coordination activities by jiccg for uhv technology standardization hisatoshi ikeda co-chairman of...

Coordination Activities Coordination Activities by JICCG for UHV by JICCG for UHV

technology technology standardizationstandardization

Hisatoshi IkedaHisatoshi IkedaCo-Chairman of IEC/JICCGCo-Chairman of IEC/JICCG

Toshiba Co.Toshiba Co. 　＆　＆Kyushu Institute oKyushu Institute o ｆｆ TechnologyTechnology

2nd International Symposium on Standards for UHV Transmission 29-30.01.2009, New Delhi

Contents of presentation1.Standardization of UHV2.Establishment of JICCG3.Objectives of JICCG4.Outputs of JICCG5.Future work


Urgent Needs for International Standards

Commercial operation Commercial operation of of 1100kV UHV AC1100kV UHV AC

1.Standardization of UHV


SB1 Recommended the urgent need in Feb. 2006

SMB Decision for UHV symposium was made in June 2006

The first UHV symposium was held in July 2007

SB1; Sector board 1 SMB; Standardization Management Board


Conclusion 0707/3 — Joint IEC-CIGRE coordination group to prepare UHV standardization

In consultation with CIGRE and IEC TCs, the SB 1 officers and members have prepared draft Terms of Reference for the joint IEC-CIGRE coordination group.

2.Establishment of JICCG

SB1 made the conclusion on ToR of JICCG in July 2007


SMB Decision 130/10 SMB Decision 130/10 Joint IEC-CIGRE Joint IEC-CIGRE group on UHV standardizationgroup on UHV standardization

The SMB approved in principle the proposed terms of The SMB approved in principle the proposed terms of reference of the joint IEC-CIGRE group on UHV reference of the joint IEC-CIGRE group on UHV given in given in document SMB/3544/DC. It further decided thatdocument SMB/3544/DC. It further decided that the the title be changed to: title be changed to: JJoint oint IIEC-EC-CCIGRE IGRE ccoordination oordination ggroup roup to to provide guidance provide guidance to IEC to IEC and CIGRE in the and CIGRE in the development of UHV standardization. development of UHV standardization. While limiting the size of the group, While limiting the size of the group, the number of IEC the number of IEC members be increased to 11 and invites NCs who have members be increased to 11 and invites NCs who have already submitted already submitted nominations to limit them to only nominations to limit them to only one and submit to Central Office by 2007-11-27.one and submit to Central Office by 2007-11-27.The SMB appointed Mr. Hisatoshi Ikeda as The SMB appointed Mr. Hisatoshi Ikeda as convenerconvener of of the joint IEC-CIGRE group.the joint IEC-CIGRE group.The SMB invited CIGRE to concur.The SMB invited CIGRE to concur.


•To To determine the domains in UHV technologydetermine the domains in UHV technology, both , both ACAC and and DCDC, where the state of the art permits , where the state of the art permits standardization to be undertaken; standardization to be undertaken; •To make recommendations for To make recommendations for what UHV standards what UHV standards the market requires and develop strategies for the market requires and develop strategies for international standardizationinternational standardization of UHV technologies, of UHV technologies, in response to rapid needs from the large in response to rapid needs from the large developing market for UHV;developing market for UHV;•To To prepare a road map of standardization of UHV prepare a road map of standardization of UHV technologiestechnologies, so as to produce the standards and , so as to produce the standards and revisions needed for UHV transmission by the end of revisions needed for UHV transmission by the end of 2010 (or, if this is impossible for certain topics, then 2010 (or, if this is impossible for certain topics, then as soon as possible thereafter) as soon as possible thereafter) with full cooperation with full cooperation between CIGRE and IECbetween CIGRE and IEC..

3. Objectives of JICCG2nd International Symposium on Standards for UHV Transmission 29-30.01.2009, New Delhi

1. UHV AC

The UHV Symposium

The Joint IEC-CIGRE Coordination Group

TC8TC28

HorizontalStandards

TC17, TC37, TC36, TC14, TC38, TC42, TC73, TC11, TC7,

TC20Product

Standards

TC95, TC57, TC99,

TC112, TC1, TC3, etc

Other RelatingStandards

- Recommendation- Recommendation - Recommendation- Recommendation

CIGREA2, A3, B2, B3, C4

-WG A3.22 ReportWG A3.22 Report-WG B3.22 ReportWG B3.22 Report

NowOngoing


2.UHV DC

The UHV Symposium

The Joint IEC-CIGRE Coordination Group

New TC TC 115

TC8, TC28, TC22, TC17, TC37, TC36, TC14, TC38, TC42, TC73,

TC11, TC7, TC20, etc.

- Recommendation- Recommendation

CIGREB4, etc

-WG B4.xx Report WG B4.xx Report (?)(?)


4. Outputs of JICCGThree meetings were held; 1st meeting at Zurich in November 2007 2nd meeting at New castle in April 2008 3rd meeting at Geneva in November 2008and 4th meeting is scheduled at New Delhi in Feb. 2009

Major outputs are; Road map for UHV AC standardization IEC TCs and CIGRÉ SCs competent sheetWith 18 conclusions

Valuable CIGRE reports from SCs


TC8

TC28

2007 2008 2009Horizontal Standards

1st Group of Product Standards

CDV

11/

4/

FDIS

9/

11/

ISResult

UHV standardizationUHV standardization

LinesTC7TC11Protection & ControlTC57TC95

IEC WORKTo pick out items which should be revisedTo prepare the draft NP for new technologies(if needed)Refer to the attacheditems list

Plenary

FDIS

10/

12/

IS

ROAD MAP of Standardization on UHV AC Technologies

Systems aspects for electrical energy supply (Standard Voltages)

Overhead lines Overhead electrical conductors

TC14

Power transformers

TC17SC17ASC17C

Switchgear and controlgear High-voltage switchgear and controlgear High-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies

Insulation co-ordination

TC36SC36ASC36BSC36C

Insulators Insulated bushings Insulators for overhead lines Insulators for substations

TC37

Surge arresters

TC38

Instrument transformers

TC42

High-voltage testing techniques

CDV

3/

8/

Result

NP Result

WD

9/

12/

6/

KICK OFF

NP Result

WD

9/

12/

6/

KICK OFF

NP Result

WD

9/

12/

6/

KICK OFF

NP Result

WD

9/

12/

6/

KICK OFF

NP Result

WD

9/

12/

6/

KICK OFF

NP Result

WD

9/

12/

6/

KICK OFF

IEC WORKTo pick out items which should be revisedTo prepare the draft NP for new technologies(if needed)

2nd Group of Product Standards

11

11

11

11

; Plenary Meeting


Sections IEC/TC CIGRE/SC New IEC TC/CIGRE SC Comments　

Section 1: General standards

Produce following standards:

1) Electromagnetic environment for high voltage direct current (HVDC) converter stations;

TC77 C4/B4 　　

2) Electromagnetic environment for high voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission lines.

TC77 C4/B4 　 Belongs to the scope of Cigre SC4

3) For UHVDC, following standards need to be revised:

4) Terminology for high voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission (IEC 60633-1998);

SC22F B4 New IEC TC Belongs to the scope of the relevant IEC TC involved

5) Insulation co-ordination – Part 5: procedures for high-voltage direct current (HVDC) converter stations (IEC/TS 60071-5-2002).

TC28 C4/B4 　 Belongs to the scope of the relevant IEC TC involved Inputs from CIGRE WG B4-45 should also be considered

Section 2: Design

Produce following standards:

1) Guide to the design of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission lines;

TC11 B4 　

In general, to collect the current knowledge is the task of Cigre WG bodies. Should be done by the relevant SC. Furthermore, do guides belong to standardization process? Some information available in SCB2-05 (JWG17)12

2) Guide to the design of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) converter stations;

SC22F B4 New IEC TC

Some information available in SCB2-05 (JWG17)09JWG A2/B4.28 is working on the “Guidelines for Conducting Design Review for HVDC Converter Transformers”.This document will be published in 2008.

3) Guide to the design of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) grounding electrodes.

SC22F B4 New IEC TC 　


5. Future work

SMB Decision 133/18 - Joint IEC/CIGRE groupThe SMB thanked and complimented the Joint IEC/CIGRE Group (JICCG) for its statusreport and results in the roadmap for guidance for UHV standardization and agreed that thegroup continue to operate for at least one more year to coordinate the technologies in thisarea.

JICCG continues at least one year based on the SMB Decision

2nd & 3rd step of UHV AC road map Special attention for 1200kVCoordination between TCs for UHV DC


SMB Decision 133/19 - IEC Strategic Group on UHVThe SMB agreed to set up a strategic group on UHV to address the IEC standardizationneeds and coordinate activities of IEC TCs.SMB members are asked to provide names of approximately 12 experts to participate in thisgroup by end December 2008.The Swedish NC will provide the name of the convener.

SG2 JICCG


coordinate the technologies

address the IEC standardization needs and coordinate activities of IEC TCs

coordination activities by jiccg for uhv technology standardization hisatoshi ikeda co-chairman of...

Documents