managing recreation-related impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the adirondack...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the
ADIRONDACK PARK and Building a Culture of Wildlands Stewardship
Prepared by Ben Lawhon, MSLeave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics | February 2020
Confidentiality Notice: This document contains confidential and proprietary information of the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics (the Center). Accordingly, this document is confidential and is intended solely for the information of the individual or entity to which it is delivered by or on behalf of the Center. By accepting a copy of this document, the recipient agrees not to copy, distribute or otherwise disclose this document or its contents or any other related information to any other individual or entity without the prior
written consent of the Center. For more information on Leave No Trace, please visit www.LNT.org or call 1.800.332.4100*Stewardship – the management necessary to preserve wilderness, natural resources, and access for current and future generations.
A S S E S S M E N T R E P O R T
![Page 2: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
AssessmentReportOverviewThisreportdetailsfindingsandobservationsfromacomprehensiveassessmentperformedbystafffromtheLeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics(theCenter).Theassessmentinvolvedseveralcomponentsincluding:
1. InitialconsultationwiththeAdirondackCouncilandtheAdirondackMountainClub(ADK)staffviaphone,email,andvideocallstogainbaselineunderstandingofrecreation-relatedissuesfacingtheAdirondackPark;
2. AdministrationofanonlinesurveytoAdirondackParkmanagers,keypartners,andothersduringAugustof2019tocollectdataonrecreationtrends,recreationpatterns,pressingrecreation-relatedissues,significantimpactsfromrecreation,andstrategiescurrentlybeingutilizedtoaddresstheseconcerns;
3. Anon-sitevisitconductedbyCenterstaffinconjunctionwithCouncilandADKstaff
toexploreandobservecurrentparkconditions,meetwithkeyParkmanagementstafffromboththeNYDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservationandtheAdirondackParkAgencyandotherstakeholders,andtoacquireasolidunderstandingofhowLeaveNoTracemightbeeffectivelyandefficientlyoverlaidonanddeployedintheAdirondackPark.
ThisreportisintendedtoserveasaguidingdocumentfortheAdirondackParkasmanagersandkeypartnersmovethroughtheprocessofintegratingLeaveNoTraceintooverallmanagementoftheParkwhereaneducationalapproachtovisitormanagementiswarranted.Educationismostsuccessfulwhenimplementedaspartofalargercomprehensivemanagementstrategy,andinconcertwithothermanagementtechniques,includinginfrastructure,staffing,anddirectintervention.Furthermore,whilethestrategies,techniques,andmethodsoutlinedinthisdocumenthavebeensuccessfullyutilizedinmanyparksandprotectedareasacrossthecountry,theseshouldbeconsideredastartingpointfortheAdirondackPark.Whenlocallandmanagerstailoreducationalandstewardshipeffortstotheirspecificenvironment,constituents,andvisitors,theeffortsaregenerallymoresuccessfulandgarnerbroaderbuy-infromthecommunityatlarge.Assuch,theCenterencouragesParkmanagersandkeypartnerstoviewthisreportasalivingdocumentthathasthepotentialtoprovideafoundationfromwhichinnovationandadaptationcanoccurtobestmeettheevolvingneedsoftheAdirondackParkforyearstocome.
![Page 3: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
TableofContents
AssessmentReportOverview .......................................................................................................................... 2
AdirondackParkOverview .............................................................................................................................. 5
NeedforEffectiveLeaveNoTraceEducation ................................................................................................. 7
AdirondackParkUsagePatternsandImpactsSurvey .................................................................................. 9 Overview .................................................................................................................................................................. 9 ExecutiveSummary ................................................................................................................................................. 9 ResultsSummary ................................................................................................................................................... 10 SurveyMethodology .............................................................................................................................................. 11 SurveyResults ........................................................................................................................................................ 11 DiscussionofSurveyResults .................................................................................................................................. 26
UnderstandingandManagingVisitors–LiteratureReview ....................................................................... 28 Introduction .......................................................................................................................................................... 28 EducationandInformation ................................................................................................................................... 28 EfficacyofVisitorEducation ................................................................................................................................. 30 DepreciativeBehaviors ......................................................................................................................................... 31 VisitorPerceptionsofImpacts .............................................................................................................................. 32 MessagingandSignage ......................................................................................................................................... 33 BarrierstoCompliance ......................................................................................................................................... 35 LeaveNoTrace ...................................................................................................................................................... 36 AttitudeTheory ..................................................................................................................................................... 37 ImplicationsforManagement–Keyfindingsfromtheliterature ....................................................................... 37 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................................. 38
LeaveNoTraceProgramImplementation–2020andBeyond .................................................................. 39
RecommendationsforManagingRecreation-relatedImpactsintheAdirondackParkandBuildingaCultureofWildlandsStewardship ................................................................................................................ 41 I.Management&PlanningRecommendations .................................................................................................... 41 II.Research&MonitoringRecommendations ...................................................................................................... 43 III.Tourism&MarketingRecommendations ....................................................................................................... 45 IV.SocialMediaRecommendations ...................................................................................................................... 48 V.Partnerships&CoordinationRecommendations ............................................................................................. 49
![Page 4: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
VI.GroupUse&Adirondack‘Challenges’Recommendations .............................................................................. 50 VII.Outreach&EducationRecommendations ..................................................................................................... 51 VIII.TrainingRecommendations .......................................................................................................................... 55 IX.Dept.ofEnvironmentalConservationRecommendations .............................................................................. 56 X.InfrastructureRecommendations ..................................................................................................................... 57
AdditionalRecommendedMethodsandTacticsforEducatingAdirondackParkVisitors ..................... 59
BenefitsofUsingLeaveNoTracefortheAdirondackPark ........................................................................ 62
PotentialResearch .......................................................................................................................................... 63 SampleMethodologies .......................................................................................................................................... 63 ResearchCouldAnswertheFollowingQuestions ................................................................................................. 64
ModelLeaveNoTraceLanguagetoAddressIssues ..................................................................................... 65
ExamplesofSignage,Brochures,andDigitalMedia .................................................................................... 71
Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 90
References ....................................................................................................................................................... 91
Appendices ...................................................................................................................................................... 96 AppendixA–LeaveNoTraceEthicsCardExamples ........................................................................................... 96 AppendixB–LeaveNoTraceResolution–SanJuanIslands,WA ....................................................................... 97 AppendixC–Whatarethe3-5mostpressingissuesonthelandsyoumanage? ................................................ 99 AppendixD–Arethereotherrecreation-relatedimpactsintheAdirondackParknotlistedabove? ............. 100 AppendixE–HowfamiliarareyouwiththetypicalAdirondackParkvisitor? ................................................ 101 AppendixF–Whatarethemainobjectivesforyourvolunteerprogram? ....................................................... 101 AppendixG–Whattypesofsitesrequireafee?Checkallthatapply. ............................................................... 102 AppendixH–WhatagenciesprovidelawenforcementonpubliclandsintheAdirondackPark? ................... 102 AppendixI–WhatareyourgoalsforaLeaveNoTraceprogramforthelandsyoumanage? ........................ 102 AppendixJ–HowwouldyouenvisionLeaveNoTraceinformationbeingdisseminatedtoAdirondackParkvisitors?Checkallthatapply. ............................................................................................................................. 104 AppendixK–PleaselistadditionalfeedbackorcommentsorfeedbackregardingLeaveNoTraceeffortsintheAdirondackPark. ................................................................................................................................................. 104
![Page 5: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
AdirondackParkOverviewTheAdirondackParkwascreatedin1892bytheStateofNewYork,effectivelyformingthelargestpubliclyprotectedareainthecontiguousUnitedStates.Atthetimeofitscreation,theAdirondackParkwasawildlandscapecontainingprodigiouswater,vastforests,andhighmountainpeaks.WhilethelandintheParkwasunderthreatfromloggingandcultivation,itwasalsopoisedforanincredibleconservationeffort,thelikesofwhichhadneverbeforebeenundertaken.ThoughtheAdirondackForestPreservewasestablishedin1885,itwasnotrecognizedasaconstitutionallyprotectedForeverWildareauntil1894,makingittheone-of-a-kindParkthatitistoday.OftheAdirondackPark's6millionacres,2.6millionacresareownedbyNewYorkState.Theremaining3.4millionacresareprivatelyowned.TheParkisalsohometoover100townsandvillages.ThereiscommonconfusionregardingthePark’sstatus–manythinkitisanationalpark.Regardlessofanyconfusion,thePark’smixofpublicandprivatelandallowsforconservationandcivilizationtoflourish.TheoriginalsurveyoroftheAdirondackParkwasVerplanckColvin,whoamongotherthings,wasatopographicalengineer.HisearlyworkinandfondnessoftheregionhelpedgenerateawarenessoftheneedtoprotecttheareawhichwouldeventuallybecometheAdirondackPark.Inthe1860s,Colvinspentmuchtimeexploringtheregion,andbythelate1860shedecidedageologicsurveyoftheareawasnecessary.ColvinappliedforfundsfromNewYorkStatein1872tocoverthecostsofthesurvey.Withagrantof$1,000,ColvinwasnamedSuperintendentoftheAdirondackSurvey,andtheworkbegan.BecauseofhisworkintheAdirondacks,hewasabletoexpressthegrowingneedtoconservethestate’swildestlands.ColvineventuallywasappointedasSuperintendentoftheNewYorkLandSurvey.HisworkinthispositionplayedasignificantroleintheestablishmentoftheAdirondackParkForestPreserve.ForestPreservelandcomprisesasignificantportionoftheAdirondackPark–2.6millionacres.ForestPreservelandhasspecificregulationsandlandusecodes,meaningthelandisdesignatedas“ForeverWild”undertheNewYorkStateConstitution,ArticleXIV.ForeverWildlandisdesignated“topreservetheexceptionalscenic,recreational,andecologicalvalue”inperpetuity.Formoreinformation,see:http://www.dec.ny.gov/lands/4960.htmlThislevelofprotectionfromtheStateensuresthattheselandswillnotbelogged,thatresourceprotectionwillbeprioritized,andthatlandswillofferexceptionalrecreationalopportunities.Thestate-ownedlandsintheParkconsistofhistoric,wilderness,canoe,primitive,wildforest,andadministrativelands.Oftheremaining3.4millionacresinthePark,theyareprivatelyowned(towns,villages,businesses,andfarms),andtheuseoftheselandsisoverseenandregulatedbytheAdirondackParkAgency.TheuniquenatureoftheAdirondackParkaddscomplexitytoconsiderationofrecreationalimpactsonseveralfronts.First,theterm“visitor”isnot,strictlyspeaking,accurateofmanyoftherecreationists.Manyareresidents,livingwithintheboundsofthePark,althoughvisitorstothepublicland.Second,unlikemanyofthefederallands,themandatefortheForestPreserveisnotequallyweightedbetweenrecreationandprotection.Theprimary
![Page 6: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
reasonforprotectionoftheForestPreservewasforpreservationofwaterqualityandtimber.RecreationisnotgivenequalweightintheNYSConstitution,orlater,intheAdirondackParkStateLandMasterPlan,althoughthislatterisadocumentthatinherentlydealswithrecreationmanagement.1Nor,indeed,doesrecreationappearinthemissionstatementoftheagencychargedwithmanagingtheForestPreserve:ThemissionoftheNYSDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservationis"Toconserve,improveandprotectNewYork'snaturalresourcesandenvironmentandtoprevent,abateand controlwater,landandairpollution,inordertoenhancethehealth,safetyandwelfareofthepeopleofthestateandtheiroveralleconomicandsocialwell-being."Asistrueofmanyprotectedlandscapes,astakeholdergroupleftoutofdiscussionofrecreationalimpactsisthenon-usegroup(thosewhomaynevervisitaprotectedlandscape,butvalueitsexistence)2.Whileprotectionofalandscapeincludesprotectiononbehalfofthisgroup,thefocusofthisreportismitigationofrecreationalimpactsthrougheducation.Assuch,protectiononbehalfoffuturegenerationsandnon-visitorsisimplied,butotherwisenotexplicit.TheParkhas30,000milesofstreamsandriversaswellas3,000pondsandlakes,makingitidealforwater-basedrecreationincludingpaddlingandangling.Additionally,thereare46mountainpeaksintheAdirondacksthatareover3,900feetinelevationknownastheHighPeaks.ThehighestoftheHighPeaksisMountMarcy,whichisalsothetallestpeakinthestateat5,343feet.HikingandbackpackingarepopularactivitiesintheParkwhichpossessesmorethan2,000milesoftrails.Year-roundrecreationoccursintheParkincludingcrosscountryanddownhillskiing,snowmobiling,andsnowshoeingduringthewintermonths.GiventhePark’sproximityto60millionpeople,itdrawsvisitorsfromacrosstheregion.*Thisinformationwasadaptedfrom:AdirondackRegionalTourismCouncil.AbouttheAdirondackPark.(n.d.).RetrievedJanuary7,2020fromhttps://visitadirondacks.com/about/adirondack-park
1("Ifthereisaunifyingthemetotheclassificationsystem,itisthattheprotectionandpreservationofthenaturalresourcesofthestatelandswithintheParkmustbeparamount.Humanuseandenjoymentofthoselandsshouldbepermittedandencouraged,solongastheresourcesintheirphysicalandbiologicalcontextandtheirsocialorpsychologicalaspectsarenotdegraded"(APSLMP1987)2https://www.nationalparks.org/connect/blog/beyond-visit-how-we-value-national-parks
![Page 7: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
NeedforEffectiveLeaveNoTraceEducationDecadesofpublicinvestmenthaveyieldedmillionsofacresoflandsetasidefortheprotectionandpreservationofnaturalresources,withrecreationencouragedaswell—theAdirondackPark.Variousinitiativeshavenotonlyprovidedanunparalleledcatalystforcreatingworld-classrecreationalopportunitiesintheregion,buttheyhavealsocreatedanexpectationoftangiblepublicbenefit.ThosecurrentlyengagedinmanagingthepubliclandswithintheAdirondackParkhavealegalmandateintheNewYorkStateConstitutiontoprotectthenaturalresourcesoftheForestPreserve.3Thisisnotinconflictwithagoalofprovidingaccesstoexceptionalrecreationalopportunities,4particularlyifcriticalminimumimpacteducationandprogrammingdirectlyrelatedtooutdoorrecreationandresponsibleenjoymentoftheParkisalsoprovided.LeaveNoTraceinformationhasthecapacitytobeasubstantialandmeaningfulpartofthisgoal.Bydevelopingandprovidinglocally-tailored,Park-specificandactivity-basedLeaveNoTraceinformation,recreation-relatedresourceandsocialimpactscanbeavoided,minimized,ormitigatedintheAdirondackPark.LeaveNoTraceisagloballyrecognizededucationprogram,backedbyscience.IntheUnitedStates,ithasbeenadoptedbyallfivefederallandmanagementagencies(USForestService,NationalParkService,BureauofLandManagement,USFishandWildlife,ArmyCorpsofEngineers)aswellastheAssociationofStateParks.ItiswidelyimplementedacrosspubliclandsfromsmallmunicipalparkstolargeWildernessareas.Researchhasdemonstratedisefficacyinreducingrecreation-relatedimpactsthroughbehaviorchange.Usingconsistent,uniformlanguagebothincreasesthemessagepenetrationamongstrecreationistsanddecreasestheburdenonlandmanagerstocreateuniqueeducationalprogramming.ResearchincludingsurveysofrecreationistsfromacrossfederalandstatelandsshowsthattheLeaveNoTracemessageiswidelyrecognized.AdoptingthismessagingallowsotherareastoamplifyamessagethatAdirondacklandmanagerswantvisitorstohear.Consistencyinmessagingincreasesthelikelihoodofsuccessinchangingvisitorbehavior.Additionally,asvisitorstootherworld-classrecreationaldestinationsareaccustomedtoseeingLeaveNoTraceasthepreferredmessage,reiterationofthatmessagereinforcesboththemessageandtheworld-classnatureoftheAdirondackPark.DefiningandbettercommunicatingasustainablerecreationparadigmforParkvisitorsisgoingtobecomeincreasinglyimportantintheyearstocome.Parkmanagersandpartners
3ArticleXIV,Section4,NYSConstitution:“Thepolicyofthestateshallbetoconserveandprotectitsnaturalresourcesandscenicbeauty”4“..[TheAdirondackPark]wasmadeawildresortinwhichnatureisgivenfreerein.Itsusesforhealthandpleasuremustnotbeinconsistentwithitspreservationasforestlandsinawildstate.Itmustalwaysretainthecharacterofawilderness”Assn.forProtectionofAdirondacksv.MacDonald,228App.Div.73,81(N.Y.App.Div.1930)
![Page 8: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
needtoaddressexpectationsforpublicusewhilesimultaneouslyprotectingthecriticalnaturalandculturalresourcesfoundinthePark.VisitorsneedaclearunderstandingofboththeexperiencesavailabletothemintheParkaswellasappropriateandresponsiblebehaviorwhileenjoyingthesesharedresources.
![Page 9: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
AdirondackParkUsagePatternsandImpactsSurvey Inordertoobtainbaselinedataon,andperceptionsof,recreationaluseandrelatedimpactsintheAdirondackPark,CenterstaffsurveyedpertinentParklandmanagementagencyandNGOstaff,keystakeholders,andotherssuchastrailclubrepresentativesormembers.ThesurveydatayieldedconsistentresultsacrossthespectrumregardingperceptionsofcurrentusageoftheParkandtheassociatedimpacts.
Overview ThefollowingreportsummarizestheresultsofasurveyadministeredbytheLeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics(theCenter)AugustandSeptemberof2019.Thepurposeofthissurveywastocollectdataregarding:
1) PerceptionsofcurrentrecreationtrendsandpatternsinthePark2) Perceptionsofrecreation-relatedimpactsinthePark3) Currentmanagementtechniquesbeingusedtoaddresstheseimpacts4) Potentialdevelopmentoflocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogram(s)
Thefollowingisasummaryofthesurveydata.Open-endedresponsescanbefoundintheappendicesofthisreport.
ExecutiveSummary SurveyresultsindicatethatrespondentsfeelthereareseveralsignificantissuesfacingtheAdirondackPark.Furthermore,fourofthereportedissueswerecategorizedassevereintermsoflevelofimpact.However,surveyrespondentsindicatedthattherearenumerouspotentialopportunitiestoutilizeLeaveNoTraceeducationthroughavarietyofmeanstoimproveconditionsinthePark.Afewofthemostsalientfindingsinclude:
• Hiking,flatwateractivities,wintersports,campingindevelopedsites,andpeakbaggingwerereportedtobethetopfiverecreationalpursuitsintheAdirondackPark.
• Overuse,crowding,traildegradation,trailerosion,humanwaste,petwaste,parkingissues,andunpreparedvisitorswerelistedasthemostpressingissuesfacingthePark.
• Improperdisposalofhumanwaste,trailimpacts,increasedvisitationduetosocialmedia,andparkingissueswereallratedsevereintermsoftheimpactresultingfromtheseproblems.
• AvarietyoftechniquesarecurrentlyinusetoeducateParkvisitorsaboutenjoyingtheParkresponsibly,whichincludeLeaveNoTraceeducation,printededucationalmaterials,web-basedinformation,signage,anddirectvisitoreducation.
• WhenaskedwhetherornotthedevelopmentofaPark-specificLeaveNoTraceprogramwasaproactiveeffortorinresponsetoincreasedrecreation-relatedimpacts,over75%ofrespondentsindicateditwasbothproactiveandreactionary.
![Page 10: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
• RespondentsindicatedthatthegoalsofafocusedLeaveNoTraceprogramfortheparkinclude:educatingvisitorsaboutprotectingthePark,reducing/preventingimpacttothePark,andpromotionofaconsistentLeaveNoTrace/stewardshipmessage.
ResultsSummary Surveyrespondentsweregivenalistof22recreationalactivitiesandaskedtoreportwhichwerethemostpopularintheAdirondackPark.Respondentsindicatedthathiking,flatwateractivities,wintersports,campingindevelopedsites,andpeakbaggingwerethefivemostpopularactivitiesintheAdirondackPark.RespondentswerealsoaskedaboutthemostpressingissuesfacingtheAdirondackPark.Thoughthiswasanopen-responsequestion,themajorityofsurveyparticipantswroteinthefollowing:overuse/crowding,traildegradation/trailerosion,humanandpetwaste,parkingissuesandunpreparedvisitors.Respondentswerealsogivenalistof20recreation-relatedimpactsandwereinstructedtorateeachashavingNoimpact,Slightimpact,Moderateimpact,ExtensiveorSevereimpact.Improperdisposalofhumanwaste,trailimpacts,increasedvisitationduetosocialmediaandparkingissueswereallselectedbythemajorityofrespondentsashavingaSevereimpact.Surveyrespondentswereaskedtoreportonthemanagementtechniquescurrentlyinusetoaddressrecreation-relatedimpacts.Theywereprovidedwithalistof15mitigationmethodsandaskedtonoteifeachwasCurrentlyinuse,UsedinthepastorNeverused.Eachmethodwasreportedasbeingcurrentlyinusebythemajorityofrespondentswiththeexceptionoflimitingaccessandpermitsystem.Fivemethodswereselectedbyover90%oftherespondentsincludingLeaveNoTraceinformation,printededucationalmaterials,websiteinformation,signage/kiosksandvisitoreducation.WhenaskedhowfrequentlyLeaveNoTracewasusedintheAdirondackPark,48%ofrespondentssaiditwasUsedoccasionally.NoneofthesurveyrespondentsindicatedthatLeaveNoTracewasNeverused.SurveyrespondentswereaskedhowfamiliartheyarewiththetypicalAdirondackParkvisitor.Themajorityofrespondents(58.5%)saidthattheywereExtremelyfamiliarwiththetypicalvisitortotheAdirondackPark.Respondentswerealsoaskedwhethertheiragencyororganizationadministersavolunteerprogram.Nearlythree-quartersofthesurveyrespondents(72.5%)indicatedthattheirorganizationadministersavolunteerprogram.Whenaskedinanopen-responsequestionwhatthemainobjectivesoftheirvolunteerprogramwere,mostoftheresponsesfocusedontrailwork/maintenance,stewardshipandeducation.RespondentswereaskedwhetherornottherewereanyusefeesintheAdirondackPark.Themajorityofsurveyrespondents(92.7%)indicatedthattherewereareasintheParkwithusefees.Whenaskedtoreportwhattypeofsitesrequiredfeesatleasthalfoftherespondentsreportedthatcampgrounds,dayusesitesandtrailheadparkingareashadusefees.Whenaskedwhetherornottherewasalawenforcementpresenceinthe
![Page 11: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Adirondackpark,100%ofrespondentsindicated,Yes,therewas.Additionally,100%ofrespondentsreportedtheDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation(DEC)wasanagencyprovidingalawenforcementpresencefortheAdirondackPark.Thefinalportionofthesurveyfocusedonthepotentialfutureofalocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogramintheAdirondackPark.First,respondentswereaskedwhetherornottheybelievedthatthedevelopmentoftheprogramwasbeingusedtoaddressexistingissuesorifitwasaproactiveeffort.Over75%ofrespondentsbelievedthatthedevelopmentofaLeaveNoTraceprogramwasbothaproactiveeffortaswellasonetoaddressexistingissues.SurveyrespondentswereaskedtowriteindesiredgoalsforaLeaveNoTraceprogram.Thoughthiswasanopen-responsequestionmanyoftheresponsesfocusedoneducatingvisitorsaboutprotectingthepark,reducing/preventingimpacttothepark,andpromotionofaconsistentLeaveNoTrace/stewardshipmessage.Themajorityofrespondents(87.8%)reportedthattheiragencyororganizationhadstaffthataretrainedinLeaveNoTrace.Additionally,over72%oftheseagencieshadstaffthathadcompletedaLeaveNoTrace5-dayMasterEducatorCourseandanother44.4%reportedhavingstaffthathadparticipatedina2-dayLeaveNoTraceTrainerCourse.SurveyrespondentswereaskedhowtheyenvisionedLeaveNoTracebeingdisseminatedtovisitors.Theywereprovidedwithalistof14differentmethodsofdisseminationandaskedtoselectallthatapply.Sixofthe14methodswereselectedbyatleast90%ofsurveyrespondentsasbeingawaytheyenvisionLeaveNoTracebeingdisseminatedtoparkvisitors.Thesemethodsincludedsocialmedia,printmedia,website,localusergroupsandvolunteers.Finally,surveyrespondentswereaskedwhattypeofagencyororganizationtheyworkedorvolunteeredfor.Themajorityofrespondents(43.9%)workedforaStateagency.Another22%ofrespondentsworkedforNon-governmentalorganizationsand14.6%reportedworkingforaTrailorganizationorclub.
SurveyMethodology Thissurveywasfacilitatedusingtheonlinesurveyplatformwww.SurveyGizmo.com.ThesurveywasadministeredfromAugust19-September25in2019.ThesamplewasaconveniencesamplewhichwasgeneratedbystafffromboththeAdirondackCouncilandtheAdirondackMountainClub.Thesurveylinkwasdistributedtoover60individualsthroughouttheregion,andatotalof44surveyresponsesweregenerated.Thissurveywasnotpassword-protected.
SurveyResults1. PleaseselectthefivemostpopularrecreationalactivitiesintheAdirondackPark.Surveyrespondentsweregivenalistof18recreationalactivitiesincludingHiking,Mountainbiking,Picnicking,Naturephotography,Bicycling,Campingindevelopedsites,Rockclimbing,Backpacking,Angling,Hunting,Birding,Wintersports(skiing,snowshoeing,sledding),ATV/OHVuse,Motorizedboating,Dispersedcamping(notindevelopedsites),Peak
![Page 12: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
bagging,Flatwateractivities(swimming,standuppaddleboarding,canoeing,kayaking)andOtherinwhichtheycouldwriteinadditionalactivitiesnotincludedonthelist.Fromthis
listrespondentswereaskedtoselectthefivemostpopularactivitiestakingplaceinAdirondackPark.Hikingwasselectedasbeingthemostpopularactivitywith100%ofrespondentsselectingitwithinthefivemostpopularactivities.ThiswasfollowedbyFlatwateractivities(swimming,standuppaddleboarding,canoeing,kayaking),Wintersports(skiing,snowshoeing,sledding),CampingindevelopedsitesandPeakbaggingwerealsolistedinthetopfiverecreationactivitiesinthePark.RespondentswerealsogiventhechancetoselectOtherandwriteinotherpopularrecreationalactivitiesthatwerenotincludedinthelist.Ofthosewhowroteinaresponse,allrespondedwithsnowmobiling.Thesewriteinanswerscanbefoundintheappendices.2. Whatarethe3-5mostpressingrecreation-relatedissuesfacingtheAdirondack
Park?Thisquestionwasanopen-responsequestioninwhichrespondentscouldwriteinthe3-5mostpressingissuesonthelandsinAdirondackPark.Theanswerstothisquestioncanbefoundintheappendices.However,themajorityoftheresponsesrelatedtooveruse/crowding,traildegradation/trailerosion,humanandpetwaste,parkingandunderpreparedvisitors.
![Page 13: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
3. Ratethefollowingrecreation-relatedimpactsintheAdirondackPark.Respondentsweregivenalistof22recreation-relatedimpacts(seetablebelow)andwereaskedtorateeachoneaseitherhavingNoimpact,Slightimpact,Moderateimpact,Extensiveimpact,SevereimpactorNotapplicable. No
ImpactSlightImpact
ModerateImpact
ExtensiveImpact
SevereImpact
Notapplicable
Petwaste 0(0.0%)
16(40.0%)
17(42.5%)
7(17.5%)
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
Damagetovegetation
0(0.0%)
4(9.8%)
9(22.0%)
22(53.7%)
6(14.6%)
0(0.0%)
Trash 0(0.0%)
5(12.2%)
16(39.0%)
14(34.1%)
6(14.6%)
0(0.0%)
Visitorconflicts
1(2.4%)
12(29.3%)
24(58.5%)
4(9.8%)
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
Inappropriateuseoftechnology(geocaching,drones,etc.)
1(2.4%)
13(31.7%)
18(43.9%)
6(14.6%)
3(7.3%)
0(0.0%)
Invasivespecies
0(0.0%)
2(4.9%)
17(41.5%)
10(24.4%)
12(29.3%)
0(0.0%)
Improperdisposalofhumanwaste
0(0.0%)
3(7.5%)
11(27.5%)
11(27.5%)
15(37.5%)
0(0.0%)
Publicsafetyissues
0(0.0%)
7(17.1%)
11(26.8%)
13(31.7%)
9(22.0%)
1(2.4%)
Petmanagement
1(2.5%)
16(40.0%)
16(40.0%)
6(15.0%)
1(2.5%)
0(0.0%)
Pollutionofwatersources
0(0.0%)
13(31.7%)
21(51.2%)
6(14.6%)
1(2.4%)
0(0.0%)
Damagetoculturalorhistoricalfeatures
1(2.4%)
24(58.5%)
10(24.4%)
5(12.2%)
1(2.4%)
0(0.0%)
Campfireimpacts
0(0.0%)
15(36.6%)
16(39.0%)
7(17.1%)
2(4.9%)
1(2.4%)
Impactstowildlife
0(0.0%)
11(26.8%)
16(39.0%)
12(29.3%)
2(4.9%)
0(0.0%)
Trailimpacts 0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
8(19.%)
13(31.7%)
20(48.8%)
0(0.0%)
ATV/OHVImpacts
0(0.0%)
16(39.0%)
15(36.6%
6(14.6%)
4(9.8%)
0(0.0%)
![Page 14: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
NoImpact
SlightImpact
ModerateImpact
ExtensiveImpact
SevereImpact
Notapplicable
Increasedimpactsduetosocialmedia
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
10(24.4%)
15(36.6%)
14(34.1%)
2(4.9%)
Offtrailtraveldamage
2(4.9%)
18(43.9%)
9(22.0%)
9(22.0%)
3(7.3%)
0(0.0%)
Stock(horse,llama,etc.)impacts
16(39.0%)
21(51.2%)
3(7.3%)
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
1(2.4%)
Undesignatedcamping
3(7.3%)
24(58.5%)
11(26.8%)
2(4.9%)
0(0.0%)
1(2.4%)
Shootingimpacts
14(35.0%)
20(50.0%)
4(10.0%)
0(0.0%)
1(2.5%)
1(2.5%)
Increasedvisitationduetosocialmedia
0(0.0%)
1(2.4%)
5(12.2%)
16(39.0%)
18(43.9%)
1(2.4%)
Parkingissues
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
6(14.6%)
16(39.0%)
19(46.3%)
0(0.0%)
Trailimpactswereratedashavingtheheaviestimpactwithover48%ofsurveyrespondentsratingthemasSevere.ThiswasfollowedcloselybyParkingissues(46.3%)andIncreasedvisitationduetosocialmedia(43.9%)whichwerebothratedbymorethan40%ofrespondentsashavingaSevereimpactonthePark.Finally,53.7%ofrespondentsratedDamagetovegetationasanExtensiveimpactintheAdirondackPark.4. Arethereanyotherrecreation-relatedimpactsnotlistedabove?Respondentswereaskedtoreportonotherrecreation-relatedimpactsthatwerenotincludedintheoriginallist.Thisquestionwasanoptional,open-responsequestionManyofthe16responsestothisquestionaddressedtheDiminishedwildernesscharacterofthePark.Afulllistofresponsescanbeseenintheappendices.5. Howdoesyouragencyororganizationaddressrecreation-relatedimpactsinthe
AdirondackPark?Surveyrespondentsweregivenalistof15mitigationmethods(seetablebelow)andaskedtoselectwhethereachisCurrentlyinuse,Usedinthepast,orNeverused.Additionally,surveyrespondentsweregiventheoptiontowriteinothermitigationmethods.
![Page 15: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
Currentlyinuse Usedinthepast NeverusedInterpretativeprograms
26(68.4%)
4(10.5%)
8(21.1%)
Lawenforcement 25(67.6%)
1(2.7%)
11(29.7%)
LeaveNoTraceinformation
37(92.5%)
0(0.0%)
3(7.5%)
Limitingaccess 13(34.2%)
3(7.9%)
22(57.9%)
Permitsystem 8(21.1%)
3(7.9%)
27(71.1%)
Printededucationalmaterials
36(92.3%)
1(2.6%)
2(5.1%)
Websiteinformation 35(92.1%)
2(5.3%)
1(2.6%)
Signage/kiosks 37(94.9%)
0(0.0%)
2(5.1%)
Stafftraining 34(85.0%)
2(5.0%)
4(10.0%)
Issuingcitations 24(63.2%)
0(0.0%)
14(36.8%)
Visitoreducation 39(100.0%)
0(0.0%)
0(0.0%)
Volunteerprograms 34(87.2%)
1(2.6%)
4(10.3%)
Youtheducation 30(76.9%)
0(0.0%)
9(23.1%)
Areaclosures 12(33.3%)
7(19.4%)
17(47.2%)
Publicoutreach 33(84.6%)
3(7.7%)
3(7.7%)
Ofthe15mitigationmethods,12werereportedbythemajorityofsurveyrespondentsasbeingCurrentlyinuse.ThemostpopularmethodsofmitigationwereVisitoreducation(100%),Websiteinfo(94.9%),LeaveNoTraceinformation(92.5%)andPrintededucationalmaterials(92.3%).Permitsystems,LimitingaccessandAreaclosuresweretheonlymethodsreportedbythemajorityofrespondentsasNeverused.Therewereonlyfourwrite-inanswersforadditionalwaysrecreation-relatedimpactswerebeingaddressed.TheywereLandconservation,Investmentininfrastructure,Publiccommentletters&advocacy,Trailmaintenanceandconstruction,andtrailheadandSummitstewards.
![Page 16: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
6. TowhatextentisLeaveNoTraceinformationcurrentlyutilizedtoaddressrecreation-relatedimpactsintheAdirondackPark?
RespondentswereaskedtoreporttheextenttowhichLeaveNoTraceisbeingutilizedtoaddressrecreationrelatedimpactsintheAdirondackPark.TheyweregiventheoptionsrangingfromNeverused,Almostneverused,Usedoccasionally/sometimes,Usedalmosteverytime,Frequently/extensivelyused,orIdon’tknow.
Nearlyhalfofrespondents(48%)reportedthatLeaveNoTracewasUsedoccasionallytoaddressrecreation-relatedimpacts.Usedextensively(25%)andUsedalmosteverytime(23%)werealsoreported.NorespondentsindicatedthatLeaveNoTracewasNeverusedorAlmostneverused.7. HowfamiliarareyouwiththetypicalAdirondackParkvisitor?
SurveyrespondentswereaskedtoreporthowfamiliartheywerewiththetypicalAdirondackParkvisitor.RespondentsweregiventheoptionofNotfamiliaratall,Slightlyfamiliar,Somewhatfamiliar,Moderatelyfamiliar,orExtremelyfamiliar.TheywerealsogiventheoptiontoselectOtherandwriteinaresponse.Afulllistofresponsescanbeseenintheappendices.
![Page 17: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Themajorityofrespondents(58.5%)reportedthattheywereExtremelyfamiliarwiththetypicalvisitortoAdirondackPark.Another22%saidthattheywereModeratelyfamiliar.Overall,surveyrespondentswerefamiliarwiththeaveragevisitorwithnorespondentsindicatingthattheywereNotatallfamiliarwiththetypicalvisitor.8. IstheAdirondackParkopentocommercialuse(outfitter/guide,summercamps,
organizedgroups,etc.)?SurveyRespondentswereaskedtoreportwhetherornotthelandstheymanageorworkonareopentocommercialusebygroupssuchasoutfitters/guides,summercamps,orotherorganizedgroups.Alloftherespondents(100%)reported,Yes,theAdirondackParkisopentocommercialuse.ThisindicatesbroadunderstandingofcurrentuseoftheParkbycommercialentities.9. Doesyouragencyororganizationadministeravolunteerprogram?Surveyrespondentswereaskediftheiragencyororganizationadministersavolunteerprogram.TheyweregiventheoptionofselectingYes,No,orNotsure.
![Page 18: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
Over72%ofrespondentsreported,Yes,thattheagencyororganizationstheyworkforadministerssometypeofvolunteerprogram.Theremaining27.5%reportedthattheiragencydidnothaveavolunteerprogram.10. Whatarethemainobjectivesforyourvolunteerprogram?Thisquestionwasanopen-endedquestioninwhichsurveyrespondentscouldlistthemainobjectivesofthevolunteerprogramsonthelandstheymanage.MostoftheresponsescenteredaroundTrailwork/maintenance,StewardshipandEducation.Afulllistofresponsescanbefoundintheappendices.11. ArethereusefeesatanysitesintheAdirondackPark?*SurveyrespondentswereaskedwhetherornottherewereanyusefeesatanyareasinthePark.TheywereabletoselectfromtheresponsesYes,No,andNotsure.*Note:WithintheAdirondackParkpermits,fees,andreservationsarerequiredatsomePrimitiveandStateLandcampsites,andatsomefrontcountryandbackcountrylocations.Atotherbackcountryorroadsidesitestheyarefreeandavailablefirst-come-firstserved.
![Page 19: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Themajorityofsurveyrespondents(92.7%)reportedYes,therewereusefeesatsitesinAdirondackPark.Only5%ofrespondentsreportedNotherewerenotusefeesatsitesintheAdirondackPark.12. Whattypesofsitesrequireafee?Checkallthatapply.SurveyrespondentswereaskedtoreportwhattypesofsitesintheAdirondackParkhadfees.TheyweregiventheoptionsofDayusesites,Campgrounds,Trailheadparking,anopen-endedresponseforOtherandaskedtocheckallthatapply.
![Page 20: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Themajorityofsurveyrespondents(89.5%)reportedthatCampgroundsintheAdirondackParkhadfees.Additionally,71.1%ofrespondentssaidthatDayusesitesintheparkhadfees.Over23%ofrespondentsselectedOther.Afulllistofthoseresponsescanbefoundintheappendices.13. IstherealawenforcementpresenceintheAdirondackPark?SurveyrespondentswereaskedwhetherornottherewasalawenforcementpresenceintheAdirondackPark.TheywereabletoselectfromYes,NoandNotSure.AllofthesurveyrespondentsselectedYesthereisalawenforcementpresenceintheAdirondackPark.14. WhatagenciesprovidelawenforcementonpubliclandsintheAdirondackPark?
Checkallthatapply.SurveyrespondentswereaskedwhatagenciesprovidelawenforcementintheAdirondackPark.TheywereabletoselectallthatapplyfromDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation(DEC),Policedepartment,Localsheriff,Federalagency,NotsureandanoptionforOtherinwhichtheycouldwriteinanagency.RespondentswereabletoselectalltheagenciesthatapplytothePark.
![Page 21: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
AllofthesurveyrespondentsreportedthattheDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservation(DEC)providesalawenforcementpresenceintheAdirondackPark.ThemajorityofsurveyrespondentsalsoreportedthataPolicedepartment(60%)andtheLocalsheriff(52.5%)providelawenforcement.FouroutoffiveoftheresponsesforOtherwereStatePoliceorStateTroopers.AfulllistofresponsestoOthercanbefoundintheappendices.15. Isdevelopingalocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogramaproactiveeffortoris
thegoaltoaddressexistingrecreation-relatedissuesintheAdirondackPark?Surveyrespondentswereaskedwhetherornottheybelievedthatdevelopingalocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogramisaproactiveeffortorgoingtobeusedtoaddressexistingissues.RespondentsweregiventheoptionofselectingtheLeaveNoTraceprogramisgoingtobeusedasProactiveeffort,Addressexistingissues,Both,NotSure,andOtherwithawrite-inoption.
![Page 22: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Themajorityofsurveyrespondents(75.6%)believethatthedevelopmentofalocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogramisbothaProactiveeffortandbeingusedtoAddressexistingissues.Only2.4%reportedtheywereNotsurewhetheritwasaproactiveeffortorworkingtoaddressexistingissues.NosurveyrespondentsansweredOther.16. WhatareyourgoalsforaLeaveNoTraceprogramfortheAdirondackPark?Thisquestionwasanopen-endedquestioninwhichsurveyrespondentscouldwriteintheirperceivedgoalsforaLeaveNoTraceprogramfortheAdirondackPark.MostofthereportedgoalsweregenerallyrelatedtoEducatingvisitorsaboutprotectingthepark,Reducing/preventingimpacttothepark,andPromotionofaconsistentLeaveNoTrace/stewardshipmessage.Afulllistofresponsescanbefoundintheappendices.17. DoesyouragencyororganizationhavestafftrainedinLeaveNoTrace?SurveyrespondentswereaskedwhetherornottheiragencyororganizationhadstafftrainedinLeaveNoTrace.TheyweregiventheoptionofselectingfromYes,No,Notsure,andOther,awrite-inoption.
![Page 23: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Themajorityofrespondents(87.8%)indicatedthattheiragencyororganizationhadstaffwhoweretrainedinLeaveNoTrace.Only9.8%reportedthattheydidnothaveanytrainedstaff.NosurveyrespondentsansweredwithOther.18. Whatisthelevelofstafftraining?Checkallthatapply.SurveyrespondentswereaskedwhatlevelofLeaveNoTracetrainingtheirstaffhavegonethrough.RespondentswereaskedtoselectallthatappliedfromMasterEducator,TrainerandAwareness.
![Page 24: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Themostcommoncourse(72.2%)thatrespondentsreportedtheirstaffhavingcompletedwasthe5-dayLeaveNoTraceMasterEducatorcourse.ThiswasfollowedcloselybytheLeaveNoTraceAwarenesscoursewith69.4%reportingthatstafffromtheiragencyhadcompletedthisleveloftraining.Only44.4%ofrespondentsindicatedthatstaffhadcompletedthe2-dayLeaveNoTraceTrainercoursewithintheiragencyororganization.19. HowwouldyouenvisionLeaveNoTraceinformationbeingdisseminatedto
AdirondackParkvisitors?Checkallthatapply.SurveyrespondentswereaskedhowtheyenvisionedthatLeaveNoTracewouldbedisseminatedtothevisitingpublic.Theyweregiven14optionsincludingaresponseforOther.Respondentswereabletocheckasmanythatappliedfrom:Socialmedia,Printmedia,Website,ChamberofCommerce,Localusergroups(e.g.hikingclub)Localmerchants,Volunteers,Signage,Maps,Guidebooks,Otherprintedmaterials,Agencystaff,Non-governmentalorganizationsandOther.
![Page 25: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
Socialmedia(97.6%)andPrintmedia(97.6%)weretiedasthemostpopularmethodsrespondentsenvisionedfordisseminatingLeaveNoTracetothepublic.ThiswasfollowedcloselybyWebsite(95.1%),Localusergroups(e.g.hikingclubs)(95.1%)andAgencystaff(95.1%).Additionally,over90%ofrespondentssuggestedVolunteersasamethodfordisseminatingLeaveNoTraceinformation.Afulllistofresponsescanbeseenintheappendices.20. Whattypeofagencydoyouworkorvolunteerfor?SurveyrespondentswereaskedwhattypeofagencytheyworkorvolunteerforTheywereaskedtoselectfromeightagencytypesincludingonefill-in-the-blankoptionforOther.TheywereabletoselectfromStateagency,Non-governmentalorganization,Township,Business,Tourismentity,TrailorganizationorclubandCollegeoruniversity.
![Page 26: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Themajorityofsurveyrespondents(43.9%)reportedthattheyworkforaStateagency.Another22%reportedworkingforaNon-governmentalorganizationand14.6%foraTrailorganizationorclub.Onlytworespondents(4.8%)workedforaBusinessorTourismentity.21. PleaselistadditionalcommentsorfeedbackregardingLeaveNoTraceeffortsin
theAdirondackPark.Surveyrespondentsweregivenablankopen-responsequestioninwhichtheycouldincludeanycommentstheyhadaboutfutureLeaveNoTraceeffortsintheAdirondackPark.Elevenindividualsrespondedtothisquestion.Afulllistofresponsescanbefoundintheappendices.
DiscussionofSurveyResultsThepurposeofthissurveywastocollectdatainregardstotheneedsofalocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogramfortheAdirondackPark.Thiswasdoneusingquestionsthatfocusonrecreation-relatedimpacts,currentmethodsandprogramsbeingusedtoaddresstheseimpacts,andstakeholderbeliefsaboutthedevelopmentofaLeaveNoTraceprogramfortheAdirondackPark.SurveyresultsrevealedthatmanyoftheimpactsthreateningtheAdirondackParkcouldbeeffectivelyaddressedwithaLeaveNoTraceprogram.TheimpactsreportedasSevereincludedImproperdisposalofhumanwaste,Trailimpacts,andimpactsfrom
![Page 27: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
Increasedvisitationduetosocialmedia.OtherimpactsincludingParkingissuesmayneedtobeaddressedwithothermethods,thoughLeaveNoTracemessagingcouldhelptomitigatesomeoftheseissues.Currently,LeaveNoTraceinformationisbeingutilizedinvaryingdegreesintheAdirondackPark.However,thereisasignificantopportunitytofurtherincorporateLeaveNoTraceintomanyoftheprogramsandmanagementstrategiesintheParkinamorecomprehensivemanner.Suchmessagingandpublicoutreachcouldbefurtherintegratedintovisitoreducation,websiteinformation,printededucationalmaterials,agencyandvolunteertraining,andsignage/kiosks.GiventhattheAdirondackParkisopentocommercialusebygroupssuchasoutfitters/guides,summercampsandotherorganizedgroups,ensuringthesegroupsareteachingandpracticingLeaveNoTracewhileintheParkiscriticalforreducingimpacts.Additionally,thereisalawenforcementpresencebytheNYDepartmentofEnvironmentalConservationinthePark,whichisacriticalcomponentoftheoverallmanagementstrategy,andshouldfunctionintandemwithLeaveNoTraceeducationaleffortsforoverallsuccess.UsingLeaveNoTracetoaddressissuesthatarebestsuitedtoaneducationalapproach(forunskilled,uninformed,andcarelessbehaviors),whilereservinglawenforcementeffortswhereneededcanbeaneffectiveandefficientstrategy(forillegalactions).Thedevelopmentofalocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceprogramisviewedasbothaproactiveeffortaswelloneintendedtoaddressimpactsalreadyfoundinthePark.ThesurveyresultsindicatedthatLeaveNoTraceinformationshouldbeincorporatedintosocialmedia,printmedia,andagencyororganizationwebsites.TheeffortshouldalsostrivetoeducatevolunteersandstakeholderstaffaboutLeaveNoTraceskillsandethics,andhowtocommunicatetheseeffectivelytoparkrecreationists.Thistypeoflocally-tailoredprogramshouldeducaterecreationalusersaboutprotectingtheParkandprovideinformationonhowtoreduceimpacts.UsingLeaveNoTraceinformationacrossallagenciesandorganizationswillleadtogreaterconsistencyandcontinualreinforcementofsalientmessagestoParkvisitorsandresidentsalike.
![Page 28: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
UnderstandingandManagingVisitors–LiteratureReview
IntroductionContemporarymanagersoflandsusedbythepublicforrecreationfacecountlessandcomplexmanagementchallenges.Fromexternalthreatssuchasdevelopmenttoincreasingrecreationaluse,manylandmanagersmuststrikeabalancebetweenresourceprotectionandtheprovisionofrecreationalopportunities.WithintheAdirondackPark,legalmandatesclearlyputtheprotectionofresourcesastheprimarygoal.However,resourcedegradationduetoinappropriatevisitorbehaviorcontinuestobeasignificantconcernformanagers.Thoughnumerousparksandprotectedareashavearecreationmandate,resourcedegradationduetoinappropriatevisitorbehaviorcontinuestobeasignificantconcernformanagers(Leung&Marion,2000;Taff,Newman,Bright,&Vagias,2011;Vagias&Powell,2010).Inlightofthefactthatminimalrecreationalusecancausesubstantialimpacts,especiallysincemostimpactsarecumulativeovertime,landmanagersmustutilizeanarrayoftacticstoreducetheseimpacts(Hammitt,Cole,&Monz,2015;Leung&Marion,2000;Marion,Leung,Eagleston&Burroughs,2016).
Often,landmanagersdealwithresourceandsocialimpactsthroughtwoprimarystrategies:indirectstrategiessuchaseducationand/ordirectstrategiessuchasenforcement(Hendee&Dawson,2002;Martin,Marsolais,&Rolloff,2009).Directmanagementapproaches,includingfines,regulationsorsitemanagement,tendtobeexpensiveandpossiblylimitvisitors’senseoffreedom(Marion&Reid,2007).However,indirectmanagementapproachessuchasvisitoreducationhavebecomeastandardandeffectivemethodusedtominimizehigh-impactbehaviorsofoutdoorenthusiastsinparksandprotectedareas(Hammitt&Cole,1998;Hendee&Dawson,2002;Manning,1999,2003;Marion&Reid,2001).Educationismosteffectiveatmitigatingcertaintypesofbehavior,andassuch,ismosteffectiveaspartofalargercomprehensivestrategy,includingstaff,infrastructure,and,forsomeimpacts,directmanagement.
EducationandInformationManylandmanagers,andthegeneralpublic,oftenviewindirectmanagementtechniquesasalight-handedapproachforaddressingdepreciativebehaviorinparksandprotectedareas.Basedonanextensivereviewoftheliterature,Manning(1999)suggestedthattheuseofeducationandinformationtoaddresscertainbehaviorsiseffective,favorablyviewedbyvisitors,andisoftenmorecosteffectivethandirectmeasuressuchaslawenforcement.Visitoreducationeffortsoftendrawononeoftwopertinentmodelsofpersuasion:thecentralroutetopersuasionandtheperipheralroutetopersuasion(Roggenbuck,1992).TheconceptualbasisforthesetwodistinctmodelsofpersuasionisTheElaborationLikelihoodModel(seePettyetal.,1992).Theoveralleffectivenessofpersuasionislargelydependentonthetypeofimpact,thetypeofbehavior,andthemotivationsforthebehaviorinquestion(Roggenbuck,1992).Parkandprotectedareamanagersoftenutilizethecentral
![Page 29: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
routetopersuasion,which,“reliesonvisitorattention,consideration,andinternalizationofthemessage”(Marion&Reid,2007,p.11).Thecentralroutetopersuasion’seffectivenessisduetothevisitorprocessingtheinformationbyfilteringitthroughpriorknowledgeandexperiencetoevaluatetheinformation(orarguments)presentedinthemessage.Onceaparticularmessageisinternalizedbythevisitor,andmeshedwiththevisitor’sbeliefstructure,long-termbehavioralchangeispossible(Marion&Reid,2007).Alternatively,theperipheralroutetopersuasiongenerallyreliesonthesourceoftheinformationratherthanthequalityorrelevanceoftheinformationitself.AsnotedbyRoggenbuck(1992),“therecipientpaysmoreattentionto‘whosaidit’thanto‘whatwassaid’”(p.195)inthecontextoftheperipheralroutetopersuasion.Whilethiscanbeaneffectivestrategyintherightcontext(e.g.parkrangertalksatavisitorcenter),thisroutetopersuasionhaslimitedeffectivenessincreatinglong-termbehaviorchange(Marion&Reid,2007).McGuire(1985)providesamodel(Figure1)forinformationprocessingthatoffersatheoreticalbasisforprogramsdesignedtochangebehavior,whichisparticularlywellsuitedforparksandprotectedareas.Asillustratedtheprocessofpersuasionbeginswhenavisitorisexposedtoaneducationalmessage,whichisfollowedbyprocessingandcomprehensionoftheinformation.Thenextstep,andperhapsthemostcriticalintheprocess,istheyieldingstep,whichinvolvesthevisitoracceptingthemessageandthenalteringhisorherattitudeaccordingly(Marion&Reid,2007).Themodelfurtherassumesthatonceavisitorhasyieldedtothemessageandachangeinattitudehasoccurred,thatthechangedattitudewillberetainedinthevisitor’smemorythusguidingfuturebehavior.Therefore,ifthegoalofa“persuasion-based”programistocreatelong-termbehavioralchangeinparkandprotectedareavisitors,thecentralroutetopersuasionislikelythemosteffectivestrategy(Pettyetal.,1992).
Figure1.Information-processingmodelofpersuasionandbehaviorchange(adapted
fromMcGuire,1985)Despitethenotionthatbehaviorchangeinparkandprotectedareavisitorsmaynotdirectlyresultfromsimplyattainingnewknowledge,bothMarionandReid(2007)andManning(2003)haveconcludedthatrobustvisitoreducationcanbeeffectiveinchangingthebehaviorofprotectedareavisitors.Althougheducationcanbeeffectiveinchangingbehavior,theoveralllevelofeffectivenessvariesbystrategy(Vagias,2009).Onestrategythathasmeritistheuseofmultiplemediatodelivereducationalmessagesratherthan
![Page 30: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
relyingonanysinglemedium(Manning,2003).AccordingtoHam(2007),makinganymeaningfuldifferenceinvisitorbehaviorrequirespresentingstrong,relevantthemesthatprovokeavisitortointernalizethethemes.Thisinturnimpactsattitudes,whichcanthenimpactvisitorbehavior(Ajzen,1991;Ham&Krumpe,1996).
EfficacyofVisitorEducationManylandmanagersrecognizethatrecreation-relatedresourceimpactsarenotmaliciousbynature.Rather,theygenerallystemfromalackofknowledgeoftheconsequencesofsuchactions,andalackofknowledgeofappropriateminimumimpactbehaviorsandtechniques(Bradley,1979;Marion&Reid,2007).Visitoreducationthatisdesignedtopersuadevisitorstoadoptminimum-impactpracticesisviewedbymanagersasalessheavy-handedapproachtomanagingresourceimpacts(Manning,1999;Roggenbuck,1992),andisgenerallypreferredbyparkandprotectedareavisitorsratherthanmoredirectmanagementapproaches(Hendee&Dawson,2002;Park,Manning,Marion,Lawson,&Jacobi,2008). AccordingtoRoggenbuck(1992),problembehaviorsofparkandprotectedareavisitorscanbeclassifiedintofivedifferenttypesasshowninFigure2.Asillustratedinthefigure,certaintypesofproblemsaremoreapttobeeffectivelyaddressedbyeducationthanothers.Fortwoofthebehaviors,illegalandunavoidable,Roggenbuck(1992)assertsthateducationwillhavelittletonoeffectoncurbingtheundesirableactions.However,behaviorsidentifiedascareless,unskilledanduninformedhavevaryingpotential(frommoderatetoveryhigh)ofeffectivelybeinginfluencedbyeducationefforts.Thelevelofeffectivenessofvariouscommunicationeffortslargelydependsonthekindofimpact,thespecificdepreciativebehaviorinvolved,andthespecificmotivationforengaginginthebehavior.
Figure2.Typologyofproblembehaviors(adaptedfromRoggenbuck,1992)
Otherfactorsofefficacyincludemessagerational,messagedelivery,andsourcecredibility(Marion&Reid,2007).ChristensenandCole(2000)foundthatprotectedareavisitorsweremorelikelytobepersuadedtochangebehaviorbyecologicalrationalesthanbysocial
![Page 31: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
ones.Intermsofmessagedelivery,timingofmessagesisacriticalfactorformaximizingefficacy(Roggenbuck,1992).Thissuggeststhatmanagersshouldstrivetotimethedeliveryofeducationalmessagestoreachrecreationistsearlyinthetrip-planningprocessformaximumeffectiveness(Marion&Reid,2007).Lastly,thecredibilityofthemessagesourceisanotherfundamentalkeytothesuccessofanyeducationaleffort.Messagesourcesviewedbyvisitorsascredible,suchasaparkranger,tendtobemoreeffective(Oliver,Roggenbuck,&Watson,1985).Inmanyparksandprotectedareas,educationalinitiativesareanessentialcomponentofaanoverallmanagementstrategyforensuringprotectionofrecreationalresources.AsnotedbyMarionandReid(2007),thereissufficientevidencethatthemajorityofcommonlyusedvisitoreducationmethodscanaffectvisitorknowledge,attitudes,andbehavior.Similarly,Manning(2003)concludedthateducationcanultimatelybeeffectiveinmodifyingparkandprotectedareavisitors’attitudes.Lastly,MarionandReid(2007)statethat,“Itisclearthatvisitoreducationcanbeaneffectivemanagementstrategyforaddressingvisitorimpactstoprotectedarearesources”(p.18).
DepreciativeBehaviorsItisclearfrombothpublishedliterature,andthefirsthandexperienceofparkandprotectedareamanagers,thatrecreationalactivityinnaturalareascreatessomelevelofecologicalandsocialimpact.Yet,manyvisitorsaresimplynotawareofhowtheirindividualbehaviorcontributestotheproblem.Researchershavepositedthatoneplausibleexplanationofdepreciativebehavioristheresultoffailuretocomplywithsocialnorms.Widner-WardandRoggenbuck(2003)proposedataxonomyofcausesofvariousdepreciativebehaviors,consistingofsixrepresentativeviolations:
1. Unintentional:“IwasunawareIwasdoingsomethingwrong.”2. Uninformed:“Ididnotknowfeedingwildlifecoulddamagetheirhealth.”3. Releasor-cue:“Isawsomeoneelseurinateinthepark,soitseemsoktome.”4. Responsibility-denial:“Itmaybewrongtolitter,butwhatIdroppedontheground
won’treallymatter.”5. Status-conforming:“Allmyfriendstagbuildings.”6. Willfulviolations:Destructionofproperty,breakinglaws,opendruguse,etc.
Evidencesuggeststhatthesevariouscausescanbelinkedandmaybeadditiveinnature.Forexample,avisitormayhaveseenaninstancewhereanothervisitordidnotpickupaftertheirpet.Assuch,thatvisitorthendoesnotpayattentiontohisorherpetonthenextparkvisitandleavespetwastebehindeventhoughheorshehadapoopbagwiththematthetime.Additionally,thevisitormaynotknowthatpetwasteisasignificantecologicalandsocialproblem.Asthisexampledemonstrates,therecanbecombinationsofcausesthatleadtodepreciativebehaviorsovertime.
![Page 32: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
VisitorPerceptionsofImpacts Somepaststudieshaveindicatedthatparkandprotectedareavisitorsandmanagersoftendifferintheirperceptionofboththetypeandlevelofrecreation-relatedimpact.Additionally,thesetwogroupsalsodifferintheirassessmentorinterpretationofimpacts,eitherpositivelyornegatively(Farrelletal.,2001;Kimetal.,2003;Whiteetal.,2001).Thesedifferingperceptions,evaluations,andinterpretationscanleadtoconflictandmisunderstandingofparkandprotectedareamanagers’prioritiesandstrategiesaimedataddressingimpacts(Dorwartetal.,2004).AccordingtoManning(1999),itiscriticalformanagerstoobjectivelyandsystematicallygatherdatafromvisitorsaboutwhatdefinesahigh-qualityorsatisfyingrecreationalexperience.Assuch,managersshouldstrivetounderstandvisitorperceptionsandattempttoresolveagencyperceptionswiththoseofvisitors.Thiscanleadtoadoptionandimplementationofmanagementstrategiesthatamajorityofvisitorscanultimatelysupport.
Whilepublicsupportformanagementisnotagoalinandofitself,strategieswithlittletonosupportfromrecreationistswillrequireaninvestmentinenforcementtobesuccessful.Moreover,asdemonstratedthroughstudies,managementstrategiesthatareaccompaniedbycleareducationalmessagingastotheeaseoftherequestedchangeandtheefficacyofdesiredoutcomecanbemoresuccessfulatachievingthemanagementoutcome(Lawhonetal.,2013;2017).IntheAdirondackPark,theimplementationoftheBearResistantFoodCanisterregulationintheHighPeaksisaclearexampleofamanagementstrategyaccompaniedbyacleareducationalmessagethathasbeenlargelysupportedbyamajorityofvisitors.Again,withintheAdirondackPark,sincerecreationisasecondaryconcernfortheForestPreserve,visitorsupportformanagementmaybedesirablebutisnotlegallymandated.Manningetal.(2004)presentthefollowingforaddressingvisitorperceptionsofrecreation-relatedimpacts:
1. Involvevisitorsindecisionsaboutacceptablelevelsofrecreation-relatedresourceandsocialimpacts;
2. Visitorsmaybewillingtoacceptsomerestrictionsonvisitorusedesignedtominimizeresourceandsocialimpacts(iftheyareinvolvedintheprocess);and
3. Understandthatitisnotfeasibletoeliminateallresourceandsocialimpactslinkedtorecreation.
Someresearchershaveexploredtherelationshipbetweenvisitor-basedstandardsofqualityandexistingconditionsinparksandprotectedareas.OnesuchstudyconductedbyLavenetal.(2005)revealedthatvisitor-basedstandardsofqualityareoftenunrelatedtoexistingconditions,indicatingthatvisitorsdon’t“see”whatmanagersseeontheground.Additionally,theresearchsuggeststhatstandardsofqualitybasedonexistingconditionsmaycontinuallycontributetostatusquoorpossiblydiminishedresourceandsocialconditionsovertimegiventhefactthatconditionstendtoworsenincrementallywithincreaseduse.Inotherwords,visitorspartakeinrecreationalactivitiesforenjoymentofa
![Page 33: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
particularareayetdon’trealizethattheiractivitymaybeconcurrentlydiminishingtheveryqualitiesoftheareathatdrewthemtheretobeginwith.Lastly,visitorassessmentofwhetheraresourceorsocialimpactisacceptableornotisoftendependentonthespecifictypesofrecreationaparticularareaismanagedtooffer,theobjectivesofvarioususergroups,andtheoverallresourcemanagementobjectivesoftheagency.Furthermore,theactuallevelofrecreation-relatedimpactmaybevieweddifferentlybyavisitordependingonthetypeofrecreationsetting.Forexample,avisitorinaforestednaturalareamaydeemlittermoreinappropriatethaninanurbanparkwithalessnaturalsetting(HammittandCole,1998).
MessagingandSignageInmanyparksandprotectedareas,signsarearegularlyutilizedtoolformanagingvisitoruseandimpact(Winter,2005;Parketal.,2008).Forcash-strappedagencies,particularlythosethatmaybeinsufficientlystaffed,implementingsignageisoftenafirstchoiceforcommunicatingrules,regulations,andinformationtovisitors.Givenvisitors’preferenceforindirectmanagementstrategies,signsaregenerallymoreappealingtomanyprotectedareavisitorsthanmoredirectstrategiessuchasenforcementofrulesorotherrestrictionsonvisitorfreedoms(Chavez,Winter,&Baas,1993;Winteretal.,2000).Asaresult,signsareakeymethodutilizedbyparkandprotectedareamanagersforgarneringdesiredvisitorbehavior.Whenconsideringtheimplementationofsignagetoaddressaparticularissue,managersmustevaluateboththetypeofmessage(DuncanandMartin,2002)andtheactualplacementofsigns(McCoolandCole,2000).Inthepastdecade,theuseoftheory-drivenapproachestomessagedesignhasbecomeamoreprominentstrategyforcreatingeffectivemessagesforvisitorstoparksandprotectedareas(Vagias,2014;Widner-WardandRoggenbuck,2003).Signsdesignedtoinform,warn,orprohibitvisitorsareoneofthemostcommonmethodsusedtoreducedepreciativeornoncompliantbehaviorinvisitors.Therearefourprimarymessagetypesutilized:
1. Plea–“Pleasepickupafteryourpet.”2. Sanction–“Dogsarenotallowedoffleash.Violatorssubjectto$250fine.”3. Prohibition–“Alcoholand/oropencontainersprohibited.”4. Interpretive–“Areaclosedforrevegetationtoprotectgroundnestingbirds.”
Numerousstudieshaveevaluatedtheefficacyofmessagesonsigns,andmostresearchhasindicatedthatanysignageisbetterthannoneatreducinginappropriate,impactful,ordepreciativebehavior(Cole,1998;DuncanandMartin,2002).Somestudieshavefocusedontheeffectivenessofcertaintypesofmessages,specificallyinterpretationandsanctionmessages(DuncanandMartin,2002;JohnsonandSwearingen,1992).Researchfindingssuggestthatthesetypesofmessageshavehadmixedsuccessinachievingcompliance.
![Page 34: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
Factorsthatcaninfluencesuccessincludevisitordemographics,visitormotivations,recreationalsetting,andvisitationlevels.Researchindicatesthattheplacementofsignscanincreaseeffectiveness,andthatthosesignsplacedatornearaproblemareatendtobemosteffective.Insuchsituations,thesignfunctionsasacontextualrestrictionorunanticipatedintervention,andcanhaveaneducationaleffectonvisitors(Slater,1992).Insomesettings,sanctionmessageshavebeendemonstratedtobeeffectiveforcertainbehaviorssuchashikingoff-trailorcollectingofartifacts(Martin,1992;JohnsonandSwearingen,1992).Yettheeffectivenessofsuchmessagingtypesinurbansettingshasreceivedfarlessfocusbyresearchers.However,inmanyurbansettings,thereisoftenatendencytoavoiddirectmanagementstrategiesinfavorofeducationorinterpretationpresentedviasignage.Placementofsignsatentrypointstoparksandprotectedareasisaroutinepractice.Theuseofthistechniqueassumesthatvisitorswilltaketimetoread,process,andunderstandpostedinformation.Yet,awidevarietyoffactorsimpedethisprocess.Limitedtimeframes,informationoverload,competinginterestormessages,frequentdistractions,non-captiveaudiences,andadesiretoproceedtotheactivityallcandiminishefficacy(Cole,1998;McCoolandCole,2000;Orams,1997).AccordingtoCole(1998),theaveragetimeavisitorwillspendonasignis3.1–9.7seconds,andithasbeennotedthatvisitorscanbecomeeasilyconfusedifaparticularsigncontainsmorethanonediscretemessage.Anadditionalconsiderationistheideathattoomanysignsinanareacancreate“signpollution,”andcanleadtonegativeeffectsonvisitorexperiencegiventhepotentialdisruptionintheoverallsenseofdiscoveryandexploration(Roggenbuck,1992).Thesefindingsindicatethatsignsatentrypointsmaynotbeusefulinallcases.Furthermore,suchsignsshouldbebrief,andonlycontainasinglemessagewheneverpossibletoaidinvisitorcomprehension.ResearchconductedbyCialdinietal.(2006)exploredfourdifferenttypesofnormativemessagesforreducingoff-trailhiking.Testedmessagesincluded:
• Injunctive:whatoughttobe• Descriptive:whatcurrentlyis• Prescriptive:positivelyphrased,“dothis”• Proscriptive:negativelyphrased,“don’tdothis”
Findingsindicatedthattheinjunctive-proscriptivemessagewasmosteffectiveatattainingthedesiredbehavior.Inotherwords,tellingvisitorswhatoughttobeoccurring,andtellingthemnottoengageinaspecificdepreciativebehaviorwasshowntobemosteffectiveinthisstudy.However,theresearchersdidindicatethatthistypeofmessageismosteffectivewhenaparticularbehaviorisdesiredsoonaftermessageexposure,andthatsuchmessagesmaynotbeeffectiveatensuringlong-termbehaviorchange.Buildingonthiswork,Winter(2006)notedthatifmanagersareinterestedinprovidinghighqualityrecreationalexperiences,thentheymustbemindfulwhendecidingtousenegatively(proscriptive)messages,assuchmessagescanhaveanunintendednegativeeffectonvisitorexperience.Therefore,abalancedapproachtomessagingiswarrantedinmostcases.
![Page 35: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
RecentstudieshavedemonstratedthatperceivedeffectivenessofLeaveNoTracepracticesisameaningfulpredictoroffutureLeaveNoTracebehavioralintent.Assuch,parkandprotectedareamanagersshouldconsiderfocusingeducationaleffortsonhowLeaveNoTracepracticeseffectivelyminimizeimpactstothelandscape.Thoughsomestudieshavefoundthatthatthisknowledgeisnotasignificantpredictoroffuturebehavioralintent,parkvisitorsdoneedtobemadeawareoftherecommendedLeaveNoTracepracticesinparksandprotectedareas.However,andperhapsmoreimportantly,parkvisitorsneedtobetterunderstandwhycertainLeaveNoTracepracticesarerecommended,andwhythosepracticesareeffectiveatreducingimpacts.FindingsfromthisresearchsuggestthateducationeffortsspecificallyfocusedontheperceivedeffectivenessofLeaveNoTracepracticesmaybemoreeffectiveatmodifyingvisitorbehaviorinordertominimizerecreation-relatedimpactinparksthanmessagesthatdon’tcontainthisinformation(Lawhonetal.,2013;2017).
BarrierstoComplianceSomeresearchhasexploredbarrierstocompliancewithpostedinformation,rules,andregulations.Whiletheexistingliteraturedoesnotexamineallpossiblebarriers,specificfactorsuniquetoparksandprotectedareashavebeeninvestigated.Miller,Borrie,andHarding(2001)hypothesizedthefollowingexplanationsfornon-compliance:
• Cognitivefailureintheformoffaultydecision-making• Unsuccessfulattitudeshiftwhenpresentedwithnewinformation• Ingrainednegative,depreciative,orimpactfulbehaviors• Afunctionalinabilitytocarryoutdesiredorappropriatebehaviors• Variousnormativeinfluencesandsocialpressuresfrompeers
Additionally,workbyBorrieandHarding(2002)foundthatinsituationswhereavailableinformationisnotthelimitingfactortocompliance,thereareother,similarfactorsatplay:
1. Lackofawarenessofaproblem2. Peergrouppressure3. Lackofanunderlyingoutdoorethic4. Routine(habitual)behavior5. Lackofabilitytoperformdesiredbehavior
Theseauthorsconcludedthatwhenvisitorsareexposedtomultiplemessagestheycanexperiencecognitiveoverload,whichcanlimitrecallofspecificmessagesregardingmanagementobjectivesorrecommendedbehaviorsdesignedtominimizeimpact.Perhapsthemostsalientfindinginthisworkwastheideathatroutineorhabitualbehaviorisparticularlydifficult,ifnotimpossible,toaddress,alter,orinfluencewithon-sitecommunicationthroughsignage.
![Page 36: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
LeaveNoTraceLeaveNoTraceisthemostprevalentminimum-impacteducationalprograminuseinparksandprotectedareasintheU.S.(Marion,2014).Theoverarchingintentoftheprogramistoeducateoutdoorenthusiastsaboutthenatureoftheirrecreation-relatedimpactaswellasteachthemtechniquesforminimizingtheimpact(Harmon,1997;LeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics,2016a;Marion&Reid,2007).LeaveNoTraceisparticularlyappealingtolandmanagersbecauseitoffersamorelight-handedapproachtovisitormanagementasopposedtomoreheavy-handedmanagementstrategies(Lawhonetal.,2013).ThefoundationoftheprogramistheSevenPrinciples(Figure3),whichareusedonprotectedareasignage,maps,andwebsitesandinterpretiveinformation.
Figure3.TheLeaveNoTracePrinciples(LeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics,2016b).
LeaveNoTraceconceptsdatebacktothe1960swhentheUSDAForestServicebeganencouragingvisitorsto“packitin,packitout.”TheseearlyeffortsweremodeledonthesuccessfulSmokeytheBearanti-forestfirecampaignandeventuallymorphedtheinitialminimumimpactcampingmessages.Asrecreationcontinuedtoincreasethroughoutthe1970sand1980s,itbecameclearthatamorecomprehensiveeducationalapproachtomanagingvisitorimpactsinthebackcountrywasnecessary.Assuch,theUSDAForestServicecreatednumerouspartnershipsinthe1990stocooperativelypromoteascience-basedapproachtominimumimpactrecreation.Thiseffortresultedinthedevelopmentofseveralpublicationsfocusedonresponsibleoutdoorrecreationpractices,andultimatelyledtothecreationofthe501(c)(3)LeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics(theCenter).TheinitialfocusofLeaveNoTracewasonimpactsinwildernessareasbuthasexpandedtoincludeothertypesofparksandprotectedareas.(Marion,2014;Marion&Reid,2001).Currently,theCenterhasaprimaryfocusonfrontcountryareavisitors,andhascreatednumerousLeaveNoTraceeducationalresourcesaddressingrecreationalpursuitscommontotheseareasincludingdayhiking,picnicking,campingindevelopedcampsites,dogwalking,biking,running,andothers(LeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics,2015;Marion,2014).
SevenPrinciplesofLeaveNoTrace
1. PlanAheadandPrepare2. TravelandCamponDurableSurfaces3. DisposeofWasteProperly4. LeaveWhatYouFind5. MinimizeCampfireImpacts6. RespectWildlife7. BeConsiderateofOtherVisitors
![Page 37: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
37
AttitudeTheoryPreviousresearchhasestablishedthatattitudesoftenhaveasignificantinfluenceonaspecific,discretebehavior(Ajzen,2001;Fishbein&Manfredo,1992;Ham&Krumpe,1996).Attitudesaregenerallydescribedasanindividual’sevaluationof,anddispositionalresponseto,aparticularobject,includingbehavior.Onceaperson’sevaluationofanobjecthasoccurred,anassociativeattitudeaboutthatobjectcanberetainedinmemoryandinfluencefuturebehavior(Ajzen&Fishbein,2000;Fishbein&Ajzen,2010).LeaveNoTracebehavioristhereforetheoreticallyinfluencedinpartbyattitudestowardspecificLeaveNoTraceguidelinesandrecommendedpractices.Ifattitudesdirectlyinfluencebehavioralintention,andattitudescanbechanged,thenparkmanagersmayaltervisitorbehaviorbyspecificallytargetingthesalientattitudethatisdeterminingbehavior(Ham,2007;Ham&Krumpe,1996).UnderstandingvisitorattitudesrelatedtoLeaveNoTraceiscriticalinordertocrafteffectiveeducationalmessagesthathavethepotentialtoreducedepreciativebehaviorinparksandprotectedareas.Somepreviousinvestigationshaveutilizedknowledgeofminimum-impactpracticesasameasureofLeaveNoTraceefficacy.Whilesomerelationshipdoesexist,aprimaryshortcomingoffocusingonknowledgeisthattheassumptionofalinearrelationshipbetweenenvironmentalknowledgeandpro-environmentalbehaviorisquestionable(Hungerford&Volk,1990;Hwang,2000;Manning,2003;Petty,McMichael,&Brannon,1992).Inotherwords,increasingknowledgeaboutenvironmentalimpactdoesnotnecessarilyequatetoachangeinanindividual’sbehavior.Recently,socialscientistshavebegunexploringtheinfluencethatvalues,beliefs,attitudes,andotherfactorsplayindeterminingthebehaviorofoutdoorenthusiastswithinthecontextofLeaveNoTrace,basedlargelyuponbehavioraltheory(Vagiasetal.,2012;2014).Additionally,recentresearchhasstartedexaminingtheperceptionsoffrontcountryvisitorswithrespecttobehavioraltheoryandLeaveNoTrace(Taffetal.,2011;Taffetal.,2014).ThisisanimportantconsiderationinLeaveNoTrace-relatedresearchgiventhetheoreticalfoundationsthatsuggestattitudesareoneoftheimportantinfluencesonbehavior(Ajzen,1991).
ImplicationsforManagement–Keyfindingsfromtheliterature
• Messagesonsignsshouldbebriefandcontainasfewmessagesaspossible.• Considertheuseofinjunctive-proscriptivemessagesnearproblemareas.• Utilizemessagesthatmakevisitorsawareoftheconsequencesoftheiractions.• Directcontactwith/fromagencypersonnelmaybemoreeffectivethanother
communicationstrategies.• Visitorsareoftenunwillingtoseethemselvesaspartoftheproblem,somangers
shouldfindwaystoincreaseattributionofresourcedamagetovisitoractions.• Managersshouldworktoreconciletheirownperceptionsofresourceandsocial
impactswiththoseofvisitors,whichmaybedifferent(vastlysoinsomecases).• Messagesshouldillustrateidealsituations,behaviors,andresourceconditions.
![Page 38: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
38
• Communicationwithvisitorsshouldprovideclearlinkagebetweenvisitorbehaviorandresourceandsocialimpacts.
• Dependingonthespecificproblem,messagesshouldemphasizeindividualresponsibilityforspecificimpacts.
ConclusionDespitethefactthatcountlessparksandprotectedareashavearecreationmandate,resourcedegradationduetoinappropriatevisitorbehaviorcontinuestobeasignificantconcernformanagers(Leung&Marion,2000;Taffetal.,2011;Vagias&Powell,2010).Formanyprotectedareamanagers,educationisanessentialcomponentofoverallmanagementeffortsforensuringprotectionofrecreationalresources.LeaveNoTraceisthemostprevalentminimum-impacteducationprograminuseinparksandprotectedareasintheU.S.,dueprimarilytoitslight-handedapproachtovisitormanagement(Vagias&Powell,2010).AsnotedbyMarionandReid(2007),thereissufficientevidenceindicatingthatvisitoreducationcanaffectvisitorknowledge,attitudes,andbehavior.
![Page 39: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
LeaveNoTraceProgramImplementation–2020andBeyondTheAdirondackParkfaceschallenges,bothintermsofincreasingvisitorimpactsandavailableresourcestoaddresscurrentandfutureimpacts.However,theDECanditspartnersarewellpoisedtominimize,mitigate,oreliminatespecificrecreation-relatedimpactsfoundintheParkbyimplementingeffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationprogramsasakeycomponentofacomprehensivemanagementplanthatincludesadditionalcomponents(suchasstaff,infrastructure,andlimits).DevelopmentofsuchaplancouldbemodeledontheInteragencyCouncilonVisitorUse’sVisitorUseManagementFramework,aplanningprocesscreatedtoprovidecohesiveguidanceformanagingvisitoruse.TheParkenjoysastrongsupportbasefromtheregion,over100partnersandfriends’groups,andactiverecreationalusergroupsthatcouldplayavitalroleineducatingParkvisitorsaboutLeaveNoTrace.Bysimplyleveragingthenumerousagencies,partners,andindividualsinvolved,muchcanbeaccomplishedintermsofcreatingacommunityofresponsibleparkandnaturalareavisitors.Therearemanypossibilitiesforprogramimplementation,whichhingeonavailablefinancialandstaffingresources.However,thetwobasicstrategies,eitherofwhichwouldlikelybeeffective,include:
1. TargetedimplementationofeducationalprogramsandstewardshipinitiativesinchosensiteswithintheAdirondackPark.Theseselectsitescouldbethoughtofas“pilotsites”whereeducationalinformationcouldbetestedineitherhigh-useareas,areaswithsensitiveenvironments,orareaswithsignificantimpacts.Whenusingthepilotsiteapproach,LeaveNoTraceinformationcanbetestedforitseffectivenessandcansubsequentlybeenhancedtoincreaseitsefficacy.Anotherbenefitofthisapproachisthatitallowsmanagersandpartnerstoworkatamanageablepaceintermsofimplementation,therebyenablingthemto“cherrypick”thestrategiesthatworkbest.ThesestrategiescanthenbeusedinotherpartsoftheParkuntiltheentireParkhasconsistentinformationandeffectivemessaging.
2. ParkwiderolloutoftheLeaveNoTraceeducationprogram.Whilelikelyamoreeffectivestrategybecauseofitscomprehensivenature,itispotentiallyunrealisticduetoresource,staffing,andotherconstraints.Basedonotherprogramsofthiskind,theCenterhasfoundthatfull-scaleprogramimplementationthatsaturatesanareatendstoachievemanagementobjectivesinashortertimeframe.However,thiskindofeffortisgenerallymoreintensiveandrequiresaconcerted,coordinatedeffortonthepartofallpartners.Furthermore,giventhecomplexityanddiversityoftheAdirondackPark,itisquitelikelythatLeaveNoTraceeffortswillbemoreeffectiveatsomesitesandlesseffectiveatothers.Thereasonsforthisincludesitetype,location,visitortype,amenities,usertype,andvisitationtrends.
Atargetedroll-outmaybethemosteffectivestrategyfortheAdirondackPark.LeveragingtheaffinityforspecificareasoftheParksuchastheHighPeaks,andimplementingatargetedLeaveNoTraceeffortinthoseandothersimilarareas,wouldlikelyprovideasuccessfulstartingpointforpromotingsustainableandresponsibleuseandenjoymentof
![Page 40: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
40
theentireParkovertime.WhileLeaveNoTracecontinuestobeeffectiveinallparktypesfromurbantowilderness,theCenterrecommendsselectionofalocationorsuiteoflocationswhereLeaveNoTracecanbemosteffectiveinaparticulararea.Forexample,LeaveNoTraceeducationcanbeutilizedeffectivelyintheHighPeakstokeepvisitorsondesignatedtrailsbutmaynotexperiencethesameinitialsuccessinOldForgeifusedtoeducatesnowmobilersaboutproperdisposalofhumanwaste.Inotherwords,deployLeaveNoTraceeffortswherethelikelihoodofinitialsuccessisgreatest,whichwillprovideaspringboardfromwhichfutureeffortscanpropagateandsucceed.ThefollowingitemsneedtobeaddressedinordertoimplementaneffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationprogramintheAdirondackPark:
1. Agreeonoverallgoalsfortheeducationalprogrampriortoimplementation.2. Determineimplementationstrategy–full-scalerolloutoratargeted,pilotsite
model.3. Ifthepilotsitemodelisselected,theinitialpilotsitesneedtobeselectedbasedon
predeterminedcriteria.4. Determinespecificmanagementconcernstobetargeted.Whileitmayseemlikean
opportunitytoaddressmultipleconcernsforanarea,theCenterrecommendschoosing1-3discreteissuesofhighestconcerntobetheprimaryfocusduringtheinitialrolloutofeducationalefforts.
5. UtilizeexistingLeaveNoTracemessagesand/orlanguagetoaddressspecificmanagementconcerns.Languagewilllikelyneedtobelocally-tailoredtobetterresonatewithresidentsandvisitorsalike.
6. Developadditionallanguage(inconsultationwiththeCenter)asnecessaryforaddressingotherconcernsforwhichtargetedlanguagemaynotbeavailable.
7. Determinewhetherornotmanagers,keystaff,partners,orvolunteerswillneedLeaveNoTracetrainingpriortoimplementationofeducationalefforts.
8. Determineoutreachmethods(possibilitieslistedbelow).9. Definethetimelineforimplementationstrategy.10. Ifbaselinedataexistforchosensiteswhereeducationaleffortswillbeimplemented,
suchdatacouldbeutilizedtoassesschanges(atpredeterminedintervals)insocialorresourceconditionsaftereducationaleffortshavebeenputinplace.
11. Createlistofspecificandrealisticmetricsformeasuringeffectivenessofeducationalefforts.
12. Ifresearchtogaugetheefficacyofoutreacheffortsisdesired,detailsofsuchresearchwillneedtobefinalizedpriortoeducationprogramimplementation.
![Page 41: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
41
RecommendationsforManagingRecreation-relatedImpactsintheAdirondackParkandBuildingaCultureofWildlandsStewardship
I.Management&PlanningRecommendations
A. Needforcomprehensiveparkplanning–Duetoitssizeandcomplexity,thereisaninherentchallengeintryingtohaveaparkwidecomprehensiveplan.However,suchaneffortwouldbenefitthelong-termstewardshipandsustainabilityofthePark.Inordertohaveasuccessfulparkwidevisitoreducationprogram,DECmanagersandpartnersmusthaveasolidimplementationplan.Totheextentpossible,keystakeholdersshouldbealignedandhaveacommongoaltoeffectivelyreachparkvisitorswithcriticalinformation.Givennationaltrendsinrecreationparticipationgrowth,increasedrecreationaluseoftheParkishighlylikelyinthefuture,andacomprehensiveParkplan(includinganoutreachandeducationplan)isimperative.
B. Utilizeanestablishedplanningframework–AdirondackParkmanagersand
partnerscouldgreatlybenefitfromworkingthroughaformalvisitorusemanagementplanningprocessforthePark.ThiswouldallowforabetterunderstandingofthecarryingcapacityoftheParkaswellashelptodefinecomplementaryvisitorexperienceopportunitiesanddesiredfutureresourceconditions.Therearenumerousplanningframeworksthatcouldbeutilized,andinclude:
• VisitorUseManagementFramework:http://visitorusemanagement.nps.gov/(themostcontemporaryandrobust):
• LimitsofAcceptableChange:http://www.fs.usda.gov/detail/dbnf/home/?cid=stelprdb5346360
• VisitorExperienceandResourceProtection:
http://winapps.umt.edu/winapps/media2/leopold/pubs/320F.pdfTheuseofanyoneofthese(orsimilar)planningframeworkswouldgreatlyaidParkmanagersandpartnersindeterminingandattainingaspecificdesiredfutureconditionforthePark,andwouldbevaluableforlong-rangestrategicplanningefforts.
C. BuildLeaveNoTraceintomanagementplans–ConsiderbuildingLeaveNoTrace
intotheAdirondackParkmasterplanningdocuments,andParkprojectplans.ManyfederalandstatelandmanagementagencieshavebuiltLeaveNoTrace(andstewardshipconcepts)intotheirlong-rangeplans.See:https://www.nps.gov/acad/learn/management/upload/schoodic_gmpa.pdfSomemunicipallandmanagementagencieshavedonethisaswell,includingtheCityofBoulder,Colorado–OpenSpaceandMountainParksDepartment:https://www-static.bouldercolorado.gov/docs/osmpmp-final-1-
![Page 42: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
42
201910221147.pdf?_ga=2.225274716.794717831.1574112296-111660396.1574112296;andTravisCountyParks:https://www.traviscountytx.gov/images/tnr/Docs/parks/2_parks_master_plan.pdf(Texas).
D. CodifyLeaveNoTraceasguidingmanagementprinciples–Considerdraftinga
formalresolutionfortheAdirondackParkpertainingtoLeaveNoTrace.Somemunicipalitiesaroundthecountryhaveundertakenthiskindofinitiativewithsuccess.OneexampleistheSanJuanIslandsinWashingtonState(mixofcounty,state,andfederallands).ThemunicipalitypassedsuchaLeaveNoTraceresolution,whichisleadingtogreaterawarenessandadoptionofLeaveNoTrace,andultimatelyareductioninrecreation-relatedimpacts.SeeappendixI
E. EnsureadequatestaffingforParkmanagementagencies–Aperennialchallengefor
parkandprotectedareasisadequatestaffing.Local,state,andfederalagenciesallfacethisissue.Whenagenciesareunderstaffed,parksandprotectedareasoftensufferfromavoidableimpacts,manyofwhichmaybedirectlyrelatedtorecreationanduse.Thoughvolunteerscanfilltherolesofsomeagencypersonnel,awell-fundedandadequatelystaffedagencywillgenerallybebettersuitedtomeetthegrowingdemandsonpublicoutdoorspacessuchastheAdirondackPark.Clearlythereisafiscalimplicationtoaddingstaffwhichmustbesortedouttoensurethenecessarystaffingresourcesareinplace.
F. Permitsystemforhighuseareas–Thoughnotanappropriateoptionforevery
location,permitsystems,whenwellthoughtout,welldesigned,andsoundlyimplemented,canserveanimportantfunctioninparksandprotectedareas.Dependingonthenatureoftheresourceinquestion,permittingusecanbenefitthenaturalresourcesandthevisitorexperience.Additionally,apermitsystemallowsforaneducationaltouchpointwithvisitorsbeforetheydepartontheirtrip.ManyparksandprotectedareashaveexistingpermitsystemsinplacesuchasGreatSmokyMountainsNationalPark.AccordingtotheNationalParkService,visitorsbenefitfromthesysteminseveralways:“Throughacombinationofeducationandenforcement,parkrangersassignedexclusivelytothebackcountryareexpectedtoleadtobettercompliancewithregulationsandLeaveNoTraceethics.IncreasedcompliancewithregulationsandLeaveNoTracealsohelpsprotectandpreserveresources,suchaswildlife,thatmostvisitorshighlyvalue.Allbackcountryusersstandtobenefitfromthechanges[tothepermitsysteminthepark].Inaddition,bymakingallsitesreservation-only,thenewreservationsystemwillhavethecapabilitytonotifypermitholdersofsiteclosures,safetyissuesandotheremergencyconditionsviaemailandtextmessagingpriortobeginningtheirtrip.”Seethisexample:https://www.nps.gov/grsm/learn/management/bc-reservation-permit-faq.htm.Seehere:https://visitorusemanagement.nps.gov/Content/documents/highres_VUMFramework_Edition1_IVUMC.pdfformoreinformationontheimplementationanduseofpermitsystems.
![Page 43: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
43
G. Revisegroupusepermittingsystem–Thoughthereisacurrentsysteminplacefortheissuanceofgroupusepermits,itcouldbeenhancedtobemoreefficient,providearobusteducationalopportunityforthegrouppriortotheirvisit,andcouldyieldvaluablegroupusedataforDECanditspartners.UnderstandingandmanaginggroupuseshouldbeapriorityfortheParkasgroupsseekingpermitsoffermanybenefitsincluding:educationalandregulatorytouchpointswithspecificgroupsthatusethePark;abilitytocollectreliabledataongroupuse;andanopportunitytomonitorresourceconditionsatsitesusedbygroups.
H. WhenprovidingalternativestotheHighPeaks,ensuresuchareasarecapableof
handlingtheincreasedvisitation–Awell-utilizedstrategybylandmanagersistodirectvisitorstootherareasofaparkorprotectedareathatoffersimilarvisitorexperiences,challenges,ornaturalenvironments.Oneofthedifficultissueswiththisstrategyisensuringsuchalternativeareasarecapableofhandlingtheincreasedimpactsassociatedwithrecreation.InthecaseoftheAdirondackPark,somecurrentsuggestedalternativesappeartobeunderresourcedtoaccommodatetheadditionalinfluxofvisitors.Lackofparkingspaces,limitedavailabilityoftoiletfacilities,trailsnotdesignedforheavyuse,andasignificantlackofvisitoreducationareasamplingofthecurrentproblemsfacedbymanyofthesuggestedalternatives.Otherparkshavesuccessfullyusedthisstrategybyconductingassessmentsofpotentialalternativestoensuretheycaninfactcopewithadditionalrecreationalusepriortoofferingthemtothepublic.Considercatalogingexistingrecommendedalternativestodetermineifinfrastructureoreducationalprogrammingarelacking.Identifiedgapsshouldberemediedandaddressedtotheextentpossible.Areasbeingconsideredasnewalternativesshouldbeassessedforoverallsuitabilitybeforelocationsgopublic.
I. Buildonsuccessfulmanagementefforts–TheDECanditspartnershave
demonstratedsuccesswithseveraleffortsintheParktominimizerecreation-relatedimpacts,e.g.implementationofthebearcanisterregulationsfortheHighPeaks,checkstationsdesignedtominimizethespreadofinvasivespeciesthroughthemovementoffirewoodandboats,etc.SucheffortscouldbefurtherenhancedandbuiltuponforcontinuedsuccessinordertoeffectivelyminimizeandmitigatevisitorimpactsinthePark.Thisisparticularlysalientnowasreinventionofthewheelistimeconsuming,resourceintensive,andoftenimpractical,whereasbuildingonexistingsuccessfuleffortscanbefarmoreefficient,effective,andtimely.
II.Research&MonitoringRecommendations
A. Baselineandongoingmonitoringdataisessentialforparkmanagement–AdirondackParkmanagersandpartnerswouldbenefitfromobtainingbaselinedataoncurrentresourceconditionsinthePark.Therearenumerousmethodologies,fromsimpletocomplex,forgatheringbaselinedata.Baselinedatacouldbecollectedbyrelativelysimplephotodocumentation,GPSdata,orothermeans.However,therearemorecomplexmethodsforgatheringrobustbaselinedataifdesired.Regardless,
![Page 44: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
44
suchdataisextremelyusefulformonitoringchangeinconditionsovertime,andcanserveasaneffectivemetricforguidingmanagementefforts.SeeVisitorUseManagement:https://visitorusemanagement.nps.gov/Content/documents/highres_trifold_Monitoring_Guidebook_Primer_Edition_One_IVUMC.pdf
B. Collectdataonvisitornumbers–Implementationofasystemforcapturingbaseline
Parkvisitationonanannualbasiswouldgreatlybenefitoverallmanagementefforts.Anunderstandingofvisitationnumbers,patterns,seasonalvariation,andvisitortypewouldaugmenteducationaloutreacheffortsbyallowingforatargetedapproach.Additionally,havinginformationonannualvisitation,includingpeakvisitation,wouldallowforbettermanagementoftheinevitablespikesinvisitorusethroughouttheyear.Therearenumerousvisitorcountmethodologies:http://agrilifecdn.tamu.edu/cromptonrpts/files/2011/06/3_2_5.pdfandhttp:/www.fs.fed.us/ne/newtown_square/publications/technical_reports/pdfs/2004/317papers/kaczynski317.pdf,whichcanbetailoredtoaparticularparksystem,oranindividualpark.
C. Gainanempiricalunderstandingofvisitorperceptions–AsrecreationintheParkispromoted,andcorrespondinglyincreasesovertimeduetoavarietyoffactors(marketing,socialmedia,promotion,etc.),itwouldbeusefulforthemanagersandpartnerstodeterminewhatvisitorperceptionsarewithregardtothelevelofimpactfoundinthePark.DovisitorsfeelthattheParkis“beinglovedtodeath?”OrdotheyfeeltheParkprovideshigh-qualityrecreationalexperiences?AnunderstandingofbaselinevisitorperceptionsoftheParkallowsfortheimplementationofappropriatemanagementandeducationalstrategies,whichcanhelpensurethepredeterminedfuturecondition:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287234314_Studies_in_Outdoor_Recreation_Search_and_Research_for_SatisfactionofthePark.
D. UsecitizensciencetogathercurrentimpactdatathroughoutthePark–Data
collectedviacitizenscientistscouldbeusedtogeneratevisualrepresentationsofimpactssuchasheatmaps(forinformationonheatmapssee:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_map)ofimpacttoallowforamorestrategicapproachtoimprovingeducationforspecificimpactissues.Thiscouldfacilitateafundamentalshiftfrombeingreactivetobeingproactive.Suchaneffortcouldbeyetanother‘challenge’eventtogathermeaningfuldataforthePark.TheprogramcouldofferrecognitionsimilartootherParkchallenges.Alternatively,thiskindofprogramcouldbeinitiallyadministeredbyagraduatestudenttoassesstheefficacyandviabilityofsuchaneffort.
E. ConsiderreinvigoratingAdirondackAll-TaxaBiodiversityInventoryorother‘bio
blitz’eventstoengagecitizenscientistsandgathervaluabledatainacentralrepository–Bothpublicandprivateentitieshavebeensuccessfullyutilizingbioblitzesforanumberofyearstoengagethepublicintheprotectionofparksandprotectedareas.FromNationalGeographic,“ABioBlitzisaneventthatfocuseson
![Page 45: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
45
findingandidentifyingasmanyspeciesaspossibleinaspecificareaoverashortperiodoftime.AtaBioBlitz,scientists,families,students,teachers,andothercommunitymembersworktogethertogetasnapshotofanarea’sbiodiversity.Theseeventscanhappeninmostanygeography—urban,rural,orsuburban—inareasassmallasabackyardoraslargeasacountry.SmartphonetechnologiesandappssuchasiNaturalistmakecollectingphotographsandbiologicalinformationaboutlivingthingseasyaspartofaBioBlitz.HighqualitydatauploadedtoiNaturalistbecomepartoftheGlobalBiodiversityInformationFacility,anopensourcedatabaseusedbyscientistsandpolicymakersaroundtheworld.”TheNationalParkServicehasalsobeenutilizingtheseeventswithgreatsuccess.See:https://www.nps.gov/subjects/biodiversity/national-parks-bioblitz.htmhttp://www.birds.cornell.edu/citscitoolkit/projects/cfab/adirondackatbi/
F. MapalllocationswheretherearecurrentlystewardsinthePark–Suchamapping
exercisewillallowfortheaccurateidentificationofwhereon-the-groundstewardsarelocated,andthereforewheregapsexist.Identificationofcaretakersandstewardsatsummits,visitorcenters,trailheads,etc.willprovideamoremeaningfulpictureofcurrent‘bootsontheground,’andwillallowforreal-timeprogrammaticenhancements,betterdeploymentofexistingresources,andidentificationofareasnotcurrentlyservedbyon-the-groundstewards.Shouldnewareasinneedofanon-sitestewardbeidentified,thisinformationcouldbeleveragedtoengagenewindividualsorgroupsinterestedinstewardshipofthePark.
III.Tourism&MarketingRecommendations
A. EstablishpartnershipwithILoveNY,ROOST,andothertourismentities–ResearchhasshownthatmostoutdoorenthusiastsfirstencounterLeaveNoTraceinformationinaparkorprotectedarea(fromvarioussources:rangers,signage,etc.).Whiletherearebenefitstopeoplebeingreachedon-siteinparks,thereisalsotheissuethattheinformationmaybecomingtoolateinthe5-stepprocessofarecreationalexperiencetoactuallymakeadifference(atleastforthatvisit).The5-stepsofrecreationalexperiencesinclude:1)anticipation–thisinvolvestripplanningandpreparation;2)travelto–thephysicalactoftravelingtoaparkorprotectedareawhetherit’sjustacrosstownoracrossthecountry;3)on-site–individualsareactuallyinapark,engagedinvariousformsofrecreation;4)travelback–thephysicalactoftravelingbackhome;and5)reflection–takingstockoftheexperience,postingphotostosocialfeeds,blogging,sharingtheadventurewithfamilyorfriends.Giventhis5-stepprocess,theidealtimetoreachoutdoorenthusiastwithLeaveNoTraceinformationisintheanticipationphaseasthey’replanningtheirouting.Whenpeoplearereachedearlierintheplanningprocessthereisagreaterlikelihoodthattheywillbebetterpreparedfortheirouting,whichgenerallymeanstheywillalsocreatelessimpact.TourismentitieshavesignificantinfluenceonpubliclandsvisitationthroughouttheUS,andtheAdirondackParkisaprimeexampleofaparkthatcouldgreatlybenefitfromhavingstrongpartnershipswiththetourismindustry.Whenpotentialvisitorsarereachedviatourismpartners
![Page 46: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
46
inthetripanticipationphase,theyarelikelytobebetterinformedandpreparedforavisittothePark.ColoradowasthefirststateintheUStocreateaspecific,focusedpartnershipbetweentheColoradoTourismOffice(CTO)andtheLeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics.Forinformationonthispartnershipseethefollowing:
• https://www.colorado.com/articles/leave-no-trace-care-colorado
• https://www.colorado.com/sites/default/files/CO_LNTBrochure_8.pdf
• https://www.colorado.com/videos/care-colorado
• https://industry.colorado.com/care-colorado-principles-toolkit#
• https://industry.colorado.com/sites/default/files/BB_Stewardship.pdf
• https://www.colorado.com/news/colorado-tourism-office-and-leave-no-
trace-center-outdoor-ethics-join-ground-breaking
B. LeveragetheuniquenatureoftheParktodrivestewardship–TheAdirondackParkisincrediblyuniqueintheworldofparksandprotectedareas,e.g.size,management,largeWildernessareas,ForeverWildprotection,patchworkofpublic/privateland,opentomanyuses(consumptive,non-consumptive,motorized,non-motorized,etc.),incrediblehistory,etc.Assuch,theseindividualattributesortheuniquenatureoftheParkasawholeshouldbeutilizedasaleveragepointfornotonlyencouragingbutactivelydrivingstewardshipeffortsinthePark.ManyunitsoftheNationalParkServiceutilizeasimilarstrategywhenworkingtoencouragestewardship.SeeexamplesfromYellowstoneNationalPark:https://www.nps.gov/yell/planyourvisit/index.htm(theworld’sfirstnationalpark).InthisNPS-createdvideo,theParkServicespecificallynotestheattributesoftheParkthatsetitapartfromallothers,andexplicitlyaddressthenotionthatparkvisitorsshouldnotonlyenjoytheparkbutlearnaboutitanddosomethingtocareforit.TheAdirondackParkshouldemployasimilarstrategygiventhattheParkistrulyone-of-a-kind.
C. DevelopandwidelyadvertiseanAdirondackStewardshipPledge–Stewardship
pledgeshavebecomemorecommonoverthepastseveralyears.They’rebeingutilizedfornotonlyparksandprotectedareasbutalsoforspecialdestinations.Theuseofpledgesisatypeofsocialmarketingthatisintendedtoinfluencebehavior.TheAdirondackParkcouldlikelybenefitfromapark-specificpledge.Suchaninitiativecouldhavenumerousbenefits:engagethepublic,provideinformationonresponsibleenjoymentofthepark,encourageandfosteron-the-groundstewardship,promoteandeducatevisitorsaboutLeaveNoTrace,andcouldgeneratealargerfollowingonsocialmediachannels.Seeexamplesofexistingpledgesthatcouldbereplicated:
![Page 47: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
47
• https://palaupledge.com
• https://www.inspiredbyiceland.com/icelandicpledge
• https://www.aspenchamber.org/pledge
• https://www.pledgewild.com–thisisanexcellentexampleofagroupofmountaintownsinthewesternUScomingtogethertopromoteresponsibletourism.
• https://www.nps.gov/zion/planyourvisit/zion-pledge.htm
• https://www.nps.gov/yell/planyourvisit/yellowstonepledge.htm
• https://www.nps.gov/romo/planyourvisit/rockypledge.htm
• https://www.nps.gov/grca/getinvolved/grand-canyon-pledge.htm
• https://www.wmf.org/sustainable-tourism-pledge
Seealsorecentarticlesontheuseofpledges:
• https://www.adventuretravelnews.com/success-of-responsible-tourism-pledges-falls-on-destinations-not-travelers
• https://www.fastcompany.com/90379126/6-american-cities-ask-for-
responsible-tourism-pledge
D. Assesscurrentcross-bordermarketingandadvertisingaimedatCanadians–GiventhesignificantnumberofCanadianvisitorstotheHighPeaksregionitwouldbeadvisedtoconsiderbothexploringcurrentcross-bordermarketingeffortsanddeveloping(orenhancing)aplanforbetterreachingthesevisitorsbeforetheycometothePark.Determiningthecurrentinformationsourcesthesevisitorsusetoplantheirvisitswouldbeusefulandcouldbeaccomplishedviainternetresearchoron-sitevisitorsurveys.HavinganunderstandingofthevariousoptionsforreachingthiscommunityofParkvisitorswouldallowformoreeffectiveandtimelycommunicationandmarketingregardingresponsibleenjoymentoftheAdirondacks.
E. Continuetoworkwithopinionleadersintheregion–Astrategythathasbeeneffectiveinsheddinglightonrecreation-relatedimpactsformanymunicipal,state,andnationalparksandprotectedareasistheengagementandenlistmentoflocalorregional“opinionleaders”tohelpbringattentionandactiontoaproblem.IfDECoritspartnerscanidentifyasuiteofopinionleaders,e.g.theleaderofawell-knownhikinggrouporclub,leadingmembersofpopularAdirondackChallenges,or
![Page 48: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
48
corporateorgovernmentalentitiesincludingsuchinfluentialfigures/entities,thiscanhelpgeneratebroadsupportandawarenessforthePark.
IV.SocialMediaRecommendations
A. EstablishandfollowacomprehensivesocialmediastrategyforthePark–Itisclearthatsocialmediaplaysaroleindrivingvisitationtopubliclands.Additionally,socialmediahasthepowertoinfluencebehaviorofoutdoorenthusiasts.Whenharnessed,socialmediacanbeanexcellenttoolforengagingtensofthousandsorevenmillionsofpeople.However,intheabsenceofcoordinatedsocialmediaeffort,effectivenessislikelylimited.Therearenumerousadvantagestohavingasocialmediastrategy,whichinclude:a)astrategyforsocialmediaprovidescleardirectionforefforts,especiallyforsuchalargepark;b)astrategywillallowforassessingthemetricsofsocialmediaeffortsandwillalsoallowforbetterreportingandimprovementsovertime;c)astrategyallowsforgreaterefficiencyinutilizingandmanagingsocialmedia;d)astrategycanensureongoing,continuous,andconsistentactivityonvarioussocialplatformstokeepcontentfresh,relevant,andcoordinated;e)astrategycanallowforloftierandmoreeffectivecampaignsorspecificactivations;and,lastly;f)astrategywillkeepsocialmediaontrackasitshouldcontaininformationandproceduresforposting,replyingtotheaudience,dealingwithquestions,addressingadulationornegativecomments,andrespondingtocomplaints.SuchastrategyfortheParkmustbebroadinscope,andshouldbeasinclusiveaspossibletoengagemanypartnerstoparticipatetherebyprovidingalevelofconsistentsocialmediathroughoutthePark.
B. Partnerwithsocialmediainfluencers–Socialmediaisonlyasgoodasthefollower
baseofanyparticularuser(agency,NGO,club,individual,etc.).Socialinfluencermarketingisatacticthatisheavilyusedtodaybymany,andissimply“leveragingthefollowerbaseofinfluencers”forspecificpurposes–sales,donations,support,volunteerism,etc.Theuseofmarketingthroughsocialmediainfluencershasmanybenefits:itisconsideredalight-handedapproachthatdoesn’tfeelaggressivetotheenduserlikesometraditionalmarketingefforts;influencersmeticulouslybuildandcuratetheirfollowerbasesooftensocialinfluencersareviewedasacrediblesource;socialinfluencermarketingcan,overtime,liftSearchEngineOptimization(SEO);lastly,socialinfluencermarketingcanfostermeaningfulonlineexchangesthatcanengagemanyinatopicofspecificinterest.IdentifyingandcollaboratingwithsocialinfluencersinNewYorkandthebroaderAdirondackregiontochampionLeaveNoTraceand/orstewardshipeffortsintheParkcouldbeaneffectualstrategyforbuildingastrongersustainabilityculturefortheAdirondacks.
C. Considertheuseofsocialmediaasamonitoringtool–Somelandmanagersarenow
monitoringsocialmediafeedsandplatformsdailytodrawreal-timedatafromsocialposts.Oftentherecreatingpublicisawareofissuesbeforethelandmanager,andsocialmediahasbecomeanimportanttoolformanagers.Examplesofissuesthatmanagersarebeingmadeawareofviasocialchannelsincludehuman-wildlife
![Page 49: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
49
conflict,dangerouswildlife,dangeroustrailconditions,userconflict,accidents,andwildfire.
V.Partnerships&CoordinationRecommendations
A. Create(orreinvigorate)anAdirondackParkWildlandsStewardshipCommittee–ThecreationofanAdirondackParkWildlandsStewardshipCommitteewouldgreatlybenefitLeaveNoTraceeffortsinthePark.Acommitteethathaspark-widerepresentation,notjusttheHighPeaksorhikers,wouldbeaneffectivewaytobettercoordinatemarketing,socialmedia,outreach,education,andtrainingforthePark.Suchacommitteeshouldincludenon-motorizeduserssuchashikers,climbers,paddlers,anglers,mountainbikers,trailrunners,skiers,etc.aswellasmotorizedusers(e.g.snowmobilers,boaters,ATVriders,etc.)andotherssuchashuntersthatutilizethepublicandprivatelandsofthePark.Furthermore,acommitteeofthiskindwouldbewellservedbyhavingNGOrepresentation,agencyrepresentation,andrepresentativesfromthemunicipalitieswithinthePark.Considerasubcommitteestructure–education,socialmedia,citizenscience,research,training,etc.TheoverarchingpurposeofsuchacommitteewouldbetodrivestewardshipeffortsintheParkinacoordinatedandorganizedfashion,andwouldallowfortheidentificationofspecificsuccessmetricsasvisitationtotheParkcontinuestoincrease.
B. ExamineexistingDECpartnershipstoenhancestewardshipefforts–TheDEC
currentlyhasmanypartnershipagreementswithmyriadentitiesinthePark.SomeoftheseexistingpartnershipsinvolvetheuseanddisseminationofLeaveNoTracetoParkvisitors.However,therearelikelyopportunitiesthathaveyettobeidentifiedbyDECandallofitspartnersforbetterpromotingresponsibleenjoymentofthePark.Totheextentpossible,theDECshouldreviewcurrentpartnershipsandidentifyopportunitiesforprovidingminimumimpactinformationtothepopulationsthevariouspartnersrespectivelyserve.Themoreexistingpartnershipscanbeleveragedinamutuallybeneficialwaytopromoteaconsistentstewardshipmessage,themorepeoplethatcanbereachedovertime.
C. WorkmorecloselywiththeNYGovernor’sOfficetopromoteresponsiblerecreation
inthePark–GiventheNYGovernor’sinterestintheAdirondackPark,hisofficeshouldbeengagedtohelppromoteresponsibleenjoymentofthePark.EverymessagecomingfromtheGovernor’sOfficeabouttheParkshouldincludeamessageaboutwildlandsstewardshipandLeaveNoTrace.Asthechiefexecutiveofthestate,theGovernorhasatremendousopportunitytoreachmillionsofpeopleinordertohelpprotecttheAdirondacks.ConsiderationshouldbegiventoinvitingtheGovernortotheParkforatourofareaswhererecreation-relatedimpactismostsignificantsoheandhisstaffcanseefirsthandthechallengesfacedbyDECanditspartnersinthePark.GreaterawarenessoftheissuesfacedbytheParkcouldbethesparkthatleadstoincreasedfunding,attention,andresourcesforthePark.Given
![Page 50: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
50
thesignificanceoftheParkasaneconomicdriverforthestate,thisshouldbeahighpriorityiftheParkistobeenjoyedinperpetuity.
VI.GroupUse&Adirondack‘Challenges’Recommendations
A. Require(orstronglyrecommend)inclusionofLeaveNoTraceineveryParkchallenge–Allchallenges(46ers,CranberryLake50,FireTowerChallenge,SaranacLake6er,etc.)thatcurrentlytakeplaceintheParkshouldberequiredtoincludeLeaveNoTraceinformationforchallengeparticipants.Web-basedinformationaswellasthespecificinclusionofLeaveNoTraceintosuchchallengesshouldbestronglyrecommendedand/orrequired.Thesechallengesareoperatingonpubliclandsandhavearesponsibilitytominimizetheimpactofparticipation.Furthermore,manychallengeparticipantsmaybedrawntotheParkforothertypesofrecreationandeducatingallparticipantsacrossallchallengescouldfurthertheLeaveNoTraceethicinthePark.InareviewofmorethantenAdirondackchallengewebsites,itwasfoundthatvirtuallynoLeaveNoTraceinformationexistsonthewebsites.EachofthesechallengeshasasignificantopportunitytoreachthousandsifnotmillionsofParkvisitorsovertime.Assuch,thisrepresentsanimmediateopportunityforvisitoreducation.
B. CreateLeaveNoTraceguidelinesforchallenges–TheLeaveNoTraceCenterfor
OutdoorEthicsroutinelyworkswithpartnerstocreatetailoredLeaveNoTracemessagingandcurriculum.SuchaneffortcouldbeeasilyundertakentoensurethatallchallengesintheParkhavethenecessaryinformationtopromoteresponsibleenjoymentofthePark.Theinformationcouldbefeaturedoneachchallenges’website,andcouldevenbemadepartofthechallengeitself.
C. All“Challenge”events/programsintheParkshouldactivelypromoteLeaveNo
Trace–Notonlyshouldchallengesberequired(orstronglyrecommended)toincludeLeaveNoTraceontheirwebsitesbuttheyshouldactivelybepromotingLeaveNoTraceaspartoftheirpublicoutreachandmarketing.AsitcurrentlyexistsinthePark,thisisasignificantmissedopportunitytoreachmanypeople.
D. Conductasurveyofchallengetakers–Challengetakerswouldhavetoparticipatein
ashortsurveybeforetheycouldreceivetheirrecognition(e.g.patch,certificate,etc.)togatherdataonwhythey’retakingthechallenge,whattheirmotivationis,iftheyarespecificallygoal-focused,etc.Withthisdata,specificmessagingcouldbedevelopedtobetterresonatewithchallengeparticipantsregardingtheirroleintakingcareofthePark.
E. Implementagroupnotificationsystem–Considertheimplementationofagroup
notificationsystemsuchastheoneutilizedbytheAppalachianMountainClub(AMC)intheWhiteMountainsandtheMahoosucRange.TheAMCimplementedthissystemtobettermanagethehighovernightuseofsites.FromtheAMC,“Tobettermanagethesepublicwildlandssothatallhikerscontinuetoexperienceanuncivilized
![Page 51: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
51
forest,wemustreceivepre-notificationfromlargegroupsconcerningwhichsitestheyplantouse.ProperuseoftheGroupNotificationSystemhelpstopreventmultiplegroupsfromconvergingatacampsiteonagivennightandexceedingsitecapacity.Thissimpleactionhelpsusworktogethertolessenimpactsonthesebeautifulareas,minimizeovercrowding,andincreaseeveryone’senjoymentofthebackcountry.However,thisnotificationisnotaformalreservation.Allsitesaremanagedonafirst-come,first-servedbasis.WehopethatuseoftheGroupNotificationSystemwillpreventtheneedforamoreformalizedreservationsystem,whichwouldmeanmoreregulationsandfees.Yourcompliancehelpsusprotecttheresourcesweallvalue!”Formoreinformationonthissystem,see:https://www.outdoors.org/lodging-camping/lodging-camping-campsites/campsites-notificationSuchasystemintheAdirondackParkcouldbeaveryeffectivewaytomanagegroupusewithouthavingtomovetoaformalreservationsystem.Furthermore,thedatacollectedthroughthistypeofsystemcouldbevaluableforpredictingtrendsingroupuse,trackinggroupuse,monitoringimpacts,andaddressingissuesresultingfromgroupuseinthePark.
VII.Outreach&EducationRecommendations
A. Createaconsistent,cohesiveeducationalplanforthePark–Comparedtootherlandsusedbythepublicforrecreation,theAdirondackParkcurrentlyappearstobereceivingasimilaramountofrecreation-relatedresourceandsocialimpact.Levelofexistingimpactisimportantbecausetimingiskeytoimplementingsuccessfulvisitoreducationprograms.Thesooneraprogramisimplemented,thebetterofftheParkwillbeinthefuture,i.e.whenpossible,havinganeducationprograminplacepriorto(orconcurrentwith)theopeningofthenewtrails(e.g.newMt.VanHoevenbergtrail)orotherrecreationalamenities(e.g.FrontierTown)willhelpensureeffectivenessofoutreachandeducationalefforts.Itisofteneasiertodealwithproblemsinanascentstageratherthantryingtoaddressdeeply-rootedresourceorsocialimpacts.Assuch,theCenterstronglyrecommendstheimmediateimplementationofcomprehensiveLeaveNoTraceeducationaleffortsParkwidetobeginminimizingandmitigatingexistingandfutureimpacts.
B. Catalogexistingrules,regulations,andeducationalmessagesinthePark–
Currently,thelistsofrulesandregulationsarenotreadilyvisibleorconsistentonkiosksthroughoutthePark,andLeaveNoTrace-typeinformationisessentiallynon-existentinmuchPark-relatedliterature.Thisisarelativelyeasyfix,butsomethingthatshouldberemediedovertimeinordertoconsistentlypromoteresponsibleandsustainableenjoymentofthePark.Onewaytoaddressthiswouldbeforaninternorgraduatestudenttodocumentexistingmessages(regulatoryandeducational)beingusedintheParktobetterunderstandthegapsinoverallmessaging.FromthereaplancouldbecreatedtofosterconsistencyacrossthePark.
![Page 52: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
52
C. Ensureconsistencyofsignage–SomeofthemoreimportantsignagecurrentlyfoundintheParkshouldbemademoreprominentandconsistentacrossthePark.Whensignagedoesnothaveanofficiallookorfeel,itcanleadtonon-compliance.Makeallsignageaspermanentaspossible.Generallyspeaking,morepermanentsignagehasamoreauthentic,authoritative,andlegitimatefeel.Visitformoreinformationonvisitorperceptionsofsigns:https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Yu_Fai_Leung/publication/260165571_Frontcountry_visitor_informationeducation_programs_Are_there_lessons_for_wilderness/links/0a85e5367ce676a965000000.pdf
D. IdentifyandcapitalizeonmissedopportunitiestoreachParkvisitors–Whilethere
areactivevisitoreducationeffortsinmanypartsofthePark,therearealsomanymoreopportunitiesthathaveyettobecapitalizedon.Fromagencies,tolocationssuchastheVIC(PaulSmith’sCollege),tothevariousChallengesinthepark,aswellaslocationsliketheI-87exit17reststop,andinformationonshuttlevehicles,therearemanypotentialopportunitiestobettereducateParkvisitorsonenjoyingtheAdirondacksresponsibly.Furthermore,therearenumerouspublicationsthatshouldbeengagedinthiseffortastheyreachmanyvisitorsofalltypesinthePark.Acursoryreviewofpossibilitiesincludes:
• NYStateCampingGuide• TownofWebbTrailSystemmap• ILoveNYRoadmap• FrontierTownliterature,e.g.“EquestrianOpportunitiesNearFrontierTown”• OldForgeSummerFunGuide• AdirondackSports• AllAdirondack-focusedILoveNYGuides–CapitalSaratogaRegion,Seasonto
Seasonvisitorguide,ILoveNYTravelGuide,ILoveNYNewYorkStateTravelHighlights,etc.
• VICSummerProgramsGuide• AdirondacksFishingGuide• AdirondacksPaddlingGuide• DEC–YourNYSCampingAdventure(goodinformationbutcallit“LeaveNo
Trace”)• OldForgeSnowmobileTrailMap• AllDECdayuseandcampgroundmaps,e.g.LimekilnLake,AlgerIsland,
NicksLake,FishCreekPond,etc.• www.ReserveAmerica.comforcampgroundreservations
AninternatoneofthecollegesoruniversitiesinornearthePark,anagencyorNGOintern,orevenadedicatedvolunteercouldundertakesuchaproject.Knowingwhatopportunitiesexists,thatarenotcurrentlybeingcapitalizedon,willallowforatargetedandstrategicefforttomaximizeandutilizeallavailableoutreachopportunities.
![Page 53: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
53
E. PSAReducationefforts–AccordingtotheDECthereareaccuratestatisticsonthenumberofsearchandrescueoperations(SAR)thatoccurinthePark.GiventheincreaseinSARinthepastfewyearsthereappearstobeaneed(andanopportunity)todevelopaPreventativeSearchandRescue(PSAR)educationaleffortand/orprogramwiththegoalofreachingparkvisitorsaboutbeingpreparedandstayingsafebeforetheyventureintothebackcountryofthePark.SuchaprogramwouldneedtobecoordinatedacrossthePark,andcouldinvolveawidevarietyofpartnersthatcouldallpromoteasinglePSARmessage.SeeexampleofsuccessfulPSAReffortsatGrandCanyonNationalPark:
• https://www.nps.gov/articles/parkscience33-1_99-
107_malcolm_heinrich_3864.htm
• https://www.nps.gov/grca/learn/photosmultimedia/hike_smart-01.htmForresearchonthetopic,see:Malcolm,C.,Hannah,H.,&Pearce,E.(2014).Effectivenessofpreventativesearchandrescue:illnessandinjurypreventionandfiscalimpact.Wilderness&EnvironmentalMedicine,25(3),355-356.Collins,EthanG.andPettengill,PeterR.(2019).AnalysisofSearchandRescueIncidentsintheAdirondackStateParkfrom2015-2016.AdirondackJournalofEnvironmentalStudies,23,49-59
F. Replicatesuccessfulexistingoutreachefforts–Therearenumerousexisting
outreacheffortsinthePark(e.g.HPICatADK,summerinvasivespecies/boatinspectionstewards,firetowerstewards,etc.)thatcouldbereplicatedovertime.Giventhedocumentedeffectivenessofthesekindsofefforts,itwouldbebeneficialandmoreefficienttoenhanceandexpandonprovenoutreachmodelsratherthantocreatenewonesoutofwholecloth.Furthermore,itmayinitiallybeeasiertoraisethenecessaryfundstoreplicateeffortsthathavegeneratedesiredoutcomesratherthanfunduntestededucationandoutreachmechanisms.
G. TailorDECwebsitetowhatvisitorsaresearchingformost–Whiletherearegood
resourcesontheDEC’scurrentwebsite,areviewutilizingGoogleAnalyticsorathird-partyauditorofthemostvisitedpageswouldallowfortheagencytobettertailorthewebsitetocurrentParkvisitors.OncetheDEChasabetterunderstandingofwhatwebsitepagesvisitorsaresearchingfororviewing,thatinformationcanthenbelocated(orrelocated)tomoreaccessiblelocationsonthewebsite.MakingthemostsearchedforinformationbetteravailableandmoreeasilylocatedwouldgreatlybenefitvisitorstotheDECwebsitewhensearchingforinformationonresponsibleandsustainableenjoymentofthePark.
![Page 54: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
54
H. SearchEngineOptimization–WhensearchingtheinternetforinformationontheAdirondackPark,themostprominentwebsitesarelargelytourism-focusedwebsites(thisisasignificantmarketing/outreachopportunity)andtheDECwebsiteisn’tfounduntilthesecondpageofaGooglesearch.Assuch,theDECshouldworkwithsearchengineoptimization(SEO)expertstoenhancethesearchabilityoftheDEC’swebsitegiventheagency’sroleinthemanagementandprotectionofthePark.BasedonacursoryreviewofsomeofthePark-relatedwebsitesthatarefoundviaGoogle,veryfewprovideinformationonresponsibleenjoyment(i.e.LeaveNoTrace)ofthePark,andnonewerefoundthatdetailedtherulesandregulationsforthePark.SearchengineoptimizationcouldhelpremedythissituationandmaketheDEC’swebsiteaprominentandeasily-accessedsourceofinformationforthePark.
I. CreateasingularwebsitefortheHighPeaks–Becauseoftheintenseandgrowing
useoftheHighPeaks,DECanditspartnersintheHighPeaksshouldconsiderasinglewebsitefortheareathatcouldserveasthecomprehensiveanddefinitiveinformationsourceforthosewishingtovisit.SuchasitecouldbeinbothEnglishandFrenchtoaccommodatevisitorsfromboththeUSandCanada.TherearecurrentlynumerouswebsitesthatprovideinformationabouttheHighPeakswhichcreatesinconsistenciesfromonesitetothenext.Aquicksearchonwww.networksolutions.comrevealsthatpotentialURLssuchaswww.adkpeaks.org(or.net),www.nyhighpeaks.org(or.net)andwww.adkhighpeaks.org(or.net)areallcurrentlyavailable.HavingonewebsitededicatedtothisspecialregionoftheParkwouldbeanexcellentwaytohelpensurethatvisitorstotheHighPeakscouldhaveaccesstoaccurateandtimelyinformationtothearea.
J. Publicizeexistingshuttleservices–TherearesomeshuttleservicesintheParkthat
havebeenimplementedtoremedythemyriadparkingissuesmanagersandpartnersarecurrentlydealingwithintheAdirondacks.Whilewellintentioned,suchservicesarevirtuallyuselessunlessParkvisitorsknowabouttheservices.TheDECanditspartnersshouldcatalogallexistingshuttleservicesandwidelypromotethemandthebenefitstheyprovide.AllvisitorsshouldbeencouragedtousetheseservicestobenefittheParkandtheexperienceitisintendedtoprovide.Forresearchonshuttleservicesinparksandprotectedareas,see:
• https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0966692313000525
• https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=684539079697772;
res=IELBUS
• https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00267-006-0061-9
K. Catalogthetop50(or100)educationalopportunitiesinthePark–Considerutilizinganinternorstudent(undergraduateorgraduate)toidentifyandcatalogthetop50–100educationalopportunitiesintheParkthatarenotcurrentlybeingutilized.Fromoutfitterandguideservicestoretailerstohotelandlodgingto
![Page 55: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
55
restaurantsandbars,therearemanypotentialopportunitiesforreachingvisitorsthathaveyettobetakenadvantageof.However,withoutabetterunderstandingoftheopportunitiesthatexistitwillbechallengingtocreateaplanforensuringthedisseminationofconsistentLeaveNoTraceorotherparkinformationthroughsuchoutlets.
L. EnsureLeaveNoTraceispartofrelevantcollegeorientationprograms,courses,and
outingprograms–TherearenumerouscollegesanduniversitiesthatprovideavarietyofprogrammingintheParkofferingmeaningfulopportunitiestoreachstudents(andstaff)withLeaveNoTraceinformationforthePark.DECanditspartnersshouldreachouttoallknowncollegesanduniversitiesthatoperateintheParkinsomecapacitytoensuretheyareprovidingLeaveNoTracetotheirparticipantsbeforeandduringanyvisit.
VIII.TrainingRecommendations
A. SpecifictrainingforDECstaffandrangers–ConsidersendingDECForestRanger,ECOs,andLandsandForestsstafftotargetedtrainingonproperuseoftheAuthorityoftheResourceTechnique,aprovenmethodforeffectivelyinteractingwithParkvisitorsaboutLeaveNoTraceandsimilarstewardshipconcepts.ThistrainingisoftencoupledwithEffectiveCommunicationtraining,whichisdesignedforstaffandvolunteerswhoroutinelyinterfacewithParkvisitors.Thisparticulartrainingmoduleisgenerallya4-hourtrainingbutcanbetailoredtoaparticularaudienceformaximumeffectiveness.ContacttheCenterforadditionaldetails.MoreinformationontheAuthorityoftheResourcetechniquecanbefoundhere:https://lnt.org/sites/default/files/ART_Wallace_Original.pdf
B. EntitiesoperatingunderaVolunteerServiceAgreement(VSA)shouldbetrainedinLeaveNoTrace–AnyentityoperatingonstatelandsasavolunteerwithDEChastheopportunitytoprovideLeaveNoTraceeducation,whetheritisexplicitlyintheirmission(suchasFrontCountryStewards)ornot(suchasvolunteertrailcrews).OrganizerscouldberequiredtohaveLeaveNoTraceAwarenesstraining(a1-dayorshorterformalLeaveNoTracetraining)ataminimum.TheLeaveNoTraceCenteroffersaFREEonlineLeaveNoTraceAwarenessCoursethatparticipantscouldtake.Uponsuccessfulcompletion,participantsreceiveacertificateofcompletion,whichcouldbesubmittedaspartoftheVSAapplicationorrenewalapplication.
C. SummercampstaffshouldbetrainedinLeaveNoTrace–Therearecountless
summercamps(bothdayandresident)intheAdirondackPark.CampsrepresentatremendousopportunitytoreachbothcampstaffandyouthwithLeaveNoTraceinanoutdoorcontext.TheLeaveNoTraceCenterhasarobustsuiteofcamp-focusededucationalcurriculumandprogramsthatareeffectiveatincreasingLeaveNoTraceknowledgeincampparticipantsaswellasinfluencingyouthbehaviortobetteralignwithLeaveNoTraceintheoutdoors.Formoreinformation,see:
![Page 56: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
56
• https://lnt.org/our-work/youth-education/
• https://lnt.org/our-work/youth-education/accreditation/
• https://lnt.org/our-work/youth-education/youth-educator-library/
• https://lnt.org/our-work/youth-education/things-to-do/
D. MakeLeaveNoTracearequiredcomponentofNYGuideLicensure–Currently
thereareapproximately2,500licensedguidesinNewYork,whichrepresentsatremendousopportunitytoeducateaprofessionalcommunityaboutLeaveNoTracethathasasignificantreachintheAdirondackPark.Outfitterandguideservicesoftencatertobeginnersornoviceswhoareinterestedinlearningnewoutdooractivities.Assuch,guidesareteachingspecificskillsandLeaveNoTraceshouldbeoneofthoseskillsthatisimpartedtoeveryindividualorgroupthatisservedbyaNYDECLicensedGuide.Furthermore,allNYGuidesshouldberequiredtohaveLeaveNoTraceAwarenesstraining(a1-dayorshorterformalLeaveNoTracetraining)ataminimum.TheLeaveNoTraceCenteroffersaFREEonlineLeaveNoTraceAwarenessCoursethatallguidescouldtake.Uponsuccessfulcompletion,participantreceiveacertificate.Thatcertificateofcompletioncouldbesubmittedaspartoftheguidelicenseapplicationortherenewalapplication.Lastly,theNYGuideexamcouldeasilyincorporateLeaveNoTracetoensurethatalllicensedguidesareawareofhowtominimizetheimpactoftheirguidingserviceandpassalongtheinformationtotheirclients.SeeLeaveNoTraceonlinecourse:https://lnt.org/get-involved/training-courses/online-awareness-course/
IX.Dept.ofEnvironmentalConservationRecommendationsA. DECworkwithmedia/outdoorindustrymedia–DEChasatremendousopportunity
toexpanditsoutreachandengagementwithoutdoorindustrymediaentitiesthatarepromotingtheAdirondackPark.ThesekindsofinfluencerscanplayakeyroleinpromotingresponsibleenjoymentofthePark.AninternetsearchrevealsnumerousmediaoutletsthatareheavilypromotingtheParkyetprovidelittletonoinformationonresponsibleenjoymentoftheareasthey’repromoting.Afewexamplesinclude:www.lonelyplanet.com;www.visittheusa.com;www.tripadvisor.com;www.alltrails.com;www.outside.com;www.backpacker.com;www.wikipedia.com;www.adirondackexplorer.com;www.outdoorproject.com,aswellasmanyothers.
B. IncludeLeaveNoTraceintheDECRangerAcademy–TheDEC’sEnvironmentalConservationPoliceOfficerandForestRangerBasicTrainingacademyshouldincludearobustLeaveNoTracecomponent.GiventheroleofECOsandForestRangersintheprotectionofthePark,interactionwiththepublicisakeypartofthescopeofworkforthesecrucialstaff.EnsuringthatECOsandRangersareequipped
![Page 57: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
57
withLeaveNoTracewillallowthemtopassalongcriticalinformationtooutdoorenthusiaststheyinterfacewiththroughoutthecourseoftheirduties.ResearchhasshownthatvisitorstopubliclandsoftenfirstlearnaboutLeaveNoTracefromaranger.Assuch,itisimperativethatDECfieldstaffarewell-versedinLeaveNoTraceskillsandethics.
C. CreateaDECJuniorRangerProgram–ConsiderthedevelopmentofanAdirondack
ParkJuniorRangerProgramthatcontainsaLeaveNoTracecomponent.Suchprogramsarewidelyutilizedbythefederallandmanagementagencies,andbysomestateagenciesaswell.Generally,theseprogramsarestructuredtoengageyouthages5–15butsomeencourageparticipationofadultsofanyageaswell.ThemajorityofthesekindsofprogramsincludeLeaveNoTraceactivitiesandassociatededucationalopportunities.TheNationalParkServicehasanexcellentJr.Rangerprogram:https://www.nps.gov/kids/junior-rangers.htmthathasbeenverysuccessfulinAmerica’snationalparks.Twootherexamples,onefromTexasStateParks:https://tpwd.texas.gov/spdest/programs/jr_ranger/andtheotherfromCaliforniaStateParks:http://kids.parks.ca.gov/?page_id=22783.Thesekindsofprogramsareeasytoreplicate,doanexcellentjobofengagingyouth,andhaveaddedbenefitssuchasparentalinvolvement(andsubsequentlearning).ThistypeofprogramcouldberolledoutParkwideintheAdirondacks,andcouldhelpfosterthenextgenerationofParkstewards.
D. Enforcementofexistingregulations–DECmanagersshouldexploreoptionsfor
greaterenforcementofrulesandregulationsinthePark.Iftheapplicablerulesandregulationscannotbeenforcedadequately,managerswillhavetorelysolelyonvoluntarycompliance,whichhasbeenshowntobelowforsomeissues.Additionally,DECcouldconsiderdevelopingamatrixfororganizingthoseimpactsintheParkthatarebestsuitedtolawenforcementandthosethatcouldeffectivelybeaddressedthrougheducationalefforts.SuchamatrixwouldallowDECstafftobejudiciouswithitsresources,andfosteramoretargetedapproachtomanaging,mitigating,andminimizingimpactsintheParkthroughbotheducationandlawenforcement.
X.InfrastructureRecommendations
A. Technological/infrastructuresolutions–DECanditspartnerswillneedtofurtherexplorewhichkindofinfrastructureandfacilitiesare,orwillbe,necessarytoprovidetheintendedvisitorexperience.Thisinfrastructurecanbeusedasaneffectivemanagementtool,e.g.parkingareascanbedesignedtolimitvisitationbasedonnumberofparkingspaces,high-trafficareascanbehardenedtominimizetramplingeffects,campsitescanbebuilttocontainandminimizeimpacts,etc.Thougheducationiseffective,technicalsolutionssuchasinfrastructure,arenecessaryandappropriateattimestomanagehighvisitoruseandrecreation-relatedimpacts.Moreinformationcanbefoundhere:https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jeffrey_Marion/publication/242240482_Ma
![Page 58: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
58
naging_Visitor_Impacts_in_Parks_A_Multi-Method_Study_of_the_Effectiveness_of_Alternative_Management_Practices/links/02e7e53a037ba53d93000000/Managing-Visitor-Impacts-in-Parks-A-Multi-Method-Study-of-the-Effectiveness-of-Alternative-Management-Practices.pdf
B. Considerestablishingactualvisitorcenter(s)forthePark–Thoughafew“visitor
centers”existinthePark,thereisnotaformalvisitorcenter(orsuiteofvisitorcenters)thatoffersaone-stop-shopforParkvisitors.Federalandstatelandmanagersroutinelyutilizevisitorcenterstointeractwithvisitors,provideeducation,interpretation,guestservices,andresources(books,maps,equipment,etc.).DECanditspartnersshouldevaluatetheneedforasinglevisitorcenter(orperhapsmultiple)forthePark.NYSDOTdatashowsthatthemajorityofvisitorsaccesstheParkthroughafewkeyentrypoints,whichmakestheideaofformalvisitorcenterspotentiallymorefeasible.GiventhatthereisnosingleentrypointforthePark,coupledwiththefactthattheParkhasaporousboundary,anassessmentshoulddeterminethefeasibilityoftrulyutilizingsuchfacilitiesforeducationandoutreachpurposesamongotherthings.
![Page 59: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
59
AdditionalRecommendedMethodsandTacticsforEducatingAdirondackParkVisitors• Brochures–Distributeatvisitorcentersandnaturalareasorindividualpilotsites–
tailoredLeaveNoTraceeducationalinformationthatcouldbedistributedattrailheads,managerandpartneroffices,orotherrecreationsites,theChambersofCommerceortourismpartnersintheParkandsurroundingcommunities,othergovernmentaloffices,localoutdoorretailshops,throughNGOpartners,theAdirondackMountainClub,theAdirondackCouncil,otherkeypartnersandstakeholders,andatothervenuesthroughoutthePark.
• Trailhead/ParkSignage–Whendonecorrectly,signagecanbeaneffectivetoolfordisseminatinginformationtoParkusers.Theinformationcontainedonsignswouldneedtobeconsistentwithotheroutreachmethods,andwouldprovidelocallyrelevantinformation.Placementofsignageandkioskcanbeanimportantfactor(theCentercanprovidemoreinformationonthisdependingonlocalvariables,constraints,andimpacts).GiventhevastanddispersednatureofthePark,andpotentialstafflimitations,signscanbeaneffectivemanagementstrategyforprovidingLeaveNoTraceinformationaswellasrules,regulations,andotherarea-specificinformation.OnekeyistheneedtohaveconsistentsignagethroughouttheParkinordertobestreachvisitorsrepeatedlywithstewardshipmessages.
• InformationonParkMaps–Locally-tailoredtocovertheentireParkorevenspecific
partsofthePark.Informationcouldbefurthertailoredtoaspecificactivityorusergroup.
• Website–Consistentinformationacrossthemanager/partnerspectrum,possibly
includingalinktotheLeaveNoTracewebsitesovisitorscangetevenmoreinformationiftheysodesire,canbeacriticaleducationaltool.Web-basedinformationshouldbethemostup-to-dategiventheeaseandrelativelowcostofupdating.ConsiderhavingaspecificLeaveNoTracesectionofagencyandpartnerwebsitessimilartowhatmostnationalparks,manystateparks,andnumerousmunicipalitieshave:
https://www.nps.gov/olym/planyourvisit/wilderness-leave-no-trace.htm;https://austintexas.gov/leavenotrace;https://dnr.maryland.gov/publiclands/Pages/lnt.aspx;andhttp://stateparks.mt.gov/protect-and-respect/leaveNoTrace.html
• ContinuetocoordinatePublicServiceAnnouncements–Anewtopiceach
week/month/season/year–“TipsforLeavingNoTraceintheAdirondackPark.”PSAscouldbedistributedthroughavarietyofoutlets–agencyandpartnerwebsites,localprintanddigitalmedia,regionalmedia,NGOs,socialmedia,etc.
• StaffTraining–Providetrainingforappropriateagencyandpartnerstaff–fromthe1-
hourLeaveNoTraceAwarenessWorkshoptothe2-dayLeaveNoTraceTrainerCourse,
![Page 60: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
60
tothe5-dayLeaveNoTraceMasterEducatorCourse(theAdirondackMountainClubisanapprovedMasterEducatorCourseProvider).AllowstaffandkeypartnerstheopportunitytolearnmoreaboutLeaveNoTrace,thesciencebehindit,andhowtoeffectivelyteachit.SuchtrainingcouldbeacriticalcomponentoftheoverallLeaveNoTraceeffortsinthePark.
• Trainingforkeypartners,volunteers,orinterestedindividuals–LeaveNoTrace
Trainingcouldbeprovidedbyagency/partnerstafforotherappropriatevolunteersforthegeneralpublic,volunteergroups,schoolgroups,etc.ThiskindoftrainingcouldengageexistingParksupporters,andfurtherbuildstrongerstewardshipeffortsforthePark.
• InterpretiveWalks/Presentations/RangerTalks–ThesecouldbeofferedbyDECor
partnersonaweeklyormonthlybasistoteachlocals,Parkusers,andtouristsabouttheuniqueresourcesfoundintheParkatkeylocations,suchascampgroundsandotherDECfacilities.Theseeducationalmethodsofferturnkeyopportunitiesfordisseminatinginformationaboutwaystominimizerecreationalimpacts.Theseeducationalsessionshelpbuildasenseof“ownership”andfosterstewardshipinParkvisitorsandsupporters.ConsiderbuildingLeaveNoTraceintoexistingprogramsofthiskindalreadybeingofferedbyDECandotherpartners.
• VolunteerPrograms–ProgramssuchasAdopt-a-ParkorFriendsoftheHighPeakscould
beveryusefulinthiseffort(assumingsimilarprogramsexistorcanbecreated).Training(bothLeaveNoTraceandAuthorityoftheResource)forvolunteersiskeysothattheycaneffectivelyinteractwithparkusersregardingLeaveNoTraceatparkingareas,trailheads,andatdestinations.Currently,trainingrequirementsaremostlylefttotheorganizationholdingtheVolunteerServiceAgreement(VSA).DECcouldrequireallorganizationsholdingVSAstoprovideLeaveNoTracetraining,eitherinpersonorviatheFREEonlineAwarenessWorkshop.
Volunteerprogramscouldbeaveryeffectivewaytohelpmanagevisitoruse,andprovidemeaningfulpublicoutreachandeducation.Researchandbestpracticehasdemonstratedthatvolunteerscanoftenmakeveryworthwhileandlastingpubliccontacts,giventhattheirpersonalattachmenttoaparticularparkornaturalareaisondisplaywheninteractingwiththerecreatingpublicratherthanuniformedagencypersonnel.Thereisagreatdealofstrategytoensuringthatvolunteerscanbeeffectivelyutilizedinparksandprotectedareaswithoutcompromisingtheirpersonalsafety.Additionally,volunteersmustbedeployedinareasthataremorelikelytobenefitfromsuchapresence,i.e.areaswithrecreation-relatedimpactssuchaspetwaste,off-trailtravel,wildlifefeeding,etc.ratherthanthosewhereillegalactivitiescomprisethegreatestmanagementconcerns.
• InterpretiveSignage–SignagecouldbeplacedatstrategiclocationsinandaroundtheParktoeducateusersabouttheareastheyarerecreatingin,theecosystemfunction,andwaystoprotectsuchareasbyusingLeaveNoTraceskillsandtechniques,e.g.
![Page 61: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
61
signageinriparianareas,historicalfeatures,criticalwildlifehabitat,sensitiveplanthabitat,etc.Researchhasshownthatvisitorsareoftenmoreapttoprotectwhattheyunderstand.Suchinterpretivesignage,whendeployedintherightcircumstance,canaccomplishbothraisingawarenessandimpartinganeffectivestewardshipmessage.
• SupplementaryOutreachMethods:
v AnAdirondackPark-specificethicsreferencecardcouldbeproducedanddistributedtoParkvisitors.Thesecardsgenerallycontainapproximately500wordsoftext,highlightingthekeyissuesinanarea,andspecifictechniquesforminimizingimpactinthearea.TheCenterhasutilizedsuchcardsforover20yearswithgreatsuccess.Theyarerelativelyinexpensive(~$0.20percard),visitorsgenerallylikethecards,andtheyareoftenkeptaseitherakeepsake/mementooraneducationaltool.TheNYSDEChaspreviouslyhadastandardlanguage,butspecificallyForestRangerbrandedethicscard,whichitdistributedtothepublic.SeeappendixII
v AnAdirondackParkappforsmartphoneuserscouldbecreatedthatwouldgivepertinentParkinformationaswellasrelevantLeaveNoTraceinformationtailoredtothePark.
v Informationcouldbepostedonthebackofrestroomstalldoors–captive
audience.
![Page 62: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
62
BenefitsofUsingLeaveNoTracefortheAdirondackPark
Ø ThrougheffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducation,recreation-relatedresourceandsocialimpactscanbeavoided,minimized,ormitigated.
Ø Bycreatingacultureofstewardshipandresponsiblerecreation,therecouldbeanoverallincreaseinvisitorsatisfactionwiththePark,whichcouldleadtogreatersupportforconservationoftheAdirondackPark.
Ø AneffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationprogramcouldleadtoareductioninmaintenanceneedsforParkamenitiessuchastrails,campsites,campgrounds,shelters,etc.
Ø Locally-tailoredLeaveNoTracemessagingandinformationwouldmeettherecreationandresourceneedsoftheAdirondackParkand/orindividuallocationsifdesired.
Ø Tappingintoanexisting,well-establishedprogramcanconservebothstaffandfinancialresources,asmuchoftheworkhasalreadybeendonebytheCenterforOutdoorEthics.
Ø TheworkundertakenintheAdirondackParkwouldbepromotednationallyasa
modelforotherrecreationalresourcesofthiskind.
Ø TheAdirondackPark(anditsmanagersandpartners)wouldbedirectlylinkedwiththepremier,nationallyrecognizedoutdoorskillsandethicseducationprogram.
![Page 63: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
63
PotentialResearchBecauseLeaveNoTraceisresearch-based,theCenterstrivestoincorporateresearchcomponentsintoappropriateprojectsorinitiativestoassesstheeffectivenessofeducationaleffortsand/orchangesinresourceconditions.Researchcanbeundertakeninavarietyofwaysfromsimplequestionnairesoronlinesurveystomorein-depth,scientificresearchconductedbymaster’sstudentsordoctoralcandidatesinconjunctionwithauniversityorcollege.Thesetypesofempiricalstudiesgenerallyresultinpeer-reviewed,publishableresearch,andaddtothebodyofparkandprotectedareamanagementliterature.RecentlytheCenterhasbeenusinganapproachtoexploreLeaveNoTrace-relatedbehaviorsofinterestwhichhasprimarilyconsistedofvisitorobservationcoupledwithsurveydata.Thismethodologyasksstudyparticipantswhattheywoulddowhilealsoobservingwhattheyactuallydoinaparkcontext.Throughamulti-method,experimentaldesignincludingunobtrusiveobservation,andpairedvisitorsurveydatacollection,thistypeofstudymethodologycanexamineattitudes,norms,perceptions,andmotivationsthatleadtovariousbehaviorsinparksandprotectedareas.Italsoprovidesopportunitiestoexploretheefficacyofindirectanddirectmanagementstrategiesforreducingrecreation-relatedimpactsandgarneringappropriatebehaviorbyparkvisitors.
SampleMethodologiesFormethodologiesthatinvolvepairedsurveyswithbehavioralobservation,specificstudyobjectivesoftenincludethefollowing:
1. Explorationofcurrentpractices,educationalstrategies,andmessagessurroundingspecificbehaviorsofinterestthroughdirectobservationand/orvisitorsurveys;
2. Thedeploymentofaseriesofeducationaland/orregulatorytreatments/controltorandomlyselectedproblemareasinselectlocationsusingastratifiedsamplingstrategy(e.g.,attemptingdistributedstratificationbyAM/PM,weekday/weekend,treatment,location,pairedsampling/observationonlysampling)overasettimeperiod(e.g.one-monthperiod),todeterminewhichtreatmentismosteffectiveatreducingimpactsfromthespecificbehavior(s)ofinterest;
3. Thepairingofobservedvisitors’responsestotreatments/controlwithsurveydata
fromthosesameobservedindividualsorpartiesforcomparativeanalysisofobservedandreportedbehavior.
OthersocialsciencemethodsutilizedbytheCenteranditsacademiccollaboratorsincludeon-site,researcher-administratedvisitorsurveys.Whenusingvisitorsurveystoexplorespecificparkandprotectedareatopicsofinterest,therearegenerallyfourprimarystudyobjectives:1)Togainanunderstandingofvisitors’attitudes,perceptions,andmotivationstowardspecificissues,impacts,orbehaviorsthroughtheoretically-basedvisitorsurveys;
![Page 64: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
64
2)Tocatalogthequantityorqualityofimpactatselectedsitesinparksandprotectedareas;3)Todevelopanintegratedunderstandingoftherelationshipbetweenpatternsofimpactand/orbehaviorsofinterestandtheinfluencesofsocialandmanagerialconstructsonthesepatterns;4)Toadvanceeducationalandmanagementrecommendationsforreducingthesocialandecologicalimpactsofrecreationthroughdirectand/orindirectmanagementactions.
ResearchCouldAnswertheFollowingQuestions
• CouldeffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationprovideadirectandmeasurablereductioninbothbiophysicalresourceimpactsandsocialimpactsintheAdirondackPark?
• CouldeffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationprovideareductioninnecessaryfacilities
maintenanceintheAdirondackPark?
• CouldeffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationresultinareductioninavoidablesearchandrescueoperationsintheAdirondackPark?
• CouldeffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationincreasevisitorsatisfactionwithoutdoor
recreationexperiencesintheAdirondackPark?
• CouldeffectiveLeaveNoTraceeducationleadtoanimprovementinthebiophysicalresourceandsocialconditionsintheAdirondackPark?
Ataminimum,itwouldbebeneficialtogatheranypossiblebaselinedatathroughacompilationofanecdotalevidence,photodocumentation,GPSdata,surveys,citizenscience,orothermeans.ThemoreinformationAdirondackParkmanagersandpartnershavepriortoprogramimplementation,thebettertheoveralleffectivenessofeducationeffortscanbemeasured,documented,andenhancedovertime.ForacomprehensiveoverviewoftheCenter’sresearch,visit:https://lnt.org/research-resources/leave-no-trace-focused-research-2011-2018/
![Page 65: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
65
ModelLeaveNoTraceLanguagetoAddressIssuesThefollowingsamplelanguage(invariousforms)hasbeensuccessfullyusedinnumerouslocationsacrosstheU.S.,includingParkCity,UT;WashingtonDC;LittleRock,AR;Boulder,CO;Boise,ID;LasVegas,NV;Kennesaw,GA;Phoenix,AZ;Philadelphia,PA;Madison,WI;Golden,CO;etc.,andcouldserveasastartingpointtodevelopthemostrelevantandeffectivemessagesthatareconsistentwithexistingrulesandregulationsfoundtheAdirondackPark.Understandably,thislanguagewillneedtosyncwithexistingParkrules,regulations,andspecificmanagementobjectivesinordertoberelevantandeffective.Petwaste:PickUpPoop–Phew!Dogpoopstinks,isnotnaturaltoForestParkandotherscanstepinit.Packapick-upbagorgraboneatthetrailheadandalwayspickupyourdog’spoop–whereveritmaybe.Dogpoopisahealthhazard.ItalsoincreasesthenitrogeninthesoilinForestPark,givingweedsanadvantageoverthenativeplantsthathavenaturallyevolvedinForestPark.DogpoopcanalsocontributetowaterpollutionintheuniqueriparianareasfoundinForestPark.Thanksforbaggingyourdog’spoop,butremember,thejob’snotdoneuntilyoudropitinthetrashcan.PleasedoyourparttokeepForestParkdogpoopfree.Petmanagement:ManageYourDog–Keepingyourdogincontrolkeepspeople,otherdogs,livestockandwildlifesafe.Othersmaynotappreciateyourdog’scompany;ifnotsure,askbeforeallowingyourdogtoapproachthem.Pleasedonotletyourdogapproachothersunlessinvited.DogsmustbeonleashatalltimesinForestParkunlessyou'reinanoff-leasharea.Inareaswhereleashesaren'trequired,keepyourdognearbyandundercontrol.Beaware-checksignsandfollowarearegulations.Keeptrackofyourpetswhileyou’rerecreatinginForestPark.Apetundercontrollessensthechanceforharmtoyourdogfromotherdogsorwildlife.Pleasedonotletyourdogapproachorchasewildlife.Chasedorharassedwildlifechangetheirfeedingpatternsandexertmoreenergy,whichcanresultinpoorhealthorevendeath.Respectadjacentprivatepropertybynotallowingyourdogtowanderfromdesignatedtrailsoroff-leashareas.Remember,unlessyou'reinanoff-leasharea,petsmustbeonleashinForestPark.Pleasedoyourparttomanageyourdog.Userconflict:ShareourTrails–WeallenjoyForestParkindifferentways.Payattention,expecttoencounterothers,slowdownandbecourteous-offerafriendlygreeting.Thosetravelingfastershouldslowdownforotherusers.Downhillriders,hikersandrunnersshouldalwaysyieldtoallotherusers.
![Page 66: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
66
Bikers,becauseoftheirmobility,shouldalwaysyieldtohikersandhorsebackriders.Thebestchoicewhenyieldingistostop,thenstepoffthetrailontoadurablesurface(rock,sand,etc.)andremainuntilotherspass.Ifyoucontinuetohikeorrideofftrailwhenyielding,youtrampletrailsidevegetationandcreatemultipletrailswhereoneisusuallybest.Weallknowhowgreatoutdoorexperiencescanbe.Onediscourteouspersoncanruinanouting.Expectandrespectothers.Makeroomforothers.Controlyourspeed.Passwithcareandletothersknowyou'repassing.Becourteousandwe'llallhaveabettertime.Litter:TrashYourTrash–Pleasepickupalltrash–yoursandothers’.Evenbiodegradablematerials,suchasorangepeels,applecoresandfoodscrapstakemonthstobreakdownandattractscavengersthatcanharmnativewildlife.Trashisunsightlyandruinseveryone’soutdoorexperience.Studieshaveshownthattrashattractsscavengingbirdsandanimalsthatdriveawayorkillnativebirds.Let’salldoourparttotakecareofForestParkbypickingupalltrash.Protectionofriparianareas:ProtectOurWaterORKeepOurWaterHealthy–ForestParkishometomanyuniqueresourcesincludingriparianareas–thegreenvegetatedareasoneachsideofstreamsandcreeks.Bothpeopleandanimalsaredrawntowater,especiallyinforestedenvironmentslikethosefoundinForestPark.RiparianareasarevitaltothehealthanddiversityofplantsandanimalsinForestPark.Theseareasareoftenthesolehabitatformanyplantandanimalspeciesthatneedwetconditions.Riparianareassupplyfoodandcoverforanimals;provideabuffer,whichactsasafiltertohelppreventwatercontamination;reducetheriskofflooding;andhelpreducestreambankerosion.Doyourparttohelpprotectthiscriticalresourcebystayingontrails,onlyaccessingthewateratdesignatedaccesspoints,keepinglitter,humanandpetwasteoutofthewater,andnottramplingstreamsidevegetation.Pleasehelpprotectourwater.Off-trailtravel:SticktoTrails–Stayingontrailsprotectswildlifeandtheirhomes.Shortcuttingtrailscauseserosionanddamagestrailsideplants.Pleasewalkandrideondesignatedtrailsonly.Contact[insertappropriatecontactorweblink]fortrailinformationandmaps.Studieshaveshownthatwhenwetramplevegetationonthesideofthetrail,thereisagreaterchanceweedswillreplacenativeplants.Inthisenvironment,nativeplantstakemonthstorecoverfromtramplingdamage.
![Page 67: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
67
Avoidareasthatareunmarked,closedforrevegetationorsignedassensitive.Respectprivatepropertybystayingondesignatedtrails.WecanallhavefuninForestParkbystickingtothetrail.Collectingand/orremovingnaturalobjects:LeaveItAsYouFindIt–Pickingflowers,collectingrocksortakingothernaturalobjectsmightnotseemlikeabigdeal,butitmeansthatotherswon’thaveachancetoenjoythem.Takingoneortwoflowersorplants,eveniftheyseemplentiful,isnotOK.Weallenjoyflowersandfruit,butpickingthemreducesseeds,whichcanmeanfewerplantsnextyear.Wildlifedependontheseplantsforfood.Remember,therearealotofusenjoyingForestPark,soweallneedtobeextracareful–pleasedoyourparttoprotectForestPark’sresourcesbyleavingthemasyoufindthem.OtherExamplesofSite-specificLanguageinUse:FromBoise,Idaho–RidgetoRiversPartnershipManageYourDogLeashesarerequiredbylawintheBoiseCityReserves.ThesearethenaturalopenspacesmanagedbyBoiseCityParksandRecreation.Checkthetrailheadsignboardsformoreinformation.Elsewhereinthefoothills,allowingyourdogtoapproachpeopleuninvitedandtorunfarandwideinvitesconflictswithotherusers.Besmart-controlyourdogatalltimes.EnjoyOff-LeashTrailsCertaintrailshavebeendesignatedforoff-leashuse,butonlywhenadogisdeemedtobeundercontrol.Thismeansdogsmustbewithin30’ofownerandreturnwhencalled;theymustnotapproachorharasspeople,petsorwildlife.Doesyourdogmeetthistest?Ifnot,thenleashesarestillrequired.PickupPoopDogwastesmells,peoplecanstepinitanditcancontributetowaterpollution.Itiseasytopickupwastebybringingabagorgrabbingoneatthetrailhead.Youcanhelpbylookingoutfor#2.Remember,thejob’snotdone‘tillthebagsinthecan.LeaveNoTraceReduceimpactstothelandbykeepingyourdogonthetrail,avoidallowingthemtodigforrodentsandmakesuretheydonotchasewildlife,especiallywinteringbiggame.SharetheTrailsNoteveryonelovesyourdoglikeyoudo.Respectothertrailenthusiastsandkeepcontrolofyourdogatalltimes.Leashupattrailheadparkingareasandothercongestedspots.Yellingforyourdogdestroysthequietthatmanyareseeking.Protectyourpet–SticktoTrails
![Page 68: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
68
Encounterswithpredators,rattlesnakes,ticksandcheatgrassaremorelikelyofftrail.Bringwaterforyouandyourdog.Accesstocreekscanincreaseerosion.Enjoyingoffleashtrailsisaprivilegeearnedbyrespectfulandresponsibleuse.Yourdog,thewildlife,thelandandyourfellowtrailenthusiastswillallbenefitfromyourresponsibleactions.Thisinformationisprovidedaspartofanongoingefforttoencourageshareduseandanenjoyabletrailexperience.FromParkCity,Utah–SnydervilleBasinSpecialRecreationDistrictLeaveNoTraceonBasinRecSpace.TheSnydervilleBasinrecreationspaceprovidesasafehavenfornativeplantsandanimalsandawelcomebreakfromourbusylives.Byrecreatingwisely,wecanminimizeourimpactonwildlifeandtheirhomesandfellowvisitors,whileenjoyingouroutdoorexperienceevenmore.WiththousandsofpeoplevisitingBasinRecreationSpace,thelessimpactweeachmake,thelongerwewillenjoywhatwehave.PleasedoyourparttoLeaveNoTraceonBasinRecSpace.ManageYourDog–Keepingyourdogincontrolkeepspeople,otherdogs,livestockandwildlifesafe.Othersmaynotappreciateyourdog’scompany;ifnotsure,askbeforeallowingyourdogtoapproachthem.Pleasedonotletyourdogapproachothersunlessinvited.DogsmustbeonleashintheBasinunlessyou'reinanoff-leasharea.Inareaswhereleashesaren'trequiredkeepyourdognearbyandundercontrol.Beaware-checksignsandfollowarearegulations.Keeptrackofyourpetswhileyou’rerecreatingintheBasin.Apetundercontrollessensthechanceforharmtoyourdogfromotherdogsorwildlife.Pleasedonotletyourdogapproachorchasewildlife.Chasedorharassedwildlifechangetheirfeedingpatternsandexertmoreenergy,whichcanresultinpoorhealthorevendeath.RespectprivatepropertyintheBasinbynotallowingyourdogtowanderfromdesignatedtrailsoroff-leashareas.Remember,unlessyou'reinanoff-leasharea,petsmustbeonleashintheBasin.Pleasedoyourparttomanageyourdog.PickUpPoop–Phew!Dogpoopstinks,isnotnaturaltotheBasinandotherscanstepinit.Packapick-upbagorgraboneatthetrailheadandalwayspickupyourdog’spoop–whereverit’sleft.Dogpoopisahealthhazard.Italsoincreasesthenitrogeninthesoilaroundthetrail,givingtheadvantagetoweedsoverthenativeplantsthathavenaturallyevolvedintheBasin.DogpoopcanalsocontributetowaterpollutionintheuniqueriparianareasfoundintheBasin.Thanksforbaggingyourdog’spoop,butremember,thejob’snotdoneuntilyoudropitinthetrashcan.PleasedoyourparttokeepBasinRecreationSpacedogpoopfree.SticktoTrails–Stayingontrailsprotectswildlifeandtheirhomes.Shortcuttingtrailscauseserosionanddamagestrailsideplants.Pleasewalkandrideondesignatedtrailsonly.ContacttheSnydervilleBasinRecreationofficefortrailinformationandmaps.
![Page 69: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
69
Studieshaveshownthatwhenwetramplevegetationonthesideofthetrail,thereisagreaterchanceweedswillreplacenativeplants.Inthisenvironment,nativeplantstakeyearstorecoverfromtramplingdamage.Avoidareasthatareunmarked,closedforrevegetationorsignedassensitive.Also,mostBasintrailspassthroughprivateland.WearefortunatethatlandownersintheBasinarewillingtoallowtrailsontheirproperty.Respectprivatepropertybystayingondesignatedtrails.WecanallhavefunonnaturalBasinRecreationspacewhilestickingtotrails.ShareourTrails–WeallenjoyBasinRecreationSpaceindifferentways.Payattention,expecttoencounterothers,slowdownandbecourteous-offerafriendlygreeting.Thosetravelingfastershouldslowdownforotherusers.Downhillridersshouldalwaysyieldtoallotherusers.Bikers,becauseoftheirmobility,shouldalwaysyieldtohikersandhorsebackriders.Thebestchoicewhenyieldingistostop,thenstepoffthetrailontoadurablesurface(rock,sand,etc.)andremainuntilotherspass.Ifyoucontinuetohikeorrideofftrailwhenyielding,youtrampletrailsidevegetationandcreatemultipletrailswhereoneisusuallybest.Weallknowhowgreatoutdoorexperiencescanbe.Onediscourteouspersoncanruinanouting.Expectandrespectothers.Makeroomforothers.Controlyourspeed.Passwithcareandletothersknowyou'repassing.Becourteousandwe'llallhaveabettertime.TrashYourTrash–Pleasepickupalltrash–yoursandothers’.Evenbiodegradablematerials,suchasorangepeels,applecoresandfoodscrapstakeyearstobreakdownandattractscavengersthatcanharmnativewildlife.Trashisunsightlyandruinseveryone’soutdoorexperience.Studieshaveshownthattrashattractsscavengingbirdsandanimalsthatdriveawayorkillnativebirds.Let’salldoourparttotakecareofBasinRecreationSpacebypickingupalltrash.LeaveItAsYouFindIt–Pickingflowers,collectingrocksortakingarrowheadsmightnotseemlikeabigdeal,butitmeansthatotherswon’thaveachancetoenjoythem.Takingoneortwoflowersorplants,eveniftheyseemplentiful,isnotOK.Weallenjoyflowersandfruit,butpickingthemreducesseeds,whichcanmeanfewerplantsnextyear.Wildlifedependontheseplantsforfood.Remember,therearealotofusenjoyingBasinRecreationSpace,soweallneedtobeextracareful–pleasedoyourparttoprotectBasinresourcesbyleavingthemasyoufindthem.ProtectOurWater–TheSnydervilleBasinishometomanyuniqueresourcesincludingriparianareas–thegreenvegetatedareasoneachsideofstreamsandcreeks.Bothpeopleandanimalsaredrawntowater,especiallyinsemi-aridenvironmentslikethosefoundintheBasin.RiparianareasarevitaltothehealthanddiversityofplantandanimallifeintheBasin.Theseareasareoftenthesolehabitatformanyplantandanimalspeciesthatneedwet
![Page 70: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
70
conditions.Researchhasshownthatover75%ofanimalspeciesinaridregionsneedriparianhabitatduringsomeportionoftheirlifecycle.Riparianareassupplyfoodandcoverforanimals;provideabuffer,whichactsasafiltertohelppreventwatercontamination;reducetheriskofflooding;andhelpreducestreambankerosion.Doyourparttohelpprotectthiscriticalresourcebystayingontrails,onlyaccessingthewateratdesignatedaccesspoints,keepinglitter,humanandpetwasteoutofthewater,andnottramplingstreamsidevegetation.Pleasehelpprotectourwater.
![Page 71: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
71
ExamplesofSignage,Brochures,andDigitalMedia
![Page 72: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
72
![Page 73: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
73
![Page 74: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
74
![Page 75: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
75
![Page 76: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
76
![Page 77: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
77
![Page 78: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
78
![Page 79: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
79
![Page 80: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
80
![Page 81: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
81
![Page 82: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
82
![Page 83: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
83
![Page 84: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
84
![Page 85: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
85
![Page 86: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
86
How Much Does Your Pack Weigh?
As a Rule of Thumb:��3DFN�ZHLJKW�VKRXOG�QRW�EH�PRUH�WKDQ�����RI �\RXU�ERG\�ZHLJKW�
�� <RXU�IRRG�ZHLJKW�VKRXOG�QRW�EH�PRUH�WKDQ�����RI �\RXU�SDFN�ZHLJKW�
3ODQ�$KHDG�DQG�3UHSDUH�)ROORZ�/HDYH�1R�7UDFH�WHFKQLTXHV�DQG�UH�SDFN�IRRG�LWHPV�LQWR�OLJKW�ZHLJKW�]LSORFN�EDJV��/HDYH�FDQV�DQG�JODVV�ERWWOHV�DW�KRPH��6WD\�VDIH�DQG�FDUU\�WKH�WHQ�HVVHQWLDOV�
� ����0DS��FRPSDVV��*36� ����)ODVKOLJKW� ����([WUD�IRRG� ����:DWHU�SXULILFDWLRQ� ����([WUD�FORWKLQJ� ����5DLQ�JHDU� ����0DWFKHV�ILUH�VWDUWHU� ����6XQ�SURWHFWLRQ� ����3RFNHW�NQLIH������)LUVW�DLG�NLW
To learn more about it: www.LNT.org
![Page 87: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
87
Steel Creek Boat Launch
You are here
• PFDs (life vests) required. For your safety, at least one wearable personal flotation device (PFD) for each occupant must be on board all vessels, including inner tubes. Children who are twelve (12) years of age or younger must wear a personal flotation device at all times while aboard any vessel. Because of hazards in the river, we recommend wearing PFDs any time while in or near the water.
• Seatbelts required. When operating a motor vehicle within the park, please stay on park roads and parking areas and wear seatbelts. ATV/UTVs are not permitted.
• Fasten cooler lids. Glass and Styrofoam prohibited. To prevent items from spilling and sinking in the river while paddling, cooler lids must be fastened and all contents in your boat must be properly secured. When beverages are removed from the cooler, keep them attached to or held within a floating holder. Glass and Styrofoam containers are not permitted on the water or on gravel bars.
• Leave cultural artifacts where you find them. Each artifact tells a story of those who inhabited this area before us. Allow future visitors the opportunity to discover those stories in proper context by observing, taking a picture, but not disturbing artifacts.
• Keep pets on leash. Please keep pets on a leash no longer than 6 feet. The following trails are open to pets: Mill Creek Trail (Pruitt, Upper District); Spring Hollow, Buck Ridge, and Rock Wall Trails (Tyler Bend, Middle District); and Forest, Overlook and Campground Trails (Buffalo Point, Lower District). Always pick up after your furry friends, and please don’t leave them unattended.
• Attach and use a mesh litter bag. To help keep this beautiful river clean, paddlers must carry and use a mesh litter bag to collect and secure trash while floating. Be prepared to pack out what you bring in.
• RV/camper access limited. RVs/camper trailers are allowed at Erbie, Ozark, Woolum, Tyler Bend, Maumee South, and Buffalo Point campgrounds. Be advised: Most access roads within park boundaries are gravel, and water/hookups are available only at Buffalo Point Campground.
For more information, check out the Superintendent’s Compendium online at www.nps.gov/buff.
The
Law
/For
You
r Saf
ety
Paddle the BuffaloThe upper river’s flow is extremely weather-dependent. Check with local concessioners for river conditions, boat rentals, and shuttle services.
Buffalo Outdoor Center: 1-800-221-5514Buffalo River Canoes: 870-446-2644Gordon Motel: 1-800-477-8509Lost Valley Canoe & Lodging: 870-861-5522Riverview Motel: 870-446-2616
IN AN EMERGENCY
You are at Steel Creek Boat Launch.
Emergency phone available outside of Steel Creek Ranger Station. Phone the
24-hour Park Dispatch at 1-888-692-1162 or dial “911” for
assistance.
Help Protect Public Lands... Follow Leave No Trace Principles!
Plan Ahead & Prepare: Know the rules and regulations for each land management agency, be ready for extreme weather and road hazards. Bring extra food, water, etc. Travel & Camp on Durable Surfaces: Reduce impacts on nature, stick to durable surfaces including established trails/campsites, rock, gravel, dry grasses or snow. Camp at least 200 feet from any water source. Dispose of Waste Properly: Pack out all trash, leftover food, and litter including toilet paper and diapers. Use portable toilets or provided facilities, otherwise bury human waste at least 200 feet from any water source in a hole 6 inches deep. Bathe and wash dishes at least 200 feet from any water source. Leave What You Find: Examine, but do not touch cultural or historic structures and artifacts including arrowheads. Do not collect natural objects such as rocks or plants and do not cut or carve trees. The collection of any live vegetation (including seeds and roots) is not allowed on USACE or Linn County property. Minimize Campfire Impacts: Use established fire rings, fire pans, or camp stoves when possible. Only use sticks from the ground that can be broken by hand, and never leave campfires unattended. Respect Wildlife: View Wildlife from a distance and never approach, feed or follow them. Seal food and store out of reach. Keep pets on a leash or contained. Be Considerate of Other Visitors: Respect other visitors and protect the quality of their experience. Avoid loud voices and noises. Yield to other users on the trail and avoid resting or camping on trails.
Bureau of Land Management Northwest Oregon District (503) 375-5646
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Willamette Valley Project (541) 367-5127
Linn County Parks and Recreation Department (541) 967-3917
U.S. Forest Service Detroit Ranger District (503) 854-3366 Sweet Home Ranger District (541) 367-5168
For more information on rules, regulations and permits contact these local managing agency offices:
Know Before You Go…
Driving Conditions: Please drive carefully, sections of this road are narrow and winding and varies from two lanes to one lane with turnouts. Weather conditions can change to wet or icy throughout the year. Snow can close parts of the road during the winter and early spring. Watch For: Oncoming traffic, non-motorized vehicles, pedestrians, fallen rocks, wildlife on the road, adverse road conditions, and inclement weather. Be Prepared: The closest full-service communities with food, gas, lodging, and supplies are Detroit, Sisters, and Sweet Home. Call reception is limited in certain areas
© 1999 by the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics: www.LNT.org.
Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics (800) 332-4100
![Page 88: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
88
![Page 89: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
89
Please Respect Wildlife
![Page 90: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
90
ConclusionTheAdirondackParkispoisedtoprovideexceptional,world-classoutdoorrecreationopportunitiesinNewYorkState.However,withrecreationgenerallycomessomelevelofbiophysicalandsocialimpact.,andrecreationaluseofparksandprotectedareasisontherise.Inordertoavoid,minimize,ormitigatetheseinevitableimpacts,ParkmanagersandpartnersneedtoprovideandactivelypromoteparkuseguidelinesthatareconsistentwithLeaveNoTrace.ParkmanagersarecurrentlyinauniquepositiontopromoteresponsibleenjoymentoftheParkgiventheaffinitytheregion’sresidentshaveforthePark.Adirondack-specificLeaveNoTraceinformationconveyedtovisitorscanbehighlyeffectiveatinfluencingvisitorbehaviorandimprovingresourceconditions,andcanultimatelyprotectandpreservetheAdirondackParkforcurrentandfuturegenerations.“Wehaveachoice:wecanregulateandtolerateparkvisitorsorwecancelebrateandeducatethemtocreatelifelongstewardsofoursharedspaces.” –RickPotts,NationalParkService
![Page 91: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
91
ReferencesAjzen,I.(1991).TheTheoryofPlannedBehavior.OrganizationalBehaviorandHuman
DecisionProcesses,50(2),179-211.Ajzen,I.(2001).Natureandoperationofattitudes.AnnualReviewofPsychology,52(1),27-
58.Ajzen,I.,&Fishbein,M.(2000).Attitudesandtheattitude-behaviorrelation:Reasonedand
automaticprocesses.EuropeanReviewofSocialPsychology,11(1),1-33.
Borrie,W.T.,&Harding,J.A.(2002).Effectiverecreationvisitorcommunicationstrategies:RockclimbersintheBitterrootValley,Montana.USDept.ofAgriculture,ForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation.
Cialdini,R.B.,Demaine,L.J.,Sagarin,B.J.,Barrett,D.W.,Rhoads,K.,&Winter,P.L.(2006).
Managingsocialnormsforpersuasiveimpact.SocialInfluence,1(1),3-15.Chavez,D.J.,&Winter,P.L.(1993).ImperialSandDunes:Visitorresearchcasestudy.US
DepartmentoftheInterior,BureauofLandManagement.Christensen,N.A.,&Cole,D.N.(2000).LeaveNoTracepractices:Behaviorsand
preferencesofwildernessvisitorsregardinguseofcookstovesandcampingawayfromlakes.InS.F.McCool,W.T.Borrie&J.O'Loughlin(Eds.),Proceedings-WildernessScienceinaTimeofChangeConference(Vol.RMRS-P-15-VOL-4,pp.77-85).USDAForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation.
Cole,D.N.(1998).Writtenappealsforattentiontolow-impactmessagesonwildernesstrailsideboards:Experimentalevaluationsofeffectiveness.JournalofParkandRecreationAdministration,16(1),65-79.
Dorwart,C.E.,Leung,Y.F.,&Moore,R.(2004).Managingvisitors’perceptions.Journalof
ParkandRecreationAdministration,5,24-31.Duncan,G.S.,&Martin,S.R.(2002).Comparingtheeffectivenessofinterpretiveand
sanctionmessagesforinfluencingwildernessvisitors’intendedbehavior.InternationalJournalofWilderness,8(2),20-25.
Farrell,T.,Hall,T.E.,&White,D.D.(2001).Wildernesscampers'perceptionandevaluation
ofcampsiteimpacts.JournalofLeisureResearch,33(3),229.
Fishbein,M.,&Manfredo,M.J.(1992).Atheoryofbehaviorchange.InM.J.Manfredo(Ed.),Influencinghumanbehaviortheoryandapplicationinrecreation,tourism,andnaturalresourcesmanagement(pp.29-50).Champaign,IL:SagamorePublishing.
![Page 92: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
92
Fishbein,M.,&Ajzen,I.(2010).Predictingandchangingbehavior:Thereasonedactionapproach.PsychologyPress.
Ham,S.H.(2007).Caninterpretationreallymakeadifference?Answerstofourquestions
fromcognitiveandbehavioralpsychology.PaperpresentedattheInterpretingWorldHeritageConference,Vancouver,BritishColumbiaCanada.
Ham,S.H.,&Krumpe,E.E.(1996).Identifyingaudiencesandmessagesfornonformal
environmentaleducation–Atheoreticalframeworkforinterpreters.JournalofInterpretationResearch,1(1),11-23.
Hammitt,W.E.,&Cole,D.N.(1998).Wildlandrecreationecologyandmanagement.New
York:JohnWiley&Sons.Hammitt,W.E.,Cole,D.N.,&Monz,C.A.(2015).Wildlandrecreation:Ecologyand
management.JohnWiley&Sons.Harmon,W.(1997).LeaveNoTraceMinimumImpactOutdoorRecreationHelena,MT:
FalconPublishing,Inc.Hendee,J.C.,&Dawson,C.P.(2002).Wildernessmanagementstewardshipandprotectionof
resourcesandvalues.Golden,CO:WILDFoundationandFulcrumPub.Hungerford,H.R.,&Volk,T.L.(1990).Changinglearnerbehaviorthroughenvironmental
education.JournalofEnvironmentalEducation,21(3),8-22.Hwang,Y.H.,Kim,S.I.,&Jeng,J.M.(2000).Examiningthecausalrelationshipsamong
selectedantecedentsofresponsibleenvironmentalbehavior.TheJournalofEnvironmentalEducation,31(4),19-25.
Kim,S.O.,Lee,C.H.,&Shelby,B.(2003).Utilizationofphotographsfordeterminingimpactindicatorsfortrailmanagement.EnvironmentalManagement,32(2),282-289.
Laven,D.N.,&Krymkowski,D.H.(2005).Therelationshipbetweenvisitor-based
standardsofqualityandexistingconditionsinparksandoutdoorrecreation.LeisureSciences,27(2),157-173.
Lawhon,B.,Newman,P.,Taff,B.D.,Vaske,J.J.,Vagias,W.M.,Bright,A.,Lawson,S.R.,&
Monz,C.(2013).FactorsinfluencingbehavioralintentionsforLeaveNoTracebehaviorinRockyMountainNationalPark.JournalofInterpretationResearch18(1),24–38.
Lawhon,B.,Taff,B.D.,Newman,P.,Vagias,W.M.,&Newton,J.(2017).Understandingand
influencingstateparkvisitors'LeaveNoTracebehavioralintent.JournalofInterpretationResearch,22(1).
![Page 93: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
93
LeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics.(2015).StrategicObjectives.Retrievedfromhttps://lnt.org/about/what-we-are-working-now
LeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics.(2016a).LeaveNoTraceMission.Retrieved
fromhttps://lnt.org/aboutLeaveNoTraceCenterforOutdoorEthics.(2016b).LeaveNoTracePrinciples.Retrieved
fromhttps://lnt.org/learn/7-principlesLeung,Y.F.,&Marion,J.L.(2000).Recreationimpactsandmanagementinwilderness:A
state-of-knowledgereview.InD.N.Cole,S.F.McCool,W.T.Boorie&J.O'Loughlin(Eds.),Wildernessscienceinatimeofchangeconference-Volume5Wildernessecosystems,threats,andmanagement:1999May23-27;Missoula,MT.ProceedingsRMSR-P-VOL-5(pp.23-48).Ogden,UT:USDAForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation.
Manning,R.E.(1999).Studiesinoutdoorrecreationsearchandresearchforsatisfaction.
OregonStateUniversityPress.Manning,R.E.(2003).Emergingprinciplesforusinginformation/educationinwilderness
management.InternationalJournalofWilderness,9(1),20-27.
Manning,R.,Lawson,S.,Newman,P.,Budruk,M.,Valliere,W.,Laven,D.,&Bacon,J.(2004).Visitorperceptionsofrecreation-relatedresourceimpacts.Environmentimpactsofecotourism.CABInternational,Cambridge,MA,259-272.
Marion,J.L.(2014).LeaveNoTraceintheOutdoors.StackpolePressMarion,J.L.,&Reid,S.E.(2001).DevelopmentoftheUSLeaveNoTraceprogram:An
historicalperspective.InM.B.Usher(Ed.),EnjoymentandUnderstandingoftheNationalHeritage(pp.81-92).Edinburgh,Scotland:ScottishNaturalHeritage&theStationeryOffice.
Marion,J.L.,&Reid,S.E.(2007).Minimisingvisitorimpactstoprotectedareas:theefficacy
oflowimpacteducationprogrammes.JournalofSustainableTourism,15(1),5-27.Marion,J.L.,Leung,Y.F.,Eagleston,H.,&Burroughs,K.(2016).Areviewand
synthesisofrecreationecologyresearchfindingsonvisitorimpactstowildernessandprotectednaturalareas.JournalofForestry,114(3),352-362.
Martin,D.C.(1992).Theeffectofthreesignsandabrochureonvisitors'removalofpumiceatMount.St.Helens.Vandalism:Research,preventionandsocialpolicy,121.
Martin,S.R.,Marsolais,J.,&Rolloff,D.(2009).Visitorperceptionsofappropriate
managementactionsacrosstherecreationopportunityspectrum.JournalofParkandRecreationAdministration,27,56-69.
![Page 94: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
94
McCool,S.F.,&Cole,D.N.(2000).Communicatingminimumimpactbehaviorwithtrailsidebulletinboards:Visitorcharacteristicsassociatedwitheffectiveness.USDAForestServiceProceedingsRMRS-P-15-Vol-4,pp.208-216.
Miller,T.,Borrie,W.,&Harding,J.(2001).Basicknowledgeoffactorsthatlimitthepractice
oflow-impactbehaviors.Draftreportonfileat:USDepartmentofAgriculture,ForestService,RockyMountainResearchStation,AldoLeopoldWildernessResearchInstitute,Missoula,MT:UniversityofMontana.
Oliver,S.S.,Roggenbuck,J.W.,&Watson,A.E.(1985).Educationtoreduceimpactsin
forestcampgrounds.JournalofForestry,83(4),234-236.
Orams,M.B.(1997).Theeffectivenessofenvironmentaleducation:Canweturntouristsinto'Greenies'?ProgressinTourismandHospitalityRresearch,3,295-306.
Park,L.O.,Manning,R.E.,Marion,J.L.,Lawson,S.R.,&Jacobi,C.(2008).Managingvisitor
impactsinparks:Amulti-methodstudyoftheeffectivenessofalternativemanagementpractices.JournalofParkandRecreationAdministration,26(1),97-121.
Petty,R.E.,McMichael,S.,&Brannon,L.A.(1992).Theelaborationlikelihoodmodelofpersuasion:Applicaionsinrecreationandtourism.InM.J.Manfredo(Ed.),Influencinghumanbehaviortheoryandapplicationinrecreation,tourism,andnaturalresourcesmanagement(pp.77-101).Champaign,IL:SagamorePublishing.
Roggenbuck,J.W.(1992).Useofpersuasiontoreduceresourceimpactsandvisitorconflicts.InM.J.Manfredo(Ed.),Influencinghumanbehaviortheoryandapplicationinrecreation,tourism,andnaturalresourcesmanagement(pp.149-208).Champaign,IL:SagamorePublishing.
Slater,M.(1992).Masscommunicationresearch:Lessonsforpersuasivecommunication.Influencinghumanbehavior.Champaign,IL:SagamorePublishing,Inc.
Taff,D.,Newman,P.,Bright,A.,&Vagias,W.(2011).Day-userbeliefsregardingLeaveNo
TraceinRockyMountainNationalPark.JournalofOutdoorRecreation,Education,andLeadership,3(2),112-115.
Taff,B.D.,Newman,P.,Vagias,W.M.,&Lawhon,B.(2014).Comparingday-users’and
overnightvisitors’attitudesconcerningleavenotrace.JournalofOutdoorRecreation,Education,andLeadership,6(2),133-146.
White,D.D.,Hall,T.E.,&Farrell,T.A.(2001).Influenceofecologicalimpactsandother
campsitecharacteristicsonwildernessvisitors'campsitechoices.JournalofPark&RecreationAdministration,19(2).
![Page 95: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
95
Widner-Ward,C.,&Roggenbuck,J.(2003).Understandingparkvisitors'responsetointerventionstoreducepetrifiedwoodtheft.JournalofInterpretationResearch,8,67-82.
Winter,P.L.(2006).Theimpactofnormativemessagetypesonoff-trailhiking.Journalof
InterpretationResearch,11(1),35-52.Winter,P.L.,Sagarin,B.J.,Rhoads,K.,Barrett,D.W.,&Cialdini,R.B.(2000).Choosingto
encourageordiscourage:Perceivedeffectivenessofprescriptiveversusproscriptivemessages.EnvironmentalManagement,26(6),589-594.
Vagias,W.M.,&Powell,R.B.(2010).BackcountryvisitorsLeaveNoTraceattitudes.InternationalJournalofWilderness,16(3),21-27.
Vagias,W.M.,Powell,R.,Moore,D.,&Wright,B.(2012).Development,psychometric
qualities,andcross-validationoftheLeaveNoTraceAttitudinalInventoryandMeasure(LNTAIM),JournalofLeisureResearch,44(2)234-256.
Vagias,W.M.,Powell,R.B.,Moore,D.D.,&Wright,B.A.(2014).Predictingbehavioral
intentionstocomplywithrecommendedLeaveNoTracepractices.LeisureSciences,36(5),439-457.
![Page 96: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
96
Appendices
AppendixA–LeaveNoTraceEthicsCardExamples3x5”recycledplasticcardcontaininglocally-tailoredLeaveNoTraceinformation.Generousflexibilitywiththisresource.
![Page 97: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
97
AppendixB–LeaveNoTraceResolution–SanJuanIslands,WA
![Page 98: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
98
![Page 99: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
99
AppendixC–Whatarethe3-5mostpressingissuesonthelandsyoumanage?(Numbersindicatethenumberofresponsesforparticulartypeofanswer)
• Overuse/highvolumeofuse/crowding/overcrowding(14)• Promotionaleffortsdirectingpeopletotheregion• Trailimpacts/degradation/deterioration/erosion(16)• Parkingissues(13)• EducationofUsers/hikers(8)• ImproperdisposalofHumanwaste(6)• Human/petwaste(2)• LackofDECEnvironmentalEducationCenter• wilderness(small“w”)ethicincorporationintothemindsandbehaviorsofpeople
usingtheresources• Lackofstaffandmoneyforpropertrailmaintenance(3)• Overcrowding/highuseinpopularareas/oncertaintrailsandsummits(12)• Underpreparedhikers/hikerpreparedness(8)• OnlineandSocialMedia(2)• Traildesignandmanagement(5)• Lackofstaffing(FieldStaff,Rangers,DECstaff,maintenance(8)• Lackofsafety,educationalandLeaveNoTraceinfo(6)• IllegalATV/UTV/snowmobileuse(4)• Transportationbarriers(2)• Lossofwildernesscharacter/solitude(2)• Hikinglistssuchasthe46highestpeaks,SaranacSixers,etc.• Usersleavingbehindgarbage(2)• Invasivespecies(6)• Resourcesdedicatedtotraildevelopment&maintenance(2)• HavingLeaveNoTracemessagesmakeadifferenceontheground• ebikes• Misuse/abuseofresources(2)• Shorelinedevelopment• Income-relatedbarriers• Improperfoodstorage/Bearencounters(4)• Resourceprotection(3)• Vegetationdamage(2)• Lawsuitsfromenvironmentalnon-profits(2)• LackofInfrastructurebythefrugalState• Irregularrules• Non-LeaveNoTraceuse• AccessandPlanningforWildlands• Trailimprovements• Lackofdataonuse/visitation• Treecutting(2)
![Page 100: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
100
• RecreationonStatelandisviewedasanincomeforlocaltowns/businesses• Poorlyadvertisedaccess• Usersafety• Userconflicts• Protectlakefrontsandwaterways• Trailsdirectlyfromthecommunities• LackofoutreachandinclusionofPOC• Trafficcongestion• Landmanagementagenciesnotadequatelysupportedtofulfilltheirmission• Planning• Protectingtourism• Campfireimpacts• LimitationsofarticleXIV• AbilityofDEClandmanagers(notForestRangers)tomanageForestPreserveunits
properly,forthelongterm,inasustainablemanner• Lackoftheconcept“CarryingCapacity”byallinvolved• 6,970milesofroads/roadswitheasyaccesstowildlands(2)• Lackofmoney&staff
AppendixD–Arethereotherrecreation-relatedimpactsintheAdirondackParknotlistedabove?
• Higheramountsofvisitors&recreation-relatedimpactsdiminishwilderness/userexperience.
• Tramplingofalpinevegetation,touristremovalofvegetation/rocks/etc.,noiseandlightpollutionwithinwildernessareas,lackofeducationmeasures,improperdisposaloffood,negativehuman-wildlifeinteractions,spreadofaquaticandterrestrialinvasivespecies
• Comprehensiveplanningistotallylacking• Agenerallackofpreparationisabigcontributingfactor.• N/A(3)• Huntingandtrappingreducecertainanimalpopulations(bobcat,coyote,fox,and
bear).• Overuseofspecificareas/trails• LossofsolitudeonthetrailsandsummitsduetoovercrowdingLossofwilderness
ethic• OrganizationschoosingtonotfightforfullWildernessAreas,whichpreventthe
excessivemotorizationofthenortheast'sremainingwildspaces.Moreroads=higheruse.Also,moremagicalWildernessAreasinotherplaceswouldhelpdrawvisitationtolocalgems,notsolelytotheHighPeaks,thePresidentials,andBaxter.Increasingpubliclandconservationisanissue.
• Probablybuttheyarelimitedincomparison• CrowdinginWildernessisasignificantsocialimpactthatdegradesWilderness
values.
![Page 101: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
101
• NoiseandimpactonsolitudeLightpollution• Trailheadaccess,specificallyparkingandsafety;trailerosion• Damagetolessaccessiblecampsites.e.g.,nailsintreesonLowerSaranacLake
Islandscampground.
AppendixE–HowfamiliarareyouwiththetypicalAdirondackParkvisitor?
• AdirondackParkvisitorsaretoodiverseofagrouptosaythereisa"typical"one• IaminaeducationalsettingsoIknowourstudentpopulationwell• Idon'tknowofa"typical"AdirondackParkvisitor-Iknowwhatactivitiesare
popularandwherevisitorstravelfrom,butIdon'tknowofa"typical"Adirondackvisitoroutofthe12.4millionpeoplevisitingtheParkeachyear
AppendixF–Whatarethemainobjectivesforyourvolunteerprogram?
• Engagestudentsinstewardshipofpubliclands.Thisincludes,butisnotlimitedto,campsiteandtrailmonitoring,trailmaintenance,andtechnicalreportwriting.
• infrastructurework• education,information,conservation• Stewardshipofnaturalresourcesandrecreationalfacilitiessuchastrails• Trailwork• Maintenance,stewardship• ToprotectNewYork'salpinehabitatthrougheducation,trailworkandresearch.• Trailworkandconstruction.• TrailMaintenanceBackcountryWaterMonitoringforInvasiveSpeciesTrailhead
andSummitResponsibleRecreationEducation• morethan250volunteeragreements• TrailMaintenance&Construction• Resourceprotection,education,freelabor• VolunteerStewardshipAgreementsareusedtoengagevolunteersinactivitieson
theForestPreserve/ConservationEasementsthatprovideanetbenefittotheperson/organizationdoingworkandtheDEC/StateofNewYork.Example:asnowmobileclubmaintainingapublictrail.
• Assistwithallofthetasks,suchastrailmaintenanceandvisitoreducation,thatarefallingbythewaysideduetoalackofstaff.
• resourcemaintenance• EducatethepubliconhowtorecreateresponsiblyTounderstandandappreciate
theimportanceofstewardshipofwildplaces• Stewardshipandeducation• Stewardshipandmaintenanceoftrailsandlean-tos.Alsopublicoutreachinparking
lotsandonsummits.Volunteersalsosurveypondsforinvasivespecies.• Educatethepublicattrailheads,summits,andparkinglotsonLeaveNoTraceand
regulations
![Page 102: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
102
• Promotetheconservation,preservation,andresponsiblerecreationaluseoftheNYSForestPreserve,whiledevelopingalifelongconnectiontothewildlandsyouenjoy.
• trailmaintenance• Assistwithmaintenanceoffacilitiesandpublicoutreach• Stewardshipandprotectionofnaturalresources• Trailwork• Mostlyfortrailprojects,someresourceprotection• Involvepublicinstewardship;helptakecareoffacilities• Helppeoplelearnofplacestopaddle,hike,bikeetc.andtheimportanceofthe10
essentialsandLeaveNoTrace• facilitiesmaintenance
AppendixG–Whattypesofsitesrequireafee?Checkallthatapply.
• IfonADKproperty• MarcyShuttle• ORDAfacilities• Paymentforshuttleservicestoaccesspubliclands• PrivateLandaccess• PrivatelyownedbusinessessuchasAusableChasm,andHighFallsGorge• historicalsites• privatesites• shuttleride
AppendixH–WhatagenciesprovidelawenforcementonpubliclandsintheAdirondackPark?
• StatePolice• Federallawsstillapplyonpubliclands&publiclandsexistbyvirtueoffederaland
statelaw...Whatdoes"lawenforcement"meaninthiscontext?• StateTroopers
AppendixI–WhatareyourgoalsforaLeaveNoTraceprogramforthelandsyoumanage?
• Toeducatevisitorsonhowtohavesafe,positiveexperienceswhileensuringappropriatestewardshipanduseofallAdirondackParklands,includingstatelands,toprotectournaturalresources
• LeaveNoTraceshouldreacheveryvisitortopreservelandsintheAdirondackPark-LeaveNoTracesignageshouldbelargeandclearlyvisibleatforestpreserveentrances/trailheads-LeaveNoTraceeducationshouldtakeaproactiveapproachandmakeuseofonlinechannelstoeducatevisitors
• Reduceecologicalandsocialimpactsfromparkvisitors.
![Page 103: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
103
• longtermplanning,sustainabletrailreroutingandrebuilding,permitsystemforeducationalprograms
• Iwouldliketoseehikerswhoareinformedandprepared,andwhorespectallaspectsofboththepublicandprivatelandsinthePark.
• TohelpvisitorsenjoytheirexperienceTohelpvisitorsunderstandtheimpactstheiractionsmayhave
• ToincreaseeducationandawarenessfrombothvisitorsandlocalsthatrecreationalactivitiesleaveanimpactontheAdirondackPark.Toincreaserecreationalpreparedness,andincreaseresponsiblerecreation.
• Educateusersbeforetheybegintheirhike.Aneducateduserwillultimatelycreatesignificantlylessimpacts.
• Tohelpeducatehikersinordertomitigateimpactontheresourceandaspartofapreparednesseffort
• Increaseduserawarenessandanimprovementinuserbehaviorandbeingagoodneighbor.
• Educationofuserstoprotecttheenvironmentandthemselves• LeaveNoTraceateverytrailhead.• Makepeopleunderstandthattheyarepart-ownersoftheADKpark,andthatthey
arebeingneglectfultoaresourcethatbelongstothem.• ToProtecttheNaturalResourcesPreserveSocialExperience• Itwouldbegreattotheaverageusertounderstandandfollowthe7LeaveNoTrace
principle• Itshouldbeconsistentwiththenationalprogram.Itshouldreducesomecurrent
useimpacts.Itshouldreducethenumberofincidentsthatresultinbackcountrysearchandrescue.
• Consistentmessaging• Parkwidebranding,MorePreventiveSearchandRescue(PSAR)• EducatepeopleabouttheAdirondackPark-whyitisspecial,different,andmore
protectedthanmostotherlandscapes.AlsohowstewardshipofthepubliclandintheParkismanagedbyDEC.2.IncorporatingandembeddingtheLeaveNoTraceprinciplesintothemindsandbehaviorsofthepeoplewhovisitthePark,sothatitactuallymakesadifferenceontheground.CreatinganethicintheParkthatisholisticandunderstoodbyall.
• Reducevisitorimpacts,steervisitorsawayfromthemorepopular/overusedsitestootherareas
• publicoutreach• ToinformvisitorsbeforetheyarriveandwhiletheyarerecreatinginthePark.• LeaveNoTracespecificinformation,dedicatedstewardswithhighqualitytraining,
andbettersignagedisseminatedacrossthepark.• Toeducatevisitorsandultimatelyreduceuserimpacts• Tominimizerecreationimpactsthroughoutthepark,increasethequalityof
recreationexperiences,andimprovepublicsafety.• Consistentsignageandmessagingfromallagencies,organizations,andbusinesses
thatoperateonstatelands.
![Page 104: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
104
• EveryvisitorshouldknowaboutLeaveNoTracebefore,while,andaftervisiting!• IncreaseAwarenesstohelppeopleinthefuture• managingwastecuttingdownontrailerosionimpactonothervisitors• ComprehensiveintegrationofLeaveNoTraceprinciplesateverylevelof
managementandvisitorengagement.• Effectiveeducationofvisitors/userssothattheyengageinspecificpracticesthat
ensuretheirrecreationalimpactisminimal• ReducingimpactstonaturalresourcesandpreservingtheoverallAdirondack
recreationalexperience;improvingaccessandvisitorsafety;encouragingbettervisitormanagementpracticesandmorebuy-infromtheDEC;gettingpeopleoutonthelandinaresponsiblewayandencouragingstewardship
• BetterTrails• Provideamoreconsistenteducationalmessagefortherecreationaluser• ReducetheimpactsofrecreationistsonthenaturalresourcesofthePark• Theultimateoutcomeistochangevisitorbehavior.Ibelievewehavetobemore
specificthantheLeaveNoTraceprinciples.Wehavetobespecificrethebehaviorswewant/need.
• impactbehaviorofuserstolessenimpactofrecreationalactivities
AppendixJ–HowwouldyouenvisionLeaveNoTraceinformationbeingdisseminatedtoAdirondackParkvisitors?Checkallthatapply.
• HighwayRestAreasandVisitorCenters• Kiosks,thatshouldbemandatoryateverytrailhead• NOLS• Schools• Schools–statewide• TownofKeeneFrontCountryStewards• Localbusinesses
AppendixK–PleaselistadditionalfeedbackorcommentsorfeedbackregardingLeaveNoTraceeffortsintheAdirondackPark.
• ScientificassessmentsofuserbehaviorandknowledgeofLeaveNoTraceprinciples.LeaveNoTracesignageandoutreacheffortsshouldmakeuseofknownpsychologicalprinciplestoensuremaximumparticipationinLeaveNoTracepractices.
• LeaveNoTraceneedstobepairedwithothermanagementtools.100peopleonasummitwithLeaveNoTracetrainingmayhavelessimpactthanalargernumberofun-trainedindividuals.Butitisstill100peopleonasummit.
• Doingalotbutsomuchmorecanbedoneparkwide!• ThishasbeenacontinuousproblemsincetheadventofStateownershipofland.
Withanincreaseinpopulation,increaseinapushfortourism(namelythroughsocialmedia),anda"mefirst"attitudethatpervadessocietytoday,degradationof
![Page 105: Managing Recreation-related Impacts in the …...recreation-related issues facing the Adirondack Park; 2. Administration of an online survey to Adirondack Park managers, key partners,](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022071105/5fdf928c646af320c75009c3/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
105
Statelandshasbecomemoreevident.Ifeelthatagrassrootsmovementbythepublic,givingthemafeelingofownershipofthelandsbeingtrashed,wouldbethebestwaytoincorporatechange.
• Thank-youfortheopportunitytotakepartinthissurvey• Let'sdomoreofthesetypesofoutreach,thanks• TheADKhasdonealotinthisfront.ItistimeforotherORGSandAGENCIEStotake
betteradvantageofLeaveNoTraceinformation.• Keepdoingthegreatworkyou'redoingtobringLeaveNoTraceinformationto
everyParkandeveryKid!Thankyou!• LeaveNoTraceisanexcellenttoolwecanusetopromotewiseuseofresources.It
doesn'tlimitanygroupbutgivesthemareasonandactiontohelptheplacestheyuse
• AsIsaidabove,wemusttargetbehaviorsandthatisalabor-intensivejob.• Isupporttheeffort