the hidden side of power and politics - wordpress.com€¦ · diss. university of new mexico, 2003....

1
Troncos Introduction Are kinship relations still as relevant in the construction of cultural and/or political power in New Mexico as they were in the past? How did ethnicity, gender, class and kinship influence the formation of local governing bodies during the early 19 th century Mexican Period in northern New Mexico? This research performs a critical analysis of petitions and political records extracted from northern New Mexico between 1800 and 1848 in order to better describe power dynamics in 19 th century New Mexico. By critically analyzing the concept of kinship or “Parentesco”, this research seeks to understand the gendered construction of power in a critical period of New Mexico’s history. This research contributes to the fields of American Studies and History with further implications for the fields of Chicana & Chicano studies, Cultural and Ethnic studies, and Gender and Women studies. Methodology of the Study This research is organized in three phases. The first phase begins with a literature review concerning the construction of cultural and political societies during the 19 th century. Phase two consists of accessing archival material from the Center for Southwest Research and Special collections at the University of New Mexico. In this phase, working with an archivist is imperative specifically finding relevant materials such as petitions, marriage certificates and other documents. The third and final phase consist of analyzing the documents focusing specifically on the construction of social, political, and economic dynamics. This phase will require working with archival Spanish documents using Old Spanish language as well as the use of Paleography to read and interpret these documents. Questions guiding research included: 1) How do individuals gain formal and informal access to power through the use of legal petitions? 2) How does kinship influence the formation of governing bodies and/ or political decisions? 3) How does gender influence the construction of kinship and political power during the 19 th century Mexican Period? Acknowledgments I would like to acknowledge the support of the University of New Mexico Chicana and Chicano Studies Program, The Center for Southwest Research Studies, and the Ronald E. McNair Scholars and Research Opportunity Program. Description of the Archival Documents Three archival documents I analyzed are written below by Don Domingo Fernandez, a local citizen. The first document is the correspondence between Don Domingo Fernandez to Señor Jefe Politico del Archivo General de la Nacion de Ayuntamientos (Mexico City) December 1834. In the document, Don Fernandez references the Supreme Spanish Law of May 19, 1813, prohibiting Parentesco in Ayuntamiento (town council) elections. Don Fernandez asks that the election be nullified due to the familial ties or affinity. Correspondence from the Jefe Politico indicates that more evidence is needed for this severe claim and that the accused is exonerated until evidence and proof of Parentesco is provided. The second document is correspondence between Don Fernandez and the Governor Don Francisco Sarracino (1835). In this document Don Fernandez indicates the kinship and Parentesco of the appointed/ elected officials. In this document, the governor’s reply is not legible but the top portion of the document states “nulado por la ley” which translates to “Void by law.” This indicates that during this time Parentesco was being contested to a higher authority. The final document is Don Fernandez genealogical Tronco which indicates Parentesco; particularly relating through matrilineal kinship. Findings Through these archival documents, evidence of Parentesco in political elections and appointments were apparent in Northern New Mexico regardless of the Supreme law prohibiting it. Correspondence between one citizen, Don Domingo Fernandez, and a higher official indicated that individuals were aware and petitioned to resolve the discrepancy. The kinship of many of the accused traced back through a matrilineal family line. In this case the Tronco led back to Don Miguel De La Vega y Coca, a prominent Mexican elite, that entered New Mexico with the colonists of 1693. The Troncos of the named individuals indicate relationships through their wives. This matrilineal relationship indicates the importance of familial bonds; not always through bloodlines but through marriage or kinship. The status and wealth of women’s familial line was reproduced through political titles and power holding. Women lacked formal access to political power; but their family lines could legitimize and support male members’ access to political office. Claudia Mitchell, Chicana and Chicano Studies, University of New Mexico Faculty Mentors: Dr. Irene Vasquez, Director of UNM Chicana and Chicano Studies, Mr. Samuel Sisneros, Archivist of UNM Center for Southwest Research Studies Key Literature Citations Ayuntamiento 1833-1834. (AGN Vol 17. f: 213-217). Archivo Nacional de la Nacion ayuntamiento, (Mexico City) Center for Southwest Research, University Libraries, University of New Mexico Chavez, Angelico, and Angelico Chavez. Origins of New Mexico Families: A Genealogy of the Spanish Colonial Period. Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico, 1992. Print. Cutter, Charles R. The Legal Culture of Northern New Spain, 1710-1810. Albuqueruque U of New Mexico, 1995. print. Gonzales, Deena J. Refusing the Favor: The Spanish-Mexican Women of Santa Fe 1820-1880. New York: Oxford UP, 1990. print Stamatov, Suzanne. Family, Kin, and Community in Colonial New Mexico, 1694-1800. Diss. University of New Mexico, 2003. print. Key Definitions Parentesco: Kinship / Relationship Troncos: Family Tree Ayuntamientos: (town council) Municipalities Jefe Político: Local political boss Preliminary Thesis The preliminary findings of this study indicate that “Parentesco” (kinship), a remnant of the Spanish colonial period, continued to impact political elections during the 19 th century. This practice developed in frontier regions and enabled families to continue political kinship through marriage. Although women did not hold formal political power, through “Parentesco” (kinship) they influenced political power. The Hidden Side of Power and Politics: Gender and Political Kinship in Northern New Mexico during the Nineteenth-Century Mexican Period

Upload: others

Post on 13-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Hidden Side of Power and Politics - WordPress.com€¦ · Diss. University of New Mexico, 2003. print. Key Definitions •Parentesco: Kinship / Relationship •Troncos: Family

Troncos

IntroductionAre kinship relations still as relevant in the construction of cultural and/or political power in New Mexico as they were in the past? How did ethnicity, gender, class and kinship influence the formation of local governing bodies during the early 19th century Mexican Period in northern New Mexico? This research performs a critical analysis of petitions and political records extracted from northern New Mexico between 1800 and 1848 in order to better describe power dynamics in 19th century New Mexico. By critically analyzing the concept of kinship or “Parentesco”, this research seeks to understand the gendered construction of power in a critical period of New Mexico’s history. This research contributes to the fields of American Studies and History with further implications for the fields of Chicana & Chicano studies, Cultural and Ethnic studies, and Gender and Women studies.

Methodology of the StudyThis research is organized in three phases. The first phase begins with a literature review concerning the construction of cultural and political societies during the 19th century. Phase two consists of accessing archival material from the Center for Southwest Research and Special collections at the University of New Mexico. In this phase, working with an archivist is imperative specifically finding relevant materials such as petitions, marriage certificates and other documents. The third and final phase consist of analyzing the documents focusing specifically on the construction of social, political, and economic dynamics. This phase will require working with archival Spanish documents using Old Spanish language as well as the use of Paleography to read and interpret these documents. Questions guiding research included:

1)  How do individuals gain formal and informal access to power through the use of legal petitions?2)  How does kinship influence the formation of governing bodies and/ or political decisions?3)  How does gender influence the construction of kinship and political power during the 19th century Mexican Period?

AcknowledgmentsI would like to acknowledge the support of the University of New Mexico Chicana and Chicano Studies Program, The Center for Southwest Research Studies, and the Ronald E. McNair Scholars and Research Opportunity Program.

Description of the Archival DocumentsThree archival documents I analyzed are written below by Don Domingo Fernandez, a local citizen. The first document is the correspondence between Don Domingo Fernandez to Señor Jefe Politico del Archivo General de la Nacion de Ayuntamientos (Mexico City) December 1834. In the document, Don Fernandez references the Supreme Spanish Law of May 19, 1813, prohibiting Parentesco in Ayuntamiento (town council) elections. Don Fernandez asks that the election be nullified due to the familial ties or affinity. Correspondence from the Jefe Politico indicates that more evidence is needed for this severe claim and that the accused is exonerated until evidence and proof of Parentesco is provided.

The second document is correspondence between Don Fernandez and the Governor Don Francisco Sarracino (1835). In this document Don Fernandez indicates the kinship and Parentesco of the appointed/ elected officials. In this document, the governor’s reply is not legible but the top portion of the document states “nulado por la ley” which translates to “Void by law.” This indicates that during this time Parentesco was being contested to a higher authority.

The final document is Don Fernandez genealogical Tronco which indicates Parentesco; particularly relating through matrilineal kinship.

FindingsThrough these archival documents, evidence of Parentesco in political elections and appointments were apparent in Northern New Mexico regardless of the Supreme law prohibiting it. Correspondence between one citizen, Don Domingo Fernandez, and a higher official indicated that individuals were aware and petitioned to resolve the discrepancy. The kinship of many of the accused traced back through a matrilineal family line. In this case the Tronco led back to Don Miguel De La Vega y Coca, a prominent Mexican elite, that entered New Mexico with the colonists of 1693. The Troncos of the named individuals indicate relationships through their wives. This matrilineal relationship indicates the importance of familial bonds; not always through bloodlines but through marriage or kinship. The status and wealth of women’s familial line was reproduced through political titles and power holding. Women lacked formal access to political power; but their family lines could legitimize and support male members’ access to political office.

Claudia Mitchell, Chicana and Chicano Studies, University of New MexicoFaculty Mentors: Dr. Irene Vasquez, Director of UNM Chicana and Chicano Studies, Mr. Samuel Sisneros, Archivist of UNM Center

for Southwest Research Studies

Key Literature Citations•  Ayuntamiento 1833-1834. (AGN Vol 17. f:

213-217). Archivo Nacional de la Nacion ayuntamiento, (Mexico City) Center for Southwest Research, University Libraries, University of New Mexico

•  Chavez, Angelico, and Angelico Chavez. Origins of New Mexico Families: A Genealogy of the Spanish Colonial Period. Santa Fe:

Museum of New Mexico, 1992. Print.•  Cutter, Charles R. The Legal Culture of

Northern New Spain, 1710-1810. Albuqueruque U of New Mexico, 1995. print.

•  Gonzales, Deena J. Refusing the Favor: The Spanish-Mexican Women of Santa Fe 1820-1880. New York: Oxford UP, 1990. print

•  Stamatov, Suzanne. Family, Kin, and Community in Colonial New Mexico, 1694-1800. Diss. University of New Mexico, 2003. print.

 

Key Definitions• Parentesco: Kinship / Relationship• Troncos: Family Tree • Ayuntamientos: (town council) Municipalities • Jefe Político: Local political boss

Preliminary ThesisThe preliminary findings of this study indicate that “Parentesco” (kinship), a remnant of the Spanish colonial period, continued to impact political elections during the 19th century. This practice developed in frontier regions and enabled families to continue political kinship through marriage. Although women did not hold formal political power, through “Parentesco” (kinship) they influenced political power.

The Hidden Side of Power and Politics: Gender and Political Kinship in Northern New Mexico

during the Nineteenth-Century Mexican Period