anca romcea -teza de doctorat (rezumat en)
DESCRIPTION
ÂTRANSCRIPT
Cover
Prospective study on the
development and complications
of variceal bleeding in patients
with liver cirrhosis
2 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
Contents
INTRODUCTION 13
PRESENT KNOWLEDGE IN LITERATURE
1. Pathophysiology data of liver cirrhosis 17
1.1. Portal hypertension in liver cirrhosis 17
1.2. Pathophysiological features of upper variceal gastrointestinal
bleeding in cirrhotic patients 19
2. Treatment principles of variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients 23
2.1. Concepts of primary prophylaxis of variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients.
The role of endoscopic therapy in primary prevention 23
2.1.1. Primary prevention strategy of variceal bleeding by
pharmacological means 24
2.1.2. The role of endoscopic therapy in the primary prevention
of variceal bleeding 25
2.2. Specific treatment (hemostasis) of active variceal bleeding 26
2.2.1. Treatment with vasoactive pharmacological agents of active
variceal bleeding 26
2.2.2. Endoscopic treatment of active variceal bleeding 26
2.3. Concepts of secondary prophylaxis of variceal bleeding 28
3. Complications of variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients 31
3.1. Complications associated with variceal bleeding 31
3.1.1. Hepatic encephalopathy 31
3.1.2. Bacterial infections 32
3.1.3. Hepato-renal syndrome 33
3.1.4. Bleeding relapses 34
3.1.5. Hypovolemic shock 34
3.1.6. Variceal bleeding consequences on cardiovascular diseases 35
3.1.7. Complications due to pharmacotherapy and to therapeutic
procedures in variceal bleeding 36
ORIGINAL PART
1. Hypothesis / objectives 41
2. Study 1. The etiopathogenesis of the upper gastrointestinal bleeding
in cirrhotic patients and the variceal bleeding risk factors 43
2.1. Introduction 43
2.2. Objectives 43
2.3. Materials and methods 43
2.3.1. Study group 43
2.3.2. Variables 45
Anca Romcea 3
2.3.3. Statistical analysis 46
2.4. Results 47
2.4.1. Aspects of pathogenesis of the upper gastrointestinal bleeding in
cirrhotic patients 49
2.4.2. Aspects of risk factors of variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients 58
2.5. Discussions 67
2.6. Conclusions 69
3. Study 2. Evolution and complications of the variceal bleeding in cirrhotic
patients 71
3.1. Introduction 71
3.2. Objectives 72
3.3. Materials and methods 72
3.3.1. Study group 72
3.3.2. Variables 75
3.3.3 Statistical analysis 75
3.4. Results 76
3.4.1. Aspects of the first bleeding relapse 78
3.4.2. Implications of the drug and endoscopic treatment in relapses
of variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients. 85
3.4.3. Complications in relapses of variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients 88
3.4.4. Analysis of mortality in variceal bleeding 92
3.4.5. Prediction factors of survival after variceal bleeding 97
3.5. Discussions 103
3.6. Conclusions 105
4. General conclusions 107
5. Originality and innovative contributions of the thesis 111
REFERENCES 113
4 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
Keywords:
variceal bleeding, esophageal varices, upper gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhotic
patients, variceal bleeding risk factors, endoscopic treatment for variceal
bleeding, mortality in variceal bleeding.
Introduction
The upper gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhotic patients is one of the
major pathology problems of Gastroenterology and it is also a public health
issue with high incidence, severe complications and high costs involved in giving
the required health care to these patients.
In spite of the application of preventive measures, as well as despite the
improvement of diagnostic methods and the greater efficiency of treatment
methods, liver cirrhosis with its most feared complication - the upper
gastrointestinal bleeding - remains a major public health problem.
The upper gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhotic patients mainly occurs
because of esophageal and gastric varices. However, there are a significant
number of non-variceal bleeding cases too. Therefore, the first study aimed to
analyze the etiopathogenesis of the upper gastrointestinal bleeding in patients
with liver cirrhosis and to assess the risk factors involved in the occurrence of
variceal bleeding. The study included 900 patients with cirrhosis, which allowed
us to have an overview of the upper gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhotic patients.
After the first episode of variceal bleeding, the risk for a bleeding relapse is
high, whereas complications (hepatic and extrahepatic ones) and mortality may
be due to multiple factors: the severity of bleeding (ie hemodynamic imbalance),
worsening of the liver failure (assessed by the Child-Pugh criteria), the
association of other diseases (infections, diabetes mellitus, heart disease,
hepatocellular carcinoma, etc.). Moreover, the methods of treatment applied to
the patients, when they experience the first variceal bleeding, involve a change in
the frequency of relapses, in the timing of their occurrence in relation to the initial
bleeding episode and in the long-term survival.
The second study looked into the bleeding relapses that occurred in patients
after the first variceal bleeding episode. Moreover, we studied the risk factors for the
first bleeding relapse, the influence of medication and that of the endoscopic
Anca Romcea 5
treatment, the complications and the mortality issues. We also analyzed the
prediction factors of survival at one year of the initial bleeding episode. International
guidelines contain a number of recommendations including an essential one, namely:
the indication to perform the upper gastrointestinal endoscopy within the first 24
hours in all patients with upper gastrointestinal bleeding.
In our country, according to the data from the Romanian Society of
Endoscopy, there are few medical centers in which on duty permanent endoscopy
service exists, and in many of the units in which emergency upper gastrointestinal
endoscopy is performed during office hours there are no resources required for
performing endoscopic hemostasis. In this respect, in order to complete the
present thesis, due to the existing on duty service, we benefited from the
possibility of performing upper gastrointestinal endoscopy in all the patients who
presented with an episode of bleeding, in the "Prof. O. Fodor" Regional Institute of
Gastroenterology and Hepatology. Moreover, all the patients received endoscopic
treatment conducted by experienced endoscopy specialists.
Hypothesis/ Objectives
The causes of upper gastrointestinal bleeding (UGI bleeding) may be
variceal or non-variceal, hence the importance of performing the upper
gastrointestinal endoscopy within the first 24 hours of admission of the UGI
bleeding patient. Thus, the source of bleeding can be specified and the
appropriate endoscopic treatment initiated.
The life prognosis of a patient with variceal upper gastrointestinal
bleeding depends on the severity of the haemorrhage, on the hepatic functional
reserve (cirrhosis stage), on the degree and location of the varices (esophageal or
gastric), on the patient’s age, on the existence of associated diseases, on the
specific treatment, etc.
For this reason, we decided to monitor the etiopathogenesis of upper
gastrointestinal bleeding in cirrhotic patients, the risk factors for variceal
bleeding, its severity, the efficiency of the endoscopic hemostasis techniques, the
assessment of bleeding relapses, the mortality and survival of these patients.
Numerous published studies have shown correlations between certain
clinical, biochemical and ultrasound parameters and the risk for variceal bleeding,
with variable results. Therefore, our first study, in this thesis, looked into some of
these aspects and into what causes variceal bleeding in these patients.
6 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
The results of speciality studies cannot be extrapolated directly onto the
cases in the territory as the variceal bleeding risk factors can significantly vary
depending on the population’s genetics, on environmental conditions and on
socio-economic conditions. This is the reason why, we considered the present
doctoral thesis useful.
Study 1. The etiopathogenesis of upper gastrointestinal bleeding in
cirrhotic patients and the variceal bleeding risk factors
Objectives
The objectives of the study were to analyze the etiology of non-variceal
bleeding in cirrhotic patients and the risk factors for variceal bleeding.
Materials and methods
The study group
The study was an analytical, experimental, longitudinal and prospective
type of study conducted in the period 1.11.2004-31.05.2006, in the "Prof. O.Fodor
" Regional Institute of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Cluj-Napoca.
Data collection was conducted by sampling, the patients study group
consisting of a representative sample.
The general group included 938 patients diagnosed with liver cirrhosis
according to clinical, biochemical, ultrasonographic and endoscopic criteria,
whereas the documentation was completed from the patients’ observation
charts. Out of the 938 patients, the group of study interest included 217 patients
with UGI bleeding, who underwent upper gastrointestinal endoscopy for
diagnosis and treatment, under emergency conditions, in the Digestive
Endoscopy Office of the"Prof. Dr. O.Fodor" Regional Institute of
Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Cluj-Napoca.
The study group of patients with bleeding was divided into two
subgroups: the group of patients with variceal bleeding (N = 168) and the group
of patients with non-variceal bleeding (N = 49). The control group consisted of
patients with no bleeding (N = 721). The patients who had upper
gastrointestinal bleeding from gastric varices were excluded from the study.
Anca Romcea 7
After the variceal or non-variceal source of the UGI bleeding was identified,
endoscopic therapy was applied where necessary.
In the cases of variceal bleeding, endoscopic sclerotherapy was
performed by using hypertonic glucose solution or by inserting elastic ligatures
according to possibilities, under emergency conditions; in the cases of non-
variceal bleeding, adrenaline 1/10000 and absolute alcohol were injected or
metal clips were inserted, depending on the etiology of the bleeding.
A record chart, which included the following data, was completed for each
patient, upon inclusion in the study:
personal data (name, age, gender)
personal pathological history suggestive of the underlying disease and of
comorbidities (liver virus infections, alcohol consumption, autoimmune
diseases, diabetes mellitus, HCC, etc.)
complete diagnosis (the underlying disease, associated diseases),
classification according to the Child-Pugh criteria
symptoms and signs:
- type of bleeding (hematemesis, melena, hematochezia)
- severity of the bleeding
- ascites
- jaundice
- the degree of hepatic encephalopathy (I, II, III, IV)
laboratory findings: complete blood count, INR, bilirubin, transaminases,
etc.
upper GI endoscopy - signaling the presence of esophageal and / or
gastric varices, the presence / absence of active bleeding on examination,
with or without signs of recent bleeding (clots), varices grade (I, II, III),
the presence / absence of red signs on the esophageal varices according
to the Guide of the Japanese Society of Endoscopy, the presence of other
bleeding lesions (ulcers, gastritis, angiodysplasia, portal hypertensive
gastropathy, polyps, Mallory-Weiss syndrome - MWS, esophagitis, etc.)
abdominal ultrasound- spleen, VP size, presence / absence of ascites, of
HCC
infections - respiratory infections, urinary infections, spontaneous
bacterial peritonitis
endoscopic treatment- sclerotherapy, elastic ligatures, injection of
adrenaline, absolute alcohol, metal clips insertion, argon plasma
coagulation (APC)
patient’s drug therapy -propranolol, nitrates.
8 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
The patient’s record chart contains clinical and laboratory data recorded
on admission, during hospitalization and at hospital discharge.
The study was approved by the local ethics committee of "Prof. O. Fodor"
Regional Institute of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Cluj-Napoca.
Results
Out of the 938 patients included in the study, 217 patients had upper
gastrointestinal bleeding (168 variceal bleeding cases and 49 non-variceal cases).
The variceal bleeding was the dominant etiology, accounting for 77.42% of the
upper gastrointestinal bleeding in the cirrhotic patients included in the study.
Non-variceal bleeding occurred at a rate of 22.58% of the upper gastrointestinal
bleeding. Peptic ulcer caused 12.44% of the initial episodes of UGI bleeding,
Mallory-Weiss syndrome caused 3.68%, acute erosive gastritis 1.84%, portal
hypertensive gastropathy 1.38% and the remaining 3.22% were bleeding from
the esophageal ulcer, gastric angiodysplasia, antral vascular ectasia, duodenal
polyps and gastric tumors.
Comparing the two groups of patients, those with variceal bleeding (N =
168) and the non-variceal bleeding ones (N = 49), in terms of the incidence of
bleeding depending on the cirrhosis severity, a statistically significant association
was found between the Child-Pugh class and the type of bleeding. Thus, there is a
higher occurrence of variceal bleeding in the patients from Child-Pugh class B (74
patients) and C (57 patients), compared with non-variceal bleeding that occurred
more frequently in patients from Child-Pugh A and B, ie the non-variceal bleeding
risk was 2.5 times higher in patients from Child-Pugh class A and B than in those
from the Child-Pugh class C (p = 0.008, Chi Square test, oR = 2.5, 95% CI 1.2 to 5.2).
The Mallory-Weiss syndrome shows a statistically significant association (p =
0.041) with ethanolic etiology, male gender (p = 0.02, RR = 1.35, 95% CI 1.1-1.6), with
the simultaneous presence of gastric varices on the upper gastrointestinal endoscopy
(p <0.001, RR = 13.34, 95% CI 3.2 to 55.58) in these patients, the Child-Pugh class A
cirrhosis (p = 0.045, RR = 4, 95% CI 2.1 to 17.87). As to the portal hypertensive
gastropathy, there is an association with thrombocytopenia (plt <60000) (p =
<0.001), INR> 2 (p = 0.001) and the Child-Pugh class C (p = <0.001). The bleeding
episode was more severe in the group with variceal bleeding than in that of non-
variceal bleeding (p <0.001, Chi-square test). The risk for the hemorrhagic
episode to be more severe in the variceal bleeding patients is 1.6 times higher
than in the non-variceal bleeding patients (RR = 1.6, 95% CI 1.28 to 2.01). Severe
bleeding was present in 69.59% of the patients who had upper gastrointestinal
Anca Romcea 9
bleeding. The variceal intrusion is the main source of bleeding in severe bleeding
(87.42%), whereas peptic ulcer and the Mallory-Weiss syndrome are mainly
diagnosed in moderate and mild bleeding (71.4%). To analyze the risk factors for
variceal bleeding in cirrhotic patients, we studied 168 patients with variceal
bleeding, in comparison with the control group, which included 721 patients
without bleeding (variceal or non-variceal). The variceal bleeding was the
dominant etiology, accounting for 77.42% of the upper gastrointestinal bleeding
in the cirrhotic patients included in the study. In the study group, the ethanolic
etiology of liver cirrhosis as a risk factor (p <0.001, RR = 1.63, 95% CI: 1.26 to
2.10) for variceal bleeding stood out, while the C viral etiology was found to be a
protective factor (p <0.001, RR = 0.64, 95% CI: 0.48 to 0.86). No other etiology
was found to be statistically significant (B viral liver cirrhosis with p = 0.587, p =
0.36 autoimmune cirrhosis, etc.).
It was determined that there is an acceptable association (φc = 0.33, p
<0.001) between the Child-Pugh class and the occurrence of variceal bleeding
(Cramer's V coefficient). The Child-Pugh class A is a protective factor , while the
Child-Pugh class C is a risk factor (p <0.001, RR = 2.39) for the occurrence of
variceal bleeding in the cirrhotic patients from the study group. The esophageal
varices intrusion depends on the grade of the varicose veins, being more frequent
in patients with grade II and III varices (p <0.001), while the risk for bleeding
from varices grade III is 3.7 times higher than in patients with varicose veins
grade I and II. On the upper digestive endoscopy, the highlighting of red marks on
the surface of esophageal varices and the simultaneous presence of gastric varices
were found to be in a statistically significant correlation (p <0.001, RR = 7) using
Chi-Square test, with the risk of bleeding from esophageal varices. The platelet
count <60,000 / mm3 was recorded in 57 patients with variceal bleeding. This
was found to be a statistically significant association with the increased risk for
variceal bleeding in these patients (RR = 1.83, 95% CI: 1.41 to 2.37, p <0.001). The
hepatic encephalopathy was also associated with the risk for variceal bleeding in
the cirrhotic patients from our study (RR = 1.45, 95% CI: 1.19 to 1.76, p <0.001). It
was determined that the spleen diameter > 140mm counted as a risk factor in the
occurrence of variceal bleeding (RR = 1.78, 95% CI: 1.35 to 2.34, p <0.001).
In our study, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis was found to be in a
statistically significant association with the risk for variceal bleeding (RR = 1.75, p
<0.003), respiratory infections were correlated with p <0.003 and RR = 1.78,
while urinary infections increased the risk for variceal bleeding (p = 0.03) by 1.38
times. Patients with variceal bleeding associated with PBS were patients with
advanced liver cirrhosis.
10 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
The presence of HCC was found in 10.12% of the patients with variceal
bleeding and it was highlighted as a risk factor for variceal bleeding (RR = 1.1; 95%
CI: 0.72 to 1.65). However, it was not found to be statistically significantly
associated with the variceal bleeding (p = 0.68). To determine the diagnostic value
of certain numeric parameters (patient’s age, the longitudinal diameter of the
spleen, platelet count, the portal vein diameter) the ROC curves (Receiver Operating
Characteristic) were constructed and compared. The ROC curve graphically
illustrates the relationship between sensitivity and specificity for certain possible
cut-off values. The optimal values in terms of reliability of the analyzed parameters
are considered cut-off points. The cut-off value (the point where sensitivity and
specificity are at a maximum) determined with highly statistical significance (p
<0.001) for the platelet count is 138,500 / mm3. For this threshold, the specificity is
high, i.e. 83.6%, which means that the variceal bleeding is well-diagnosed. Thus, a
positive result confirms the diagnosis of variceal bleeding, but the sensitivity is
reduced. The longitudinal diameter of the spleen, measured by ultrasound, was
established to have a threshold value of 232.5 mm (p <0.001) with high specificity,
but very low sensitivity. For the portal vein diameter, a cut-off value of 9.6 mm (p
<0.001) was fixed, with very high sensitivity (98.3%), which means that a negative
result (below the threshold) refutes the diagnosis of variceal bleeding. Age shows a
cut-off of 54.5 years, but without statistical significance (p = 0.245).
Study 2. Evolution and complications of variceal bleeding in cirrhosis
Objectives
The objectives of the study were to evaluate the evolution of variceal
bleeding, the aspects of bleeding relapse, the implications of the treatment
principles, the complications within bleeding relapses and the factors predictive
of survival in the patients included in the study.
Materials and methods
The study group
The study was one of an analytical, experimental, longitudinal,
prospective type, conducted in the period 1.11.2004-31.08.2006. The
Anca Romcea 11
inclusion and study of patients within regular check-ups took place at "Prof.
Fodor O. " Regional Institute of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Cluj-Napoca,
for over a year, until 31.08.2007. Data collection was conducted by sampling
and the study group consisted of a representative patient sample. The study
included 198 patients, with upper gastrointestinal bleeding from esophageal
varices, who underwent diagnostic and therapeutic upper gastrointestinal
endoscopy, under emergency conditions, at the Office of "Prof. O.Fodor"
Regional Institute Endoscopy Gastroenterology and Hepatology Cluj-Napoca.
The study included only patients whose source of bleeding was the esophageal
varices intrusion. This was assessed by emergency endoscopic examination
performed within 6 hours of the patient’s admission at the latest.
Subsequently, we studied 74 patients who had variceal bleeding relapses while
the control group was formed of patients without bleeding relapses (N = 124).
Patients, who had a diagnosis of cirrhosis of unknown etiology at the time of
discharge, were excluded from the study. After the source of variceal bleeding
in the UGI bleeding had been identified, endoscopic therapy was performed
(elastic ligatures or sclerotherapy with hypertonic glucose solution, depending
on the specific possibilities). In order to investigate the factors predictive of
morbidity and mortality after bleeding episodes, as well as those predictive of
survival, we monitored bleeding relapses because of esophageal varices
intrusion, the occurrence or worsening of specific complications of cirrhosis -
hepatic encephalopathy, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, ascites, the
occurrence or worsening of complications due to associated diseases
(infections, cardiovascular diseases, etc.), the number and causes of deaths.
Regular check-ups were carried out after 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months and 1
year of the initial bleeding.
The study was stopped for each patient at the end of the follow-up
period or in case of death. The study was approved by the local ethics
committee of "Prof. O. Fodor" Regional Institute of Gastroenterology and
Hepatology, Cluj-Napoca.
Results
Out of the 198 patients with variceal bleeding, bleeding relapses occurred
in 74 patients: 48 men and 26 women. In the group of patients with bleeding
relapses, there were a total of 118 bleeding relapses in the period immediately
after the application of endoscopic hemostasis, (between 2 and 5 bleeding
episodes per patient).
12 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
Out of the 198 cases in which control over the initial variceal bleeding was
obtained, the first hemorrhagic relapse was recorded in 37.37% of the patients.
Gender, age and etiology of cirrhosis of patients who experienced variceal bleeding
did not correlate with the risk for a first bleeding relapse. There is a statistically
significant correlation of the first bleeding relapse with the Child-Pugh liver cirrhosis
(p = 0.04); mainly patients with liver cirrhosis of Child-Pugh class B (37.6%) and C
(44%) presented a bleeding relapse, in comparison with patients in Child-Pugh class
A who had their first variceal bleeding (23%). The severity of the acute bleeding
episode originally influences the occurrence of the relapse (p <0.001). Thus, out of the
54 patients with a clinically significant bleeding episode when they first had variceal
bleeding, 30 patients had their first hemorrhagic relapse.
Prevention of bleeding relapses, by pharmacological treatment, was done by
administering beta-blockers. Monitoring the response to treatment could ideally
be done by GVPH measuring, but this was dependent on the access to methodology
and on the generated costs. Thus, decision was made to decrease the pulse by 25%
of the baseline. Each patient in the group of patients with variceal bleeding was
administered 20-80 mg of propranolol, starting on the sixth day of hospital
admission for the first variceal bleeding episode. The influence of the beta-blocker
administration on the occurrence of bleeding relapses was presented previously.
We continued to study the influence of the treatment with nonselective beta-
blockers (propranolol), nitrates or combinations of the two classes of drugs, on all
the 118 bleeding relapses occurred in the group of 74 patients.
• Analysis of variceal bleeding mortality
During the first variceal bleeding and during bleeding relapses 47 deaths
were recorded.
The following factors were found to statistically significantly correlate
with mortality within the first 48 hours:
- severity of cirrhosis: deaths were recorded, within the first 48 hours, only in
cases with Child-Pugh class B and C liver cirrhosis; no death was recorded in
the Child-Pugh class A (p = 0.04).
- severity of bleeding: we have noticed an increased death rate at 48 hours in
cases with clinically significant bleeding (p <0.001).
- HCC presence - increased the risk of death at 48 hours by 4 times in these
patients; 33.33% of the deceased patients at 48 hours also had HCC
(p = 0.004, RR = 4, 95% CI: 1.5 - 10.63).
Anca Romcea 13
- large amount of ascites - correlates with death at 48 hours (p = 0.017).
Gender and the age of patients, the etiology of cirrhosis and the endoscopic
treatment were not found to have significantly correlated with the deaths
recorded within 48 hours after the initial bleeding, but we found that 33.3% of the
patients who died in this period were diagnosed with liver cirrhosis of alcohol
consumption etiology (p = 0.05).
In the following period, from day 3 and up to six weeks after the initial
bleeding episode, 40.43% of all deaths in the study group were recorded and they
mainly occurred because of hemorrhagic shock (Fig. 17) .
The analysis of mortality up to 6 weeks showed statistically significant
correlation with the following factors:
- Child-Pugh C liver cirrhosis - in the deceased patients compared with the
cirrhosis severity in the patients who survived (p = 0.015, RR = 2.5, 95% CI:
1.4 to 12.7)
- treatment with medication - no treatment with propranolol was correlated
with death (p <0.001, RR = 1.33, 95% CI: 1.1-1.6); patients who did not
receive beta-blockers had a risk of death by 1.33 times higher than those who
were treated with medication.
- treatment performed endoscopically - of all deaths up to 6 weeks, there was
no death in patients with associated endoscopic treatment (sclerotherapy
and ligation); 79% of deaths occurred in patients treated by endoscopic
sclerotherapy of esophageal varices (p = 0.002)
- -presence of HCC - increased the risk of death in these patients by 4.5 (p
<0.001, RR = 4.5, 95% CI: 1.97 to 10.32)
- associated PBS increased the risk of death by 2.35, at 6 weeks (p = 0.048, RR
= 2.35, 95% CI: 1.1 to 5.7)
- hepatic encephalopathy was present in 73.7% of the patients who died up
until 6 weeks (p = 0.001) in comparison with the survivors
- acute ischemic hepatitis increased the risk of death by 12.5 (p = 0.031, RR =
12.5, 95% CI: 1.05 to 5.89)
- hemorrhagic shock increased the risk of death in these patients by 5.94 (p
<0.001, RR = 5.94, 95% CI: 2.5 to 14.1)
Mortality between 46 and 365 days, after the initial bleeding episode, was
found to have a statistically significant correlation with the presence of HCC (p
<0.001, RR = 6.18, 95% CI: 2.26 to 16.91) in the deceased patients (13 patients) in
comparison with the survivors (151 patients), and with the presence of
hemorrhagic shock (p <0.04, RR = 2.91, 95% CI: 1.02 to 8.25).
14 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
• Prediction factors of survival after variceal bleeding
At the end of one year since the first bleeding episode, 47 patients died and
151 survived. After the initial episode of variceal bleeding, patients were given
medication (propranolol, nitrates or propranolol plus nitrates) and were called
for check-ups to undergo consolidation therapy for the esophageal varices by
sclerotherapy or elastic ligatures.
• General conclusions
UGI bleeding occurred in 23.14% of the cirrhotic patients included in the
study, the variceal bleeding representing the dominant etiology and accounting
for 77.42% of the first episode of bleeding in these patients.
Non-variceal bleeding occurred in 22.58% of all the patients with upper
gastrointestinal bleeding and was represented, in descending order, by: peptic
ulcer, Mallory-Weiss syndrome, acute erosive gastritis, portal hypertensive
gastropathy and other etiologies which were seldom found in our study
(esophageal ulcer, gastric angiodysplasia, antral vascular ectasia, duodenal polyps
and gastric tumors).
The incidence of UGI bleeding was high in patients aged over 55 years, the
gender ratio male:female being 2:1 in both groups of patients (both in the variceal
bleeding goup and in the non-variceal bleeding group).
Alcoholic etiology was predominant in the variceal bleeding group.
Non-variceal upper gastrointestinal bleeding such as those of peptic ulcer
type, acute erosive gastritis and esophageal ulcer were recorded in greater
numbers in patients with Child-Pugh class A and B liver cirrhosis, in comparison
to those with Child-Pugh class C liver cirrhosis.
Mallory-Weiss syndrome shows a statistically significant correlation with
ethanolic etiology, male gender and Child-Pugh class A.
portal hypertensive gastropathy bleeding was found in correlation with
thrombocytopenia (plt <60,000), INR> 2 and Child-Pugh class C cirrhosis.
Comparing the two groups of patients (the variceal bleeding group vs.
the non-variceal bleeding group), the risk for non-variceal bleeding was 2.5
times higher in patients with Child-Pugh class A and B than in patients with
Child-Pugh class C.
Anca Romcea 15
The bleeding episode was more severe in the group with variceal bleeding
than in the non-variceal bleeding group.
The variceal intrusion was the main bleeding source in severe bleeding;
peptic ulcer and Mallory-Weiss syndrome were mainly diagnosed in moderate
and mild bleeding.
The esophageal varices intrusion depended on the varices grade, on the presence
of variceal red wheals and it increased with the severity of the liver damage.
The presence of hepatic encephalopathy, platelet count <60,000 / mm3 and
the spleen longitudinal diameter>140 mm were found to have a statistically
significant correlation with the risk of variceal bleeding.
Bacterial infections - spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, respiratory infections,
and urinary tract infections occurred in 49.4% of the patients in the group with
variceal bleeding.
The presence of HCC was found in 10.12% of the patients with variceal
bleeding, but did not correlate with the risk of variceal bleeding.
Building and comparing ROC curves for the group of patients with variceal
bleeding, a threshold of 138,500 / mm3 for the platelet count was set and of 232.5
mm for the longitudinal spleen diameter to make the diagnosis of variceal
bleeding. The size of the portal vein was set below 9.6 mm in order to refute
variceal bleeding. However, none of these parameters had a big enough AUC to
make a firm diagnosis.
By multivariate logistic regression it was found that the strongest predictor
of variceal bleeding was the presence of red weals on the surface of esophageal
varices, followed by the ethanol etiology of cirrhosis, Child-Pugh class C,
thrombocytopenia below 138,500 / mm3 and the grade of the esophageal
varices, the latter highlighting a directly proportional relationship between a
higher grade of the esophageal varices and the influence on the occurrence of
variceal haemorrhage.
The risk for the first bleeding relapse in cirrhotic patients increased with
the severity of the liver disease (Child-Pugh class), with the presence of
hemorrhagic shock and of acute alcoholic hepatitis during the first episode of
variceal bleeding.
The drug treatment with propranolol as secondary prophylaxis is a
protection factor for the first bleeding relapse; the endoscopic sclerotherapy
treatment resulted in a higher incidence of the first bleeding relapse than that
performed with elastic ligatures.
In all the bleeding relapses that occurred in the cirrhotic patients from our
study, no treatment with propranolol statistically significantly correlated with the
16 Prospective study on the development and complications of variceal bleeding in patients with liver cirrhosis
occurrence of bleeding relapse, while the endoscopic ligation treatment of the
esophageal varices correlated with a decrease in relapse episodes.
Bleeding complications that occurred during relapses were found to have a
statistically significant correlation with the severity of cirrhosis, the presence of
hemorrhagic shock and the hepatic encephalopathy.
Bacterial infections (spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, respiratory and
urinary tract infections) were common in the first bleeding relapse and were
present in 41.2% of these patients.
Overall mortality by variceal bleeding was 23.73%.
The causes of death were: hemorrhagic shock (47%), hepatic coma (38%),
myocardial infarction (13%) and stroke (2%).
Immediate mortality, within the first 48 hours after the initial bleeding
episode, was statistically significantly correlated with the severity of the liver
cirrhosis, with the presence of hemorrhagic shock, with a large amount of ascites,
with serum bilirubin> 3 mg / dl, with acute ischemic hepatitis, with HCC, with
myocardial infarction and spontaneous bacterial peritonitis in these patients.
Mortality within 3 days to 45 days (six weeks) of the initial bleeding episode
significantly correlated with Child-Pugh class C cirrhosis, with no treatment with
propranolol, with the endoscopic sclerotherapy treatment versus ligation or
combined therapy, with HCC, with the spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, with the
hepatic encephalopathy, with the hemorrhagic shock and acute ischemic hepatitis
in patients who died, in comparison with the survivors from our study.
From 46 days up until one year after the initial bleeding episode, mortality
was recorded in 6.56% of the patients and our study found it statistically
significantly correlated with the presence of HCC and the hemorrhagic shock.
The statistical analysis of the events recorded after one year from the first
episode of variceal bleeding in the cirrhotic patients from our study revealed that
the patients who survived longer were patients with Child-Pugh class A liver
cirrhosis, without PBS, who were given drug treatment with propranolol and
whose esophageal varices were treated by sclerotherapy plus elastic ligatures;
these patients had no hemorrhagic shock during the acute episode and were aged
under 55 years. The most important survival prognostic factors analyzed by
multivariate Cox regression were: the hemorrhagic shock, PBS, the treatment with
propranolol and the applied endoscopic treatment.