un voted 138-9 to grant ...imes | biola university

2/21/2015 UN voted 138-9 to grant Palestine observer state status « The Chimes | Biola University

http://chimes.biola.edu/story/2012/dec/13/palestine-story/ 1/6

Biola University

AboutAcademicsAdmissionsAthleticsNews & EventsResourcesOfficesSearch

The Chimes: Biola’ Student Newspaper

About UsPositions

NewsFeaturesSportsA&EOpinionsBlogsPhotos & Videos

Go

Tweet 0

0Like

Email

Print

UN voted 138-9 to grant Palestine observer statestatus

By Julia HenningDecember 13, 20121 Comments



United Nation Headquarters | Courtesy of wilpf.org [Creative Commons]

Palestine joined the Holy See as the second observer state to the United Nations after a 138-9 vote in the

U.N. on Nov. 29. This occurred on the 65th anniversary of the U.N. Special Committee on Palestine

ruling which approved the plan to divide Palestine in order to make create a Jewish state.

An observer state is a non-member state allowed to observe the U.N.

“Non-member States having received a standing invitation to participate as observers in the sessions and

the work of the General Assembly and maintaining permanent observer missions at Headquarters,”

according to the online U.N. description of permanent observer states.

Robert Williams, associate professor of political science at Pepperdine University, said that this was a

step in the direction of statehood.

UN recognition unecessary for statehood

He said that it is not U.N. recognition that establishes a state. It is a bilateral recognition of statehood by

other countries in the world. Prior to the Nov. 29 ruling, Palestine was recognized by 132 countries as a

legitimate state, including many European nations, according to the United Nations’ “Status of Palestine

in the United Nations.” However, Palestine is gaining international attention by applying for and gaining

observer statehood, Williams said.

This ruling may have little effect on people actually in Palestine, according to Williams.

“I don’t think there’s really any discernable impact for people in these places. It’s something that

diplomats and international lawyers will worry over,” Williams said.

Young Palestinian ideas of statehood

Junior intercultural studies major Riley Wall explained that in 2011, he was given the opportunity to live



with an American couple in Palestine. During this time, he was talked to the people about political issues,such as the importance of having a Palestinian state.

He said that he talked to a 16-year-old girl, who told him she did not want Palestine to be an independentstate, because then Palestine would lose international funding and aid. The younger generation inPalestine is more concerned with having rights and freedom than they are with having the politicalrecognition of statehood, Wall said. This contrasted with the conversations Wall had with the oldergeneration in Palestine, who typically want Palestine to become an independent nation.

“The reason that the adults and older people would want their independence is because they were the firstgeneration out of [the land] and are the recipients of being kicked out of Jerusalem, so they are mostsensitive to the issues at hand whereas the youth are more detached from knowing what it was like to be astate,” Wall said.

Opportunities for Palestine

This ruling may allow Palestine the opportunity to take Israel before the international court and chargethem of war crimes, according to Williams.

“One of things people have been focusing on is whether or not Palestine can now join the internationalcriminal court and accept its jurisdiction, which might give it the opportunity to bring complaints againstIsrael,” Williams said.

In order for Palestine to become a full state in the U.N., they would have to fit the criteria outlined by TheMontevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States from 1933. This outlined four major goals aprospective state must fulfill in order to be established as a nation-state including a permanent population,defined territory, government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. Williams believesPalestine’s next step would be to draft a constitution.

There will be a turning point in mid-January, Williams explained, when Israel has elections. Palestinewould have to respond to either a strengthening of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu'sgovernment, or a new government.

“This is always one of those issues where a new government potentially means changes in negotiations,changes in the status of whatever is not working at present. So there might be something new that mightwork,” Williams said.

Ronald Pierce, professor of biblical and theological studies at Biola, explained that he thought anyprogress Palestine gained in becoming a recognized people and state was positive.

“I think it’s a step forward. As I’ve studied negotiations over the years and been in a few myself on otherissues, I’ve come to learn that very small steps are better than no steps,” he said.

However, Wall didn’t think Palestine gaining observer state status in the eyes of the U.N. meant verymuch.

“If the term statehood is not accomplishing to get the Israeli settlements out of there, then it doesn’t reallymatter if it’s a state or not because it’s their territory but they don’t really have rights to it because Israelhas property there,” Wall said.

Junior political science major Anna Reeser, president of the Jewish Studies Club, said she thought thatPalestine going through the U.N. for statehood, rather than approaching Israel for peace talks, may havemore harm than good.

“I actually think it undermines the whole peace process thing and kind of shows an unwillingness onPalestine’s part to have direct negotiations with Israel. It’s almost like they’re going in the back door,”



Reeser said.

Pierce explained that he thought Biola needed to facilitate more discussions about the Israel-Palestineconflict where both sides of the conflict.

“We need to have a greater awareness for the other voice,” Pierce said. “I think we need to hear the othervoices … We’ve been intentional about other issues, I don’t think this is an issue of clear biblical rightand wrong.”

By Julia Henning

Other Stories

Stribbling/Mattocks and Brady Lee take SGA/SMUpresidential electionsby Dayna Drum , Grace Gibney & Alondra Urizar on February 19, 2015

Taylor Stribbling and Drew Mattocks beat their opponents for the SGA presidential seat by 99votes.

Debate brings platforms to the tableby Alondra Urizar on February 18, 2015

Candidates defend their goals for their potential new positions through a question and answersession in front of a student audience.



SCORR conference facilitates further racial discussionby Melissa Hedrick on February 18, 2015

The annual SCORR conference will address racial issues brought up last semester as one avenue ofcontinuing the conversation

Your Turn. Post a Comment1. Prof. Taheri

The final resolution of the conflict is brilliantly depicted (as though in fiction) in JonathanBloomfield’s award-winning book, “Palestine.” December 13, 2012

Name:

Email: Your email will not be published as part of your comment.

Comment:

Submit

Advertisement YOUR AD HERE

More from Williams:Similar reasons that the United States supports Israel:

the United States is the protector of Israel’s interests in the U.N.the Jewish lobby means a lot to the United States governmentthe United States played a significant part in Israel's foundingthe idea of Israel being an important ally in a troublesome regionIsrael is a democracy in a region where there aren’t very many democracies



Contact BiolaRequest Admission InfoLibraryGiving to BiolaEmploymentPress Room

Biola University13800 Biola Ave. La Mirada, CA 906391-562-903-6000Maps & Directions | Privacy Policy© 1996-2015 Biola University, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

un voted 138-9 to grant ...imes | biola university

Documents