the richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by harold mattingly and w.p.d. stebbing
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
1/155
NUMISMATIC
NOTES
AND
MONOGRAPHS
No.
80
THE RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
OF RADIATES, 1931
By Harold Mattingly
and
W. P. D. Stebbing
The
American
Numismatic
Society
Broadway at 156th Street
New
York
1938
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:05 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
2/155
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
3/155
NUMISMATIC
NOTES AND
MONOGRAPHS
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:05 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
4/155
Numismatic otes
and Monographs
is devoted oessays nd treatisesn sub-
jects
relating
to
coins,
paper money,
medals and decorations
nd is uniform
with
Hispanic
Notes
and
Monographs
publishedby
the
Hispanic Society
of
America,
nd with
Indian Notes
and
Monographs
ssued
y
theMuseum
fthe
American
ndian
Heye
Foundation.
Publication
Committee
Agnes
Baldwin
Brett,
Chairman
Stephen
H.
P.
Pell
Thomas
.
M
bbott
Editorial
Staff
Sydney
hilip
Noe,
Editor
SawyerMcA.Mosser,Associateditor
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:05 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
5/155
COPYRIGHT
938
BY
THE MERICAN
UMISMATIC
OCIETY
THENTELLIGENCERRINTINGO.
LANCASTER,
A.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:05 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
6/155
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
7/155
THE RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
BY HAROLD
MATTINGLY
and
W. P. D. STEBBING
The
American
umismatic
ociety
BROADWAY
T
56TH
TREET
NEW ORK
I938
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
8/155
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
9/155
THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
By Harold Mattingly
and
W.
P. D.
Stebbing
The hoard f 875bronze oins, fvaryingizes
and
weights,
hichwe
have here o
describe,
as
found
n
September
st,
1931,
t
a
levelwithin
he
Romanfort
f
Richborough,
hich
as
beendated
to the
ame
ge
as thewalls.
Thesewere
robably
erected ithin
he
years
A. D.
275and
296.
The evidence
f hefinder
s to the ffecthat he
coins,
hough
ound
n
a
mass,
were
naccompanied
by any
trace
f
purse,
ox or other ontainernd
showed o
sign
f
having
een
ecreted
n
a hole
n
a
wall
or n thatch.1
The
corrosionf some f
the
coins nd traces fwood-fibre?) on them uggest
possible
urial
n a box
with
ron
ands.
The site
on
which
hecoins
were ound eems o
have carried
hut,
with
foundation
ourse o
its
walls
f
arge ough
ieces
f
Folkstonetone. The
coins
ay
near
n
angle
of this
foundation,
s
they
might
f buried nder
hearth.
The
general
evel
of he ite
has
yielded ottery
f
ate hird
o
fourth
century
ate.
We
begin
by
a
general
ummary
f
the
hoard
followed
y
more
etailed
escriptions:
SUMMARY
A.
REGULAR.
Gallienus
1
POSTUMUS
1
A
ate
th
entury
oard,
ound
y
Mr.
tebbing
owards
he
centre
f
he
ort
n
1926,
ad
een
husoncealed.
I
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
10/155
2 THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
VlCTORINUS
2
Claudius I
1
Tetricus
1
7
Tetricus I 4
Allectus
1
Con
tantiu II
(or
Constans)
1
Theodosius
2
Arcadius
1
Uncertain
heodosian
1
22
B.
IRREGULAR.*
Imitationsf
Known
Radiate
Types.
Consecratio
eagle)
5
Consecratio
altar)
21
Felicitas 1
Fides
Militum
10
Fortuna
2
Hilar
t
s
2
Invictus
21
Laetitia
6
Mars
1
Pax
branch
nd
ceptre)
26
Pax
uncertain)
1
Pax
(branch
nd
cornucopiae)
5
Pietas
Augg. priestly
mblems)
40
Pietas
sacrificing)
5
Providentia 2
Salus
10
Spes
22
Victory
o
r
1
Victory
'comes
vgg.'
ype)
6
Virtus
3
190
*
Fromhis
ointn,
he
rrangement
s
by
everse
ypes.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
11/155
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
3
Various
Figure
Types.
Standing
ront
'male')
17
Standing
ront
'female')
6
Standingront,ead . 'male') 9
Standingront,
ead
.
'female')
4
Standingront,
ead
.
'male')
8
Standingront,
ead
.
'female')
4
Standing
.
'male')
20
Standing
.
'female')
14
Advancing
.
'male')
21
Advancing
.
'female')
3
Standing
.
'male')
25
Standing
.
'female')
119
Advancing
.
'male')
9
Advancing. 'female') 4Seated
1
264
Various.
Animals
8
Birds
3
Temples.
3
Miscellaneous
4
Crosses,
tc
5
Patterns
20
Notable
bverses
8
~~5ĪTwoFigureTypes.
'Fel.
Temp.
eparatio'
model
7
'Gloria
Romanorvm'
odel
12
Various
to r
8
Various
to
1
3
Various
o
front
6
36
Total
f
ll
classes
563
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
12/155
4
THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
There remain
312
coins,
which were
either
illegible
r,
t
least,
eemed
o add
nothing
o
those
here
escribed, aking p
a
grand
otal
f
875.
The
coins,
when
ound,
ere
n
the
whole
n
very
fair ondition.
They
were
mainly
oose,but,
n a
few
ases,
were tuck
ogether
n
two's
nd
three's.
The ncrustation
aried rom
soft,
arthy
overing
to
a
hard
nodular xide
f
ron,
ither
n
patches
r
covering
he whole urface.
In
some
cases both
faces fthe
coinhad
been orroded
in
others,
here
were
uggestions
f
possible
urning y
fire.
All,
without
xception,
were
struck,
not
cast.
The
flans ary nthicknessrom aper-likelakes oan
average
radiate'
ize;
they
re
often
rregular
n
shape
nd
occasionally
ave
one
or more
rojecting
knobs f
metal
n
the
dge.
Extensive
lipping
as
in
a few ases
produced
omething
ike
triangular
shape.
The die
is sometimes
orrectly
djusted
o
the
flan,
ometimest
fails to findroom
on
it.
Apart
from
his
occasional
ailure f
adjustment,
the
striking
as
fairly
ell
done.
In
some
cases
there
s
a
border
f
dots,
hat
may
degenerate
nto
various
arrangements
f
strokes,
n
others,
no
bordert all. The coins
ary
nsizefrom35to 85
inches
9
to
22
mm);
n
weight,
rom .8
gr.
o
69.5
gr.
.31-4.5
gm).
An
interesting
eature
f
the hoard
s the
occur-
rence
f
die-identities,
ither n
both ides
or one
only.
The same
obverse nd
reverse
ies
occur
n
Nos.
104 nd
105;
65 nd
266;
281,
82
nd
292;
307
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
13/155
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
5
and
308;
407
and
412;
413 and
414A;
77,
508 and
509;
478 and
479:
the
sameobverse ies occur n
Nos. 414and 414a; thesamereverseies on Nos.178 nd
179;
Nos.
307,
308 and
309;
537and 538.
These dentities
re not
numerous
nough
o
suggest
that
our
mass
of
coinage
had comedirect
rom
single
mint;
hey
re
sufficiently
umerouso con-
vince s that
we
are not
dealing
with chance
mass
of
oin
drift
n the
market.
We
shall onsiderater
what his
may
mean.
The
greatmajority
f
he
oins ear
neitherame
of
Emperor
orfeatures
o
identify
ne;
but
not n-
frequent
xceptions
ccur nd
we
are
reminded
t
one pointor another, y legendor portrait,f
Gallienus,
Nos.
163,
172),
Claudius
I,
(Nos.
23
ff,
166, 184,
346),
Quintillus
Nos.
160, 316,
453),
Tacitus,
Nos.
206,
359),
Probus,
Nos.
245, 465,
492,
522,
550),
Postumus,
Nos.
69,
298,
350, 396,
406,
553),
Victorinus,
Nos.
187,
237, 357,
360),
Carausius,
No. 451).
Far commonestre the
ug-
gestions
fTetricus
(Nos.
51,
53,
85, 114, 93, 12,
430,
461,
etc.)
and
of
Tetricus
I,
with
youthful
features,
Nos.
77,
102, 163,
312, 401,
421,
etc.).
Examples
f
head
to left
ccur,
ut
they
re
even
rarerhan n theoriginaleries.The range fthe
imitation,
hen,
s over he
period
f xtremeebase-
ment,
rom
ircaA. D.
258
to 274
and,
ess
nten-
sively,
ver he
radiates
f
the reformf
Aurelian,
circaA.
D.
274-296. There s more
iversity,
hen,
in the
bverses
han s usual n
hoards
f barbarous
radiates.'
In some
cases,
there
s
something
n-
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
14/155
6 THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
definably
lien
n
the ookofthe
head
hardly
ny-
thing
utthe
adiation
emindss of Roman
oin.
The reverse
ypes re,
n
some
ases, opied
with
considerable
idelity
rom rd
entury
odels; ut,
even
where he
riginal
ype
s
preserved,
he
egend
is seldom lear.
Exceptions
hat
prove
he ule
may
be seen
in
consecratio
(Nos.
24
ff),
hilaritas
(No.
62),
PAX
Nos.
99,
119,
195),
PES
Nos.
181,
198),
VIRTUS
No.
173).
A
remarkableeature
f
the reverse
ypes
s that
many
of them
produce
variations
n the
standing
igures
f their
3rd
century
riginals,
o markeds to
appear
eliberate
rather
han accidental
r
careless.
Occasionally,
thedirectionf theoriginal ype s reversed,s,
for
xample,
ol invictus to
right,
nstead
f to
left
Nos.
83
ff).
In
so far as
the reverses
opy
definite
riginals,
he
divergence
rom he normal
may
be
studiedunderour careful
lassification,
assisted
y
the Plates.
The
large
lass
f oins ot
to
be associated
with
pecificriginals
as
been
r-
ranged
n
formal
roups,standing
ront/
right'
r
'left,'
figures ndraped'
r
draped.'
It
may
ulti-
mately
e
possible,
ith he id of
further
oards,
o
trace
he
riginal
f
many ypes
t
present
ysteri-
ous. That therehould e mistakesnourdescrip-
tions
fobscurend
hithertonknown
ypes
s nev-
itable.
May
the scholar
f
thefuture ho orrects
such
errors
udge
us not too
unkindly
The mostnotable eature f our
hoardremains
still to be mentioned.
t includes
l)
a
series
f
coins
Nos. 528-546)
howing nowledge
f
riginals
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
15/155
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
7
of
he ourth
entury,
c. A. D. 348-361
nd
c. A.
D.
364r-
75
(2)
another
eries
Nos.
547-563)
howing
types,
ften ithmore
han ne
figure,
f
o
originala characterhat
hey
annot etracedo
ny
Roman
modelof the
third
entury
r
later. Both
eries,
though
elatively
mall n
the bulk of
the
hoard,
contain
sufficient
umber
f
coins
to
assure
us
that
t s
no case of
mere
ccident. Of
eries
l)
we
shall
have to
speak
more
ully
ater. Of
series
2)
we
may say
at once
that
t
supplies
ull
vidence
that hemakers f
our oins
were
not
opyists
nly,
-
that
they ctually
had
new
deas of
their
wn,
which
hey
ried,
with
varying
uccess,
o
express
inthe anguagefreverseypes. Someofthe wo-
figure
ypes
eem to
aim
at
expressing
cenesof
combat
r,
possibly,
n
some
ases,
f
ritual,
hich,
however
bscure
o
us,
yet peak
language
f
heir
own.
Of the
other
ypes
f the
group,
ome
may
well be derived
ultimately
rom
adiate
models.
The 'Cross
with
pellets,'
or
xample,might
rise
either
rom
he Altar'
f
Divus
Claudius r
from
completely
ormalized
nd
degraded
tanding
igure,
such
s
Spes.
But,
n
such
ases,
ven f
mitation
be
present,
t
has
reached he
point
f
new
reation;
theRoman ypesnly erve srawmaterialor ew.
We
are now n
a
position
o
attack
he
problems
that onstitutehemain
nterest
f
our
hoard
the
date at which
t was
buried
nd
the
conditions
t
Rutupiae
which
ts burial
would
seem
to
imply.
Our
knowledge
s still
mperfect,
mere
ay
of
ight
in
the
darkness,
ut,
even
so,
its
disclosures
re
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
16/155
8
THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
exciting nough.
As
our hoard
belongs,
ormally,
to the
arge
nd
much
iscussed
lassof
barbarous
radiates,' glance
t
thehistory
f
these uriousfindswillbe ofvalue.
The barbarous
adiates' ave
ong
been battle-
field
of
conflicting
reeds.
The idea
that
they
might epresent
n some
way
or
other he
oinage
f
theDark
Age
n Britain thefiftho sixth
entury
A. D.
-
was natural
nough
nd
seems
o havebeen
widely
eld
n
the
arly
ndmid-nineteenth
entury.2
M.
Adrien
lanchet,
n a
notable
aper,
epudiated
the
dea,
s far s it affected
aul,
nddeclared hat
imitations
f
radiate
oins,
mall s well
as
large,
belonged o approximatelyhe same age as the
originals.3
is
arguments,
ased
on some
vidence
of
hoards
nd
ably developed,
ave
found
eneral
acceptance
n
France.
In our sland he
fortunesf
war
have
beenmore aried
nd successes
avebeen
recorded
rom ime o time
y
both chools
early
and
late daters.4
n a
paper,
written
y
the
ate
Mrs.
Mortimer heeler
nd now
published
fter
er
*
Cf.
Thomas
right,
On
Anglo-Saxon
ntiquities,
ith
particular
eference
othe aussett
ollection,'
854;
. Roach
Smith,
rch.ant.
ol.
viii,
1889) .
72,
Roman
oins
ound
atRichborough'heree ecantsis reviouseliefn late ate
for
hemitations.
*
Lesmonnaies
arbares
ux
oms
t
ypes
es
eux
etricus'
(Congrès
ntern,
e
Num.,ruxelles,
910).
«'
or
he
eneral
uestion,
f. .
H.
V.
Sutherland
n
he
um.
Chron.
International
umismatic
ongress
olume,
938):
he
same
riter
n
The
Hayle
oardfRadiate inimi'
Num.
Chron.
936,
p.
202
f.),
The
Whitchurchoardf
Radiate
Minimi'
ibid.
935,
p.
6
ff.);
.
Mattingly,
Three
oards
f
Barbarous
oman
oins,'
bid.
934,
p.
55
f.;
.G.
Collingwood
'Archaeology
f
Roman
ritain,'
930,
.
199.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
17/155
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
9
death
by
Mr.
O'Neil,5
we
have
a
description
f a
hoard
f
radiate
mitations,
ound
n
the theatre
t
St.Albans. The coins re lmostllverymall, e-
scending
o minim'6ize.
Theyvary onsiderably
from
heir
models,
nd
they
re
almost,
f
not om-
pletely,
nmixed ith
egular
adiate
oinage.
The
hoard, hen,
s
one
which
many
numismatists,
n
general
rinciples,7
ould
havewished o
place
very
late.
The
archaeological
vidence,however,
s
definitelygainst
his
view.
All
competent
rchae-
ologists
hohave
ested
heevidence
gree
hat
he
hoard
ouldnot have
been
buriedmuch
ater han
A. D.
300, nd,
from
he
numismatic
ide,
t must e
admitted hat close xaminationfdetails eveals
nothing
hich
equires
later
date. We
must d-
mit,
hen,
n
important
ain
by
the
early'
chool,
most
ppropriately
on
by
one who was
always
gallant ighter
n
that
ide. That
there
s
still
n-
other
iew f
the
ase,
he
present
oardwill
how.
There s
no
likelihood f an
immediate ecision
perhaps
f
ny
decision
in
favour f ither
xtreme
view.
Radiatecoins
may
have
been
mitated oth
early
nd
ate.
If,
n
both
ases,
he mitations ere
the
work f
non-Roman,
ative
rtists,
heymight
wellhave generalinshipfkind,which ould end
to
blur he
distinctionsf
date.
For
the ime
eing,
we
must heck ach
hoard n
ts
merits,
ccumulate
6
Num.
hron.
937,p.
11 f.
6
A
convenient,
f
vague,
escription
f
inymitations,
ery
muchmaller
han
ny
riginals.
7
The
ontemporary
mitations
aturally
ould
e
xpected
o
mix
reely
ith
riginals.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
18/155
10 THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
evidence
nd,
above
all,
treasure
ur
exceptions
the
points
hat do not
harmonize ith our own
favourite
heories.
The
Richborough
oard of 1931 s
beyond
ll
question
ate. We
leave out of
accountforthe
moment
he Theodosian
opper
that was found
with r near t. Even
f
we should
nd
by
believing
that
twas
ctually art
f he
hoard,
heres at east
a
possibility
hat
t was
not,
nd the
rgument
ill
be
surer
without
t.
The
decisive vidence
ies
n
theradiate
oinage
tself. Radiate
heads,
ot o be
distinguished
rom he
general
unof heads
n
the
hoard,
re combined
n a
number
f
cases with
reverses hatbetrayknowledgeffourthentury
types,
'Fel.
Temp. Repara
io,'
'Warrior
riving
spear
at
fallen
horseman,'
onstantius
I,
etc.,
c.
A. D.
348
and
361,
nd Gloria
Romanorum,'
'Emperor
raggingaptive
ight,'
alentiņian
and
colleagues,
. A. D. 364-375. Thesereverses
re,
n
the
whole,
uiteremarkably
ike
he
fourth-century
models,
nd
there
re no
third-century
odels o
which
hey
ould,
with
ny
reason,
lternatively
e
traced.
Here, hen,
e
have he
vidence,
hich as
hitherto
een
lacking,
f
the
muling'
f
radiate
obverseswith ater reverses.8The date of the
later
of the two reverses hus
imitated,
Gloria
Romanorum,'
akes s
down
o the
very dge
f he
Theodosian
ge.
This
evidence
s
strongnough
o
stand
by
tself.
f
support
ere
needed,
we
might
8
mitationsf
adiatesnd iademedeads
re,
s
rule,
uite
distinct
n
hoards:
or
ossible
xceptions,
f.H.
Mattingly.
Num.
hron.
934,
p.
55
f.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
19/155
OF
4
RADIATES,'
1931
11
point
o
theunusual reedom
ith
which ew
ypes
are here
reated
rom
he
imited tock f
standing
or
walking igures
n
the
hird-centuryriginalsnd,particularly,o a rangeofreverse
ypes,
lready
mentioned,
hat eems
o
exceed he
bounds f
3rd
century ossibilities
the
1
Cross'
type
nd
certain
two-figure
ypes
n
particular.
As
we have
said,
the die-cutter
eems not so
much to
have been
copying
s
creating
ew
types.
Two-figure
ypes
in
the
third
entury,
xcept
or
short
eriod
fter
Aurelian,
were rare
n
the
Western
mints;
s a
matter f
fact,
hey
o
not seem to
have
supplied
models or
urhoard.
Theearliest ossible ate,then, or heburial f
our
hoard
s circa
A.
D. 380-390. But this s
only
theoretical
ossibility.
Even
without
ommitting
ourselves
o
any general
heory
f
coin-drift,
e
must
obviously
llow
some time
o
elapse
for n
imperial
oin to
become familiar
nough
o
be
imitated
n an
outlying
rovince. Further,
we
know rom henumerous
ite-finds
f
Richborough,
that he
actual
circulation
n
thefort
n
the
Theo-
dosian
ge
was
the
small
bronze f
Theodosius
and
his
colleagues,
nd
of his
predecessors.
t is
certainly ossible hatthemassesofTheodosian
coindid notreach
Richborough
ill
nearly
he
end
of
the
fourth
entury;
t is
more han
possible
a
moral
ertainty
that
hey
ontinuedo
accumulate
there
ell nto he ifth
entury.9
here s áo
room,
*
Even hen
he
upplies
romaulnd
taly
ried
p,
what as
to
prevent
he
Roman-Britons
rom
xtending
he
ife
f their
Theodosian
oinagey
kilful,
fficialmitation?
here
s,
s
yet,
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
20/155
12 THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
then,
t
Richborough,
or
coinage
f the
extraor-
dinarilyrregular
haracter
f our
hoard or
ome
longyears
fter
hedeath
f
Theodosius
he
Great.Beforewe take our next
tep,
we shallfind t
useful o ask ourselves hat he
ssue
of
barbarous1
imitations
ay
mean. We
have
little
direct vi-
dence nd must
ely
n
careful
nd sober
eduction
from
generalprobabilities.
Two
general
lasses
might
e
distinguished
(l)
Imitationsnside
he
Empire.
These
might
e
in
the
nature f
tokens,
ssued
locally
in
municipalities
r
camps)
to
supplement
supplies f mperialmoney,tolerated,erhaps,f
not
pproved, y
authority.
he
rebellion
f
pre-
tender
might,
n
theory,
ive
rise
to
some
kind f
'barbarianmitation'
but,
s a
matterf
act,
ardly
a
single
ctual
example
an
be
quoted.10
(2)
Issues
utside
he
Empireģ
These
would
naturally
e
made
by
peoples,
or-
dering
n
the
Empire
nd familiar
ith
ts
money,
who,
needing
n
increase
f
supplies nd,
perhaps,
desiring coinage
f heir
wn,
re
yet ompelled
o
beginwithRomanmodelsnd
betray
llmannerf
misunderstanding
oth
of
types
and
legends.
Imitation
f
models,
bsolete
r
obsolescentn
the
no
proof
hat
hey
id
o,
ut
he
ossibility
eemso
be
worth
consideration.
10
t s
possible
hathe
agaudae
n
Gaul,
nder
eliamusnd
Amandus,
. D.
285-286,
truck
ude
mitations
f he
Gallic
radiates.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
21/155
OF
'RADIATES/
1931
13
Empire,
would
be
more
properlyssigned
o
this
than
o thefirst
lass.
Between lasses
l)
and
(2)
would
fall
ssues
f
communities,hich,
while
oyal
n
intention,
ere
temporarily
r
more
permanently
etached
from
the
Empire.
We
can nowreturno the
problems
fourhoard
with ome
general rinciples
o
guide
s.
Rutupiae
was one of the ast
places
possibly
he
very
ast
place
in
Britain
o
be held
officiallyy
Rome,
The Romano-British
opulation,
hen,
might
on-
fidently
e
expected
o
hold o
its
atest
Roman
the
Theodosian
ronze
currency:
he site-finds
f
the Fortprove hat t actually id so. Only fter
the
Roman
roops
nd civil
ervants ad
departed
can we
imagine
n
abandonment
f
the
mperial
coinage
nd
a
return
o
obsolescent
odels.
Such
a
relapse
emands
omething
ore
hanthe mere
withdrawalf the Romans
o
explain
t
it
implies
the
intrusion
f
other,
ess
civilized,
lements
n
their
lace.
Even thebroken
istory
f
our
sland
in
thefifth
entury
as
preserved
heessential
act
for s here. Whatwe have
before
s is
the
oinage
of
Hengist
nd Horsa with
heir
Jutes,
whenVor-
tigernnvited hem o aid himagainstPicts and
Scots
nd
gave
them
he sland fThanet or heir
hire
A.
D.
449).
1
Can
we hazard
guess
t
thereason or he
p-
11
f
oinage
f
his lass
eallyelongs
o he
nglo-Saxon
nd
Juti8h
nvaders,
t
may
asily
e
xtensivend f
more
han
ne
class.
On
late
,
Appendix
,
we
dd ome
xamples
rom
he
Britishuseum
f
what
ay
e
ate adiatemitations.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
22/155
14
THE RICHBOROUGH HOARD
pearance
f
third-century
odels almostto the
exclusion
f
fourth-century
odels
in
this
new
coinage? Perhaps
n observation
ong
ince
made
and
developed y
C. F.
Keary12may
ive
us the
ight
we
need.
He noticed hat the
silver f Carausius
had exercised
remarkablytrong
nfluence
n the
types
f ceattas
nd
explained
t
on
the
heory
hat,
as comes ittoris
axonici
nd, afterwards,
s
Em-
peror y
the
grace
fSaxons
nd
other
ebels,
ar-
ausius
had circulated
is
money reely
n both ides
of
heChannel.
Developing
his ine
f
hought,
e
may
uggest
hat,
or boutthe
ast
quarter
f the
third
entury,
ncluding
he
usurpations
f Carau-
sius ndAllectus,heWesternoasts ftheEmpire
were
xposed
o
Saxon
aiders, ho,
mid
he
rest f
their
ooty,
must
avecarried ff
masses fradiate
coinage.
Constantius
hlorus,
when he
brought
Britain ack to the
eternal
ighť
of
Rome,
reor-
ganized
the coast defences
nd barred
he door
»against
he
pirate.
For
many
long
year
he
axon
was
held t
bay.
The
Saxons, hen,
might
ellbe
familiar
ith he
coinage
f the
ate third
entury,
as
they
never
werewith
hatof the
fourth,
ight
continue
o use
and imitatet
in their
omes
n
the
LowCountries,nd,finally, hen hey eturnedo
Britain,
s settlers ot
marauders,
n
the
fifth
century, ight
hoose
o
copy
t
rather han the
later
Romanmodels.
fthis s the
ase,
here
hould
be some
evidence
f
hoards. We
cannot
t the
moment heck
hem
atisfactorily.
«
The
Coinages
f
Western
urope,
ondon,879,
specially
pp.
103
f.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
23/155
OF
1
RADIATES/
1931
15
The
theory
hat mitationsf
radiate
oins
n
the
fifth
entury
elong
o
the
Saxons,
while
mitations
of
diademed
may belong
rather
o the
Roman-
Britons, ightlearlyepushedoabsurdxtremes.
Mr.
Sutherland,
as
already
uggested
ome
of
the
difficulties
hat
might
e
involved.
We
can
hardly
magine
heRoman-Briton
aying
o
himself
"I am
Roman:
diademed or
me,"
while he
axon
retorts I am
Saxon: I
prefer
adiates."
But,
we
may
be
very
near
actual
historical
ruth
if we
make our
theory
narrower
nd
more
precise
nd
say
that he
urviving
rban
ommuni-
ties
n
Britain fthefifth
enturylung
o
Theodo-
siancoinage,nd,after hat, o imitationsf the
early
fourth-century
oinage,
ut
that the
recru-
descence f
radiate mitations as
due
either o
Saxon nvaders r to
Britons,
ho
bandoned
ity-
life
nd
went native'
gain.
Whether
he
radiate
coinage
was felt o be
pagan,
s
the
diademed as
not,
s
best eft
ndecided
or
he
moment.Of
the
mint r mints f our coins
we know
nothing.
The
occurrence
f
everal
ie-identities
ertainly
uggest
a
mint r mintsnot far
remote rom
he
place
of
finding.
Of thevalue
represented
y
the
coins
we
againknow othing.Wemighterhaps indnour
hoard
n
average'
oin,
measuring
bout
7(19
mm)
and
weighing
irca 0
gr. 1.3
gm),
nd
suppose
hat
it
represented
standard
alue.
But
ome ew
ieces,
of
greater
moduleand
weight,
would
represent
higher
alues,
he
minims,'
resumably,
lower.
The artofour
hoard,
f
t
may
bear hat
name t
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
24/155
16 THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
all,
s of a
very
humble
rder,
ut
t
is
not
ntirely
without
hape
r
character
f
ts
own.
If
t cannot
effectively
e
compared
ith
he nobler
roducts,in
gold
and
enamel,
f nativeBritish r
Jutish
artists,
t finds
requent arallels
n
the
series
f
sceattas nd
of
Merovingian
ilver.
This
point
s
developed
or s
in
a
short
Appendix
II),
by
Mr.
DerekAllen. The
bearing
f
these
arallels
n
the
question
f
date s
obvious.
They uggest
much
longer
un,
and
perhaps
later
origin,
or
our
imitations
han we
should t
first
ave
been
n-
clined
o
assign
o
them.
The
Richborough
oard
of
1931
lready
timu-
lates, f t does not ompletelyatisfy,ur uriosity.
It
may
have
a
permanent
lace
in
our
historical
study
f
t
directscholars o a
place
where
hey
may
hopefully
earch
or
ome f
the
till
buried
ecrets
of Britain's
ark
Age.
"The
imitationf Roman
types
y
the
moneyers
f
the
Anglo-Saxon
ceattas
will
no
longer ppear
s
a
rather
urious
eturn o
the
past:
it will
simply
e
the
continuationf a
process
hat
had been
ontinuous."13
The authors
ish
o thank
Miss
Anne
Robertson
of
Glasgow
most
warmly
or
nvaluable
ssistance
with hedescriptions.
A closer
description
f
the 563
classified
oins
follows.
The
normal
bverse s
to
be taken
s
a
radiate
eadto
r.,
without
egend;
nything
eyond
this
s noted
n
the
obverse'
olumn.
The reverse
descriptions
ave
given
us
much
trouble,
s
we
i«
H.
Mattingly
ndW. .D.
Stebbing,
aper
o
he
nternational
Archaeologicalongress.
ug.
932.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
25/155
of
'radiates;
1931
17
wished o describe
s
fully
s
possible
what
was to
be
seen,
nd
yet
often
ould
notdetermine
xactly
what hedie-cutter eant. We
have had
to
resort
to
frequent
arks f
nterrogation:
holding
inr.
hand/
for
example,
means
'holding
uncertain
object;
In
the ase
of ome
oins
f
pecial
nterest
and
difficulty,
rawings
re
added
cf.p.
108).
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
26/155
18 THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
A. COINS OF REGULAR MINTAGE
1.
Gallienus.
Obv. gall]ienvs [avg]Headradiate. jRev.
d[ianae] con[s avg]
Stag
walking
.
x
Mattingly
nd
Sydenham,
i,
p.
146,
No.
179;
Cohen 58.
2.
Postumus.
Obv.
imp
postvmvs f
avg]
Bust
adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
pax avg Pax
standing
.
holding
ranch
and
vertical
ceptre.
M.&S., Vii,
p.
363,
No.
318;
Cp.
C.
215.
3. V CTORINUS.
Obv.
mp c
v[ictorinvs
F
avg]
Bust
adi-
ateanddraped .
Rev.
Providentia
avg]
Providentia
tanding
1.
holding
aton nd
cornucopiae;
t
foot,
globe.
M.&S.,
Vii,
p.
392,
No.
61;
C.
101.
4.
V
CTORINU
.
Obv.
imp
ic]torinvs p
f
avg]
Heador
bust
radiate
.,
ower
art
ff lan.
Rev.
llegible.
5.
Claudius I.
Obv.
imp
clavdivs
avg]
Bust
radiate
.
Rev.[pax]avg Pax tanding.holdingranch
and
vertical
ceptre.
M.
&
S.,
V
i,
p.
217,
No.
80;
C. 201.
6.
Tetricus .
Obv.
mp
c
tetricv]s
p F
avg Bust
adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
HILARITASVGG
ilaritas
tanding
.
hold-
ing
palm
nd
cornucopiae.
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,p.
408,
No.
79;
C. 55.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
27/155
OF
'RADIATES/
1931 19
7.
Tetricus .
Obv.
m[p
c
tetricvs
pf
avg]
Bust
adiate
and
cuirassed.
Rev.[hilar]itas avgg Hilaritastanding.
holding
alm
and
cornucopiae.
M. &
S.,
V
ii,
p. 408,
No.
79;
C. 55.
8. Tetricus .
Obv
[imp
c
tet]ricvs
f
avg Bust
adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
[Laetitia avg]
Laetitia
standing
.,
holding
reath nd
anchor. Small
flan.
M. &
S.,
V
ii,
p. 408,
Nos.
87ff;
.
7
ff.
9.
Tetricus .
Obv.
mp
c
tetricvs
p F
avg Bust
adiate
anddraped .
Rev.
pax
avg
Pax
tanding
.,
olding
ranch
and vertical
ceptre.
M.
&
S.,
100;
C. 95.
10.
Tetricus .
Obv.
mp
c tetricvs
p
F
avg]
Bust
adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
[pax]
avg Pax
tanding
.,
olding
ranch
and
vertical
ceptre.
M. &
S.,
V
ii,
p.
409,
No.
100;
C.
95.
11.
Tetricus .
Obv. imp tet]ricvspf[avg] Bust adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
[pax av]gg
Pax
standing
.,
holding
branchnd
vertical
ceptre.
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,
p.
409,
No.
100;
C.
95.
12.
Tetricus .
Obv.
imp tet]ricvs
p f
avg Bust
adiate
r. Double-struck.
Rev.
Uncertain.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
28/155
20
THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
13.
Tetricus I.
Obv.
c
piv
Esv
tetri]cvs
caes Bustradi-
ate
nd
draped
.
Rev pa[x avg] Pax tanding., oldingranch
and
ceptre.
M. &.
S.,
V
i,
p. 422,
No.
248;
C.
34.
14.
Tetricus
I.
Obv.
c]
piv
TETRicvs
p] a[vg]
Bust
adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
[pax]
vg Pax
tanding
.,
olding
ranch
and
transverse
ceptre.
Not
n M.
&
S.
or
C.
15. Tetricus
I.
Obv. c p e] tetricvs [caes] Bust adiate
and
draped
.
Rev.
Illegible.
16. Tetricus I.
Obv.
Legend
ff
lan.
ust
adiate
nd
draped
.
Rev.
Illegible.
17. Allectus.
Obv.
imp]
allectvs
p
f
avg Bust
adiate,
draped
ndcuirassed.
Rev.
[fi]des
militvmFides
standing
.
hold-
ing wo tandards.s^p
M.
&
S.,
V
i,p.
565,
No.
69;
C. 8.
18.
Con
tantius I
orConstans.14
Obv.
onst
.
. Bustdiademednd
draped
.
Rev.
[fel
temp
reparatio]
Legionary
.,
spearing
allen
orseman.
çqn
14
or he elationfNos. 8-22
o
his
oard,
ee
.
10.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
29/155
OF
'RADIATES/
1931
21
19.
Theodosius.
Obv.
d N
[theodo]sivs
f
AVG Bust
dia-
demed nd
draped
.
Rev [salvs reipvblicae] Victorydvancing
1.,
dragging
aptive:
|c
1.
(obliterated)
Mint-mark
llegible.
20. Theodosius.
Obv
[d
n
theodo]sivs
p f
avg Bust
dia-
demed
nd
draped
.
Rev
[victor]ia av[ggg]
Victory
dvancing
.
holding
reathnd
palm.
Mint-mark
l-
legible.
21.
Arcadius.
Obv.
d n
arcad[ivs]pf
avg Bust
iademed
anddraped .
Rev. victoria
[avggg]
Victory
dvancing
.
holding
reath
nd
palm.
Mint-mark
l-
legible.
22.
House of Theodosius.
Obv.
Legend llegible.
Bust
diademed nd
draped
.
Rev.
[victor]ia
avggg.
Victory
dvancing
.
holding
reath
nd
palm.
Mint-mark
l-
legible.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
30/155
22 THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
B. COINS OF
IRREGULAR MINTAGE
Prototype:
laudius .
Consecrationssue.
Obv. DIVO LAVDIO
No. Plate Size
Wt. Obverse
23
I,
1
.6 28.8 ....
div
(1.87)
24
.6
15.5
(1.0)
25
.55
17.6 DIVO
..
(1.14)
26
.55 14.9 d
. . .
.
o
(.97)
27 .55 21.6 No legend. Barbarous
(1.4)
small
ead. Traces f
border
fdots.
Prototype:
laudiusI.
Consecration
ssue.
Obv. DIVO LAVDIO
28
.6 16.3
. . . vDio
(1.06)
29
.5
14.2
(.92)30 .5 18.2
(1.18)
As
bove
31
.6
22.5
.... VTV
..
(1.46)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
31/155
OF
1
RADIATES/
1931
23
a)
Copying ecognizable
Models
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,p.
234,
No.
266;
C.
41 ff.
Rev coNSECRATioaglewith eadr.or1.
No.
Reverse
23
Eagle
tanding
ront,
ead .
24 Same
ype,
consecratio
25 Same
ype,
conse....
26
Same
ype
. .
secra
. .
.
27 Eagle tandingront,ead .
M.
&
S.,
V
i, p.
233,
No.
261fC. 50
ff.
Rev.
consecratio
Square
ltar.
28 Plain
ltarwith lames
...
rati . . .
29 Same
ype.
.
atio
30 Plain ltarwith oubleides nd op. .. . o . . .
but
tylised.
31
Double-topped
ltarwith
our
anels,
ach on-
taining
ellet.
.
. . v . . . tv...
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
32/155
24
THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
No.
Plate
Size
Wt.
Obverse
32
.55 15.5
(1.0)
33 I, 2 .55 16.4
(1.06)
34
.6
19.9
(1.29)
35
I,
3
.6
19.5
(1.26)
36
.65 12.8
Almost
mooth.
(.83)
37
.6 21.4
.
.
. CLA
. .
(1.39)
38
I,
4
.5
21.4
Head
very
arbarous.
(1.39)39 .5 16.7 Bust
raped?).
(1.08)
...
or
va
....
40
.55
9.1
Small
ust.
(.59)
41
.6
20.0
Good
workmanship.
(1.30)
DIV
...
DIO.
42
1,5
.6
24.1
Very
arbarous.
(1.56)
Traces f
etters.
43
.55
22.0 Traces f
etters.
042)
Rev.
Altar
44
1,6
.55 14.3
Large
ead,
eck ff
lan.
(.93)
Rev. Altar
with
45
I,
7
.55
26.5
Barbarous
ead
with
hin
(1.72)
neck
nding
n
row
f
dots.
. . .
PNOC
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
33/155
OF
1
RADIATES,*
1931 25
No.
Reverse
32 Altar
with lames
nd
palmettes,
nd
four
anels
each
ontaining
ellet,
con .
.
.
33 Altarwithflames nd panel,containingive
pellets.
34 Altarwith
tylised
lames,
ivided
orizontally
into
wo
anels
ontaining
ellets.
ecrati
35 Double-sided
ltar with
five
pellets.
Double-
struck.
36
Plain ltarwith
anel.
Flan
hin
nd
pread.
37 Plain ltarwith our
anels
cratio.
38 Small
lain
ltarwith
anel.
39 Small altar withflames,oughlyivided nto
six
?) panels.
40 Altarwith lames
nd
crescent
n
panel.
41
Altar
with
pellet
nd
circle
n
panel.
Nearly
smooth.
42
Altarwith
ines,
xtendedo end
n
arrows,
nd
small
anel
ontaining
ellet.
43
Square
ltar
?),
containingrregular
ines.
and
Figure.
44 Lower
art
of male
figure
.
(?)
To
r.,
high
n
field,
mall ltarwith orizontal
ines.
Traces
of
borderfdots.
Concave
ides.
45 Altar
with ncurved
ides,
hree
tylised
lames
and
ound
eet.
Borderf
dots.
Flanhas
pro-
jecting
ongue,
mi
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
34/155
26
THE RICHBOROUGH HOARD
No.
Plate Size
Wt.
Obverse
46
I,
8
.75
27.
Barbarous
raped
ust.
(1.75)
. . .
VSP
H A
ve
47
.75
12.0
. .
.
APN
o
(.78)
48
I,
9
.55
17.5 Lineborder.
(1.13)
Prototype:
robus. Rev.
elicitas
vg
Felicitas
tanding
ront,
ead
.,
49
.5
21.4
Barbarous
head,
neck
(1.39)
ending
n
traight
ine.
Borderfdots.
Prototype:
etricus
. Rev. idesmilitvm
Fides
tanding
.,
A.
Reverselose
o
prototype.
50
I,
10 .6
17.0
(l.i)
51 .65
23.5
...
ti TRI
. .
(1.52)
52
.65
19.9
(1.29)
B. Main
details
reserved
but dd
tyle
53
I,
11
.6
11.6
...
TETR
. . .
(.75)
54 .45
8.2
...ah...
(.53)
55
.5 14.5
Draped.
(.94)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
35/155
OF
1
RADIATES/
1931
27
No.
Reverse
46 Altarwith ncurved
ides,
rom
hich
ise
wo
arrows nd between
hem lames.
Pellet
n
centre.Traces f etters.
47 Altarwithncurved
ides,
ound
eet,
aised
anel
and flamesn 1. ...
u
....
mi
48
Altar
with ncurvedides. Two
pellets
nd
styl-
ised
lamesll round.
Border
f ots
nd
ines.
(cp.
Probus:
M. &
S.,
V
ii,
p.
55,
No.
355
ff.)
holding
aduceusnd
cornucopiae.
49
Felicitas
tanding
ront,
ead
.,
olding
aduceus
and
cornucopiae.
M.
&
S.
(Webb)
V
ii,
p.
407,
Nos.
68
ff.;
.
37 ff.
holding
wo tandards.
50
Fides
tanding
.,
olding
tandard
n
ither and.
mili
.
.
51
Same
ype
standard
n
r.
hand,
lmost
ff
lan).
.
. . TAI
.
. .
52
Same
ype
standard
n1.
hand,
lmost ff
lan).
53
Fides,
tanding
.,
holding
tandard
n
either
hand ..
v
M
(Fides
s a short
quat igure).
54
Same
type
standards
eld
lose
o
sides).
55
Same
type
standard
n r. hand
off
lan: ides
is
very
road
n
he
hest).
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
36/155
28
THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
C. Derivation
rom
rototype
ncertain
No.
Plate
Size
Wt.
Obverse
56 I, 12 .7 31.9 . . . AVDivs . .
(2.07)
Features
ike
those
of
Claudius
I.
57
I,
13
.6
26.3
Draped
?)
(1.7)
58
I,
14
.6
22.2
...tiv...
(1.44)
59
.55
11.0
. .
.
T
. .
.
v
. . .
(.71)
Prototype
Tetricus
.
Fortuna
tanding
.,
holding
udder
Rev.
ORTVNA
VG
Not
60
.6 19.1
. .
.
A
. . . v
.
.
.
(1.24)
61
.55
12.0
. .
. V .
. .
(.78)
Prototype:
etricus. Rev
hilaritas
vgg
Hilaritas
tanding
.,
holding
62
I,
15
.7
21.7
Draped
.
.
p
tvcs .
.
(1.41)
63
.6
23.6
Draped
.
. avg
(1.53)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
37/155
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931 29
No.
Reverse
56 Female igure,raped,tanding.,holdingerti-cal trident
?
brokent
top)
inr. hand nd
vertical
ceptre
?)
in
1.
C,
ow,
eft,
n
field.
57
Figure,
ndraped?),
radiate
?),
advancing
.,
holding
ertical
bject
sceptre )
in
either
hand . .
v
.
.
.
58
Male
figure,
raped
o
knees,
tanding
.,
holding
vertical
pear
n r. hand
nd
vertical
ceptre
in
1.
59
Female
igure,
raped,tanding
.,
holding
erti-
cal
object
sceptre
r standard
)
in
either
hand.
M. &
S.,
V
ii,
p.
407,
No.
73;
C. 44.
Tetricus.
in
r.
hand nd
cornucopiae
n
1.
common
nthis
roup).
60
Fortuna
tanding
.,
holding
uddern
r.
hand
and
cornucopiae
n
1.
..AIA...
61
Same
ype.
.
.
. c .
.
.
M. & S.,V i,
p.
408,Nos.79ff; . 53ff.
long
alm
nd
cornucopiae.
62 Hilaritas
tanding
.,
oldingong
alm
n
r.hand
and
cornucopiae
n
1. ...
ilari
. . .
63
Same
ype,
vi
a
.
. .
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
38/155
30
THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
Prototype:
ictorinus. Rev.
nvictvs
Sol
walking
.,
.
hand
aised,
A. Main ype: o tar
No.
Plate
Size Wt. Obverse
64
II,
1
.55
12.6
...
it
Ricvsi
(.82)
65
.55
19.6
Draped.
Curiously
aint
(1.27)
lines . .
in
. . .
66
.6
18.3
Draped.
Overstruck
?)
(1.19)
67
.6
12.7 Curious
oose
drawing.
(.8)
68
.6
22.2 . . .
I
. . .
(1.44)
69
II,
2 .65
21.7 . . .
AV
i
OCT
M
.
.
.
(1.41)
Features
f Postumus.
Bš
Main
ype:
tar
or
ther
bject)
.,
nfield
70
.6
22.5
(1.46)
71
.6
21.2 . . .CTETI . .
(1.37)
72
.55
18.0
Draped
. . avg
(1.17)
73
.5
8.4
...vs...
(.54)
74
II,
3 .65
22.2 . . .
nisdiv
. .
(1.44)
75
.5
17.2
(1.11)
76
.55
21.5
Draped
(1.39)
77
.7
27.2
Draped.
Youthfulead.
(1.76)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
39/155
OF
4
RADIATES/
1931
31
M. &
S.,
V
i,
p.
396,
Nos.
112
f.;
.
46
ff.
1.
holding
hip
sometimes,
tar
.,
n
field).
No.
Reverse
64
Sol
walking
.,
aising
.
hand
nd
holding
hip
upright
n
1.
.
.
.x. .
.
65
Same
ype
Sol
radiate).
66
Same
ype.
r.
hand ff
lan)
67 Same
ype.
68
Same
ype.
. . .
i
^
69 Same
ype
radiate:
mantle
cross
hest).
70
Sol
walking
.,
aising
. hand nd
holding
hip
upright
n
1. Star .
n
field
.
. TV .
.
7
1
Same
ype.
...
v
s
72
Same
ype.
73
Same
ype
r.
hand
ff
lan)
. . ni
I
Radiate.
74 Same
ype.
.
. . ictvs
75
Same
ype.
Radiate
. . . cta ....
76 Same
ype.
Star
?)
1.
77
Same
ype
1.
hand
ff
lan,
.
holding
hip).
NN. .
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
40/155
32 THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
No.
Plate
Size Wt.
Obverse
78
II,
4
.75
19.2
Draped
m.
.
(1.24)
79 II, 5 .55 19.6 Draped . .izinn. .
(1.27)
C Main
ype:
.,
I.
infield.
80
.6 15.8
Draped
. .icv
(1.02)
D
Main
ype
aried.
81
II,
6
.6
20.7
.
. . AVG . .
(1.34)
82
II,
7 .6
18.1
Draped
. .AVO
(1.17)
Seven
urtherorn oinseem o derivemorer
E.
Main
ype
but urned
o
r.
83
II,
8 .6
19.3
Draped.
Youthful
(1.25) portrait
?)
84 .65 10.6
Draped
.
.v.
(.69)
Prototype:
etricus
.
Rev.
aetitia
avg.
Laetitia
tanding
.,
A. Main
ypes.
85
.6
27.6
Draped
nd
uirassed
?)
(1.79)
. . .
PCTETRCVS.
86
.55
12.3
.
.
.II
.
TETPiicvs
. .
(.8)
87
.65
17.5
Draped.
Youthful
or-
(1.13)
trait . .
.TETR
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
41/155
OF
'
RADIATES,1
1931 33
No.
Reverse
78 Same
ype on
1.,
low
n
r.).
79 Same ype+ on1.),gea ...vav...
80
Sol
walking
.,
raising
.
hand
nd
holding
hip
upright
n
1.:
P.,
1.,
n
field.
81
Sol
walking
.,
aising
. hand nd
holding lobe
in
1. above
globe
*
.
.
.
.oti.
. .
82 Sol
walking
.,
aising
oth
hands. Radiate
. . .v. . .
AI
less
losely
romhe Invictus'
rototype.
83 Sol
running
.,
raising
.
hand
nd
holding
hip
in
r. . . .CYOT.
.
84
Sol
walking
.,
raising
.
hand,
.
hand,
olding
whip?),
off lan
.
.tv. .
(r.
o
1.,
utwardly)
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,
p.
408,
Nos.
86
ff.;
.
70
ff.
holding
reath
nd nchor.
85
Laetitia
tanding
.,
olding
reath
?)
in
r.
hand
(off
lan)
nd nchorn
ground
n
1.
...
c v G
86 Same
ype.
. .
.V
87
Same
type very
worn,
ut traces
uggest
his
type).
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
42/155
34
THE
RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
No.
Plate
Size
Wt.
Obverse
88
II,
9
.6 16.6
Draped
. . .vt.
.icvi
(1.08)
B. Main
ype
aried
89
II,
10
55 20.7
. .
.
TIVZ
(1.34)
90
.55 23.0
...III...
(1.49)
Prototype:
iocletian
Mars
dvancing
.,
arryingpear
91 II, 11 65 36.6 Draped
(2.37)
IMPCITRIC.
.
Prototype:
etricus.
Rev.
ax
avg.
Pax
standing
.,
holding
A.
Main
ype:
o
drapery
ver
.
arm
92
.6 25.3
. .
.
urn
(1.64)
93
.6
8.4
...
TETRICVSII.
.
(.54)
94
.6 13.2
...Il
ilio...
(.86)
95
II,
12 6 21.9
Draped
nd uirassed
?)
(1.42)
96 .6
18.8 .
.
. mi.
.
(1.22)
97
.6 18.2
Draped
. .
.vr. .
(1.18)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
43/155
OF
4
RADIATES/
1931
35
No.
Reverse
88
Laetitia
tanding
ront,
ead
.,
with nees
light-
lybent, oldingp
?
(wreath)
in
r. hand
nd
holdingnchorngroundn1. c.v.D. . .Ti I
89
Laetitia
?)
standing
.,
holding
atera
(or
wreath
)
in
r. hand
nd
nchorn
ground
n
1.
Low
1.,
ross
nd
(?)
...
i
J
..
90
Laetitia
?)
standing
.,
olding
reath
n
r.
hand
andvertical
ceptre
n
1. .
.
.vg
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,
p.
244,
No.
239;
C. 314.
and
trophy.
Reverse
f
Diocletian.
91 Marsadvancing ., carryingrophy?) over
shoulder
n
r. hand nd
transverse
pear
n
1.
.
.
.iv . . .
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,
p.
409,
Nos. 100
f;
. 95
ff.
branch
ndvertical
ceptre.
92 Pax
tanding
.,
olding
ranch
p
n
r.hand
nd
vertical
ceptre
n
1. . . .nc
93
Same
ype. (Curly
ines f
figure)
.
.v. . .
94 Same
ype
r.
hand lmost ff
lan).
95
Same
ype
r.
hand lmost
ff
lan).
96 Same
ype,
pa
. . .
97 Same
ype.
. . .e c
c
.
. .c
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
44/155
36 THE RICHBOROUGH HOARD
B.
Main
type: rapery
ver
. arm.
No. Plate Size Wt.
Obverse
98 .65 17.9 I mPCL . .
(1.16)
99
.65
18.8
(1.22)
100
.65
24.2
I
H
I
P
HT
. .
(1.57)
101
II,
13
6
14.8 Youthful
ortrait
(.96)
.
. .CS . TETRIC
£
.
.
102
.65
19.2
Draped.
Youthful
or-
(1.24)
trait
103
.6
22.0
Draped.
Youthful
or-
(1.42) trait . .ricvsca. .
104*
II,
14
7 17.6
Draped
(1.14)
105*
II,
15
8 21.7
Draped
.
.
.ci.
. .
(1.41)
106
.55
19.5
Draped
(1.26)
C.
Probably
s
B.,
but ot
uite
ertain.
107
III,
1
.55
18.0
Draped.
Youthful
or-
(1.17)
trait . .
AVDAVi
.
108
.6
17.4
Draped
dnocc. .
VG
(1.13)
109 .55
18.0
Draped
?).
.
. .saiac
(1.17)
(overstruck)
110
.55
15.1 Youthful
ortrait
(.98)
...
A
v
A
V
. .
.
111
.55 12.9
Youthful
ortrait
(.84)
. . .SA
c
*
Samebv. nd ev. ies.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
45/155
OF
4
RADIATES/
1931 37
No
Reverse
98 Pax tanding., oldingpbranchnr. hand ndvertical
ceptre
n1. a fold f
drapery
alls ver
her
.
rm.
. .
x
A
.
.
.
99
Same
ype.
pa.
. .
100 Same
ype.
. . .av.
.
.
101 Same
ype,
dvx
. .
102 Same
ype.
(r.
hand lmost ff
lan)
103 Same
ype.
.
. .xa . .
.
104* ame
ype.
(r.
hand lmost
bliterated)
. . .x.
.v. . .
105* ame
ype.
(r.
hand
ff
lan)
.
.av.F
106 Same
ype.
(Curly
ines f
figures)
. .x. . .
107
As
B.
No.
1.
(r.
rm ff
lan)
108 Same
ype.
(Indefinitebject
nr.
hand)
...OA XV. . (r.to1., utwardly)
109
Same
ype.
(1.
rm lmost ff
lan)
110 Same
ype.
(r.
rm ff
lan)
111
Same
ype.
(r.
rm ff
lan)
.
.
. iva.
. .
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
46/155
38 THE RICHBOROUGH
HOARD
No. Plate Size
Wt
Obverse
112
.6
22.3 . .PC
TETRIC
. .
(1.45)
113 .5 17.8 Draped. No egend?)
(1.15)
114 .6
15.1
...ETRIC . .
(r.
toi.,
(.98) outwardly)
115 .6 23.7
054)
1
15A
III,
2
Nine
ther
orn oins
robably
how
D.
Probably
s
B
but ltar .
116 .65
12.6
Draped
iiiip.
.
C82)
Prototype:
etricus
. Rev. axavg.
Pax
standing
.,
holding
117 .65
10.1
C65)
Uncertain
Pax*
Type
118
.65
19.3
Draped
. . .vsc.
.
0-25)
Prototype:
arausius.
Rev pax
avg.
Paxstanding.,holding
119
.55
14.6
Draped
?)
(.95)
. . .TETRI. .
120
.6
22.4
. .
.vsic
. .
(1.45)
121
.55
16.3
(1.06)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
47/155
OF
'
RADIATES/
1931
39
No.
Reverse
112
Same
ype.
(r.
arm
bscure)
. . .A.
.
113 Same ype. (Details fr. hand bscure) . .s
1.
eg
drawn
ack.
1 4
Same
ype.
(r.
rm ff
lan)
115
Same
ype,
(details
f
.
rm
bscure)
.
. .
the ame
everse,
f
whichne
s
llustrated.
116
As
B.,
No. 1
r.
hand lmost ff
lan)
Altar
.
M.&
S.,
V
ii,
p. 409,
Nos.100
f.;
. 95ff.
branchnd
transverse
ceptre.
117
Pax
standing
.,
holding
ranch
n
r. hand
nd
transverse
ceptre
n
1.
normal
tyle ?)
118
Female
igure
tanding
.,
holding (rudder
)
on
ground
n
r.
hand,
n
1.
. . .nx.
. .
M.
&
S.,
V
ii,
p.
475,
No.
130;
C.
222.
branchndcornucopiae.
119 Pax
standing
.,
holding
p
branch
n
r.
hand
and
cornucopiae
n
1.: a fold
f
drapery
alls
over . rm.
pax
avg.
120
Same
ype.
..
A
xav.
121
Same
ype.
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
48/155
40
THE
RICHBOROUGH HOARD
Probably
ame
No.
Plate Size Wt. Obverse
122 III, 3 .5 23.8 Curiousarrowortrait
(1.54)
. .
.ia.
. .
123
.7
24.0
.
.
.
RicvsPi.v.
(1.55)
Two
more orn oins
Prototype:
etricus .
Rev
PIETAS VGG
avgvsto
tc.).
Priestly
mblems
ariouslyrranged.
A
big ug
knife.
and
1.)
A.
Jug
lone isible
124
.5
7.0
(.45)
125 .5
10.4 II
...
v c
(.67)
126 .5
17.2
Draped
(1.11)
127
III,
4 .6 12.5 Youthful
ortrait?)
(.81)
128 .65 17.9
Draped
(1.16)
129 .6
20.00
(1.3)
130 .55 9.5
Draped
?)
...
A
(.62)
131 .5 9.8 . .. IAIITI . .
(.64)
132 .6
17.2
Draped
. . .
s
. . .
.
(1.10
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
49/155
OF
'RADIATES,'
1931
41
reverse.
No.
Reverse
122 AsNo.119 bover. rm ff lancorncopiae?)
in
1.
hand).
123
As
No.
119
bove
r.
rm ff lan: orn
copiae
?)
in
1.
hand),
v. 1.
n
field.
probably
how
he ame everse.
M. &
S.,
V
ii,
p.
423,
Nos.
254
ff.;
.
48
ff.
is
always
n he entre
simpulum,
prinkler,
ituusnd
124
Jug
with
ip
r.
(Jug
as wo
eet,
ne
aised).
. . .R.
.
125 Same
ype.
(Only
op
f
ug
visible)
MOIRC
126
Same
ype.
(Jug
s
curiouslytylized
nd ooks
almost
ike
standingigure)
127 Same
ype.
(Around
he
ug,
hain
f
ndecipher-
able
etters
r
border)
128
Jug
with
ip
1.
?)
IUA Double
truck.
129
Jug
with
ip
1.
?)
. .
.TA.
.
130 Same
ype
s
131
Same
ype.
.
. .
hi
. . .
132
Same
ype.
(?
Sprinkler
n
r.)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
50/155
42 THE RICHBOROUGH HOARD
No.
PlateSize Wt
Obverse
133 .6
26.9
Draped
nd
uirassed
?)
(1.74)134 .5 15.1 . . .TS . .CON . .
(.98)
B.
Jug
nd dditionalmblem
.
135 .7
27.0
Draped
mte.
.
(1.75)
136
.45
8.1
(.52)
137 .5 22.5
(1.46)
138
III,
5
.6 13.0
. .
.TIOTIC
(.84)139 .65 17.8 IM. .VD
(1.15)
C.
Jug
nd
dditionalmblem
.
140 .6 20.3
Draped
(1.32)
.
. .STR
. .sc. .
.
141
III,
6
.6 27.0
. .
.O
. .
(1.75)
D.
Jug
nd
dditional
mblemsor
.
142
.65 30.6
Draped
uirassed
?)
(1.98) PC . . VG
143
.55 15.0
Draped.
Youthful
or-
(.97)
trait
?)
144
III,
7
.55 17.7
Draped
(1.15)
145
.6
25.0
. . .spiv
.
.
(1.62)
146
III,
8
.55
9.7
(.63)
This content downloaded from 83.85.134.3 on Tue, 02 Feb 2016 10:27:11 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 The Richborough hoard of 'radiates', 1931 / by Harold Mattingly and W.P.D. Stebbing
51/155
OF
4
RADIATES/
1931
43
No.
Reverse
133
Same
ype.
(? Sprinkler
n
1.)
134 Same ype. (Onlyopof ugvisible) . .A
135
Jug
with
ip
r.:
ituus n
r.
136
Jug
with
ip
1.:
ituus
?)
on r.
137
Jug
uncertain
f
ip
s
1.
or
r.,
s
top
s
obliter-
ated)
lituus
?)
r.
3ca.
. .
138
Jug
with
ip
r.:
uncertain
bject
ttached
o ton
r. . . .XQ. .139
Jug
withwohandles?) ontwofeet: ncertain
emblem
?).
140
Jug
with
ip
1.:
ituus
?)
on
1.,
object
ost n
r.
SD...
141
Jug
with
wo
andles:
op
s
shaped
ike aduceus
.
.
.;
nesnil
uncertain
mblem,
,
with
long
troke
n
1.
142
Jug
with
ip
r.
lituusnd
knife
n
1.,
prinkler
n
r. .. .IE ... as ... Ill inex.
143 Same
ype:
ncertain
mblem
n
1.,
ituus n
r.
/V
# ,
144
Same
type:
sprinkler
n
1.,
ituus n
r.,
+
r.
in field.
145
Jug
with
ip
r.:
uncertain