nadp scientific symposium agendanadp.slh.wisc.edu/lib/proceedings/nadppro2017.pdfbetween ambient and...
TRANSCRIPT
1
NADP Scientific Symposium Agenda
2
3
NADP Annual Meeting and Scientific Symposium
San Diego, California
October 30–November 3, 2017
Monday, October 30, 2017 Room Location
9:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. CLAD Shell
10:00 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. AMSC Del Mar
12:30 p.m. – 4:30 p.m. TDEP Del Mar
3:00 p.m. – 5:00 p.m. CLAD Shell
Tuesday, October 31, 2017
Open All Day Registration Desk Mezzanine
8:30 a.m. – 10:00 a.m. Joint Subcommittee Meeting Bay E
10:00 a.m. – 10:15 a.m. Break Foyer
10:15 a.m. – 12:00 p.m. Subcommittee Meetings
Network Operations Bay E
Ecological Response and Outreach Del Mar
Critical Loads Shell
12:00 p.m. – 1:30 p.m. Lunch on your own
1:30 p.m. – 2:30 p.m. Joint Subcommittee Meeting Bay E
2:30 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. Break Foyer
3:00 p.m. – 6:00 p.m. Executive Committee Meeting Del Mar
6:00 p.m. City Dep Ad-hoc Subcommittee Shell
4
Wednesday, November 1, 2017 Room Location
Open All Day Registration/Office Mission Foyer
8:00 a.m. – 8:30 a.m. Welcome, Program Office Report Mission A, B, C, D
Awards and Announcements
Tamara Blett: NADP Vice Chair, Symposium Chair
National Park Service
Donna Schwede: NADP Chair
U.S. EPA
8:30 a.m. – 9:15 a.m. Mapping the Future of NADP
NADP Executive Committee
9:15 a.m. – 10:00 a.m. Annual State of the NADP Report
David Gay: NADP Program Coordinator
10:00 a.m. – 10:30 a.m. Break Mission Foyer
Technical Session 1: Critical Loads: Acidification and Excess Nitrogen Thresholds
Session Chair: Mike Bell
National Park Service
10:30 a.m. – 10:50 a.m. Developing Critical Loads of Acidity for Stream
Ecosystems in the Adirondack Region of New York State Shuai Shao, Syracuse University
10:50 a.m. – 11:10 a.m. Critical Load of Sulphur and Nitrogen for Terrestrial
Ecosystems in Alberta, Canada: Sensitivity to Input Data Yayne-abeba Aklilu, Government of Alberta
11:10 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. Extreme nitrogen saturation of serpentine grasslands in Santa
Clara County, California: A nexus for conservation action Stuart Weiss, Creekside Center for Earth Observation
11:30 a.m. – 11:50 a.m. Individual tree species’ responses to concurrent nitrogen and
sulfur deposition across the contiguous United States Kevin Horn, Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation,
Virginia Tech
11:50 a.m. – 12:10 p.m. Critical loads of nitrogen deposition for trees and forest
ecosystems across the continental U.S.
Linda Pardo, USDA Forest Service
5
Wednesday, November 1, 2017 Room Location
Mission A, B, C, D
12:10 p.m. – 12:30 p.m. Recent Advances in Critical Loads Research
Christopher Clark, US EPA
12:30 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Lunch on your own
Technical Session 2: Air & Water Quality: Linkages and Synergies
Session Chairs: Mark Nilles and Helen Amos
USGS and US EPA
Moderator: Rich Pouyat, USDA Forest Service
2:00 p.m. – 2:20 p.m. Bridging the air-water quality information gap to improve
nutrient management Helen Amos, AAAS Fellow hosted by US EPA
2:20 p.m. – 2:40 p.m. CMAQ modeling in the nitrogen inventory study in the
Nooksack-Abbotsford-Sumas Transboundary Region Donna Schwede, US EPA
2:40 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. Episodic Acidification in the Adirondack Region of New York:
Spatial Patterns and Evidence of Recovery
Douglas Burns, U.S. Geological Survey
3:00 p.m. – 3:30 p.m. Break
Technical Session 3: Air & Water Quality: Linkages and Synergies (cont.) Session Chairs: Mark Nilles and Helen Amos
USGS and US EPA
Moderator: Rich Pouyat, USDA Forest Service
3:30 p.m. – 3:50 p.m. Changes in stream chemistry at high flow during 23 years of
decreasing acid deposition in the Catskill Mountains of New
York Michael McHale, U.S. Geological Survey
3:50 p.m. – 4:10 p.m. Evaluating Potential Water Quality Impairments on National
Forest Priority Watersheds Using Estimates of Atmospheric
Deposition
David Levinson, U.S. Forest Service
4:10 p.m. – 4:30 p.m. Integration of atmospheric deposition and water
quality monitoring in the El Yunque National Forest, Puerto
Rico
Anita K. Rose, USDA Forest Service
6
Wednesday, November 1, 2017 Room Location
4:30 p.m. – 5:30 p.m. Break
5:30 p.m. – 8:00 p.m. Poster Session and Reception William D. Evans
Thursday, November 2, 2017 Room Location
Open All Day Registration/Office Mission Foyer
Thursday, November 2, 2017 Room Location
Mission A, B, C, D
8:00 a.m. – 8:10 a.m. Opening Remarks, Announcements, and Overview of Day 2
Tamara Blett, NADP Vice Chair,
National Park Service
8:10 a.m. – 8:40 a.m. Keynote Address
Dr. Lynn Russell
Professor of Atmospheric Chemistry
Scripps Institution of Oceanography
Technical Session 4: Deposition Modeling and Monitoring
Session Chair: Anne Rea and Eric Prestbo
USDA Forest Service and Tekran
8:40 a.m. – 9:00 a.m. Evaluation of wet atmospheric deposition along the coast of
the Gulf of Mexico:- An international collaboration
opportunity
Rodolfo Sosa, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico
9:00 a.m. – 9:20 a.m. Methylmercury and total mercury in marine stratus cloud and
fog water: Sources, sinks, and lifetimes Peter Weiss-Penzias, University of California, Santa Cruz,
9:20 a.m. – 9:40 a.m. Trends in NADP bromide wet deposition concentrations,
2001-2016
Gregory Wetherbee, U.S. Geological Survey
9:40 a.m. – 10:00 a.m. Total deposition by measurement-model fusion using ADAGIO
Amanda Cole, Environment and Climate Change Canada
10:00 a.m. – 10:30 a.m. Break
7
Thursday, November 2, 2017 Room Location
Mission A, B, C, D
Technical Session 5: Urban Air Quality and Deposition
Session Chair: Steven Decina
Boston University
10:30 a.m. – 10:50 a.m. Quantifying urban nitrogen emission and deposition through
optical sensing techniques Kang Sun, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics
10:50 a.m. – 11:10 a.m. Using Moss to Detect Fine-Scaled Deposition of Heavy Metals
in Urban Environments
Sarah Jovan, U.S. Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research
Station
11:10 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. Elemental carbon deposition to urban tree canopies:
Magnitudes and spatial patterns
Alexandra G. Ponette-González, Department of Geography and
The Environment, University of North Texas
11:30 a.m. – 11:50 a.m. Characteristics and Ecological Impacts of Atmospheric
Deposition in Urban and Urban-Affected Regions
Mark Fenn, USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station
11:50 a.m. – 12:10 p.m. Assessing Sources and Fluxes of Reactive Nitrogen Deposition
to Urban Landscapes Using Ion Exchange Resins
Rebecca Forgrave, University of Pittsburgh
12:10 p.m. – 12:30 p.m. Increasing ethanol consumption as a renewable fuel: How will
vehicle ethanol emissions impact the urban atmosphere? J. David Felix, Texas A&M University - Corpus Christi
12:30 p.m. – 2:00 p.m. Lunch on your own
Technical Session 6: Nitrogen: Transport Deposition and Effects
Session Chair: Justin Valliere
University of California Los Angeles
2:00 p.m. – 2:20 p.m. Ecosystem flip-flops in response to anthropogenic N
deposition: The importance of long-term experiments
George Vourlitis, California State University
8
Thursday, November 2, 2017 Room Location
Mission A, B, C, D
2:20 p.m. – 2:40 p.m. Organic nitrogen in aerosols at a forest site in southern
Appalachia John Walker, US EPA
2:40 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. Quantifying nitrogen deposition inputs and impacts on plant
richness in a Mediterranean-type shrubland
Justin Valliere, University of California Los Angeles
3:00 p.m. – 3:30 p.m. Break
Technical Session 7: Nitrogen: Transport Deposition and Effects (cont.)
Session Chair: Justin Valliere
University of California Los Angeles
3:30 p.m. – 3:50 p.m. Atmospheric deposition evaluation as a tool to preserve urban
natural green areas: Mexico City case
María Alejandra Fonseca
3:50 p.m. – 4:10 p.m. Spatial and temporal relationships of key nitrogen species
between ambient and deposition regimes
Richard Scheffe, US EPA
4:10 p.m. – 4:30 p.m. Nutrient deposition in the headwaters of streams may impact
nitrogen loading in Southern Californian estuaries Pamela Padgett, USDA Forest Service
4:30 p.m. – 4:50 p.m. Contributions of organic nitrogen to the gas phase and
speciation of amines in ambient samples Katherine Benedict, Colorado State University
Friday, November 3, 2017 Room Location
Open A.M. Session Registration/Office Mission Foyer
9
Friday, November 3, 2017 Room Location
Mission A, B, C, D
8:00 a.m. – 8:10 a.m. Opening Remarks, Announcements, and Overview of Day 3
Tamara Blett, NADP Vice Chair
National Park Service
Technical Session 8: Ammonia Emissions, Trends, Deposition
Session Chair: Katie Benedict
Colorado State University
8:10 a.m. – 8:30 a.m. Investigation of hourly concentration ratios of ammonia gas
and particulate ammonium at CASTNet site in Beltsville, MD
Greg Beachley, US EPA
8:30 a.m. – 8:50 a.m. Urban and On-Road Emissions: Underappreciated Sources of
Atmospheric Ammonia
Mark Fenn, USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station
8:50 a.m. – 9:10 a.m. “Fingerprinting” Vehicle-Derived Ammonia Utilizing
Nitrogen Stable Isotopes Wendell Walters, Brown University
9:10 a.m. Adjourn
8:30 a.m. – 6:00 p.m. Optional Field Trips – Marine ecosystem field trip by kayak to
LaJolla Sea Caves (morning trip 8:30 departure from hotel and
afternoon trip 12:30 p.m. departure from hotel)
10
11
2017 NADP SITE OPERATOR AWARDS
12
13
Sit
e C
od
e
Op
era
tor
Nam
eS
ite
Nam
eFu
nd
ing
Ag
en
cy
We
t S
tart
CA
75 -
MD
NErik
Meyer
Sequoia
Natio
nal P
ark
- G
iant Fore
st
Natio
nal P
ark
Serv
ice -
AR
D07/2
2/0
3
CA
75 -
NTN
Erik
Meyer
Sequoia
Natio
nal P
ark
- G
iant Fore
st
Natio
nal P
ark
Serv
ice -
AR
D07/0
8/8
0
CA
83 -
AM
oN
Erik
Meyer
Sequoia
Natio
nal F
ore
st -
Ash
Mounta
inN
atio
nal P
ark
Serv
ice -
AR
D03/2
2/1
1
CA
96 -
NTN
Eliz
abeth
Hale
Lassen V
olc
anic
Natio
nal P
ark
-
Manzanita
Lake
Natio
nal P
ark
Serv
ice -
AR
D06/1
3/0
0
IN20 -
NTN
Kare
y D
avis
Roush L
ake
U.S
. G
eolo
gic
al S
urv
ey
08/2
2/8
3
KY
99 -
NTN
Cla
rk H
endrix
Mulb
err
y F
lat
Murr
ay S
tate
Univ
ers
ity12/2
7/9
4
MD
08 -
AM
oN
Mark
Castr
oPin
ey R
eserv
ior
Mary
land D
epart
ment of
Natu
ral
Resourc
es
08/0
3/1
0
MN
23 -
MD
NM
eg N
ygre
nC
am
p R
iple
yM
innesota
Pollu
tion C
ontr
ol A
gency
07/0
2/9
6
MN
23 -
NTN
Meg N
ygre
nC
am
p R
iple
yU
.S. G
eolo
gic
al S
urv
ey
10/1
8/8
3
MT98 -
NTN
Julia
Dafo
e
Havre
- N
ort
hern
Agricultu
ral
Researc
h C
ente
rU
.S. G
eolo
gic
al S
urv
ey
07/3
0/8
5
NC
30 -
AM
oN
Scott M
oore
Duke
Fore
st
U.S
. EPA
-
Cle
an A
ir M
ark
ets
06/2
4/0
8
NH
02 -
AM
oN
Bre
nda M
inic
ucci
Hubbard
Bro
ok
U.S
. EPA
-
Cle
an A
ir M
ark
ets
06/0
5/1
2
NH
02 -
NTN
Am
ey B
aile
yH
ubbard
Bro
ok
U.S
. Fore
st S
erv
ice
07/2
5/7
8
NS
01 -
AM
Net
Robert
Keenan
Kejim
kujik
Natio
nal P
ark
Environm
ent C
anada
01/2
6/0
9
NY
20 -
AM
oN
Charlotte D
em
ers
Huntin
gto
n W
ildlif
eU
.S. EPA
-
Cle
an A
ir M
ark
ets
06/0
5/1
2
5 Y
EA
R A
WA
RD
S
14
Sit
e C
od
e
Op
era
tor
Nam
eS
ite
Nam
eFu
nd
ing
Ag
en
cyW
et
Sta
rt
NY
52 -
NTN
Ste
ven
Sku
bis
Ben
nett
Brid
geU
.S. E
PA -
Cle
an A
ir M
arke
ts06
/10/
80
NY
98 -
NTN
Paul
Cas
son
Whi
tefa
ce M
ount
ain
U.S
. Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y07
/03/
84
PA21
- N
TNK
evin
Hor
ner
God
dard
Sta
te P
ark
Penn
sylv
ania
DEP
/Pen
n S
tate
Uni
vers
ity07
/26/
11
PA98
- N
TNK
evin
Hor
ner
Fran
ces
Slo
cum
Sta
te P
ark
Penn
sylv
ania
DEP
/Pen
n S
tate
Uni
vers
ity07
/26/
11
SC
03 -
MD
NR
icha
rd W
alke
rS
avan
nah
Riv
erS
avan
nah
Riv
er N
ucle
ar S
olut
ions
01/2
9/01
SK
21 -
NTN
Glo
ria S
tang
Hud
son
Bay
Sas
katc
hew
an M
inis
try
of E
nviro
nmen
t04
/30/
12
UT0
1 -
AM
oNR
andy
Mar
tinLo
gan
Uta
h D
epar
tmen
t of
Envi
ronm
enta
l
Qua
lity
11/0
8/11
UT0
1 -
NTN
Ran
dy M
artin
Loga
nU
.S. G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
12/0
6/83
WV
18 -
AM
oNC
hris
Cas
sidy
Pars
ons
U.S
. EPA
- C
lean
Air
Mar
kets
06/0
7/11
WV
18 -
NTN
Chr
is C
assi
dyPa
rson
sU
.S. F
ores
t Ser
vice
07/0
5/78
WY
95 -
AM
oNJo
hn K
orfm
ache
rB
rook
lyn
Lake
U.S
. EPA
- C
lean
Air
Mar
kets
06/1
9/12
WY
99 -
NTN
Eric
Sch
nell
New
cast
leU
.S. B
urea
u of
Lan
d M
anag
emen
t08
/11/
81
5 Y
EAR
AW
ARD
S
15
16
Sit
e C
od
e
Op
era
tor
Nam
eS
ite
Nam
eFu
nd
ing
Ag
en
cyW
et
Sta
rt
KY
10 -
MD
NJo
hnat
han
Jern
igan
Mam
mot
h C
ave
Nat
iona
l Par
k -
Hou
chin
Mea
dow
Nat
iona
l Par
k S
ervi
ce -
AR
D08
/27/
2002
KY
10 -
NTN
John
atha
n Je
rnig
an
Mam
mot
h C
ave
Nat
iona
l Par
k -
Hou
chin
Mea
dow
Nat
iona
l Par
k S
ervi
ce -
AR
D08
/27/
2002
ME0
8 -
NTN
Kur
t Joh
nson
Gile
adU
.S. G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
09/2
8/19
99
MT9
7 -
NTN
Tany
a N
iedh
ardt
Lost
Tra
il Pa
ssU
SD
A F
ores
t Ser
vice
09/2
5/19
90
NY
01 -
NTN
Wes
Ben
tzA
lfred
U.S
. Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y08
/17/
2004
PA00
- M
DN
Sha
ron
Sca
mac
kA
rend
tsvi
llePe
nnsy
lvan
ia D
EP/P
enn
Sta
te U
nive
rsity
11/1
4/20
00
SD
04 -
NTN
Mar
c O
hms
Win
d C
ave
Nat
iona
l Par
k -
Elk
Mou
ntai
nN
atio
nal P
ark
Ser
vice
- A
RD
11/0
5/20
02
VA
99 -
NTN
Ken
Hic
kman
Nat
ural
Brid
ge S
tatio
nU
SD
A F
ores
t Ser
vice
07/0
2/20
02
WI3
6 -
NTN
Ther
ese
Hub
ache
rTr
out L
ake
Wis
cons
in D
epar
tmen
t of
Nat
ural
Res
ourc
es01
/22/
1980
WI3
6 -
MD
NTh
eres
e H
ubac
her
Trou
t Lak
e
Wis
cons
in D
epar
tmen
t of
Nat
ural
Res
ourc
es03
/05/
1996
15 Y
EA
R A
WA
RD
S
17
18
19
KEYNOTE SPEAKER DR. LYNN RUSSELL, PROFESSOR OF CLIMATE, ATMOSPHERIC SCIENCE AND PHYSICAL OCEANOGRAPHY – SCRIPPS INSTITUTE OF OCEANOGRAPHY, UC SAN DIEGO
20
Biography
Professor of Atmospheric Chemistry
Lynn M. Russell is Professor of Atmospheric Chemistry at Scripps
Institution of Oceanography on the faculty of University of California at San
Diego, where she has led the Climate Sciences Curricular Group since
2009. Her research is in the area of aerosol particle chemistry, including the
behavior of particles from both biogenic and combustion processes. Her
research group pursues both modeling and measurement studies of
atmospheric aerosols, using the combination of these approaches to
advance our understanding of fundamental processes that affect
atmospheric aerosols. She completed her undergraduate work at Stanford
University, and she received her Ph.D. in Chemical Engineering from the
California Institute of Technology for her studies of marine aerosols. Her
postdoctoral work as part of the National Center for Atmospheric Research
Advanced Studies Program investigated aerosol and trace gas flux and
entrainment in the marine boundary layer. She served on the faculty of
Princeton University in the Department of Chemical Engineering before
accepting her current position at Scripps in 2003. She has been honored
with young investigator awards from ONR, NASA, Dreyfus Foundation,
NSF, and the James S. McDonnell Foundation, and she received the
Kenneth T. Whitby Award from AAAR (2003) for her contributions on
atmospheric aerosol processes and the Princeton Rheinstein Award for
excellence in teaching and scholarship (1998).
21
TECHNICAL SESSION 1:
CRITICAL LOADS: ACIDIFICATION AND
EXCESS NITROGEN THRESHOLDS
Session Chair: Mike Bell,
National Park Service
22
23
Developing Critical Loads of Acidity for Stream Ecosystems in the
Adirondack Region of New York State
Shuai Shao1, Charles T. Driscoll
2, Douglas A. Burns
3, Gregory B. Lawrence
4 and
Timothy J. Sullivan5
The Adirondack region of New York has high inputs of acidic deposition and many acidic
streams. The PnET-BGC is an integrated biogeochemical model formulated to simulate the
response of soil and surface waters in northern forest ecosystems to changes in atmospheric
deposition. In this is study, the model was applied to twenty-one streams in the Adirondacks to
simulate the effects of past and future (1000-2200) changes in atmospheric sulfur (S) and
nitrogen (N) deposition on stream water chemistry. The model was calibrated using observed
stream water and soil chemistry data. The results indicated model simulated stream water
chemistry generally agreed with the measured data at all sites. Model hindcasts indicated that
stream water in the Adirondack are inherently sensitive to acidic deposition. The average of
model simulated stream ANC is 175 μeq/L (range 48 to 335 μeq/L) before anthropogenic
disturbances are applied to the model (1850) and it decreased in response to historical acidic
deposition to 59 μeq/L (−37 to 242 μeq/L) in 2015. The model was run under a range of future
scenarios from 2016 to 2200 of changes in sulfate, nitrate, and combination of sulfate and nitrate
deposition to evaluate how the stream water chemistry might respond to emission control
strategies. Future model projections suggested that decreases in sulfate deposition is more
effective in increases in stream ANC compared with equivalent decreases in nitrate deposition;
nevertheless, the simultaneous controls on nitrate and sulfate deposition are more effective way
to restore stream ANC than individual control of nitrate or sulfate deposition. However, only ten
of the twenty-one sites will restore the stream ANC to the preindustrial level under the most
aggressive deposition reduction scenarios. The model results were used to determine the critical
loads of acidity (CLs, the level of atmospheric deposition above which the harmful ecosystem effects occur) for all twenty-one sites.
1Syracuse University, [email protected] 2Syracuse University, [email protected] 3U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 4U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 5E&S Environmental Chemistry, [email protected]
24
Critical Load of Sulphur and Nitrogen for Terrestrial Ecosystems in
Alberta, Canada: Sensitivity to Input Data
Yayne-abeba Aklilu1, Laura Blair
2, Gordon Dinwoodie
3, Julian
Aherne4, Naomi Tam
5 and Sunny Cho
6
The steady state mass balance model (SSMB) was used to calculate the critical loads of acidity:
the maximum critical loads for sulphur (CLmax(S)) and nitrogen (CLmax(N)) deposition and the
minimum critical load for nitrogen deposition (CLmin(N)). These critical loads were calculated for
terrestrial ecosystems in the province of Alberta. While SSMB is relatively simple to use, the
challenge in using this model lies in estimating the required input especially for large study area
such as a province (661,848 km2). Base cation weathering and appropriate application of
chemical criteria are two such critical inputs. For this work, the soil texture approximation
method and soils information from a national soil database was used to determine base cation
weathering. The chemical criteria, base cation to aluminum ratio, used to determine acid
neutralizing capacity leaching was applied by land use. Higher CLmax(S) and CLmax(N) (> 600 eq
ha-1yr-1) resulted for areas of the province with deeper soil and higher clay content providing the
conditions which can result in higher base cation weathering. CLmax(S) and CLmax(N) less than
200 eq ha-1yr-1 were determined for areas with sandy acidic soils as well as soils with higher
organic content. The distribution of CLmin(N) reflects biomass nitrogen content and removal of
harvested biomass. For the most part CLmin(N)was less than 100 eq ha-1yr-1 with some areas
having a CLmin(N) less than 50 eq ha -1yr-1. Areas with CLmin(N) greater than 50 eq ha-1yr-
1 contain managed forests which have notable nitrogen removal rates from biomass harvest and
removal. Exceedance of critical loads can indicate areas of potential ecosystem impact and areas
that need focused deposition monitoring. Exceedances and sensitivity of these exceedances are
explored using modelled sulphur and nitrogen deposition and calculated critical loads of acidity.
The findings are used to better inform the precipitation monitoring network for the province.
1Government of Alberta, [email protected] 2Government of Alberta, [email protected] 3Government of Alberta, [email protected] 4University of Trent, [email protected] 5Government of Alberta, [email protected] 6Government of Alberta, [email protected]
25
Extreme Nitrogen Saturation of Serpentine Grasslands in Santa Clara County,
California: A Nexus for Conservation Action
Stuart Weiss1 and Meredith Hastings
2
Serpentine grasslands are nutrient-poor, low biomass ecosystems that harbor high native
biodiversity including many listed species such as the Bay checkerspot butterfly. Research since
the 1990s has documented the threat of atmospheric nitrogen deposition from upwind Silicon
Valley that allows non-native annual grasses to overrun the dazzling displays of low-statured
wildflowers, and that the grass invasions are controlled by managed cattle grazing. The
estimated critical load for serpentine grasslands is 6 kg-N ha-1 year-1. Since 2015, in the high
deposition zone (10-20 kg-N ha-1 year-1 ), spring water nitrate up to 25 ppm (as NO3-) were
measured in baseflow, levels higher than any reported for non-agricultural sites in California.
Nitrate levels in samples from low deposition areas were 1-5 ppm. Isotopic analyses including
Δ17O show that 50-60% of the nitrate in spring and well water is unprocessed atmospheric
nitrate. Passive samplers, CMAQ models, N-cycling measurements, and emissions
inventories/projections are used to interpret the findings. High levels of nitric acid in summer
and low ecosystem capacity for N-retention in the fall growing season allow for flushing of
accumulated dry NO3 deposition into the fractured bedrock, and eventually into the springs.
Increased N-deposition from highway improvements and development was a major regulatory
nexus for the Santa Clara Valley Habitat Plan, a Habitat Conservation Plan/Natural Communities
Conservation Plan (HCP/NCCP). A novel nitrogen fee based on car trips generated is one of the
funding mechanisms, driving a need for cost-effective and robust monitoring of N-deposition
trends over the 50-year plan and beyond. A set of sentinel springs for long-term monitoring will
be identified and sampled on an interval commensurate with shallow groundwater residence
times.
1Creekside Center for Earth Observation, [email protected] 2Brown University, [email protected]
26
Individual Tree Species’ Responses to Concurrent Nitrogen and Sulfur Deposition
across the Contiguous United States
Kevin Horn1, R. Quinn Thomas
2, Linda H. Pardo
3, Christopher M. Clark
4, Mark
E. Fenn5, Gregory B. Lawrence
6, Steven S. Perakis
7, Erica A.H. Smithwick
8,
Douglas Baldwin9, Sabine Braun
10 and et al.
11
Atmospheric deposition of nitrogen (N) and sulfur (S) concurrently impact temperate forests through similar
and diverse mechanisms. Both N and S compounds contribute to soil acidification; however, N deposition also affects individual tree physiology and stand competition through eutrophication. Tree responses to S and
N deposition can be difficult to separate, especially since N and S deposition often originate from common sources. Additionally, tree responses to deposition are controlled by individual species physiologies and the
influence of local soil and climatic factors. Understanding the impacts of S and N deposition, both separate
and concerted, on demographics of tree species will help identify how forests and forest resources are changing, and facilitate setting response thresholds for N and S deposition.
Here we examine tree growth and survival rates against modeled N and S deposition and climate at the species level for the contiguous United States. Of the 94 species examined, growth and/or survival of 74 and
66 tree species were associated with S and/or N deposition, respectively. Only 5 species showed no
relationship with S or N deposition in either growth or survival. Of the 94 tree species, 30 tree species increased in growth with N deposition, 6 decreased, and 19 increased then decreased while 39 showed no
relationship with N deposition. For survival, 5 increased, 6 decreased, and 26 increased then decreased while
57 did not change across N deposition gradients. Only non-positive responses to S deposition were allowed in the models, for which 41 and 51 of the 94 species showed negative growth and survival responses,
respectively. When N deposition was considered without S deposition in the models, growth and survival
responses associated with N deposition decreased from an average rate of 17 Δkg C/Δkg N to 9.9 Δkg C/Δkg N and -0.065 Δ%P(s)/Δkg N ha-1yr-1 to -0.441 Δ%P(s)/Δkg N ha-1yr-1. Surprisingly, the presence of S
deposition in the models affected observed N deposition responses regardless of the correlation between N
and S inputs. Nonetheless, forest sensitivities to N and S deposition seemed to be associated with species-specific mechanisms as co-occurring species often demonstrated contrasting responses. These relationships of
tree species dynamics across highly variable N and S deposition gradients provide estimates for N and S
deposition impacts on forests in the U.S. and identify quantifiable thresholds for species responses to N and S deposition.
1Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation, Virginia Tech, Cheatham Hall, Blacksburg, VA 24061, [email protected] 2Forest Resources and Environmental Conservation, Virginia Tech, [email protected] 3USDA Forest Service, Northern Research Station, Burlington, VT 05405, [email protected] 4US EPA, National Center for Environmental Assessment, Washington, DC 20460,
[email protected] 5USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Riverside, CA 92507, [email protected] 6U.S. Geological Survey, Troy, NY 12180, [email protected] 7Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center, US Geological Survey, Corvallis, OR 97331,
[email protected] 8Department of Geography, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802,
[email protected] 9Department of Geography, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, [email protected] 10Umeå Plant Science Centre, Umea, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Sweden,
[email protected] 11Umeå Plant Science Centre, Umea, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Sweden,
27
Critical Loads of Nitrogen Deposition for Trees and Forest Ecosystems across the
Continental U.S.
Linda Pardo1, Kevin J. Horn
2, Christopher M. Clark
3 and R. Quinn Thomas
4
Critical loads of nitrogen deposition and exceedance of critical loads are being used increasingly
by resource managers and policy makers to assess the risk of detrimental effects to forests. A
recent analysis has allowed us to calculate critical loads for tree growth and survival in a
systematic way for over fifty species across the continental US.
We used United States Forest Service Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) data with modeled S
and N deposition rates and climate data to identify species-specific responses of trees associated
with S and N deposition across the conterminous United States. Growth and survival estimates
were made from repeated measurements of more than 1.1 million individual trees measured
between 2000 and 2016.
We used these data to set critical loads for growth (for 32 species) and survival (for 54 species)
for individual tree species and for level 3 ecoregions across the continental US. Using FIA
expansion factors we were able to assess the extent of forest area at risk from nitrogen deposition.
These species-specific responses will allow resource managers to understand the likely impacts
from atmospheric nitrogen deposition and to manager their forests accordingly. The critical loads
and exceedance maps will allow policy makers to assess the likely impacts of current and future
deposition scenarios.
1US Forest Service, [email protected] 2Virginia Tech, [email protected] 3US EPA, [email protected] 4Virginia Tech, [email protected]
28
Recent Advances in Critical Loads Research
Christopher Clark1, Kevin Horn
2, Linda Pardo
3, Robert Sabo
4, Jen Phelan
5, Jason
Lynch6 and Quinn Thomas
7
Nitrogen and sulfur deposition have declined in the eastern U.S. since the 1980s and 1990s
following the 1990 Amendments to the Clean Air Act, yet they remain significantly elevated
above thresholds where sensitive ecological end points are affected. Here we summarize several
projects on assessing ecosystem sensitivity to N and S deposition, and the ecosystem services
affected. One focus of the talk is on forest health and biodiversity, and here we use recently
available critical loads for 94 tree species to examine how individual tree species are affected
across the conterminous U.S. We also explore methods for synthesizing this information to
inform development of air quality policies under the secondary standards of the NAAQS. The
views expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views or
policies of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
1US EPA, [email protected] 2Virginia Polytechnical University 3US Forest Service 4US EPA 5University of Illinois 6US EPA 7Virginia Polytechnical University
29
TECHNICAL SESSION 2:
AIR & WATER QUALITY: LINKAGES AND
SYNERGIES
Session Chairs: Mark Nilles and Helen Amos,
USGS and US EPA
Session Moderator: Rich Pouyat, USDA Forest
Service
30
31
Bridging the Air-Water Quality Information Gap to Improve Nutrient
Management
Helen Amos1, Chelcy Miniat
2, Lori A. Sprague
3, David Gay
4, Mark A. Nilles
5,
Anne W. Rea6, Richard V. Pouyat
7, Denice M. Shaw
8, Jerad Bales
9, Jeff Deacon
10,
Jana E. Compton11
, Doug Burns12
, Jason A. Lynch13
, LaToya Myles14
, Pamela H.
Templer15
, John T. Walker16
and Dave Whitall17
Nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) enrichment in fresh and coastal waters is one of today’s most
pervasive, expensive, and challenging water quality issues in the US. Continued inputs of excess
nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) have created chronic drinking water contamination, harmful
algal blooms, and persistent hypoxic zones in some aquatic systems. Atmospheric deposition can
be a significant non-point source of N and P over large regions of the continental U.S. - yet there
is a shortage of coordinated information about how air quality impacts aquatic nutrient
enrichment. WADeIn (Water Quality & Atmospheric Deposition Integration) is an interagency,
multi-organization collaboration that aims to fill this gap and improve the coordination and
integration of atmospheric deposition and surface water quality monitoring to better understand
the sources, transport, and impacts of excess N and P. We present a call for better integration of
atmospheric deposition and water quality monitoring for N and P at a national scale that
leverages existing infrastructure and expertise with the long-term objective to develop an
integrated air/water monitoring consortium. We examine several issues driving the need for
enhanced integrated monitoring, including: coastal eutrophication, urban hotspots of deposition,
shift from oxidized to reduced N deposition, land-use change and land management, and
disappearance of pristine lakes. We offer specific next steps to move the U.S. towards a 21st-century integrated air/water monitoring consortium for improved management of ecosystems.
1AAAS Fellow hosted by US EPA, [email protected] 2US Department of Agriculture, [email protected] 3US Geological Survey, [email protected] 4University of Illinois, [email protected] 5US Geological Survey, [email protected] 6US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 7US Forest Service, [email protected] 8US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 9Consortium of Universities for the Advancement of Hydrologic Science, Inc.,
[email protected] 10US Geological Survey, [email protected] 11US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 12US Geological Survey, [email protected] 13US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 14NOAA, [email protected] 15Boston University, [email protected] 16US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 17NOAA, [email protected]
32
CMAQ Modeling in the Nitrogen Inventory Study in the Nooksack-
Abbotsford-Sumas Transboundary Region
Donna Schwede
1, Ellen Cooter
2, Jiajia Lin
3, Jana Compton
4 and Jill Baron
5
Optimizing nitrogen (N) use for food production while minimizing the release of N and co-
pollutants to the environment is an important challenge. The Nooksack-Abbotsford-Sumas
Transboundary (NAS) Region, spanning a portion of the western interface of British Columbia,
Washington State, the Lummi Nation and Nooksack Tribal lands, supports agriculture, estuarine
fisheries, diverse wildlife, and vibrant urban areas. Excess N has contributed to surface and
ground water pollution, shellfish closure, and impaired air quality (such as haze or smog) in some
areas in the NAS Transboundary region. To reduce the release of N to the environment,
collaborative approaches that engage all stakeholders and appropriate institutions are needed to
integrate science, outreach and management efforts. The goal of the NAS Transboundary N
inventory study is to quantify the sources and fate of N, including inputs and transfers within the
watershed. We are synthesizing publicly available data on N sources including atmospheric
deposition, sewage and septic inputs, fertilizer and manure applications, marine-derived N from
salmon migrations, natural N-fixing vegetation, and more.
CMAQv5.2 is used to estimate daily total nitrogen deposition as well as other air quality
indicators in the target year (2014) at a 4-km grid resolution. An existing 12-km CMAQ model
of Western US is employed to provide boundary conditions for the new model. The model
domain is centered on the NAS Transboundary region, and includes nearly all of Washington
State and the Fraser Valley in Canada. Bi-directional CMAQ ammonia flux will be presented
from simulations that couple the USDA EPIC model which provides estimates of agricultural
fertilizer application form, timing and amount based on the NLCD2011 land use classification
and USDA regional cropping and agricultural management patterns, with the CMAQ model.
The information on cross-boundary N inputs to the landscape will be coupled with stream and
groundwater monitoring data and existing knowledge to estimate the N residual in the watershed
and N transport out of the watershed. Results will inform N management in the search for the
environmentally and economically viable and effective solutions. The NAS Transboundary
Region study is one of seven international demonstration projects contributing knowledge of
regional N budgets and collaborative approaches toward N management as part of the
International Nitrogen Management System (INMS).
1EPA, [email protected] 2EPA, [email protected] 3National Research Council, [email protected] 4EPA, [email protected] 5USGS, [email protected]
33
Episodic Acidification in the Adirondack Region of New York: Spatial
Patterns and Evidence of Recovery
Douglas Burns1, Gregory Lawrence
2, Timothy Sullivan
3, Charles Driscoll
4, Shuai
Shao5 and Todd McDonnell
6
Episodic acidification occurs when the pH and ANC of surface waters temporarily decrease
during rain events and snowmelt. The principal drivers of episodic acidification are increases in
sulfuric acid, nitric acid, organic acids, and dilution of base cations. In regions where surface
waters are sensitive to acid deposition, episodic acidification may result in several days to weeks
when ANC values may approach or decline below 0 µeq/L, a threshold below which increases in
monomeric aluminum concentrations become evident, which may result in deleterious effects to
sensitive aquatic biota. The Adirondack Mountains of New York is a region with abundant
streams and lakes, many of which are highly sensitive to the effects of acid deposition. Long-term
monitoring data indicate that pH and ANC in regional surface waters are increasing in response
to decreases in the acidity of atmospheric deposition that result from decreasing SO2 and
NOx emissions as the Clean Air Act and its ancillary rules and amendments have been
implemented. Most surface-water monitoring focuses on low-flow and broad seasonal patterns,
and less is known about how episodic acidification has responded to emissions decreases. We are
exploring spatial and temporal patterns in episodic acidification through analysis of stream
chemistry from surveys that target varying flow conditions as well as data from a few long-term
intensively sampled stream monitoring sites. Each stream sample is assigned a flow percentile
value based on a resident or nearby gage, and a statistical relation between ANC values and flow
percentile is developed. The magnitude of episodic decreases in ANC increases as low-flow ANC
increases, a pattern that likely results from an increasing influence of dilution, especially evident
when low-flow ANC values exceed 100 µeq/L. Chronically acidic streams with low-flow ANC
near 0 µeq/L show little episodic acidification, whereas streams with low-flow ANC values of
about 50 µeq/L generally show ANC decreases to less than 0 µeq/L at high flow. Preliminary
analysis of a 24-yr data set (1991-2014) at Buck Creek near Inlet, NY indicates that high-flow
ANC has recovered twice as much as low-flow ANC, and values generally no longer decline
below 0 µeq/L at the highest flows, which typically occur during spring snowmelt. Further
analyses will explore how the drivers of episodic acidification vary across the region with low-
flow ANC and whether clear trends are evident in the influence of these drivers over the past few decades.
1U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 2U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 3E&S Environmental, tim.sullivan@esenvironmental 4Syracuse Univ., [email protected] 5Syracuse Univ., [email protected] 6E&S Environmental, todd.mcdonnell@esenvironmental
34
35
TECHNICAL SESSION 3:
AIR & WATER QUALITY: LINKAGES AND
SYNERGIES (CONTINUED)
Session Chairs: Mark Nilles and Helen Amos,
USGS and US EPA
Session Moderator: Rich Pouyat, USDA Forest
Service
36
37
Changes in Stream Chemistry at High Flow during 23 Years of Decreasing Acid
Deposition in the Catskill Mountains of New York
Michael McHale1, Douglas Burns
2, Jason Siemion
3 and Michael Antidormi
4
The Catskill Mountains of New York is a region with demonstrated sensitivity to acid rain. The
headwaters of the Neversink River basin are the most sensitive waters in the region with both
chronically and episodically acidic streams. High-flow events (storms and snowmelt) cause sharp
reductions in acid neutralizing capacity (ANC) and increases in nitrate (NO3-) and inorganic
monomeric aluminum (Alim). Even as streams recover from chronic acidification because of
reductions in acidic deposition, episodic acidification may continue to cause sharp declines in
ANC and increases in NO3-NO3- and Alim that can have deleterious effects on stream
ecosystems. We examined changes in stream chemistry throughout a 23 year period of decreasing
acid deposition across all flow conditions, with particular emphasis on examining changes during
high flow. Our results indicate that both chronically and episodically acidic streams are
improving at similar rates and that trends were similar between high flow and all flow conditions.
Initially we focused on spring snowmelt; we computed Mann-Kendall trends for stream
chemistry during April of each year because April is the month during which peak spring
streamflow typically occurs in this region. We found that ANC and sulfate (SO42-) trends were of
similar magnitude and direction between April-only and annual seasonal-Kendall trends.
Furthermore, the most acidic stations showed the largest recovery from acidification during
spring melt. In fact the only significant Alim April trends occurred at the 2 most acidic stations. In
general, there were fewer significant trends in chemistry during April compared to the entire year
at every station and there were no significant trends that changed direction between the April and
annual trends. We also compared annual flow-weighted mean solute concentrations at low flow,
high flow, and all flow conditions to examine whether the recovery documented by seasonal-
Kendall and the April Mann-Kendall trend analyses was apparent across flow conditions. The
greatest increases in ANC from the beginning of the study period to the end of the study period
were measured during high flow. The decrease in the number of acid episodes resulted in a
decrease in Alimconcentrations at high flow. Perhaps the most important finding was that the
frequency and magnitude of acidic episodes has decreased dramatically at the most acidic station
and Alim concentrations have decreased considerably during acidic episodes.
1U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 2U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 3U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 4U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected]
38
Evaluating Potential Water Quality Impairments on National Forest Priority
Watersheds Using Estimates of Atmospheric Deposition
David Levinson1, Anita Rose
2 and Rich Pouyat
3
The U.S. Forest Service Watershed Condition Framework (WCF) is a nationally consistent
reconnaissance-level approach for assessing and classifying watershed condition, using a
comprehensive set of 12 indicators that are surrogate variables representing the underlying
ecological, hydrological, and geomorphic functions and processes that affect watershed
condition. Primary emphasis of the WCF is on aquatic and terrestrial processes and
conditions that Forest Service management activities have on stream, riparian and aquatic
habitat. As part of the WCF, National Forests designate “Priority Watersheds” where a
variety of land management treatments are planned and implemented. One of the primary
aquatic indicators of the WCF is water quality, but measuring and monitoring water quality
impacts has been difficult since many of the almost 300 Priority Watersheds are located in
headwater regions on National Forests. Initial steps are under way to collocate both water
and air monitoring on Priority Watersheds, to improve understanding of water quality
impairments due to atmospheric deposition. A primary question is understanding when air
deposition is coupled with water quality, and when they are decoupled, and why? A
specific concern is Nitrogen (N) deposition, since it impacts large parts of the U.S., and
initial efforts will be to use N deposition estimates to identify a subset of Priority
Watersheds with potential water quality impairments for collocating air and water monitoring.
1US Forest Service, [email protected] 2US Forest Service, [email protected] 3US Forest Service, [email protected]
39
Integration of Atmospheric Deposition and Water Quality Monitoring in the El
Yunque National Forest, Puerto Rico
Anita K. Rose1, Richard Pouyat
2, Linda Geiser
3, David Levinson
4, Chelcy Miniat
5,
Bret A. Anderson6, Helen M. Amos
7 and Denice Shaw
8
Excess levels of nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) in surface water are associated with
increased biological stress and decreased biological diversity. There is a significant need to
enhance connections between atmospheric deposition monitoring and surface water quality
monitoring to better understand linkages between air quality and the health of aquatic
ecosystems. The limited integrated air/water monitoring we currently have is almost exclusively
concentrated in temperate latitudes. El Yunque National Forest, Puerto Rico offers a unique
opportunity to investigate air/water linkages because (1) watershed N/P loads are dominated by
atmospheric inputs, (2) it already has an NADP super site, and (3) it is a tropical rainforest that
experiences frequent, intense convective storms that are major source of lightning NOx. As part
of WADeIn (Water Quality & Atmospheric Deposition Integration) -- an interagency
collaboration improving the coordination and integration of atmospheric deposition and surface
water quality monitoring to fill critical knowledge gaps about the sources, transport, and impacts
of N and P -- the USDA Forest Service is proposing to install real-time water quality sensors for
nutrients in the El Yunque National Forest. The goal is to integrate the resulting data with those
from the NADP super site that currently exists in the National Forest. This pilot study will
demonstrate the usefulness of the selected water sensors for quantification of nutrients in stream
and provide quantitative information about how closely coupled stream nutrient exports are to
atmospheric inputs. The window of opportunity for the El Yunque pilot is very timely and will be
able to leverage a number of other pilots launching on similar timelines by other agencies and
organizations. Additional benefits of the El Yunque pilot include: outreach to the local
community through the El Yunque National Forest visitor center; test usefulness of sensors to be
deployed as part of the recently established Watershed Condition Framework; foster
collaborations between the Forest Service’s National Forest System and Research and
Development branches, EPA, NOAA, and USGS. Results from this pilot study will provide an
opportunity to further explore integrated air/water quality monitoring, as well as provide a much
needed investigation into the status of watershed/water quality in the El Yunque National Forest.
1USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 2USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 3USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 4USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 5USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 6USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 7EPA, [email protected] 8EPA, [email protected]
40
41
TECHNICAL SESSION 4:
DEPOSITION MODELING AND MONITORING
Session Chairs: Anne Rea and Eric Prestbo,
USDA Forest Service and Tekran
42
43
Evaluation of Wet Atmospheric Deposition along the Coast of the Gulf
of Mexico: An International Collaboration Opportunity
Rodolfo Sosa E.1, Humberto Bravo A.
2, Ana Luisa Alarcon J.
3, Maria del Carmen
Torres B.4, Pablo Sanchez A.
5, Monica Jaimes P.
6, Elias Granados H.
7, David
Gay8, Christopher Lehmann
9 and Gregory Wetherbee
10
The evaluation of atmospheric deposition at regional scales requires international collaboration to adequately characterize the occurrence of potential impacts and establish measures to mitigate them. The central theme
for the 2017 NADP Meeting, “NADP data: making the world a better place, one monitor, one network, one
study at time,” gives us the direction to evaluate atmospheric deposition in the Gulf of Mexico Region.
The Gulf of Mexico Region has important sources of acid rain precursors, both on land and at sea, located in
countries bordering the region, such as the USA, Mexico and Cuba. It is very important to study the chemical composition of atmospheric wet deposition through international cooperation. Studies on the Mexican coast
have recorded the presence of acid rain since 2003. The aim of this study was to evaluate the major ions (Na+,
NH4+, K+, Mg2+, Ca2+, SO4
2-, NO3- and Cl-), pH and conductivity in atmospheric wet deposition, collected
daily from 2003 to 2015 at a sampling site located along the coast of Mexico (La Mancha, Veracruz) and
compare the values with the NADP sampling sites located along the Gulf of Mexico coast from Texas to
Florida.
Among the major findings: all ions were present in greater levels in “La Mancha” in comparison with each
one of the sampling sites in the USA, with exception of nitrogen compounds (NO3- and NH4
+ ), which were comparable to the USA sites. The levels of sulfates in Mexico were comparable to the highest US NADP
sites. The ratio of SO42- to NO3
- has been used as indicator of the effectiveness of SO2 and NOx emissions
reductions in the USA. The SO42-/NO3
- ratio found for “La Mancha” in 2015 was 4.8, the highest value when compared to other sites in the Gulf of Mexico, which had ratios between 1.03 and 1.87. Due to the high levels
of SO42- and the ratio SO4
2-/NO3- found at “La Mancha,” it is important to monitor the sulfur dioxide emission
sources in Mexico.
In addition to “La Mancha” sampling site, two additional sampling sites, in Mexico, have recently been
incorporated to the atmospheric deposition study: one in the City of Campeche and another in the Port of Veracruz. Initial results from these sites will be shown.
The establishment of the international network for the evaluation of atmospheric deposition in the Gulf of Mexico represents a great opportunity for international collaboration. NADP protocols for sampling and
analysis will be adopted, including quality-assurance and quality-control protocols, to ensure that information
generated is comparable between current participating countries, USA and México and possibly Cuba.
1Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), [email protected] 2UNAM, [email protected] 3UNAM, [email protected] 4UNAM, [email protected] 5UNAM, [email protected] 6UNAM, [email protected] 7UNAM, [email protected] 8National Atmospheric Deposition Program (NADP), [email protected] 9NADP, [email protected] 10United States Geological Survey, [email protected]
44
Methylmercury and Total Mercury in Marine Stratus Cloud and Fog Water:
Sources, Sinks, and Lifetimes
Peter Weiss-Penzias1, Kenneth Coale
2, Wes Heim
3, Armin Sorooshian
4, Hossein
Dadashazar5, Alex MacDonald
6, Zhen Wang
7, Ewan Crosbie
8, Haflidi
Jonsson9 and Jerry Lin
10
Monomethylmercury (MMHg) concentrations in marine stratus cloud and fog water in California
are enhanced to upwards of 1 ng L-1 compared to concentrations typically found in rain water,
which are closer 0.1 ng L-1. This raises the possibility that coastal terrestrial ecosystems
impacted by marine fog and clouds could be exposed to this potent neurotoxin. Efforts to
measure MMHg in cloud and fog water on the California coast indicate that the source of MMHg
is from evasion of dimethylmercury (DMHg) and subsequent demethylation in the air or in the
droplet to form MMHg. This presentation will highlight the data collected on land, at sea, and by
aircraft at numerous locations in coastal California since 2014, and discuss the major gaps in our
understanding of the cycling and transport of methylated Hg compounds in the oceanic mixed layer, atmospheric marine boundary layer, and the cloud droplet.
1University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected] 2Moss Landing Marine Labs, [email protected] 3Moss Landing Marine Labs, [email protected] 4University of Arizona, [email protected] 5University of Arizona, [email protected] 6University of Arizona, [email protected] 7University of Arizona, [email protected] 8NASA UNIVERSITIES SPACE RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, [email protected] 9Naval Postgraduate School, [email protected] 10Lamar University, [email protected]
45
Trends in NADP Bromide Wet Deposition Concentrations, 2001-2016
Gregory Wetherbee1, Christopher M.B. Lehmann, Ph.D.
2, Lee A. Green
3, Mark F.
Rhodes4, Brian M. Kerschner
5 and Amy S. Ludtke
6
Bromide (Br-) and other solute concentration data from wet deposition samples collected by the
National Atmospheric Deposition Program (NADP) from 2001 to 2016 (study period), were
analyzed for statistical trends both geographically and temporally and by precipitation type.
Bromide was more frequently detected at NADP sites in coastal regions of the continental United
States. The Br- concentration data set was characterized by greater than 86 percent of sample
concentrations below analytical detection. Analysis revealed that Br- concentrations were higher
in rain (only) versus precipitation containing snow. Decreasing Br- wet deposition concentrations
were observed at a majority of NADP sites over the study period; approximately 25 percent of
the trend slopes were statistically significant at the alpha=0.10 level. Correlations between Br-,
Cl-, and NO3- concentrations were evaluated to investigate sea-salt as a Br-source and potential
Br- oxidation of atmospheric nitrite (NO2(g)) to NO3-(aq).
Potential causes for decreasing Br- concentrations were explored, including annual and seasonal
changes in precipitation depth, reduced emissions of methyl bromide (CH3Br) from coastal
wetlands, and declining industrial use of bromine compounds. Trend analyses indicated that
precipitation depth generally increased during the study period at the majority of NADP sites,
which diluted Br- below analytical detection in many samples. Declining Br- concentrations also
are consistent with declining industrial CH3Br emissions mandated by the Montreal Protocol.
Chemical processes that deplete Br- from sea-salt aerosols and inundation of saltmarsh habitat
suggest changing marine conditions were identified as possible influences on temporal trends in
Br- concentrations. There are no known ecological consequences of changing Br- concentrations
in wet deposition at this time, but the trends may help to explain the chemistry of pollutants like CH3Br and the changing chemical climate of the atmosphere.
1U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected] 2Univ. Illinois, Prairie Research Institute, ISWS, [email protected] 3Univ. Illinois, Prairie Research Institute, ISWS, [email protected] 4Univ. Illinois, Prairie Research Institute, ISWS, [email protected] 5Univ. Illinois, Prairie Research Institute, ISWS, [email protected] 6U.S. Geological Survey, [email protected]
46
Total Deposition by Measurement-model Fusion using ADAGIO
Amanda Cole1, Alain Robichaud
2, Mike Moran
3, Mike Shaw
4, Alexandru Lupu
5,
Marc Beauchemin6, Guy Roy
7, Vincent Fortin
8 and Robert Vet
9
Environment and Climate Change Canada’s ADAGIO project (Atmospheric Deposition Analysis
Generated by optimal Interpolation from Observations) generates maps of wet, dry and total
annual deposition of oxidized and reduced nitrogen (N) and sulphur (S) in Canada and the United
States by fusion of observed and modeled data. Optimal interpolation methods are used to
integrate seasonally-averaged surface concentrations of gaseous, particulate, and precipitation
species into concentration fields predicted by Environment and Climate Change Canada’s in-line
regional air quality model GEM-MACH (Global Environmental Multiscale model - Modelling
Air quality and Chemistry). The result, a product called objective analysis (OA), corresponds to
an interpolation of the difference between the modeled and measured values at network
observation sites. Gas and particulate OA concentration fields are then combined with effective
deposition velocities from GEM-MACH to calculate dry deposition. Similarly, OA
concentrations of precipitation ions are combined with precipitation amounts from the Canadian
Precipitation Analysis (CaPA) to calculate wet deposition. CaPA is also an objective analysis
where all available precipitation data sets are fused with precipitation amounts predicted by
GEM. Results from the 2010 development year are compared with previously-generated wet
deposition kriging maps, results from the US EPA’s Total Deposition (TDEP) method, and
independent validation performed with surface measurements not used in the analysis where available.
1Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 2Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 3Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 4Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 5Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 6Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 7Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 8Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected] 9Environment and Climate Change Canada, [email protected]
47
TECHNICAL SESSION 5:
URBAN AIR QUALITY AND DEPOSITION
Session Chair: Steven Decina,
Boston University
48
49
Quantifying Urban Nitrogen Emission and Deposition Through Optical
Sensing Techniques
Kang Sun1
As the third most abundant nitrogen species in the atmosphere, ammonia (NH3) is a key
component of the global nitrogen cycle. Since the industrial revolution, humans have more
than doubled the emissions of NH3 to the atmosphere by industrial nitrogen fixation,
revolutionizing agricultural practices, and burning fossil fuels. Ammonia is a major
precursor to fine particulate matter (PM2.5), which has adverse impacts on ecosystem and
human health. On-road vehicles are key sources of NH3 emissions and depositions in urban
areas. Due to the successful control of oxidized nitrogen (NOx) emissions and the lack of
NH3emission control, new vehicles manufactured now emit more NH3 molecules than
NOx molecules. To quantify NH3 emissions at an urban scale, a quantum cascade laser-
based NH3 sensor was integrated into a mobile laboratory, which participated in extensive
field campaigns, including the NASA DISCOVER-AQ campaigns and the CAREBeijing-
NCP campaign in China (400 h on-road time, 18,000 km total sampling distance). Vehicle
NH3:CO2 emission ratios in the U.S. are found to be similar between cities (0.33–0.40
ppbv/ppmv, 15% uncertainty) despite differences in fleet composition, climate, and fuel
composition. While Beijing, China has a comparable emission ratio (0.36 ppbv/ppmv) to
the U.S. cities, less developed Chinese cities show higher emission ratios (0.44 and 0.55
ppbv/ppmv). If the vehicle CO2 inventories are accurate, NH3 emissions from U.S. vehicles
(0.26 ± 0.07 Tg/yr) are more than twice those of the National Emission Inventory (0.12
Tg/yr). Vehicle NH3 emissions are greater than agricultural emissions (which is highly
uncertain as well) in counties containing near half of the U.S. population and require
reconsideration in urban air quality models. Future opportunities of characterizing
NH3 emissions and investigating the transition of NH3/NOx regimes at the global scale enabled by satellite observations will also be discussed.
1Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, [email protected]
50
Using Moss to Detect Fine-Scaled Deposition of Heavy Metals in Urban
Environments
Sarah Jovan1, Geoffrey Donovan
2, Demetrios Gatziolis
3, Vicente Monleon
4 and
Michael Amacher5
Mosses are commonly used as bio-indicators of heavy metal deposition to forests. Their
application in urban airsheds is relatively rare. We used moss to develop fine-scaled, city-
wide maps for heavy metals in Portland, Oregon, to identify pollution “hotspots” and serve
as a screening tool for more effective placement of expensive air quality monitoring
instruments. In 2013 we measured twenty-two elements in epiphytic moss sampled on a
1km x1km sampling grid (n = 346). We detected large hotspots of cadmium and arsenic in
two neighborhoods associated with stained glass manufacturers. Air instruments deployed
by local regulators to moss-detected hotspots measured cadmium concentrations 49 times
and arsenic levels 155 times the state health benchmarks. Moss maps also detected a large
nickel hotspot near a forge where air instruments later measured concentrations 4 times the
health benchmark. In response, the facilities implemented new pollution controls, air
quality improved in all three affected neighborhoods, revision of regulations for stained
glass furnace emissions are underway, and Oregon’s governor launched an initiative to
develop health-based (vs technology-based) regulations for air toxics in the state. The moss
maps also indicated a couple dozen smaller hotspots of heavy metals, including lead,
chromium, and cobalt, in Portland neighborhoods. Ongoing follow-up work includes: 1)
use of moss sampling by local regulators to investigate source and extent of the smaller
hotspots, 2) use of lead isotopes to determine origins of higher lead levels observed in moss
collected from the inner city, and 3) co-location of air instruments and moss sampling to
determine accuracy, timeframe represented, and seasonality of heavy metals in moss.
1U.S. Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, [email protected] 2U.S. Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, [email protected] 3U.S. Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, [email protected] 4U.S. Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, [email protected] 5U.S. Forest Service, retired, [email protected]
51
Elemental Carbon Deposition to Urban Tree Canopies: Magnitudes and Spatial
Patterns
Alexandra G. Ponette-González1, Tate E. Barrett
2, Jenna E. Rindy
3 and Rebecca J.
Sheesley4
Urban areas are a major source of atmospheric elemental carbon (EC), a component of fine
particulate matter and a powerful climate-forcing agent. However, empirical
measurements of EC removal from urban atmospheres by wet and dry deposition are few in
number and virtually none explicitly quantify intra-urban variability in deposition rates.
Tree canopies are likely important sinks for EC on the cityscape because of their
propensity to scavenge suspended particulate matter, of which EC can be a significant
component in urban settings. This research aims to quantify magnitudes and spatial
patterns of total (wet + dry) EC deposition to urban tree canopies in the Dallas-Fort Worth
Metroplex using the throughfall method (collection of water that falls from the canopy to
the forest floor). In March 2017, we established 41 throughfall collectors across a 51
km2 area in the City of Denton, Texas. Collectors were deployed beneath 22 post oak
(Quercus stellata) and 19 live oak (Quercus virginiana) trees in residential yards and urban
greenspaces, both near (≤100 m) and far from roads (>100 m) with truck traffic.
Additionally, 16 bulk rainfall samplers were established in grassy areas with no canopy
cover. Throughfall and rainfall are currently being sampled on an event basis. Total EC
deposition to urban tree canopies measured during a single rainfall event in May 2017
ranged widely, from 0.12 to 5.6 mg m-2. On average, EC deposition to post oak canopies
was more than 2-fold higher (1.8 ± 2.0 (SD) mg m-2) compared to live oak canopies (0.67 ±
0.27 mg m-2) whereas bulk rainfall deposition was 0.077 ± 0.11 mg m-2. Our preliminary
findings show that oak trees are effective urban air filters, removing up to 23 times more
EC from the atmosphere than rainwater alone. Qualitative observations suggest that tree
size and density of emissions sources within a 50-m radius buffer also contribute to spatial
variability in EC deposition. Resolving surface controls on atmospheric EC removal is key to developing and assessing climate and air quality mitigation strategies.
1Department of Geography and the Environment, University of North Texas,
[email protected] 2Department of Geography and the Environment, University of North Texas,
[email protected] 3Department of Geography and the Environment, University of North Texas,
[email protected] 4Department of Environmental Science, Baylor University, [email protected]
52
Characteristics and Ecological Impacts of Atmospheric Deposition in Urban
and Urban-Affected Regions
Mark Fenn1, Andrzej Bytnerowicz
2, Susan Schilling
3, Michael Bell
4 and James
Sickman5
Urban air pollution causes major effects on human and ecosystem health and the environment.
On-road emissions are major drivers of air quality in urban regions. Technologies for reducing
NOx emissions result in production of reduced forms of N. Industrial, urban and on-road
emissions of NOx have declined dramatically while NH3 emissions have increased. Simulation
models underestimate NH4+ deposition, and models and regional monitoring networks do not
capture fine-scale spatial heterogeneity in dry deposition or fogwater deposition to receptor sites
affected by urban emissions. The highest N deposition reported for the Western hemisphere (70
kg/ha/yr as throughfall) occurs in the San Bernardino National Forest within the eastern region of
the Los Angeles Air Basin. Deposition can vary ten-fold over a 50-60 km gradient in forests
downwind of Los Angeles. Contrary to previous assumptions, sulfur deposition in Los Angeles
remains unusually high (30-40 kg/ha/yr), due to emissions from shipping, heavy transport and
industry. Wet deposition data are of limited utility in characterizing deposition in arid regions.
Notwithstanding, long-term data at the NADP site near Los Angeles (CA42) indicate decreasing
temporal trends in deposition of SO42+ and NO3
- and slightly increasing trends in NH4+. At
several such urban-dominated NADP sites across the U.S., wet deposition switched to
NH4+ values that are consistently greater than NO3
- molar values during the 2005 to 2010 period.
Data on urban NH3 concentrations support this trend of increasing importance of reduced forms
of N, primarily from on-road emissions of NH3. In this light, the Lake Tahoe Air Basin case
study will also be discussed.
Nitrogen critical loads in ecosystems of highly-urbanized southern California have been
determined for streamwater NO3-, epiphytic lichen community change, vegetation type change,
tree health, soil acidification and mycorrhizal responses. Urban emissions have resulted in
extensive areas of CL exceedance, although agricultural emissions are also important in some
locations. Urban emissions of N from Mexico City have likewise caused eutrophication impacts
to forested catchments in the air basin of this megacity. Ecosystems downwind of Mexico City
and Los Angeles are also exposed to phytotoxic levels of ozone---thus multipollutant effects are
important in evaluating ecosystem responses to urban air pollution. Urban air pollution affects
ecosystem services within the urban environment and in wildland ecosystems located within the
path of urban and transport corridor plumes. Impacted services include the provision of clean
drinking water and aesthetic, residential and recreational use of forests and other vegetation
types.
1USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 2USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 3USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 4National Park Service, Air Resources Division, [email protected] 5University of California, Riverside, Department of Environmental Sciences, [email protected]
53
Assessing Sources and Fluxes of Reactive Nitrogen Deposition to Urban
Landscapes Using Ion Exchange Resins
Rebecca Forgrave1, Kassia Groszewski
2, Elizabeth Boyer
3 and Emily Elliott
4
Previous research documents that urban reactive nitrogen deposition is both higher than rural
areas and spatially variable, highlighting key knowledge gaps in understanding the sources,
dynamics, and overall fluxes of reactive nitrogen deposition in urban areas. Traditional methods
used by the NADP NTN and US EPA CASTNET, for wet and dry deposition fluxes respectively,
require considerable cost to establish and maintain, thus making it difficult to establish enough
sites to fully explore this phenomenon or spatial variability. Ion exchange resins, however, offer
a robust alternative as they are relatively inexpensive, integrate fluxes over many weeks without
requiring exact precipitation volume, and can be used for isotopic analyses of resin eluents
without fractionation. In this project, ion exchange resin columns selectively targeting nitrate
(NO3-) or ammonia (NH4
+) were deployed at 7 monitoring sites (5 urban and 2 rural) around
Pittsburgh and the nearest NTN-CASTNET site and were exchanged every 1-2 months over a
one-year period. Column eluents were analyzed for concentrations of NO3- and NH4
+ to calculate
deposition fluxes, as well as dual nitrate isotopes (δ15N, δ18O) to examine emission sources and
oxidation chemistry. Fluxes were compared to those recorded by NTN and CASTNET at the
nearest rural national monitoring sites to verify that the ion exchange resins are capturing the
same signal as the established networks. Contrary to previous research, preliminary results
indicate no significant differences in deposition fluxes between urban and rural sites for either
NO3- or NH4
+. δ15N and δ18O values of eluted NO3- were highly variable among network sites
where both δ15N and δ18O values are generally higher in winter than summer. The range in δ15N
and δ18O values and the seasonal patterns are consistent with prior reports linking temporal
patterns in δ15N with increased power plant emissions during the winter months and δ18O value
with seasonal changes in oxidation chemistry. This research seeks to narrow existing knowledge
gaps regarding the fluxes of reactive nitrogen deposition to landscape, and how the high degree
of spatial variability observed in urban systems is related to NOX and NH3 emission sources. The
preliminary results reported here demonstrate the need for finer spatial scale sampling to further
understand causes of site variability, as well as the potential for ion exchange resins to be used as
a tool for this type of analysis.
1University of Pittsburgh, [email protected] 2University of Pittsburgh, [email protected] 3Penn State University, [email protected] 4University of Pittsburgh, [email protected]
54
Increasing Ethanol Consumption as a Renewable Fuel: How Will Vehicle
Ethanol Emissions Impact the Urban Atmosphere?
J. David Felix1, Rachel Thomas
2, Matt Casas
3, Megumi Shimizu
4, G. Brooks
Avery5, Robert Kieber
6, Ralph Mead
7, Joan Willey
8 and Chad Lane
9
US ethanol fuel consumption has increased exponentially over the last two decades as part of a
movement to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and become more fuel independent. US annual
renewable fuel production is ~16 billion gallons and is required to increase to 36 billion
according to the renewable fuel standard. Regardless of the technology or feedstock used to
produce renewable fuel, the primary end product will be ethanol. This has spurred extensive
debate among a diverse array of US stakeholders about the practicality of the renewable fuel
standard. Much of the evidence for both sides of the debate relies on the life cycle analysis of
ethanol production and weighing the effects of ethanol production on our economy, environment,
and food and water supply. However, one principal uncertainty not adequately addressed by
either side in this debate is “What are the impacts of increasing ethanol fuel consumption and
subsequently ethanol and aldehyde emissions on atmospheric composition and chemistry?” This
is despite modeling efforts that predict increases in blended fuel consumption will increase
national average ozone concentrations. This is especially true for urban air sheds consisting of
blended fuel vehicle emissions that result in elevated concentrations of VOCs with relatively high
ozone reactivities (i.e. aldehydes, alcohols).
The presented work provides evidence of high ethanol atmospheric concentrations associated
with densely populated urban areas and ethanol refineries throughout the globe by measuring wet
deposition ethanol concentrations. This has also produced the first global deposition flux of
ethanol (2.4± 1.6 Tg/yr) based on empirical data and suggests wet deposition removes 6 to 17%
of atmospheric ethanol annually. To provide further evidence of the increasing anthropogenic
sources leading to higher atmospheric ethanol concentrations, a method to measure the carbon
isotopic composition of ethanol at natural abundance levels was developed and carbon isotope
signatures (δ13C) of vehicle ethanol emission sources are reported for both Brazil (-12.7‰) and
the US (-9.8‰). An isotope mixing model using vehicle and biogenic endmembers was used to
estimate ethanol source apportionment in wet deposition and results suggest anthropogenic
sources contribute up to 7X more ethanol than previously predicted in modeled ethanol
inventories. With the US renewable fuel standard requiring a substantial increase in the next five
years, it is essential that the entities involved in deciding the fate of US fuel consumption have
knowledge of all the advantages and disadvantages of increased ethanol consumption, including
the atmospheric impacts of ethanol fuel emissions.
1Texas A&M University - Corpus Christi, [email protected] 2Florida State University, [email protected] 3University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected] 4University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected] 5University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected] 6University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected] 7University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected] 8University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected] 9University of North Carolina Wilmington, [email protected]
55
TECHNICAL SESSION 6:
NITROGEN: TRANSPORT DEPOSITION AND
EFFECTS
Session Chair: Justin Valliere
University of California Los Angeles
56
57
Ecosystem Flip-Flops in Response to Anthropogenic N Deposition: The
Importance of Long-term Experiments
George Vourlitis1
Anthropogenic nitrogen (N) deposition has the capacity to alter terrestrial ecosystem structure
and function; however, short-term (months-years) responses may be fundamentally different than
long-term (years-decades) responses. Here the results of a 14 year field N addition experiment
are reported for two semi-arid shrublands, a post-fire chaparral and a mature coastal sage scrub
(CSS), located in San Diego County, California that have been exposed to 50 kgN ha-1 yr-1 since
2003. Since >90% of the anthropogenic N in this region consists of dry deposition, N was added
during the late-summer or early-fall each year to assess how dry N inputs alter ecosystem
processes. Both shrublands experienced complete “flip-flops” in their response to experimental
dry N inputs. For example, post-fire chaparral plots exposed to added N had significantly lower
net primary production (NPP) than control plots over the first 3 years of the experiment, but
thereafter, the NPP in N plots increased consistently each year and became significantly higher
than in control plots after 7 years of N fertilization. In CSS, NPP and the abundance of Artemisia
californica, a co-dominant shrub, increased significantly in N plots over the first 6 years, but
thereafter, NPP and the abundance of A. californica and Salvia mellifera, the other co-dominant
shrub, declined, and now the N plots have a lower NPP and are dominated by the invasive
annual Brassica nigra. These transient responses, and interactions between N accumulation and
other factors such as post-fire succession (chaparral) and chronic drought (CSS), would have
been missed if the experiment was ended after the end of a typical funding cycle, highlighting the
importance of long-duration field experiments in assessing ecosystem responses to chronic N enrichment.
1California State University, [email protected]
58
Organic Nitrogen in Aerosols at a Forest Site in Southern Appalachia
John Walker1, Xi Chen
2, Mingjie Xie
3, Michael Hays
4 and Eric Edgerton
5
This study investigates the composition of organic particulate matter (PM2.5) in a remote montane
forest in the southeastern U.S., focusing on the role of organic nitrogen (N) in sulfur-containing
secondary organic aerosol (SOA) and aerosols associated with biomass burning. Measurements
targeted four groups of compounds: 1) nitro-aromatics associated with biomass burning; 2)
organosulfates and nitrooxy organosulfates produced from biogenic SOA precursors (i.e.,
isoprene, monoterpenes and unsaturated aldehydes); 3) terpenoic acids formed from monoterpene
oxidation; and 4) organic molecular markers including methyltetrols, C-5 alkene triols, 2-
methylglyceric acid, 3-hydroxyglutaric acid and levoglucosan. Terpenoic acids and organic
markers were included to assist in characterizing the extent of biogenic compound oxidation and
atmospheric processing (i.e., aerosol aging) as well as contributions from biomass burning sources.
The average fraction of WSON in water soluble total nitrogen (WSTN) exhibited a pronounced
seasonal pattern, ranging from ~18% w/w in the spring to ~10% w/w in the fall. Nitro-aromatic
and nitrooxy-organosulfate compounds accounted for as much as 28% w/w of WSON. Oxidized
organic nitrogen species showed a maximum concentration in summer (average of 0.65ngN/m3,
maximum of 1.83ngN/m3) consistent with greater relative abundance of aged biogenic SOA
tracers (higher generation oxygenated terpenoic acids). Highest concentrations of nitro-aromatics
(eg. Nitrocatechol and methyl-nitrocatechol) were observed during the fall season associated with
aged biomass burning plumes. Isoprene derived organosulfate (MW216, 2-methyltetrol derived),
which is formed from isoprene epoxydiols (IEPOX) under low Nox conditions, was the most
abundant individual organosulfate. Although nitro-aromatics and nitrooxy organosulfates account
for a small fraction (seasonal averages of 1.0 to 4.4%) of WSON, our results provide insight into
atmospheric formation processes and sources of these largely uncharacterized organic nitrogen
species.
1US EPA, [email protected] 2US EPA, [email protected] 3US EPA, [email protected] 4US EPA, [email protected] 5ARA, Inc, [email protected]
59
Quantifying Nitrogen Deposition Inputs and Impacts on Plant Richness in a
Mediterranean-type Shrubland
Justin Valliere1, Andrzej Bytnerowicz
2, Mark E. Fenn
3, Irina C. Irvine
4, Robert F.
Johnson5 and Edith B. Allen
6
Human activities have contributed to increased nitrogen (N) availability in terrestrial ecosystems
worldwide due to atmospheric pollution and resulting N deposition. Previous work in coastal
sage scrub (CSS) of southern California has established a clear link between elevated N
deposition and negative ecological impacts on native vegetation. However, while declines in
plant richness have been observed under high N deposition in a number of ecosystems
worldwide, studies examining this relationship in CSS are severely lacking. We measured levels
of N pollutants in the atmosphere and determined rates of N deposition across the landscape
based on atmospheric concentrations, deposition velocities of different reactive N forms, leaf area
index and plant stomatal uptake. We also measured soil N availability and plant community
composition of CSS at thirty sites across the Santa Monica Mountains in an effort to explore
relationships between plant richness and cover with atmospheric N inputs. We predicted elevated
rates of N deposition would be associated with lower plant diversity and higher cover of
nonnative species. Consistent with these hypotheses, we demonstrate that N deposition is
associated with reduced plant richness and slight increases in nonnative cover across the Santa
Monica Mountains. We also show through a number of field and greenhouse experiments that
declines in native species may be driven by changes to plant-water relations, altered plant-soil
feedbacks, and contrasting plant functional traits in native and invasive species. As human
activities continue to alter global N cycling, efforts to conserve native ecosystems will require explicit consideration of atmospheric N deposition.
1University of California Los Angeles, [email protected] 2U.S. Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Riverside, CA 3U.S. Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Riverside, CA 4National Park Service, Pacific West Regional Office, San Francisco, CA 5Center for Conservation Biology University of California, Riverside, CA 6Department of Botany and Plant Sciences University of California, Riverside, CA
60
61
TECHNICAL SESSION 7:
NITROGEN: TRANSPORT DEPOSITION AND
EFFECTS (CONTINUED)
Session Chair: Justin Valliere,
University of California Los Angeles
62
63
Atmospheric Deposition Evaluation as a Tool to Preserve Urban Natural Green
Areas: Mexico City Case
María Alejandra Fonseca1, Julio Campo
2, Luis Zambrano
3, Rodolfo Sosa
4, Ana
Luisa Alarcón5, María del Carmen Torres
6, Pablo Sánchez
7, Olivia Rivera
8 and
Mónica del Carmen Jaimes9
United Nations data indicate that by the year 2030, approximately 60% of the world’s population will live in urban areas.
Within urban ecosystems, the anthropogenic pollutants emissions in the atmosphere are concentrated and intensified, mainly
linked to economic activities. Since most of these pollutants are harmful to humans, its reduction in the environment is a
topic of international, national and local interest. It is important to note that mitigating these emissions is also vital for the
conservation of urban natural green areas, which at the same time provide ecosystem services to cities.
Mexico City Metropolitan Area (MCMA) has a dynamic population of more than 20 million inhabitants being the twelfth
largest city in the world and as all megacities faces great challenges in which it refers to environmental sustainability and
quality of life of its inhabitants. Actually, MCMA has 23 urban natural green areas and a community area corresponding to
26,047 ha with ecological conservation status (it corresponds to 17.42% of the city territory of 148,500 ha) which offer
various ecosystem services such as aquifer recharge, greenhouse gas fixation, climate regulation, agricultural production,
noise control, CO2 fixation, local wildlife reservoir, both flora and fauna, and of course, and not least important, recreational
and cultural activities. That is why it is essential to evaluate the quality of the atmospheric deposition that is presented in this
megacity, to maintain the conservation and management of these natural protected areas. Fortunately, the city is provided
with a network of monitoring atmospheric deposition (REDDA) that uses semi-automatic equipment for the collection of dry
deposition and wet deposition samples at 16 sampling sites. Some of these monitoring sites are within natural urban areas.
The operation of this network is in collaboration with the Government of Mexico City with the Center for Atmospheric
Sciences of the National Autonomous University of Mexico.
The most important findings in relation of the atmospheric deposition evaluation in MCMA include:
The pH values of the samples at the stations located in the south were more acidic than the samplesfor the stations in the
north. It is important to mention that in the south part of the MCMA is where most of the urban natural green areas are
located.
These results are in line with meteorological conditions, prevailing winds blowing from the north to the south, as well as
emission sources located in the north sector.
In most study sites, annual volume weighted decreased from 2003 to 2014. For example, “Montecillos" station located in the
North in a rural area, values decreased from 7.48 in 2003 to 5.03 in 2014.
In the stations located in a rural area (“Montecillos” in the North and “Ajusco” in the South), a strong correlation was found
between NH4+ and SO42-, NO3-, and Cl-; this is likely due to their origin in soil (i.e., fertilizer use). The same concentration
trend was observed for SO42- and NO3- in the MCMZ stations; this indicates that the sources of acid rain precursors are
upwind (i.e., to the north) of the study area.
It is important to take advantage of the information generated by the existing network and, if necessary, increase the number
of sites to generate information for the integral decision-making on the quality of life of people in MCMA and the
conservation of the urban natural green areas, as well as studying the critical loads that occur in megacities with local and
global impact.
The actions described will help to establish an integral monitoring of the natural components of the urban ecosystem that
consider the potential impact of atmospheric deposition in soils, water bodies, flora and fauna, etc.
[email protected] 2Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, [email protected] 3Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, [email protected] 4Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, [email protected] 5Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, [email protected] 6Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, maria [email protected] 7Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, [email protected] 8SIMAT Gobierno de la Ciudad de México, [email protected] 9SIMAT Gobierno de la Ciudad de México, [email protected]
64
Spatial and Temporal Relationships of Key Nitrogen Species between
Ambient and Deposition Regimes
Richard Scheffe1
There is increased interest in addressing adverse ecosystem effects associated with nitrogen
deposition through the secondary National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS). The
NAAQS structure raises interesting challenges in bridging ambient and deposition space while
imposing some constraints on biologically active forms of nitrogen that may not explicitly be
considered a NAAQS specie. This presentation explores two “NAAQS” bridging constructs –
transference ratios and the delineation of particulate ammonium contribution to wet deposition –
through a series of three dimensional spatial analyses across a variety of Federal Class 1 and
Ecoregion Level 3 areas based on a time series of 2002 -2012 CMAQ air quality simulations that
underpin the TDEP deposition surfaces. These analyses are used to better understand the limits
of using surface level indicators, associated with ground based monitoring systems, intended to
capture processes through the entire atmospheric column.
1U.S. EPA, [email protected]
65
Nutrient Deposition in the Headwaters of Streams may Impact Nitrogen
Loading in Southern Californian Estuaries
Pamela Padgett1, Karen McLaughlin
2 and Martha Sutula
3
As has been shown for other estuarine ecosystems, roughly a quarter of the total N and P load in Southern
California coastal waters cannot be accounted for by known anthropogenic sources. Although the contribution of deposition to estuarine nutrient loads has been demonstrated in other regions, it is has not
been well characterized in California. In particular, little data are available on the dry N and P deposition.
Studies were conducted to address the following research objectives:
1. Identify methods for measuring dry deposition controlled fumigation systems. These included
water surface samplers and acid impregnated filters and Nylasorb filters. 2. Estimate the spatial and temporal variability in N and P deposition to five, undisturbed feeder
catchments.
3. Evaluate the utility of dual isotopes: (δ18O and δ15N) to assess the contribution of atmospheric NO3
- to streams.
Of the surrogate surfaces tested in fumigation chambers, the water surface samplers produce the most reliable results for both NO3
- and NH4+. They demonstrated a strong linear relationship with air concentrations. For
the Nylasorb filters the linear relationship was weaker, and the flux of HNO3 was significantly less than to
water samplers. Citric acid impregnated filters were poor passive samplers for NH4+, but oxalic acid
impregnated filters were satisfactory under controlled fumigations. Under field conditions, the water
samplers had limited usefulness due to as evaporation and freezing, Nylasorb prove more robust under field
conditions.
The average N dry deposition was ~70% of, and the average P dry deposition is ~30% of the total load. An
important finding was that at several sites NH3+ was a more dominant N component of both wet and dry
deposition than was expected. Water surface sampler deposition data show that in general, NH4+ dry
deposition is nearly twice as high as NO3- and at some sites NH4
+ wet deposition also dominated the N
deposition pool. The prevalence of NH4+ is likely due to the proximity of agriculture even in an area of
moderately high traffic.
The high δ18O value for atmospheric NO3- across all sites suggests that the dual isotopic composition of NO3
-
could be a useful tracer for atmospheric N deposition. However, dissolved NO3- in streams did not reflect the
isotopic composition of atmospheric NO3. This was not surprising given the relatively small surface area of
headwater streams. Atmospheric deposition of nutrients is more likely indirectly accumulated in streams, following deposition to other surface before entering the streams through surface and subsurface runoff.
1USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 2Southern California Coastal Water Research Project, [email protected] 3Southern California Coastal Water Research Project, [email protected]
66
Contributions of Organic Nitrogen to the Gas Phase and Speciation of Amines in
Ambient Samples
Katherine Benedict1, Amy P. Sullivan
2 and Jeffrey L. Collett, Jr.
3
Atmospheric reactive nitrogen is a mixture of inorganic compounds like NOx, nitric acid,
ammonia, nitrate, and ammonia and organic compounds that contain nitrogen. There is
significant uncertainty in the contribution of organic nitrogen compounds to the
atmospheric reactive nitrogen budget and the deposition budget. Amines are a class of
compounds known to be present in both the gas and aerosol phase but measurements of
their abundance and speciation are limited. We have developed an ion chromatography
method using a Dionex CS19 column with conductivity detection which can speciate more
than 10 different amine compounds including the methyl and ethyl amines. A number of
amine compounds were detected in variety of ambient filter and denuder samples analyzed
and these results will be presented. The sampling efficiency of several amine compounds
will be determined. Additionally, recent papers by Matsumoto and Yamato describe a
method to determine the basic and acidic organic nitrogen contribution using a denuder
sampling technique. In this work, we test this method in the laboratory and with samples
collected in Rocky Mountain National Park. Results of laboratory testing examine
carryover between the sodium carbonate denuder used for nitric acid determination and
“acidic organic nitrogen” and the phosphorous acid coated denuder used for ammonia
determination and “basic organic nitrogen”. The contribution of “basic organic nitrogen”
and “acidic organic nitrogen” will be presented for select periods of sampling in Rocky
Mountain National Park.
1Colorado State University, [email protected] 2Colorado State University, [email protected] 3Colorado State University, [email protected]
67
TECHNICAL SESSION 8:
AMMONIA EMISSION, TRENDS, DEPOSITION
Session Chair: Katie Benedict,
Colorado State University
68
69
Investigation of Hourly Concentration Ratios of Ammonia Gas and Particulate
Ammonium at CASTNet Site in Beltsville, MD
Greg Beachley1, John T. Walker
2, Gary Lear
3 and Melissa Puchalski
4
The chemical composition of atmospheric nitrogen pollution has shifted from predominantly
oxidized nitrogenous species (particulate NO3- and gaseous NOx) to reduced inorganic nitrogen
(particulate NH4+and gaseous NH3) (Li et al., 2016, Du et al., 2014). Understanding the particle
formation chemistry and the transport of nonpoint source (i.e. fertilizer application, animal
operations) emissions is key in assessing NH3 bidirectional air-surface exchange, deposition, and
subsequent ecological impacts. Currently, national air monitoring networks are situated for
measuring integrated reduced nitrogen samples often collected for periods of a week or more.
These measurements are typically filter-based and can suffer from volatilization losses especially
for ammonium nitrate.
The EPA’s Clean Air Status and Trends Network (CASTNET) has operated co-located Monitor
for Aerosols and Gases (MARGA) online analyzers at Beltsville, MD for a long-term period
(spanning from July 2013 to July 2015 and including the Fall of 2016) in order to assess the
precision of the analyzers as well as the efficacy of co-located weekly integrated filter pack
measurements. The MARGAs hourly samples include both NH4+ and NH3 in addition to nitrate
(NO3-), sulfate (SO4
-2) and their acid gas precursors (HNO3 and SO2) and base cations (Ca+2, Na+,
Mg+2, K+). The MARGAs sampled approximately 13-months of valid data, capturing all seasons
at a site located in crop fields managed by USDA’s Agricultural Research Service. There is a
need to better understand hourly NH3:NH4+ chemistry and a need to better characterize long-term
measurements of these compounds that are deployed in national networks (CASTNET, NADP’s
AMoN, IMPROVE). This communication will explore daily and seasonal trends along with
analysis of episodic events of NH3 and NH4+ using the entire suite of MARGA measurements and
co-located meteorological measurements.
1US EPA, [email protected] 2US EPA, [email protected] 3US EPA, [email protected] 4US EPA, [email protected]
70
Urban and On-Road Emissions: Underappreciated Sources of Atmospheric
Ammonia
Mark Fenn1, Susan Schilling
2, Andrzej Bytnerowicz
3, Michael Bell
4, James
Sickman5, Ken Hanks
6 and Linda Geiser
7
As a result of over-reduction of nitrogen oxides, light and medium duty vehicles and newer heavy duty vehicles on U.S.
roadways emit significant levels of ammonia (NH3). Herein we provide updated spatial distribution and inventory data for
on-road NH3
emissions for the continental U.S. On-road NH3
emissions in urbanized regions are typically 0.1 – 1.3
t/km2/yr. By comparison, NH3 emissions in agricultural regions generally range from 0.4 – 5.5 t/km2/yr, with a few hotspots
as high as 6 – 11 t/km2/yr. We have identified 500 counties that receive at least 30% of the NH3
emissions from on-road
sources. Counties with higher vehicle NH3 emissions than from agriculture include 41% of the U.S. population. Within
CONUS the percent of wet inorganic N deposition from the NADP/NTN as NH4+ ranged from 37 to 83% with a mean of
59.5%. Only 13% of the NADP sites across the U.S. had less than 45% of the N deposition as NH4
+ based on data from
2014-2016, illustrating the near-universal occurrence of NH4+ deposition across the United States, regardless of the primary
sources of NH3
emissions.
In four urban sites in Oregon and Washington the NH4-N:NO
3-N ratio in throughfall averaged 1.0 (range of 0.8 – 1.3)
compared to an average ratio of 2.3 in bulk deposition (range of 1.8 – 2.9) measured in open canopy-free areas. In bulk
deposition at urban sites in the LA Basin deposition of NH4
-N and NO3-N were highly similar to each other. Ratios of NH
4-
N:NO3-N in throughfall under shrubs in the Los Angeles Air Basin ranged from 0.7 to 1.5 across a spatially extensive
network of chaparral and coastal sage scrub sites with high but varying degrees of urban influence. The NH4
-N:NO3
-N ratio
at ten sites in the Lake Tahoe Basin averaged 1.4 and 1.6 in bulk deposition and throughfall, respectively. The ratio in
throughfall at Valhalla, immediately adjacent to the city of South Lake Tahoe, was 1.9. Annual throughfall deposition and
bulk deposition of NH4-N was strongly correlated with summertime NH
3 concentrations in the Tahoe Basin. Values of
δ15NH4+ in bulk deposition and throughfall samples in the Tahoe Basin were predominantly within the range of -5.0 to -
0.9‰, indicative of tailpipe NH3
emissions. The relative importance of urban and on-road NH3 emissions versus emissions
from agriculture varies regionally. In some areas both are important and should be considered when evaluating the principal
sources of N deposition to affected ecosystems.
1USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 2USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 3USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 4National Park Service, Air Resources Division, [email protected] 5Environmental Sciences Department, University of California, Riverside, [email protected] 6USDA Forest Service, PSW Research Station, [email protected] 7USDA Forest Service, NFS-WO, Wildlife, Fish & Rare Plants, Planning, [email protected]
71
“Fingerprinting” Vehicle Derived Ammonia Utilizing Nitrogen Stable Isotopes
Wendell Walters1, Nadia Colombi
2 and Meredith Hastings
3
Ammonia (NH3) is the primary alkaline molecule in the atmosphere and plays a key role in
numerous atmospheric processes that have important implications for human health and climate
control. While agriculture activities dominate the global NH3 budget, there are large
uncertainties in the urban NH3emission inventories. The analysis of the nitrogen stable isotope
composition of NH3 (δ15N-NH3) might be a useful tool for partitioning NH3 emission sources, as
different emission sources tend to emit NH3 with distinctive δ15N signatures or “fingerprints”.
This novel tool may help improve upon urban emission inventories, which could help to improve
modeling of important atmospheric processes involving NH3. However, there is a current lack of
δ15N-NH3 measurements of potentially important urban NH3 emission sources, and many of the
reported NH3 collection methods have not been verified for their ability to accurately characterize δ15N-NH3.
Here we present a laboratory tested method to accurately measure δ15N-NH3 using honeycomb
denuders coated with a 2% citric acid solution. Based on laboratory tests, the NH3 collection
device has been optimized under a variety of conditions. Near quantitative NH3 collection is
found at a sampling rate of 10 SLPM for NH3 concentrations less than 2 ppmv, and δ15N-
NH3 precision is found to be approximately 1.0‰. This newly developed NH3 collection device
for isotopic characterization has been applied to improve our understanding of the δ15N-
NH3 signatures from vehicles. Preliminary results of NH3 collected near a road-side indicate an
average δ15N-NH3 of -2.1 ± 1.9‰. This work is ongoing, and plans are in place to collect
NH3 directly from tailpipes and from on-road air. Our preliminary results indicate that vehicle
derived NH3 has a distinctive δ15N signature compared to agricultural and waste emissions; thus,
δ15N(NH3) has the potential to be used to understand urban NH3 emission sources.
1Brown University, [email protected] 2University of California Los Angeles, [email protected] 3Brown University, [email protected]
72
73
POSTER SESSIONS
IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER BY AUTHOR
74
75
Measurement of Air-Surface Exchange of Speciated Nitrogen and Sulfur
Compounds in a Coastal Environment
Greg Beachley1, John T. Walker
2, Ian Rumsey
3, Mike Larsen
4, Joseph
Niehaus5 and Monica Mullis
6
Ecosystem exposure and vulnerability to atmospheric deposition of nitrogen and sulfur
compounds is assessed by the United States Environmental Protection Agency’s (U.S. EPA’s)
primary regulatory tool, the Community Multiscale Air Quality Model (CMAQ). Observational
datasets are required for the development of the dry deposition algorithms used in CMAQ. These
deposition datasets are influenced by local environmental conditions such as meteorology,
atmospheric chemistry, and surface conditions. There is a paucity of direct deposition datasets in
coastal environments, which often have different environmental conditions than inland locations.
This study builds on the previous work of Rumsey and Walker, 2016 to deploy the Monitor for
AeRosols and GAses (MARGA) to directly measure hourly fluxes of gases (NH3, HNO3, HNO2,
and SO2) and aerosols (NH4+, NO3
-, and SO42-) above a grassy field. The MARGA on-line ion-
chromatography analyzer was deployed in the same setup with two samplers at 4-m and 1-m to
directly measure concentration gradients over a grassy field in a coastal environment near
Charleston, South Carolina from mid-May through June 2017. The multi-species concentration
gradient measurements are used in conjunction with the micrometeorological aerodynamic
gradient method to determine air-surface exchange fluxes for each species to further characterize
dry nitrogen and sulfur deposition processes in a coastal environment and assess how they differ
from inland deposition processes. This communication highlights preliminary results for species
concentration gradients and meteorological data measured this summer.
1US EPA, [email protected] 2US EPA, [email protected] 3US EPA, [email protected] 4College of Charleston, [email protected] 5College of Charleston, [email protected] 6College of Charleston, [email protected]
76
Measuring Low-Level Concentrations of Trace Metals in Wet Deposition
Samples
Katie Blaydes1 and Lee Green2
Trace metals are released into the environment via natural and anthropogenic processes. Metals
such as Al, Mn, Fe, Cr, Ca2+ and K+ are indicative of soil contribution. The Earth’s crust is
enriched with many of these elements and Aeolian dusts can efficiently transport some crustal
elements and heavy metals. Non-crustal volatile metals, such as Cd, Zn, and Pb are characteristic
of fuel combustion and metal smelting. The Central Analytical Laboratory (CAL) has come up
with a method to measure low level concentrations in wet deposition samples via Inductively
Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES).
1Central Analytical Laboratory, [email protected] 2Central Analytical Laboratory, [email protected]
77
First Diagnosis of Allergenic Airborne Pollen and its Interaction with Atmospheric
Pollutants in the Mexico City Metropolitan Zone (MCMZ) and their Transport
and Dispersion in the Atmosphere
Ma Carmen Calderon E.1 , Rodolfo Sosa E
2, Benjamin Martínez l.
3, Cesar
Guerrero4, Juan Alcivar
5, Fernando Téllez U
6, Invonn Santiago L.
7, Ma Luisa
Alarcon J.8, Ma Carmen Torres B.
9, Pablo Sánchez A.
10 and Mónica Jaimes P.
11
Air pollution is one of the main characteristics of areas where human population density is very high; It plays
an important role in the health of the entire population. In addition to the atmospheric pollutants (gases and
particles) emitted by human activities, the atmosphere is the transport medium for a wide variety of biogenic particles. These include bioaerosols such as viruses, bacteria, fungi, plant fragments, pollen grains, their
allergenic proteins or small airborne particles containing pollen allergens.
Atmospheric pollutants have direct effects on pollen, modifying their biological and reproductive functions, causing a decrease in viability and germination; alteration of the physicochemical characteristics of the pollen
surface and its allergenic potential and adjuvant effect, increasing the potential risks to health. It has been
reported that pollutants such as O3, NO2, SO2 and atmospheric deposition (wet and dry) interact with allergenic pollen in the atmosphere aggravating asthma symptoms and particulate matter together with pollen
allergens play a very important role in increasing the allergic inflammatory response. Therefore, the
objective of this work was to perform a first diagnosis of airborne allergenic pollen from MCMZ, its interaction with atmospheric pollutants and their transport and dispersion in the atmosphere. Sampling of air
pollen grains was carried out at four city stations belonging to the Mexican Aerobiology Network (REMA)
during the period 2014 to 2016. Records of atmospheric pollutants and meteorological conditions, including wind fields, were analyzed for the same study period. The first spatial-temporal interpretation (diurnal and
seasonal cycle) was performed among all variables evaluated, their transportation through the atmosphere of
Mexico City and the risk to the health of the population were determined.
In this study, spatial and temporal variations in the air quality (RAMA Network) and chemical composition of
rain (REDA Network) in Mexico City between 2014 to 2016 were analyzed. Major ions (Na+, NH4+, K+,
Mg2+, Ca2+, SO42-, NO3
- and Cl-), pH, and electrical conductivity (EC) were analyzed weekly at 4 sampling stations located in the same region MCMZ.
Spatial distribution of wet atmospheric deposition shows that pH decreases throughout the study from north
to south in the MCMZ. In the stations located in a rural area, a strong correlation was found between NH4
+ and SO42-, NO3
-, and Cl-;
this is likely due to their origin in soil (i.e., fertilizer use).
The same concentration trend was observed for SO42- and NO3 in the MCMZ stations; this indicates that the
sources of acid rain precursors are upwind (i.e., to the north) of the study area.
Considering that external emission sources play a decisive role in driving acid rain within the MCMZ, it is
necessary to establish strategies for the emission reductions of acid rain precursors from upwind sources outside the MCMZ.
This shows the need to continue multidisciplinary studies as well as to expand the interaction among the
different available networks: REMA, REDA and RAMA 1Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), [email protected] 2UNAM, [email protected] 3UNAM, [email protected] 4UNAM, [email protected] 5UNAM, [email protected] 6UNAM, [email protected] 7UNAM, [email protected] 8UNAM, [email protected] 9UNAM, [email protected] 10UNAM, [email protected] 11UNAM, [email protected]
78
Live Demo: Critical Loads Mapper Tool
Christopher Clark1, Amy Ramsdell2, Jen Phelan3, Jason Lynch4, Claire O'Dea5,
Anita Rose6, Bill Jackson7, Tamara Blett8 and Mike Bell9
The Critical Loads Mapper Tool is a EPA-USFS-NPS collaborative effort to enable decision
makers, researchers, and the public to easily access information on atmospheric deposition of
nitrogen and sulfur, critical loads, and their exceedances to better understand local and regional
vulnerability to atmospheric pollution. This interactive mapping tool displays nitrogen and sulfur
deposition levels through time for several air quality models, critical load levels for terrestrial and
aquatic ecosystems in the National Critical Loads Database, and the exceedance of deposition over the critical loads as an estimate of vulnerability to air pollution.
1EPA, [email protected] 2Blue Raster LLC, [email protected] 3RTI, [email protected] 4EPA, [email protected] 5USFS, [email protected] 6USFS, [email protected] 7USFS, [email protected] 8NPS, [email protected] 9NPS, [email protected]
79
The Geospatial Monitoring of Air Pollution (GMAP) and its Role in Addressing
Critical Scientific Knowledge Gaps in Air Quality and Source Emissions
Justin Coughlin1, Marta Fuoco
2 and Scott Hamilton
3
The U.S. EPA Geospatial Mapping of Air Pollution (GMAP) project has been utilized to
determine stationary sources’ influence on surrounding air quality. The mobile GMAP platform
allows for air quality monitoring at ~1 sec resolution coupled with mobile 2D anemometer
measurements (vehicle speed corrected) and real-time GPS coordinates. Additionally, stationary
measurements are able to be conducted to determine source apportionment influences on monitor
readings. Currently, the GMAP system is equipped with a cavity ring-down spectroscopy
(CRDS) that is able to measure hydrogen sulfide (H2S) and methane (CH4) and a multi-pass UV
optical spectrometer that can measure benzene-toluene-ethylbenzene-xylene (BTEX), sulfur
dioxide (SO2), oxides of nitrogen (NOx), ozone (O3), formaldehyde, and styrene. During
stationary measurements, a 3D anemometer is also attached to provide 3D wind measurements
used to determine emissions flux estimates from ground level emission sources.
The GMAP platform has primarily been utilized to assess air quality impacts near facilities such
as landfills, wastewater treatment centers, oil and gas processes, and paper mills. With the
importance of ammonia (NH3) as a precursor in particulate matter (PM) formation and the
growing regulatory interest of decreasing NH3 emissions to limit PM pollution in the U.S., the
mobile geospatial measurement systems may be useful in both quantifying emission rates and
assessing plume size and variability, helping to fulfill critical knowledge gaps of NH3 emissions
and their role in regional PM concentrations. CRDS instruments are able to measure air
pollutants at a high degree of accuracy and precision with a relatively low residence time. NH3-
measuring instrumentation is being explored as a possible addition to the GMAP system.
1US EPA Region 5, [email protected] 2US EPA Region 5, [email protected] 3US EPA Region 5, [email protected]
80
Wet and Dry Deposition of Excess Chloride near a Hardrock Salt Mine
Jeremy Deitrich, Tom Butler*, Francoise Vermeylen and John Dennis
A preliminary study was undertaken to assess both wet and dry deposition of chloride in the vicinity of an
active salt mine in Lansing, NY. Multi-day sampling of 3 wet events and 3 dry events were undertaken using
triplicate NADP sampling buckets over a 5 station transect from 244 m to 600 m from the salt pile storage facilities at the mine. A 6th, control site was located 4100 m from the salt piles. Overall wet and dry
deposition rates were estimated for each site using a random effects model. Similar analyses were performed
on the conductivity of the wet samples, and dry samples with a standard addition of deionized water added to the dry sample buckets after collection. The transect was arranged north of the mine and deployments were
attempted when forecasts predicted that the transect area was going to be downwind of the mine, at least
some of the time. Summary results show the control site having an average daily wet deposition of 3.2 ±22.3 (s.e.) mg Cl-/m2
and a daily dry deposition of 3.1 ±22.5 mg Cl-/m2. Stations 1 through 4, located 250 to 550 m from the salt
piles, show a 40 to 75-fold increase in wet deposition and a 19 to 41-fold increase in the mean daily dry Cl- deposition, compared to the control site.
Combining wet + dry deposition on an annual basis, Cl- deposition was 25 to 48 times greater than the
control site for stations #1 through #4. Annual NaCl total deposition in kilograms per hectare were: Station #1, 904; #2, 837; #3, 725; #4, 470; and #5, 342, with a standard error of ~ ±20%. Our control location yields
an annual deposition rate of only 19 kg NaCl/ha. There is an excess of NaCl deposition of 61 metric tons/yr
for the 235 hectare area within a 500 m radius of the salt piles. Within a 1 km radius of the salt piles, the
excess NaCl deposition is 99 metric tons per year. These data suggest substantial excess chloride deposition
to the surrounding landscape, especially within ½ km of the salt piles. Visible damage to local vegetation and excess corrosion of metal nearby most likely from excess salt deposition, corroborates these findings.
*Corresponding author: [email protected], 607 351 9926, 211 Rice Hall, Ithaca, NY 14853
81
Acidification and Climate Drive Increased Dissolved Organic Carbon in High
Elevation Lakes
Amanda Gavin1, Sarah J. Nelson
2, Amanda J. Klemmer
3, Ivan J. Fernandez
4,
Kristin E. Strock5 and William H. McDowell
6
Increasing concentrations of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) in the northeastern US have been
attributed to two potential mechanisms: recovery from acidification and changing climate. Due
to geology and landscape setting, Maine’s high elevation lakes (>600m) provide unique insight
into the response of surface water chemistry to declining acidic deposition and interannual
climate variability. Long-term geochemical response in 29 lakes was analyzed during 30 years of
change in sulfate (SO42-) deposition and climate. All 29 lakes exhibited positive trends in DOC
from 1986-2015, and 19 of 29 (65%) lakes had statistically significant increases in DOC
throughout the study period. These results illustrate a region-wide change from low DOC lakes
(<5 mg/L) to moderate DOC lakes (5-30 mg/L). Increasing DOC trends were more consistent
across high elevation lakes than in previous studies from lower elevation lakes in the northeastern
US. Net increases in DOC concentrations were correlated with net decreases in SO42-, and a
direct comparison of high elevation and low elevation lakes in Maine revealed greater extent of
acidification and larger increases in DOC concentrations in high elevation lakes. A linear mixed
effects models demonstrated that SO42- and climate variables describe most of variability in
DOC concentrations (r2 = .78). The strongest predictor of DOC concentration was an inverse
relationship with SO42- (p < 0.0001). Coefficient of variation (CV) of DOC in all lakes was
negatively correlated with air temperature, suggesting a homogenous DOC response to increasing
temperature. Due to SO42- concentrations trending towards pre-acidification levels and
projections of a warmer, wetter, and more variable climate, there is uncertainty for the future
trajectory of DOC trends in surface waters. Given the importance of DOC to lake
biogeochemistry, long-term monitoring of Maine’s high elevation lakes is increasingly important
to understand both recovery and response in surface water chemistry to a changing chemical and
physical environment in the decades ahead.
1University of Maine, [email protected] 2University of Maine Ecology and Environmental Sciences, [email protected] 3University of Maine Ecology and Environmental Sciences, [email protected] 4University of Maine School of Forest Resources, [email protected] 5Dickinson College Environmental Science Department, [email protected] 6University of New Hampshire Department of Natural Resources and the Environment,
82
Selecting Critical Loads of Atmospheric Deposition when the Response is
Continuous: A Case Study of Risk Assessment to Lichens
Linda Geiser1, Heather Root
2, and Peter Nelson
3
Empirical responses of terrestrial and aquatic organisms to the deposition of acidifying and
eutrophying air pollutants are often continuous. Whether the response metric be community
composition, growth rate, seedling survival, or something else, the absence of a discontinuity
signaling an obvious exceedance of a biological response threshold can make critical load
selection annoyingly subjective. How, by gum, does one evaluate harm—is even the smallest
measurable amount of change harmful? Here we share some ideas for assessing risk associated
with depositional loadings of 1.5, 2, 2.5, and 3 kg S and N ha-1 yr-1 to five lichen community
indices: sites scores calculated as the abundance weighted mean sensitivity of species present;
total species richness; forage lichen richness; cyanolichen richness; and sensitive species
richness. We use national-scale data to show how risk assessments can help managers select a
geographical-, climate-relevant critical load and explain the potential harm associated with its
exceedance.
1USDA Forest Service, Washington, DC 2Weber State University, Ogden, UT 3University of Maine, Ft. Kent, ME
83
A Pilot Study of the Radiello Passive Ammonia Samplers at Three Canadian
(CAPMoN) Sites with Comparisons to Continuous Measurements and Satellite
Retrievals
Edward Hare1, Robert Vet
2, Jason O'Brien
3, Richard Tanabe
4, Mark Shephard
5,
Shailesh Kharol6 and Christopher M.B. Lehmann
7
The Canadian Air and Precipitation Monitoring Network (CAPMoN) has increased its efforts in
monitoring of ammonia by establishing three sites in central and eastern Canada to test the
effectiveness of the AMoN Radiello passive ammonia samplers for potential inclusion into the
mainstream CAPMoN suite of measurements. Three evaluation sites, Kejimkujik, Nova Scotia
and two Ontario sites at Bonner Lake and Longwoods all began sampling in October 2013. The
data presented in this poster examines the annual cycles, the application of a temperature
adjustment to account for the extended temperature range of measurements and also establishing
a method detection limit (MDL). In addition, some of the challenges encountered with the
application of travel and lab blanks to the data records will also be examined and presented. In
March 2017 the two Ontario sites were moved to Saskatchewan (Flat Valley and Pinehouse
Lake) where the Radiello samplers are collocated with continuous ammonia monitoring
instruments. This move was facilitated to extend the study by adding the comparison of these bi-
weekly aggregate values to the continuous measurements using a modified Thermo 42i-TL
instrument and a Picarro G2103. The two week integrated values from the Radiello are
compared with an equivalent bi-weekly integrated record from the continuous measurements. In
turn, these records are compared to Cross-track Infrared Sounder (CrIS) satellite ammonia
retrievals both as the integrated values and as discrete point-to-point comparisons during each
satellite overpass. Preliminary results will be presented.
1Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), [email protected] 2Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), [email protected] 3Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), jason.o'[email protected] 4Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), [email protected] 5Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), [email protected] 6Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), [email protected] 7Univ. Illinois, Prairie Research Institute, ISWS, [email protected]
84
Glyphosate: Understanding its Atmospheric Transport and Fate
Christopher Lehmann1, David A. Gay
2, John W. Scott
3 and Wei Zheng
4
Glyphosate is a widely used agricultural chemical in the United States. It's an environmental
contaminant of concern as a suspected carcinogen, although an evaluation of its health effects is
ongoing. There is a need to better understand its transport and fate in the environment,
particularly in sensitive ecosystems. Glyphosate is non-volatile and sorbs to soil particles.
Studies have detected it in air and rainwater samples, suggesting that its transport and fate in the
atmosphere is linked to airborne particulate matter. The Illinois State Water Survey (ISWS) and
the Illinois Sustainable Technology Center (ISTC) have performed limited studies to assess the
transport of glyphosate in the atmosphere.
The National Atmospheric Deposition Program (NADP) within ISWS collects rainwater and
snowmelt samples at more than 300 locations across North America. Preliminary work performed
at ISTC has demonstrated that glyphosate and several of its environmental decomposition
products can be readily measured by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LCMS)
down to 60 ng/L.
1NADP/CAL; University of Illinois, [email protected] 2NADP; University of Illinois, [email protected] 3Prairie Research Institute; Univ. Illinois, [email protected] 4Prairie Research Institute; Univ. Illinois, [email protected]
85
Evaluation of Ammonia Air-Surface Exchange at the Field Scale: Improvement of
Soil and Stomatal Emission Potential Parameterizations
Nebila Lichiheb1, LaToya Myles
2, Erwan Personne
3, Mark Heuer
4 and Michael
Buban5
Intensive agriculture typically uses nitrogen-based fertilizers to increase yields for sustaining a
growing human population. Agriculture is the main source of atmospheric emissions of ammonia
(NH3), a precursor to particulate matter in the atmosphere. The impact of NH3 emissions on air
quality is of concern in the U.S. due to adverse effects on human health, and terrestrial and
aquatic ecosystems. With reductions in nitrogen oxide emissions due to legislation
implementation, the importance to NH3 for particulate matter formation and atmospheric
deposition of reactive nitrogen has increased. Emissions of NH3 from fertilized cropland occur as
soon as fertilizer is applied on the farmed surface and emission can last from a few days to
several weeks, depending on the properties of the specific fertilizer, plant properties,
pedoclimatic conditions, environmental conditions, and agricultural practices. The complex
interactions between agronomic and environmental conditions make necessary the use of
modeling to study the NH3 volatilization.
In this study, we implemented in the SURFATM-NH3 model, which simulates the bi-directional
exchanges of NH3 between the biogenic surface and the atmosphere, a new parameterization of
the stomatal and ground layer emission potentials (Γs and Γg). This operational parameterization
enables a dynamic modelling of Γs and Γg by taking into account the N status of the plant which
includes the N input and the atmospheric N deposition.
This new parameterization was evaluated with a dataset comprising NH3 fluxes measured using
the flux-gradient (FG) and relaxed eddy accumulation (REA) methods in a corn canopy fertilized
with UAN and urease inhibitor NBPT over a period of approximately 3 months at the Energy
Farm at the University of Illinois at Urbana‐Champaign, IL, USA. The results showed that the
SURFATM- NH3 model satisfactorily simulates the NH3 fluxes by implementing the
parameterization of Γs and Γg and by taking into account the effect of the urease inhibitor. The
latter need to be more closely examined because it had a considerable effect on the rate and
extent of NH3volatilization.
1NOAA/ATDD, [email protected] 2NOAA/ATDD, [email protected] 3INRA-AgroParisTech, [email protected] 4NOAA/ATDD/ORAU, [email protected] 5NOAA/ATDD/ORAU, [email protected]
86
N Deposition Effects on Hermes Copper Butterfly (Lycaena hermes) Habitat in
Southern California
Liberty Malter1, George Vourlitis
2, Alison Anderson
3 and Tracey Brown
4
Atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition has become a global concern over the past few decades as
population sizes have increased. San Diego County, CA, USA, with a high population density,
Mediterranean-type climate, and high biodiversity, is an ideal site for an extensive N deposition
study. Chronic anthropogenic N deposition is one of the main contributing factors to affect plant
species diversity (Vourlitis and Pasquini 2009) and invasive species encroachment (Minnich and
Dezzani 1998). It is also the location of the rare endemic Hermes copper butterfly (Lycaena
hermes), which has received minimal research and remains a mystery to many ecologists. We
hypothesized that N deposition will impact Hermes abundance; however, there is limited research
on the effects of N deposition on butterfly habitat. Thus, this study aims to determine the effect of
increased N on the alterations to plant-insect interactions. These effects are being measured at
five sites throughout San Diego County in current or historical Hermes copper habitat. N
deposition collectors have been placed under the canopy of spiny redberry shrubs (Rhamnus
crocea) to accumulate N throughfall at each site. Soil and redberry stem fragments are being used
to analyze total N and Carbon (C), water potential, and shrub growth throughout the course of
this study. Despite the preliminary nature of our results, we show a number of trends between
data groups, such as large differences in soil and tissue N and C between the study sites,
suggesting differences in atmospheric N inputs. These variations in soil N availability lead to
variations in leaf tissue chemistry, which can ultimately impact the performance of the Hermes
copper larvae. Our current data demonstrate some clear trends, but whether these trends remain
consistent and interpretable remains to be seen. We anticipate this research will increase our
understanding of spatial variation patterns of N deposition in southern California and how that N
input might affect the rare Hermes copper butterfly and its host plant, Rhamnus crocea.
Furthermore, these data are important because they might help us understand why Hermes is in
decline and which sites should be prioritized for management.
1California State University San Marcos, [email protected] 2California State University San Marcos, [email protected] 3United States Fish and Wildlife Service, [email protected] 4California State University San Marcos, [email protected]
87
Evaluating Variation in Sources of Atmospheric Nitrogen Deposition in the Rocky
Mountains using d15
N−NO3− and d
15N−NH4
+
Leora Nanus1, Christopher M.B. Lehmann
2 and M. Alisa Mast
3
Spatial and temporal variation in sources of nitrogen (N) deposition to high-elevation ecosystems
in the Rocky Mountains were evaluated using N isotope data for water years 1995-2016. This
unique dataset links N in wet deposition and snowpack to emissions sources, and improves
understanding of the impacts of anthropogenic activities and environmental policies that mitigate
effects of accelerated N cycling. d15N−NO3− at 50 US Geological Survey Rocky Mountain
Snowpack sites ranged from −3.3 ‰ to +6.5 ‰, with a mean value of +1.4 ‰. At 15 National
Atmospheric Deposition Program (NADP)/National Trends Network wet deposition sites,
summer d15N−NO3− is significantly lower ranging from −7.6 ‰ to −1.3 ‰ while winter
d15N−NO3− ranges from −2.6 ‰ to +5.5 ‰, with a mean value of +0.7 ‰ during the cool season.
Winter NADP wet deposition d15N−NO3− is lower than snowpack, possibly due to the influence
of dry deposition in the snowpack. Spatial trends in wet deposition are similar to Snowpack, with
higher NO3− concentrations and d15N−NO3
− in the Southern Rockies located near larger
anthropogenic N emission sources compared to the Northern Rockies. Wet deposition
d15N−NH4+ ranged from −10 ‰ to 0 ‰, with no observed spatial pattern. However, the lowest
d15N−NH4+(−9 ‰), and the highest NH4
+ concentration (35 meq/L) were observed at a Utah site
dominated by local agricultural activities, whereas the higher d15N−NH4+ observed in Colorado
and Wyoming are likely due to mixed sources, including fossil fuel combustion. These
findings show spatial and seasonal variation in N isotope data that reflect differences in sources
of anthropogenic N deposition to high-elevation ecosystems and have important implications for
environmental policy.
1San Francisco State University, [email protected] 2NADP, Illinois State Water Survey, [email protected] 3US Geological Survey, [email protected]
88
An Air Quality Portal to Support the Use of Critical Loads of Atmospheric
Deposition in National Forest and Grassland Planning
Claire O’Dea1, Linda Geiser
2, Rich Pouyat
3, Anita Rose
4, and Linda Pardo
5
Forest Plans provide the basis for management decisions made on national forests and grasslands
of the United States. The USDA Forest Service 2012 Planning Rule requires national forest and
grassland managers to consider air quality when developing plan components and to treat air
resources similar to soil and water resources. This provides a unique opportunity to standardize
the way national forests view and manage air quality as a forest resource. By creating an easy-to-
use resource to guide managers in considering and treating air quality, we can ensure a nationally
consistent methodology which incorporates the best available science and data and eases the
burden on the managers. The Air Quality Portal ensures that managers understand the concept of
critical loads of air pollution, allowing for appropriate incorporation of critical loads/exposures
and target loads/exposures into Forest Plan revisions to meet the intent of the 2012 Planning
Rule. The Portal hosts the following documents:
Decision tree guiding a nationally standardized air quality assessment process to
determine exceedances of critical loads of air pollution
Decision trees guiding monitoring and management decisions based on the results of
the air quality assessment
Detailed protocols/instructions for following assessment process
Spatial data available for download (and/or potentially for web viewing)
Sample specialist report(s)
Briefing papers and other communications tools
Training tools
The Air Quality Portal, accessible from https://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/airqualityportal/, will be
demonstrated live by US Forest Service staff during the poster session of the NADP meeting.
1USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 2USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 3USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 4USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 5USDA Forest Service, [email protected]
89
HANDS-ON CRITICAL LOADS TOOL DEMO: N-CLAS
Effects of Climate, Site and Soil Characteristics on Critical Loads and Exceedance
in Forests in the Northeastern U.S.
Linda Pardo1, Jason A. Coombs
2, Molly Robin-Abbott
3, Jennifer Pontius
4 and
Claire B. O’Dea5
Assessing the impacts of the multiple threats impacting ecosystem health and sustainability over
the long term, in particular climate change and nitrogen (N) deposition, remains a critical
challenge for resources managers and policy makers. To facilitate such assessments, we
developed a GIS-based tool, Nitrogen Critical Loads Assessment by Site (N-CLAS), which
calculates critical loads and exceedances for N deposition to forests in the northeastern US. It
provides high resolution outputs (maps, graphs, and tables) for multiple areas and accounts for
the influence of site, climate, and topographic conditions on 23 key tree species in the region. N-
CLAS evaluates the impact of multiple stressors (N deposition and climate change)
simultaneously for species of management concern on forest lands in the Northeast and Upper
Midwest. In addition to calculating species-specific critical loads, N-CLAS is designed to take
into account the impact of site abiotic factors on the response of trees to N deposition. The
abiotic modifying factors include, precipitation, temperature (e.g., January T, July T, May-
September T), and soil characteristics. This tool is designed N-CLAS facilitates assessment of
risk to forest ecosystems for resource managers and policy makers.
In this hands-on demo session, we will demonstrate how to use the tool, the types of outputs it
produces, and the ways that it can be utilized to assess extent and magnitude of risk to forest ecosystems and to evaluate the susceptibility of individual tree species.
1USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 2USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 3USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 4UVM/USDA Forest Service, [email protected] 5USDA Forest Service, [email protected]
90
Effects of Climate, Site and Soil Characteristics on Critical Loads and Exceedance
in Forests in the Northeastern U.S.
Linda Pardo1, Molly Robin-Abbott
2, Claire O'Dea
3, Jennifer Pontius
4 and Jason
Coombs5
Assessing the impacts of the multiple threats impacting ecosystem health and sustainability over
the long term, in particular climate change and nitrogen (N) deposition, remains a critical
challenge for resources managers and policy makers. To facilitate such assessments, we used a
GIS-based tool, Nitrogen Critical Loads Assessment by Site (N-CLAS), to evaluate the impact of
multiple stressors (N deposition and climate change) simultaneously for species of management
concern on forest lands in the Northeast and Upper Midwest. In addition to calculating species-
specific critical loads, N-CLAS is designed to take into account the impact of site abiotic factors
on the response of trees to N deposition. The abiotic modifying factors include, precipitation,
temperature (e.g., January T, July T, May-September T), and soil characteristics. We conducted
our analysis for the full region and at the Ecoregion levels 2 and 3. Application of N-CLAS
across the northeastern U.S. allows us to evaluate which areas and tree species are most
susceptible to impacts from N deposition. In this analysis, we determined the critical load and
exceedance for individual tree species and all the species present. We also evaluated the extent
and magnitude of the CL exceedance and how that would change under future deposition
scenarios. N-CLAS facilitates analysis of the extent of the area impacted by N deposition which
provides resource managers with a simple way to incorporate the current state-of-the-science
knowledge into their planning and management decisions.
1US Forest Service, [email protected] 2US Forest Service, [email protected] 3US Forest Service, [email protected] 4UVM/US Forest Service, [email protected] 5US Forest Service, [email protected]
91
Atmospheric Elemental Carbon Deposition to Oak Trees and Litterfall Flux to
Soil in an Urban Area
Jenna Rindy1, Alexandra G. Ponette-González
2, Tate E. Barrett
3 and Brett W.
Luce4
Elemental Carbon (EC), a product of incomplete combustion of fossil fuels and biomass,
contributes to climate warming and poor air quality. In urban areas, diesel fuel trucks are the
main source of EC emissions from mobile sources. After emission, EC is deposited to receptor
surfaces via two main pathways: precipitation (wet deposition) and directly as particles (dry
deposition). Urban trees may play an important role in removing EC from the atmosphere by
intercepting and delivering it directly to the soil. The goal of this research is to quantify the
magnitude of EC retention on leaf surfaces (leaf EC) and EC fluxes to soil via leaf litterfall in the
City of Denton, Texas. Denton is a rapidly growing urban area north of the Dallas-Fort Worth
metropolitan Area. We are using a foliar extraction technique to determine EC retention on leaf
surfaces. Foliar samples are being collected monthly, from April to November, from co-
located Quercus stellata (post oak, n = 10) and Quercus virginiana (live oak, n = 10) trees.
Samples are rinsed with water and chloroform in a two-step process to determine surface-
deposited EC and EC retained in leaf waxes. A Sunset EC/OC carbon analyzer will be utilized to
analyze EC content of extracts filtered onto quartz-fiber filters. For one year, leaf litter is being
collected bi-weekly under 35 trees (20 post oak, 15 live oak), and oven dried to determine dry
weight. EC retained by tree canopies will be calculated by multiplying leaf EC by canopy leaf
area index, while EC flux to soil will be estimated by multiplying in-wax EC by leaf litterfall
mass. Here, preliminary results of EC retention on leaf surfaces, as well as EC flux to soil for
spring and summer 2017 are presented. Results of this study will assess urban tree’s ability to
filter air pollution and mitigate climate change.
1University of North Texas, [email protected] 2University of North Texas, [email protected] 3University of North Texas, [email protected] 4University of North Texas, [email protected]
92
CASTNET Ozone Monitoring Program
Christopher Rogers1, Timothy Sharac
2, Melissa Puchalski
3, Marcus Stewart
4,
Kevin Mishoe5 and Kemp Howell
6
The Clean Air Status and Trends Network (CASTNET) is a long-term monitoring network
designed to measure acidic pollutants and ambient ozone (O3) concentrations in rural areas in the
United States and Canada. CASTNET is managed collaboratively by the Environmental
Protection Agency – Clean Air Markets Division (EPA), the National Park Service – Air
Resources Division (NPS), and the Bureau of Land Management – Wyoming State Office (BLM-
WSO). In addition to EPA, NPS, and BLM-WSO, numerous other participants provide site
operator support and grant land access including North American tribes, other federal agencies,
States, private land owners, and universities.
Eighty-two CASTNET sites report hourly O3 concentrations. The data provide accountability for
EPA’s regional Nox emission reduction programs (i.e. Nox SIP Call, Cross State Air Pollution
Rule, and Cross State Air Pollution Rule Update) and exposure effects on vegetation. The
National Park Service uses CASTNET O3 data to develop strategies for improving visibility and
protecting resources within park boundaries. Additionally, eighty of the O3 monitors at
CASTNET sites meet the requirements of Title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part
58 and are used to determine compliance with the O3National Ambient Air Quality Standard
(NAAQS). Populations located in areas that exceed the primary NAAQS are more susceptible to
adverse health effects. CASTNET provides a unique dataset to rural populations where state-
operated O3 monitors are not required.
Each CASTNET monitor measures ambient O3 concentrations for the entire year. CASTNET
O3 data are submitted to the AIRNow Tech website for near-real time reporting
(www.airnowtech.org) and to EPA’s Air Quality System (AQS) database
(https://aqs.epa.gov/aqs). Annual performance evaluations (PE) and results from the National
Performance Audit Program (NPAP) are also submitted to AQS routinely.
Preliminary 2014-2016 3-year average of the fourth highest daily maximum rolling 8-hour
averages calculated using the 2015 ozone NAAQS indicate that four CASTNET sites exceed the
70 ppb O3 NAAQS including Joshua Tree National Park, CA; Sequoia National Park, CA;
Yosemite National Park, CA; and Washington Crossing, NJ.
Ozone data and additional information about the CASTNET monitoring program can be found on
the CASTNET webpage at https://www.epa.gov/castnet.
1Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 2USEPA, [email protected] 3USEPA, [email protected] 4Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 5Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 6Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected]
93
Characterization of Reduced Nitrogen at IMPROVE and CSN Monitoring Sites in
the Southeastern United States
Christopher Rogers1, John Walker
2, Rich Scheffe
3, Kevin Mishoe
4, Doris Chen
5,
Katherine Barry6, Melissa Puchalski
7, Bret Schichtel
8 and Joann Rice
9
The Interagency Monitoring of Protected Visual Environments (IMPROVE) and Chemical
Speciation (CSN) networks have provided two decades of routine particulate matter (PM)
speciation data that support regional haze and PM NAAQS programs. As shown by the NADP
wet deposition record over the same period, the chemical composition of the ambient atmosphere
has changed markedly from one dominated by nitrate, sulfate, and carbonaceous aerosols, and
their associated precursor gases to an atmospheric mixture that includes a significant amount of
reduced inorganic nitrogen – particulate ammonium (NH4+) and its precursor gas, ammonia
(NH3). The magnitude of this change is reflected by a nationwide shift in the atmospheric
composition from one dominated by inorganic oxidized compounds, to one where reduced
inorganic nitrogen species (NHx = NH3 + NH4+) now have similar or greater contributions to the
total nitrogen budget.
To address this change, it becomes necessary to characterize reduced nitrogen emission sources
and atmospheric composition. Previous studies conducted primarily in the western United States
have examined the possibility of using acid-impregnated filters in the IMPROVE system to
measure NHx. Results were considered successful leading to a current study using acid-
impregnated filters in both the IMPROVE and CSN systems to conduct similar measurements in the southeastern United States.
The study is occurring from late May through late November 2017 at Duke Forest, NC (near
Research Triangle Park) and Gainesville, FL. Both sites are running CSN, IMPROVE, and URG
annular denuder systems as the reference method to measure NHx. In addition, both sites include
NH4+ and NH3 measurements from the CASTNET filter pack and NADP/AMoN, respectively.
The Duke Forest site also has a Monitor for Aerosols and Gases in Ambient Air (MARGA)
collecting hourly measurements of NH3 and NH4+. Here, results from the Duke Forest and
Gainesville sites are compared to determine the feasibility of adding an acid-impregnated filter to capture NHx at a subset of the IMPROVE and CSN long-term measurement stations.
1Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 2USEPA, Office of Research and Development, [email protected] 3USEPA, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, [email protected] 4Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 5USEPA, Office of Research and Development, [email protected] 6Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 7USEPA, Clean Air Markets Division, [email protected] 8NPS, Cooperative Institute for Research in the Atmosphere, Colorado State University,
[email protected] 9USEPA, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, [email protected]
94
The Atmospheric Chemistry and Canopy Exchange Simulation System
for Ammonia (ACCESS-NH3): Formulation and Application to a Corn
Canopy
Rick Saylor1, LaToya Myles
2, Nebila Lichiheb
3, Mark Heuer
4, Andrew
Nelson5, Sotiria Koloutsou-Vakakis
6and Mark Rood
7
As nitrogen oxide and sulfur dioxide emissions decrease in the U. S. as a result of implemented
air quality regulations, agricultural emissions of ammonia (NH3) are being recognized as playing
an increasingly important role in fine particle (PM2.5) formation. If regulations on agricultural
emissions are implemented in the future, it will be necessary to have reliable models of NH3 bi-
directional exchange over a variety of crop types to help formulate effective control or mitigation
strategies. The Atmospheric Chemistry and Canopy Exchange Simulation System for Ammonia
(ACCESS-NH3) is a multilayer, single column model that simulates the bi-directional transport
and exchange of ammonia throughout the soil-plant-atmosphere continuum. In this presentation,
the ACCESS-NH3 modeling system is described and results from its application to a corn (Zea
mays) canopy are presented. NH3 concentration and flux measurements, along with
micrometeorological and environmental observations, were made within and above a Zea mays
canopy at the University of Illinois Energy Biosciences Institute Energy Farm in Urbana, IL,
during the entire growing season of 2014. ACCESS-NH3 has been applied to the data obtained
during this field experiment to evaluate the model and to assess how NH3 interacts with the Zea
mays canopy and how these interactions vary over the growing season and as a function of environmental conditions. Results from the evaluations and simulations will be presented.
1NOAA/ARL/ATDD, [email protected] 2NOAA/ARL/ATDD, [email protected] 3ORAU, [email protected] 4NOAA/ARL/ATDD, [email protected] 5University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, [email protected] 6University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, [email protected] 7University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, [email protected]
95
Long-term Trends in Atmospheric Sulfur and Nitrogen Species across the United
States: 30 years of Clean Air Status Network (CASTNET) Operations
David Schmeltz1, Melissa Puchalski
2, Gary Lear
3, Greg Beachley
4, Kemp Howell
5,
Taylor Macy6, Chris Rogers
7, Tim Sharac
8 and Marcus Stewart
9
The Clean Air Status and Trends Network (CASTNET) and the National Atmospheric
Deposition Program (NADP) offer a robust capability to investigate long-term trends in
atmospheric concentrations and deposition of sulfur and nitrogen species in rural areas of the
U.S. The U.S. EPA, National Park Service, and the Bureau of Land Management (Wyoming
State Office) manage the CASTNET program and network operations at 90+ sites located
throughout the contiguous US, Alaska, and Canada. For nearly three decades, CASTNET has
produced data of proven quality following consistent methods required for long-term trends
analysis. Observational data from CASTNET (and NADP) are used commonly to assess the
effectiveness of emission control policies, to evaluate and develop air quality models, and are
important inputs to critical load assessments and ecosystem studies. CASTNET is recognized as
a dynamic and resilient program that has evolved to respond to changing agency objectives and
emerging issues while still maintaining a consistent set of measurements (SO2, HNO3, SO4, NO3,
NH4, base cations, CL, and O3) over time in the face of static or declining federal budgets.
CASTNET complements measurements from co-located or nearby air quality monitoring
network sites (i.e. NCore, Chemical Speciation Network, Interagency Monitoring of Protected
Visual Environments). Further, the CASTNET platform has facilitated new deposition and effects
research and methods development geared toward reducing uncertainties in the nitrogen budget.
Here we present results from CASTNET, featuring regional long-term trends (1990-2016) in
atmospheric concentrations and estimates of dry deposition of key sulfur and nitrogen species.
We also look at how the network has adapted to advance deposition research, reduce spatial gaps
in remote areas, and build or expand upon existing partnerships to meet the evolving needs of the
policy and scientific communities. Finally, we discuss the challenges the network will face in the
next 5-years and plans for minimizing the impacts of those challenges.
1EPA, [email protected] 2EPA, [email protected] 3EPA, [email protected] 4EPA, [email protected] 5Amec Foster Wheeler, Inc., [email protected] 6EPA, [email protected] 7Amec Foster Wheeler, Inc., [email protected] 8EPA, [email protected] 9Amec Foster Wheeler, Inc., [email protected]
96
Mobile Measurements of Atmospheric Ammonia in Northeastern
Colorado
Yixing Shao1, Jeffrey L. Collett, Jr.
2 and Katherine B. Benedict
3
The spatial and temporal variability of ammonia is not well characterized in regions like
northeastern Colorado where there are large agricultural sources adjacent to urban and remote
areas. Northeastern Colorado is of interest since it is home to Rocky Mountain National Park
(RMNP), a protected area experiencing the effects of increased nitrogen deposition. To protect
the park from increasing nitrogen deposition it is crucial to understand the degree to which the
urban and agricultural sources are impacting RMNP, as well as how meteorological conditions
are influencing the ammonia concentrations and nitrogen deposition in the park. Mobile
measurements of ammonia were made in June 2016 to examine the spatial variability of ammonia
at high-time resolution. These data, together with modeling results from the Hybrid Single
Particle Lagrangian Integrated Trajectory Model (HYSPLIT), will be used to investigate the
transport of ammonia across the region. From previous observations it is unclear whether distinct
plumes of ammonia are being transported over large distances or whether regional ammonia
concentrations are relatively homogeneous. The combination of these measurements and
modeling results will provide a clearer picture of how ammonia-rich air parcels in the eastern plains of Colorado are transported and contribute to nitrogen deposition in the park.
1Colorado State University, [email protected] 2Colorado State University, [email protected] 3Colorado State University, [email protected]
97
Deposition of Atmospheric Mercury to the Lulin Atmospheric Background Station
(LABS) in Taiwan in 2009-2016
Guey-Rong Sheu1, Nguyen Ly Sy Phu
2, Da-Wei Lin
3, Leiming Zhang
4 and Neng-
Huei Lin5
Although East Asia is the major anthropogenic mercury (Hg) emission source region, studies
concerning atmospheric Hg deposition in its downwind region are still limited. Taiwan is
considered downwind of the East Asian continent in fall, winter and spring because of regional
monsoon activity. Monitoring of various atmospheric Hg species, including gaseous elemental
Hg (GEM), gaseous oxidized Hg (GOM) and particle-bound Hg (PBM), began since April 2006,
whereas collection of weekly rainwater samples for total Hg analyses began since early 2009, at
the Lulin Atmospheric Background Station (LABS; 120.87ºE, 23.47ºN, 2862 m a.s.l.), a tropical
mountain-top site in central Taiwan. Here we reported the wet and dry deposition of atmospheric
Hg to the LABS between 2009 and 2016. Dry deposition of speciated Hg was estimated using
bidirectional air-surface resistance model. Amounts of annual rainfall ranged from 2160 to 4991
mm and the volume-weighted mean concentrations of rainwater Hg ranged from 5.04 to 13.08 ng
L-1. Annual wet Hg deposition fluxes ranged between 10.89 and 46.05 µg m-2, with a grand
average of 27.3 µg m-2 yr-1. Wet Hg deposition fluxes were higher in summer as a result of higher
rainfall and rainwater Hg concentrations. Weekly wet deposition fluxes and rain depths were
highly correlated (R2 = 0.654, p < 0.01). As there is no anthropogenic Hg emission source around
the LABS, the high summertime rainwater Hg concentration hints at the importance of
Hg0 oxidation and/or scavenging of upper-altitude Hg(II) by deep convection. Annual dry
deposition fluxes ranged from 51.79 to 70.15 µg m-2, with a grand average of 60.8 µg m-2 yr-1. On
average, the annual dry deposition flux was 2.2 times that of wet flux. Nighttime GOM dry
deposition flux (8.09±1.96 µg m-2 yr-1) was higher than that of daytime (5.21±1.58 µg m-2 yr-1)
because of higher GOM concentration and wind speed at night. Due to the high percentage of
forest canopy coverage around the LABS, average annual GEM dry deposition flux (47.2 µg m-2)
was significantly higher than GOM (13.31 µg m-2) and PBM (0.21 µg m-2). Results of this
research indicate that wet and dry Hg deposition fluxes to the tropical mountain site are
significantly higher than values reported from sites in temperate region.
1National Central University, [email protected] 2National Central University 3National Central University 4Environment and Climate Change Canada 5National Central University
98
AMoN Site Characterization Study: Phase I Field Measurements
John Walker1, Kevin Mishoe
2, Christopher Rogers
3, Zhiyong Wu
4, Melissa
Puchalski5, Donna Schwede
6, Kim Hutchison
7, Wayne Robarge
8 and Ralph
Baumgardner9
Reduced inorganic nitrogen (NH3 + NH4+) is an increasingly important contributor to the total
nitrogen deposition budget, yet the bi-directional nature of NH3 air-surface exchange makes
incorporation of NH3 measurements into dry deposition schemes in field-scale and regional
chemical transport models (i.e. CMAQ) difficult. The purpose of this study is to develop a
methodology for providing NADP with modeled NH3 fluxes using bi-weekly AMoN
concentrations. NH3 fluxes derived from site specific NH3 measurements (AMoN) and surface
parameterizations (i.e., compensation points) will provide “best” estimates of NH3 deposition for
developing ecosystem specific deposition budgets, assessing sub-grid variability of fluxes within
CMAQ, and characterizing the impact of bias correcting CMAQ NH3 concentrations on
NH3 fluxes. This effort will therefore improve the total nitrogen deposition estimates provided
by TDEP, which does not currently use the AMoN NH3 concentrations for deposition estimates.
The first phase of the project will focus on measurements while the 2nd phase will focus on
evaluation of the bi-directional air-surface exchange model. During Phase I, a database of soil
and vegetation chemistry, micrometeorology, and surface physical characteristics will be
developed for 3 pilot sites: Chiricahua National Monument, AZ (desert); Bondville, IL
(agricultural); and Duke Forest, NC (hardwood forest). These sites were selected based on
available data (AMoN, CASTNET, and NADP/NTN), and differences in land-use type,
vegetation and soil types, and average ambient NH3 concentrations. Soil, live vegetation, and
litter will be collected and analyzed for NH4+ and pH to develop seasonal estimates of surface
NH3 emission potentials (Г) from which compensation points will be derived. Biogeochemistry
will be combined with on-site meteorology and surface characteristics will be used to calculate
net and component fluxes (i.e., foliage versus ground) using a 2-layer bi-directional flux model.
Measurements will be used to assess model sensitivities to biogeochemical and meteorological
inputs to develop a model suitable for implementation across the entire AMoN network.
Field measurements began in the summer of 2017 and will continue through spring 2018. Here
we describe the field and laboratory measurement methods that have been designed to capture a
robust biogeochemical dataset for the 3 AMoN pilot sites. Aspects of model development and
evaluation will also be discussed. 1US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 2Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 3Amec Foster Wheeler, [email protected] 4US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 5US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 6US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected] 7North Carolina State University, [email protected] 8North Carolina State University, [email protected] 9US Environmental Protection Agency, [email protected]
99
Testing Coastal Lichen and Moss Species as a Bioindicator of Atmospheric Total
Mercury and Monomethylmercury in Santa Cruz County, CA
Belle Zheng1, Wendy Lin
2, Peter Weiss-Penzias
3, Ken Kellman
4, Alfred
Freeberg5 and Brian Young
6
Lichen are unique terrestrial organisms that form stable mutualistic associations between fungi,
algae and cyanobacteria.. They have also been used as indicators of healthy air as they are able to
accumulate airborne pollutants such as heavy metals like mercury in their thalli (vegetative
tissue). A previous study done in the Canadian High Arctic found that lichen had median
monomethylmercury (MMHg) and median total mercury (THg) concentrations that were two
orders higher of magnitude than the soils underlying them. Intrigued by these data, we decided to
test the concentrations of MMHg and THg in lichen and moss in Santa Cruz, CA. The main
purpose of the study is to find out whether lichens and mosses can be used as bioindicators of
environmental mercury, especially the effects of coastal fog. Various lichen and moss species
were collected in Santa Cruz County, then freeze-dried and homogenized, and then analyzed for
MMHg and THg concentrations. Lichen and moss THg concentrations ranged from 31.9 to 400.4
ng g-1, with an average of 178.9±111 ng g-1. Lichen and moss MMHg concentrations ranged
from 3.86 ng g-1 to 73.3 ng g-1, with an average of 30.3±37.8 ng g-1. In a similar study the
median THg and median MMHg were found at 66.8 ng g-1 and 4.27 ng g-1 respectively. From
our preliminary data, we are optimistic that lichen and moss are good indicators of airborne
mercury concentrations. We will continue this idea by sampling along a coastal-inland transect
(fog frequency gradient) at the end of the fog season. Our study may be able to provide insight on
how MMHg and THg enter the coastal food chain through fog water deposition.
1University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected] 2University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected] 3University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected] 4University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected] 5University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected] 6University of California, Santa Cruz, [email protected]
100
101
.
NTN Map and Site Listings
102
103
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Ala
ba
ma
AL
10
Bla
ck B
elt
Res
earc
h &
Ex
ten
sio
n C
ente
r
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
8/8
3
AL
99
San
d M
oun
tain
Res
earc
h &
Ex
ten
sio
n C
ente
r
AM
oN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
-CA
M
10
/84
Ala
ska
AK
01
Po
ker
Cre
ek
U
SDA
Fo
rest
Ser
vic
e
12
/92
AK
02
Jun
eau
M
DN
USD
A F
ore
st S
erv
ice
06
/04
AK
03
Den
ali
NP
- M
oun
t M
cKin
ley
A
MN
et
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
06
/80
AK
97
Kat
mai
Nat
ion
al P
ark
- K
ing
Salm
on
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
11
/09
Arg
en
tin
a AG
01
Lau
ren
ti-M
AR
NO
AA
-Air
Res
our
ces
Lab
1
0/1
1
Ari
zo
na
A
Z0
3
Gra
nd
Can
yo
n N
P -
Ho
pi
Po
int
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
08
/81
AZ
06
O
rgan
Pip
e C
actu
s N
M
N
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
0
4/8
0
AZ
97
P
etri
fied
Fo
rest
NP
-Rai
nbo
w F
ore
st
N
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
1
2/0
2
AZ
98
C
hir
icah
ua
AM
oN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
-CA
M
02
/99
AZ
99
O
liv
er K
no
ll
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
8/8
1
Na
tio
na
l A
tmo
sph
eri
c D
ep
osi
tio
n P
rog
ram
/Na
tio
na
l T
ren
ds
Ne
two
rk S
ite
s
Ju
ly 3
1,
20
17
104
105
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
ode
Sit
e N
ame
Col
loca
tion
Spo
nso
rin
g A
gen
cy
Sta
rt
Dat
e
Col
orad
o
CO
00
Ala
mos
a
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
4/80
CO
01
Las
Ani
mas
Fis
h H
atch
ery
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
10/
83
CO
02
Niw
ot S
addl
e
N
SF-I
nsti
tute
of
Arc
tic
& A
lpin
e R
esea
rch/
Uni
vers
ity
of C
O
06/
84
CO
06C
AM
P C
ity
and
Cou
nty
of D
enve
r 0
1/17
CO
08
Fou
r M
ile P
ark
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y-C
AM
1
2/87
CO
09
Kaw
anee
chee
Mea
dow
US
Bur
eau
of L
and
Man
agem
ent/
Nat
iona
l Par
k Se
rvic
e-A
RD
07/
12
CO
10
Got
hic
A
MoN
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y-C
AM
0
2/99
CO
11 A
rvad
a G
arde
ns U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
1
2/16
CO
15
San
d Sp
ring
US
Bur
eau
of L
and
Man
agem
ent
0
3/79
CO
19
Roc
ky M
ount
ain
NP
- B
eave
r M
eado
ws
Nat
iona
l Par
k Se
rvic
e -
Air
Res
ourc
es D
ivis
ion
0
5/80
CO
21
Man
itou
USD
A F
ores
t Se
rvic
e
10/
78
CO
22
Paw
nee
Nat
iona
l Par
k Se
rvic
e -
Air
Res
ourc
es D
ivis
ion
0
5/79
CO
84 B
etas
so U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
5/17
CO
85 B
ould
er C
O D
PH
E 0
1/17
CO
86R
ocky
Fla
ts N
WR
US
Fish
& W
ildlif
e Se
rvic
e -
Air
Qua
lity
Bra
nch
0
1/17
106
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
ode
Sit
e N
ame
Col
loca
tion
Spo
nso
rin
g A
gen
cy
Sta
rt
Dat
e
CO
87N
atio
nal J
ewis
h H
ospi
tal
CO
DP
HE
01/
17
CO
90
Niw
ot R
idge
-Sou
thea
st
N
SF-I
nsti
tute
of
Arc
tic
& A
lpin
e R
esea
rch/
Uni
vers
ity
of C
O
01/
06
CO
91
Wol
f C
reek
Pas
s
U
SDA
For
est
Serv
ice
0
5/92
CO
92
Sun
light
Pea
k
U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
01/
88
CO
93
Buf
falo
Pas
s -
Dry
Lak
e
U
SDA
For
est
Serv
ice
1
0/86
CO
94
Sug
arlo
af
U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
11/
86
CO
96
Mol
as P
ass
M
DN
USD
A F
ores
t Se
rvic
e
07/
86
CO
97
Buf
falo
Pas
s -
Sum
mit
Lak
e
MD
N
USD
A F
ores
t Se
rvic
e
02/
84
CO
98
Roc
ky M
ount
ain
NP
- L
och
Val
e
AM
oN U
SGS/
Col
orad
o St
ate
Uni
vers
ity
0
8/83
CO
99
Mes
a V
erde
NP
- C
hapi
n M
esa
M
DN
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
4/81
Con
nec
ticu
t
CT
15
Abi
ngto
n
AM
oN U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
01/
99
Flo
rida
FL
03
Bra
dfor
d Fo
rest
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y-C
AM
1
0/78
FL
05
Cha
ssah
owit
zka
NW
R
MD
N
US
Fish
& W
ildlif
e Se
rvic
e -
Air
Qua
lity
Bra
nch
0
8/96
FL
11
Eve
rgla
des
NP
- R
esea
rch
Cen
ter
M
DN
/AM
oN
Nat
iona
l Par
k Se
rvic
e -
Air
Res
ourc
es D
ivis
ion
0
6/80
107
108
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
ode
Sit
e N
ame
Col
loca
tion
Spo
nso
rin
g A
gen
cy
Sta
rt
Dat
e
Ill
inoi
s
IL
11
Bon
dvill
e
AIR
MoN
/
MD
N/A
MoN
U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
02/
79
IL
46
Alh
ambr
a
AM
oN U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
01/
99
IL
78
Mon
mou
th
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
1/85
In
dian
a
IN
20
Rou
sh L
ake
A
MoN
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
08/
83
IN
22
Sou
thw
est
Pur
due
Agr
icul
ture
Cen
ter
MD
N/A
MoN
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
09/8
4
IN
34
Ind
iana
Dun
es N
L
MD
N N
atio
nal P
ark
Serv
ice
- A
ir R
esou
rces
Div
isio
n
07/
80
IN
41
Agr
onom
y C
ente
r fo
r R
esea
rch
and
Ext
ensi
on
S
AE
S-P
urdu
e U
nive
rsit
y
07/
82
Iow
a
IA
08
Big
Spr
ings
Fis
h H
atch
ery
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
08/
84
IA
23
McN
ay M
emor
ial R
esea
rch
Cen
ter
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
09/
84
Kan
sas
KS0
7
Far
lingt
on F
ish
Hat
cher
y
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
3/84
KS3
1
Kon
za P
rair
ie
AM
oN S
AE
S-K
ansa
s St
ate
Uni
vers
ity
0
8/82
KS3
2
Lak
e Sc
ott
Stat
e P
ark
M
DN
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
3/84
KS9
7
Kic
kapo
o A
MoN
Kic
kapo
o T
ribe
in K
ansa
s10
/15
109
110
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Ma
ryla
nd
MD
08
P
iney
Res
erv
oir
MD
N/A
MN
et/
AM
oN
M
ary
lan
d D
epar
tmen
t o
f N
atur
al R
eso
urce
s
06
/04
MD
13
W
ye
SA
ES-
Un
iver
sity
of
Mar
yla
nd
0
3/8
3
MD
15
S
mit
h I
slan
d
N
OA
A-A
ir R
eso
urce
s L
ab
06
/04
MD
18
A
ssat
eagu
e Is
lan
d N
S -
Wo
odc
ock
Mar
yla
nd
Dep
artm
ent
of
Nat
ural
Res
our
ces
0
9/0
0
MD
99
B
elts
vil
le
MD
N/A
MN
et
AM
oN
M
ary
lan
d D
epar
tmen
t o
f N
atur
al R
eso
urce
s
06
/04
Ma
ssa
chu
sett
s
MA
01
N
ort
h A
tlan
tic
Co
asta
l L
ab
MD
N
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
12
/81
MA
08
Q
uabb
in R
eser
vo
ir
N
ort
hea
st S
tate
s fo
r C
oo
rdin
ated
Air
Use
Man
agem
ent
0
3/8
2
MA
14
Nan
tuck
et N
antu
cket
Lan
d C
oun
cil
03
/14
MA
22
Bo
sto
n U
niv
ersi
ty B
ost
on
Un
iver
sity
- D
epar
tmen
t o
f B
iolo
gy0
6/1
5
MA
98
Arn
old
Arb
ore
tum
Arn
old
Arb
ore
tum
of
Har
var
d U
niv
ersi
ty0
2/1
6
Mic
hig
an
MI0
9
Do
ugla
s L
ake
M
DN
SA
ES-
Mic
hig
an S
tate
Un
iver
sity
0
7/7
9
MI2
6
Kel
logg
Bio
logi
cal
Stat
ion
M
DN
SA
ES-
Mic
hig
an S
tate
Un
iver
sity
0
6/7
9
MI4
8
Sen
ey N
WR
- H
eadq
uart
ers
M
DN
U
S F
ish
& W
ildl
ife
Serv
ice
- A
ir Q
uali
ty B
ran
ch
11
/00
MI5
1
Un
ion
vil
le
AM
oN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
-CA
M
01
/99
MI5
2
An
n A
rbo
r
MD
N/A
Mo
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
0
1/9
9
MI5
3
Wel
lsto
n
U
SDA
Fo
rest
Ser
vic
e
10
/78
MI9
8
Rac
o
U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
0
5/8
4
MI9
9
Ch
asse
ll
U
SDA
Fo
rest
Ser
vic
e
02
/83
111
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Min
ne
sota
MN
01
Ced
ar C
reek
Min
neso
ta P
ollu
tion
Con
trol
Age
ncy
1
2/96
MN
08
Hov
land
Min
neso
ta P
ollu
tion
Con
trol
Age
ncy
1
2/96
MN
16
Mar
cell
Exp
erim
enta
l For
est
M
DN
U
SDA
For
est
Serv
ice
0
7/78
MN
18
Fer
nber
g
MD
N/A
MoN
U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
11/
80
MN
23
Cam
p R
iple
y
MD
N
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
10/
83
MN
27
Lam
bert
on
MD
N
Min
neso
ta P
ollu
tion
Con
trol
Age
ncy
0
1/79
MN
28
Gri
ndst
one
Lak
e
M
inne
sota
Pol
luti
on C
ontr
ol A
genc
y
12/
96
MN
32
Voy
ageu
rs N
P -
Sul
livan
Bay
Nat
iona
l Par
k Se
rvic
e -
Air
Res
ourc
es D
ivis
ion
0
5/00
MN
99
Wol
f R
idge
Min
neso
ta P
ollu
tion
Con
trol
Age
ncy
1
2/96
Mis
siss
ipp
i
MS1
0
Clin
ton
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
07/
84
M
S12
G
rand
Bay
NE
RR
MD
N
NO
AA
-Air
Res
ourc
es L
ab
03/
10
MS1
9
New
ton
NO
AA
-Air
Res
ourc
es L
ab
11/
86
MS3
0
Cof
feev
ille
A
MoN
USD
A F
ores
t Se
rvic
e
07/
84
Mis
sou
ri
MO
03
Ash
land
Wild
life
Are
a
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
10/
81
MO
05
Uni
vers
ity
Fore
st
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
1
0/81
112
113
114
115
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
ode
Sit
e N
ame
Col
loca
tion
Spo
nso
rin
g A
gen
cy
Sta
rt
Dat
e
Ok
lah
oma
OK
00
Sal
t P
lain
s N
WR
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
12/
83
OK
17
Kes
sler
Far
m F
ield
Lab
orat
ory
N
OA
A-A
ir R
esou
rces
Lab
0
3/83
OK
29
Goo
dwel
l Res
earc
h St
atio
n
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
0
1/85
Ore
gon
OR
09
Silv
er L
ake
Ran
ger
Stat
ion
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
08/
83
OR
10
H J
And
rew
s E
xper
imen
tal F
ores
t
USD
A F
ores
t Se
rvic
e
05/
80
OR
18
Sta
rkey
Exp
erim
enta
l For
est
US
Geo
logi
cal S
urve
y
03/
84
OR
97
Hys
lop
Farm
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y-C
AM
0
4/83
Pen
nsy
lvan
ia
PA
00 A
rend
tsvi
lle
MD
N/A
MoN
U
S E
nvir
onm
enta
l Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy-
CA
M
01/
99
PA
13 A
llegh
eny
Por
tage
Rai
lroa
d N
atio
nal H
isto
ric
Site
MD
N
PA
Dep
t. o
f E
nv. P
rote
ctio
n/P
enn
Stat
e U
nive
rsit
y
07/1
1
PA
15 P
enn
Stat
e
AIR
MoN
N
OA
A-A
ir R
esou
rces
Lab
/PA
Gam
e C
omm
issi
on
06/
83
PA
18 Y
oung
Wom
an’s
Cre
ek
MD
N U
S G
eolo
gica
l Sur
vey
04/
99
PA
29 K
ane
Exp
erim
enta
l For
est
M
DN
/AM
oN U
SDA
For
est
Serv
ice
0
7/78
PA
30 E
rie
MD
N P
A D
ept.
of
Env
. Pro
tect
ion/
Pen
n St
ate
Uni
vers
ity
07
/11
PA
42 L
eadi
ng R
idge
M
DN
PA
Dep
t. o
f E
nv. P
rote
ctio
n/P
enn
Stat
e U
nive
rsit
y/SA
ES
0
4/79
116
117
Sta
te/P
ro
vin
ce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
TX
04
B
ig B
end
NP
- K
-Bar
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
04
/80
TX
10
A
ttw
ater
Pra
irie
Ch
ick
en N
WR
US
Geo
logi
cal
Surv
ey
07
/84
TX
16
S
on
ora
US
Geo
logi
cal
Surv
ey
06
/84
TX
21
L
on
gvie
w
MD
N
Tex
as C
om
mis
sio
n o
n E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l Q
uali
ty
06
/82
TX
22
G
uada
lup
e M
oun
tain
s N
P-F
rijo
le R
ange
r St
n
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
6/8
4
TX
43
C
añó
nce
taA
Mo
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
0
7/0
7
TX
56
L
BJ
Nat
ion
al G
rass
lan
ds
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
9/8
3
Uta
h
UT
01
L
oga
n
AM
oN
US
Geo
logi
cal
Surv
ey
12
/83
UT
09
C
any
on
lan
ds N
P -
Isl
and
in t
he
Sky
A
Mo
N N
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
1
1/9
7
UT
98
G
reen
Riv
er
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
4/8
5
UT
99
B
ryce
Can
yo
n N
P -
Rep
eate
r H
ill
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
01
/85
Ve
rm
on
t
VT
01
B
enn
ingt
on
US
Geo
logi
cal
Surv
ey
04
/81
V
T9
9
Un
derh
ill
M
DN
/AM
oN
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
6/8
4
Vir
gin
Isla
nd
s
VI0
1
Vir
gin
Isl
ands
NP
- L
ind
Po
int
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
04
/98
Vir
gin
ia
VA
00
C
har
lott
esv
ille
US
Geo
logi
cal
Surv
ey
10
/84
VA
13
H
ort
on
's S
tati
on
A
Mo
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
0
7/7
8
VA
24
P
rin
ce E
dwar
d
AM
oN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
-CA
M
01
/99
VA
28
S
hen
ando
ah N
P -
Big
Mea
dow
s
MD
N
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
05
/81
118
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
VA
99
N
atur
al B
ridg
e St
atio
n
U
SDA
Fo
rest
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Pro
gram
07
/02
Wa
shin
gto
n
WA
14
O
lym
pic
NP
- H
oh
Ran
ger
Stat
ion
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
05
/80
WA
19
N
ort
h C
asca
des
NP
-Mar
blem
oun
t R
ange
r St
n
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
2/8
4
WA
21
L
a G
ran
de
U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
0
4/8
4
WA
24
P
alo
use
Co
nse
rvat
ion
Far
m
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
8/8
5
WA
98
C
olu
mbi
a R
iver
Go
rge
USD
A F
ore
st S
erv
ice
- P
acif
ic N
ort
hw
est
Reg
ion
0
5/0
2
WA
99
M
oun
t R
ain
ier
NP
- T
aho
ma
Wo
ods
A
Mo
N N
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
1
0/9
9
We
st V
irg
inia
WV
04
B
abco
ck S
tate
Par
k
U
S G
eolo
gica
l Su
rvey
0
9/8
3
WV
05
C
edar
Cre
ek S
tate
Par
k
AM
oN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
-CA
M
01
/99
WV
18
P
arso
ns
A
Mo
N U
SDA
Fo
rest
Ser
vic
e
07
/78
Wis
con
sin
WI0
8
Bru
le R
iver
M
DN
Wis
con
sin
Dep
artm
ent
of
Nat
ural
Res
our
ces
0
4/1
4
WI1
0
Po
taw
ato
mi
M
DN
Fo
rest
Co
unty
Po
taw
ato
mi
Co
mm
unit
y
06
/05
WI3
1
Dev
il's
Lak
e M
DN
Wis
con
sin
Dep
artm
ent
of
Nat
ural
Res
our
ces
0
1/1
4
WI3
5
Per
kin
sto
wn
A
Mo
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
0
1/9
9
WI3
6
Tro
ut L
ake
M
DN
W
isco
nsi
n D
epar
tmen
t o
f N
atur
al R
eso
urce
s
01
/80
WI3
7
Sp
oo
ner
USD
A F
ore
st S
erv
ice
0
6/8
0
119
120
121
AIRMoN Map and Site Listings
122
123
Sta
te
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
ollo
cati
on
Sp
on
so
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Date
Dela
ware
DE
02
L
ew
es
NO
AA
-Air
Reso
urc
es
Labo
rato
ry
09
/92
Ill
ino
is
IL
11
B
on
dv
ille
M
DN
/NT
N/A
Mo
N
NO
AA
-Air
Reso
urc
es
Labo
rato
ry
10
/92
New
Yo
rk
NY
67
C
orn
ell
Un
ivers
ity
A
Mo
N N
OA
A-A
ir R
eso
urc
es
Labo
rato
ry
09
/92
Pen
nsy
lvan
ia
PA
15
P
en
n S
tate
N
TN
N
OA
A-A
ir R
eso
urc
es
Labo
rato
ry
10
/92
Ten
ness
ee
TN
00
W
alk
er
Bra
nch
Wate
rsh
ed
NO
AA
-Air
Reso
urc
es
Labo
rato
ry
09
/92
West V
irgin
ia
WV
99
C
an
aan
Vall
ey
In
stit
ute
N
OA
A-A
ir R
eso
urc
es
Labo
rato
ry
06
/00
Ju
ly 3
1,
20
17
Na
tio
na
l A
tmo
sp
he
ric
De
po
sit
ion
Pro
gra
m/A
tmo
sp
he
ric
In
teg
ra
ted
Re
se
arch
Mo
nit
orin
g N
etw
ork
Sit
es
124
125
AMoN Map and Site Listings
126
127
Sta
te/P
ro
vin
ce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Ala
ba
ma
AL
99
S
an
d M
oun
tain
Rese
arc
h &
Ex
t. C
en
ter
N
TN
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
03
/11
Ariz
on
a
AZ
98
C
hir
icah
ua
NT
N N
ati
on
al
Park
Serv
ice -
Air
Reso
urc
es
Div
isio
n
03
/11
Ark
an
sa
s
AR
03
C
addo
Vall
ey
N
TN
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
03
/11
AR
09
Ram
bo
Hil
l A
RS-A
gri
cult
ura
l R
ese
arc
h S
erv
ice
10
/15
AR
15
L C
Farm
s A
RS-A
gri
cult
ura
l R
ese
arc
h S
erv
ice
10
/15
Ca
lifo
rn
ia
CA
44
Yo
sem
ite N
P-
Turt
leback
Do
me
N
ati
on
al
Park
Serv
ice -
Air
Reso
urc
es
Div
isio
n
03
/11
CA
67
J
osh
ua T
ree N
P -
Bla
ck
Ro
ck
N
TN
Nati
on
al
Park
Serv
ice -
Air
Reso
urc
es
Div
isio
n
03
/11
CA
83
Sequo
ia N
P-A
sh M
oun
tain
Nati
on
al
Park
Serv
ice -
Air
Reso
urc
es
Div
isio
n
03
/11
Co
lora
do
CO
10
Go
thic
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
09
/12
CO
13
Fo
rt C
oll
ins
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
11
/07
CO
88
Ro
ck
y M
oun
tain
NP
- L
on
gs
Peak
Nati
on
al
Park
Serv
ice -
Air
Reso
urc
es
Div
isio
n
05
/11
CO
98
R
ock
y M
oun
tain
NP
- L
och
Vale
N
TN
Nati
on
al
Park
Serv
ice -
Air
Reso
urc
es
Div
isio
n
05
/11
Co
nn
ecti
cu
t
CT
15
A
bin
gto
n
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
03
/11
Na
tio
na
l A
tmo
sp
he
ric
De
po
sit
ion
Pro
gra
m/A
mm
on
ia M
on
ito
rin
g N
etw
ork
Sit
es
Ju
ly 3
1,
20
17
128
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Flo
rid
a
FL
11
E
ver
glad
es N
P -
Res
earc
h C
ente
r
NT
N/M
DN
N
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
0
3/1
1
FL
19
In
dian
Riv
er
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
04
/11
FL
23
Sum
atra
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
FL
94
Gai
nes
vil
le U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
5/1
7
Ge
org
ia
GA
41
Geo
rgia
Sta
tio
n
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
6/1
1
Id
ah
o
ID
03
C
rate
rs o
f th
e M
oo
n N
M
NT
N N
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
0
6/1
0
ID0
7 N
ez P
erce
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
12
/15
Ill
ino
is
IL
11
B
on
dvil
le
AIR
Mo
N/M
DN
/
NT
N
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
10
/07
IL3
7 S
tock
ton
U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
4/1
1
IL
46
A
lham
bra
N
TN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
03
/11
In
dia
na
IN2
0 R
ous
h L
ake
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
IN2
2SW
Pur
due
Ag
Cen
ter
MD
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
IN9
9 I
ndi
anap
oli
s
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
10
/07
129
130
131
Sta
te/P
ro
vin
ce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
NY
89
Pin
nacle
Sta
te P
ark
NY
SE
RD
A/N
YSD
EC
06
/16
NY
90
Po
tsdam
-Cla
rkso
n U
niv
ers
ity
NY
SE
RD
A0
6/1
6
NY
91
Cla
ryv
ille
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
01
/15
NY
94
Nic
k's
Lak
eN
TN
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
11
/12
NY
96
Cedar
Beach
NT
N/M
DN
Co
un
ty o
f Suff
olk
/Dep
t o
f H
ealt
h S
erv
ices
-
Peco
nic
Est
uary
Pro
gra
m0
8/1
4
NY
98
Wh
itefa
ce M
oun
tain
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
11
/12
No
rth
Ca
ro
lin
a
NC
02
Cra
nberr
y U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
01
/15
NC
06
B
eaufo
rt
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
04
/10
NC
25
C
ow
eeta
N
TN
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
05
/11
NC
26
Can
do
rM
DN
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
04
/11
NC
30
Duk
e F
ore
st U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
06
/08
NC
35
Cli
nto
n C
rop
s R
ese
arc
h S
tati
on
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
08
/08
Oh
io
OH
02
Ath
en
s Sup
er
Sit
eA
MN
et/
MD
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
10
/07
OH
09
Ox
ford
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
01
/15
OH
27
C
incin
nati
U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
10
/07
OH
54
D
eer
Cre
ek
Sta
te P
ark
N
TN
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
03
/11
OH
99
Quak
er
Cit
y U
S E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
01
/15
Ok
lah
om
a
OK
98
Quap
aw
Quap
aw
Tri
be o
f O
kla
ho
ma
10
/15
OK
99
Sti
lwell
M
DN
/AM
Net
US E
nv
iro
nm
en
tal
Pro
tecti
on
Agen
cy
- C
AM
10
/07
132
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Pe
nn
sylv
an
ia
PA
00
A
ren
dtsv
ille
N
TN
/MD
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M1
0/0
9
PA
29
K
ane
Ex
per
imen
tal
Fo
rest
N
TN
/MD
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
3/1
1
PA
56
M.K
. G
odd
ard
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
12
/14
PA
96
Pen
n S
tate
- F
airb
roo
k P
ark
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
01
/15
PA
97
Lau
rel
Hil
l U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
7/1
5
Pu
ert
o R
ico
PR
20
El
Ver
deM
DN
/NT
N U
.S.
Fo
rest
Ser
vic
e0
3/1
4
So
uth
C
aro
lin
a
SC
05
C
ape
Ro
mai
n N
WR
N
TN
/MD
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M1
0/0
7
Te
nn
ess
ee
TN
01
Gre
at S
mo
ky
Mo
unta
ins
NP
- L
oo
k R
ock
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
03
/11
TN
04
Sp
eedw
ell
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
TN
07
Edg
ar E
vin
s U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
Te
xa
s
TX
41
Ala
bam
a- C
ous
hat
ta U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
TX
43
C
añó
nce
taN
TN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
10
/07
133
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Uta
h
UT
01
L
oga
nN
TN
Sta
te o
f U
tah
/DE
Q1
1/1
1
UT
09
C
any
on
lan
ds N
atio
nal
Par
k-I
slan
d in
th
e Sk
yN
TN
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
05
/14
UT
97
S
alt
Lak
e C
ity
MD
N/A
MN
et S
tate
of
Uta
h/D
EQ
11
/11
Ve
rmo
nt
VT
99
Un
derh
ill
MD
N/N
TN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
11
/12
Vir
gin
ia
VA
13
Ho
rto
n's
Sta
tio
nN
TN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
01
/15
VA
24
P
rin
ce E
dwar
d
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
3/1
1
Wa
shin
gto
n
WA
99
M
oun
t R
ain
ier
NP
- T
aho
ma
Wo
ods
N
TN
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n
03
/11
We
st V
irg
inia W
V0
5C
edar
Cre
ek S
tate
Par
k
NT
N U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M0
1/1
5
WV
18
Par
son
sN
TN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
06
/11
Wis
con
sin
WI0
7 H
ori
con
Mar
shA
MN
et U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy -
CA
M1
0/0
7
WI3
5
Per
kin
sto
wn
N
TN
US
En
vir
on
men
tal
Pro
tect
ion
Age
ncy
- C
AM
03
/11
134
135
MDN Map and Site Listings
136
137
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt
Da
te
Ala
ska
AK
02
Jun
eau
NT
NN
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
12
/16
AK
06
Gat
es o
f th
e A
rcti
c N
P -
Bet
tles
NT
NU
S B
urea
u o
f L
and
Man
agem
ent
11
/08
AK
98
Ko
diak
Ko
diak
Isl
and
Bur
oug
h
Ca
lifo
rnia
CA
20
Yur
ok
Tri
be-R
equa
Ele
ctri
c P
ow
er R
esea
rch
In
stit
ute
08
/06
CA
75
Sequ
oia
NP
-Gia
nt
Fo
rest
NT
NN
atio
nal
Par
k S
erv
ice
- A
ir R
eso
urce
s D
ivis
ion
07
/03
CA
94
Co
nv
erse
Fla
tsN
TN
USD
A F
ore
st S
erv
ice
04
/06
Co
lora
do
CO
96
Mo
las
Pas
s
NT
NU
S B
urea
u o
f L
and
Man
agem
ent
06
/09
CO
97
Buf
falo
Pas
s -
Sum
mit
Lak
eN
TN
USD
A F
ore
st S
erv
ice
09
/98
CO
99
Mes
a V
erde
NP
-Ch
apin
Mes
aN
TN
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n 1
2/0
1
Na
tio
na
l A
tmo
sph
eri
c D
ep
osi
tio
n P
rog
ram
/Me
rcu
ry D
ep
osi
tio
n N
etw
ork
Sit
es
Ju
ly 3
1,
20
17
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
AMNet Map and Site Listings
148
149
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
od
e
Sit
e N
am
eC
oll
oca
tio
nS
po
nso
rin
g A
ge
ncy
Sta
rt D
ate
Ala
ska
AK
03
Den
ali
Nat
ion
al P
ark
N
TN
Nat
ion
al P
ark
Ser
vic
e -
Air
Res
our
ces
Div
isio
n 0
3/1
4
Ha
wa
ii
HI0
0 M
aun
a L
oa
Nat
ion
al O
cean
ic &
Atm
osp
her
ic A
dmin
istr
atio
n1
2/1
0
Ind
ian
a
IN2
1C
lift
y F
alls
MD
N L
ake
Mic
hig
an A
ir D
irec
tor'
s C
on
sort
ium
(L
AD
CO
)0
5/1
6
Ma
ine
ME
97
Pre
sque
Isl
e A
roo
sto
ok
Ban
d o
f M
icm
acs
12
/13
Ma
ryla
nd
MD
08
Pin
ey R
eser
vo
ir
MD
N/N
TN
/AM
oN
S
tate
of
Mar
yla
nd
01
/08
MD
99
B
elts
vil
le
MD
N/N
TN
/AM
oN
N
OA
A/U
S E
nv
iro
nm
enta
l P
rote
ctio
n A
gen
cy-C
AM
D 1
1/0
6
Mis
siss
ipp
i MS1
2 G
ran
d B
ay N
ER
RM
DN
/NT
N
Nat
ion
al O
cean
ic &
Atm
osp
her
ic A
dmin
istr
atio
n 0
9/0
6
Na
tio
na
l A
tmo
sph
eri
c D
ep
osi
tio
n P
rog
ram
/Atm
osp
he
ric
Me
rcu
ry N
etw
ork
Sit
es
Ju
ly 3
1,
20
17
150
Sta
te/P
rovi
nce
Sit
e C
ode
Sit
e N
ame
Col
loca
tion
Spo
nso
rin
g A
gen
cyS
tart
Dat
e
New
Jer
sey
NJ3
0N
ew B
runs
wic
kM
DN
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y -
CA
M10
/15
NJ5
4E
lizab
eth
Lab
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y -
CA
M10
/15
New
Yor
k
NY
06 N
ew Y
ork
Cit
yM
DN
/NT
N S
tate
of
New
Yor
k 0
8/08
NY
20 H
unti
ngto
n W
ildlif
e Fo
rest
MD
N/N
TN
/AM
oN
NY
SER
DA
11/
07
NY
43 R
oche
ster
BM
DN
/NT
N S
tate
of
New
Yor
k 0
9/08
Oh
io
OH
02 A
then
s Su
per
Site
AM
oN/M
DN
Lak
e M
ichi
gan
Air
Dir
ecto
rs C
onso
rtiu
m 0
1/07
OH
52 S
outh
Bas
s Is
land
MD
N L
ake
Mic
higa
n A
ir D
irec
tors
Con
sort
ium
12/
11
Ok
lah
oma
OK
99St
illw
ell
US
Env
iron
men
tal P
rote
ctio
n A
genc
y -
CA
M 1
0/08
Uta
h
UT
97 S
alt
Lak
e C
ity
MD
N/A
MoN
Sta
te o
f U
tah
11/
08
151
152
153
Proceedings Notes
154
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
155
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
156
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
157
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
158
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
159
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
____________________________________________________
160
The National Atmospheric Deposition Program (NADP) was established in
1977 under State Agricultural Experiment Station (SAES) leadership to address the
problem of atmospheric deposition and its effects on agricultural crops, forests,
rangelands, surface waters, and other natural and cultural resources. In 1978, sites in
the NADP precipitation chemistry network first began collecting one-week, wet-only
deposition samples for analysis at the Illinois State Water Survey’s Central
Analytical Laboratory (CAL), located at the University of Illinois, Urbana-
Champaign. The network was established to provide data on amounts, temporal
trends, and geographic distributions of the atmospheric deposition of acids, nutrients,
and base cations by precipitation.
Initially, the NADP was organized as SAES North Central Regional Project
NC-141, which all four SAES regions further endorsed in 1982 as Interregional
Project IR-7. A decade later, IR-7 was reclassified as National Research Support
Project No. 3 (NRSP-3), which it remains. NRSP projects are multistate activities
that support research on topics of concern to more than one state or region of the
country. Multistate projects involve the SAES in partnership with the USDA
National Institute of Food and Agriculture and other universities, institutions, and
agencies.
In October 1981, the federally supported National Acid Precipitation
Assessment Program (NAPAP) was established to increase understanding of the
causes and effects of acidic precipitation. This program sought to establish a long-
term precipitation chemistry network of sampling sites distant from point source
influences. Because of its experience in organizing and operating a national-scale
network, the NADP agreed to coordinate operation of NAPAP’s National Trends
Network (NTN). To benefit from identical siting criteria and operating procedures
and a shared analytical laboratory, NADP and NTN merged with the designation
NADP/NTN. This merger brought substantial new federal agency participation into
the program. Many NADP/NTN sites were supported by the USGS, NAPAP’s lead
federal agency for deposition monitoring.
In October 1992, the Atmospheric Integrated Research Monitoring Network
(AIRMoN) joined the NADP. AIRMoN sites collect samples daily when
precipitation occurs. In January 1996, the NADP established the Mercury Deposition
Network (MDN), the third network in the organization. The MDN was formed to
provide data on the wet deposition of mercury to surface waters, forested
watersheds, and other receptors. In October 2009, the Atmospheric Mercury
Network (AMNet) joined the NADP as the fourth network. AMNet measures the
concentration of atmospheric mercury. In October 2010, the Ammonia Monitoring
Network (AMoN) joined the NADP, measuring atmospheric ammonia
concentrations using passive monitors.
SAES project NRSP-3 was renewed in 2014 and it continues to offer a unique
opportunity for cooperation among scientists from land-grant and other universities,
government agencies, and non-governmental organizations. It provides a framework
for leveraging the resources of nearly 100 different sponsoring agencies to address
contemporary and emerging issues of national importance.
161
NADP Program Office
Illinois State Water Survey
2204 Griffith Drive
Champaign, IL 61820-7495
NADP Home page: http://nadp.isws.illinois.edu
Phone: 217/333-7871