class activity rubric (rubrik aktivitas dalam kelas · batas satuan batuan structural geology...
TRANSCRIPT
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Class Activity Rubric (Rubrik Aktivitas dalam Kelas)
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Interaction (5%)
(Interaksi)
Interaction among fellow
participants and lecturers are very
well
Interaksi antara sesama peserta
mata kuliah dan dosen sangat
baik
Interaction only to lecturers and not fully
to other participants.
Interaksi hanya kepada dosen dan tidak
sepenuhnya kepada peserta lainnya
Interaction is only among fellow
participants of the course, interaction
with lecturer is minimu.
Interaksi hanya sesama peserta mata
kuliah, interaksi dengan dosen kurang
No interaction among
friends and lecturers.
Tidak ada interaksi
antara teman dan dosen
Question (25%)
(Pertanyaan)
Actively ask each question in
class
Aktif mengajukan pertanyaan
setiap tatap muka berlansung di
kelas
Occasionally asking questions in class
Sesakali mengajukan pertanyaan dalam
kuliah tatap muka di kelas
Ever ask questions during class
Pernah mengajukan pertanyaan
selama tatap muka di kelas
Never asking questions
during class
Tidak pernah mengajukan
pertanyaan saat kuliah
Attitude (20%)
(Perilaku)
Shows a good attitude and never
comes late
Menunjukkan sikap yang baik dan
tidak pernah terlambat
Shows a good attitude, once ever come
late
Menunjukkan sikap yang baik, pernah
terlambat
Shows a good attitude, but often come
late
Menunjukkan sikap yang baik, tetapi
sering telambat
Not showing a good
attitude and often comes
late
Tidak menunjukkan sikap
yang baik dan sering
telambat
Effort (25%)
(Usaha)
Completed the task/exercise with
full awareness and confidence
Menyelesaikan tugas/latihan
dengan penuh kesadaran dan
percaya diri)
Completed the task, alone but not yet
fully confident
Menyelesaikan tugas, sendiri tetapi
belum sepenuhnya percaya diri
Completed the task, but cannot work
independently
Menyelesaikan tugas, tetapi tidak
dapat bekerja mandiri
No effort in finishing the
given assignments or
exercises
Tidak ada usaha saat
diberi tugas atau latihan
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Group
Discussion
(25%)
(Diskusi
Kelompok )
Able to discuss and take full
participation and focus on the
topic
Mampu berdiskusi dan mengambil
peran serta sepenuhnya focus
pada subtansi
Able to discuss with other participants,
but not fully focus on the substance
Mampu berdiskusi dengan peserta
lainnya, tetapi belum sepenuhnya focus
pada subtansi
Able to discuss with other participants,
but less contribution to the substance
Mampu berdiskusi dengan peserta
lainnya, tetapi kurang konstribusi
pada subtansi
Not taking any role in the
discussions with friends
Tidak mengambil peran
salam diskusi dengan
teman
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Geological Mapping Rubric (Rubrik Pemetaan Geologi)
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Presentation
(15% )
(Presentasi)
Introduction, method,
result according to
report and map,
conclusion
Pengantar, metode,
hasil sesuai laporan
dan peta, kesimpulan
Structured with a clear
voice indicates the
relevance of the substance
as well as the evidence of
geological mapping
Berstruktur dengan suara
jelas sepenuhnya
menunjukkan relevansi
subtansi serta bukti
pemetaan geologi)
Structured with a clear voice
and partially able to
demonstrate the relevance of
the substance and evidence of
geological mapping
Berstruktur dengan suara
jelas dan sebagian mampu
menunjukkan relevansi
subtansi dan bukti pemetaan
geologi)
Structured with a clear
voice, but not fully relevant
to the substance and
evidence of geological
mapping
Berstruktur dengan suara
jelas, tetapi tidak
sepenunhnya relevan
dengan subtansi dan bukti
hasil pemetaan geologi
Unstructured, unclear voice
and seemingly not covering
the geological mapping
results
Tidak berstruktur, suara
tidak jelas dan kelihatan
tidak mengusai hasil
pemetaan geologi
Report (35% ) (Laporan)
Geomorphology
Geomorfologi
Identification and
geomorphological
description is complete,
geomorphological elements
fully describe the conditions
of lithology and structure
Identifikasi dan deskripsi
geomorfologi lengkap,
unsur geomorfologi
menggambarkan kondisi
litologi dan struktur
Identification and
geomorphological
descriptions are sufficient,
and the geomorphological
element sufficiently describe
the conditions of lithology
and structure
Identifikasi dan deskripsi
geomorfologi cukup, unsur
geomorfologi cukup
menggambarkan kondisi
litologi dan struktur
Identification and
geomorphological
descriptions are sufficient,
but the geomorphological
element does not describe
the conditions of lithology
and structure
Identifikasi dan deskripsi
geomorfologi cukup, tetapi
unsur geomorfologi tidak
menggambarkan kondisi
litologi dan struktur
Identification and
geomorphological
description is not complete,
geomorphological elements
do not describe the
conditions of lithology and
structure
Identifikasi dan deskripsi
geomorfologi tidaklengkap,
unsur geomorfologi tidak
menggambarkan kondisi
litologi dan struktur
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Stratigraphy
Stratigrafi
The description of lithology
is correct and the division of
stratigraphic units is
arranged correctly
supported by relative
elements, the discussion is
interrelated with maps,
geological columns and
sections
Deskripsi litologi benar dan
pembagian unit stratigrafi
disusun secara benar yang
didukung oleh unsur
relative, pembahasan saling
terkait dengan peta, kolom
dan penampang geologi)
The description of lithology
is correct and the division of
stratigraphic units is arranged
correctly supported by
relative elements, but the
discussion is not fully
synchronized with maps,
geological columns and
sections
Deskripsi litologi benar dan
pembagian unit stratigrafi
disusun secara benar yang
didukung oleh unsur relative,
tetapi pembahasan tidak
sepenuhnya singkron dengan
peta, kolom dan penampang
geologi
The description of lithology
is correct, the division of
stratigraphic units is not
arranged correctly, not
supported by relative
elements, the discussion is
not synchronized with maps,
geological columns and
sections
Deskripsi litologi benar,
pembagian unit stratigrafi
tidak disusun secara benar,
tidak didukung oleh unsur
relatif, pembahasan tidak
singkron dengan peta,
kolom dan penampang
geologi
The lithologic description is
incorrect, the stratigraphic
unit division is not correctly
arranged, not supported by
relative elements, the
discussion is not
synchronized with maps,
geological columns and
sections
Deskripsi litologi tidak
benar, pembagian unit
stratigrafi tidak disusun
secara benar, tidak
didukung oleh unsur relatif,
pembahasan tidak singkron
dengan peta, kolom dan
penampang geologi
Structural Geology
Struktur Geologi
Identification and
interpretation of correct
geological structures
supported by geological
structures data from field
observations
Identifikasi dan interpretasi
struktur geologi benar yang
didukung oleh data struktur
geologi hasil pengamatan
lapangan
Identification and
interpretation of geological
structures are correct, but
geological structure data is
minimum
Identifikasi dan interpretasi
struktur geologi telah benar,
tetapi data struktur geologi
sangat minim
The identification and
interpretation of geological
structures are correct, but
the geological structure data
are not interrelated
Identifikasi dan interpretasi
struktur geologi telah benar,
tetapi data struktur geologi
tidak saling terkait
The identification and
interpretation of geological
structures is not supported
by geological structure data
Identifikasi dan interpretasi
struktur geologi tidak
didukung oleh data struktur
geologi
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Geological History
Sejarah Geologi
The geological history is
arranged in order of time,
place and origin of material
and well synchronized with
stratigraphy and geological
structure
Sejarah geologi disusun
berdasarkan urutan waktu,
tempat dan asal material
dan sangat singkron dengan
stratigrafi dan struktur
geologi)
The Geological history is
arranged in the order of time,
place and origin of materials,
some of which have been
synchronized with the
stratigraphy and structure of
geology
Sejarah geologi disusun
berdasarkan urutan waktu,
tempat dan asal material,
sebagian telah singkron
dengan stratigrafi dan
struktur geeologi
The Geological history is
arranged in terms of time,
place and origin of material,
but not synchronized with
stratigraphic data and
geological structures
Sejarah geologi disusun
berdasarkan urutan waktu,
tempat dan asal material,
namun tidak singkron
dengan data stratigrafi dan
struktur geologi
The Geological history is
made not on the order of
time, place and origin of
material
Sejarah geologi dibuat tidak
berdasarkan urutan waktu,
tempat dan asal material
Mineral Resources
Bahan Galian
Identification of minerals in
accordance with the
geological setting of the
research area
Identifikasi bahan galian
sesuai dengan setting
geologi wilayah penelitian
Identification of minerals is
sufficiently in accordance
with the geological setting of
the research area
Identifikasi bahan galian
cukup sesuai dengan setting
geologi wilayah penelitian
Identification of minerals is
hardly in accordance with
the geological setting of the
research area
Identifikasi bahan galian
sesuai dengan setting
geology wilayah penelitian
Identification of minerals
does not match with the
geological setting of the
research area
Identifikasi bahan galian
tidak sesuai dengan setting
geology wilayah penelitian
`
Geological Map
(35% ) (Peta Geologi)
General Information :
Title, name, date, north
arrow, scale, lithologic
key, explanation of
geologic symbols
Informasi Umum :
Judul, nama, tanggal,
tanda panah utara,
skala, kunci litologis,
penjelasan simbol
geologi
All elements present and
correctly portrayed
Semua elemen hadir dan
digambarkan dengan benar
Most elements present and
correctly portrayed
Sebagian besar elemen hadir
dan digambarkan dengan
benar
Some elements present and
correctly portrayed
Beberapa elemen hadir dan
digambarkan dengan benar
Minimal information
Informasi minimal
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Primary Geologic
Information :
Contact and unit
identifications
Batas satuan batuan
Structural Geology
Struktur Geologi
Strikes & Dips
Correct units and correct
symbology and contacts
within acceptable distance
of correct location
Unit lithologi dan
Simbologi benar dan jarak
kontak dapat diterima serta
plot lokasi yang benar
Proper structural symbols
in proper location
Simbol struktural dan
lokasi yang tepat
Adequate number of strikes
and dips to define map
pattern and structure(s) and
symbols plotted correctly
Jumlah strike dan dip yang
memadai untuk menentukan
peta pola dan struktur dan
Simbol diplot dengan benar
Correct units and either
correct symbology with
Contacts slightly outside
acceptible limits or incorrect
symbology with contacts
within acceptable limits.
Unit litologi benar dan
beberapa simbologi belum
tepat, kontak litologi masih
ada yang melenceng atau
simbologi yang salah dengan
kontak dalam batas yang
dapat diterima.
Structural symbols present in
proper location with minor
symbol problem
Simbol struktur masih ada
yang salah
Inadequate number of strikes
and dips or symbols
inappropriately plotted
Jumlah strike dan dip
memadai, tetapi masih
banyak yang salah plot
Correct units identified but
little else going for it
Unit litologi sebagian telah
benar, yang lain masih
perlu diperbaiki
Structural symbols present
but major problems with
symbols or locations
Simbol struktur tepat, tapi
posisi lokasi tidak tepat
Inadequate number of
strikes and dips and symbols
inappropriately plotted
Jumlah strike dan dip
cukup, tetapi masih banyak
yang salah plot
Incorrect map units
identified
Unit litologi umumnya salah
Lack of agreement between
structural symbols and
mapped geology
Menunjukkan ketidak sesuai
peta geologi dengan symbol
struktur geologi
No strike and dip
information
Provided
Tidak memiliki strike dan
dip
Geologic Cross-
Section :
Scales, vertical
exaggeration,
topographic profile
Everything is complete
Semuanya sudah lengkap
Scales and vertical
exaggeration correct but
topographic profile askew
Skala vertikal benar tapi
Profil topografi tidak benar
One of scales incorrect
Salah satu sisi penampang
salah
Nothing is correct
Tidak ada yang benar
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Highly Competent Competent
Minimally
Competent Not Competent
100-86 85-70 69-46 45-0
Skala penampang
geologi
Geologic interpretation
Interpretasi Kondisi
Geologi
Interpretation sound and
unit thicknesses appropriate,
strong critical thinking skills
Exhibited
Interpretasi sudah benar
dan ketebalan unit yang
tepat, kemampuan berpikir
kritis yang kuat
Interpretation plausible but
suspect and unit thicknesses
Appropriate
Interpretasi masuk akal tapi
ketebalan unit litologi perlu
penyempurnaan
Interpretation plausible but
suspect and problems with
unit thicknesses or unit
thicknesses appropriate but
interpretation not feasible
Interpretasi masuk akal tapi
masih perlu perbaikan,
termasuk ketelan unit
stratigrafi
Interpretation not feasible
and inappropriate unit
Thicknesses, weak critical
thinking skills exhibited.
Interpretasi unit tidak layak
dan tidak sesuai aturan,,
tebal, kemampuan berpikir
kritis lemah
Answering
Question
(15% ) (Kemampuan
Menjawab
Pertanyaan)
Able to answer questions
smoothly and thoroughly
Dapat menjawab
pertanyaan dengan lancar
dan tuntas
Able to answer questions
fluently, but does not answer
all questions
Dapat menjawab pertanyaan
dengan lancar, tetapi tidak
sepenunhnya menjawab
pertanyaan
Able to answer some of the
questions of the audience
and the answer is not
immediately relevant to the
substance
Dapat menjawab sebagian
dari pertanyaan audience
dan jawaban tidak
sepenunhnya relevan
dengan subtansi
pertannyaan
Answers and explanations
are not relevant to mapping
results, in terms of reports or
geological maps.
Jawaban dan penjelasan
tidak relevan dengan hasil
pemetaan, baik dari segi
laporan maupun peta
geologi
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Final Report Rubric (Rubrik Tugas Akhir)
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
Presentation
(25% )
(Presentasi)
Presentation of Talk
(Analisis Presentase)
Clear introduction and
stated importance of the
topic
Pendahuluan cukup
jelas dan dan
menjelaskan pentingnya
topik yang dibahas
Organized talk with
logical progression of
ideas
Presentase dikelola
dengan perkembangan
logis dari gagasan
Sufficient evidence to
support assertions
(Bukti yang cukup untuk
mendukung pernyataan
Thorough knowledge of
the topic displayed
Pengetahuan
menyeluruh tentang
topik yang
ditampilkan
Appropriate summary
of findings and stated
conclusions
Ringkasan temuan
dan kesimpulan yang
sesuai
- The talk was well
structured supported
by enough data
evidence, the
conclusion was online
with the research
objectives and
supported by adequate
knowledge Presentase
dilakukan secara
berstruktur yang
didukung oleh
evidence data cukup,
kesimpulan telah
sesuai tujuan
penelitian serta
didukung oleh
pengetahuan yang
cukup sempurna
- The presentation
structure was managed
well Struktur presentase
cukup baik
- Organized with good
material Perorganisasi
materi cukup baik
- Supporting evidence
still needs to be added to
support the research
Bukti-bukti pendukung
masih perlu ditambah
untuk mendukung
penelitian
- Adequate understanding
of the topic presented
Pemahaman cukup
tentang topik yang
disajikan
- The conclusion is quite
good according to the
structure of the
presentation Kesimpulan
cukup baik sesuai
struktur presentase
- The presentation
structure still needs to
be improved Struktur
presentase masih perlu
diperbaiki
- The material
organization still needs
to be improved
Perorganisasi materi
masih perlu diperbaiki
- Supporting evidence
still needs to be added
to support the research
Bukti-bukti pendukung
masih perlu ditambah
untuk mendukung
penelitian
- Adequate understanding
of the topic presented
Pemahaman cukup
tentang topik yang
disajikan
- Conclusions still need to
be sharpened to suit the
context and presentation
structure Kesimpulan
masih perlu dipertajam
sesuai konteks dan
struktur presentase
- Unstructured
presentation
Presentase tidak
berstruktur
- Organizing unstructured
material
Perorganisasi materi
tidak terstruktur
- Not enough evidence to
support the research
Tidak cukup bukti-bukti
yang mendukung
penelitian
- Understanding the about
the topic presented is
not adequate
Pemahaman penulis
kurang tentang topik
yang disajikan
- The deficiency of the
above points resulted
irrelevant conclusions
Kekurangan hal
tersebut diatas
berdaampak pada
kesimpulan yang tidak
relevan
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
Visual aids
(Alat peraga)
Figures are
professional and neat
Gambar terlihat
profesional dan rapi
Figures and text are
helpful in illuminating
aspects of presentation
Gambar dan teks
sangat membantu
dalam menjelaskan
aspek presentasi
Appropriate labeling
and indication of scale
Pelabelan dan petunjuk
skala yang sesuai
- Figures and tables
presented strongly
support the research,
numbering arranged
nicely and well
supporting the contents
of the report writing.
The map scale is
accurate describing the
actual condition
Gambar dan table
disajikan sangat
mendukung penelitian,
penomoran tersusun
secara apik dan sangat
mendukungan isi
laporan penulisan.
skala peta sudah tepat
menggambarkan
kondisi sebenarnya
- Figures, maps and tables
are sufficient,
numbering is well
ordered and relevant to
the needs of research
and report content, the
scale of the map is
appropriate to describe
the actual conditions
Gambar, peta dan table
cukup, penomoran
sudah tertata dengan
baik dan relevan dengan
kebutuhan penelitian
dan isi laporan, skala
peta sudah tepat
menggambarkan kondisi
sebenarnya
- Figures, maps and
tables are enough, but
the arrangement of
code and numbers are
still a lot of mistakes,
as well as map scale
Gambar, peta dan
table cukup, tetapi
penataan kode dan
nomor masih banyak
kekeliruan, begitupula
skala peta
- Lack of display of
figures as supporting
evidence of research
Kurang menampilkan
gambar sebagai bukti
pendukung penelitian
-
Speaker
(Pembicara)
- Clear with audible vocal
projection
Jelas dengan proyeksi
vokal yang terdengar
- Articulate with minimal
verbal clutter
Mengartikulasikan
dengan sedikit
gangguan verbal
- The Talk was with a
loud voice
Penyampaian dengan
suara lantang
- Grammar follows
language rules and
appropriate foreign
terms
Tata Bahasa mengikuti
kaidah Bahasa
- The Talk was loud
enough Penyampaian
dengan suara cukup
lantang
- Grammar simply follow
the rules of Indonesian
and appropriate foreign
terms
Tata Bahasa cukup
mengikuti kaidah
- The Talk was loud
enough Penyampaian
dengan suara cukup
lantang
- Grammar is less to
follow the rules of
Indonesian and
appropriate foreign
terms
- The Talk was with small
voice and doubtful
Penyampaian dengan
suara kecil dan ragu
- Grammar does not
follow Indonesian rules
and appropriate foreign
terms Tata Bahasa tidak
mengikuti kaidah
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
- Developed a rapport
with audience
Mengembangkan
hubungan baik dengan
audience
- Delivered talk at an
appropriate rate
Pembicaraan
disampaikan pada ritme
yang sesuai
- Welcomed and
thoughtfully addressed
audience questions
Menyambut dan
menjawab secara serius
pertanyaan audiens
Indonesia dan istilah
asing yang sesuai
- Delivery is very
focused and open to
Audience
Penyampaian sangat
focus dan terbuka ke
Audiens
Bahasa Indonesia dan
istilah asing yang sesuai
- Delivery enough focus
to Audience but still
lack confidence
Penyampaian cukup
focus ke Audiens tetapi
masih kurang percaya
diri
Tata Bahasa kurang
mengikuti kaidah
Bahasa Indonesia dan
istilah asing yang sesuai
- The Talk was less focus
to Audience
Penyampaian kurang
focus ke Audiens
Bahasa Indonesia dan
istilah asing yang sesuai
- Talk does not focus to
Audience Penyampaian
tidak focus ke Audiens
Report (50% )
(Presentasi)
Organization and Content
of Thesis/Repot
(Struktur dan Isi
Skripsi/Laporan)
- Title (clear, concise, and
informative)
Judul (jelas, singkat,
dan informatif)
- Abstract (effective
summary of the paper's
thesis, evidence and
conclusions)
Abstrak (ringkasan
efektif dari tesis, bukti
dan kesimpulan
makalah)
- Introduction (provides
context and purpose for
the paper)
- Title is clear and
informative enough
Judul jelas dan cukup
informatif
- Abstract consists of
title, method and
conclusion Abstrak
tersusun memuat judul,
metoda dan
kesimpulan
- Introduction, the
background is very
much aligned with the
research objectives
- Title is clear and
informative enough
Judul jelas dan cukup
informative
- Abstract consists of title,
method and conclusion
Abstrak tersusun
memuat judul, metoda
dan kesimpulan
- Introduction,
background in line with
research objectives
Pendahuluan, latar
belakang sejalan
- Title is clear and
informative enough
Judul jelas dan cukup
informative
- Abstract has not fully
described the title,
method and conclusion
- Abstrak belum
sepenuhnya
menggambarkan judul,
metoda dan kesimpulan
- Introduction,
background and
research objectives need
- Title is clear and
informative enough
Judul perlu
penyempurnaan
- Abstract has not fully
described the title,
method and conclusion
Abstrak tidak efektif
menggambarkan judul,
metoda dan kesimpulan
- Introduction,
background and
research objectives need
refinement
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
Pendahuluan
(menyediakan konteks
dan tujuan untuk
makalah)
- Thesis/Hypothesis
(clearly stated and
relevant to the topic)
Skripsi / Hipotesis
(dinyatakan dengan
jelas dan relevan
dengan topik)
- Application of scientific
method (demonstrates
use/understanding of
scientific method)
Penerapan metode
ilmiah (menunjukkan
penggunaan /
pemahaman metode
ilmiah)
- Content of paper
(writing displays a deep
understanding of topic)
Isi laporan (tulisan
menampilkan
pemahaman mendalam
tentang topik)
- Insights (supports
discussion with
evidence and student’s
own analysis)
- Wawasan (mendukung
diskusi dengan bukti
dan analisis dari
mahasiswa sendiri)
Pendahuluan, latar
belakang sangat
sejalan dengan tujuan
penelitian
- The hypothesis is
highly relevant to the
research topic
Hipotesis sangat
relevan dengan topik
penelitian
- The contents are
intertwined with
images and research
data
Isi saling terkait
dengan gambar dan
data penelitian
- The structure of the
presentation of
content, analysis and
discussion arranged
logically with the
purpose of research
Struktur penyajian isi,
analisis dan diskusi
tersusun secara logis
dengan tujuan
penelitian
- Recent literatures are
appropriate in the text
and bibliography
Pustaka terkini sesuai
didalam teks dan
daftar pustaka
dengan tujuan
penelitian
- Hypotheses are relevant
to the research topic
- Hipotesis relevan
dengan topik penelitian
- The contents still need
refinement so that they
are related to figures and
data
- Isi masih perlu
penyempurnaan
sehingga saling terkait
dengan gambar dan
data
- The structure of the
presentation of content,
analysis and discussion
arranged logically with
the purpose of research
- Struktur penyajian isi,
analisis dan diskusi
tersusun secara logis
dengan tujuan
penelitian
- Quotation in text and
bibliography is still
wrong does not support
research Pustaka dalam
teks dan daftar pustaka
masih ada yang keliru,
pustaka tidak
mendukung penelitian
- Quotation in text and
bibliography is still
refinement
Pendahuluan, latar
belakang dan tujuan
penelitian perlu
penyempurnaan
- Hypotheses are relevant
to the research topic
Hipotesis relevan
dengan topik penelitian
- Contents do not support
each other with images
and data
Isi tidak saling
mendukung dengan
gambar dan data
- The structure of the
presentation of content,
analysis and discussion
arranged logically with
the purpose of research
Struktur penyajian isi,
analisis dan diskusi
tersusun secara logis
dengan tujuan
penelitian
- Quotation in text and
bibliography is still
wrong does not support
research Pustaka dalam
teks dan daftar pustaka
masih ada yang keliru,
pustaka tidak
mendukung penelitian
Pendahuluan, latar
belakang dan tujuan
penelitian perlu
penyempurnaan
- Hypotheses are not
relevant to the research
topic Hipotesis tidak
relevan dengan topik
penelitian
- Contents do not support
each other with figures
and data
Isi tidak saling
mendukung dengan
gambar dan data
- The structure of the
presentation of content,
analysis and discussion
arranged logically with
the purpose of research
Struktur penyajian isi,
analisis dan diskusi
disusun tidak logis
dengan tujuan
penelitian
- Quotation in text and
bibliography is still
wrong does not support
research
Pustaka dalam teks dan
daftar pustaka banyak
yang keliru, pustaka
tidak mendukung
penelitian
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
- Citation of sources (all
borrowed ideas and
words adequately cited)
Kutipan sumber (semua
gagasan dan kata-kata
yang diambil cukup
dikutip)
wrong does not support
research
Question (25% )
(Presentasi)
- Ability to answer
questions from the
Audience Kemampuan
menjawab pertanyaan
Audiens
- Able to answer
questions fluently and
perfectly according to
the context of the
material being asked
Mampu menjawab
pertanyaan dengan
lancar dan sempurna
sesuai konteks materi
yang ditanyakan
- Able to answer
questions fluently and
perfectly according to
the context of the
material being asked
Mampu menjawab
pertanyaan sesuai
konteks materi yang
ditanyakan
- Able to answer
questions in the context
of the material being
asked Mampu menjawab
pertanyaan tetapi tidak
sesuai konteks materi
yang ditanyakan
- Unable to answer
questions fluently Tidak
mampu menjawab
pertanyaan dengan
lancer
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Laboratory Activity Work Rubric (Rubrik Aktifitas Laboratorium)
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
Laboratory
Activity (50% )
Kegiatan
Laboratorium
(50% )
Followed all lab
procedures safely
Mengikuti semua
prosedur lab dengan
aman
Discipline, adheres
to all safety rules
Disiplin mematuhi
semua aturan safety
Have followed safety
rules
Telah mengikuti aturan
safety
Less compliance with
safety rules Kurang
mematuhi aturan safety
Do not follow safety
rules
Tidak mengikuti
aturan safety
Correctly measured or
observed
Mengukur dan
mengamati dengan
benar
Able to make
measurements and
observations
perfectly
Mampu melakukan
pengukuran dan
observasi dengan
sempurna
Measurements and
observations are
appropriate
Pegukuran dan
observasi cukup tepat
Measurements and
observations still need
refinement
Pegukuran dan
observasi masih perlu
penyempurnaan
Measurements and
observations are not
appropriate Pegukuran
dan observasi tidak
tepat
Worked in cooperation
with others
Bekerjasama dengan
baik
Very flexible and can
work with other
participants
Sangat fleksibel dan
dapat bekerjasama
dengan peserta lain
Can cooperate with other
participants Dapat
bekerjasama dengan
peserta lain
Can cooperate only with
certain participants
Dapat bekerjasama
hanya dengan peserta
tertentu
Unable to cooperate
with other participants.
Tidak mampu
bekerjasama dengan
peserta lain.
Cleaned up work area
and equipment
Membersihkan
lingkungan kerja dan
peralatan
Very concerned with
cleanliness and
equipment
maintenance
Sangat peeduli
dengan kebersihan
rungan dan
perawatan alat
Able to maintain
cleanliness and
equipment
Mampu menjaga
kebersihan rungan dan
alat
Able to maintain
cleanliness but not
concerned with the
maintenance of the tool
Mampu menjaga
kebersihan rungan
namun tidak peduli
dengan perawatan alat
Unable to maintain
cleanliness including
equipment
maintenance Tidak
mampu menjaga
kebersihan termasuk
perawatan alat
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
Report submission on
time
Ketepatan
pengumpulan laporan
On time report
submission
Pengumpulan
laporan tepat waktu
On time report
submission
Pengumpulan laporan
tepat waktu
Late report submission
Pengumpulan laporan
terlambat
Did not submit the
report
Tidak mengumpulkan
laporan
Laboratory
Report (50% )
Laporan
Laboratorium
(50% )
Correctly recorded
data in a chart or table
Merekam data dalam
grafik dan tabel
dengan benar
Data, tables and
graphs are perfect
Data, table dan
grafik sangat
sempurna
Data, and tables are
sufficient, but the graph
still needs refinement
Data,dan table cukup,
tetapi grafik masih perlu
penyempurnaan
Data, tables, and graphs
need refinement
Data, table dan grafik
perlu penyempurnaan
Data, tables and graphs
are not exact
Data, table dan grafik
tidak tepat
Used complete
sentences with correct
capitalization, spelling,
and punctuation
Menggunakan kalimat
lengkap dengan
kapitalisasi, ejaan dan
tanda baca yang benar
The report follows a
very perfect grammar
and scientific writing
technique
Tata bahasa
mengikuti teknik
penulisan ilmiah
sangat sempurna
The report followed
grammar and the
technique of scientific
writing, the use of
sentences quite
precisely, still need to
improve the use of
capital letters Tata
bahasa telah mengikuti
teknik penulisan ilmiah,
penggunaan kalimat
cukup tepat, masih perlu
perbaikan penggunaan
huruf kapital
The report has followed
grammar and the
technique of scientific
writing, but still needs
improvement of
sentence and
improvement of
capitalization
Tata bahasa telah
mengikuti teknik
penulisan ilmiah, tetapi
masih perlu
penyempurnaan kalimat
dan perbaikan
penggunaan huruf
kapital
The report does not
follow grammar and
scientific writing
techniques
Tata bahasa tidak
mengikuti teknik
penulisan ilmiah
MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY AND HIGHER EDUCATION
HASANUDDIN UNIVERISTY, ENGINEERING FACULTY
GEOLOGICAL ENGINEERING STUDY PROGRAM Jl. Poros Malino KM. 6 Bontomarannu (92171) Gowa, South Sulawesi. Fax (0411) 586015 http://eng.unhas.ac.id; E-mail : [email protected] -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dimension Excellent Good Average Fair
100-86 85-70 69-45 45-0
Made appropriate
conclusions
Mengambil kesimpulan
yang benar
The conclusion is
very much in line
with the practicum
material
Kesimpulan sangat
sesuai dengan materi
praktikum
The conclusion is in
accordance with the
practicum material
Kesimpulan telah sesuai
dengan materi
praktikum
The conclusion is in
accordance with the
practicum material, but
still needs refinement
Kesimpulan telah sesuai
dengan materi
praktikum, namun masih
perlu penyempurnaan
The conclusion does
not match the practice
material
Kesimpulan tidak
sesuai dengan materi
praktikum
Applied critical
thinking skills
Menggunakan analisis
yang kritis
Think critically and
have perfect
understanding
Berfikir kritis dan
mempunyai
pemahaman yang
sempurna
Thinking Critically, but
skills need to be
improved
Berfikir kritis, namun
skill perlu ditingkatkan
Need to think critically,
skills need to be
improved
Perlu berfikir kritis, skill
perlu ditingkatkan
Unable to think
critically
Tidak mampu berfikir
kritis