ge medium voltage drives

88
TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association Medium Voltage Drives Overview, Evolution & Application Bill Horvath, PE TMGE Automation Systems Western Mining Electrical Association November 2004

Upload: jorgeluis793714

Post on 28-Apr-2015

175 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

DESCRIPTION

Dispositivos de arranque y control para motores de media tensión

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: GE Medium Voltage Drives

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Medium Voltage DrivesOverview, Evolution &

Application

Bill Horvath, PETMGE Automation Systems

Western Mining Electrical AssociationNovember 2004

Page 2: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 2

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV Drive Session Overview• Provide links to more reference materials.• Review the benefits of ASDs in motor starting and control• Cover basic drive application • Cover basic tradeoffs between MV & LV drives• Review one recent mining conveyor MV drive application• Trace the Evolution of MV drives & circuit configuration

• Compare each historical and current major MV drive topology• Compare each drive topology's major strengths and

weaknesses.• Review the TMGE Dura-Bilt5i MV IGBT Drive as an

example of current technology

Page 3: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 3

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV Drive Materials -1• MV Drive Evolution White Paper GEZ-S1006

• Engineering Reference Manual & CDROM,GET-S1009

• Obtain from TMGE General Industrieswww.tmge.com

Page 4: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 4

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

More MV Drive Materials - 2

• Electronic MV Newsletterhttp://www.imakenews.com/getoshiba_mve-news/

• TM GE Automation Web Link:www.tmge.com

Page 5: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 5

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

AC Motors & Control Overview• Induction Motor Basic Characteristics• Load Types

– Starting and Running Torque-Speed Profiles– Typical Applications

• Starting and Running Control Methods• Variable Frequency Drives

– Low Voltage vs Medium Voltage– MV Drive Evolution– TMGE Automation Systems Dura-Bilt5i MV

Overview

Page 6: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 6

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Induction Motor Speed-Torque Profile

LockedRotor Tq

Pull UpTorque

Peak[Breakdown]Torque, BDT

Rated Torque

SyncRPM

RPM

Rated SlipRPM =Sync - Rated RPM

RatedRPM

Torq

ue

Sync Rpm = 120 x Freq.#Poles

Sync Rpm = 120 x Freq.#Poles

Page 7: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 7

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Motor Starting

Page 8: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 8

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Motor StartingFactors That Apply

• Inrush Amps and Duration• Motor Limit on Number of Starts Per Hour• Motor Connected Inertia Limits• Load Mechanical Issues

– Pumps, Piping & Hydraulic issues– Coupling Stress

• Starting Torque vs Load Requirements

Page 9: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 9

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Full-Voltage Motor Starting

Single Motor, Single Starter

Multiple Motors, SingleStarter

Torque

Amps

Full LoadTorq

ue,

Amps

RPM >

Full Voltage Amps & Torquevs Speed

Page 10: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 10

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Reduced -Voltage Motor Starting

ReducedVoltageStarter

Bypass

Start Inrush amps ~ VoltsTorque ~ Volts2

Torque

Amps

Full Load

Torq

ue,

Amps

RPM >

Reduced VoltageMotor Amps & Torque vs Speed

1. Frequency is = line frequency2. Inrush current and torque are limited for a “soft”

start, but no true speed or torque control is possible.

Page 11: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 11

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Motor on AC Adjustable Speed Drive

Motor AvailableTorque

Full LoadTorque Level

Torq

ue,

Amps

Amps

AC Adjustable Speed DriveMotor Amps & Torque vs Speed

MAdjustable

SpeedDrive

No Starting Inrush amps,Torque & Volts Controlled to

Match Load

1. Frequency and voltage are controlled.2. Line current, motor voltage torque regulation provide true speed

and torque control.3. KEY: Process and energy use can be optimized.

Page 12: GE Medium Voltage Drives

2/12/2001 VFD APPLICATION 12

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Drive Ratings and Torques

• Variable Torque - ratings usually include 110 -115% OL rating for 60 seconds at rated Temp

Page 13: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 13

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Loads & Motor “Capability” Curves

TEFC

Variable Load [P

ump, F

an]

Constant TorqueLoad, Example 2

Constant TorqueLoad, Example 1

RPM -- >

Load

Tor

que

Theoretical Motor Capability

Actual Motor Capability

100% Load Point,NP RPM, Sine wave power

Induction Motor CapabilitiesUnder Variable Speed Operation

imcapab1.drw June 4, 98

Page 14: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 14

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Pump & Fan “Affinity” Laws: 1-2-30

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

HP - %

flow - %0.00%

10.00%20.00%30.00%40.00%50.00%60.00%70.00%80.00%90.00%

100.00%

% Speed

% of Total

- 1 Flow Rate Varies 1st power of Speed [Proportional]- 2 Pressure & Load Torque Varies as the 2nd power [square] of Speed- 3 Horsepower at Motor Shaft varies as the 3rd power [cube] of Speed

Page 15: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 15

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Fans Fans --Things to RememberThings to Remember“Fans” have variable torque loads. “Blowers” mayhave constant torque or variable torque loads.

• Load torque goes up as the square of the speed.• Horsepower load goes up as the cube of the speed.

• Torque needed to run an Induced Draft fan increases significantly as gas temperature decreases.

• Fan Motor sizing greatly effected by across the line

Page 16: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 16

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Page 17: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 17

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Variable Torque Drive Applications

Page 18: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 18

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Multiple Motor Pumping Application

ST1

ST2

ST3

M1

M2

M3

MTR1

MTR2

MTR3

Starting/Running Drive

4160 V

Drive

Starting/RunningContactors

PumpMotors

Across the LineContactors

4160 V

Page 19: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 19

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Drive Ratings and Torques

Constant Torque [CT] rating usually includes 150% - 250% OL rating for 60 seconds when at rated Temp.

Page 20: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 20

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Constant Torque –Characterized as a load curve that looks like

Variable Load [Pump,Fa

n]

Constant TorqueLoad, Example 2

Constant TorqueLoad, Example 1

RPM -- >

Load

Torq

u e

Theoretical Motor Capability

Actual Motor Capability

100% Load Point,NP RPM, Sine wave power

Page 21: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 21

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Conveyor or Mill Loading

conveyor typical demand

Typical InductionMotor Char on 60 Hz power

TOR

QU

E

FREQ, SPEED

BREAKAWAYTORQUE

Page 22: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 22

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Conveyor or Mill Loading

conveyor typical demand

Typical Induction Motor Char on 60 Hz power

TOR

QU

E

FREQ, SPEED

BREAKAWAYTORQUE

VFD CONTROLLED MOTOR -ENOUGH TORQUE ACROSS THE RANGE

Page 23: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 23

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Page 24: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 24

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Crushing and Crushing and Conveying SystemsConveying Systems

Page 25: GE Medium Voltage Drives

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Example MV Drive Mining Application

MINE-MOUTH TO PROCESSING PLANT CONVEYOR

Page 26: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 26

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Application Story – Long Conveyor1. Underground Molybdenum Mine in Colorado had 15

mile long train to take ore from mine tunnel to processing plant

2. Train equipment became obsolete, unreliable

3. Three segment conveyor at variable speed was winning concept to replace train

4. Total length of conveyors over 15 miles! One section over 10 miles!

Page 27: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 27

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

PWM-3 1000 HP.

900 kVA13,800/2300 V

13.8kV1000 HP2.3 kV

C 1000 HP PWM-3 w/1 1000 HP Motor Basic configuration for Pulleys 4, 5, 6, 7

PWM-3. 2250 HP.

2140 kVA13,800/2400 V

13.8kV

2250 HP2.3 kV

A 2250 HP PWM-3 w/1 2250 HP Motor Basic Configuration for Pulleys 1, 2, 3

ELECTRICAL ONE LINES

2000 HP Drive CanAccommodate [2]1000 HP Motors

B 2000 HP PWM-3 w/ two 1000 HP Motors Alternate for pulley 4

PWM-3 2000 HP.

1900 kVA13,800/2300 V

13.8kV

1000 HP2.3 kV

1000 HP2.3 kV

ELECTRICAL ONE LINES

PC-2 ConveyorPlan View

10.5 miles, 16.8 kM

CONVEYOR PC-2

Elev.9,500 ft

2,400 ft

Elev.7,100 ft

2 13

Head end equip house@ 9500 feet AMSL

GRADE = Variable 5% to 1%

5%

3%

1%

GRADE = Variable 0% to 8%

CONVEYOR PC-1CONVEYOR PC-3

PC-1 ConveyorPlan View

4

Head end equip house@ 7,100 feet AMSL

PC-3 ConveyorPlan View Head end equip house

@ 9,500 feet AMSL

7

4.0 miles, 6.4 kM0.76 miles, 1.2 kM

6 5

Tail end equip house@ 9,500 feet AMSL

2 x 1000 HP 2 x1000 HP

1 x1000 HP

1 x2250 HP

2 x2250 HP

1 x2250 HP

1 x1000 HP

Application Story – Long Conveyor

8/18/97 Henpres1.ppt Slide S-21

Page 28: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 28

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Application Story – Long ConveyorConveyor Mechanical Application

Considerations

Stretch, Length, Belt weight,load weight,speed

Friction

T1

T2

T3

T4

D1

D2 D3

Tension Ratios,Dynamic Response,Programmed Torque, Load Sharing

Page 29: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 29

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

PC-2 UPHILL CONVEYOR with PWM Drives

PC-2 ConveyorPlan View

2 13

Head end equip house@ 9500 feet AMSL

1 x2250 HP

2 x2250 HP

1 x2250 HP

PWM-3. 2250 HP.

2140 kVA13,800/2400 V

13.8kV

2250 HP2.3 kV

A 2250 HP PWM-3 w/1 2250 HP Motor Basic Configuration for Pulleys 1, 2, 3

ELECTRICAL ONE LINES

8/18/97 Henpres1.ppt Slide S-23

Page 30: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 30

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

PC-3 OVERLAND CONVEYOR with PWM-3 Drives

PC-3 ConveyorPlan View Head end equip house

@ 9,500 feet AMSL

7 6 5

Tail end equip house@ 9,500 feet AMSL

2 x1000 HP

1 x1000 HP

1 x1000 HP

PWM-3 1000 HP.

900 kVA13,800/2300 V

13.8kV1000 HP2.3 kV

C 1000 HP PWM-3 w/1 1000 HP Motor Basic configuration for Pulleys 4, 5, 6, 7

8/18/97 Henpres1.ppt Slide S-24

Page 31: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 31

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

PC-1 FEED CONVEYOR with PWM-3 Drives

PC-1 ConveyorPlan View

4

Head end equip house@ 7,100 feet AMSL

2 x 1000 HP

PWM-3 1000 HP.

900 kVA13,800/2300 V

13.8kV1000 HP2.3 kV

C 1000 HP PWM-3 w/1 1000 HP Motor Basic configuration for Pulleys 4, 5, 6, 7

8/18/97 Henpres1.ppt Slide S-22

Page 32: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 32

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Application Story – Long Conveyor

Motor Challenges

• High Starting Torque for PC3

• Two sizes: 1000 HP & 2250 HP each

• wide speed range

Drive Challenges

• 24/7 Reliable• Energy Efficient

• Low Maintenance

• High overload torques in winter on PC3

Power Challenges

• Long power feeds

• Cable capacitance created resonance high order harmonics

Control Challenges• Precise, programmable

torque for belt tension control

• Head-to-tail tension coordination for PC3.

• Allow variable speed operation of any motor

Motor Solution

GE 2.3 kv induction motor separate

cooling air by user

Drive And Control Solution

GE Innovation PWM 2300 volt 3-level, 18 pulse rectifiers. Utilized Innovation Series Controller for torque programming & PLC Ethernet interface.

Power Solution

3-level Inverter with IEEE 519 compliant 18 pulse converters and high frequency filters to eliminate cable resonance at 19th harmonic

Challenges & Solutions

Page 33: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 33

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Customer Benefits• Train system replacement with conveyor has

proven to be very reliable.• Variable speed operation on the conveyor

resulted in added energy savings, reduced friction and belt wear.

• Biggest risks and failure potentials were avoided by careful design:

Slippage and stretch of long strand 20 mile total length PC2 with 4 x 2250 HP at head endTension control of up-and-down PC3 overland with many curves

Application Story – Long Conveyor

Page 34: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 34

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

All AC Drive Selection Factors

• Load type: CT, VT, CH, Regen or non-regen• Physical Environment at drive location• Power system compatibility• Precision of control needed• Overload ratings needed• Operator control & digital communication

needed• Drive Output Voltage & Motor Application

Page 35: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 35

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Drive Output Voltage & Motor ApplicationLV drives: defined as having output

volts <690 volts

• Why Pick LV [<690v] Drive & Motor?• Why pick MV over LV?

Trends:Some users select MV at >250 HPMany users select MV over 500 HP.

Page 36: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 36

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Drive Output Voltage & Motor Application• Why Pick LV [<690v] Drive & Motor?

– LV drives are lower cost / HP than MV– Reduces some safety & MV training concerns– HP range is small enough– Individual preference

• Why pick MV [>690v] Drive & Motor over LV?– Lower cost wiring, smaller cables– Lower power system harmonic impact– High HP LV require dual winding motors– Individual preference

• Trend: Some users select MV at >250 HPMany users select MV over 500 HP.

•• Why Pick LV [<690v] Drive & Motor?Why Pick LV [<690v] Drive & Motor?–– LV drives are lower cost / HP than MVLV drives are lower cost / HP than MV–– Reduces some safety & MV training concernsReduces some safety & MV training concerns–– HP range is small enoughHP range is small enough–– Individual preferenceIndividual preference

•• Why pick MV [>690v] Drive & Motor over LV?Why pick MV [>690v] Drive & Motor over LV?–– Lower cost wiring, smaller cablesLower cost wiring, smaller cables–– Lower power system harmonic impactLower power system harmonic impact–– High HP LV require dual winding motorsHigh HP LV require dual winding motors–– Individual preferenceIndividual preference

•• Trend:Trend: Some users select MV at >250 HPSome users select MV at >250 HPMany users select MV over 500 HPMany users select MV over 500 HP..

Page 37: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 37

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV vs LV AC Drives:Cost Factors of Various Configurations

MV vs LV AC DrivesBudgetary $ per HP

vs HP

0.0

100.0

200.0

300.0

400.0

500.0

0 500 1000 1500Horsepower

Bud

geta

ry

$ pe

r Hor

sepo

wer

LV 6-Pulse w/o Transformer

MV 4160 v 24-Pulse DB5i

LV 6-Pulse w/8% Mirus filt

LV 18 pulse incl transf

• MV drive $ / HP decreases with HP

• Harmonic content can be important:–MV data is 24 pulse TMGE Automation Systems DB5i MV

–LV data is GE-Fuji AF300 P11

• Installed cost must be considered

Page 38: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 38

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Safety, Training & MV Drives• Different level of training and personnel for MV

vs LV equipment• Different procedures MV vs LV• Local maintenance staff may not be

“comfortable” with MV equipment• MV drive include many safety features:

Optical control isolation: feedbacks and firingElectrical and mechanical interlocks & isolator switchesBolt on covers, warning labels

Page 39: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 39

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV vs LV Drives: Some Conclusions• For drives > 1000 HP, MV makes sense• For long cable runs, MV makes sense• For drives < 500 HP, LV makes sense.• If low system harmonics are required, LV filter

or multi-pulse expense can favor MV over LV. • In the range 500 to 1000 HP the various

application & installation factors apply.Final choice may boil down to user

preference.

Page 40: GE Medium Voltage Drives

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV Drive Evolution

History,Topology Comparisons,& Future Trends

Page 41: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 41

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Typical AC Inverter System

Transformation

UtilitySupply

Conversion

Load

Utilization

AC Inverter TechnologyUp To 97% Efficiency, including transformers

RECTIFICATION

AC TO DC

OROR

ENERGYSTORAGE

OR

SWITCHING

DC TO AC

OR

AC MOTOR

Page 42: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 42

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Advances in Power

Semiconductor Technology

Lead the Way in MV Drive

Development

• The Common Threads:– All AC Drives rectify AC to DC – All AC Drives use switches to create

AC from DC• Drive topologies were created as

power rectifiers and switches grew in ratings and capabilities.

• Each new or uprated device opens up new applications

• A quick look at the device development timeline is useful

Page 43: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 43

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Development Time Line of Power Semiconductors

1955 1965 1975 1985 1995 2005

Diode (D) SiliconControlled

Rectifier (SCR)

Bipolar PowerTransistor

(BPT)

Gate Turn OffThyristor(GTO)

Low Voltage InsulatedGate Bipolar Transistor

(LV IGBT)

Integrated GateCommutated Thyristor

(IGCT)

Medium Voltage InsulatedGate Bipolar Transistor

(MV IGBT)

Symmetrical GateCommutated Thyristor

(SGCT)

Injection EnhancedGate Transistor

(IEGT)

Thyristor Devices

Transistor Devices

Page 44: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 44

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Gate Power Supply

GTO Gate Driver & Cell Stack EquipmentGE GTO-IMD Example

• Liquid-cooled configuration• Many discrete parts in

firing and auxiliary parts• Snubber network also

shown• Physically quite large

Page 45: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 45

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

GCT Gate Driver EquipmentCovers on

Gate Power Supply

Isolation Transformer

IntegratedGate Signal Unit GCT

4.5kV-4kA

Page 46: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 46

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

GCT & Gate Driver BoardCovers off

4.5kV-4kA4.5kV-800 A

36 Electrolytic caps21 FET Switches

Page 47: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 47

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Typical IGBT & IGBT Gate Driver CircuitIGBT

400 amp 3300 volt dual packageLarger ratings have 1/package

Typical MV IGBT Dual Gate DriverEach board has 2 drivers, & fires 2 IGBT’s

Approximate Size:

4 inches x 4.5 inches

2 in,50 mm

Page 48: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 48

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

IEGT Gate Driver Equipment

IEGT4.5kV-4kA

Gate Drive BoardGate Drive Board

IEGT = Injection Enhanced Gate Transistor

Page 49: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 49

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

0

5 0 0

1 0 0 0

1 5 0 0

2 0 0 0

2 5 0 0

3 0 0 0

3 5 0 0

IC

LE D

FILM C AP AC IT O R

E LE C TR O LYT IC

R E S IS TO R (1/4)

R E S IS TO R (P W R )

D IO D E

FE T

TR ANS IS TO R

FITs

F

ailu

res

per B

illion

Hou

rs

IGCT IEGT

IGCT vs IEGT Calculated Failure Rates of Gate DriversCalculated Reliability of Gate DriversIEGT Voltage Fired vs GCT Current Fired

Page 50: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 50

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Power Switching DevicesFinal Comparisons & Conclusions

• Current switched devices [SGCT, IGCT] require many more parts in firing / gate control than voltage switched devices [IGBT, IEGT].

• Voltage switched devices [IGBT, IEGT] have MUCH lower switching losses than current switched.

• Conduction losses are nearly equal for equivalent volt & amp-rated device SGCT, IGCT vs IGBT, IEGT

• Voltage switched devices allow higher switching rates and can give better output waveforms

Page 51: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 51

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

• Current source drive: ENERGY STORAGE section between converter and inverter consists of an inductor.

• Voltage Source Drive: ENERGY STORAGE section between converter and inverter consists of capacitors.

Two Basic AC Drive Topologies

A map-like diagram showing the elements of an AC drive and the relationships between them.

AC Drive Topology:

Page 52: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 52

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Comparing Topologies

• Current Source Drives– LCI – Load Commutated Inverter– GTO/SGCT Current Source Induction Motor Drive

• Voltage Source Drives– LV IGBT “Paice” Multilevel PWM– MV IGCT PWM – Diode or Active Source– MV IGBT PWM – Integrated package– MV IEGT PWM – Active or Diode Source

Page 53: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 53

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Current Source Drives

Page 54: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 54

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

InverterTopology

Advantages Drawbacks Practical Power Range

Current sourceLoad-CommutatedInverter

SCR = Silicon Controlled Rectifier, Thyristor

• Low Parts Count• Full Regen is inherent• Rugged – ultra reliable• Economical High HP• N+1 SCR device

redundancy possible

• Requires a controlled front end• High motor current THD• Slow transient response• Narrow motor frequency range• Reduced Starting Torque• Limited starting performance• Poor PF at low motor speeds• High harmonics unless

multiple channels used; filters may be needed.

Above 6 MW

Synchronous Motors Only

Example: GE-Innovation Series® LCIEnergy stored in

Link Inductor

Volts SyncMotor

UTILITY

SCR

SCR

Alternate: Multi-pulse/Multi-channel Converter

DC LinkInductor

LCI – Current Source Load Commutated Inverter

Primarily being offered by:

TMGE, ABB, Siemens

Page 55: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 55

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

InverterTopology Advantages Drawbacks Practical Power

Range

Current SourceGTO or SGCT

PWM Inverter

GTO = Gate Turn Off Thyristor

SGCT = Symmetrical Gate-Controlled Thyristor

• Low power device (GTO/SGCT) parts count

• Low motor THD• Low motor insulation

stress when input isolation transformer is used

• Requires a controlled front end – extra complexity

• Poor input power factor, with SCR front end

• Slow transient response• Narrow speed range• Potential resonance

between motor & caps• Limited availability of

power devices• Complex firing circuit

2 - 15 MW

Primarily induction motor load

Energy stored inLink Inductor

Volts InductMotor

UTILITY

GTO /GCT

SCRDC LinkInductor

Alternate: Multi-pulse/Multi-channel Converter

Example: GE-GTO IMDInduction Motor Drive

Current Source GTO / SGCT Induction Motor Drive

Primarily being offered by:

Allen Bradley

Page 56: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 56

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Current Source SGCT Induction Motor DriveWith “Isolation” Reactor in Place of Transformer

Volts InductMotor*

UTILITYSCR

orGCT * non-

standard

DC LinkInductor

"Isolation"Inductor

Energy stored inLink Inductor

Page 57: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 57

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Voltage Source Drives

Page 58: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 58

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Voltage Source General Drive Arrangements

UTILITY 1 2 3

VoltsMotor

Alternate: Multi-pulse/Multi-channel Converter

Diode RectifierConverter Fed

Active RectifierConverter Fed 3

VoltsMotor

12

Page 59: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 59

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

PWM: Pulse Width ModulationA method of varying voltage by changing the average

“ON” time of switches between source and load.

Example Pulse-Width-Modulated [PWM] Waveform

Voltage: The Average of the time the Voltage is on Plus the time the Voltage is Off.

Current: The Motor tends to smooth the resulting current

PEAK DC SOURCE VOLTAGE

EXAMPLE SIMULATED SINE WAVEPRODUCED BY 2-LEVEL

PWM INVERTER

Page 60: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 60

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Example Two-Level Voltage Source Inverter

MDBR

3 PhaseDiode Bridge

ab

c

AC IncomingLine

[ + ]

[- ]

Three Phase Input

-1.3

-0.8

-0.3

0.2

0.7

1.2

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

Rectified 3-Phase

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

Rectified 3-Phase

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

DC Buss Rectified Power

PWM Motor Volts

Motor Amps

CapBank

Page 61: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 61

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Fixed DCBus

Inverter(IGBT)

DiodeRectifier

LV IGBT Multi-level Voltage Source PWM Inverter

InverterTopology

Major Advantages Major Limitations Practical Power Range

Multi-level Voltage Source LV IGBT PWM Inverter

LV IGBT = Low-voltage Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor

• Power Cell N+1 redundancy available

• Low motor current THD• Fast transient response• Wide motor frequency range• No significant torque pulsations• High starting torque.• Multi-pulse converter for very

low AC line harmonics• High true pf over all speeds

• No regen or DB possible• Large parts count – lowers

base MTBF• N+1 redundancy adds parts

and decreases MTBF• Large footprint in high HP• Electrolytic capacitors are

sensitive to over temp & overvoltage

0.5 – 10 MW

Sync or Induction motor

Example: GE Innovation Series® Type H

Energy stored in electrolytic capsTypical Power Cell

Primarily being offered by:Robicon, Toshiba Japan

Page 62: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 62

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Power Cell “N+1” Redundancy• “N+1 redundancy” originated in LCI drive design, defined as having an extra

SWITCHING DEVICE per leg, with no other added parts.• One Robicon method re-defines “N+1” as including a complete extra cell

transformer secondary & SCR bypass switch: Cell must be intact and control 100% functional to workAdded parts work all the time and decrease drive component MTBF

• Traditionally, increased reliability comes from reducing parts count and conservative design.

Loadconverter

Sourceconverter

DC linkreactor

Sync MotorFeedTransformer

Added Power Devices forRedundancy

Shaded Green

LCI driveN+1 requires

12 SCR’s

Fixed DCBus

Inverter(IGBT)

DiodeRectifier

TYPICAL LV IGBT POWER MODULE FOR REDUNDANT USE

ELECTROLYTICCAPS

BYPASSSCR

LV IGBT MV DriveN+1 [3 extra power cells] adds

18 diode Rectifiers12 LV IGBTs, 15 bypass SCRs

42 electrolytic Caps, Firing circuits+ 3 added transf windings

Page 63: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 63

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Fixed DCBus

Inverter(IGCT)

Diode or IGCTRectifier

AC Input

InductionMotor or

syncMotor

[req fieldexciter]

Filter

Energy stored in liquid filled caps

IGCT PWM Voltage Source Inverter

Example: GE-Innovation Series® SP IGCT Mill Drive

InverterTopology

Practical Power Range

IGCT PWM Voltage Source Inverter

Three Level

• Low power switch device count for voltage rating

• Fast transient response & wide motor frequency range

• High starting torque• High power levels with largest

IGCT devices• Regen possible with active IGCT

converter

0.5 – 4.8 MVA per inverter, air cooled

4.8 – 9.6 MVA, dual channel

• Complex high parts count firing circuit

• 3-level output above 3.3 kV requires output filter for low motor current distortion.

• Potential for electrical and mechanical resonance between load and filter.

Major Advantages Major Limitations

Primarily being offered by:

TM GE, ABB

Page 64: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 64

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

InverterTopology

Practical Power Range

Three / Five Level Voltage Source MV IGBT PWM Inverter

MV IGBT = Medium-Voltage Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor

• Minimum parts count forvoltage rating & waveform

• Simple firing circuit.• High efficiency• Low motor current THD• Fast transient response• Wide motor frequency range• No significant torque pulsations• High starting torque.• Multi pulse converter for very

low AC line harmonics• High true pf over all speeds

0.5 – 4.8 MVA per inverter, air cooled

4.8 – 9.6 MVA, dual channel

Sync or Induction Motors

• No regeneration available• Fast rise time IGBT switching

may require dv/dt output filter in some cases

• Power Device redundancy not practical

Example: TMGE Automation Systems Dura-Bilt5i® MV

MV IGBT NPC Voltage Source Drive

Ind orSyncMotor

Multi-WindingTransformer

Multi-PulseDiode Rectifier

MV-IGBTNPC Inverter

1

23

Liquid FilledPower Caps

Major Advantages Major Limitations

Primarily being offered by:TMGE Automation Systems,

Siemens

Energy stored in liquid filled caps

Page 65: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 65

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV IGBT NPC Voltage Source Drive Details

U-Phase LegAssembly

VoltageDetection

Module

OpticalLink

Module

24-PulseSource

460 Vac

V-Phase LegW-Phase Leg

24-P Source24-P Source

NM

•Neutral Point Clamped [NPC] reduces voltage to ground•5 / 9 level waveform < 3% motor current distortion•24 pulse diode converter <2% line current distortion, better than IEEE 519 limits

Example 5/9 level motor voltage & current waveforms

Page 66: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 66

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

InverterTopology

Practical Power Range

Three Level Voltage Source LV IGBT PWM Inverter

LV IGBT = Low Voltage Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor, 1700 volt rating

• With High reliability design and component selection, measured MTBF of > 50 years is possible.

• Simple firing circuit.• High efficiency• Low motor current THD• Fast transient response• No significant torque pulsations• High starting torque.• Active Front End for full regen,

Harmonic, and PF control.

0.5 – 10 MVA using up to 4 bridges, air cooled

Sync or Induction Motors

• Power Device redundancy not practical

• 1250 volt rating limits max power

Example: TMGE Automation Systems TMdrive 30

LV IGBT NPC Voltage Source Drive

Major Advantages Major Limitations

Primarily being offered by:TMGE Automation Systems

Fixed DC3-level Bus

Inverter(IGBT)

AC Input

InductionMotor or

sync Motor[req fieldexciter]

Converter(IGBT)

Energy stored in high reliability electrolytic caps

Page 67: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 67

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

MV IGBT NPC Voltage Source Drive Details

• Neutral Point Clamped [NPC] reduces voltage to ground

• 3 level waveform ~ 3% motor current distortion

• Active PWM front end better than IEEE 519 guideline limits

0.2

0.7

1.0

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

1.08

RMS

PEAK

Red = 3-level PWM Voltage output

M

+ 900

- 900

Simulated Inverter Voltage Waveforms of 3 level NPC PWM

Page 68: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 68

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Fixed DCBus

Inverter(IEGT)

AC Input

InductionMotor or

sync Motor[req fieldexciter]

Converter(IEGT)

InverterTopology

Practical Power Range

Three Level Voltage Source IEGT PWM Inverter

IEGT = Injection Enhanced Gate Transistor

• Minimum power device count – 24 for complete 8 mw regen system

• Simple firing circuit [4:1 more reliable than IGCT] and very high system MTBF.

• Low motor current THD• Fast transient response & wide motor

frequency range• High starting torque with no

significant torque pulsations• Active front end for low harmonics,

regeneration, unity or leading PF

6 to 26 MW, water cooled, one or two channelAt 3300 volts

Sync or Induction Motor

Example: TMGE Automation Systems 8 MW TM-70IEGT drive with active IEGT Source

• IEGT device limits allow 3300 volt motor output [European and Asian Standard]

• 3300 volts is not as common as 4160 volts in North American applications.

IEGT PWM Voltage Source Inverter

Energy stored in liquid filled caps•

Major Advantages Major Limitations

Primarily being offered by:TMGE Automation Systems

Page 69: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 69

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

IEGT PWM Voltage Source Inverter & Active Converter Circuit Details & Alternate Diode Converter Configuration

Fixed DCBus

Inverter(IEGT)

DiodeRectifier

AC Input

InductionMotor or

sync Motor[req fieldexciter]

IEGT PWM Voltage Source Inverter with Diode Converter

INDUCTIONOR SYNCMOTOR

Sync Field[If Applic]

Transformer& Feed Reactor

20% Z

8 MW IEGT Inverter with active regen-capable source

3 Level VFD Line-Line Output &Reference Sine Wave

0.2

0.7

1.0

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

1.08

RMS

PEAK

Red = 3-level PWM Voltage output

Simulated Inverter Voltage Waveforms of 3 level NPC PWM

Page 70: GE Medium Voltage Drives

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

A Modern MV Drive Example:

TMGE Automation Systems Dura-Bilt5i® MV

Page 71: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 71

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Dura-Bilt5i MV Overview• An AC Fed Medium Voltage Drive Featuring:

– Compact/compartmentalized design– Integral incoming fused disconnect– Integral converter transformer– 24 pulse IEEE 519 compliant ac

to dc converter– Advanced user interface

and system features

Page 72: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 72

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Covering a Broad Range of Medium Voltage Drive Applications

200 300 400 1000 2000 4000 10000 HP

150 450 300 750 1500 3000 7500 kW

Vac4200

4000 Series

3000 Series

2000 Series

400 – 10,000 HP [300 – 7500 kW]

300 – 8500 HP [225 – 6340 kW]

200 – 5000 HP [150 – 3730 kW]

4000

3300

3000

2400

2000

Page 73: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 73

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Very Compact

EST WT: 7,500 LBS 3,402 KG

300- 900 HP 3.3 & 4kV Outline

103.7[2634]

90.1 [2288]

110 [2794]

flapper clearance

43.4 [1102] 74 [1880 ]

Left Side / End View

No rear access required

300-900 HP Dura-Bilt5i MV Inverter, 3000 & 4000 series

24" fan top to ceiling for airflow clearance

ConverterSection

With IncomingConnections

Control [front]Motor Connections[Behind Control,

RH - Side]

Inverter

Front View

OptionalRedundant

Fan

StandardFan

Page 74: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 74

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Dura-Bilt5i MV3300 - 4160 VoltDetailed One-Line Diagram

Dura-Bilt5i MV Control

INVERTER

Main Power7.2 kV class or below

Sensing PT's120 output

Integral12 winding

Transformer

circuit

IntegralDisconnect

Option

Hall CTCurrent

Feedback

IntegralLightningArrestor

Optionalredundant fansshown dotted

StandardE.S. Shield

M

Aux & ControlPower

460 std., others avail

33

U-Phase LegAssembly

VoltageDetectionModule

OpticalLink

Module

24-PulseSource

460 Vac

Control powerfeed option

V-Phase LegW-Phase Leg

24-P Source

CONVERTER24-P Source

OptionalDV/DT Filter

E

Incoming PowerCompartment

3

ACLM1

M2

Fan FanFan Fan

Page 75: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 75

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Power System and Motor FriendlyAMPSGREEN

VOLTSBLACK

Note: traces time-shifted for clarity Utility Motor

Current Distortion: THD < 3%,Voltage Distortion: THD < 6%Line Current Distortion < 3%

Meets IEEE-519-1992 – With No Filters. With No Filters. Requires No Special Motor Thermal Rating

Operating Conditions: Full Speed, 95% LoadNOTE: Utility current trace displaced in time for clarity

Page 76: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 76

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

INCOMINGPOWER

BYPASSCONTACTOR

[option] TRANSFORMER & DC CONVERTER

INVERTERSECTION

Compartmentalized Design…

•Separate cooling for converter and inverter

•Control and power separated

•Voltage levels separated

•Only front access required

A Look Inside . . .

DRIVECONTROL

Typical Dura-Bilt5i MV 1850 kVA Drive

Page 77: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 77

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Incoming Power Compartment

Built-in 3-phase fused disconnect, interlocked with cubicle door that can be padlocked in the open position

Integral lightning arresters for transient and surge protection

Dedicated wireways support bottom or top incoming cabling

Integral ac reactor for charging and protection of dc bus components

Built-in 3-phase MV contactor interlocked with disconnect

Fused potential transformers

Page 78: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 78

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Transformer and Converter Compartment

DC cables to inverter compartment minimizes connections; thisspeeds and simplifies installation

24-pulse rectification gives power quality better than IEEE 519 recommended limits

Transformer secondaries fused with blown fuse indicators

Washable filters can be changed while drive is operational

Forced air cooled with dedicated fan. [Optional redundant fan with auto throw-over available]

Page 79: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 79

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Drive Control Compartment

Optional controls for drive by-pass or other auxiliary functions

Process input-output [I/O] control board

Communication board supporting Profibus, ISBus, DeviceNet™ and Tosline S20

Separate disconnect for control power

Microprocessor control boards for drive sequencing and motor speed/ torque control

Page 80: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 80

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Inverter Compartment• Easy access roll-out inverter

phase modules• Inverter module consists of:

•MV IGBT’s and heat sinks•Liquid-filled capacitors•Snubbers•Gating power supplies•Gate driver board

• Air cooled heat plate cooling system• High efficiency, low fan noise• Low device temperature rises

and temperature cycling• Optional redundant fan with

auto throw-over available

Page 81: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 81

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

High Efficiency Plate Heat Exchanger for IGBTs

• Devices are mounted to side of plates

• Current flow generates heat in devices

• With only a few degrees of temperature rise, coolant is vaporized within the plate

• Vapor rises to the top condensing unit passages

• Heat is removed by airflow over fine fins, which liquefies coolant

• Coolant returns to base of chill plate for next cycle

How it works

Page 82: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 82

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

• Liquid-cooled performance is achieved with air-cooled simplicity!

• Low IGBT-to-plate thermal resistance keeps IGBTs cool

• Minimized temperature fluctuations during operation maximize IGBT life up to 10x

• Sealed system is maintenance free

• Like the proven GE Innovation Series heat pipe design, but even more effective, with a larger active surface

High Efficiency Heat Pipe Exchanger for IGBTsAdvantages

Page 83: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 83

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Inside a Typical Power IGBTThis example: 400 amp, 1700 Volt.• Inside the package, many individual devices paralleled with bonding leads.

• Thermal cycling from wide load cycle can cause fatigue failure of bonds due to expansion and contraction

• Heat plate, like liquid cooling, keeps mounting plate surface more even during load cycles.

• Minimized temperature fluctuations during operation maximize IGBT life up to 10x

Page 84: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 84

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

By-Pass Contactor CompartmentRequires optional additional cubicle integrated into drive line up

Cubicle extension houses both input and output contactors

Allows full speed motor operation from utility power if drive is not available.

Contactors are interlocked to allow drive by-pass and connect motor across the power lines

Page 85: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 85

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Dura-Bilt5i MV Display Unit Parameter EditingIntuitive menu interface for parameter editing

Drive StatusGraphic screen displays key variables in bar chart format with additional status icons

Status IndicatorsGive quick indication of drive operation, without requiring separate panel lamps

Control System Toolbox Interface10-100 Mbps Ethernet can be multi-drop networked -access to GE 24-7 on-site monitoring

Signal MonitorAnalog signals for test instrumentation

Local Drive ControlDedicated keys for local control of the drive for commissioning and maintenance activities

Page 86: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 86

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Integrated Trend Window

• Drag and drop variables• Real time trending or

archiving to buffer for historical trending

• Auto scaling• Zoom in/out function• Different views by using

variable hide feature• Analyze specific time with

cross hair• Frequency-based analysis of

trend with fast Fourier transform function

Easy to UnderstandData Structure:• Drive parameters

and variables in tree structure

Animated Block Diagrams

World Class TMGE Control System Toolbox Supplied with Every Drive!

Same Toolbox as all GE System Drives and Many Exciters!

Page 87: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 87

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Summary & Conclusions• ASDs offer superior motor control• MV Drives can make sense at even

modest HP levels• MV Drives have come a long way• MV drives using MV IGBTs have

simplest control• MV Drive Reliability needs to be built in,

not added on

Page 88: GE Medium Voltage Drives

November 2004 TMGE Automation Systems - All rights Reserved 88

TM GE Automations Systems Western Mining Electrical Association

Thanks!

Bill HorvathTMGE [email protected]