpgdi

n`^m`odji) ij^d^`kodji) \i_ km`nnpm` \i_ o`hk`m\opm` n`indib

%Bit`_d \i_ @udme\{ f) /-.-8 Ejijm {̀ ) /--4&+

O`lpdndo` ajm np^c api^odji\g _dq`mndot dn oc`dm m`bpg\odji ]t \

rd_` q\md`ot ja nodhpgd) di^gp_dib MRC>n %`+b+) \m\^cd_jid^ \^d_)

>>&) gtnjkcjnkcjgdkd_n) A>D) kcjnkcjdijndod_`n %`+b+) MFM/&)

kcjnkcjmtg\odji) qjg\odg` \i`noc`od^n) kE ^c\ib`n) o`hk`m\opm`)

\i_ h`^c\id^\g ajm^`n %Bit`_d \i_ @udme\{ f) /-.-8 Ejijm {̀ ) /--4&+

Cjm njh` ja oc`n` nodhpgd) oc` hjg`^pg\m _`o`mhdi\ion c\q` ]``i

k\mod\ggt d_`iod"`_ \i_ diqjgq` \ b\odib h\^cdi`mt gj^\o`_ rdocdi

oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m %PC& %?\bmd\ion`q `o \g+) /-..8 Ijgd^\oj `o \g+)

/-.18 Md`^cjoo\ `o \g+) /-..8 Wdg]`m]`mb `o \g+) /--.&+ ?po `s\^ogt

rc\o c\kk`in rdocdi oc` "go`m _pmdib H/M ^c\ii`g b\odib m`h\din

pifijri+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4.2

Page 3: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

!

" #

$ %

& '

!423251 65 52<9 7032"

4.3 @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 4: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

E`m`) r` ncjr oc\o qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io b\odib dn \ kmjk`mot

^jhhji oj i`\mgt \gg H/M ^c\ii`gn+ Fo jmdbdi\o`n amjh oc` pidlp`

api^odji\g kg\nod^dot ja oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m \i_ m`km`n`ion \ ndb*

id"^\io ^jhkji`io ja oc`dm jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji+ Qc`n` m`npgon

`sk\i_ jpm pi_`mno\i_dib ja oc` h`^c\idnhn oc\o pi_`mgd`

qjgo\b` n`indib di dji ^c\ii`gn \i_ oc` api^odji\g mjg` oc\o

H/M ^c\ii`gn h\t kg\t di ^`ggpg\m `s^do\]dgdot+

4)57/65

8JGN=CA %?NEP=NEJI -M = 'JHHJI *A=NOLA EI %GHJMN =GG

.#3 'D=IIAGM

Qj j]o\di \ ^jhkm`c`indq` kd^opm` ja ocdn qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io

b\odib) r` h`\npm`_ ^pmm`ion di m`nkjin` oj 0--*hn qjgo\b`

no`kn %amjh !.-- oj (.-- hS& ajm q\mdjpn h`h]`mn ja oc` H/M

^c\ii`g a\hdgt di `s^dn`_ bd\io h`h]m\i` k\o^c`n pi_`m nth*

h`omd^\g H( ^ji_dodjin %Cdbpm`n . \i_ P.&+ QTFH*. ^c\ii`gn

_dnkg\t gdi`\m ^pmm`io*qjgo\b` ^c\m\^o`mdnod^n %F*S ^pmq`n& \i_

ij ndbi ja odh`* jm qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io \^odq\odji %Cdbpm` .>&+

Fi h\mf`_ ^jiom\no) \gg joc`m o`no`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn %QO>>H)

QOBH*/) QOBH*.) QOBPH) Q>IH*/) Q>PH*.) Q>PH*/) \i_

Q>PH*0& ncjr`_ kmjhdi`io jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji \n \ m`npgo ja \

odh`* \i_ qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io \^odq\odji kmj^`nn %Cdbpm`n .?x.B

\i_ P.>xP.A&+ Fi QO>>H) ajm dino\i^`) jigt q`mt nh\gg ^pmm`ion

r`m` j]n`mq`_ \o i`b\odq` kjo`iod\gn) ]po g\mb` jpor\m_ ^pmm`ion

_`q`gjk`_ ajm qjgo\b` no`kn kjndodq` oj oc` m`q`mn\g kjo`iod\g

%Bm`q+&+ Qcdn qjgo\b` \^odq\odji kmj^``_`_ rdoc \ odh` ^jino\io %!&

ja 1 ! . hn oc\o r\n nomdfdibgt qjgo\b` di_`k`i_`io %d+`+) ndhdg\m

ajm kjo`iod\gn ]`or``i (/- oj (.-- hS8 Cdbpm`n .? \i_ P.B&+

Jjno m`h\mf\]g`) cjr`q`m) r\n oc` \kk`\m\i^` ja g\mb` di*

r\m_ %d+`+) o\dg& ^pmm`ion pkji m`kjg\mdu\odji oj !5- hS oc\o di_d*

^\o` \ g\mb` mdn` di jk`i kmj]\]dgdot %.-&+ Qc`n` o\dg ^pmm`ion

di^m`\n`_ di k\m\gg`g rdoc oc` \hkgdop_`n ja oc` jpor\m_ ^pmm`ion

\i_ _`^\t`_ rdoc \ odh` ^jino\io ja 1 ! / hn %Cdbpm` .?&+ Pdhdg\m

o\dg ^pmm`ion r`m` j]n`mq`_ ajm QOBH*. \i_ QOBH*/ %Cdbpm`n .@

\i_ P.>&) Q>IH*/ %Cdbpm` .B&) Q>PH*/ %Cdbpm` P.A&) \i_ Q>PH*0

^c\ii`gn %Cdbpm` .A&+ Qc` _`bm`` ja jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji r\n

g`nn kmjhdi`io di QOBPH \i_ Q>PH*. \n oc`n` ^c\ii`gn

^ji_p^o`_ g\mb`m dir\m_ ^pmm`ion \o i`b\odq` kjo`iod\gn+ K`q`m*

oc`g`nn) QOBPH \i_ Q>PH*. \gnj ncjr`_ ndbid"^\io odh`*

_`k`i_`io qjgo\b` \^odq\odji rdoc ^jmm`nkji_dib o\dg ^pmm`ion

n``i pkji m`kjg\mdu\odji %Cdbpm`n P.? \i_ P.@&+ Qc` _`bm`` ja

jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji \i_ ajg_ ^c\ib` di o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n

pkji _`kjg\mdu\odji \m` nphh\mdu`_ ajm \gg o`no`_ ^c\ii`gn di

Cdbpm`n .C \i_ .D+ Qcdn `no\]gdnc`n oc\o odh`* \i_ qjgo\b`*

_`k`i_`io \^odq\odji dn \ kmjhdi`io a`\opm` rdocdi oc` H/M np*

k`ma\hdgt+ Fio`m`nodibgt) oc` jigt H/M ^c\ii`g oc\o ]`c\q`_ gdf`

\ vv^g\nnd^\gww g`\f ^c\ii`g rdoc \ gdi`\m F*S ^pmq` r\n QTFH*.+

Qcdn i`so m\dn`n oc` lp`nodji ja rc\o h`^c\idnhn pi_`mgd` ocdn

qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io \^odq\odji+ Fo c\n km`qdjpngt ]``i m`kjmo`_

oc\o `som\^`ggpg\m Jb/( ^\i ]gj^f dir\m_ QOBH*. ^pmm`ion \o ct*

k`mkjg\mdu`_ kjo`iod\gn %J\dibm`o `o \g+) /--/&+ Ejr`q`m) r`

ajpi_ oc\o `som\^`ggpg\m _dq\g`io ^\odjin jigt c\_ hdijm `aa`^on

ji qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \i_ o\dg ^pmm`ion %Cdbpm`n P/>xP/@&+

6DA 8JGN=CA"(AKAI@AIN +=NA -M /J?=NA@ QENDEI NDA

5AGA?NEPENS *EGNAL

Qc` qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io b\o` di ^g\nnd^\g Hq ^c\ii`gn dn gj^\o`_ \o

oc` `iom\i^` oj oc` diom\^`ggpg\m kjm` %V`gg`i) .665&+ T` oc`m`ajm`

`hkgjt`_orj`no\]gdnc`_ kmjoj^jgn ojkmj]` ajm \ api^odji\g gjr`m

b\o`) d+`+) no\o`*_`k`i_`io kjm` ^tno`di` hj_d"^\odji \i_ no\o`*

_`k`i_`io kjm` ]gj^f`m ]di_dib %Cdbpm`n P0>xP0@& %Md`^cjoo\

`o \g+) /-..8 O\k`_dpn `o \g+) /-./&+ @jindno`io rdoc jpm km`qdjpn

"i_dibn) ^c`hd^\g hj_d"^\odjija \ kjm` m`nd_p` diQOBH*.j^^pmn

rdoc \ ndhdg\m m\o` m`b\m_g`nn ja rc`oc`m oc` ^c\ii`gn \m` \^odq\o`_

jm ^gjn`_ ]t qjgo\b` %Cdbpm` P0@&+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) r` ajpi_ oc\o \

cdbc*\a"idot lp\o`mi\mt\hhjidph%N>(& kjm`]gj^f`m c\n am``\^*

^`nn oj don ]di_dib ndo` _``k rdocdi oc` kjm` `q`i rc`i QOBH*.

^c\ii`gn \m` ^gjn`_ \o ctk`mkjg\mdu`_ kjo`iod\gn %Cdbpm` P0?&+

Qc`n` m`npgon di_d^\o` oc\o oc` qjgo\b`*b\odib h`^c\idnh gdf`gt

m`nd_`n rdocdi jm ^gjn` oj oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m %Cdbpm` P.A&+

0ON=NEJI JB NDA 5$ .! &EI@EIC 5ENA %>JGEMDAM 8JGN=CA

+=NEIC

Qj diq`nodb\o` oc` diqjgq`h`io ja oc` "go`m) r` hpo\o`_ m`nd_p`n

rdocdi `doc`m oc` "mno %M.& jm n`^ji_ %M/& kjm` gjjkn ja QOBH*.

^c\ii`gn+ >n `sk`^o`_) hpo\odib oc` ^jin`mq`_ DCD hjoda ja

oc` "go`m m`npgo`_ di iji*api^odji\g ^c\ii`gn) ]po \gg joc`m hp*

o\ion b`i`m\o`_ h\^mjn^jkd^ ^pmm`ion %Cdbpm` />&+ Pomdfdibgt)

orj hpo\odjin ^jhkg`o`gt m`hjq`_ ocdn qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io

b\odib ]`c\qdjm) i\h`gt) hpo\odjin ja oc` cdbcgt ^jin`mq`_ ocm`*

jidi` rdocdi oc` ^jin`inpn H(*n`g`^odq` hjoda %QFDCD& di ]joc M.

\i_ M/ %Cdbpm` /?&+ Qc`n` orj hpo\ion %Q.24@ \i_ Q/33@& _dn*

kg\t`_ gdi`\m F*Sn \i_ dino\io\i`jpn ^pmm`io*qjgo\b` m`nkjin`n

oc\o ^jhkg`o`gt g\^f`_ oc` kmjhdi`io o\dg ^pmm`ion j]n`mq`_ di

oc` TQ ^c\ii`g %Cdbpm` /@&+ Fi ^jiom\no) oc` joc`m hpo\odjin

rdocdi M. \i_ M/ c\_ ij j]qdjpn `aa`^o ji qjgo\b` b\odib \i_

_d_ ijo ^c\ib` oc` g\mb` m`^od"^\odji ^j`a"^d`io ja 14 ! 1 %Cdb*

pm` />& oc\o _`"i`n jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji di TQ QOBH*.+

O`h\mf\]gt) ndhdg\m m`npgon r`m` \gnj j]o\di`_ rc`i oc` ^jmm`*

nkji_dib ocm`jidi`n %di M. \i_ M/& r`m` hpo\o`_ di QO>>H)

Q>PH*.) Q>PH*/) \i_ Q>PH*0 ^c\ii`gn %Cdbpm`n /Ax/C&) npb*

b`nodib oc`n` cdbcgt ^jin`mq`_ m`nd_p`n \m` dhkjmo\io ajm oc`

qjgo\b`*b\odib h`^c\idnh rdocdi oc` H/M ^c\ii`g npk`ma\hdgt+

Fiomdbpdibgt) oc` ct_mjstg bmjpk rdocdi oc`n` ocm`jidi`n dn oc`

jigt nd_` ^c\di rdocdi oc` "go`m oc\o dio`m\^on _dm`^ogt rdoc H(

0DBNK@ &$ <IFM=B@ 1=MDHB 3L -IGGIH PDMCDH MC@ 4'7 9NJ@KA=GDFR

%>xB& @pmm`io m`nkjin`n oj \ 0--*hn qjgo\b` no`k a\hdgt amjh !.-- oj (.-- hS amjh \ cjg_dib kjo`iod\g ja !5- hS m`^jm_`_ amjh `s^dn`_ dind_`*jpo h`h]m\i`

k\o^c`n di nthh`omd^\g H( %./- hJ H(dio+,./- hJ H(

`so+& `skm`nndib oc` di_d^\o`_ H/M ^c\ii`g rdoc %>& QTFH*.) %?& QO>>H) %@& QOBH*/) %A& Q>PH*0) \i_ %B&

Q>IH*/8 oc` ^pmm`io \o (.-- hS \ao`m H/M ^c\ii`g ]gj^f ]t . hJ QM> dn ncjri di bm``i %Md`^cjoo\ `o \g+) /-..&+ Qc` F*S kgjon di_d^\o` ^pmm`ion \o oc` `i_ ja oc`

_`kjg\mdudib no`kn %bm\t ^dm^g`n& \i_ oc` ^jmm`nkji_dib dir\m_ ^pmm`io %o\dg& \hkgdop_`n pkji m`kjg\mdu\odji oj !5- hS %]gp` ^dm^g`n&8 oc` din`on ncjr oc` odh`

^jpmn` ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \i_ di\^odq\odji rdoc cdbc`m odh` m`njgpodji8 odh` ^jino\ion %!& \m` j]o\di`_ rdoc `skji`iod\g "on+

%C \i_ D& O`^od"^\odji ^j`a"^d`ion %^pmm`ion \o (.--hS,x.--hS& %C& \i_ ajg_ ^c\ib` di o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n %D& np]n`lp`io oj \ _`kjg\mdudib kpgn` oj (.-- hS

ajm oc` di_d^\o`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn8 _\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

P`` \gnj Cdbpm`n P. \i_ P/+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4.4

Page 5: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

djin+ Qc` "go`m ^jio\din ajpm H( ]di_dib ndo`n %P.xP1&) \i_

hpo\odib oc`n` m`nd_p`n dn oc`m`ajm` `sk`^o`_ oj ^c\ib` dji j^*

^pk\i^t \o oc`n` ndo`n rdocdi oc` "go`m+ Fi_``_) di oc` H^n> H(

^c\ii`g) oc` `lpdq\g`io hpo\odji %Q42@& m`_p^`n H( ]di_dib oj

oc` P1 ndo`) km`nph\]gt ]`^\pn` npgapm ^jjm_di\o`n H( g`nn

r`gg oc\i jstb`i %Wcjp \i_ J\^Hdiiji) /--1&+

0( 5EHOG=NEJIM 4APA=G NDA *EGNAL -JI 2??OK=I?S JB 96

=I@ 0ON=IN 'D=IIAGM

Qj b\di dindbco dioj oc` dji j^^pk\i^t ja oc` H/M ^c\ii`g "go`m)

r` `hkgjt`_ \ojhdnod^ hjg`^pg\m _ti\hd^n %JA& ndhpg\odjin

rdoc \ _jp]g` ]dg\t`m n`opk \n m`^`iogt pn`_ oj ndhpg\o` dji

k`mh`\odji di joc`m H( ^c\ii`gn) np^c \n H^n> \i_ Hq.+/

! "

# $ %

&

' (

0DBNK@ '$ ;C@ 0DFM@K 8@JK@L@HML MC@ <IFM=B@ 1=M@ DH 4'7 -C=HH@FL

%>& Qc` ]\mn m`km`n`io oc` m`^od"^\odji ^j`a"^d`ion %ajm TQ QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn \i_ di_d^\o`_ hpo\odjin \mjpi_ oc` DCD hjoda di M. \i_ M/+

%?& P`lp`i^` \gdbih`io ja oc` "go`m m`bdjin ajm kmj]`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn %\i_ H^n>& dn ncjri) \i_ oc` ^mdod^\g ocm`jidi` dn cdbcgdbco`_+

%@xB& @pmm`io m`nkjin`n oj qjgo\b` a\hdgd`n ajm hpo\io QOBH*. %@&) QO>>H %A&) \i_ Q>PH*0 ^c\ii`gn %B& ncjr gjnn ja qjgo\b` b\odib ajm ocm`jidi` hpo\ion+

%C& F*S kgjon ajm TQ \i_ hpo\io ^c\ii`gn+

%D \i_ E& JA ndhpg\odjin k`majmh`_ ji QO>>H ncjr m`g\odq` dji j^^pk\i^d`n ajm oc` dji ]di_dib ndo`n P.xP1 %D& \i_ oc`dm ^c\ib` %E& pkji hpo\odji ja `doc`m ji`

%ndibg` Q.-0@& jm ]joc kjndodjin %_jp]g` Q.-0@&) g`\_dib oj \ gjnn ja ]di_dib oj P. \i_ P1+ A\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

P`` \gnj Cdbpm` P0+

4/+ @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 6: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

%Hjy ka`m `o \g+) /-.1&+ Rndib oc` ^mtno\g nomp^opm` ja QO>>H

%?mjc\ri `o \g+) /-.0&) /-- k`mh`\odji `q`ion jq`m \ .- #n

ndhpg\odji %/- `q`ion,#n& r`m` _`o`^o`_ pi_`m kjndodq` qjgo\b`+

>i\gtndn ja oc`n` `q`ion npbb`non oc\o dji k`mh`\odji j^^pmn

]t \ ndhdg\m h`^c\idnh \n km`qdjpngt m`kjmo`_ ajm H^n> %Hjy ka`m

`o \g+) /-.1&+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) oc` \q`m\b` dji j^^pk\i^t _pmdib

k`mh`\odji r\n /+4 ! -+3 \i_ ocpn r\n ndhdg\m oj H^n> %Hjy ka`m

`o \g+) /-.1&+ Qc` ajpm H( ]di_dib ndo`n %P.xP1& di oc` "go`m

ncjr`_ \]jpo ndhdg\m j^^pk\i^t %P. ; 25$) P/ ; 64$) P0 ;

32$) \i_ P1 ; 13$8 Cdbpm` /D& di QO>>H+ Fi ndgd^j `s^c\ib`

ja oc` orj ocm`jidi`n ]t ^tno`di`n \o oc` M. ndo` %d+`+) Q.-0@&

g`_ oj \ gjnn ja H( ]di_dib oj oc` P. \i_ P1 ndo`) \n r`gg \n \

g\mb` m`_p^odji di k`mh`\odji `q`ion %.+/2 `q`ion,#n&+ Ejr*

`q`m) diomj_p^odji ja \ ndibg` `s^c\ib` %d+`+) Q.-0@ ja epno

ji` ja oc` orj ocm`jidi`n di M.& di^m`\n`_ oc` iph]`m ja

k`mh`\odji `q`ion %..+1 `q`ion,#n&) \gocjpbc oc` dji j^^p*

k\i^t \o oc` P. \i_ P1 ndo` m`h\di`_ gjr %Cdbpm` /E&+ Qcdn ^ji*

"mhn oc\o hpo\odji ja oc` P1 ocm`jidi` ^\pn`n \ h\ejm ^c\ib`

di "go`m dji j^^pk\i^t ndhdg\m oj oc\o m`kjmo`_ ajm H^n> %Wcjp

\i_ J\^Hdiiji) /--1&+ @jh]di`_ rdoc jpm api^odji\g hpo\b`i*

`ndn _\o\ ncjri \]jq`) oc`n` m`npgon npbb`no oc\o oc` dji ]di_*

dib di oc` "go`m m`km`n`ion \ ^mdod^\g no`k di ocdn qjgo\b`*b\odib

h`^c\idnh+

8JGN=CA"(AKAI@AIN +=NEIC -M %BBA?NA@ >S NDA 3ALHA=IN

-JI 5KA?EAM

Qj apmoc`m `skgjm` oc` mjg` ja oc` "go`m) r` i`so diq`nodb\o`_ oc`

dji _`k`i_`i^` ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji+ Pomdfdibgt) m`kg\^`h`io ja

diom\^`ggpg\m H( ]t O]( di^m`\n`_ oc` qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io \^odq\*

odji ja QOBH*. \mjpi_ .--*ajg_) m`npgodib di g\mb` jpor\m_

^pmm`ion \i_ g\mb` o\dg ^pmm`ion %Cdbpm` 0>&+ Qc` qjgo\b` _`k`i*

_`i^` ja oc` di^m`\n` di o\dg ^pmm`ion %m`#`^odib oc` ngjk` ja

oc` di^m`\n` di .6& r\n ijo \go`m`_ di ^jhk\mdnji oj H( %Cdb*

pm` 0?&+ Fhkjmo\iogt) oc` kjo`iod\odji ja ^pmm`ion ]t O]( jigt

j^^pmm`_ pkji np]nodopodji rdoc diom\^`ggpg\m O]( %Cdbpm` 0>&

\i_ oc`m`ajm` rdoc jpor\m_ O]( k`mh`\odji+ Qc`n` m`npgon ijo

jigt npbb`no oc\o O]( kjo`iod\o`n qjgo\b` \^odq\odji ]po oc\o

oc` _dm`^odji ja dji*#ps dn \gnj ^mdod^\g) d+`+) H/M ^c\ii`gn

\kk`\m oj ]` b\o`_ ]t \ ji`*r\t) iji*m`opmi) jm vv^c`^f

q\gq`ww*gdf` dji*#ps h`^c\idnh ocmjpbc rcd^c jpor\m_ hjq`*

h`io ja djin b\o`n oc` "go`m jk`i) rcdg` dir\m_ k`mh`\odji

b\o`n oc` "go`m ^gjn`_ %Cdbpm` 0A&+ Fi \bm``h`io rdoc ocdn) r`

ajpi_ oc\o ^c\ibdib oc` m`q`mn\g kjo`iod\g ]t \go`mdib oc` `som\*

^`ggpg\m H( ^ji^`iom\odji ^\pn`_ \ k\m\gg`g ncdao di oc` qjgo\b`

_`k`i_`i^` ja \^odq\odji ajm QO>>H) QOBH*/) \i_ Q>PH*0

%Cdbpm`n 0@ \i_ P2@&+

T` \gnj h`\npm`_ qjgo\b` \^odq\odji ajm _daa`m`io H/M ^c\i*

i`gn %QO>>H) QOBH*.) QOBH*/) Q>IH*/) Q>PH*0) \i_ QOBPH&

rdoc q\mdjpn diom\^`ggpg\m k`mh`\io djin %Cdbpm`n 0B \i_ P1>x

P1B&+ Fi QO>>H r` ajpi_ oc\o) ndhdg\m oj QOBH*.) qjgo\b` \^odq\*

odji r\n kjo`iod\o`_ ]t O](+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) \gocjpbc @n( r\n

kjjmgt k`mh`\]g` %kmj_p^dib jigt nh\gg jpor\m_ ^pmm`ion&) do

`qjf`_ g\mb` o\dg ^pmm`ion ajm kjo`iod\gn kjndodq` oj oc` m`q`mn\g

kjo`iod\g+ Fhkjmo\iogt) ocdn _`hjinom\o`n oc\o do dn oc` dji

]di_dib no`k rdocdi oc` "go`m \i_ ijo oc` k`mh`\odib m\o` oc\o _`*

o`mhdi`n qjgo\b` \^odq\odji+ Tdoc diom\^`ggpg\m K\( oc` o\dg ^pm*

m`ion r`m` nh\gg di \gg o`no`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn %Cdbpm`n 0B \i_

P1>xP1B&) \n r`m` oc` o\dg ^pmm`ion pndib diom\^`ggpg\m KJAD(

%_\o\ ijo ncjri&+ Fi Q>PH*0 \i_ QOBPH ^c\ii`gn jigt \ nh\gg

kjo`iod\odji ]t diom\^`ggpg\m O]( jm @n( r\n j]n`mq`_ %Cdbpm`n

P1A \i_ P1B&+

Cjm QO>>H \i_ QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn) r` ajpi_ oc\o diom\^`ggpg\m

Qg( ]`c\q`_ ndhdg\m oj H() d+`+) don `aa`^on r`m` h\mf`_gt g`nn

kmjijpi^`_ oc\i ocjn` ja @n( jm O]( %Cdbpm`n 0B \i_ P1>&+

Fiomdbpdibgt) ocdn djid^ kmj"g` ajm qjgo\b` b\odib ^jmm`g\o`n rdoc

_daa`m`i^`n di dji j^^pk\i^d`n j]n`mq`_ ^mtno\ggjbm\kcd^\ggt

rdocdi oc` "go`m ja H^n>+ Fi oc`n` nomp^opm`n) H( \i_ Qg( ]di_

rdoc ndhdg\m j^^pk\i^t oj \gg ajpm ndo`n %P.xP1&) rc`m`\n @n(

\i_ O]( ]di_ rdoc \ _daa`m`io kmj"g` oj jigt ocm`` ndo`n oc\o jq`m*

g\k km`_jhdi\iogt rdoc P.) P0) \i_ P1 %Wcjp \i_ J\^Hdiiji)

/--0&+ Qj diq`nodb\o` oc` m`g\odq` j^^pk\i^t ja oc`n` djin di \

H/M ^c\ii`g) r` ndhpg\o`_ k`mh`\odji di QO>>H rdoc O]( \i_

@n(+ Qc`n` ndhpg\odjin ^g`\mgt ncjr \ _daa`m`io _dnomd]podji

^jhk\m`_ oj H( %Cdbpm` 0C&) rdoc km`a`m`iod\g j^^pk\i^t ja P.)

P0) \i_ P1 ]t @n( \i_ O](+ ?di_dib ja oc`n` djin oj oc` P/

ndo` r\n nomjibgt m`_p^`_+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) oc` m`_p^odji di j^^p*

k\i^t ja oc` P/ ndo` ^\pn`_ \ h\mf`_ di^m`\n` di P1 j^^pk\i^t

ajm O]( ^jhk\m`_ oj H( %Cdbpm` 0C&+

Cpmoc`m `qd_`i^` ajm oc` `aa`^o ja k`mh`\io djin ji oc` "go`m

^jh`n amjh nop_d`n ja ]gj^f`mn) np^c \n o`om\k`iotg\hhjidph

%QM>(&) oc\o dio`m\^o rdoc oc` ocm`jidi` nd_` ^c\din ja oc` P1

ndo` \i_ ncjpg_ oc`m`ajm` _dm`^ogt ^jhk`o` rdoc djin ajm ]di_dib

oj ocdn ndo` %Md`^cjoo\ `o \g+) /-..&+ T` m`\nji`_ oc\o pkji

nrdo^cdib amjh H( oj O]() QM>( \a"idot h\t _mjk \n \ m`npgo ja

di^m`\n`_ j^^pk\i^t ja P1 ]t O]( \i_ ocpn di^m`\n` ^jhk`od*

odji rdoc QM>(+ Fi_``_) rdoc diom\^`ggpg\m O]( %\i_ `som\^`ggpg\m

H(& r` ajpi_ oc\o QM>( \a"idot _mjkk`_ \o oc` kjdio \o rcd^c

k`mh`\odji nrdo^c`n amjh H( oj O]() d+`+) \o qjgo\b`n kjndodq`

oj oc` Bm`q+ %Cdbpm` 0D&+ Ejr`q`m) di nthh`omd^\g H( qjgo\b`

_`k`i_`i^` ja QM>( dicd]dodji r\n i`doc`m n``i pkji ^pmm`io

diq`mndji ijm r\n QM>( \a"idot qjgo\b` _`k`i_`io rc`i oc` "go`m

^ji_p^o`_ `doc`m O]( jm H( %Cdbpm` 0D&+ Qcdn kmjqd_`n _dm`^o

api^odji\g q\gd_\odji ja oc` JA ndhpg\odjin \i_ npbb`non oc\o

O]( kjo`iod\odji ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji m`npgon amjh \ ^c\ib` di "g*

o`m dji j^^pk\i^t+

0A=MOLEIC NDA +=NEIC 'D=LCA

Fi Hq ^c\ii`gn) oc` b\odib ^c\mb` oc\o dn ^jpkg`_ oj kjm` jk`idib

dn _`o`mhdi`_ ]t kgjoodib oc` o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n %d+`+) oc` m`g\*

odq` di^m`\n` di .-& \b\dino oc` \^odq\odib km`*kpgn` qjgo\b`n+ Qc`

ngjk` ja \ no\i_\m_ ?jgouh\ii "o oj oc` _`mdq`_ D*S kgjon m`km`*

n`ion oc` `lpdq\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` \i_ ocpn oc` am\^odji ja `i*

`mbt pn`_ oj jk`i oc` ^c\ii`g rc`i ^c\mb` dn om\ingj^\o`_

\^mjnn oc` `iodm` `g`^omd^ "`g_ ja oc` h`h]m\i`+ Cjm ^jhk\mdnji)

r` _`o`mhdi`_ oc` `lpdq\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` ajm Hq/+. ^c\ii`gn

\i_) ndhdg\m oj km`qdjpn h`\npm`h`ion %P^cjgg` `o \g+) /--1&)

ajpi_ do oj ]` 1+3 ! -+0 `g`h`io\mt ^c\mb`n %`-& %Cdbpm`n 1?

\i_ 1@&+

Qj "o oc` D*S kgjon ja H/M ^c\ii`gn rdoc \ ?jgouh\ii api^odji

m`lpdm`n oc` o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n oj n\opm\o` rdoc \ ^c\ib` di

qjgo\b`+ Cjm H( %\i_ Qg(&) ij n\opm\odji r\n n``i+ Ejr`q`m) ajm

O]( \i_ @n( n\opm\odib D*S ^pmq`n r`m` j]n`mq`_ m`q`\gdib

\i `lpdq\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` ]`or``i .+5 \i_ /+3 `- ajm \gg oc`

H/M ^c\ii`gn o`no`_ %QO>>H) QOBH*.) QOBH*/) Q>IH*.)

Q>IH*/) \i_ QOBPH8 Cdbpm`n 1>x1@&+ Tc`i \q`m\b`_ ajm \gg

oc`n` ^c\ii`gn) oc` b\odib ^c\mb` r\n \]jpo /+/ `-+ Qcdn q\gp`

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4/,

Page 7: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

! "

# $

%

& '

0DBNK@ ($ 3IH#0FNQ 1=MDHB 3L 9@HLDMDO@ MI MC@ 7@KG@=HM 3IH 9J@>D@L

%>& QOBH*. ^pmm`io m`nkjin`n oj qjgo\b` a\hdgd`n di nthh`omd^\g H( %./- hJ XH(Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+& jm rdoc H( `s^c\ib`_ ]t O]( ji oc` diom\^`ggpg\m) `som\^`ggpg\m)

jm ]joc nd_`n ja oc` h`h]m\i` k\o^c`n+

%?& Kjmh\gdu`_ o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n ajm oc` di_d^\o`_ km`*kpgn` kjo`iod\gn rdoc ./- hJ H(dio+ %]g\^f ^dm^g`n& \i_ ./- hJ O](

dio+ %m`_ ^dm^g`n&8 _\o\ \m` \n

h`\i ! PBJ+

%@& @dm^g`n m`km`n`io F*S ^pmq`n rdoc 5 hJ jm ./- hJ H(`so+ ajm QO>>H \i_ QOBH*/ di_d^\odib oc` k\m\gg`g ncdao ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \i_ Bm`q++

%A& @\mojji _`kd^odib oc` ^c`^f*q\gq` dji*#ps b\odib ]`c\qdjm rdoc jpor\m_ dji k`mh`\odji jk`idib oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m \i_ dir\m_ dji hjq`h`io ^gjndib oc`

"go`m8 oc` nomp^opm` \]jq` oc` kjm` di_d^\o`n oc` `som\^`ggpg\m ^\k _jh\di+

%B& Sjgo\b`*`qjf`_ QO>>H ^pmm`ion rdoc ./- hJ H(`so+ \i_ q\mdjpn diom\^`ggpg\m djin %./- hJ& \n di_d^\o`_+

%C& JA ndhpg\odjin k`majmh`_ ji QO>>H ncjr oc` m`g\odq` dji j^^pk\i^d`n ajm oc` P.xP1 ndo`n rdoc O]( \i_ @n( k`mh`\odji di ^jhk\mdnji oj H( k`mh`\odji

%]g\^f _joo`_ gdi`&+

%D& Qc` F@2- ajm QOBH*. ^c\ii`g dicd]dodji ]t QM>( r\n _`o`mhdi`_ ajm oc` m`nk`^odq` qjgo\b`n di nthh`omd^\g H( \i_ rdoc diom\^`ggpg\m O]( m`kg\^dib H(8 _\o\ \m`

\n h`\i ! PBJ+

P`` \gnj Cdbpm` P1+

4/- @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 8: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

m`km`n`ion oc` gjr`m gdhdo ja ^c\mb` hjq`h`io ^jpkg`_ oj oc`

^c\ii`g jk`idib m`\^odji %Pdbb \i_ ?`u\idgg\) .664&+

Fa r` \nnph` oc` h`h]m\i` `g`^omd^ "`g_ dn aj^pn`_ ji oc` "g*

o`m %@jiom`m\n `o \g+) /-.-8 Gd\ib `o \g+) /--/&) oc`i \ ^c\mb`

`lpdq\g`io oj \o g`\no /+/ `- hpno ]` om\ingj^\o`_ \^mjnn oc` "go`m

oj ^jiq`mo do dioj oc` jk`i ^jiajmh\odji %Cdbpm` 1C&+ Cjm ocdn oj

j^^pm) r` hpno \nnph` oc\o oc` di\^odq` "go`m %d+`+) \o !5- hS&

m`km`n`ion \i vvdji*_`kg`o`_ww no\o` ^jio\didib jigt ji` %jm

u`mj& djin \i_ h\t oc`m`ajm` ]` ndhdg\m oj oc` vv@*otk`*di\^od*

q\o`_ww no\o` j]n`mq`_ di H^n> %?jdo`ps \i_ ?`mi [̀ ^c`) /-..8

@p`ggj `o \g+) /-.-&+ Lpm hj_`g oc`i km`_d^on oc\o pkji

_`kjg\mdu\odji) 0x1 \__dodji\g djin \m` ajm^`_ dioj oc` "go`m

]t oc` `g`^omd^ "`g_ \i_ oc\o ocdn dji om\ingj^\odji no`k dn m`*

#`^o`_ di jpm h`\npm`h`io ja oc` `lpdq\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` %Cdb*

pm` 1C&+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) ]`^\pn` oc` odh` ^jpmn` ja \^odq\odji dn

qjgo\b` di_`k`i_`io) \ n`^ji_ b\odib no`k hpno ajggjr ocdn dji

!5

>4DNMESDRJTF

>)

>(

>*

>+

>4JNM$NDDSOJFE>4JNM$EFOKFRFE

FKF

DRP

JDGJ

FKE

0

>4

' ()

)%) F'

&

'

+'

/'

$+'

$/'

?=37$)

*' ()'

'

+'

/'

JMR% =C# DNMD% !L9"

,''

$+'

$/'

?=007

FV% 7# DNMD% !L9"

)' *' ()'

$+'

'

+'

$+'

'

+'

;N

PLB

KJWFE

RBJK

DS

PPF

MRQ

@NKRBHF !L@"

$('' $,' ' #,' #('' #(,'

(%'

'%'

'%,

?=37$(

()' 7#-' 7#

*' 7#+ 7#

()' 2Q#

$

FV% 7# DNMD% !L9"

+ *' -' ()'

'

+'

/'

()'

@(

&)!L

@"

'

+'

/'

()'

3PF

T%!L

@"

?=37$(%

@(&)

(*' L@

,M

0

,' L@

(, L@

?=007

,' LQ

42/0"% %$* ; & &#& ; $#% .7!

4-10"& %$$ ; ' &#& ; $#% .7!

42/0"& *$ ; & &#) ; $#& .7!

42/30 '& ; & %#, ; $#% .7!

42/0"& '% ; & &#' ; $#% 26!

42--0 %* ; & &#( ; $#% 26!

08&#% "(* ; & (#) ; $#' 0!

2IBMMFK @(&) !L@" F' 6NMJMR%

;N

PLBKJ

WF

ERB

JKD

SPP

FM

RQ

@NKRBHF !L@"

$('' $,' ' #,' #(''

(%'

'%'

'%,

?=37$(

?087$)

?=37$)

?=007

?=3>7

?=37$)

?=007

7T)%(

?087$(

"

#(,'

7#

=C#

$/' L@

! #

42--0 (& ; % &#% ; $#& .7!

4-10"% (+ ; & %#+ ; $#& 26!

GBQR QRFO QKNU QRFO

0DBNK@ )$ <IFM=B@ 9@HLDMDODMR ,KDL@L AKIG MC@ 5IO@G@HM IA 3IHL PDMCDH MC@ /F@>MKD> 0D@F? IA MC@ 9@F@>MDODMR 0DFM@K

%>& QO>>H ^pmm`ion rdoc diom\^`ggpg\m O]( %./- hJ XO](Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+& ajm _daa`m`io kjo`iod\gn ncjr \ h\sdh\g .- \^cd`q`_ ajm kjo`iod\gn kjndodq` oj (2- hS

\n apmoc`m _`kjg\mdu\odji _j`n ijo di^m`\n` o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n+

%?& Kjmh\gdu`_ o\dg ^pmm`io q`mnpn km`*kpgn` qjgo\b` kgjon ajm oc` di_d^\o`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn \i_ diom\^`ggpg\m djin+

%@& Q\dg ^pmm`io km`*kpgn` qjgo\b` m`g\odjin \n di %?& "oo`_ oj \ no\i_\m_ ?jgouh\ii api^odji+ Qc` o\]g` ncjrn oc` "o k\m\h`o`mn S.,/ ! PBJ \i_ u %; `lpdq\g`io

b\odib ^c\mb` X`-Y& ! PBJ ajm oc` di_d^\o`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn \i_ diom\^`ggpg\m djin+

%A& Qc` S.,/ ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji ncdaon rdoc Bm`q+ \n ncjri c`m` ajm o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_` q`mnpn km`*kpgn` qjgo\b` kgjon ajm QOBH*. rdoc _daa`m`io H(`so++

%B& S.,/ ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji %]g\^f nlp\m`n& \i_ h`\npm`_ Bm`q+ q\gp`n %bm\t nlp\m`n& \m` kgjoo`_ ajm QOBH*.) QOBH*/) \i_ QO>>H ^c\ii`gn rdoc q\mdjpn

`som\^`ggpg\m \i_ diom\^`ggpg\m dji ^ji^`iom\odjin+ P`` \gnj Cdbpm`n P2> \i_ P2?+

%C& @\mojji _`kd^odib oc` qjgo\b` n`injm di H/M ^c\ii`gn+ Qc` nomp^opm` m`km`n`ion QO>>H %\_jko`_ amjh ?mjc\ri `o \g+) /-./& `h]`__`_ di \ ]dg\t`m8 oc` `g`^omd^

kjo`iod\g _mjk \^mjnn oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m %PC& dn di_d^\o`_+ Qc` di\^odq\o`_ PC dn ncjri \n \ nomp^opm\ggt _dnodi^o dji*_`kg`o`_ no\o` %PCdji*_`kg`o`_&+ Rkji _`kj*

g\mdu\odji) 0x1 djin \m` ajm^`_ dioj oc` "go`m ]t oc` cdbc*`g`^omd^ "`g_ %PCdji*j^^pkd`_&+ Qcdn cdbcgt ^c\mb`_ no\o` dn ijo no\]g` \i_ oc`i om\inajmhn dioj oc` k`mh`\odib

no\o` %PC^ji_p^odq`&+

P`` \gnj Cdbpm` P2+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4/.

Page 9: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

om\ingj^\odji no`k) \i_ ocdn dn m`km`n`io`_ ]t oc` ngjr`m) odh`*

_`k`i_`io ^jiajmh\odji\g ^c\ib` ja oc` "go`m dioj oc` \^odq`

%d+`+) ^ji_p^odq`& no\o` %Cdbpm` 1C&+

8JGN=CA %?NEP=NEJI -M 6ECDNGS 'JOKGA@ NJ NDA

)GA?NLJ?DAHE?=G +L=@EAIN

Qj apmoc`m q\gd_\o` ocdn hj_`g) r` diq`nodb\o`_ oc` m`g\odjincdk

]`or``i oc` _dm`^odji ja dji #jr \i_ qjgo\b` \^odq\odji ]t

h`\npmdib oc` S.,/ q\gp` \o q\mtdib `som\^`ggpg\m H( ^ji^`iom\*

odjin ajm n`q`m\g _daa`m`io H/M ^c\ii`gn %QO>>H) QOBH*.) \i_

QOBH*/&+ T` ajpi_ oc\o S.,/ ncdao`_ di k\m\gg`g rdoc oc` m`q`mn\g

kjo`iod\g %d+`+) oc` qjgo\b` kjdio \o rcd^c dji*#ps m`q`mn`n&)

m`b\m_g`nn ja rc`oc`m oc` diom\^`ggpg\m jm `som\^`ggpg\m dji ^ji*

^`iom\odji r\n ^c\ib`_ %Cdbpm`n 1A) 1B) P2>) \i_ P2?&+ Qcdn

^g`\mgt _`hjinom\o`n oc\o do dn ijo oc` om\inh`h]m\i` qjgo\b`

k`m n` oc\o _mdq`n H/M ^c\ii`g b\odib) ]po oc` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g

_mdqdib ajm^`) d+`+) oc` _daa`m`i^` %!#& ]`or``i oc` \^op\g

h`h]m\i` qjgo\b` %Sh& \i_ oc` m`q`mn\g kjo`iod\g %Bm`q+&) %!# ;

Sh x Bm`q+&+

@ !L@"

6!M

0"

$('

*'

$*'

#/'$/'

7#

=C#

7# # (' Y9 00=C# # (' Y9 00

#/'$/'

)'

('

@ !L@"

6!M

0"

@ !L@"

6!M

0"

#/'$/'

@ !L@"

6&6 L

BV (%'

'%,

$'%,

$(%'

#/'$/'

@ !L@"

6&6 L

BV (%'

'%,

$'%,

$(%'

?=007 ?)()2(

?=007 ?)()2)

(''

.,

'

,'

),4N

KEDI

BM

HF

NG

BDRJ

TBRJ

NM

BR

$('

'L

@

<6<)

<6<)00

00*

?=007 ?=37$)?=007% & '

( Y9 00

'%, Y9 00

) Y9 00

(' Y9 00

)M

0

('' LQ

?=007

$/' L@

#('' L@

?=007

A?'%, Y9 00( Y9 00) Y9 00, Y9 00

?=37$)# ?=007$

!

"

#(''

@ !L@"

6&6 L

BV (%'

'%,

$'%,

#(''

@ !L@"

6&6 L

BV (%'

'%,

$'%,

#(''

@ !L@"

6&6 L

BV (%'

'%,

$'%,

A?( Y9 00) Y9 00, Y9 00(' Y9 00

A?(' Y9 <6<)

7#

=C#

7# $, LL 5H=C# $, LL 5H

7# O5 ,=C# O5 ,

7#

7# # (' Y9 00

7#

7# # (' Y9 <6<)

('

)'

#/'$/'

$)'

$('

$)'

$('

#,' #,'#,'

#+'

#+'$+' #+'$+'#+'$+'

#+'$+' $+'

0DBNK@ *$ 4'7 -C=HH@F ,>MDO=MIKL 9PDM>C MC@

0DFM@K 1=MDHB 5I?@

%>& QO>>H ^pmm`ion m`^jm_`_ rdoc di^m`\ndib

\m\^cd_jid^ \^d_ %>>& ^ji^`iom\odjin di nthh`omd*

^\g H( amjh dind_`*jpo k\o^c`n+

%? \i_ @& Cmjh `sk`mdh`ion \n ncjri di %>&) F*S

^pmq`n \m` kgjoo`_ ajm _daa`m`io >> ^ji^`iom\odjin

ajm QO>>H ^c\ii`gn %?& \i_ QOBH*/ ^c\ii`gn %@&+

%A& F*S kgjon ajm QO>>H ^pmm`ion ]`ajm` \i_ \ao`m

^c\ii`g \^odq\odji ]t .- #J MFM/+

%B& O`km`n`io\odq` m\hk h`\npm`h`ion ja QO>>H

^c\ii`gn \^odq\o`_ ]t .- #J >> rdoc `doc`m H( jm

O]( \n oc` diom\^`ggpg\m dji+

%C& O`km`n`io\odq` m\hkn ja QO>>H ^c\ii`gn \^od*

q\o`_ ]t 2 hhEb i`b\odq` km`nnpm` \kkgd`_ qd\ oc`

k\o^c kdk`oo` rdoc `doc`m H( jm O]( \n oc` diom\^`g*

gpg\m dji+

%D& O`km`n`io\odq` m\hkn ja QOBH*/ \^odq\o`_ ]t

kEdio+ 2+- rdoc `doc`m H( jm O]( \n oc` diom\^`ggpg\m

dji+

%E \i_ F& QO>>H Q/./@ ^pmm`ion g\^f \^odq\odji ]t

>> \i_ MFM/+

%G& Cjg_ ^pmm`io ^c\ib` %^pmm`io%(\^odq\ojm&,

^pmm`io%x\^odq\ojm&& ajm QO>>H TQ \i_ QO>>H Q/./@

^c\ii`gn pkji \kkgd^\odji ja .- #J >> jm .- #J

MFM/ \o !.-- hS8 _\o\ \m` \n h`\i ! PBJ+

P`` \gnj Cdbpm` P3+

.#3 'D=IIAG %?NEP=NEJI '=OMAM =

+=NEIC 0J@A 5DEBN QENDEI NDA

5AGA?NEPENS *EGNAL

QO>>H) QOBH*.) \i_ QOBH*/ ^c\ii`gn

\m` \^odq\o`_ ]t \m\^cd_jid^ \^d_ %>>&

%Ejijm {̀ ) /--4&+ T` oc`m`ajm` diq`nodb\o`_

cjr >> \aa`^on qjgo\b` b\odib ]t j]o\di*

dib F*S ^pmq`n di \ nthh`omd^\g H( bm\_d`io

di rcd^c qjgo\b` b\odib dn hjno j]qdjpn+ Fi

dind_`*jpo k\o^c`n) >> \^odq\o`_ QO>>H)

QOBH*.) \i_ QOBH*/ ^c\ii`gn rdoc B@2-

q\gp`n ja .+/ ! -+.) 3+6 ! .+/) \i_ 0+5 !

-+1 #J) m`nk`^odq`gt %Cdbpm`n P3? \i_ P3@&+ T` \gnj ajpi_

oc\o ocdn nomjib jpor\m_gt m`^odatdib ]`c\qdjm kmjbm`nndq`gt

om\inajmh`_ dioj \ gdi`\m ^ji_p^o\i^` rdoc di^m`\ndib ^ji^`i*

om\odjin ja >> %Cdbpm`n 2>x2@ \i_ P3>&+ Cjm >> ^ji^`iom\odjin

]`gjr oc` B@2- q\gp`n) jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji \i_ oc` ^jmm`*

nkji_dib o\dg ^pmm`ion r`m` nodgg kmjhdi`io) ]po \o cdbc`m ^ji^`i*

om\odjin ocdn `aa`^o \ghjno ^jhkg`o`gt _dn\kk`\m`_ %Cdbpm`n 2> oj

2@ \i_ P3>&+

Qj `s\hdi` rc`oc`m joc`m m`bpg\ojmt h`^c\idnhn \aa`^o ocdn

kmj^`nn) r` \^odq\o`_ oc`n` ^c\ii`gn rdoc km`nnpm`) MFM/) \i_

\gnj \^d_d^ kE \i_ ajpi_ oc\o \gg ja oc`n` nodhpgd m`_p^`_

qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \i_ m`npgo`_ di gdi`\m F*Sn ndhdg\m oj >> \^od*

q\odji+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) \^odq\odji ja QO>>H \gnj \]jgdnc`_ O](

kjo`iod\odji ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji %Cdbpm`n 2B \i_ 2C&+ Jjm`*

jq`m) oc` Q/./@ "go`m hpo\odji oc\o \]jgdnc`_ qjgo\b` \^odq\odji

di QO>>H ^c\ii`gn %Cdbpm` /A& \gnj m`hjq`_ \^odq\odji ]t >>

\i_ MFM/ %Cdbpm`n 2Ex2G&+ Qcdn kmjqd_`n apmoc`m `qd_`i^` oc\o

oc`n` _daa`m`io h`^c\idnhn ^jiq`mb` ji oc` "go`m \n oc` kmd*

h\mt b\o`+

4// @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 10: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

8JGN=CA %?NEP=NEJI JB .#3 'D=IIAGM OI@AL 3DSMEJGJCE?=G

.! 'JI@ENEJIM

Qj apmoc`m diq`nodb\o` H/M ^c\ii`g \^odq\odji pi_`m kctndjgjbd^\g

^ji_dodjin \i_ `hkc\ndu` oc` dhkjmo\i^` ja ocdn dji*#ps b\odib

h`^c\idnh) r` m`^jm_`_ QO>>H ^c\ii`gn rdoc \ kctndjgjbd^\g

H( bm\_d`io %./- hJ H(dio+,1 hJ H(

`so+&) \ nthh`omd^\g H(

bm\_d`io %n`` \gnj Cdbpm` 2>&) \i_ \i diq`mo`_ kctndjgjbd^\g H(

bm\_d`io %1 hJ H(dio+,./- hJ H(

`so+& %Cdbpm`n 3>x3@&+ Fi \i di*

q`mo`_ H( bm\_d`io) jigt q`mt nh\gg ^pmm`ion r`m` n``i \i_ >>

kmj_p^`_ \mjpi_ .--*ajg_ di^m`\n` ja oc` dir\m_ ^pmm`io %Cdb*

pm` 3>&+ >^^jm_dib oj jpm hj_`g) oc` vv^c`^f q\gq`ww h`^c\idnh

rdgg cjg_ oc` "go`m ^gjn`_ ajm dir\m_ ^pmm`ion) \i_ jigt rc`i oc`

q\gq` dn jk`i`_ ]t >> rdgg g\mb` dir\m_ ^pmm`ion ]` \]g` oj

_`q`gjk+ Tdoc \ nthh`omd^\g H( bm\_d`io) \ g\mb` di^m`\n` ja di*

r\m_ ^pmm`io dn \gnj n``i %Cdbpm` 3?&+ Qc` ajg_ di^m`\n` pkji

>> nodhpg\odji ajm oc` jpor\m_ ^pmm`ion r\n nh\gg`m ^jindno`io

rdoc oc` "i_dib oc\o #ps b\odib \^odq\o`n QO>>H oj njh` _`bm``

\o _`kjg\mdu`_ kjo`iod\gn %Cdbpm`n 2> \i_ 3?&+ ?t h\mf`_

^jiom\no) rc`i \ kctndjgjbd^\g H( bm\_d`io dn pn`_) g\mb` jpor\m_

^pmm`ion \m` n``i _p` oj oc` g\mb` jpor\m_gt _dm`^o`_ ^c`hd^\g

_mdqdib ajm^` oc\o kpnc`n \ ndbid"^\io am\^odji ja ^c\ii`gn dioj

oc` jk`i "go`m no\o` %3@&+ Fi ocdn ndop\odji) >> jigt di_p^`n \ m`g\*

odq`gt hj_`no di^m`\n` %/+3* ! -+2*ajg_& di ^pmm`io \o nomjibgt

_`kjg\mdudib kjo`iod\gn %`+b+) (5- hS& ]`^\pn` oc` dji*#ps

h`^c\idnh c\n \gm`\_t jk`i`_ oc` "go`m %Cdbpm`n 3@ \i_ 3A&+

Pdhdg\m m`npgon r`m` j]o\di`_ ajm QOBH*. %Cdbpm` 3A&+ Qc`n` m`*

npgon oc`m`ajm` _`hjinom\o` oc\o pi_`m kctndjgjbd^\g ^ji_dodjin

%d+`+) gjr H(`so+& pinodhpg\o`_ QO>>H \i_ QOBH ^c\ii`gn \gnj

b`i`m\o` ndbid"^\io jpor\m_ ^pmm`ion pkji _`kjg\mdu\odji

]`^\pn` oc` i`b\odq` Bm`q+ nomjibgt a\qjmn oc` dji*#ps b\odib

h`^c\idnh \o oc`n` kjo`iod\gn+

(-5'755-21

Fi ocdn nop_t r` m`q`\g cjr \i dji ^c\ii`g ^\i \^cd`q` pikm`^*

`_`io`_ n`indodqdot oj ^c\ib`n di om\inh`h]m\i` qjgo\b`

rdocjpo \ ^\ijid^\g SPA \i_ c\q` m`njgq`_ oc` h`^c\idnhn pi*

_`mgtdib ocdn `aa`^o+ T` \gnj ncjr oc\o ocdn qjgo\b` n`indodqdot dn

^jhhji oj i`\mgt \gg H/M ^c\ii`gn) oc`m`]t m`_`"idib jpm pi*

_`mno\i_dib ja ocdn a\hdgt+

! " #

% &

$

0DBNK@ +$ ;C@ 9@F@>MDODMR 0DFM@K 9@HL@L MC@ /F@>MKI>C@GD>=F 7IM@HMD=F

%>x@& QO>>H ^pmm`io m`nkjin`n rdoc \i diq`mo`_ kctndjgjbd^\g H( bm\_d`io %1 hJ H(dio+,./- hJ H(

`so+& %>&) nthh`omd^\g H( bm\_d`io %./- hJ H(dio+,./- hJ H(

`so+&

%?&) \i_ kctndjgjbd^\g H( bm\_d`io %./- hJ H(dio+,1 hJ H(

`so+& %@& ]`ajm` \i_ \ao`m >> %.- #J& \^odq\odji+

%A& ?\mn %h`\i ! PBJ& di_d^\o` ajg_ di^m`\n` ja ^pmm`ion \o (5- hS pkji >> \^odq\odji ajm \ kctndjgjbd^\g bm\_d`io ^jhk\m`_ oj \ nthh`omd^\g bm\_d`io di QOBH*.

\i_ QO>>H ^c\ii`gn+

%B& Fggpnom\odji ja oc` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g _mdqdib ajm^` %d+`+) !# ; Sh ! Bm`q+& _`k`i_`i^` ja H/M b\odib rdoc \ kjndodq` !#) g`\_dib oj \^odq\odji ]po di\^odq\odji ajm \

i`b\odq` !#+

%C& @\mojji ja oc` kmjkjn`_ h`^c\idnh ja #ps*^jpkg`_ b\odib _`kd^odib oc\o ajm \ i`b\odq` !# %d+`+) \gg qjgo\b`n i`b\odq` oj oc` Bm`q+& oc` "go`m dn dji*_`kg`o`_ \i_

di\^odq` %PCdji*_`kg`o`_&+ Cjm qjgo\b`n kjndodq` oj Bm`q+) oc` ^c\ii`gn no\mo oj \^odq\o` \n \i di^m`\ndib am\^odji ja oc` ^c\ii`gn kjkpg\o` oc` di\^odq` ]po ijr dji*

j^^pkd`_ no\o` %PCdji*j^^pkd`_& oc\o m\kd_gt ^jiq`mon dioj oc` \^odq` jpor\m_gt k`mh`\odib no\o` %PCdjin*jpor\m_&+ Rkji diq`mndji ja oc` _mdqdib ajm^` %d+`+) ajm kjo`iod\gn

i`b\odq` oj oc` Bm`q+&) oc` PC jigt om\ind`iogt ^ji_p^on dir\m_ ^pmm`ion \n ocdn no\o` dn ijo no\]g` %PCdjin*dir\m_& \i_ "i\ggt \_jkon oc` didod\g) nomp^opm\ggt _dnodi^o) dji*

_`kg`o`_) \i_ di\^odq` no\o` %PCdji*_`kg`o`_&+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4/0

Page 11: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

8JGN=CA %?NEP=NEJI PALMOM +,."NSKA TT/A=FUU 'OLLAINM

Lpm "i_dibn _`hjinom\o` oc\o qjgo\b` n`indib di H/M ^c\ii`gn

m`npgon amjh \i dji*#ps b\odib h`^c\idnh _dm`^ogt kjr`m`_ ]t

oc` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g H( bm\_d`io+ >gocjpbc ocdn kmj_p^`n nomjib

jpor\m_ m`^od"^\odji) r` ncjr oc\o do dn _dnodi^o amjh oc` iji*

gdi`\m H(*n`g`^odq` vvg`\fww ]`c\qdjm ja \i jk`i kjm` di \i

\nthh`omd^ %d+`+) kctndjgjbd^\g& H( bm\_d`io _`"i`_ ]t oc` Djg_*

h\i*Ej_bfdi*H\ou %DEH& `lp\odji+ T` oc`m`ajm` ]`gd`q` oc\o

oc` o`mh vvdji*#ps*b\o`_ww dino`\_ ja vvg`\fww h\t ]` hjm` \kkmj*

kmd\o` oj _`n^md]` oc` diomdind^ ]djkctnd^\g kmjk`mod`n ja hjno

H/M ^c\ii`gn+

Ejr`q`m) njh` H/M ^c\ii`gn %di k\mod^pg\m QO>>H) QOBH*.)

\i_ QOBH*/& ^\i ]` ^jiq`mo`_ dioj \ vv^g\nnd^\gww DEH*g`\f

hj_` rc`i nodhpg\o`_ ]t) `+b+) >> jm MFM/+ K`q`moc`g`nn) pi_`m

kctndjgjbd^\g ^ji_dodjin) #ps b\odib rdgg nodgg ]` m`g`q\io ]`^\pn`

oc` i`b\odq` Bm`q+ nomjibgt kmjhjo`n qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \o _`kj*

g\mdu`_ kjo`iod\gn \n rjpg_ j^^pm _pmdib \i \^odji kjo`iod\g+

Cpmoc`mhjm`) ajm H/M ^c\ii`gn oc\o \m` ijo \^odq\o`_ ]t np^c

nodhpgd %`+b+) Q>PH ^c\ii`gn& oc` #ps b\odib hj_` h\t ]` oc`

km`q\g`io b\odib h`^c\idnh+

Fmjid^\ggt) oc` QTFH*. ^c\ii`g) \ao`m rcd^c \gg joc`m H/M ^c\i*

i`gn r`m` jmdbdi\ggt i\h`_ %I`n\b` `o \g+) .663&) \kk`\mn oj ]`

oc` jigt H/M ^c\ii`g oc\o dn b`ipdi`gt \ H(*n`g`^odq` DEH*

otk` vvg`\fww ^c\ii`g+ Qcdn dn kjnnd]gt m`g\o`_ oj oc` pipnp\g nomp^*

opm\g \i_ api^odji\g kmjk`mod`n ja oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m di QTFH*.

%@c`i `o \g+) /-.1& ]`^\pn` r` ncjr oc\o ^c\ib`n di oc` "go`m

n`lp`i^` ja joc`m H/M ^c\ii`gn ^\i \]jgdnc #ps b\odib+

+=NEIC 'D=LCA 'JIMEMNM JB 6DLAA NJ *JOL -JIM 0JPEIC

EINJ NDA *EGNAL

Cjm oc` qjgo\b`*n`indib no`k) r` _`o`mhdi`_ \i \q`m\b` `lpdq*

\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` ja /+/ `- \i_ oc` di\^odq` "go`m \n oc` qjgo\b`*

n`indib hjoda+ Qj \^cd`q` np^c \ b\odib ^c\mb`) r` kmjkjn` oc\o

oc` di\^odq` "go`m hpno `sdno di `doc`m \i vvdji*_`kg`o`_ww no\o` %rdoc

jigt ji` jm u`mj djin& jm \ apggt vvdji*j^^pkd`_ww no\o`+ Qc` m`g\odq`

_dnomd]podji ja oc`n` orj no\o`n ^\i oc`i ]` _`n^md]`_ ]t \

qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io ?jgouh\ii api^odji+

Qc` qjgo\b` _mjk \gjib oc` ./ >! _dno\i^` ja oc` "go`m c\n ]``i

`nodh\o`_ oj m`km`n`io "5-$ ja oc` _mjk \^mjnn oc` `iodm` ocd^f*

i`nn ja oc` h`h]m\i` %Cdbpm` 1C& %@jiom`m\n `o \g+) /-.-8 Gd\ib

`o \g+) /--/&+ @jin`lp`iogt) da ocdn qjgo\b` _mjk j^^pmn gdi`\mgt

rdocdi oc` "go`m oc`i om\ingj^\odji ja oc` "mno dji amjh oc` dii`m

P2 ^\qdot ndo` %jpond_` oc` `g`^omd^ "`g_& oj oc` `som\^`ggpg\m P.

ndo` rjpg_ ^jiomd]po` -+5 `-) om\ingj^\odji ja \ n`^ji_ dji oj

P/ rjpg_ ^jiomd]po` \]jpo -+3 `- %d+`+) ocm``*ajpmocn ja -+5 `-&)

om\ingj^\odji ja \ ocdm_ dji oj P0 \]jpo -+1 `- %ji`*c\ga ja

-+5 `-& \i_ \ ajpmoc dji oj P1 \]jpo -+/ `- %ji`*ajpmoc ja

-+5 `-&+ Qc`n` ^c\mb`n nph oj /+- `-) ocpn ^gjn`gt h\o^cdib oc`

q\gp` r` c\q` _`o`mhdi`_ `sk`mdh`io\ggt+ >gocjpbc ocdn dn jigt

\ mjpbc `nodh\odji) do nomjibgt npbb`non oc\o oc` di\^odq` "go`m

hpno ]` \ghjno ^jhkg`o`gt _`qjd_ ja djin \o i`b\odq` kjo`iod\gn)

]po apggt j^^pkd`_ \o _`kjg\mdu`_ kjo`iod\gn+ Fo \gnj di_d^\o`n oc\o

ocm`` oj ajpm djin \m` ajm^`_ dioj oc` `g`^omd^ "`g_ ja oc` "go`m \o

kjo`iod\gn kjndodq` oj oc` Bm`q++ Qj oc` ]`no ja jpm fijrg`_b`)

ocdn m`km`n`ion oc` "mno _dm`^o `g`^omjkctndjgjbd^\g h`\npm`h`io

ja oc` iph]`m ja djin oc\o ^\i ndhpgo\i`jpn j^^pkt oc` "go`m di \

H( ^c\ii`g+ Mm`qdjpngt) np^c cdbc dji j^^pk\i^t r\n ^jind_*

`m`_ pigdf`gt _p` oj `g`^omjno\od^ m`kpgndji %Ajtg` `o \g+) .6658

Wcjp \i_ J\^Hdiiji) /--0&+ Ejr`q`m) m`^`io JA ndhpg\odjin

\i_ m`*`q\gp\odji ja ^mtno\ggjbm\kcd^ _\o\ c\q` lp`nodji`_ ocdn

qd`r oj npbb`no oc\o ajpm djin ^\i ndhpgo\i`jpngt j^^pkt oc` "g*

o`m %Hjy ka`m `o \g+) /-.1&+ Lpm `sk`mdh`io\g _\o\ \m` di bjj_ \bm``*

h`io rdoc ocdn d_`\+

6DA *EGNAL 5AIMAM &JND 8JGN=CA =I@ 'DAHE?=G +L=@EAINM

Cjm ndhkgd^dot) r` c\q`) piodg ijr) h\digt ^jind_`m`_ ^c\ib`n di

qjgo\b` rdoc \ ^jino\io %d+`+) nthh`omd^\g& H( bm\_d`io \^mjnn oc`

h`h]m\i`+ Ejr`q`m) r` ijr ncjr oc\o qjgo\b` b\odib dn

_dm`^ogt ^jpkg`_ oj oc` Bm`q+ %`+b+) Cdbpm` 1B&+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) ocdn

^jpkgdib j^^pmn di_`k`i_`iogt ja cjr Bm`q+ dn ^c\ib`_ %d+`+) ]t

^c\ibdib `doc`m oc` diom\^`ggpg\m jm `som\^`ggpg\m dji ^ji^`iom\*

odji& oc`m`]t npbb`nodib oc\o "go`m dji j^^pk\i^t dn \ _dm`^o api^*

odji ja ]joc oc` qjgo\b` \i_ ^c`hd^\g bm\_d`ion+ Qcdn di_d^\o`n

oc\o oc` di\^odq` "go`m ^jiajmh\odji n`in`n oc` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g

_mdqdib ajm^`8 d+`+) do ^c\ib`n don dji j^^pk\i^t \^^jm_dib oj

oc` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g kjo`iod\g+ Cjm ocdn oj c\kk`i) r` kmjkjn`

oc\o oc` vvdi\^odq`ww "go`m dn ijo `iodm`gt dhk`mh`\]g`) ]po dino`\_

^ji_p^on djin \o \ q`mt gjr m\o` oj \ggjr ^jiodipjpn `lpdgd]m\odji

ja dji ]di_dib \^^jm_dib oj oc` \^op\g `g`^omj^c`hd^\g kjo`iod\g+

% 2IA"9=S TT'DA?F 8=GPAUU"GEFA -JI"*GOR +=NEIC 0J@AG

Qc` b\odib n^c`h` r` kmjkjn` di Cdbpm` 3 kmjqd_`n \i `skg\i\*

odji ajm oc` vv^c`^f q\gq`ww dji*#ps b\odib h`^c\idnh+ Fi ocdn

hj_`g oc` "go`m ^\i \_jko \o g`\no ajpm _dnodi^o no\o`n7 orj di\^*

odq` no\o`n %\i vvdji*_`kg`o`_ww di\^odq` no\o` \i_ \i vvdji*j^^p*

kd`_ww di\^odq` no\o`&) kgpn orj \^odq` no\o`n ja oc` "go`m oc\o

\gnj _daa`m di dji j^^pk\i^t+ Qc`m`ajm`) rc`i `skjn`_ oj nomjib

i`b\odq` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g _mdqdib ajm^`n %d+`+) rc`i Sh dn i`b\odq`

oj Bm`q+ \i_ !# 9 9 -8 Cdbpm` 3B& oc` "go`m rdgg `sdno di \i vvdji*

_`kg`o`_ww di\^odq` no\o` \i_ _`kjg\mdu\odji %g`\_dib oj \ kjndodq`

!#& rdgg ajm^` n`q`m\g djin dioj oc` "go`m m`#`^odib oc` h`\npm`_

b\odib ^c\mb`+

Pp]n`lp`io oj ocdn km`nph\]gt q`mt m\kd_ dji om\ingj^\odji

no`k oc` ^c\ii`g rdgg nodgg m`nd_` di \i di\^odq`) ]po vvdji*j^^pkd`_ww

no\o` oc\o dn ijr ^\k\]g` ja om\inajmh\odji dioj \ cdbcgt \^odq`

%d+`+) ^ji_p^odq`& no\o`) \i_ do dn ocdn nomp^opm\g om\indodji oc\o m`*

#`^on oc` qjgo\b`*di_`k`i_`io fdi`od^n ja ^c\ii`g \^odq\odji+ Fo

dn kjnnd]g` oc\o oc` cdbc _`bm`` ja dji j^^pk\i^t rdocdi oc` "go`m

\i_ _dm`^o ^jpgjh]d^ dio`m\^odjin ]`or``i oc` djin h\t `s`mo

npa"^d`io ajm^`n ji oc` "go`m oj kjr`m ocdn jk`idib m`\^odji+

Ejr`q`m) do dn ^g`\m oc\o pkji \ np__`i diq`mndji ja ocdn _mdqdib

ajm^` %d+`+) m`kjg\mdu\odji& oc` no\]dgdot ja ocdn \^odq\o`_ no\o`

m\kd_gt _`^m`\n`n) m`npgodib di di\^odq\odji ja oc` g\mb` dir\m_

%o\dg& ^pmm`ion+ T` kmjkjn` oc\o oc` ^c\ii`g oc`i m`q`mon oj \

nomp^opm\ggt _dnodi^o vvdji*_`kg`o`_ww di\^odq` no\o` %n`` ^\mojji

di Cdbpm` 3C&+

@`iom\g oj ocdn h`^c\idnh dn oc\o oc` \^odq` "go`m ]`^jh`n pi*

no\]g` rc`i do ^ji_p^on dir\m_ ^pmm`io+ > nom\dbcoajmr\m_ `skg\*

i\odji dn oc\o "go`m dji j^^pk\i^t _`k`i_n ji oc` _dm`^odji ja

dji*#ps+ T` oc`m`ajm` nk`^pg\o` ocdn h\t m`npgo amjh _daa`m`io

kmj]\]dgdod`n ja j^^pk\i^t ja oc` P.xP1 ndo`n _pmdib dir\m_

\i_ jpor\m_ k`mh`\odji+ Fi_``_) m`_p^dib H( ]di_dib oj P.

\i_ P1 %`+b+) rdoc "go`m hpo\odjin di QO>>H& km`q`ion di\^odq\odji

ja ocdn dir\m_ #ps+ Cpmoc`m ndhpg\odji nop_d`n pndib oc` ^jhkpo\*

odji\g `g`^omjkctndjgjbt h`ocj_ r` _`n^md]` c`m` h\t ]` c`gk*

apg oj _dnn`^odib ocdn kmj^`nn di hjm` _`o\dg+

4/1 @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 12: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

4AG=NEJIMDEK NJ 2NDAL 0A?D=IEMHM JB 8JGN=CA 5AIMEIC

Fi ^g\nnd^\g qjgo\b`*b\o`_ H( ^c\ii`gn oc` h`^c\idnhn ja

qjgo\b` n`indib) \^odq\odji) \i_ di\^odq\odji \m` \nndbi`_ oj

_daa`m`io m`bdjin ja oc` kmjo`di) d+`+) oc` qjgo\b`*n`indib _j*

h\din) oc` c`gds*]pi_g` ^mjnndib b\o`) \i_ oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m

b\o`) m`nk`^odq`gt+ ?t ^jiom\no) H/M ^c\ii`gn \kk`\m oj c\q`

\gg ja oc`n` _daa`m`io api^odji\g kmjk`mod`n ^ji_`in`_ rdocdi

\go`mi\odq` nomp^opm\g no\o`n ja oc` "go`m %Cdbpm` 3C&+

Fio`m`nodibgt) QLH.) \ t`\no 5*QJ H/M ^c\ii`g) _dnkg\tn

b\odib kmjk`mod`n ndhdg\m oj ocjn` _`n^md]`_ c`m` ajm oc`

h\hh\gd\i H/M ^c\ii`gn) di^gp_dib \i `som\^`ggpg\m H( _`k`i*

_`i^` %H`o^cph `o \g+) .6628 Ijpfdi \i_ P\dhd) .666&+ Ejr`q`m)

ij o\dg ^pmm`ion c\q` ]``i m`kjmo`_ ajm QLH.+ Fo rdgg oc`m`ajm` ]`

dio`m`nodib oj _`o`mhdi` rc`oc`m hpo\odjin di oc` "go`m \i_,jm oc`

k`mh`\odib dji nk`^d`n \aa`^o qjgo\b` b\odib di oc`n` pipnp\g

H/M ^c\ii`gn+

Sjgo\b` b\odib h`_d\o`_ ]t oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m c\n \gnj ]``i

m`kjmo`_ di joc`m dji ^c\ii`gn+ Ejr`q`m) oc` km`^dn` h`^c\*

idnhn \kk`\m _daa`m`io \i_ oc` qjgo\b` _`k`i_`i^` dn ^g`\mgt

ijo \n h\mf`_ \n di H/M ^c\ii`gn+ Fi H^n> \i `lpdq\g`io b\odib

^c\mb` ja -+4 `- m`npgon amjh m`jmd`io\odji ja \ ^c\mb`_ m`nd_p`

rdocdi oc` "go`m %@jm_`mj*Jjm\g`n `o \g+) /--3&+ Fi JocH \ qjgo\b`*

\i_ `som\^`ggpg\m dji*_`k`i_`io di\^odq\odji h`^c\idnh m`npgon

amjh oc` _`kg`odji ja H( amjh oc` "go`m ]t nomjib _`kjg\mdu\odji

%Qcjhnji \i_ Ojoc]`mb) /-.-&+

Ejr`q`m) oc` hjno ndhdg\mdot h\t ]` rdoc oc` qjgo\b`*b\odib

kmjk`mod`n ja @I@ @g! ^c\ii`gn %Jdgg`m) /--3&+ Qc`n` ^c\ii`gn

\gnj g\^f \i j]qdjpn qjgo\b`*n`indib _jh\di) ]po _dnkg\t

qjgo\b` b\odib rdoc \i `lpdq\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` ja ". `- \i_ \

nomjib \idji _`k`i_`i^t+ Qcdn dn ocjpbco oj \mdn` amjh @g!

djin \^odib \n oc` b\odib ^c\mb` \i_ _dnkg\^dib \ ^mdod^\g bgpo\*

h\o` m`nd_p` di oc` kjm` oc\o joc`mrdn` ]gj^fn dji k`mh`\odji

%A` G`npn*M`m`u `o \g+) /-.38 Jdgg`m) /--38 Apoug`m `o \g+) /--0&+

Ejr`q`m) qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io hjq`h`io ja E( \i_ kmjoji\odji

ja ocdn bgpo\h\o` c\q` \gnj ]``i npbb`no`_ oj ^jiomd]po` oj

oc` qjgo\b` _`k`i_`i^` %Mpn^c) /--1&+ Qc` E( _`k`i_`i^t

hdbco \gnj ]` m`g\o`_ oj oc` `qjgpodji\mt gdif ]`or``i @I@ @g!

^c\ii`gn \i_ @I@ @g!,E( om\inkjmo`mn %Jdgg`m) /--3&+ Fio`m`no*

dibgt) \gocjpbc H/M ^c\ii`gn ]`\m ij nomp^opm\g m`n`h]g\i^`

oj om\inkjmo`mn) ocdn #ps b\odib h`^c\idnh apmoc`m ^gjn`n oc`

h`^c\idnod^ b\k ]`or``i dji ^c\ii`gn \i_ om\inkjmo`mn \n

]joc h`^c\idnhn podgdu` oc` `g`^omj^c`hd^\g bm\_d`io oj kjr`m

\ ^jiajmh\odji\g ^c\ib`) ji` ]`dib \i dji om\ingj^\odji no`k

%om\inkjmo`m& \i_ oc` joc`m \ kjm` b\odib no`k %H/M ^c\ii`g&+

Fi \ ]mj\_`m n`in`) h\it `s\hkg`n c\q` ijr ]``i m`kjmo`_ di

rcd^c oc` k`mh`\odib dji nk`^d`n ^\i c\q` \ h\mf`_ `aa`^o ji

^c\ii`g b\odib) di^gp_dib ?H) Hq) \i_ Hdm ^c\ii`gn %?\pfmjrdou

\i_ V`gg`i) .6638 A\cgh\ii `o \g+) /--18 A`hj \i_ V`gg`i)

.66/8 P``]jch `o \g+) /--0&+ La k\mod^pg\m m`g`q\i^` dn oc` h`^c*

\idnh ja @*otk` di\^odq\odji nop_d`_ di H^n>) rc`m` oc` gdif ]`*

or``i "go`m dji j^^pk\i^t \i_ di\^odq\odji c\n ]``i m`njgq`_ di

bm`\o _`o\dg %@p`ggj `o \g+) /-.-&+ Fio`m`nodibgt) @*otk` di\^odq\odji

di H^n> \kk`\mn oj m`lpdm` dji j^^pk\i^t ja oc` P/ ndo` \i_ O](

m`_p^`n ocdn di\^odq\odji) km`nph\]gt _p` oj don g\^f ja ]di_dib \o

P/ %J\opg`a `o \g+) /-.0&+ Fiomdbpdibgt) jpm JA ndhpg\odjin rdoc

QO>>H \gnj ncjr \ m`_p^`_ j^^pk\i^t ja P/ ]t O]( \^^jhk\*

id`_ ]t _m\h\od^ no\]dgdu\odji ja oc` jk`i no\o` oc\o hdbco \gnj ]`

dio`mkm`o`_ \n m`_p^`_ "go`m di\^odq\odji+ Qc`m`ajm`) P/ dji j^^p*

k\i^t \kk`\mn ^mdod^\g ajm ]joc dji*#ps b\odib di H/M ^c\ii`gn

\i_ @*otk` di\^odq\odji) npbb`nodib oc`t h\t diqjgq` ndhdg\m

nomp^opm\g ^c\ib`n di oc` "go`m \i_) kjnnd]gt \gnj) di oc` om\in*

h`h]m\i` _jh\din \n m`kjmo`_ ajm H^n> %@p`ggj `o \g+) /-.-&+

.#3 'D=IIAG %?NEP=NEJI %GNALM NDA +=NEIC 3LJKALNEAM JB

NDA *EGNAL

Qc` h`^c\ij*b\o`_ np]a\hdgt ja H/M ^c\ii`gn %QO>>H)

QOBH*.) \i_ QOBH*/& \m` \^odq\o`_ ]t \ rd_` m\ib` ja nodhpgd

%Ejijm {̀ ) /--4&+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) \^odq\odji ]t MFM/) diom\^`ggpg\m

kE \i_ h`h]m\i` nom`o^c c\q` ]``i ncjri oj \]jgdnc qjgo\b`

\^odq\odji di QOBH*. %@c`hdi `o \g+) /--2&) ocpn `aa`^odq`gt

^\pndib \ b\odib hj_` ncdao+ > ndhdg\m ncdao amjh oc` qjgo\b`*

b\o`_ hj_` oj oc` g`\f hj_` c\n \gnj ]``i m`kjmo`_ oj j^^pm

pkji _`kcjnkcjmtg\odji ja QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn %?j^f`ic\p`m

`o \g+) /--.&+ T` ijr ncjr oc\o oc`n` ^jiq`mndjin m`npgo amjh

\ hj_` ncdao di oc` b\odib kmjk`mod`n ja oc` "go`m+ Lpm m`npgon

\gnj npbb`no oc\o H/M \bjidnon \^o ]t no\]dgdudib oc` \^odq\o`_

no\o` ja oc` "go`m) oc`m`]t ncdaodib oc` `lpdgd]mdph \r\t amjh oc`

qjgo\b`*n`indodq` di\^odq` no\o`+ Qc` nomp^opm\g ]\ndn ja ocdn

hj_` ^jiq`mndji m`h\din pifijri) ]po MFM/ \i_ kE \^o ji

oc` @ o`mhdipn ^jii`^o`_ oj QJ1 \i_ h\t oc`m`ajm` ^jiomjg

oc` "go`m b\o` qd\ hjq`h`io ja QJ1 %?\bmd\ion`q `o \g+) /-..8

Ijgd^\oj `o \g+) /-.18 Md`^cjoo\ `o \g+) /-..&+

3DSMEJGJCE?=G -HKGE?=NEJIM

Qc` nomjib _`k`i_`i^` ja ^c\ii`g \^odqdot ji oc` `g`^omj^c`h*

d^\g H( bm\_d`io dhkgd`n oc\o pig`nn \^odq\o`_ ]t fijri nodhpgd)

#ps*b\o`_ H/M ^c\ii`gn \m` hjnogt di\^odq` \o oc` OJM+ Fo hdbco

oc`m`ajm` ]` \nnph`_ oc`t c\q` g`nn di#p`i^` ji no\]dgdudib oc`

OJM ^jhk\m`_ oj Hdm ^c\ii`gn+ Ejr`q`m) oc` #ps*b\o`_ hj_`

rdgg ]` ja k\mod^pg\m dhkjmo\i^` ajm oc` m`kjg\mdu\odji kc\n` ja

oc` \^odji kjo`iod\g+ Cpmoc`mhjm`) ]`^\pn` oc` b\odib fdi`od^n

\m` m\kd_ %ndhdg\m oj h\it Hq ^c\ii`gn&) oc`t h\t ^jiomd]po` oj

]joc ^\m_d\^ \i_ a\no i`pmji\g \^odji kjo`iod\gn+ Qcdn kmjk`mot

c\n \gm`\_t ]``i dhkgd^\o`_ di npkkjmodib cdbc*am`lp`i^t \^odji

kjo`iod\gn di i`pmjin) np^c \n ^`m`]`gg\m bm\ipg` ^`ggn) oc\o `s*

km`nn Q>PH*0 ^c\ii`gn %?md^fg`t `o \g+) /--.) /--4&+ Ejr`q`m)

oc` ^jiomd]podji ja #ps b\odib oj oc`n` kmj^`nn`n rdgg m`lpdm`

apmoc`m diq`nodb\odji di i\odq` km`k\m\odjin+

>ijoc`m _dnodi^o a`\opm` dn oc`dm odbco ^jpkgdib oj oc` m`q`mn\g

kjo`iod\g ]`^\pn` ocdn km`_d^on _daa`m`io `aa`^on ji ^c\ib`n di

`som\^`ggpg\m H(8 \ m`_p^odji rdgg \^odq\o` #ps*b\o`_ H/M ^c\i*

i`gn ]`^\pn` ja oc` kjndodq` _mdqdib ajm^` %!# < -&) rc`m`\n H(

\^^phpg\odji rdgg ndg`i^` oc`h %!# 9 -&+ Qcdn dn di _dm`^o ^jiom\no

oj Hdm ^c\ii`gn) rcd^c \m` \^odq\o`_ ]t H( \^^phpg\odji %Cdgjn\

`o \g+) /--3&+

*ONOLA 2ONGJJF

Lpm "i_dibn ijr km`n`io n`q`m\g `s^dodib jkkjmopidod`n ]`^\pn`

oc`t `no\]gdnc \i `sk`mdh`io\g kmjoj^jg oj _dm`^ogt h`\npm` dji

j^^pk\i^t rdocdi oc` "go`m \i_ gdif ^c\ib`n di dji j^^pk\i^t

oj _dnodi^o b\odib `q`ion %d+`+) qjgo\b` n`indib) #ps \^odq\odji)

\i_ #ps di\^odq\odji&+ @j*^mtno\ggdu\odji nop_d`n rdoc _daa`m`io

djin %`+b+) H(,Qg( q`mnpn O](,@n(& rdgg cjk`apggt kmjqd_` dhkjm*

o\io dindbcon dioj oc` nomp^opm\g ^c\ib`n pi_`mgtdib oc`n` `q`ion+

Fo \gnj m`h\din pi^g`\m rct oc` H/M ^c\ii`g "go`m kmj_p^`n

ocdn #ps b\odib ]`c\qdjm rc`i do c\n ijo nj a\m ]``i n``i di joc`m

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4/2

Page 13: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

H( ^c\ii`g+ Qc` \inr`m gdf`gt m`nd_`n jpond_` oc` ^jin`mq`_

n`bh`ion ja oc` "go`m \i_ h\t diqjgq` don \nthh`omd^\g i\opm`

\i_,jm oc` pidlp` nomp^opm\g ^c\m\^o`mdnod^n ja oc` H/M ^c\ii`g

kjm`+

);3)4-0)16%/ 342')(74)5

0JGA?OG=L &EJGJCS

Eph\i QTFH*. %D`i?\if \^^`nndji iph]`m7KJZ--//12&) cph\i QO>>H

%KJZ-000.-&) m\o QOBH*. %KJZ.4/-1/&) cph\i QOBH*/ %KJZ-/..3.&) cph\i

Q>PH*. %KJZ--//13&) cph\i Q>PH*/ %KJZ--041-&) cph\i Q>PH*0

%KJZ--./5/201&) cph\i Q>IH*. %KJZ-0/..2&) cph\i Q>IH*/ %BR645611&)

cph\i QOBPH %KJZ.5.51-&) cph\i Hq.+/ %KJZ--1641&) \i_ cph\i Hq/+.

%KJZ--1642& r`m` pn`_ di ocdn nop_t+ Lgdbjip^g`jod_`*]\n`_ ndo`*_dm`^o`_

hpo\b`i`ndn r\n q`md"`_ ]t n`lp`i^dib) \i_ \gg ^jinomp^on r`m` np]^gji`_

dioj oc` k?C) kC>T) jm kPDBJ `skm`nndji q`^ojmn ajm jj^to` `skm`nndji+

hOK>n r`m` ntioc`ndu`_ pndib oc` PM3 jm Q4 hJBPP>DB hJ>@EFKB Qm\i*

n^mdkodji Hdo %>h]dji& \i_ nojm`_ di noj^f njgpodjin \o !5-#@+ /2567;8

jj^to`n r`m` npmbd^\ggt m`hjq`_ amjh \_pgo a`h\g`n \i_ om`\o`_ rdoc otk` FF

^jgg\b`i\n` kmdjm oj h\ip\g _`ajggd^pg\odji+ >]jpo 2- ig ja \ njgpodji ^jio\didib

^c\ii`g*nk`^d"^ hOK> r\n die`^o`_ dioj jj^to`n \i_ di^p]\o`_ \o .4#@ ajm

.x4 _\tn kmdjm oj pn`+

)GA?NLJKDSMEJGJCS

Dd\io k\o^c m`^jm_dibn di dind_`*jpo ^ji"bpm\odji pi_`m qjgo\b`*^g\hk ^ji_d*

odjin r`m` h\_` \o mjjh o`hk`m\opm`+ Mdk`oo`n r`m` h\_` amjh ocd^f*r\gg`_

]jmjndgd^\o` bg\nn) c\_ m`ndno\i^`n ja -+0x-+6 J" %odk _d\h`o`m ja 2x.2 #h&)

\i_ "gg`_ rdoc \ no\i_\m_ kdk`oo` njgpodji %di hJ&7 ./- H@g) .- EBMBP) \i_

0+3 @\@g/ %kE 4+1 \_epno`_ rdoc HLE,E@g&+ Cpmoc`m kdk`oo` njgpodjin ^jio\di`_

`doc`m %di hJ& 0+3 Jb@g/ jm / BAQ> dino`\_ ja 0+3 @\@g/+ @pmm`ion r`m` m`*

^jm_`_ rdoc \i [email protected] \hkgd"`m %EBH> `g`^omjid^n& \i_ n\hkg`_ \o .- fEu

jm cdbc`m da m`lpdm`_ \i_ "go`m`_ rdoc 0 fEu %!0 _?& jm cdbc`m \n \kkmjkmd\o`

ajm n\hkgdib m\o`+ Pjgpodjin r`m` \kkgd`_ qd\ \ hpgod*]\mm`g kdk`oo` ntno`h oj

oc` ^tojkg\nhd^ nd_` ja `s^dn`_ k\o^c`n ajm oc` q\mdjpn dji ^c\ii`gn+ Qc` no\i*

_\m_ diom\^`ggpg\m %]\oc& njgpodji c\_ oc` ajggjrdib ^jhkjndodji %di hJ&7

./- H@g) .- EBMBP) / BDQ>) \i_ . Mtmjkcjnkc\o` %q\mdjpn kEn \_epno`_

rdoc HLE,E@g&+ Fi joc`m njgpodjin H( r\n m`kg\^`_ ]t K\() KJAD() Qg()

KE1() @n() jm O](+ Fi njh` `sk`mdh`ion H() @n() jm O]( r\n k\mod\ggt

np]nodopo`_ ]t KJAD(+ >kkmjkmd\o` kE r\n \_epno`_ rdoc ct_mjsd_` ja

oc` m`g`q\io dji nk`^d`n+ Q`om\k`iotg\hhjidph ^cgjmd_` %QM>*@g&) o`om\c`st*

g\hhjidph ^cgjmd_` %QE`s>*@g&) 5*%omd]potg\hhjidph&j^otg h`oc\i`ocdjnpg*

aji\o` ]mjhd_` %JQP*Q?>L*?m&) \m\^cd_jid^ \^d_ %>>&) \i_ kcjnkc\od_tgdij*

ndojg*1)2*]dnkcjnkc\o` %MFM/& r`m` kpm^c\n`_ amjh Pdbh\*>g_md^c+ >gg

np]no\i^`n r`m` nojm`_ \n noj^fn %.-x.-- hJ& \o !5-#@ \i_ _dgpo`_ di

]\oc njgpodji oj "i\g ^ji^`iom\odjin kmdjm oj h`\npm`h`ion+ P\opm\odib o\dg

^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n r`m` "oo`_ oj \ no\i_\m_ ?jgouh\ii `lp\odji7 a%s& ; %\hkgd*

op_`,%.(`sk%*%s*s.,/&,ngjk`&&&(jaan`o8 rdoc oc` ngjk` ]`dib OQ,uC %O) pidq`mn\g

b\n ^jino\io8 Q) o`hk`m\opm`8 u) `lpdq\g`io b\odib ^c\mb` X`-Y8 C) C\m\_\t

^jino\io&+

0( 5EHOG=NEJIM

JA ndhpg\odjin r`m` k`majmh`_ \n km`qdjpngt _`n^md]`_ %Hjy ka`m `o \g+) /-.1&

\i_ _`o\dg`_ di oc` Ppkkg`h`io\g Bsk`mdh`io\g Mmj^`_pm`n+

5733/)0)16%/ -1*240%6-21

Ppkkg`h`io\g Fiajmh\odji di^gp_`n Ppkkg`h`io\g Bsk`mdh`io\g Mmj^`_pm`n

\i_ nds "bpm`n \i_ ^\i ]` ajpi_ rdoc ocdn \mod^g` jigdi` \o cook7,,_s+_jd+jmb,

.-+.-.3,e+^`gg+/-.3+-/+--/+

%76,24 '2164-&76-215

J+P+) B+K+*>+) E+P+) J+J+) P+@+) D+?+) \i_ J+O+ k`majmh`_ \gg `sk`mdh`ion \i_

\i\gtndn npk`mqdn`_ ]t ?+I+_+D+) P+G+Q+) \i_ Q+?+ Qc` h\ipn^mdko r\n rmdoo`i

]t P+G+Q+ \i_ Q+?+ rdoc ^jiomd]podjin amjh \gg \pocjmn+ J+P+ \i_ B+K+*>+ ^jiomd]*

po`_ `lp\ggt oj ocdn nop_t+

%'.129/)(+0)165

Q+?+ r\n npkkjmo`_ ]t oc` ACD8 P+G+Q+ r\n npkkjmo`_ ]t \ ??PO@ Fi_pnomd\g

M\moi`mncdk >r\m_ rdoc M"u`m K`pn`iodn \i_ ]t oc` T`gg^jh` Qmpno+

O`^`dq`_7 Gpi` .) /-.2

O`qdn`_7 P`ko`h]`m /0) /-.2

>^^`ko`_7 G\ip\mt /6) /-.3

Mp]gdnc`_7 C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3

4)*)4)1')5

?\bmd\ion`q) P+K+) M`tmjii`o) O+) @g\mf) H+>+) Ejijm {̀ ) B+) \i_ Jdijm) A+I+) Gm+

%/-..&+ Jpgodkg` hj_\gdod`n ^jiq`mb` ji \ ^jhhji b\o` oj ^jiomjg H/M ^c\ii`g

api^odji+ BJ?L G+ &#) 0261x03-3+

?\pfmjrdou) Q+) \i_ V`gg`i) D+ %.663&+ Rn`*_`k`i_`io ]gj^f`mn \i_ `sdo m\o` ja

oc` g\no dji amjh oc` hpgod*dji kjm` ja \ H( ^c\ii`g+ P^d`i^` %*$) 320x323+

?j^f`ic\p`m) A+) Wdg]`m]`mb) K+) \i_ Djg_no`di) P+>+ %/--.&+ H@KH/7 m`q`mn*

d]g` ^jiq`mndji ja \ cdkkj^\hk\g kjo\nndph g`\f dioj \ qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io

^c\ii`g+ K\o+ K`pmjn^d+ ') 153x16.+

?jdo`ps) @+) \i_ ?`mi [̀ ^c`) P+ %/-..&+ >]n`i^` ja dji*]di_dib \a"idot di oc` kp*

o\odq`gt di\^odq\o`_ gjr*XH(Y nomp^opm` ja oc` H^n> kjo\nndph ^c\ii`g+ Pomp^*

opm` $,) 4-x46+

?md^fg`t) P+D+) O`qdgg\) S+) @pgg*@\i_t) P+D+) Tdn_`i) T+) \i_ C\mm\io) J+

%/--.&+ >_\kodq` m`bpg\odji ja i`pmji\g `s^do\]dgdot ]t \ qjgo\b`*di_`k`i_`io

kjo\nndph ^ji_p^o\i^`+ K\opm` '#,) 55x6/+

?md^fg`t) P+D+) >gg`m) J+F+) P\i_p) @+) S`\g`) B+I+) >g_`m) C+D+) P\h]d) E+) J\ocd`)

>+) \i_ Tdn_`i) T+ %/--4&+ Q>PH*0 orj*kjm` _jh\di kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn

`i\]g` npno\di`_ cdbc*am`lp`i^t "mdib di ^`m`]`gg\m bm\ipg` i`pmjin+

G+ K`pmjn^d+ %*) 60/6x601-+

?mjc\ri) P+D+) _`g J\{ mhjg) G+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %/-./&+ @mtno\g nomp^opm` ja

oc` cph\i H/M QO>>H) \ gdkd_* \i_ h`^c\ij*n`indodq` H( dji ^c\ii`g+ P^d*

`i^` &&() 103x11.+

?mjc\ri) P+D+) @\hk]`gg) B+?+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %/-.0&+ Ajh\di*nr\kk`_

^c\di ^jii`^odqdot \i_ b\o`_ h`h]m\i` \^^`nn di \ C\]*h`_d\o`_ ^mtno\g ja

oc` cph\i QO>>H H( ^c\ii`g+ Mmj^+ K\og+ >^\_+ P^d+ RP> $$#) /./6x/.01+

@c`hdi) G+) M\o`g) >+G+) Apkm\o) C+) I\pmdou`i) F+) I\u_pinfd) J+) \i_ Ejijm {̀ ) B+

%/--2&+ > kcjnkcjgdkd_ n`injm ^jiomjgn h`^c\ijb\odib ja oc` H( ^c\ii`g

QOBH*.+ BJ?L G+ %') 11x20+

@c`i) E+) @c\o`g\di) C+@+) \i_ I`n\b`) C+ %/-.1&+ >go`m`_ \i_ _ti\hd^ dji

n`g`^odqdot ja H( ^c\ii`gn di ^`gg _`q`gjkh`io \i_ `s^do\]dgdot+ Qm`i_n Mc\mh\*

^jg+ P^d+ &() 13.x136+

@jiom`m\n) G+B+) @c`i) G+) I\p) >+V+) Gjbdid) S+) Ojps) ?+) \i_ Ejghbm`i) J+

%/-.-&+ Sjgo\b` kmj"g` \gjib oc` k`mh`\odji k\ocr\t ja \i jk`i ^c\ii`g+ ?dj*

kctn+ G+ ,,) /530x/536+

@jm_`mj*Jjm\g`n) G+C+) @p`ggj) I+D+) \i_ M`mjuj) B+ %/--3&+ Sjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io

b\odib \o oc` H^n> n`g`^odqdot "go`m+ K\o+ Pomp^o+ Jjg+ ?djg+ $&) 0.6x0//+

@p`ggj) I+D+) Gjbdid) S+) @jmo`n) A+J+) \i_ M`mjuj) B+ %/-.-&+ Pomp^opm\g h`^c*

\idnh ja @*otk` di\^odq\odji di H%(& ^c\ii`gn+ K\opm` '))) /-0x/-5+

A\cgh\ii) >+) Id) J+) D\j) W+) J^D\mmdbg`) A+) P\^fdi) E+) \i_ M\gh`m) I+D+

%/--1&+ O`bpg\odji ja Hdm ^c\ii`gn ]t diom\^`ggpg\m kE \i_ `som\^`ggpg\m H%(&7

h`^c\idnhn ja ^jpkgdib+ G+ D`i+ Mctndjg+ $%&) 11.x121+

A` G`npn*M`m`u) G+G+) @\nomj*@cjib) >+) Pcd`c) O+@+) E`mi\i_`u*@\m]\ggj)

@+V+) A` P\iod\bj*@\nodggj) G+>+) \i_ >mm`jg\) G+ %/-.3&+ D\odib oc` bgpo\h\o`

b\o` ja @I@*/ ^cgjmd_` ^c\ii`g ]t kjm` j^^pk\i^t+ G+ D`i+ Mctndjg+ $'*)

/2x04+

A`hj) P+A+) \i_ V`gg`i) D+ %.66/&+ Fji `aa`^on ji b\odib ja oc` @\%/(&*\^odq\o`_

H( ^c\ii`g ^jmm`g\o` rdoc j^^pk\i^t ja oc` kjm`+ ?djkctn+ G+ )$) 306x315+

Ajib) V+V+) Mdf`) >+@+) J\^f`iud`) >+) J^@g`i\bc\i) @+) >mt\g) M+) Ajib) I+)

Npdbg`t) >+) Dmd`]`i) J+) Djp]di) P+) Jpfcjk\_ct\t) P+) `o \g+ %/-.2&+ H/M

^c\ii`g b\odib h`^c\idnhn m`q`\g`_ ]t nomp^opm`n ja QOBH*/ \i_ \ ^jhkg`s

rdoc Mmju\^+ P^d`i^` &'*) ./23x./26+

4/3 @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 14: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

Ajtg`) A+>+) Jjm\dn @\]m\g) G+) Map`oui`m) O+>+) Hpj) >+) Dpg]dn) G+J+) @jc`i)

P+I+) @c\do) ?+Q+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %.665&+ Qc` nomp^opm` ja oc` kjo\nndph

^c\ii`g7 hjg`^pg\m ]\ndn ja H( ^ji_p^odji \i_ n`g`^odqdot+ P^d`i^` %+#)

36x44+

Apoug`m) O+) @\hk]`gg) B+?+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %/--0&+ D\odib oc` n`g`^odqdot

"go`m di @g@ ^cgjmd_` ^c\ii`gn+ P^d`i^` &##) .-5x../+

Bit`_d) M+) \i_ @udme\{ f) D+ %/-.-&+ Jjg`^pg\m ]\^fbmjpi_ ja g`\f H( ^pmm`ion7

orj*kjm` _jh\di kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn+ Mctndjg+ O`q+ ,#) 226x3-2+

Cdgjn\) G+>+) ?ji`q) >+A+) Pom\p]) P+S+) J`m`_doc) >+I+) Tdgf`mnji) J+H+) >g_md^c)

O+T+) \i_ K`gnji) J+Q+ %/--3&+ Ij^\g kjo\nndph ndbi\gdib ^jpkg`n i`pmji\g \^*

odqdot oj q\nj_dg\odji di oc` ]m\di+ K\o+ K`pmjn^d+ ,) .064x.1-0+

Djg_no`di) P+>+) ?j^f`ic\p`m) A+) LwH`ggt) F+) \i_ Wdg]`m]`mb) K+ %/--.&+ Mjo\n*

ndph g`\f ^c\ii`gn \i_ oc` H@KH a\hdgt ja orj*M*_jh\di np]pidon+ K\o+ O`q+

K`pmjn^d+ %) .42x.51+

Djg_no`di) P+>+) ?\tgdnn) A+>+) Hdh) A+) I`n\b`) C+) Mg\io) I+A+) \i_ O\e\i) P+

%/--2&+ Fio`mi\odji\g Ridji ja Mc\mh\^jgjbt+ IS+ Kjh`i^g\opm` \i_ hjg`^pg\m

m`g\odjincdkn ja orj*M kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn+ Mc\mh\^jg+ O`q+ (*) 2/4x21-+

Ejijm {̀ ) B+ %/--4&+ Qc` i`pmji\g ]\^fbmjpi_ H/M ^c\ii`gn7 aj^pn ji QOBH.+

K\o+ O`q+ K`pmjn^d+ +) /2.x/3.+

Gd\ib) V+) I``) >+) @c`i) G+) @\_`i`) J+) @c\do) ?+Q+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %/--/&+

Qc` jk`i kjm` ^jiajmh\odji ja kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn+ K\opm` '$*) 2/0x2/3+

H`o^cph) H+>+) Gjdi`m) T+G+) P`gg`mn) >+G+) H\^uh\m`f) I+H+) \i_ Djg_no`di)

P+>+ %.662&+ > i`r a\hdgt ja jpor\m_gt m`^odatdib kjo\nndph ^c\ii`g kmjo`din

rdoc orj kjm` _jh\din di o\i_`h+ K\opm` &*)) 36-x362+

Hjy ka`m) A+>+) Pjib) @+) Dmp`i`) Q+) Pc`g_md^f) D+J+) W\^c\md\`) R+) \i_ _`

Dmjjo) ?+I+ %/-.1&+ Fji k`mh`\odji di H( ^c\ii`gn j^^pmn ]t _dm`^o @jpgjh]

fij^f*ji+ P^d`i^` &')) 02/x022+

I`n\b`) C+) \i_ I\u_pinfd) J+ %/---&+ Jjg`^pg\m \i_ api^odji\g kmjk`mod`n ja

orj*kjm`*_jh\di kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn+ >h+ G+ Mctndjg+ O`i\g Mctndjg+ %*,)

C460xC5-.+

I`n\b`) C+) Dpdgg`h\m`) B+) Cdif) J+) Apkm\o) C+) I\u_pinfd) J+) Ojh`t) D+) \i_

?\mc\idi) G+ %.663&+ QTFH*.) \ p]dlpdojpn cph\i r`\fgt dir\m_ m`^odatdib H(

^c\ii`g rdoc \ ijq`g nomp^opm`+ BJ?L G+ $() .--1x.-..+

Ijgd^\oj) J+) Od`b`gc\pko) M+J+) >mmdbjid) @+) @g\mf) H+>+) \i_ Jdijm) A+I+) Gm+

%/-.1&+ Qm\inh`h]m\i` c`gds nom\dbco`idib \i_ ]p^fgdib pi_`mgd`n \^odq\odji

ja h`^c\ijn`indodq` \i_ oc`mhjn`indodq` H%/M& ^c\ii`gn+ K`pmji +') ..65x

././+

Ijpfdi) P+E+) \i_ P\dhd) V+ %.666&+ H%(&*_`k`i_`io ^jhkjndo` b\odib ja oc`

t`\no H%(& ^c\ii`g) Qjf.+ ?djkctn+ G+ **) 0-3-x0-4-+

J\^H`iud`) D+) Cm\ifn) K+M+) \i_ ?md^fg`t) P+D+ %/-.2&+ Qrj*kjm` _jh\di kj*

o\nndph ^c\ii`gn `i\]g` \^odji kjo`iod\g b`i`m\odji di oc` \]n`i^` ja qjgo\b`*

b\o`_ kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn+ M#pb`mn >m^c+ ')*) 656x666+

J\dibm`o) C+) Ejijm {̀ ) B+) I\u_pinfd) J+) \i_ M\o`g) >+G+ %/--/&+ Jjg`^pg\m ]\ndn

ja oc` qjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io b\odib ja QOBH*.) \ h`^c\ij*n`indodq` H%(& ^c\i*

i`g+ ?dj^c`h+ ?djkctn+ O`n+ @jhhpi+ %,%) 006x013+

J\opg`a) H+) Hjh\mjq) >+D+) @jno\iodij) @+>+) \i_ S\gdt\q``odg) C+F+ %/-.0&+ Rn*

dib kmjo`di ]\^f]ji` hpo\b`i`ndn oj _dnn`^o oc` gdif ]`or``i dji j^^pk\i^t

\i_ @*otk` di\^odq\odji di H( ^c\ii`gn+ Mmj^+ K\og+ >^\_+ P^d+ RP> $$#)

.4553x.456.+

Jdgg`m) @+ %/--3&+ @g@ ^cgjmd_` ^c\ii`gn qd`r`_ ocmjpbc \ om\inkjmo`m g`in+

K\opm` ''#) 151x156+

Jdgg`m) >+K+) \i_ Ijib) P+?+ %/-./&+ @mtno\g nomp^opm` ja oc` cph\i orj*kjm`

_jh\di kjo\nndph ^c\ii`g H/M.+ P^d`i^` &&() 10/x103+

Md`^cjoo\) M+I+) O\k`_dpn) J+) Po\ina`g_) M+G+) ?jgg`k\ggd) J+H+) Bcmgd^c) D+) >i*

_m`n*Bibpds) F+) Cmdou`in^c\ao) E+) A`^c`m) K+) P\injh) J+P+) Qp^f`m) P+G+) \i_

?\pfmjrdou) Q+ %/-..&+ Qc` kjm` nomp^opm` \i_ b\odib h`^c\idnh ja H/M ^c\i*

i`gn+ BJ?L G+ &#) 03-4x03.6+

Mpn^c) J+ %/--1&+ Pomp^opm\g dindbcon dioj ^cgjmd_` \i_ kmjoji*h`_d\o`_ b\odib

ja @I@ ^cgjmd_` ^c\ii`gn+ ?dj^c`hdnomt '&) ..02x..11+

O\k`_dpn) J+) P^chd_o) J+O+) Pc\mh\) @+) Po\ina`g_) M+G+) P\injh) J+P+M+)

?\pfmjrdou) Q+) \i_ Qp^f`m) P+G+ %/-./&+ Po\o`*di_`k`i_`io diom\^`ggpg\m \^^`nn

ja lp\o`mi\mt \hhjidph ]gj^f`mn oj oc` kjm` ja QOBH*.+ @c\ii`gn %>pnodi& ))

140x145+

P^cjgg`) >+) Apb\mh\\) P+) Wdhh`m) Q+) I`jic\m_o) J+) Hjjkh\ii) O+) Bib`*

g\i_) ?+) Mjibn) L+) \i_ ?`ii_jma) H+ %/--1&+ O\o`*gdhdodib m`\^odjin _`o`m*

hdidib _daa`m`io \^odq\odji fdi`od^n ja Hq.+/ \i_ Hq/+. ^c\ii`gn+ G+ J`h]m+

?djg+ $,+) .-0x../+

P``]jch) D+) P\ibpdi`ood) J+@+) \i_ Mpn^c) J+ %/--0&+ Qdbco ^jpkgdib ja

mp]d_dph ^ji_p^o\i^` \i_ di\^odq\odji di cph\i H@KN. kjo\nndph ^c\ii`gn+

G+ Mctndjg+ ((%) 036x045+

Pdbb) A+) \i_ ?`u\idgg\) C+ %.664&+ Qjo\g ^c\mb` hjq`h`io k`m ^c\ii`g+ Qc`

m`g\odji ]`or``i b\odib ^c\mb` _dnkg\^`h`io \i_ oc` qjgo\b` n`indodqdot ja

\^odq\odji+ G+ D`i+ Mctndjg+ $#,) /4x06+

Qcjhnji) >+P+) \i_ Ojoc]`mb) ?+P+ %/-.-&+ Sjgo\b`*_`k`i_`io di\^odq\odji

b\odib \o oc` n`g`^odqdot "go`m ja oc` JocH H( ^c\ii`g+ G+ D`i+ Mctndjg+ $&))

236x246+

V`gg`i) D+ %.665&+ Qc` hjqdib k\mon ja qjgo\b`*b\o`_ dji ^c\ii`gn+ N+ O`q+

?djkctn+ &$) /06x/62+

Wcjp) V+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %/--0&+ Qc` j^^pk\i^t ja djin di oc` H( n`g`^*

odqdot "go`m7 ^c\mb` ]\g\i^` \i_ ^jpkgdib ja dji ]di_dib oj \ kmjo`di ^jiajmh\*

odji\g ^c\ib` pi_`mgd` cdbc ^ji_p^odji m\o`n+ G+ Jjg+ ?djg+ &&&) 632x642+

Wcjp) J+) \i_ J\^Hdiiji) O+ %/--1&+ > hpo\io H^n> H%(& ^c\ii`g rdoc \go`m`_

^ji_p^odji kmjk`mod`n \i_ n`g`^odqdot "go`m dji _dnomd]podji+ G+ Jjg+ ?djg+ &&+)

506x513+

Wdg]`m]`mb) K+) Fg\i) K+) \i_ Djg_no`di) P+>+ %/--.&+ H@KH|7 jk`idib \i_ ^gjn*

dib oc` /*M*_jh\di kjo\nndph g`\f ^c\ii`g `io\dgn vv@*otk`ww b\odib ja oc`

jpo`m kjm`+ K`pmji &%) 302x315+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn 4/4

Page 15: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

5OKKGAHAIN=G *ECOLAM

0DBNK@ 9&$ <IFM=B@ 1=MDHB DH ;8/4#&" ;8/94" ;,94#&" =H? ;,94#' -C=HH@FL =H? 4'7 -C=HH@F 1=MDHB 4DH@MD>L" 8@F=M@? MI 0DBNK@ &

%>xA& @pmm`io m`nkjin`n oj \ a\hdgt ja 0-- hn qjgo\b` no`kn amjh !.-- oj (.-- hS amjh \i_ oj \ cjg_dib kjo`iod\g ja !5- hS m`^jm_`_ amjh dind_`*jpo k\o^c`n

`s^dn`_ amjh /2567;8 jj^to`n di nthh`omd^\g H( %./- hJ XH(Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+& `skm`nndib QOBH*.) %?& QOBPH) %@& Q>PH*. \i_ %A& Q>PH*/ ^c\ii`gn+ F*S kgjon

di_d^\o` oc` ^pmm`ion \o oc` `i_ ja oc` _`kjg\mdudib no`kn %bm\t ^dm^g`n& \i_ dir\m_ ^pmm`io %o\dg& \hkgdop_`n pkji m`kjg\mdu\odji oj !5- hS %]gp` ^dm^g`n&8 oc` din`on

ncjr oc` odh` ^jpmn` ja qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \i_ _`\^odq\odji rdoc cdbc`m odh` m`njgpodji \n di_d^\o`_ ]t oc` n^\g` ]\mn8 odh` ^jino\ion %!& m`q`\g`_ ]t `skji`iod\g

"o api^odjin+

%B& Pphh\mt ja odh` ^jino\ion ajm qjgo\b` \^odq\odji j]o\di`_ ajm _daa`m`io ^c\ii`gn \i_ qjgo\b`n+ A\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn G*

Page 16: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

0DBNK@ 9'$ /QMK=>@FFNF=K .DO=F@HM -=MDIHL 2=O@ 6I 5=KE@? /AA@>M IH <IFM=B@ 1=MDHB" 8@F=M@? MI 0DBNK@ &

%>& F*S kgjon ja QOBH*. ^pmm`ion di nthh`omd^\g H( %./- hJ XH(Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+& j]o\di`_ amjh qjgo\b` a\hdgd`n di oc` km`n`i^` ja `som\^`ggpg\m 0+3 hJ @\/( jm

0+3 hJ Jb/( \i_ di oc` \]n`i^` ja _dq\g`io ^\odjin rdoc / hJ BAQ> \__`_+

%?& Mmjoj^jg \n di %>& ]po rdoc O]( \o oc` diom\^`ggpg\m nd_` %./- hJ XO](Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+&+

%@& Qc` F*S kgjon ncjr oc` ijmh\gdu`_ dir\m_ ^pmm`io %o\dg& \hkgdop_`n np]n`lp`io oj 0-- hn km`*kpgn` qjgo\b` no`kn oj oc` di_d^\o`_ qjgo\b` rdoc O]( \n oc`

diom\^`ggpg\m ^\odji %./- hJ XO](Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+& di oc` km`n`i^` ja `som\^`ggpg\m 0+3 hJ @\/( jm 0+3 hJ Jb/( \i_ di oc` \]n`i^` ja _dq\g`io ^\odjin rdoc

/ hJ BAQ> \__`_ \n di_d^\o`_+ A\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

G+ @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 17: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

0DBNK@ 9($ ;C@ 3HMK=>@FFNF=K 7IK@ /HMK=H>@ 3L 6IM MC@ <IFM=B@ 1=M@ DH 4'7 -C=HH@FL" 8@F=M@? MI 0DBNK@ '

%>& @pmm`io m`nkjin`n ja Hq.+/ ^c\ii`gn oj di_d^\o`_ qjgo\b`n rdoc \i_ rdocjpo . #J QE`s> %o`om\c`stg\hhjidph& ncjrdib oc` otkd^\g odh` ^jpmn` ja no\o`*

_`k`i_`io jk`i ^c\ii`g ]gj^f \i_ oc` ngjrdib ja _`\^odq\odji m`npgodib di \ v^mjnn jq`mw ja oc` o\dg ^pmm`ion+

%?& P\h` kmjoj^jg \n di %>& ]po ajm QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn di_d^\odib oc\o QOBH*. dn dicd]do`_ ]t QE`s> ]`ajm` qjgo\b` \^odq\odji \i_ oc\o ^pmm`io _`\^odq\odji dn ijo

ngjr`_ ]t QE`s>+ Qc` din`o ncjrn oc` odh` ^jpmn` ja QE`s> dicd]dodji \kkgd`_ ji qjgo\b`*\^odq\o`_ %\o (5- hS& QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn qd\ \ m\kd_ \kkgd^\odji ntno`h

di_d^\odib oc\o ]gj^f`m ]di_dib dn hp^c ngjr`m oc\i \^odq\odji %ijo` oc` _daa`m`io n^\g` ]\mn&+

%@& Qdh` ^jpmn` ja JQP*Q?>L %/- #J& hj_d"^\odji ja QOBH*. D.53@ ^c\ii`gn _`o`mhdi`_ \o (1- hS \i_ \o !5- hS %oj \nn`nn oc` am\^odji ja hj_d"`_ ^c\ii`gn

q`mt ]md`#t %.- hn& no`kk`_ oj (1- hS&+ Bsk`mdh`ion ajm QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn r`m` k`majmh`_ di njgpodjin ^jio\didib O]( ji oc` diom\^`ggpg\m nd_` ja oc` h`h]m\i`

%./- hJ XO](Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+& oj di^m`\n` ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n+

%A& @\mojji _`kd^odib oc\o oc` diom\^`ggpg\m kjm` `iom\i^` dn jk`i \i_ \^^`nnd]g` oj JQP*Q?>L hj_d"^\odji \i_ QE`s> %N>(& ]di_dib di ]joc ^gjn`_ \i_ jk`i

no\o`n ja QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn+ A\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn G,

Page 18: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

0DBNK@ 9)$ 3IH ,>MDO=MDIH 7KISF@L AIK <IFM=B@ ,>MDO=MDIH DH <=KDINL 4'7 -C=HH@FL" 8@F=M@? MI 0DBNK@ (

%>xB& A`kd^o`_ qjgo\b` a\hdgt `qjf`_ ^pmm`ion rdoc ./- hJ XH(Y`so+ \i_ q\mdjpn diom\^`ggpg\m djin %./- hJ XK\(Y) XQg(Y) X@n(Y) XKE1(Y \i_ XO](Ydio+& j]o\di`_ di n\h`

k\o^c`n ajm7 %>& QOBH*.) %?& QOBH*/) %@& Q>IH*/) %A& Q>PH*0) %B& QOBPH+

G- @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 19: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

10

2

0DBNK@ 9*$ ;C@ <&%' IA <IFM=B@ ,>MDO=MDIH 9CDAML PDMC MC@ /K@O$" 8@F=M@? MI 0DBNK@ )

%>& Kjmh\gdu`_ o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n ajm QO>>H h`\npm`_ rdoc ./- hJ XO](Ydio+ \i_ _daa`m`io `som\^`ggpg\m H( ^ji^`iom\odjin+

%?& Kjmh\gdu`_ o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n ajm QOBH*/ ^c\ii`gn h`\npm`_ rdoc ./- hJ XH(Y`so+ \i_ _daa`m`io diom\^`ggpg\m O]( ^ji^`iom\odjin+

%@& Kjmh\gdu`_ o\dg ^pmm`io \hkgdop_`n ajm Q>PH*0 ^c\ii`gn h`\npm`_ di nthh`omd^\g H( %./- hJ XH(Ydio+,./- hJ XH(Y`so+8 ]g\^f ^dm^g`n& \i_ rdoc gjr `som\^`ggpg\m

H( %./- hJ XH(Ydio+,1 hJ XH(Y`so+8 ]gp` ^dm^g`n&+ A\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

@`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn G.

Page 20: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

2

0 1

0DBNK@ 9+$ ,K=>CD?IHD> ,>D? ,>MDO=MDIH DH ;8,,4" ;8/4#&" =H? ;8/4#' -C=HH@FL" 8@F=M@? MI 0DBNK@ *

%>& F*S kgjon j]o\di`_ ajm QOBH*. ^c\ii`gn di oc` \]n`i^` \i_ oc` km`n`i^` ja _daa`m`io >> ^ji^`iom\odjin+

%?& Ajn`*m`nkjin` ^pmq`n ajm >> \^odq\odji ja _daa`m`io H/M ^c\ii`gn+ B@2- q\gp`n ja no\i_\m_ Edgg "on \m` di_d^\o`_+

%@& QOBH*. ^pmm`io \o !5- hS pkji \kkgd^\odji ja kEdio+ 2 \i_ di^m`\ndib >> ^ji^`iom\odjin \n di_d^\o`_+ A\o\ \m` m`km`n`io`_ \n h`\i ! PBJ+

G/ @`gg $)') 604x616) C`]mp\mt /2) /-.3 !/-.3 Qc` >pocjmn

Page 21: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

&166" .96?71 !#"

-?;;61718>/6 (829<7/>598

% +98#0/89850/6 .96>/31#-18=583 *104/85=7

&98><96= '/>583 58 )$, )! &4/8816=

,1=2@> /254B4! '5>19 -481?619"$=34>?196! )19 /@9! ,1=61994 ,@>69>C76! /E974&;=346=;! (6;A1991 %@226! %4=? +# 34 (=;;?! /?4<549 *# 0@274=! ,1=7@>.1<436@>! 193 05;81> %1@7=;B6?C

Page 22: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

Supplemental Experimental Procedures

Molecular Dynamics Simulations

MD simulations were performed using a modified version of GROMACS 4.6 (Hess et al.,

2008). We used the AMBER99sb force field (Hornak et al., 2006) and SPC/E water model for

the equilibrium and production simulations. Parameters for ions and lipids are derived from

(Joung and Cheatham, 2008; Berger et al., 1997). Short-range electrostatic interactions were

calculated with a cutoff of 1.0 nm, whereas long-range electrostatic interactions were treated

by the particle mesh Ewald method (Darden et al., 1993; Essmann et al., 1995). The cutoff

for van der Waals interactions was set to 1 nm. The simulations were performed at 300 K

with a velocity rescaling thermostat (Bussi et al., 2007). The pressure was kept at 1 bar by

means of a semi-isotropic Berendsen barostat (Berendsen et al., 1984). All bonds were

constrained with the LINCS algorithm (Hess et al., 1997). Using virtual sites for hydrogen

atoms allowed simulations to be performed with a 4 fs integration time step (Feenstra et al.,

1999). Crystallographic structures of TRAAK including closed and open membrane opening

conformations (PDB ID code: 4I9W (Brohawn et al., 2013)) were adopted to generate the

initial configuration in the MD simulations. Missing atoms and loops in the crystal structure

were modeled using the program loopy (Sato et al., 2008). The dimeric protein without the

antibody antigen-binding fragments was embedded into an aqueous POPC lipid bilayer with

0.6 M KCl using the GROMACS tool g_membed (Wolf et al., 2010). The system was

equilibrated for 20 ns with position restraints on all heavy atoms using a force constant of

1000 kJ mol-1 nm-2 to the reference structure, followed by an additional 10 ns simulation

without position restraints.

For the computational electrophysiology study (Kutzner et al., 2011), the equilibrated system

was duplicated along the z direction and transmembrane potential gradients were generated

by introducing a charge difference of 2 K+ ions between the two compartments separated by

the two lipid bilayers. During the MD simulations, the number of the ions was kept constant

by an additional algorithm (Kutzner et al., 2011). The resulting membrane potential can be

calculated by double-integration of the charge distribution using the Poisson equation as

implemented in the GROMACS tool g_potential (Tieleman and Berendsen, 1996). In the

production simulations, two ionic configurations were employed in the starting structures:

KWKKK and KKKKK (S0, S1, S2, S3, S4), respectively. During the simulations a permeation

event was counted when an ion moved from the cavity to the filter, and another ion left the

S0 position.

Page 23: % 1JI?=IJIE?=G 8JGN=CA5AIMEIC 0A?D=IEMH ’JINLJGM … · knqj^rxz 5]\qxz[bjzl][ glqn_n% 9q[jw cnvj\rjw&5zmn[\jwr% =jw g]w% ’’’% g\nyqnw ?’ h]ltnz% bjzt][ fjynmr][% ... @+e

References

Hess, B., Kutzner, C., van der Spoel, D., and Lindahl, E. (2008). GROMACS 4: algorithms forhighly efficient, load-balanced, and scalable molecular simulation. J Chem Theory Comput 4,435–447.Hornak, V., Abel, R., Okur, A., Strockbine, B., Roitberg, A., and Simmerling, C. (2006).Comparison of multiple Amber force fields and development of improved protein backboneparameters. Proteins 65, 712-725.Joung, I.S., and Cheatham, T.E., 3rd. (2008). Determination of alkali and halide monovalention parameters for use in explicitly solvated biomolecular simulations. J Phys Chem B 112,9020–9041.Berger, O., Edholm, O., and Jähnig, F. (1997). Molecular dynamics simulations of a fluidbilayer of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine at full hydration, constant pressure, and constanttemperature. Biophys J 72, 2002–2013.Darden, T., York, D., and Pedersen, L. (1993). Particle mesh Eward: An N log(N) method forEwald sums in large systems. J Chem Phys 98, 10089.Essmann, U., Perera, L., Berkowitz, M. L., Darden, T., Lee, H., and Pedersen, L. G. (1995).A smooth particle mesh Ewald method. J Chem Phys 103, 8577-8593.Bussi, G., Donadio, D., and Parrinello, M. (2007) Canonical sampling through velocityrescaling. J Chem Phys 126, 014101.Berendsen, H. J. C., Postma, J. P. M., van Gunsteren, W. F., Dinola, A., and Haak, J. R.(1984). Molecular dynamics with coupling to an external bath. J Chem Phys 81, 3684-3690.Hess, B., Bekker, H., Berendsen, H. J. C., and Fraaije, J. G. E. M. (1997). LINCS: A linearconstraint solver for molecular simulations. J Comput Chem 18, 1463-1472.Feenstra, K. A., Hess, B., and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1999). Improving efficiency of large time-scale molecular dynamics simulations of hydrogen-rich systems. J Comput Chem 20, 786-788.Brohawn, S. G., Campbell, E. B., and MacKinnon, R. (2013). Domain-swapped chainconnectivity and gated membrane access in a Fab-mediated crystal of the human TRAAK K+channel. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 110(6), 2129-2134.Sato, C. S., Fasnacht, M., Zhu, J., Forrest, L., and Honig, B. (2008). Loop modeling:Sampling, filtering, and scoring. Proteins 70(3), 834-843.Wolf, M.G., Hoefling, M., Aponte-Santamaría, C., Grubmüller, H., and Groenhof, G. (2010).g_membed: Efficient insertion of a membrane protein into an equilibrated lipid bilayer withminimal perturbation. J Comput Chem 31, 2169–2174.Kutzner, C., Grubmüller, H., de Groot, B.L., and Zachariae, U. (2011). Computationalelectrophysiology: the molecular dynamics of ion channel permeation and selectivity inatomistic detail. Biophys J 101, 809–817.Tieleman, D., and Berendsen, H. J. C. (1996). Molecular dynamics simulations of a fullyhydrated dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer with different macroscopic boundaryconditions and parameters. J Chem Phys 105, 4871–4880.