2015 state of latino housing in nc — 1...2015 state of latino housing in nc — 1 principal...

37

Upload: others

Post on 21-Feb-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman
Page 2: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman
Page 3: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1

Principal InvestigatorsRoberto G. QuerciaJames H. Johnson Jr.

Contributing AuthorsAllison FreemanAllan ParnellKevin A. ParkRebecca Tippett

Project Sta!Mark McDaniel, Project DirectorRobert Donnelly, Program ManagerDavid Ball, Project AssistantPamela Santos, Focus Group Facilitator

Acknowledgements

This study was supported by the Latino Community Development Center in cooper-ation with Latino Community Credit Union (LCCU) and North Carolina State Employ-ees’ Credit Union (SECU), with additional funding from the Z. Smith Reynolds Foun-dation and Square 1 Bank, a division of Pacific Western Bank. We are indebted to the managers and sta! of LCCU branches in Charlotte, Durham and Greensboro who helped recruit and support the qualitative component of our research. Additionally, this report would not have been possible without support from the Center for New Carolinians, El Pueblo Inc., El Centro His-pano, Global Scholars Academy and Neigh-borhood Assistance Corporation of Amer-ica. Finally, we’d like to acknowledge the Latino Housing Advisory Committee, con-vened early in the research process to pro-vide input and guidance to this study.

We, of course, assume sole responsibility for the analyses, findings and conclusions presented in this report.

Page 4: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

Page 5: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 3

Table of Contents

Executive Summary 6Study Rationale and Purpose 6

1.0 Demographic Trends 11What are the trends in Latino population growth in North Carolina? 11From where do North Carolina’s Latino populations originate? 11Where are North Carolina’s Latinos settling? 11Do North Carolina’s Latinos fit the typical demographic profile of immigrant populations? 12What is the level of American citizenship among Latinos in North Carolina? 13How large is the unauthorized Latino population in North Carolina? 13Will North Carolina’s Latino population continue to grow? 15What are the projected changes in age groups of North Carolina’s Latino population? 16What is the likely impact of Latino births in North Carolina? 17How do Latinos fit into North Carolina’s socio-economic profile? 18

2.0 Housing Trends 18What kind of housing do Latinos occupy? 19Are Latinos in North Carolina buying or renting homes? 22Has the homeownership rate of Latinos changed significantly?     22What challenges have Latinos faced as renters in the North Carolina housing market? 23What has been the experience of Latinos as homeowners in North Carolina? 24Do North Carolina’s Latinos aspire to become homeowners? 25What are the challenges and obstacles to Latino homeownership? 25How large is the Latino home loan market? 26What were the e!ects of the recession on mortgage lending to Latinos? 26How large was the decline in home lending for Latinos in North Carolina?     27What are the major Latino mortgage markets in North Carolina? 27What accounts for the decline in home purchase lending among Latinos following the housing crisis?                                        27How successful are loan applications by Latinos for manufactured homes? 29How active are specific lenders in making loans to Latinos or in communities where there are higher concentrations of Latinos in North Carolina? 31

3.0 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 31What are the macro-level takeaways from this study? 31How do Latinos in North Carolina define their ideal living conditions? 32What are the programmatic implications that can be derived from this study? 33

Page 6: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

4 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

Executive SummaryStudy Rationale and Purpose

Latinos  are  a  rapidly  growing  share  of  North  Caro-­‐‑lina’s  population,  accounting  for  25%  of  net  growth  

9%  of  the  state’s  population  in  2014.    With  an  aging  

-­‐‑

to   ensure   that   Latinos   are   fully   integrated   into  

 -­‐‑

rent   and   future   housing   needs   of   North   Caro-­‐‑lina’s   Latino   population.1     We   analyze   existing  

describe   barriers   and   challenges   that   inhibit   ex-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Data and Methods

that   drew   upon   publically-­‐‑available   quantitative  

-­‐‑

residents.    Our  quantitative  data  on  Latino  popu-­‐‑

the  U.S.  Census  Bureau’s  2000  and  2010  decennial  -­‐‑

Health  Statistics.2   -­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

pirical  indicators  of  the  Latino  population’s  experi-­‐‑

Our   qualitative   data   on   the   housing   experiences  and  needs  of  North  Carolina’s  Latino  population  were   collected   via   six   focus   groups   with   Latino  

counties  have  high  concentrations  of  Latinos  and  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

here   that   in  U.S.  Census   reports   and   tabulations,  Hispanic   or   Latino   is  

-­‐‑lina  Hispanics  fall  under  one  of  two  racial  categories:  other  race  or  White.

-­‐‑

Page 7: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 5

population   growth   between   2010   and   2020.   4    

Key Findings

Demographics

Between   2000   and   2010,   North   Carolina’s  -­‐‑

rate   of   111.1%.   The   Latino   population   is   ex-­‐‑pected   to   continue   to   grow   in   all   100   North  

 

-­‐‑

-­‐‑tions   such   as   California,   Texas,   and   Illinois.

     Latinos   are   highly   concentrated   in   the   state’s  

-­‐‑

   Most   of   the   Latinos   in   North   Carolina   are  

4   The   Latino   focus   group   participants   were   recruited   through   partner  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

 

or  older,  close  to  half  of  the  Latinos  in  this  age  range  have   less   than  a  high  school  education.

-­‐‑stantially   lower   than   it   was   for   non-­‐‑Latino  

 Housing Trends

renters   in   the   North   Carolina   housing  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

ship  rate  for  North  Carolina’s  total  population  

 

-­‐‑-­‐‑

Page 8: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

6 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

In   part   due   to   a   disproportionate   decline   in  

an   increase   in   the   share   of   Latino   loan   ap-­‐‑plication   denials,   lending   to   Latinos   has  

Traditionally,   Latino   borrowers   sought   con-­‐‑ventional   loans,   but   the   proportion   of   loans  that   are   insured,   guaranteed,   or   otherwise  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

 

       -­‐‑

-­‐‑

Obstacles in Renter and Homeowner Markets

About   50%   of   Latino   renters   are  

-­‐‑ilies  needing  larger  units  and  security  deposits.    

Even  when  Latinos  possess  a  valid  visa  to  live  or  stay  in  the  U.S.,  the  search  for  rental  housing  

do  not  accept  alternative  proof  of  legal  status.  

 

-­‐‑

build   and   repair   credit,   and   about   ways  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

Page 9: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 7

-­‐‑

Many   Latinos   raised   explicit   concerns   about  

-­‐‑

Latinos   are   fully   aware   that   housing   units  in   desirable   areas   close   to   good   schools   and  

-­‐‑cially.    Nevertheless,   they   expressed   a   strong  

-­‐‑bors,   and   other   nuisances,   and   close   to   their  

-­‐‑

Latinos   also   expressed   a   desire   for   large   lots  

-­‐‑

Recommendations

Housing   Tax   Credit   and   fully   funding   the  National  Housing  Trust  Fund  would  substan-­‐‑

and   directly   address   the   inventory   shortage  

funding  for  the  Housing  Voucher  Choice  pro-­‐‑

available   to   pay   for   decent   rental   housing.

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

uncertainty  and   loosen   their   lending   require-­‐‑

Latinos  will   continue   to  be   reluctant   to  apply  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑tinos,   housing   advocates   and   other   partners  

single   organization   can   create   the   large-­‐‑scale  change  needed  to  address  the  inventory  short-­‐‑ages,   policy   barriers,   and   legal   constraints  

approach   also   suggests   that   advocates,   poli-­‐‑

create  a  clear  policy  agenda  and  plan  for  action.

policies  such  as  inclusionary  zoning  and  devel-­‐‑oper  incentives  can  contribute  to  the  inventory  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Page 10: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

8 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

-­‐‑

   For  renters,  housing  advocates  should  partner  

partnerships  with  Legal  Aid,  the  North  Caro-­‐‑

-­‐‑tion   for   identifying   legal   representation   for  Latino   renters   involved   in   fair   housing   and  other   legal   disputes   with   property   owners.    

based   organizations   across   North   Carolina  that   serve   Latinos   should   also   have   access  

phone   hot-­‐‑line   and   other   resources   that   ad-­‐‑

raised   by   focus   group   participants   could   be  -­‐‑

budsperson   position.     Such   a   person   could  refer  Latino  renters  and  owners   to   the  appro-­‐‑priate  agencies  for  assistance  with  fair  housing  

-­‐‑

Whether  real  or  perceived,  expressed  concerns  about  real  estate  agents  suggests  that  advocates  

-­‐‑

to  address  the  unique  challenges  that  aspiring  

the  training  should  be  available  in  both  English  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

edge  the  general  challenges  faced  by  Latinos  in  

of  these  challenges,  Latinos  should  be  strongly  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

Organization of the Study  

To  set  the  context  for  this  research  on  current  and  future   housing   needs   of  North  Carolina’s   Latino  population,  we  begin  with  a  detailed  analysis  of  

-­‐‑lation.  We  then  shift  to  the  core  of  the  study:  the  

-­‐‑tention  is  devoted  to  location,  housing  types  and  

quality   of   residential   life   for   both   renters   and  

Page 11: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 9

1.0 Demographic Trends

As essential background and context for our analysis of Latino housing issues, we begin by providing an overview of Latino population growth and settlement trends in North Carolina. We also present a brief profile of the demographic characteristics of the Latino population. We conclude this section with projections of Latino popu-lation growth between 2010 and 2020.

What are the trends in Latino population growth in North Carolina?

After   growing   rapidly   during   the   1990s,   North  -­‐‑

bled   between   2000   and   2010,   increasing   in  

of   North   Carolina’s   total   population   growth.      

were   single   people   living   alone,   and   12%   were  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

5

From where do North Carolina’s Latino populations originate?

population  in  North  Carolina  was  largely  concen-­‐‑

-­‐‑grounds  began  in  the  1990s  when  the  state’s  Latino  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑tions.    Latinos  in  North  Carolina  are  diverse  even  

Where are North Carolina’s Latinos settling?

Figure   1   shows   the   geographic   distribution   of  

-­‐‑lenburg   County   had   the   largest   Latino   popula-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑tion  by  county  in  2000  and  2010.  

Page 12: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

10 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

and   Onslow—had   noteworthy   Latino   concen-­‐‑trations.       Other   concentrations   include   sites   of  

these  clusters,   it  should  be  noted  that  Latinos  ac-­‐‑counted   for   over   half   of   the   population   growth  between  2000  and  2010   in  Tier  1  counties,   the  40  

Do North Carolina’s Latinos fit the typical demographic profile of immigrant

populations?

-­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

world  are  young  adults,  and  this  has  been  the  case  

-­‐‑tinos  and  the  total  population,  as  well  as  between  

non-­‐‑Latino  whites,  in  North  Carolina.    Latinos  are  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

North  Carolina  population  and  10.9%  of  the  non-­‐‑

15%  of  all  children  under  10  years  old  in  the  state.    

Figure 1: Distribution of Latino Households in North Carolina, 2010

Page 13: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 11

-­‐‑

Latino   sex   ratio   had   shifted,   dropping   to   115  

-­‐‑

typical  sex  distribution  of  births.  The  sex  ratio  at  

What is the level of American citizenship among Latinos in North Carolina?

residents   of  North  Carolina   to   be   citizens   of   the  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Figure   2   shows   the   age-­‐‑sex   structure   of   Latinos  and   non-­‐‑Latinos   by   citizenship   status.   The   top  

Latino   citizens.   The   youth   of   the   Latino   citizen  -­‐‑

tion   in  North  Carolina   is  relatively  new  and  that  

ages  of  15  and  54,   regardless  of  Latino  origin,  as  

How large is the unauthorized Latino pop-ulation in North Carolina?

-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Mexico   is   the   largest  source  country   for  undocu-­‐‑

-­‐‑

9      Another  4%  of  North  Carolina’s  un-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Page 14: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

12 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

Figure 2: Age-Sex Structure of Latinos and Non-Latinos by Citizenship, 2013

Source: Tabulations of 2013 American Community Survey Public Use Microdata, via iPUMS-USA.

Page 15: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 13

-­‐‑

Will North Carolina’s Latino population continue to grow?

By   2020,   North   Carolina’s   Latino   population   is  

-­‐‑

of   North   Carolina’s   100   counties   (see   Appendix  

-­‐‑lation   growth   is   greater   than   the   growth   of   all  

-­‐‑

Continuing  the  observed  trend  of  the  2000s,  four  

absolute   increase   in   Latino   population   between  

half  of  the  state’s  total  population  growth  between  

-­‐‑

in   North   Carolina’s   Latino   population—and  

Table 1: Projected Total and Latino Population Change, North Carolina and Selected Counties, 2010-2020

Total Latino Latino as % of Total

Total 2020 % Change Total 2020 Change % Change

North Carolina 12%Durham County 20.50%Guilford County 11%

Mecklenburg County

24.10%

Wake County 22.50% 151,910 14%

Page 16: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

14 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

-­‐‑

Latino   growth   in   North   Carolina   between   2010  

-­‐‑lina’s   Latino   population   between   2010   and   2020.

Table 2: Projected Total and Latino Population Change, North Carolina and Selected MSAs. 2010-2020

What are the projected changes in age groups of North Carolina’s Latino

population?

growth  in  the  state’s  youth  population  between  2010  

in  the  15-­‐‑24  and  25-­‐‑44  age  cohorts  will  account  for  

groups   for   Latinos   and   all   others   based   on   the  -­‐‑

centrated   in   the   younger   age   groups,   the   age  

Total Latino Latino as % of TotalTotal 2020 % Change Total 2020 % Change

North Carolina 12%Charlotte (NC Only) 2,211,459 14%Durham-Chapel Hill 15%Greensboro-High Point 11%Raleigh 21% 14%

Page 17: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 15

What is the likely impact of Latino births in North Carolina?

-­‐‑

higher  than  the  total  fertility  rates  of  other  groups.    

10  

child  population  –  children  under  the  age  of  10  –  grew  at  a  higher  rate  than  the  Latino  population  as  10  Data  source:  NC  State  Center  for  Health  Statistics

a  whole  between  2000  and  2010.  Over  the  decade,  

of   all   North   Carolina   children   under   age   10.   By  

The   proportion   of   the   child   population   that   is  

Latino   in   the   U.S.   Census   Bureau’s   2014   popu-­‐‑11

Carolina   children   under   10   will   be   Latino.12  

10,000   Latino   students   enrolled   in  North   Carolina   public   schools.   This  

Page 18: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

16 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

How do Latinos fit into North Carolina’s socio-economic profile?

only  15.1%  of  all  North  Carolinians  who  are  25  or  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

14  In  a  2014  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

school  students.

people  living  together.

-­‐‑

Table 3: Median Household and Family Incomes, North Carolina, 2009-2013 ACS

15

-­‐‑

spending  was   responsible   for   creating   92,000  

2.0 Housing Trends

In   this   section,   we   shift   our   focus   to   housing  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

Total White Latino BlackHouseholdFamily

Page 19: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 17

What kind of housing do Latinos occupy?

Table   4   shows   the   type   of   housing   for   the   total  and   Latino   populations   of  North   Carolina.     The  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

The   type   of   housing   Latinos   live   in   varies   sub-­‐‑stantially   across   the   state.     In   Burlington,   Char-­‐‑

-­‐‑

and  40%  of  Latino  households   in   the  Burlington,  -­‐‑

Table 4: Housing Types, All and Latino Households, North Carolina

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

areas  discussed  above,  the  data  do  reveal  regional  

lowest  Latino  occupancy  rate   for   single-­‐‑detached  

Total LatinoSingle family-detached 45.2%Single family-attachedDuplex 2.2%Apartment 3 - 19 unitsApartment 20+ units 4.2%Mobile home 24.9%

Page 20: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

18 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

Table 5: Housing Types for Latino Households, Metropolitan Areas in North Carolina, 2009-13

Source: ACS

Table 6: Housing Types for Latino Households, Durham, Guilford, Mecklenburg and Wake Counties, 2009-13

Source: ACS

Metropolitan Area Single-detached

Single-attached

Duplex 3-19 units 20+ units Mobile Home

Asheville 10.2% 2.5% 45.9%Burlington 0.9%Charlotte-Concord-Gastonia (NC only)

50.2%

Durham-Chapel Hill

5.4% 15%

FayettevilleGoldsboro 2.9% 4.4%Greensboro-High Point

2.0%

Greenville 15.1%Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton

4.5% 21.4% 21.9%

Jacksonville 50.2% 1.4% 10.9%New Bern 0.1% 4.0% 1.9%Raleigh 44.0%Rocky Mount 0.2% 59.0%Wilmington 2.4% 15.9%Winston-Salem 1.5% 1.9% 25.9% 4.2%

County Single-detached

Single-attached

Duplex 3-19 units 20+ units Mobile Home

Durham 40.4%Guilford 4.4% 0.9% 29.2% 5.0% 12.0%Mecklenburg 4.0% 1.9% 5.5%Wake 42.1% 2.0% 14.5%

Page 21: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 19

Table 7: Owners and Renters, Total and Latino Households, Metropolitan Areas, 2010

Total Households

Owner % Owner Renter % Renter

Asheville 125,590Burlington 40,104Charlotte-Concord-GastoniaDurham-Chapel HillFayetteville 42.4%GoldsboroGreensboro-High PointGreenville 45.4%Hickory-Lenoir-Morganton 144,504Jacksonville 42.9%New BernRaleighRocky Mount 21,495Wilmington

Winston-SalemLatino Households

TotalHouseholds

Owner % Owner Renter % Renter

Asheville 45.4%Burlington 4,052Charlotte-Concord-GastoniaDurham-Chapel HillFayettevilleGoldsboro 55.2%

Greensboro-High PointGreenvilleHickory-Lenoir-Morganton 41.1%

JacksonvilleNew BernRaleigh 12,209

Rocky Mount 1,111

WilmingtonWinston-Salem 14,504 40.1% 59.9%

Page 22: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

20 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

has   a   higher   rate   of   single-­‐‑detached   housing   oc-­‐‑-­‐‑

Are Latinos in North Carolina buying or renting homes?

relative  to  renters  for  all  households  and  for  Latino  households,  for  North  Carolina  as  a  whole  and  for  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

Table 8: Households and Homeownership, North Carolina, 2000 and 2010

Source: www.census.gov

Has the homeownership rate of Latinos changed significantly?  

rates   for  North  Carolina’s   total  and  Latino  popu-­‐‑lations  between  2000  and  2010.    For  the  state  as  a  

2000 2010Total HouseholdsTotal Homeowners

Latino Households 91,194Latino Homeowners

42.9%

Page 23: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 21

Table 9: Average Household Size, Owners and Renters, 2010

-­‐‑

-­‐‑holds   are   on   average   larger   than   the   households  

fertility   rates   largely   account   for   these   observed  

on  average   larger   than  Latino   renter  households.

-­‐‑

households.  On  average,  Latino  households  have  

other  households  in  the  state,  as  shown  in  Table  10.

What challenges have Latinos faced as renters in the North Carolina housing

market?

-­‐‑-­‐‑

where  Latinos  reside,  the  presence  of  illegal  drugs  and   related   gang   activity   resulted   in   feelings   of  

property   owners   and   unresponsive   landlords  

was   reported   in   the   application  process,  perhaps  -­‐‑

Table 10: Average Household Size by Age, 2010

Total Owners RentersTotal 2.52 2.40LatinoWhite (non-Latino) 2.42 2.15African American 2.59

Total Under 18 18 and OverTotalLatinoWhite (non-Latino) 0.51African American

Page 24: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

22 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

lords  place  on  Latino  households  in  the  property  

denying  application  eligibility.    While   requesting  

rental  applications  is  legal,  restricting  this  request  

is  a  violation  of  federal  housing  laws.    Lastly,  while  

subsequent  burden   it  places  on   their  households,  

Latino  renters  tend  to  pay  less  than  their  non-­‐‑La-­‐‑    paid  

lower  rents,  a  larger  share  of  Latino  households  is  

-­‐‑ers  statewide  and  41%  of  non-­‐‑Latino  White  renters.

What has been the experience of Latinos as homeowners in North Carolina?

-­‐‑ship,   including:   the   need   for   reliable   and   trust-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Focus  group  participants  expressed  a  desire  for  ac-­‐‑

-­‐‑

 

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

A  widely-­‐‑held  view  was  that  Latinos  as  a  group  do  -­‐‑

group  participant  stated,  “We  Latinos  are  often  not  -­‐‑

focused  on  the  challenges  of  having  the  appropri-­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

Focus   group   participants   raised   questions   about  

Page 25: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 23

buying   process,   and   the   cost   of   their   services.  

Latino  White  neighborhoods  and   toward  racially  

Finally,   focus   group   participants   characterized  -­‐‑

focus  group  participants  said  they  believed  the  un-­‐‑derwriting  process  favors  loan  applicants  who  are  

Do North Carolina’s Latinos aspire to be-come homeowners?

The   focus   group   participants   indicated   a   strong  

and   increased   control  over  one’s   living   situation.

to  the  expense  of  paying  rent.    Many  have  found  -­‐‑-­‐‑

equity   that   can   be   used   toward   purchasing   the  

and   lower   their   expenses  before   they   retire.   Sev-­‐‑

as   acquiring   assets   to   pass   on   to   their   children.

-­‐‑

repairs,   and   upgrades   rather   than   relying   on   a  

-­‐‑ing   that   their   residence   is   assured   for   the   long  

or   the   changing   ownership   of   their   rental   units.      

What are the challenges and obstacles to Latino homeownership?

Focus   group   participants   outlined   several   ob-­‐‑

buying   process,   understanding   how   to   qualify  

-­‐‑nos   in  our  focus  groups  was   identifying  the  best  

Many  participants  who  wanted  to  buy  a  house  had  

how  to  start  or  what  organization  to  approach  for  in-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Page 26: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

24 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

what  was  included  in  their  credit  history,  how  to  

credit   score.     There   was   also   confusion   around  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

by   focus   group   participants   was   who   to   engage  

Again,   the   confusion   was   whether   the   lend-­‐‑

How large is the Latino home loan market?

What were the e!ects of the recession on mortgage lending to Latinos?

-­‐‑

state.     For   non-­‐‑Latino   whites,   lending   has   fallen  

-­‐‑pacted  by  the  foreclosure  crisis.    A  2011  report  by  

that  Latinos   fared  worse   than  non-­‐‑Latino  whites  in  the  foreclosure  crisis.19  Latinos  were  dispropor-­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

Disclosure   Act   data   suggests   that   the   slowly   re-­‐‑

and  than  would  be  expected  based  on  their  share  

20  Further,  while  there  -­‐‑

ownership  and  wealth-­‐‑building,  “since   the  crisis,  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Page 27: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 25

Table 11: Changes in Home Lending by Loan Type

How large was the decline in home lending for Latinos in North Carolina?  

Across   the   state,   purchase   loans   are   down   45%  

purchase  lending  for  Latino  borrowers  has  fallen  

-­‐‑

North  Carolina,  particularly  to  Latino  borrowers,  

What are the major Latino mortgage markets in North Carolina?

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑21

What accounts for the decline in home purchase lending among Latinos following

the housing crisis?  

A   substantial   portion   of   the   decline   can   be   ex-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

2004-2006 2011-2013 ChangeLoans (Ths.)

Amt. ($B) Loans (Ths.)

Amt. ($B) Loans (Ths.)

Amt. ($B)

All Loans -­‐‑9% Latino 4.5 -­‐‑42% -­‐‑24% White -­‐‑21%Purchase 51.0 -­‐‑45% Latino 10.2 1.5 White -­‐‑54% -­‐‑42%Refinance 92.0 41% Latino 1.1 12.5 1.9 White 45.1 20% 52%

Page 28: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

26 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

plained   by   a   disproportionate   decline   in   the  

-­‐‑chase   of   owner-­‐‑occupied   site-­‐‑built   one-­‐‑to-­‐‑four  

in  Latino  households  over   this  period,  which  we  

-­‐‑

were  well  above  those  for  non-­‐‑Latino  Whites  and  

three-­‐‑year  period  for  which  data  are  available,  the  

-­‐‑

Table 13: Denial Rates of Mortgage Applications by House Type

Table 12: Home Purchase Mortgage Applications

Note: Restricted to first lien mortgage applications for purchase of owner-occupied manufactured and site-built one-to-four unit properties. Incomplete applications and applications withdrawn by the appli-cant are not included.

Note: Restricted to first lien mortgage applications for purchase of owner-occupied manufactured and site-built one-to-four unit properties. Incomplete applications and applications withdrawn by the appli-cant are not included.

Site-Built Manufactured2004-06 2011-13 Change 2004-06 2011-13 Change

Applications (000s) Latino 5.0 2.4 -­‐‑52% White 194.0 -­‐‑42% 42.0 19.5 -­‐‑54%Per 1,000 Households -­‐‑52% Latino White -­‐‑44% -­‐‑55%

Site-Built Manufactured2004-06 2011-13 2004-06 2011-13

Denial Rate 14% 50% 55% Latino 19% 55% White 9% 11%

Page 29: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 27

Table 14: Mortgage Originations by Loan Type

How successful are loan applications by Latinos for manufactured homes?

-­‐‑

also  been  an  increase  in  the  share  of  applications  

-­‐‑

non-­‐‑Latino   whites.   Since   then,   denial   rates   have  increased   slightly   for   all   groups,   despite   general  

What role do conventional loans play in the Latino mortgage market in North Carolina?

Note: Restricted to first lien mortgage originations for purchase of owner-occupied manufactured and site-built one-to-four unit properties.

Site-Built Manufactured2004-06 2011-13 2004-06 2011-13

Originations (Ths.) 415.1 10.2 Conventional 59% Latino 42% White 51% Federal Housing Adm. 20% 29% Latino 14% 24% White Veterans Administration 14% 5% Latino 9% 20% White 9% Rural Housing Service 0% 0% 2% Latino 0% 0% 1% White 1% 9% 0%

Page 30: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

28 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

Table 15: Financial Institutions Serving the Latino Market

Note: First lien mortgage originations for purchase of owner-occupied site-built one-to-four unit properties.

*Mean Census tract market share (2012 and 2013 only) weighted by number of Latino residents in tract according to

2009-2013 American Community Survey.

Loans (2011-13) Share of Total Latino Share of TotalAll Borrowers1 Wells Fargo Bank2 Branch Banking and Trust 9.1%3 State Employee’s Credit Union 2.1%4 Movement Mortgage 4.0% 4.2%5 Bank of America6 Suntrust Mortgage7 Primelending 5,454 2.5% 5.0%8 USAA Federal Savings Bank9 American Security Mortgage 1.9%10 CMC Funding 2.2%Latino Borrowers1 Wells Fargo Bank 14.0%2 Branch Banking and Trust 5993 Bank of America 4.5%4 Movement Mortgage 4.1% 4.2%5 Latino Community Credit Union6 State Employee’s Credit Union 299 2.1%7 USAA Federal Savings Bank8 Primelending 5.0%9 Self-Help Credit Union 220 2.5%10 American Security Mortgage 2.0%Latino Neighborhoods*1 Wells Fargo Bank 11.0%2 Branch Banking and Trust 10.9%3 State Employee’s Credit Union 2.1%4 Movement Mortgage 5.0% 4.2%5 Primelending 5.0%6 Bank of America 2.4%7 Suntrust Mortgage 2.1%8 Fairway Independent Mortgage 2.0%9 American Security Mortgage

10 USAA Federal Savings Bank

Page 31: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 29

statewide  and  less  than  12%  of  conventional  loans  to  non-­‐‑Latino  White  borrowers  were  higher-­‐‑priced.

-­‐‑ventional   share  of   loan  originations  has   fallen   to  

borrowers.     Finally,   loans   in   rural   areas   insured  

-­‐‑

Across   the   state,   the   conventional   share   of   loan  

How active are specific lenders in making loans to Latinos or in communities where there are higher concentrations of Latinos

in North Carolina?

-­‐‑

hold  the  top  two  places  when  lending  institutions  

22 -­‐‑

active   in   lending   for   the   purchase   of   site-­‐‑built,  

3.0 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

What are the macro-level takeaways from this study?

This   report   shows   that   addressing   the   housing  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

ous  Latino  population   in  North  Carolina  relative  to  other  groups  in  the  state.    Most  Latinos  in  the  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑

The   Latino   population   is   growing   in   all  -­‐‑

target   the   rapidly   growing   urban   areas.

Latinos   living   in   larger  urban  areas   tend  to  have  22   We   assess   lender   activity   where   Latinos   live   in   North   Carolina  

Page 32: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

30 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

Second,  lending  institutions  have  tightened  credit  -­‐‑-­‐‑

of  loan  applications  by  potential  Latino  borrowers.    

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

How do Latinos in North Carolina define their ideal living conditions?

neighbors,   and   other   nuisances.     They   want   to  

schools,  and  other  services.     In  addition   to  place,  the   characteristics   of   the   housing   unit   itself   also  

their  household’s  needs  today  but  that  can  also  be  -­‐‑

countries.     To   this   end,   Latinos   value   having   a  

 Many   Latinos   express   the   desire   for   their   ideal  

-­‐‑reotypical  single-­‐‑wide  or  double-­‐‑wide  on  wheels.    

between  the  quality  of  structure,  location,  and  cost.

Page 33: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 31

What are the programmatic implications that can be derived from this study?

Latinos  living  in  North  Carolina  face  challenges  in  

should   be   thoughtful   and   strategic   in   how   they  devise  solutions.    In  the  sections  below,  we  identify  

Latino   renters   confront  multiple  problems.  The  

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

three   factors.   First,   fewer   households   are   buying  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑ing   crisis   at   the   national   level   include   both   ef-­‐‑

increasing   the   ability   of   households   to   pay   for  -­‐‑

-­‐‑

at   the  needed   level  would  go  a   long  way   toward  

In  addition,  Congress  should  consider  fully  fund-­‐‑

-­‐‑-­‐‑

lina.   The   fund   is   designed   to   provide   subsidies  and   incentives   to   build   and   rehabilitate   housing  

was   that   it  would  be   funded   through   the   opera-­‐‑tions  of  Fannie  Mae  and  Freddie  Mac.  Since  these  

uncertain  into  the  foreseeable  future.  As  a  result,  Congress  should  consider  requiring  the  conserva-­‐‑

-­‐‑bly  has  never  fully  funded  the  state’s  on  Housing  

Page 34: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

32 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

the  construction  and  rehabilitation  of  units  for  low  

-­‐‑tiatives   at   the   national   level  will   help   address   at  least   in   part   the   need   to   expand   the   supply   of  

addition,   addressing   this   need   will   require   the  

ordinances  that  overly  restrict  where  rental  hous-­‐‑ing   can   be   developed.     The   high   cost   of   land   in  

the  supply  of  units  for  rent  but  also  add  to  needed  

who   want   to   age   in   place.   Obviously,   anything  that   can   be   done   to   reduce   red   tape   and   delays  

Finally,   inclusionary   zoning   could   be   considered  

-­‐‑velopers  have  to  provide  a  percentage  of  the  new  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

and   Manteo.   Currently,   these   ordinances   apply  

as  well.  Concerns  have  been   raised  about   the   le-­‐‑-­‐‑

nances  in  North  Carolina  without  explicit  state  ap-­‐‑

-­‐‑portions   of   Latino   households   that   is   housing  

North  Carolina  Latinos   confront   additional   chal-­‐‑lenges   as   renters   requiring   other   interventions.  Many   Latino   renters   are   unaware   of   their   rights  as  renters  and  what  they  can  do  about  substand-­‐‑ard   housing,   fair   access   to   housing,   and   other  

-­‐‑

valid  visa  to  live  or  stay  in  the  country.    Unfortu-­‐‑

do   not   accept   alternative   proof   of   legal   status,  

and   others   are   available   to   answer   questions   on  

on  housing  rights  printed  in  Spanish  and  English.

One  way  to  address  the  challenges  faced  by  Latino  -­‐‑

can   create   the   large-­‐‑scale   change  needed   to   sup-­‐‑port   a   fair,   equitable   and   sustainable   change.    A  

Page 35: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 33

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

strategic   opportunities   and   addressing   obstacles  -­‐‑

-­‐‑cation   across   partners   to   build   trust   and   assure  

instance,   advocacy   organizations   could   partner  

with  Legal  Aid  organizations,  the  North  Carolina  

provide  assistance  to  renters  about  their  rights  and  provide   legal   representation   for   Latino   renters.

Most  Latinos  want  to  own  their  homes.   -­‐‑

-­‐‑

buying.     Few   were   aware   of   the   ways   to   build  -­‐‑

gage   loans,   especially   without   a   social   security  

-­‐‑-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

-­‐‑

They  are  often  seen  as  neglectful,  unwilling  to  share  -­‐‑

the  perceived  steering  is  in  fact  occurring.    These  concerns  suggest  a  need  to  educate  both  potential  

for   real   estate   agents   and   other   professionals   in-­‐‑

should   educate   these   professionals   on   the   needs  

of   Latino   borrowers   should   be   a   priority.     For  -­‐‑

Page 36: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

34 —2015 State of Latino Housing in NC

able  in  English  should  be  translated  into  Spanish.

The  growing  Latino  population  in  North  Carolina  

-­‐‑

While   Latinos   currently   account   for   only   2%  of   all   registered   voters   in   the   state,   registra-­‐‑

next   decade.     By   stepping   up   to   address   basic  

-­‐‑

 

-­‐‑-­‐‑

Page 37: 2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1...2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 1 Principal Investigators Roberto G. Quercia James H. Johnson Jr. Contributing Authors Allison Freeman

2015 State of Latino Housing in NC — 35

North Carolina Latino Housing Assessment Advisory Committee

Jeremey CarterNational Association for Latino Community Asset BuildersLeonor ClavijoN.C. Hispanic Chamber of Commerce Satana Deberry North Carolina Housing Coalition Javier Diaz De LeonMexican Consulate - RaleighTracey Greene-DorsettZ. Smith Reynolds Foundation Jess GeorgeLatin American Coalition Hannah GillUNC Institute for the Study of the AmericasMonica Colin GutierrezMexican Consulate - RaleighJohn Herrera Self Help Credit Union Bob KucabN.C. Housing Finance AgencyPierre LaPierreKeller WilliamsLuis MattaCharlotte-Mecklenburg Community Relations CommitteeBeth Mckee-HugerGreensboro Housing Coalition Roger MontesLatino Community Credit UnionDani MoreNorth Carolina Justice Center Javier OlaveLatino Community Credit UnionLuis PastorLatino Community Credit UnionJulie PorterCharlotte–Mecklenburg Housing PartnershipRafael PrietoLatin American Coalition Diana RodriguezGovernor’s Advisory Council on Hispanic/Latino A!airsAlexandra Forter Sirota North Carolina Justice Center Peter SkillernReinvestment PartnersJenny Snead-Williams Duke University Program in Latino/a Studies in the Global SouthKen SzymanskiN.C. Apartment AssociationGregg WarrenDHIC Inc.