natc czt data analysis working group achievements · overview 1. summary of august 24‐26, 2016...

49
NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements Derek Hultquist – Health Physicist, & David W. Miller, NATC Regional Director, D.C. Cook, American Electric Power 2016 ISOE Asian ALARA Symposium Fukushima, Japan, September 7-9, 2016

Upload: others

Post on 15-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements

Derek Hultquist – Health Physicist, & David W. Miller, NATC Regional Director, D.C. Cook, American Electric Power

2016 ISOE Asian ALARA SymposiumFukushima, Japan, September 7-9, 2016

Page 2: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Overview1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working 

Group Meeting held at Cook2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic mapping analyzed by group:3. FF/Primary to Secondary Leakage4. Foreign Material Investigation5. Particle Investigation / Mitigation

1. General2. Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 3: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• D. C. Cook has failed fuel and current primary‐to‐secondary leakage in U2

• U1 has completed an outage (U1C27) with failed fuel

Failed Fuel & Primary-to-Secondary Leakage Tracking

Page 4: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Tracking & Investigation with CZT

• New Library: Noble Gases / Iodines / Corrosion Products

• Low energy – Lack of imaging

Failed Fuel & Primary-to-Secondary Leakage Tracking

Page 5: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Not always traceable

Failed Fuel & Primary-to-Secondary Leakage Tracking

Page 6: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Failed Fuel & Primary-to-Secondary Leakage Tracking

*Not a bad “0”

Page 7: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Increased Dose Rates in VCT

Page 8: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Increased Dose Rates in VCT

Page 9: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Increased Dose Rates in VCT

Page 10: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Increased Dose Rates in VCT

Page 11: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

VCT bypass Vent hose to Vent Stack

*Trace with energies > 250 keV if possible, preferably short half‐lives

Page 12: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

VCT bypass Vent hose to Vent Stack

Page 13: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Charging Pump Rotor Replacement

Page 14: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Charging Pump Rotor Replacement

Page 15: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Charging Pump Rotor ReplacementEngineered Controls worked 

No PCM/PM AlarmsNo Uptakes (Lapel)

Page 16: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Charging Pump Rotor Replacement

Page 17: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Charging Pump Rotor Replacement

Page 18: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Failed Fuel Bundle in SFP• Track Release• Should drop off with no delta‐P

SFP Exhaust Trend

Page 19: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

SFP Exhaust Trend

4/28/16

4/5/16

4/18/16

4/12/16

8 day half‐life

Page 20: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

SFP Exhaust Trend

Page 21: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Foreign material found during outage• Approximately the size of a fingernail• Contact exposure of 16 R/hr w/ 

Telepole• CZT estimated exposure rate of 100‐

200 mR/hr 30 inches away.

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 22: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• 3 minute, 25 second duration• 72.7% dead time• 56 second live time• The lowest counts seen in a peak 

energy region was 55,750 for Fe‐59• Only Activation Products seen

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 23: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 24: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 25: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Percent Contributions

Page 26: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Activity Contributions

Page 27: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 28: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 29: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 30: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Results indicate high chromium and iron, with very low or non‐existent nickel content.

• Not believed to be RCS/Fuel Component Related

• Not the cause of failed fuel. Leak location and size indicate foreign material would likely be on the order of a wire bristle

Foreign Material Analysis

Page 31: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Cook has a history of legacy or ghost particles with no known origin

• Whole Aux. Building CA at one point• CZT used to search for contamination

Particle Investigation / Mitigation

Page 32: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / Mitigation:Seal Table Eddy Current

Page 33: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / Mitigation

Page 34: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / MitigationTESCA Seal: Moving Material

Page 35: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / MitigationTESCA Seal: Moving Material

Page 36: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / MitigationTESCA Seal: Moving Material

Page 37: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / MitigationGray Steel Move Stud Racks are to the right of 

the detector. Low level contamination (<100 ccpm) found

Page 38: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / MitigationHot Chem Lab Percon

Page 39: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Particle Investigation / MitigationHot Chem Lab Percon

Page 40: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Challenges• Alpha Level III (First in Cook History)• HCA/RPA• Infrequently Entered (Previous Entry 

was 2007)• Multiple particles found during surveys

• 1 Percon attributed to the project

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 41: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

• Coverage techs used CZT to validate contamination control

• Documented in RP Survey Program• Used with other tools

• Airflow test• Masslinn / Tacky Roller / Surface Covers

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 42: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Particle Search – Red is Check Source, Particle found on scaffold

Page 43: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 44: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Hot Spot on Cavity hole cover

Page 45: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 46: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job CoveragePOI previously HEPA, now man basket

Page 47: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 48: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Transfer Canal Job Coverage

Page 49: NATC CZT Data Analysis Working Group Achievements · Overview 1. Summary of August 24‐26, 2016 CZT Data Analysis Working Group Meeting held at Cook 2. Examples of CZT 3D isotopic

Questions?