國立巨治大學國弽掖展研究屻 碩士棄文 指導慡授：李酉潭 博士 民...

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

I

102 7

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

II

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

III

RI-1999

RI-2003

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

IV

Abstract

The purpose of this research is to understand the power relationship between

husbands and wives, including the factors and the transition during 1999-2003 within

the process of Taiwans democratization, especially the context of culture. Researcher

adopts family decision-making as an important index. Base on the resources theory,

the exchange theory and the theory of resources in culture context, the main

questions of this research are: 1. Does the proportion of family decision-making

change? 2. The situation that the more resources one has, the more power in making

decision one has would increase.

The results are as follows. The proportion of family decision-making does not

change significantly, however, the situation that one has more resources would have

more power in making decision does increase. Nevertheless, the research tells us

that some personal characteristics like ones ethnic group, do not have the same

result as research in past. How will Taiwans democratization influence these factors,

or change their nature in the process of decision-making? That could be a good

research direction in the future.

Key words: Taiwan, democratization, the power of husbands and wives, family

decision-making, resources differences

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

V

1

1

3

4

4

7

10

15

15

16

18

22

22

28

49

53

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

VI

60

60

61

75

75

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

VII

1 15

1 6

2 RI-1999RI-2003 22

3 RI-1999RI-2003 23

4 RI-1999RI-2003 24

5 RI-1999RI-2003 25

6 RI-1999RI-2003 26

7 27

8 RI-1999RI-2003 28

9 RI-1999RI-2003 29

10 RI-1999RI-2003 30

11 RI-1999RI-2003 31

12 RI-1999RI-2003 32

13 RI-1999RI-2003 34

14 RI-1999RI-2003 34

15 RI-1999RI-2003 35

16 RI-1999RI-2003 42

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

VIII

17 RI-1999RI-2003 42

18 RI-1999RI-2003 43

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

1

2011 6 24

2008

1

1996

20

only game in townLinz1990158

Freedom House

1996 politic rights

civil liberties 2005-2006

1 1

Larry Diamond

1 2011 6 24

http://www.chinareviewnews.com/crn-webapp/doc/docDetailCreate.jsp?coluid=98&kindid=2994&docid=101

743877

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

2

Diamond

Diamond

1999171-174

(family decision-making) David Easton

instrumental

affectiveeconomic

social

1999

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

3

2008

RI-1999

RI-2000RI-2003RCI-2004RCI-2005

RCI-2007

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

4

democracydemos

kratosrule by the peopleSorensen1993

16

Joseph A.

Schumpeter

Sorensen199310-12 Samuel P. Huntington

Huntington19915-13

Huntington Schumpeter

Larry Diamond electoral

democracyminimalistDiamond1996

21

ODonnell and Schmitter19868

Karl199622

Robert A. Dahl polyarchy

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

5

Dahl19711-32(1)

(2)(3)(4)

(5)(6)(7)

Dahl1989221

201136

Sorensen Dahl

competitionparticipationliberties

Sorensen199313Diamond liberal democracy

Diamond199621

Alexis de Tocqueville

Bova

1997112-116

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

6

Dahl

1-1 7-7

7-71-1

Sorensen200320-21 1

1

1-7 1-7

1-2.5

3-5.5

5.5-7

McColm, R. Bruce (1991). The Comparative Survey of Freedom: 1991. Freedom

Review, 22(1), 14.

1972

2

2

Sorensen200321-25

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

7

Robert O. Blood and

Donald M. Wolfe 1960 Husband and Wives

2000

2005Chen and Yi2006

R. E. Cromwell and D. H. Olson1975

baseprocess

outcome

J. M. Steil1997

1989

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

8

1989

115-116 Sarah F. Berk1985

Mirowsky1985

1991

1989

2000

final say

20052008

Blood and Wolfe1960

Richard Centers, Bertram H. Raven and Aroldo Rodrigues1971

Constantina Safilios-Rothschild1970

1989121

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

9

Blood and Wolfe1960husband dominant

typewife dominant typeequalitarian of syncretic

typeautonomic type

1989

Eshleman1981

Blood and Wolfe1960

1987188

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

10

feminism

Gender MainstreamingGM

stakeholders

200933-34

gender parity

1995 1996

2000

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

11

2006

1.

1989

3

2.

1990

1996

2002

1993

20072002

3.

3 1995

1999 500 41

2000

http://taiwanpedia.culture.tw/web/content?ID=1002412013/9/10

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

12

2002

20072007

2006

Olson and DeFrain2003213

Warner et al.1986Mirowsky

1985

4

1.

Blood and Wolfe

1960

1984

4 2005

48http://mail.nhu.edu.tw/~society/e-j/48/48-45.htm

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

13

1989

19972003 Hyman

Rodman 1967 1972

2.

the principle of least interestOlson and DeFrain2003

3.

rewardcost

Investment modelEquity

theoryOutcome-interdependence theory

Sprecher1998

rewardscosts Mirowsky1985

McDonald1980

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

14

Whyte1995

Rodman1970

Wesley R. Burr1973

5

5 2008

http://www.npf.org.tw/post/1/86732013/8/22

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

15

1

1

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

16

Panel Study of Family

Dynamics PSFD

(panel)

6

6

1998

() ()

Gary Becker (Chicago)Angus Deaton

(Princeton)Robert Hauser (Wisconsin) Cheng Hsiao (USC)Ronald Lee (Berkeley)William Parish

(Chicago) George Tiao (Chicago) James Vaupel (Max Plank) Arthur Wolf (Stanford)

1999

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

17

PSFD

1000

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

RI-1999RI-2003

https://psfd.sinica.edu.tw/plan_01.htm

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

18

PSFD 1999

1996 RI-1999

RI-2003

7

PSFD

1989

PSFD

7 Huntington

two-turnover test

Huntington1991266-267

Huntington

Huntington19911082000

RI-2003

1996 2000

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

19

200016-17

PSFD

2005

2000

20072004

Bielby1984

PSFD

Na

t iona l Chengch i U

nive

rsi t

y

20

2006261PSFD

200018

50000 5000-50000

5000 5000-50