patent remedies assistant professor colleen chien

17
Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien [email protected]

Upload: valerie-golden

Post on 18-Jan-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Money

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

Patent Remedies

Assistant Professor Colleen [email protected]

Page 2: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

Two Types of Remedies

Page 3: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

Money

Page 4: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

What is the value of a patent?

$599

“Slide to Unlock Patent”

Page 5: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

How about now?

$599

250K patents

Page 6: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

How about now?

$599

250K patents

Cost of components $120Cost of marketing $60Cost of R&D $200

Page 7: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

What the jury sees

$599

“Slide to Unlock Patent”

Page 8: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

Two Types of Remedies

Page 9: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

How much does it cost to design around the patent?

Page 10: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

How much does it cost to design around the patent?

Page 11: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

How much does it cost to design around the patent?

Page 12: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

Two Types of Remedies + a third consideration

Page 13: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

How much does it cost to fight over the value of the patent?

Page 14: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

What the law says

35 U.S.C. 284 Damages.

…the court shall award the claimant damages adequate to compensate for the infringement…

Page 15: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

What the law says

35 U.S.C. 283 Injunction.

The courts []may grant injunctions

Page 16: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

The Business Opportunity

Nuisance-Value Litigation Business Model

The Cost of Offense is greater than the Expected RecoveryThe Cost of Defense, and therefore Likely Settlement Fees are greater than the Cost of Offense

Settlement?

Page 17: Patent Remedies Assistant Professor Colleen Chien

Thank You!

Colleen [email protected]

Links to my papers with data referenced here:http://papers.ssrn.com/Auth_id=362060