the prevention of sports injuries in · pdf file · 2015-03-26the prevention of...

14
. PEDIATRIC AND ADOLESCENT SPORTS INJURIES 0278-5919/00 $15.00 + .00 THE PREVENTION OF SPORTS INJURIES IN CHILDREN Lyle]. Micheli, MO, Rita Glassman, and Michelle Klein, BS Injuries from sports participation are a significant cause of hospital- ization and health care costs in children and adolescents.38 Injuries are the second leading cause of emergency room visits for youth and the second leading cause of injury in schools.37 Although there are no hard statistics,. owing to surveillance and external cause of injury code (E-code) limitations (only 33% of injuries are identifiable as a sports injury using the International Classification of Diseases,Ninth Revision [ICD-9] cod- ing system38), estimates are that 3 million youth are seen in hospital emergency rooms each year for sports-related injuries,40 and another 5 million are seen by their physicians and sports medicine clinics for sports-related injuries. Twenty-five percent to 30% of youth sports injur- ies occur in organized sports, and another 40% occur in unorganized sports}S Deaths from some sports, even those specified by E-codes, may be underestimated. For example, in 1986the 58 recreational scuba diving deaths identifiable in the National Health Statistics Data using E-codes were far fewer than the 94 reported to the National Underwater Accident Data Center.! In 1997, the medical cost of sports injuries for youth age 0 to 14 in the United States for product-related injuries was $365,470,091,189 for 28 sports: archery, baseball, basketball, bicy- cling, boxing, diving, field hockey, football, golf, gymnastics, horseback riding, ice hockey, ice skating, inline skating, martial arts, mountain bikes, roller skating, skiing, soccer, softball, swimming, tennis, track and field, trampolines, volleyball, weightlifting and wrestling.42(These statistics do not reflect the large number of overuse injuries currently presented to pediatricians, family physicians, and clinics.) It is estimated that 25 million scholastic and 20 million organized, From the Departments of Sports Medicine and Orthopedic Surgery, dilldren's Hospital and Harvard Medical School (LJM); and the National Youth Sports Safety Foundation (RG, MK), Boston, Massachusetts CLINICS IN SPORTS MEDICINE 821 VOLUME 19 .NUMBER 4 .OCTOBER 2000

Upload: vophuc

Post on 30-Mar-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

.

PEDIATRIC AND ADOLESCENT SPORTS INJURIES 0278-5919/00 $15.00 + .00

THE PREVENTION OF SPORTSINJURIES IN CHILDREN

Lyle]. Micheli, MO, Rita Glassman, and Michelle Klein, BS

Injuries from sports participation are a significant cause of hospital-ization and health care costs in children and adolescents.38 Injuries arethe second leading cause of emergency room visits for youth and thesecond leading cause of injury in schools.37 Although there are no hardstatistics,. owing to surveillance and external cause of injury code (E-code)limitations (only 33% of injuries are identifiable as a sports injury usingthe International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision [ICD-9] cod-ing system38), estimates are that 3 million youth are seen in hospitalemergency rooms each year for sports-related injuries,40 and another 5million are seen by their physicians and sports medicine clinics forsports-related injuries. Twenty-five percent to 30% of youth sports injur-ies occur in organized sports, and another 40% occur in unorganizedsports}S Deaths from some sports, even those specified by E-codes, maybe underestimated. For example, in 1986 the 58 recreational scuba divingdeaths identifiable in the National Health Statistics Data using E-codeswere far fewer than the 94 reported to the National UnderwaterAccident Data Center.! In 1997, the medical cost of sports injuriesfor youth age 0 to 14 in the United States for product-related injurieswas $365,470,091,189 for 28 sports: archery, baseball, basketball, bicy-cling, boxing, diving, field hockey, football, golf, gymnastics, horsebackriding, ice hockey, ice skating, inline skating, martial arts, mountainbikes, roller skating, skiing, soccer, softball, swimming, tennis, trackand field, trampolines, volleyball, weightlifting and wrestling.42 (Thesestatistics do not reflect the large number of overuse injuries currentlypresented to pediatricians, family physicians, and clinics.)

It is estimated that 25 million scholastic and 20 million organized,

From the Departments of Sports Medicine and Orthopedic Surgery, dilldren's Hospitaland Harvard Medical School (LJM); and the National Youth Sports Safety Foundation(RG, MK), Boston, Massachusetts

CLINICS IN SPORTS MEDICINE

821VOLUME 19 .NUMBER 4 .OCTOBER 2000

822 MICHELI et al

community-based youth participate in sports annually in the UnitedStates.40 Young athletes often begin their competitive careers as early asage 721 and organized sports participation as early as age 4.

MECHANISMS OF SPORTS INJURIES

There are two mechanisms of sports injury: macrotrauma, that is,acute trauma, and repetitive microtrauma, that is, injury resulting fromoveruse.43

Macrotrauma is defined as a sudden acute injury from a major force,for example a collision or a fall. Acute macrotrauma injuries of themusculoskeletal system include fractures of the long bones and axialskeleton; sprains of joint ligaments; strains of muscle tendon units; andcontusions involving muscle tendon units and their overlying soft tissue.

Microtrauma results from chronic repetitive injury to tissue over anextended period, such as a stress fracture. Other overuse injuries includebursitis, tendonitis, apophysitis of tendon insertions, and in certain cases,osteochondral injuries of the joint surface.

Injuries related to sports participation range from catastrophic acuteaccidents, such as spinal damage and concussions, to overuse injuries,such as tennis elbow and shin splintS.28 Overuse injuries may be thecommonest class of sports injuries encountered by primary care physi-cians.31

FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO SPORTS INJURIES

Sports injuries are not accidents. They are predictable incidents thatare amenable to prevention.3 There are many reasons why sports injuriesoccur. Research has identified the following frequent factors2:

.Lack of coaching education

.Inadequate preparticipation physical exams

.Hazardous playing fields

.Conditioning and training errors

.Lack of, improper, poorly fitted, or inadequate safety equipment.Playing while injured or overtired.Declining fitness levels of children.Grouping teams by age instead of size.Poor nutrition.Rules and officials.Improper technique (e.g., in tennis, improper swing may cause

the tennis player to develop tennis elbow).Inadequate supervision.Psychologic stress.Weather conditions.Growth (e.g., bones grow faster than ligaments and tendons, caus-

823'mE PREVENTION OF SPORTS INJURIES IN CHILDREN

ing ligaments to be "tight," which may lead to injury if attentionis not paid to flexibility training)

Each young athlete has individual risk factors;S and each sportposes its own risk for injury. The number and severity of injuries differswith the level of competition. Unfortunately, little systematic researchhas been done to obtain baseline rates of injury in youth sports or tostudy the effects of alterations of their risk factors on the incidence orrelative severity of injury.24 One of the most obvious risk factors is theequipment used in sports, which is relatively accessible for evaluation.In 1988, Janda et al20 published a landmark prospective study thatcompared the rates of injury in recreational softball between leaguesusing traditional fixed bases and leagues using breakaway bases. Theydemonstrated an injury rate seven times lower in leagues using break-away bases: Regarding volume and intensity of training, Goldstein etalll reported, in 1991, on back injuries in young female gymnasts. Theyfound a significantly increased incidence of back injuries in those gym-nasts who trained more than 16 hours per week. A second study pro-vided additional insight into the volume of training outcomes fromJapan. This study of youth baseball pitchers found that pitchers whoperformed more than 300 skilled throws per week in games and trainingsessions sustained a significantly higher incidence of elbow injuries.

A third area of research, playing technique, has focused recently onthe relatively high rate of noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injuriesin young female athletes engaged in contact or "cutting" sports, such assoccer, basketball, and team handball.25 Henning et al14 first studied therole that playing techniques such as cutting might have on the recurrenceor amelioration of this injury in female athletes. More recently, Hewettet al16 published an important prospective study that demonstrated asignificant decrease in ACL injuries in female athletes engaged in soccerand basketball who are taught a structured, proprioceptive technique ofcutting and turning before engaging in their sports. Their rate of injurywas significantly less compared with controls.

Before preventative measures can be implemented effectively, it isimportant to determine what types of injuries are most prevalent, whosustains the injuries, and why and where they occur}7 This is accom-plished through surveillance, which is mandatory if progress is to bemade in the prevention of sports injuries.26

Despite considerable literature devoted to the sports injuries ofchildren and youth, there is no surveillance system to document theepidemiology of the injuries for young athletes.33 Isolated studies haverecorded the incidence and frequency of injuries in some sports, but themethodology of data collection and reporting is so fragmented that asystematic analysis and recommendations for change are speculative.4

Recognizing the need for data, the National Institutes of Health39convened a conference in 1991, Sports Injuries in Youth: Surveillance Strate-gies, to develop guidelines for programs to monitor the rates and costsof youth sports injuries. The objectives of the conference were to increase

824 MICHELI et aI

awareness of the need for data, to demonstrate how the informationcould be used, to stimulate data collection efforts, and to encourageepidemiologic research in this area.39

More recently, the Federation Internationale de Medecine du Sportand the World Health Organization (FIMS / WHO)9 issued a joint positionstatement calling for all youth sports organizations to initiate injurysurveillance systems.

Several surveillance systems to capture limited data are in existence.The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) operates the NationalElectronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS), which captures data frommore than a hundred hospital emergency rooms on only product-relatedinjuries. In 1982, the National Center for Catastrophic Sports InjuryResearch was established at the University of North Carolina at ChapelHill. Several national governing bodies of sports have established sur-veillance systems, in addition to the National Collegiate Athletic Associ-ation.

As many as 18 national medical and sports organizations have beeninvolved with injury prevention efforts in the last 20 years, advocatingsafer sports for youth.33 The American Academy of Pediatrics, the Ameri-can Medical Association, the American College of Sports Medicine,the International Federation of Sports Medicine, the American DentalAssociation, the National Athletic Trainers Association, and the Ameri-can Association of Orthopedic Sports Medicine have come forth withposition papers addressing topics such as nutritional supplements, safetyequipment, conditioning, training, and sport-specific injuries. Nationalgoverning bodies of sports and the National Federation of State HighSchool Associations and the National College Athletic Association havesports medicine committees that address rules, safety equipment, play-ing time, preparticipation physicals, and supplements. There was how-ever, no system or organization to disseminate the information otherthan journals, and it took many years for the information to reachthe public. '

Recognizing the need for the timely dissemination of informationand the lack of one organization in the country devoted solely to theprevention of athletic injuries in youth, the National Youth Sports SafetyFoundation, Inc. (NYSSF) was created in 1989 to serve as an educationalresource. The mission of the NYSSF (a nonprofit educational organiza-tion) is to reduce the number and severity of injuries that youth sustainin sports and fitness activities through the education of health profes-sionals, program administrators, coaches, parents, and athletes. TheNYSSF's mission is a commitment to promote the healthy developmentof youth and to keep them physically active and involved in sportsfor life.

The NYSSF publishes fact sheets, resource sheets, guidelines, re-ports, and a quarterly newsletter, Sidelines. In addition, the NYSSF pub-lishes the Yearbook of Youth Sports Safety, a compilation of informationfrom national medical and sports organizations. The NYSSF is the leadorganization for National Youth Sports Safety Month, a national health

825'mE PREVENTION OF SPORTS INJURIES IN anLDREN

campaign observed during the month of April to promote safety inyouth sports activities, which is supported by more than 60 nationalmedical and sports organizations. The NYSSF has initiated a new move-ment and is leading the country in promoting safety in sports activitiesfor youth.

Many conferences addressing different aspects of sports injurieshave been held throughout the United States. The American Society forTesting and Materials Sports Equipment Committee convened severaldifferent conferences on sports safety. In 1992, the Second InternationalSymposium on Safety in Ice Hockey5 was held in Pennsylvania. Itaddressed epidemiological factors, injury treatment modalities, playingfacilities, and protective equipment such as eye protection, helmets, andmouthguards. A Symposium on Head and Neck Injuries in Sports17 washeld in Atlanta, Georgia in May 1993. It had two objectives, alongwith its main focus of epidemiology: (1) To review and evaluate theeffectiveness of factors related to safety; and (2) to determine whetherthese safety factors could be modified and improved to reduce injuryrates, while not adversely modifying or affecting the basic nature of thephysical activity or sports in which the injuries occurred. The Sympo-sium on Safety in American FootbalP8 was held in Phoenix, Arizona, in1994 and focused on risks and whether risks could be modified orlimited. The International Symposium on Safety in Baseball/Softbal16was held in Atlanta, Georgia, in 1995. This symposium's mission wasto review the state-of-the-art and science of new products, materials,technology, and epidemiology.

The problem of youth sports injuries also has recently stimulatedthe Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) and the Centers forDisease Control and Prevention to conduct national forums on thistopic.33 Several roundtable discussions were held that focused on soccergoal posts and baseball safety equipment. In 1996, the CPSC issued afinal report on the Youth Baseball Protective Equipment Project.23 Thegoal of the project was to develop information for the general publicabout what types of available protective equipment could prevent orreduce the severity of baseball-, softball-, and tee-ball-related injuriesand deaths to children ages 5 to 14. The reported concluded:

There were an estimated 162,100 baseball related injuries tochildren ages 5-14 treated in hospital emergency rooms in 1995.

About one-third of these injuries (more than 58,000 injuries)occurred in circumstances where available protective equipment

could be expected to help reduce the severity of the injury, oreliminate it altogether. The 47,900 injuries that involved ball impact

to the head/neck area might have been lessened in severity orprevented by the use of softer balls. The 3,900 facial injuries thatoccurred to batters in organized play could have been prevented

by the use of face guards. And the 6,600 base-contact slidinginjuries that occurred in organized play might have been lessened

in severity or prevented by the use of safety release bases.23

On May 4, 1999, the CPSC and the soccer equipment industry

826 MIGffiLI et al

announced the development of a new safety standard that will reducethe risk for soccer goal tip-over. Since 1979, the CPSC has learned of 23deaths and 38 serious injuries from soccer goals tipping over and crush-ing children who climb on them or hand from the crossbar.41

Coaching Education

The United States is the only country in the major sporting worldthat does not have a national coaching education program. With morethan 3.5 million coaches in the United States there is no nationallyaccepted system of certification for coaches.22 There are no federal lawsrequiring coaching education at any level of competition, includingyouth sports, interscholastic, collegiate, or Olympic. Untrained coachesunknowingly may contribute to the occurrence of sports injuries insteadof helping to prevent them because they may have no formal educationin conditioning and training, growth and development, injury preven-tion, sport pedagogy, or psychology.

Coaching education programs have been developed by individuals,organizations, and universities. Until 1996, there were no standards forthese programs until The National Standards for Athletic Coaches, aconsensus project, was published. The project was facilitated by theNational Association for Sport and Physical Education (NASPE), con-sisting of more than 200 organizations and individual experts}O NASPEis currently in the process of developing the National Council for Accred-itation of Coaching.29

The National Federation of State High School Associations adoptedthe American Sport Education Program for coaching education in 1990.35It is up to each state to mandate it, however. In 1998, it was noted that36 states had passed legislation requiring coaches to have educationalcourses to be able to coach.36 More than 50% of the interscholasticcoaches in the country do not hold a teaching certificate and have noaffiliation with the school systems. Only one state (New Jersey) has anyrequirements for volunteer coaches}3

In 1997, the United States Olympic Committee (USOC), the leadorganization for sports in the United States, joined with the AmericanRed Cross to develop a Sports Safety Training Course (SST) for coaches.The USOC has announced the course will be mandatory for all USOCcoaches.7 The SST includes injury prevention, first aid, and CPR, and isdelivered nationwide through local chapters of the American Red Cross.

PREVENTION STRATEGIES

It is estimated that up to one half of all injuries sustained whileplaying organized sports by children and adolescents may be prevent-able.8 The American College of Sports Medicine8 noted that, as thenumber of children and adolescents in organized sports increases, newinjury patterns are developing that were not apparent when youth spent

THE PREVENTION OF SPORTS INJURIES IN CHILDREN 827

most of their sport and fitness time in free play. The following preventionmeasures were highlighted8:

.Coaches and teachers should emphasize that general fitness is thebasis for all sports participation. Fitness exercises should be in-cluded in the training routine rather than devoting all of eachtraining session to the development of specific skills required fora certain sport.

.Children may be encouraged to participate in several differentsports, rather than specializing in a single sport at an early age.

.Instructors of sport should adhere to appropriate training princi-ples and encourage athletes to begin training one or two monthsbefore the actual season begins.

.In the prevention of overuse injuries, it is important for adults toallow the children to play. When young children control the inten-sity of an activity themselves, they seem likely to stay within saferanges of activity level. Parents or coaches, however, often controlthe intensity of the game or training, and this may lead to over-use injuries.

.Rules for adult games should be modified as appropriate foryoung people. For example, softball bases may need to be closer,playing periods shorter, and playing fields proportionatelysmaller.

.Coaches or parents of young athletes who place too much empha-sis on winning may well contribute to the risk for an athletesustaining an injury.

.Opponents in a sports event should ideally be matched by age,height, weight, maturity and skill in order to decrease the inci-dence of injury.

.Competitive sports among children and adolescents should becarefully supervised and rules strictly enforced.

.There should be no more than a 10% increase each week in theamount of training time, amount of distance covered, or numberof repetitions performed in an activity.

.Training sessions should include warm-up and cool-down periodsand flexibility exercises.

.Comprehensive pre-participation physical examinations are rec-ommended for all young athletes.

.Resistance training for children and adolescents should excludelifting of the maximal weight that an individual can accomplish.The amount of weight lifted or resistance used should be no largerthan the amount with which the participant can complete at leastten repetitions in good form.

Consensus Statements

One consensus statement of significance was published by theFIMS/WHO Ad Hoc Committee on Sports and Children.9 Its recommen-dations are as follows9:

828 MIOiEU et al

Addressed to Sports Governing Bodies

.Sports governing bodies must be directly responsible for the safetyand training of young athletes engaged in their particular sports.

.They should institute systems to monitor the level of intensity andcategories of competition in their sports.

.Sports governing bodies should be responsible for preparing andmaintaining ongoing statistics of illness and injury for childrenand adolescents participating in their sports.

.They should be responsible for certifying the credentials ofcoaches at this age level. This will include direct participation incoaching education, certification, and a reasonable assessment ofthe ethical and moral character of their coaches.

.Sports governing bodies have the responsibility to determine stan-dards for protective equipment, playing fields, and duration ofcompetition appropriate for children.

.They should formulate the appropriate legislation related to orga-nized sports for children.

Addressed to Youth Sports Coaches

.Coaches should participate in special programs of education..They should have credentials that encompass: (1) the techniques

and skills of youth sports, (2) the specific safety risks of children'ssports, (3) the psychology and sociology of children and adoles-cents, and (4) the physiology of growth and development as itrelates to physical activity during childhood and adolescence aswell as common medical related issues.

Addressed to Health Professionals

.Health professionals must take steps to improve their knowledgeand understanding of the organized sports environment as wellas the risk factors and safety factors inherent to this type of sportsparticipation.

.Physicians should monitor the health and safety of children in-volved in organized sports whenever possible, in particular, thoseinvolved in elite sports training.

Sports Training

.Sports training for children and adolescents encompasses the agerange from five to 18 years. In the early stages of training, everyemphasis should be given to broad-based participation opportuni-ties to enhance general motor development.

.Sports specialization should be avoided before the age of 10.

.During specialized training, the nutritional status should be moni-tored carefully. In particular, care should be taken to ensure that

THE PREVEN110N OF SPORTS INJURIES IN CInLDREN 829

child athletes are given adequate diets for the high-energy de-mands of sports. In addition, avoid marginal dietary practices, inparticular caloric deprivation, in an attempt to delay maturationof physical development during sports training. (Such dieteticmanipulations to attain competitive advantages must be viewedas a form of child abuse.)

Addressed to Parents

.The Ad Hoc Commission stresses the importance and responsibil-ity of parental participation in the education process regarding thebenefits and risks of sports training in childhood.

.Parents must increase their knowledge and awareness of the bene-fits and risks of competitive sport.

.Parents must be active participants in the process of the coachingand training of their children in sports.

Research

.More research is needed to ascertain the specific benefits and risksof organized sport for children. This information is essential tomaximize the benefits while minimizing the risks that the childrenmay incur in organized sports.

The Inter-Association Guidelines for the Appropriate Care of Spine InjuredAthletes, a consensus paper of 26 professional organizations was devel-oped at a summit initiated by the National Athletic Trainers Associationin Indianapolis, Indiana, May 30-31, 1998. These guidelines were devel-oped for the prehospital management of the physically active participantwith a suspected spinal injury.

Another work of great significance was the guidelines for the pre-participation physical examination endorsed by five medical societies34:American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediat-rics, American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, American Orthopae-dic Society for Sports Medicine and the American Osteopathic Academyof Sports Medicine. Primary objectives of the preparticipation physicalevaluation are to detect conditions that may predispose an athlete toinjury; to detect conditions that may be life threatening or disabling; andto meet legal and insurance requirements. Secondary objectives are todetermine general health, to counsel on health-related issues, and toassess fitness level for specific sports.

BARRIERS TO PREVENTION

There are many barriers to injury-prevention efforts that greatlyaffect the outcome of safety programs. These include misinformation,

830 MICHEU et al

lack of dissemination, tradition-bound resistance, and attitude and prior-ities.

Misinformation

Perhaps the most important barrier to progress in injury control isthe perception that injuries are random occurrences that cannot be pre-dicted or prevented.32 The reality is, however, that injuries are no morelikely to occur by chance than are diseases}2

Common examples of misinformation are typified by statementssuch as, "injuries are part of the game," and "our organization will beheld to a higher standard if we are informed."

Many injuries may be prevented through educational programs, butthere has to be a perceived need for these programs. Many programadministrators and coaches believe injuries are not a problem and thereis no reason to address the issue. In addition, some administratorsbelieve their coaches will be held to a higher standard if they becomeinvolved in litigation resulting from an injury sustained in their program,if their group has had a presentation on safety, or if they have safetyeducational resources available to their coaches.

Dissemination

Another barrier is dissemination. The structure of sports in theUnited States makes the dissemination of injury prevention informationa challenging task. There are collegiate sports programs governed bythe NCAA; interscholastic sports programs governed by the NationalFederation of State High Schools Associations and the Association ofIndependent Schools; competitive sports programs run by national gov-erning bodies of sport; recreational sports programs run by parks andrecreation departments, boys and girls clubs, gyms, YMCAs, and manycommunity independent programs that have no affiliation with a na-tional organization.

At the high school level, as many as 50% of coaches are not certifiedteachers and are termed "walk ons" (individuals not currently employedby the schools as teachers), making the dissemination of information tothem, according to high school athletic directors, difficult, if not impossi-ble. In 1994, the NYSSF Education Committee sent a survey to theexecutive directors of the state high school athletic associations to deter-mine the effectiveness of an injury prevention program to prevent cata-strophic neck and spinal injuries in football. A video, "Prevent Paralysis:Don't Hit with Your Head," was distributed through the National Feder-ation of State High School Associations to its member state associations,who were, in turn, supposed to distribute materials to their local highschools. It was recommended by the National Federation of State High

831mE PREVEN110N OF SPORTS INJURIES IN cmLDREN

School Associations that the video be mandatory viewing for all footballcoaches and students. Of the 51 state high school athletic associationssurveyed, 37 responded. Fourteen state high school athletic associationssaid they never received a copy of the program. Twenty-three respondedthey had received the program, and of those, only two states made theviewing of the video mandatory for players, and six states made itmandatory for football coaches}O Eleven states had catastrophic injuriesthat year, and whether those injuries could have been prevented if thevideo had been shown will not be known.

The results of the survey clearly define the need for program admin-istrators at the highest levels to advocate injury prevention as a highpriority when they disseminate information on prevention programsand to have evaluation procedures.

Community-organized sports programs are independent groupsformed with the objective of giving youth an opportunity to participatein sports activities. Groups may multiply out of parents' dissatisfactionwith existing programs because their children did not have enoughcompetition or enough opportunity to play. Each program indepen-dently addresses rules and safety, without consulting national guidelinesor resources. Often they run without an emergency plan, an immediatefirst-responder in case of injury, and have little access to injury preven-tion resources.

Tradition-Bound Resistance

Tradition-bound resistance is a term dubbed by injury preventionprofessionals to describe a mind-set against change. Examples of thishave appeared in headlines and articles of newspapers across the coun-try: "Debate: Protection vs. tradition. Safety equipment has hard timegaining acceptance" (USA Today, April 23, 1990) and "Baseball, or safeball" (Garden City Telegram, Garden City, KS, February 5, 1992).

Equipment manufacturers have determined the safety needs of chil-dren and youth based on their liability claims. They have been rebuffed,however, by rules committees who await additional, confirming evi-dence that the equipment will promote greater safety or are concernedthat the equipment will alter the traditional nature of the sport.33

Attitude and Priorities

Some sports medicine committees of national governing bodies,such as USA Hockey, believe one death in a sport is one death toomany, and circumstances must be addressed so it never happens again.Another national governing body may justify their catastrophic injurystatistics by the number of youth participating in their sport. The cost-benefit ratio is another barrier to sports safety. At a program on commo-tio cordis (sudden death as a result of nonpenetrating chest wall impact

832 MICHELletal

in the absence of structural injury to the ribs, sternum, and heart)convened by USA Hockey and the American Society for Testing andMaterials, in 1995, in Denver, Colorado, it was reported that the cost ofsafety equipment for each team must be considered in relationship tothe number of deaths, number of participants, and the cost to society.The example presented was: "Four chest protectors for a youth baseballteam would cost approximately $200. There are five million childrenparticipating in youth baseball, with an average of several deaths eachyear. In youth baseball deaths there is very little cost to society becausethe victim died, whereas helmets could be justified because of the hugeexpense involved in maintaining a brain-injured child."

SUMMARY AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS

Sports injuries are a significant problem for children and adolescentsand a great cost to society. With the growth of 'sports has come a growingnumber of injuries. More data are needed to make the issue a nationalpublic health priority, and more funding is needed for research andinjury prevention programs. Education is at the core of sports safety: forprogram administrators, so they will become strong advocates of sportssafety; for coaches, so they will understand the risks for injury and howto prevent them; for parents, so they will understand how to be goodsupport systems for their children; and for the athletes, so they willunderstand how to stay in the game. Although some injury preventionprograms have been developed, their success has been hampered by alack of dissemination, lack of recognition of need by program adminis-trators, and by tradition-bound resistance. An effective injury programrequires effective leadership, dissemination, follow-up, and evaluationsystems in place. Until these happen, millions of children will be injuredeach year resulting from their participation in sports, and at a cost ofbillions of dollars to the US public.

References

1. Baker SF, O'Neill B, Ginsburg MI, et al: Sports and recreation. In Chapter 7: The mjuryFact Book, ed 2. Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1992, pp 89-99

2. Bay State Youth Sports Guide: Resources for sports injury prevention: Sports mjuries:An Overview. Boston, Massachusetts Deparhnent of Public Health, 1989, pp 1-3

3. Bonnie RJ, Fulco CE, Liverman CT (eds): Executive Summary: Reducing the Burdenof mjury: Advancing Prevention and Treatment. Washington, DC, Institute of Medicine.National Academy Press, 1999, pp 1-17

4. Caine D, Caine C, Lindner KJ: Epidemiologic Approach to Sports mjuries, Epidemiol-ogy of Sports mjuries. Olampaign, IL, Human Kinetics Publishers, 1996

5. Castaldi CR, Bishop PI, Hoerner EF, (eds): Safety in Ice Hockey, vol 2. AmericanSociety for Testing and Materials Special Technical Publication 1212. American Societyfor Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, 1993

6. Cosgrove FA, Hoerner EF (eds): mternational Symposium on Safety in Baseball/

833mE PREVENnON OF SPORTS INJURIES IN CHILDREN

Softball. American Society for Testing and Materials Special Technical Publication 1313.American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, 1997

7. Crawford, T: Presentation at the 1995 Coaching Symposium, Olympic Training Center,Colorado Springs, CO. Sept. 7-9, 1995

8. Smith AD, Andrish }T, Micheli LJ: Current comment: The prevention of sport injuriesof children and adolescents. American College of Sports Medicine, August, 1993

9. Federation Internationale de Medecine du Sport/World Health Organization Ad HocCommittee on Sports and Children: Sports and children: Consensus statement onorganized sports for children. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 76:445-447,1998

10. Glassman R: Barriers to injury prevention in youth football: Safety in AmericanFootball. Earl Hoerner (ed): American Society for Testing and Materials Special Techni-cal Publication 1305. American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia, 1996,pp. 3-8

11. Goldstein JD, Berger PE, Windler GE, et al: Spine injuries in gymnasts and swimmers.An epidemiologic investigation. Am J Sports Med. 19:463-468, 1991

12. Haddon W, Jr, Baker SP: Injury control. In Oark DW, MacMahon B (eds): Preventiveand Community Medicine, ed 2. Boston, Little Brown, 1981, pp 109-140

13. Heinzmann GS: Promoting Coaching Education: Lessons from New Jersey's Law.Presentation at National Forum on Coaching Education and Accreditation, Austin TX,January 16-18, 1997

14. Henning CE, Griffis NO, Vequist SW, et al: Sports-specific knee injuries. In RenstromPAFH (ed): Oinical Practice of Sports Injury Prevention and Care: The Encyclopediaof Sports Medicine, vol 5. Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications 1994, pp 164-178

15. Hergenroeder AC: Prevention of sports injuries. Pediatrics 101:1057-1063, 199816. Hewett TE, Lindenfeld TN, Riccobene ]v; et al: The effect of neuromuscular training

on the incidence of knee injury in female athletes: A prospective study. Am J SportsMed 27:699-706, 1999

17. Hoerner EF (ed): Head and Neck Injuries in Sports. American Society for Testing andMaterials Special Technical Publication 1229. American Society for Testing and Materi-als, Philadelphia, 1994

18. Hoerner EF (ed): Safety in American Football. American Society for Testing andMaterials Special Technical Publication 1305. American Society for Testing and Materi-als, Philadelphia, 1997

19. Micheli LJ, et al: Individual Risk Factors Fact Sheet. Boston, Education Committee ofthe National Youth Sports Safety Foundation, 1996

20. Janda DH, Wojtys EM, Hankin FM, et al: Softball sliding injuries: A prospective studycomparing standard and modified bases. JAMA 259:1848-1850,1988

21. Kammer SK, Young CC, Niedfeldt MW: Swimming injuries and illnesses. The Physi-cian and Sports Medicine 27:51-60, 1999

22. Kimiecik JC: Who needs coaches? education? US Coaches do. The Physician and Sportsmedicine, 16:124-136, 1988

23. Medford R, Kyle S: Youth Baseball Protective Equipment Project Final Report. Director-ate for Epidemiology and Health Sciences, Division of Hazard Analysis, US ConsumerProduct Safety Commission, Washington DC, May 1996

24. Micheli LJ: Sports injuries in Children and adolescents: Questions and controversies.am Sports Med. 14:727-745, 1995

25. Micheli LJ, Metzl JD, Di Canzio J, et al: Anterior cruciate ligament reconstructivesurgery in adolescent soccer and basketball players. am J Sport Med..9:138-141, 1999

26. Mueller OF, Cantu RC, Van Camp SP: Catastrophic Injuries in High School and CollegeSports, HK Sport Science Monograph Series, vol 8. Human Kinetics Publishing, 1996

27. Mueller F, Blyth C: Epidemiology of sports injuries in children. Clin Sports Med1:343-352, 1982

28. Muscari M: Preventing sports injuries. Am J of Nurs 7:58-60, 199829. National Coaching Congress, National Association of Sport and Physical Education,

Englewood, Colorado, January 22-24, 199930. National Standards for Athletic Coaches, National Association for Sport and Physical

Education. 1995. p 124

834 MICHEU et al

31. O'Connor FG, Howard TM, Nirschl RP: Managing overuse injuries: A systematicapproach. The Physician and Sports Medicine 25:xx, 1997

32. Pinkham JR, Kohn DW: Epidemiology and prediction of sports-related traumaticinjuries. Dent Gin North Am 35:609-627,1991

33. Poinsett A: The role of sports in youth development. Carnegie Meeting Papers, Carne-gie Corporation of New York, March 18, 1996, pp 109

34. American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediatrics, AmericanMedical Society for Sports Medicine, et al: Pre-participation Physical Evaluation, ed 2.Physician and Sports Medicine 1997 .

35. American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Pediatrics, AmericanMedical Society for Sports Medicine, et al: Raising the Standard: The 1997 NationalInterscholastic Coaching Requirements Report. American Sports Education Program,Human Kinetics, December, 1996

36. Raising the Standard: The 1999 National Interscholastic Coaching Requirements Re-port. American Sport Education Program and National Federation of State HighSchools Association, 1998

37. School Injuries Fact Sheet. Injuries in the School Environment: A Resource Packet.Children's Safety Network, National Injury and Violence Prevention Resource Center,October 1994

38. Smith GS, Gallagher 55, Helsing K et al: Sports Injury Hospitalizations: Incidence andCoding Problems [abstract]. Paper Presented at 115th Annual Meeting of the AmericanPublic Health Association, New Orleans, October 20, 1987

39. Sports Injuries in Youth: Surveillance Strategies Proceedings. Bethesda, MD: NationalInstitutes of Health, April 8-9, 1991

40. Stanitski C: Pediatric and adolescent sports injuries. Clin Sports Med 16:613-633, 199741. US Consumer Product Safety Commission: Fifteen Deaths Prompt Warning: Movable

Soccer Goals Can Tip Over On Children. Washington DC, Release no. 92-133, 199242. US Consumer Product Safety Commission, Office of Economic Analysis, Prunella W,

Chief Economist, 199943. Wojtys EM: Sports injuries in the immature athlete. Orthop Clin North Am 18:689-

708, 1987

Address reprint requests to

Lyle J. Micheli, MDChildren's Hospital and Harvard Medical School

300 Longwood AvenueBoston, MA 02115